# Adolf Müller

# Adolf Müller (politician, born 1916)

Adolf Müller (13 May 1916 – 22 February 2005), entered in the Bundestag’s master file as Müller (Remscheid), was a German trade-union official and a politician of the [Christian Democratic Union](/organizations/christian-democratic-union-of-germany) (CDU). Born in Remscheid-Lennep, in North Rhine-Westphalia, he was a Catholic skilled worker, married, with two children. He was a member of the Bundestag from 17 October 1961 until 18 February 1987 and was returned at each election on the CDU state list for North Rhine-Westphalia.

The handbook of West German parliamentarians records that he served a grinder’s apprenticeship. Between 1937 and 1945 he went through the Reich Labour Service, service in the Wehrmacht and captivity as a prisoner of war. The same account dates the start of his union work to 1947, when he became specialist secretary for labour law and social policy at the [German Trade Union Confederation](/organizations/german-trade-union-confederation) (DGB) in Remscheid.

In 1953 he became managing chairman of the Remscheid DGB committee, and from 1958 to 1978 he was deputy chairman of the DGB district of North Rhine-Westphalia. He joined the CDU in 1945 and was deputy chairman of the Christlich-Demokratische Arbeitnehmerschaft, the party’s employee association, in the Rhineland. The finding aid to his papers repeats that sequence and adds that he chaired the employee group of the CDU/CSU parliamentary party from 1972 to 1981.

In the Bundestag he chaired the Committee on Labour from 1965 to 1969 and was deputy chairman of the Committee on Labour and Social Affairs from 1969 until September 1981. From 1981 to 1987 he was a deputy chairman of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group, and he sat in the [Federal Convention](/organizations/federal-convention) in 1964 and 1969. In April 1972 *[Der Spiegel](/organizations/der-spiegel)* described the strain of holding a DGB office and a CDU seat at once: Müller, who was seeking to succeed Bernhard Tacke as a deputy chairman of the confederation, had backed a February resolution of the DGB federal committee in favour of Ostpolitik, had then been persuaded by party colleagues to oppose the Eastern treaties, and left a Bonn reception at which DGB chairman Heinz Oskar Vetter pressed union members of parliament to ratify them.

His papers, catalogued as Nachlass 01-416, run to about 6.8 linear metres and consist chiefly of files from 1964 to 1986. They are kept by the Archiv für Christlich-Demokratische Politik of the [Konrad Adenauer Foundation](/organizations/konrad-adenauer-foundation) in Sankt Augustin. The Bundestag file records his death on 22 February 2005.

## Early life and the Second World War

### Family and apprenticeship in Lennep

Adolf Müller was born on 13 May 1916 in Lennep. Bundestag membership data give the birthplace as Remscheid-Lennep and the religion as Catholic, and they list his occupation as Facharbeiter, a skilled worker. The same file records him as married with two children, without a date for the marriage or the children’s births, and it does not name his parents. The biographical handbook prepared for the Kommission für Geschichte des Parlamentarismus und der politischen Parteien enters him as Müller (Remscheid), Catholic, with a grinder’s apprenticeship (Schleifer-Lehre), again without parents, a school or an employer.

Lennep’s historic centre now lies in the municipality of Remscheid, in the Bergisches Land of North Rhine-Westphalia. A memorandum of the county of Lennep, issued in December 1928, when Müller was twelve, described a county town of 14,845 inhabitants in October 1928. Of 4,902 people counted in industry and crafts on 15 April 1928, 1,744 worked in textiles, 1,329 in textile machinery, 314 in the tool industry and 88 in other iron trades, including small ironware and wire. The memorandum also listed four elementary-school systems, one of them for Catholic children.

A remembrance published in 2011 by Sebastian Stein, district chair of the Christian Democratic Employees in Remscheid, states the training the handbook leaves blank: after elementary school (Volksschule), Müller apprenticed as a Schleifer in a hammer forge and passed the skilled-worker examination in the small-iron industry. Neither that account nor the parliamentary biography names the forge.

### Reich Labour Service and military service

The handbook compresses 1937 to 1945 into Reich Labour Service, service in the Wehrmacht, and captivity, without separating the three. Stein’s remembrance gives a sequence: Müller entered the Reichsarbeitsdienst in 1937, was then called up to the Wehrmacht, became a prisoner of war at the end of the [Second World War](/facts/world-war-ii), and was released in 1945. Neither source records a rank, a branch of service, a unit or a theatre.

He turned 21 in May 1937, inside the ages for which labour service was compulsory. From 1935, in Nazi Germany, men between 18 and 25 owed six months in the Reich Labour Service. The [German Historical Museum](/organizations/german-historical-museum) describes that service, under Reichsarbeitsführer [Konstantin Hierl](/people/konstantin-hierl) and attached to the Reich Interior Ministry, as a low-paid “Ehrendienst am deutschen Volke”: camp life with military drill and National Socialist instruction, officially aimed at unemployment and at levelling social differences. Columns drained moors, cultivated land and worked on the autobahns and the Westwall; reported strength was about 200,000 in 1935 and about 350,000 by October 1939. The biographies do not say where Müller was posted, or whether his own term lasted the statutory six months, before military call-up.

