# Anthony Lester, Baron Lester of Herne Hill

# Anthony Lester, Baron Lester of Herne Hill

Anthony Paul Lester, Baron Lester of Herne Hill, QC (3 July 1936 – 8 August 2020) was a British barrister and Liberal Democrat life peer who worked on equality statutes and on making the [European Convention on Human Rights](/facts/european-convention-on-human-rights) enforceable in domestic courts. Born in London, he was educated at the City of London School, served in the Royal Artillery from 1955 to 1957, read history and law at [Trinity College, Cambridge](/organizations/trinity-college-cambridge), and took a master's degree at [Harvard Law School](/organizations/harvard-law-school). He was called to the Bar by [Lincoln's Inn](/organizations/lincoln-s-inn) in 1963 and appointed Queen's Counsel in 1975. Letters patent dated 13 October 1993 created him Baron Lester of Herne Hill, of Herne Hill in the London Borough of Southwark, and he sat in the [House of Lords](/organizations/house-of-lords) until his resignation in December 2018. He died of heart disease at the age of 84.

As special adviser to Home Secretary [Roy Jenkins](/people/roy-jenkins), he was credited by Jenkins with writing much of the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 and the Race Relations Act 1976, passed under [Harold Wilson](/people/harold-wilson)'s Labour government. He argued for more than thirty years that Convention rights should be pleadable in British courts, a change made by the Human Rights Act 1998 under [Tony Blair](/people/tony-blair). Later parliamentary work associated with him included civil partnerships, given statutory form in the Civil Partnership Act 2004, and changes to the law of libel in the Defamation Act 2013. In the Lords he was a member of the Joint Committee on Human Rights from 2001 to 2015 and was the Liberal Democrat spokesman on human rights until the 2018 complaint against him.

At the Bar he acted in several widely reported cases, among them the *Sunday Times* litigation in 1972 over the drug thalidomide, the attempt by [Margaret Thatcher](/people/margaret-thatcher)'s government in 1987 to restrain publication of the former MI5 officer Peter Wright's memoir *Spycatcher*, and the 1997 proceedings in which Diane Blood obtained the right to use her dead husband's stored sperm. He had stood for the [Labour Party](/organizations/labour-party-uk) at Worthing in the 1966 general election, joined the Social [Democratic Party](/organizations/democratic-party-us) in 1981, and was nominated for a peerage by [Paddy Ashdown](/people/paddy-ashdown) after he moved to the [Liberal Democrats](/organizations/liberal-democrats). In 2007 Prime Minister [Gordon Brown](/people/gordon-brown) appointed him an adviser on constitutional reform to the justice secretary, Jack Straw; he resigned the post the following year.

In November 2017 the House of Lords Commissioner for Standards received a complaint from the campaigner [Jasvinder Sanghera](/people/jasvinder-sanghera) about conduct she dated to 2006. The Privileges and Conduct Committee upheld findings that Lester had sexually harassed her and had offered her a peerage if she slept with him, and it recommended suspension until 2022. Lester described the allegations as completely untrue. On 15 November 2018 the House voted by 101 to 78 to send the report back to the committee to consider arguments about natural justice. He resigned on 12 December 2018, the day the committee published a further report standing by the investigation, and told *[The Times](/organizations/the-times)* that the case had taken a serious toll on his health. He was survived by his wife, the barrister Catherine Wassey, their son Gideon and their daughter Maya, who was appointed Queen's Counsel in 2016.

## Early life and education

### Family and childhood

Anthony Paul Lester was born Anthony Paul Raab in London on 3 July 1936. The *Oxford Dictionary of National Biography* records that his father had immigrated from Hungary, that his parents divorced shortly after his birth, and that he was brought up by his mother, Kate (née Cooper-Smith), a milliner, and his stepfather, the barrister Harry Lester, who later adopted him. Obituaries describe him as Harry and Kate Lester’s elder son and as the grandchild of Jewish refugees.

He was educated at the [City of London School](/organizations/city-of-london-school). A contemporary, John Cooper, recalled that Lester commanded the school cadet force at an outside inspection, sometimes took Jewish prayers, and, with the future television producer Brian Lapping, co-founded a debating society that other schools took up. He was not religious, but he made sure that other Jewish boys observed the festivals, later joking that he had been a “kapo”.