### Return in 1945

The Remscheid remembrance states that captivity came at the war’s end, that he was released in 1945, and that he was again in Lennep. The parliamentary handbook gives no civilian occupation for 1945. Its next date is 1947, when he became specialist secretary for labour law and social policy at the German Trade Union Confederation (Deutscher Gewerkschaftsbund) in Remscheid. The handbook does not record what he did between discharge and that appointment.

## Trade-union work in the DGB

Müller’s union career ran inside the German Trade Union Confederation (Deutscher Gewerkschaftsbund, DGB), built as an Einheitsgewerkschaft rather than as separate party or confessional unions. In 1947 the British military government allowed organisation at zonal level; on 13 October 1949 sixteen industrial unions founded the federal DGB in Munich and elected Hans Böckler its first chairman. The confederation was to be independent of parties without being politically neutral, while wage bargaining stayed with the affiliated unions. A Catholic who had joined the Christian Democratic Union in 1945, Müller worked inside that settlement rather than in a separate Christian federation.

### Remscheid local office

From 1947 he was specialist secretary for labour law and social policy at the DGB in Remscheid. In 1953 he became managing chairman of the local DGB committee (Ortsausschuss) there. The catalogue of his papers gives the same year, 1947, for his entry into the DGB. The post belonged to the confederation, not to a bargaining union: collective agreements remained with the industrial unions, which kept their autonomy under the umbrella body.

### Deputy chairmanship in North Rhine-Westphalia

From 1958 to 1978 he was deputy chairman (stellvertretender Landesbezirksvorsitzender) of the DGB district of North Rhine-Westphalia. That dating is given both by the biographical handbook of Bundestag members and by the finding aid to his papers. The district’s own list of full-time executive members includes him from the 1959 term through 1978, under Wilhelm Haferkamp (1959–1963), Georg Neemann (1963–1968), Peter Michels (1968–1975) and Bert Hartig (1975–1978). A report on the 1972 congress called him second chairman of the district. From 1961 the office ran together with a seat in the Bundestag. *Der Spiegel* described the combination as a dual career in the CDU and the DGB.

### The 1972 succession dispute

The dispute that stopped a further rise concerned the federal executive in Düsseldorf, not the state district. Bernhard Tacke, a CDU trade unionist and deputy DGB chairman, was leaving that executive in 1972, and the place was again to go to a CDU colleague. Müller was the original candidate. In April *Der Spiegel* reported that he hoped to take Tacke’s post as deputy DGB leader around the middle of the year.

What the unions held against him was his line on Ostpolitik. At the beginning of February 1972, in the DGB federal committee, he joined a resolution that expressly approved the Eastern policy. A few weeks later, the magazine reported, party colleagues in Bonn persuaded him to oppose the Eastern treaties. Friedhelm Farthmann, of the Social [Democratic Party](/organizations/democratic-party-us) and a former DGB co-determination specialist, called the change “the old routine, raising one’s hand everywhere” (*überall das Händchen heben*).

That April, DGB chairman Heinz Oskar Vetter received Bundestag members who were also DGB officials at the Hotel Tulpenfeld in Bonn, formally to thank them for their part in the new Works Constitution Act. He then demanded unconditional support for ratification, telling them to “look the people in the mouth” and adding: “The people are we.” Müller and Hans Katzer, chairman of the CDU social committees and a former federal labour minister, walked out; Katzer said that if that was the position they would thank Vetter for the dinner. Müller found the allusion to his February vote out of place. Norbert Blüm, managing director of the social committees, said the demand broke an unwritten law of the Einheitsgewerkschaft.

The next day the social-committee leaders met at the Adam-Stegerwald-Haus in Königswinter and agreed that, on the treaties, party discipline would rank above union solidarity. An attempt to put Blüm, or Karl-Heinz Hoffmann, deputy chairman of the public-services union ÖTV, into the Düsseldorf leadership instead of Müller failed. Both deferred to Katzer. The CDU Bundestag member Wolfgang Vogt said the group was holding to Müller, and Fritz Biggeleben, the CDU representative on the [IG Metall](/organizations/ig-metall) executive, called Vetter tactically unwise.

At the ninth ordinary federal congress, in Berlin from 25 June to 1 July 1972, the unions no longer accepted Müller, because of what Gerhard Leminsky in *Gewerkschaftliche Monatshefte* called his fluctuating stance on the Eastern treaties. A group around Katzer tried to make the rejection a test of the unified union. Leminsky wrote that the congress dismissed the charge unanimously, and that Tacke had said the quarrel was, wrongly, about a person and not about the principle of one trade-union movement. Maria Weber, on the managing federal executive since 1956, was elected a deputy member of the board; the DGB has described her as its first woman vice-chair, an office she held until 1982. Martin Heiß, until then deputy chairman of the textile and clothing union, was newly elected. Both, Leminsky noted, drew weaker support because of the row, and both were chosen without a candidates’ debate. *Der Spiegel* reported that Heinz Kluncker of the ÖTV and Eugen Loderer of IG Metall had asked for a “convincing majority” for Weber, and that she received 284 votes, against 345 at the Munich congress of 1969. When CDU chairman Rainer Barzel took up Müller’s failed candidacy, the hall answered with laughter, contradiction and booing. Müller did not join the federal executive. He remained deputy chairman in North Rhine-Westphalia until 1978.

## Christian Democracy and Catholic labour organisations

### Joining the CDU in 1945

The handbook of Bundestag members records Adolf Müller, a Catholic resident of Remscheid, as having joined the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) in 1945. The finding aid to his papers gives the same year. In the Rhineland, former Christian trade unionists were among the founders of the new interconfessional party and, from the end of 1945, were organising employees inside it.

Biographical compilations state that he was elected to the Landesvorstand of the CDU Rheinland. His papers, Nachlass 01-416 in the Archive for Christian Democratic Policy of the Konrad Adenauer Foundation at Sankt Augustin, include the Rhineland Landesverband’s files on the Landesvorstand and on Land party congresses for 1974–1977. The same deposit holds material from the CDU federal committee (1978–1986), federal party congresses (1978–1985) and the federal specialist committee on social policy (1973–1982).

### The CDA and the social committees

The Christlich-Demokratische Arbeitnehmerschaft (CDA), formerly the Sozialausschüsse, is the CDU’s association of employees. Its stated aim was to influence political life “according to the principles of the Christian-social idea” and to help bring about a social order based on social justice. Former Christian trade unionists in the Rhineland, Westphalia and other working-class centres built it because the unitary German Trade Union Confederation and the interconfessional CDU no longer left them the old confessional unions as a platform in the unions, the party, parliament and the workplace. Johannes Albers began the work at the end of 1945 on the advice of Adam Stegerwald. The first Rhineland meeting was held in Düsseldorf on 16 February 1946; an association for North Rhine-Westphalia followed in November 1946; and the first all-German congress, at Herne in November 1947, made Albers managing chairman. Jakob Kaiser was the first federal chairman. In federal governments led by the CDU or the CSU, the labour and social ministry was held by a member of the CDA. While Müller was active the federal chairmen were Hans Katzer (1963–1977) and Norbert Blüm (1977–1987).

The handbook lists Müller as deputy chairman of the CDA Rheinland and gives no years. A commemoration published on 13 May 2011 by Sebastian Stein, then chairman of the CDA in Remscheid, dated that deputy chairmanship from 1963 to 1986, described him as a member of the federal executive, and said that he was later made an honorary member of the CDA board in North Rhine-Westphalia and of the federal board. The same text states that in 1945 he joined the Sozialausschüsse, the name then used. A further compilation, drawing on biographical reference works, likewise records the Rhineland deputy chairmanship and a seat on the federal board. The finding aid does not itself name those offices, but the files cover the period: statutes, correspondence and minutes of the federal CDA for 1972–1983; Land associations, above all the Rhineland and its Betriebsgruppen, for 1964–1982; the Europäische Union Christlich-Demokratischer Arbeitnehmer (EUCDA) for 1974–1980; and the working group of Christian-democratic DGB trade unionists for 1981–1985.

Reporting at the time placed him in that employee circle, with Katzer and Blüm, and apart from the employer-aligned side of the CDU/CSU. In September 1972 *Der Spiegel*, writing on the pension dispute, called him a CDU trade unionist and a member of the Sozialausschüsse and quoted his dismissal, as “Quatsch”, of a proposal from the Bundesvereinigung der Deutschen Arbeitgeberverbände to delay contribution increases and to cut early pensions. Earlier that year the magazine had grouped him with Katzer, then Sozialausschuss chairman and a former federal labour minister, and with Blüm, the association’s Hauptgeschäftsführer, as the employee leadership that stood by him when his place between party and union was contested.

### Kolping, the KAB and church bodies

The same compilations list him as a member of the Kolpingsfamilie, a local body of the Kolping Society, and of the Katholische Arbeitnehmer-Bewegung (KAB). The parliamentary handbook notes the Catholic confession and not those memberships. His papers contain KAB correspondence, minutes and working papers for 1970–1981. They also contain membership lists and circulars of the Central Committee of German Catholics (Zentralkomitee der deutschen Katholiken, ZdK) for 1972–1985; the finding aid does not record a ZdK office. A further series covers the Stiftung für christlich-soziale Politik und Bildung for 1979–1985.

In 1996 the Katholisch-Soziales Institut der Erzdiözese Köln, at Bad Honnef, published a first-edition paperback of 191 pages, with illustrations and documents, edited by Hans Nitsche and Joachim Sikora under the title *Adolf Müller (Remscheid) – christlich motiviert, politisch engagiert*.