### Cambridge, national service and Harvard

From 1955 to 1957 he did National Service as a second lieutenant in the Royal Artillery. A non-observing Jew, he refused a senior officer’s suggestion that he record his religion as [Church of England](/organizations/church-of-england) rather than Jewish. The *Jewish Chronicle* reported that he was then barred from a dance at the officers’ mess, and that he afterwards said: “I was good enough to die for my country but not good enough to dance with the maids of Kent.” The *Guardian* and the *Irish Times* reported that the advice was given before the 1956 [Suez Crisis](/facts/suez-crisis), on the ground that he would be less likely to be tortured if captured.

In 1957 he went up to Trinity College, Cambridge, with an exhibition, read history and then law, and graduated in 1960. With [Leon Brittan](/people/leon-brittan), later a Conservative home secretary, he tried without success to have careers-service staff removed after antisemitic remarks about students. The *Jewish Chronicle* reported the description “short and Jewish with wet palms”, and that too few students were willing to object.

After Cambridge he declined an invitation to join the foreign ministry of Israel and spent two years at Harvard Law School as a Harkness Fellow of the [Commonwealth Fund](/organizations/commonwealth-fund), taking an LLM. He later recalled finding himself among “loads of Jews” whose approach to law was “quite different”, and called the experience “transforming”. During that period of study he visited the Southern states.

In the summer of 1964 [Amnesty International](/organizations/amnesty-international) sent him, unpaid, on a ten-week inquiry into the administration of criminal justice in ordinary cases involving Black defendants and in cases involving civil-rights workers, choosing him for the knowledge gained at Harvard. He began in [New York](/organizations/new-york) and Washington, then travelled through Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana, spending most of his time in Mississippi during Freedom Summer, a voter-registration campaign by more than 800 students. The project opened on 21 June 1964 with the murder, near Philadelphia, Mississippi, of three civil-rights workers, James Chaney, Michael Schwerner and Andrew Goodman; the [Civil Rights Act of 1964](/facts/civil-rights-act-of-1964), banning discrimination in public facilities and in much of education and employment, came into force during the same summer. Lester interviewed more than 200 federal and state officials, judges, lawyers, police officers, journalists, and members of civil-rights and white-supremacist organisations. His report, *Justice in the American South*, was published by Amnesty in 1964. He wrote that he had gone as a committed sympathiser of the civil-rights struggle but with the advantage of being a foreign observer, and that Britain had “little to teach and much to learn” from the United States about combating racial discrimination, while the Deep South remained sharply different from the rest of the country.

## Practice at the Bar

### Call, silk and chambers

Lester was called to the Bar by Lincoln's Inn in 1963, as a Mansfield Scholar, and joined 2 Hare Court, the set later known as Blackstone Chambers. The *Telegraph* recorded that much of the early work was commercial. He was appointed Queen's Counsel in 1975, became a bencher of Lincoln's Inn in 1985, and sat as a recorder from 1987 to 1993. He was called to the Irish Bar in 1983 and to the Bar of Northern Ireland in 1984; the catalogue of his papers also lists him as Queen's Counsel in Northern Ireland.

### Press freedom and public-law cases

A substantial part of the practice was for Times Newspapers and [*The Sunday Times*](/organizations/the-sunday-times). In the thalidomide contempt litigation, the publisher, the editor [Harold Evans](/people/harold-evans) and a group of journalists challenged restraints on an article about the drug and Distillers. At the hearing in *The Sunday Times v. the United Kingdom*, Lester QC appeared with A. Whitaker, the newspaper's legal manager, assisting the delegates of the [European Commission of Human Rights](/organizations/european-commission-of-human-rights). On 26 April 1979 the European Court of Human Rights held, by eleven votes to nine, that the injunction breached Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

He and [David Pannick](/people/david-pannick-baron-pannick) represented Times Newspapers Ltd and its editor, [Andrew Neil](/people/andrew-neil), in *The Sunday Times v. the United Kingdom (No. 2)*, the case on *Spycatcher*, the memoir of the former MI5 officer Peter Wright. The complaint concerned interlocutory restraints which, through contempt of court, bound the paper from 30 July 1987 to 13 October 1988. The Court held unanimously on 26 November 1991 that those restraints violated Article 10. The judgment also records the domestic result: on 13 October 1988 the House of Lords held that an extract published on 12 July 1987 was a breach of confidence, so the paper had to account for profits, but that further injunctions were not justified once the book was public. A finding of contempt was later upheld, although the Court of Appeal set aside a fine of £50,000.