## Elections and membership of the Bundestag

### State-list mandates, 1961–1987

Adolf Müller was a member of the Bundestag for seven consecutive electoral terms, from the constituent sitting of the fourth Bundestag on 17 October 1961 until the eleventh was constituted on 18 February 1987. The chamber’s biographical master data record him as Müller (Remscheid), identification number 11001542, of the Christian Democratic Union of Germany; the place-name separated him from other deputies named Müller. Every mandate is a state-list seat (Landesliste) for North Rhine-Westphalia, with no constituency entered and no direct mandate, and he sat throughout in the CDU/CSU parliamentary group.

The recorded intervals are 17 October 1961–17 October 1965, 19 October 1965–19 October 1969, 20 October 1969–22 September 1972, 13 December 1972–13 December 1976, 14 December 1976–4 November 1980, 4 November 1980–29 March 1983 and 29 March 1983–18 February 1987. Those opening dates are the constituent sittings after the elections of 17 September 1961, 19 September 1965, 28 September 1969, 19 November 1972, 3 October 1976, 5 October 1980 and 6 March 1983. The sixth-term entry ends on 22 September 1972, before the seventh Bundestag met on 13 December 1972; the ninth runs to 29 March 1983, when the tenth Bundestag met after the election of 6 March.

Article 38 of the Basic Law provides that deputies are elected in general, direct, free, equal and secret ballots and represent the whole people, not bound by instructions. The Federal Elections Act, as amended on 14 February 1964, filled seats from constituency nominations and from state lists, and from the second electoral term the Bundestag’s statistics report party shares by the second vote. In *Die Volksvertretung 1946–1972*, issued by the Kommission für Geschichte des Parlamentarismus und der politischen Parteien, a list candidacy is printed as place over the number of names on the list, and the siglum v marks election. On the CDU list in North Rhine-Westphalia the handbook gives Müller place 25 of 99 in 1961, place 19 of 109 in 1965 and place 21 of 107 in 1969. It documents candidacies through 1969 and prints no later list ranks; the master data still classify the seventh through tenth mandates only as North Rhine-Westphalian state-list seats.

### The 1969 constituency candidacy

For 1961 and 1965 the handbook records only the state-list places. For 1969 it adds a candidacy in Wahlkreis 75 beside list place 21 of 107. The annex to the act of 14 February 1964 named constituency 75 Düsseldorf II, the part of Düsseldorf east of a line through the city; Düsseldorf I (74) was the area west and north of that line plus the whole left bank, and Düsseldorf III (76) the rest of the city. The electoral-district commission reported in 1970 that the 248 constituencies used on 28 September 1969 were that scheme as adapted, under section 49a of the Federal Elections Act, to municipal boundary changes through 1 October 1968, and number 75 was still Düsseldorf II. The same annex named constituency 68 Remscheid: the city of Remscheid plus Hückeswagen, Radevormwald and the Amt Wermelskirchen in the Rhein-Wupper district. The 1969 mandate is stored with no constituency, so Wahlkreis 75 did not become a direct seat.

### The Federal Convention

Article 54 of the Basic Law provides that the Federal President is elected without debate by the Federal Convention, made up of the members of the Bundestag and an equal number elected by the state parliaments by proportional representation. The handbook enters Müller, for the CDU/CSU, as a member of the Federal Convention in 1964 and 1969, the assemblies during his Bundestag membership for which it collated names against the official rolls.

*Crowd gathered outside the Fourth Federal Convention in Berlin on 1 July 1964, with a convertible and a federal flag in the foreground.*

The Fourth Federal Convention met in Berlin on 1 July 1964, with 521 Bundestag members and 521 members elected by the Länder, and re-elected [Heinrich Lübke](/people/heinrich-lubke) with 710 votes. The Fifth met there on 5 March 1969, called early by [Kai-Uwe von Hassel](/people/kai-uwe-von-hassel) after the Federal President announced on 14 October 1968 that he would leave office on 30 June 1969, ahead of the Bundestag election. On the third ballot it elected [Gustav Heinemann](/people/gustav-heinemann), nominated by the [Social Democratic Party of Germany](/organizations/social-democratic-party-of-germany), with 512 votes to 506 for [Gerhard Schröder](/people/gerhard-schroder), the CDU/CSU nominee. The stenographic reports do not name Müller; they list only members excused, and his membership is the handbook entry.

## Labour-market and social legislation

### Chair of the Committee on Labour, 1965–1969

From 1965 to 1969 Adolf Müller (Remscheid), of the Christian Democratic Union/[Christian Social Union](/organizations/christian-social-union-in-bavaria), chaired the Bundestag Committee on Labour. Until 1969, policy rested on placement and unemployment insurance; the Employment Promotion Act added active measures to prevent unemployment, chiefly further training and retraining. The bill went through parliament while Hans Katzer was federal minister of labour under Chancellor [Kurt Georg Kiesinger](/people/kurt-georg-kiesinger).

### The Employment Promotion Act

Katzer had introduced the government draft about eighteen months before the final debate. The committee read it with an initiative of the Social Democratic Party. On 13 May 1969 Müller, as chairman, said the committee had spent about a year and a half on the text, in special sittings and expert hearings and alongside the Vocational Training Act, and had settled the version before the House. For the CDU/CSU he then called it close to the most important social-policy law of the term, without claiming the draft as his own.

He described a shift from removing unemployment to preventing it. Past the government text, the committee added § 8a, requiring employers to warn Land labour-office presidents of changes, foreseeable within twelve months, that would dismiss large numbers of workers or move them to lower-paid work. Employers, he said, had pressed to keep such plans confidential; the committee balanced that against early action, and he held that without the duty prevention would remain on paper. He wanted a legal right, not a discretion, to training support, called help for older workers a duty rather than charity, and welcomed counting short-time work as full time in the pension insurance.

Financing was, on his account, among the sharpest disputes. Folger, for the SPD, held that contributions should pay only unemployment, short-time and bad-weather benefits, and that placement, training and unemployment assistance were public tasks; a report due by the end of 1972 was, for the SPD, a delay, not a settlement. Müller answered that vocational adaptation should not wait, or rank below higher education, and rejected the view that self-administration had been weakened. Katzer’s written statement recalled doubts, among employers’ associations, unions, the self-administration and politicians, that the 1927 law needed replacement rather than amendment, thanked Müller by name, and called the committee text an improvement reached by joining his draft to the SPD initiative. The House passed the bill unanimously the same day. The Act of 25 June 1969 (Bundesgesetzblatt I, page 582) took effect on 1 July 1969, directed the measures toward high employment, a better employment structure and growth, and named the administration the Bundesanstalt für Arbeit.

### Deputy chair of the Committee on Labour and Social Affairs

From 1969 until September 1981 Müller was deputy chairman of the Committee on Labour and Social Affairs. On 1 July 1976, as the nineteenth Pension Adjustment Act took effect, he said the CDU/CSU had introduced or helped shape every such statute, and he traced the wage-linked dynamic pension to the 1957 reform under Anton Storch and Chancellor [Konrad Adenauer](/people/konrad-adenauer). He treated the 1972 opening of pension insurance, and the move of the adjustment from 1 January to 1 July, as Union proposals, and criticised a social-report projection that the health-insurance contribution would rise from 10.6 per cent to 13 per cent by 1979. Asked by an FDP member whether he again wanted unnecessary retraining paid for, he said the 1969 Act had been meant to finance vocational promotion and that later cuts had set it back.

### Works constitution and social insurance

On 10 November 1971 the Bundestag gave a second and third reading to the bill that became the Works Constitution Act of 15 January 1972, and to a CDU/CSU bill on participation in the plant and the enterprise.

Müller defended a CDU/CSU amendment giving the works council co-determination and initiative rights in social matters not already fixed by law or collective agreement, including piece rates, and said it could create substantive entitlements. The House rejected it. He also asked to reverse the burden of proof where a dismissal was challenged for lack of social selection: from his work as a legal representative, he said a worker could not realistically name who should have been dismissed instead, and he appealed to trade unionists on the SPD benches. Schellenberg (SPD) answered that the Union had withdrawn a related motion in committee on 16 September 1971, after the works council’s right to object to dismissals was settled, and that the committee had adopted the clause unanimously on 17 October. The plenary rejected the renewed motion.

On 18 February 1976 the same committee adopted, on the Bundestag’s later account, a unanimous compromise for firms with more than 2,000 employees: equal shareholder and employee seats, at least two open to unions, the rest split among workers, salaried staff and executive staff, and a casting vote for the chair. Unions criticised the lack of 1951 coal-and-steel parity and of a labour director; employers’ associations warned of pressure on managerial freedom and bargaining. Most of the CDU/CSU opposed stricter parity. Müller, named as deputy committee chairman, with Norbert Blüm and Otto Zink, still found the outcome unsatisfactory because 1951-style motions had failed, but voted for the bill as an improvement for employees. Philipp von Bismarck, of the CDU Economic Council, thought a shareholder majority constitutionally required. The Bundestag passed the Co-Determination Act on 18 March 1976 by 389 votes to 22. The Act of 4 May 1976 (Bundesgesetzblatt I, page 1153) applied from 1 July 1976; employers’ associations challenged it, and in 1979 the [Federal Constitutional Court](/organizations/federal-constitutional-court) upheld the statute and the principle of co-determination.

## Role in the CDU/CSU parliamentary group

### Chair of the employee group, 1972–1981

The Arbeitnehmergruppe was the employee caucus inside the Christian Democratic Union/Christian Social Union group in the Bundestag, distinct from the Sozialausschüsse, the party’s social committees. A 2011 remembrance by Sebastian Stein, then district chairman of the Christlich-Demokratische Arbeitnehmerschaft in Remscheid, dates Müller’s chairmanship of that caucus from 1972 to 1981. The biographical handbook of Bundestag members does not itself give those years.

Contemporary CDU publications place him in the office through the middle of the span. On 16 January 1975 *Union in Deutschland* called him chairman of the Arbeitnehmergruppe after a special sitting in Berlin on youth unemployment. The group asked the federal government to press firms and the public service for more training places, to use wage subsidies for jobs for young unemployed people, and to apply the Employment Promotion Act to training, including courses run by the Bundesanstalt für Arbeit where other bodies would not act. The faction list of 24 February 1977, issued while [Helmut Kohl](/people/helmut-kohl) was group chairman, still named him chair of the Arbeitnehmergruppe and a Beisitzer of the executive, not one of the deputy chairs. Those deputies included Hans Katzer, leader of the Sozialausschüsse. The same list had Müller as deputy chairman of the Committee on Labour and Social Affairs, Norbert Blüm on that committee, and Wolfgang Vogt among the group’s members of the Council of Elders.

### Deputy parliamentary group chair, 1981–1987

The handbook records him as a deputy chairman (stellvertretender Fraktionsvorsitzender) of the CDU/CSU group from 1981 to 1987, and as deputy chairman of the Committee on Labour and Social Affairs from 1969 until September 1981. The step into the deputy chairs therefore coincided with his leaving the committee post. In February 1977 he had still been only a Beisitzer, outside the Stellvertreter. The Remscheid CDA remembrance closes the Arbeitnehmergruppe chairmanship in 1981 and, like the handbook, dates the deputy chairmanship to 1981–1987, ending when he left the Bundestag.

### Party discipline and the Eastern treaties

The collision between union office and the parliamentary group came in the spring of 1972, over the Treaty of Moscow and the Treaty of Warsaw. *Der Spiegel* reported that, at the federal committee of the German Trade Union Confederation early in February, Müller had joined a resolution expressly endorsing Ostpolitik, and that colleagues in Bonn had within weeks talked him into opposing the treaties. The magazine described a dual CDU–DGB career already distrusted by the confederation and by CDU chairman Rainer Barzel, and a bid to succeed Bernhard Tacke as a deputy DGB chairman. Friedhelm Farthmann of the Social Democratic Party called the shift “the old routine, raising one’s hand everywhere” (*überall das Händchen heben*).

In April, DGB chairman Heinz Oskar Vetter received Bundestag members who were also DGB officials at the Hotel Tulpenfeld, formally to thank them for work on the new Works Constitution Act, then demanded unconditional approval of the Eastern treaties. He told them to “look the people in the mouth” and added: “The people are we.” Katzer, former federal labour minister and chairman of the Sozialausschüsse, and Müller walked out; Katzer said they would in that case thank Vetter for the dinner. Annotated minutes of the CDU federal executive record that, in the *Westfälische Rundschau* of 10 April, Vetter had urged Müller to vote for the treaties because the DGB had unanimously backed ratification, and that the CDU/CSU group criticised him the same day.

The next day the social-committee leaders, meeting at the Adam-Stegerwald-Haus in Königswinter, agreed that party discipline would rank above union solidarity. Blüm, managing director of the Sozialausschüsse and, on Spiegel’s account, personally inclined toward the government’s Ostpolitik, said the unions should leave the question to the parties. Vogt hoped Social Democrats would see that DGB policy should not be SPD policy. On 24 April Blüm told the CDU executive that Vetter’s handling of “the Müller affair” was a tactical mistake, noticed by capable Social Democrats as well.

The [roll call](/organizations/roll-call) of 17 May did not record a No from Müller. Among members with a full vote, the Moscow ratification passed by 248 to 10, with 238 abstentions, and the Warsaw ratification by 248 to 17, with 231 abstentions. Müller (Remscheid) stands with Katzer and Vogt in the CDU/CSU abstentions on both. On the joint resolution of the CDU/CSU, SPD and FDP, tabled on 10 May as Umdruck 287 and carried by 490 votes with five abstentions, he is listed among the yes votes. Foreign Minister [Walter Scheel](/people/walter-scheel) had described that pairing—yes to the common resolution, abstention on the treaties—as the line the Union had announced.

The quarrel also ended the DGB candidacy. An attempt to substitute Blüm, or Karl-Heinz Hoffmann of the public-services union ÖTV, failed; neither, Spiegel wrote, was under Barzel’s faction whip, and both deferred to Katzer. Vogt’s line was: “We are holding to Adolf Müller.” The annotated minutes record that the DGB executive did not propose Müller and that, at the ninth federal congress in Berlin from 25 to 30 June 1972, Maria Weber was elected instead. The *[Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung](/organizations/frankfurter-allgemeine-zeitung)* of 10 June, cited there, reported that Katzer was holding to Müller.

## Writings and parliamentary arguments

### Arbeitsmarkt, Risiko und Chance

The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek records a monograph by Adolf Müller (1916–2005), *Arbeitsmarkt, Risiko und Chance: Beschäftigungs- und Arbeitsmarktpolitik im Strukturwandel von Wirtschaft und Technik*. The Paulus-Verlag at Recklinghausen published the 78-page booklet in 1968; Bitter issued a second edition of the same length there in 1969. Only the tables of contents are digitised, and they match. The chapters run from the history and organisation of the labour administration through the aims of labour-market policy and the insurance questions—whether unemployment is insurable, how benefits should be harmonised, pension contributions during unemployment, benefit in industrial disputes, and partial loss of wages—to research, placement, guidance, training, retraining, older workers and regional structural policy. Müller set out the same instruments in the Bundestag in 1969.

### Speeches on the labour market and social reports

On 24 April 1963, in the 72nd sitting in Bonn, Müller (Remscheid) spoke for the CDU/CSU on the major interpellation on the labour shortage (Drucksache IV/1072), joined to an FDP bill favouring overtime in tax (Drucksache IV/1161). He held that the assessment of 10 January 1963 by Sabel, president of the [Federal Institute for Labour Placement and Unemployment Insurance](/organizations/bundesagentur-fur-arbeit), was still right, and that the interpellation had dropped Sabel’s hint of some easing. A 9 April report of the North Rhine-Westphalia Land labour office, he said, already showed weaker demand in steel and metalworking and greater difficulty placing older workers. Interference with collective bargaining on hours was “entirely out of the question”. Citing the German Institute for Economic Research, he rejected a stop to shorter hours, and he shared the labour minister’s objections to tax and social-insurance privileges for overtime.

On 13 May 1969, at the second and third reading of the Employment Promotion Act, he spoke as chairman of the Committee on Labour and then for the CDU/CSU. The committee, he said, had recast the government bill in about a year and a half so that it would serve people and the economy together and shift the institute from removing unemployment to preventing it. The Act was “a courageous step into a new phase of modern social policy”.

His last speech, on 10 December 1986, opened the 255th sitting’s debate on the Social Report 1986 (Drucksachen 10/5810 and 10/6704). After twenty-five years in the Bundestag he called the report a convincing balance of Union and FDP policy since 1982, with growth of about 2.5 per cent, lower prices and higher employment set against that year’s fall in output, 5.4 per cent inflation and job losses. Benefit adjustments were not a demolition of the welfare state, he said, but changes required if the same employees were to finance what they received; the “social” in the social market economy still had to be written large. Older, sick and long-term unemployed people formed the hard core. Quoting the chancellor, he called an end to unemployment “a command of humanity”, to be won by “a thousand small steps”, and noted entries to further training and retraining rising from about 265,000 in 1982 to half a million. He defended the wage-related dynamic pension as pay for a lifetime’s work. As a “son of the Kolping family” he closed with an 1851 passage from Adolph Kolping. The SPD deputy Lutz called him a fair opponent, then described the report as numerically padded disinformation that left out losses for pensioners, parents and the unemployed.

## Honours, retirement and death

### Federal and papal orders

The Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany (*Verdienstorden der Bundesrepublik Deutschland*), instituted in 1951 by Federal President Theodor Heuss and commonly called the *Bundesverdienstkreuz*, is the highest recognition the Federal Republic confers for service to the common good, including political, economic, intellectual, social and charitable work. The Federal President confers it in eight classes. A first award is ordinarily the Medal of Merit or the Cross of Merit on ribbon. Above those come, in order, the Cross of Merit, 1st class (*Verdienstkreuz 1. Klasse*), the Grand Cross of Merit (*Großes Verdienstkreuz*), the Grand Cross of Merit with Star, the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and sash, and the Grand Cross. A special class of the Grand Cross is reserved for heads of state. The president presents the insignia in person only rarely; a minister-president, a federal or *Land* minister, a regional government president or a mayor usually does so.

A biographical profile drawn from the Bundestag’s membership data and from reference works records four decorations. In 1970 Müller received the federal Cross of Merit, 1st class; in 1979 the Grand Cross of Merit; and in 1986 the Grand Cross of Merit with Star. In 1972 he received the Commander’s Cross (*Komturkreuz*) of the Order of St Gregory the Great (*Gregoriusorden*). That order is one of the Holy See’s own orders of chivalry. In a clarification of 10 October 2026 the Secretariat of State listed it with the Supreme Order of Christ, the Order of the Golden Spur, the Order of [Pope Pius IX](/people/pope-pius-ix) and the Order of Saint Sylvester, apart from orders the Holy See only recognises and from unrecognised bodies using sacred titles.

### Work after leaving parliament

Müller’s membership of the Bundestag ended on 18 February 1987, the date the Bundestag’s biographical register gives for the close of his mandate in the tenth legislative period. The register has him sitting continuously from 17 October 1961, always for the Christian Democratic Union on the state list of North Rhine-Westphalia, and it records no later mandate. The handbook *Die Volksvertretung 1946–1972*, from the Commission for the History of Parliamentarism and Political Parties, gives the same span, 1961–1987, and describes no public office after he left the chamber.

The account of his years in Remscheid after that date comes from a local remembrance rather than from those parliamentary records. On 13 May 2011, when Müller would have turned 95, Sebastian Stein, district chairman of the Christian Democratic Employees’ organisation in Remscheid, said that after leaving the Bundestag Müller worked among older people in the city. Stein said the consultation hours Müller held in residential homes for the elderly were well attended, and that Müller helped many residents with his knowledge and experience.

### Death

The Bundestag register records Müller’s death on 22 February 2005. Born on 13 May 1916 in Remscheid-Lennep, he was 88. The same entry describes him as Catholic, married and the father of two children, and gives his occupation as a skilled worker; it names no place of death. The parliamentary handbook gives the same date, 22 February 2005.

## Papers and historical assessment

### The ACDP deposit

The papers are the Nachlass Müller, Adolf, in the Archive for Christian Democratic Policy of the Konrad Adenauer Foundation at [Sankt Augustin](/organizations/sankt-augustin), signature 01-416. Kalliope gives the extent as 6.8 linear metres, dated 1964–1986. The record is a database finding aid, entered on 24 March 2008 and modified on 28 April 2024; the years 1916–2005 in the same entry are a biographical note, not file dates. The handbook of the Commission for the History of Parliamentarism and Political Parties notes only “Nachlaß: ACDP Sankt Augustin.”

The series are working files from those years. Bundestag material for 1972–1985 is correspondence, especially on social insurance and Section 218, plus protocols and letters of the Committee on Labour and Social Affairs (1968–1984) and a short file of the Committee on Youth, Family and Health (1983/84). CDU papers cover the federal committee (1978–1986), federal congresses (1978–1985), the federal social-policy committee (1973–1982), the Rhineland Land association (1974–1977) and the 1976 agreement with the CSU on a joint parliamentary group. Christian Democratic Employees’ files cover the federal association (1972–1983), the working group of Christian-democratic DGB trade unionists (1981–1985), Land bodies and especially Rhineland workplace groups (1964–1982), and the Europäische Union Christlich-Demokratischer Arbeitnehmer (1974–1980). Further groups are DGB letters and cuttings (1970–1979), the Central Committee of German Catholics (1972–1985), the Katholische Arbeitnehmer-Bewegung (1970–1981), the Stiftung für christlich-soziale Politik und Bildung (1979–1985), the foundation’s trade-union advisory board (1975–1983), press releases of the Bundesanstalt für Arbeit (1973–1976), and speeches, articles and drafts.

### Place among Christian trade unionists in the Union

Wolfgang Schroeder places Müller, with Maria Weber and Rudi Nickels, in a second generation of Christian-social officials in the German Trade Union Confederation, born mainly from 1916 to 1930 and formed by the Nazi years, Catholic youth work and the war, for whom the unitary union was a given rather than a gain of their own. He also counts Müller among the leading Christian-social functionaries of the North Rhine-Westphalia district, with the deputy federal chairman the senior post of that tendency. In 1959 he and Bernhard Tacke headed the Arbeitsgemeinschaft christlich-sozialer DGB-Gewerkschafter in den Sozialausschüssen, which Schroeder describes as the lasting gathering of those trade unionists and, after the Christlich-Soziale Kollegenschaft left the DGB in 1960, as the body that drew them closer to the CDU. Of the group he judges that its strength was too slight, and its initiatives too little profiled, to remake relations between the DGB and Catholicism, though their staying in the DGB helped to leave a separate [Christian union](/organizations/christian-union) unsuccessful. Müller is not among the federal chairmen of the Sozialausschüsse on Schroeder’s list.

In 1972 he was the original candidate to succeed Tacke as a deputy DGB chairman, and was not elected. *Der Spiegel* reported in April, before the vote in the Bundestag, that he had backed a February DGB resolution for Ostpolitik and had then let CDU colleagues talk him into opposing the Eastern treaties. Friedhelm Farthmann of the Social Democratic Party called the change “the old routine, raising one’s hand everywhere” (*überall das Händchen heben*). Gerhard Leminsky wrote that the unions dropped him for that fluctuating line, that a circle around Hans Katzer tried to make his candidacy a test of the unitary union, and that the Berlin congress (25 June–1 July 1972) rejected the charge. Tacke said the quarrel had wrongly been about a person, not the principle; Maria Weber took the deputy seat. The social committees kept him; Wolfgang Vogt’s reported line was “We are holding to Adolf Müller.” From 1972 to 1981 he instead chaired the employee group of the CDU/CSU in the Bundestag. One published appreciation is a commemorative volume of 191 pages from the Katholisch-Soziales Institut of the Archdiocese of Cologne, edited by Hans Nitsche and Joachim Sikora, *Adolf Müller (Remscheid) – christlich motiviert, politisch engagiert* (1996).

## Dated facts

_No published facts on this page yet._

## Methodology

https://factrail.ai/methodology

Canonical: https://factrail.ai/people/adolf-muller