In *Derbyshire County Council v. Times Newspapers Ltd.*, Lester QC and Desmond Browne QC appeared for the newspaper, and Charles Gray QC and Heather Rogers for Derbyshire County Council. On 18 February 1993 the House of Lords dismissed the council's appeal. It held that a body of central or local government could not sue in defamation over its governmental reputation, and struck out the claim on *Sunday Times* articles about the council's superannuation fund.

In *Reynolds v Times Newspapers Ltd*, the former taoiseach [Albert Reynolds](/people/albert-reynolds) sued over a 1994 article, "Goodbye gombeen man", about his resignation. Lord Lester of Herne Hill QC, James Price QC and Pushpinder Saini appeared for the newspaper; Andrew Caldecott QC and Benjamin Hinchliff appeared for Reynolds. On 28 October 1999 the House of Lords, Lord Steyn and Lord Hope dissenting, held that the newspaper was not entitled to qualified privilege on the facts, because serious allegations had been presented as fact without Reynolds's explanation. The House refused to treat all political information as privileged, while holding that the nature, status and source of the material, and the circumstances of publication, went to whether a duty to publish and a corresponding interest existed.

### Medical, family and overseas work

In *Airedale NHS Trust v. Bland*, Lester QC and Pushpinder Saini, instructed by the Treasury Solicitor, appeared as amici curiae. Tony Bland had been in a vegetative state since the Hillsborough disaster. On 4 February 1993 the House of Lords dismissed an appeal by the Official Solicitor. It held that stopping life support, including feeding by nasogastric tube, was a lawful omission where treatment was futile, there was no prospect of improvement, and discontinuance accorded with responsible medical opinion; a positive act to end life remained unlawful.

In *Regina v. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, ex parte Blood*, Lord Lester QC, Peter Duffy and Michael Fordham represented Diane Blood, and David Pannick QC and Dinah Rose the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Sperm had been taken while Stephen Blood was in a coma from meningitis; he died without the written consent required by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990. On 6 February 1997 the Court of Appeal (Lord Woolf MR, Waite and Henry LJJ) held that storage and use in the United Kingdom without that consent were unlawful. It held that the refusal to permit export to Belgium was flawed, because the Authority had not taken account of Mrs Blood's directly effective rights under Articles 59 and 60 of the EC Treaty to receive medical services in another member state. The Authority had to reconsider, and was not bound to authorise the export.

He was counsel for the United Kingdom, with the Attorney General, S. Silkin QC, J. B. E. Hutton QC and N. Bratza, in *Ireland v. the United Kingdom*. On 18 January 1978 the Court held, by sixteen votes to one, that the "five techniques" of interrogation used in Northern Ireland in 1971 were a practice of inhuman and degrading treatment in breach of Article 3, and, by thirteen votes to four, that they were not torture. The *Irish Times* recorded later appearances in Northern Ireland for the *Irish News* in a defamation claim over a restaurant review, for the Family Planning Association on information about lawful abortion, for *The Times* in a defamation action concerning the soldier Lee Clegg, and in an unsuccessful 1991 challenge to the Home Secretary's 1988 ban on broadcast interviews with IRA spokespersons.

In 1989, after a human-rights case in the courts of Singapore, he was barred from any further case there. The *Telegraph* reported the stated ground as his having been "combative and truculent"; the *Guardian* reported that the exclusion took on a diplomatic aspect when the Foreign and Commonwealth Office objected.

## Equality legislation

### Campaign Against Racial Discrimination and the Runnymede Trust

Lester later wrote that, after Harvard Law School and reporting on the American South, he joined the Grenadian physician David Pitt and others to found the Campaign Against Racial Discrimination (CARD), inspired by [Martin Luther King Jr](/people/martin-luther-king-jr).. A London meeting with King in December 1964, arranged by Marion Glean, led to the founding meeting on 10 January 1965. Pitt chaired it, and Dipak Nandy and Hamza Alavi were among the other founders.

Lobbying the Home Secretary, Sir Frank Soskice, as a Labour Party lawyer, Lester pressed for civil remedies rather than a criminal offence enforced by the Attorney General. The Race Relations Act 1965 was confined to incitement to racial hatred and discrimination in public places: a Race Relations Board could conciliate, only the Attorney General could sue, and employment, housing, education and services were excluded. Lester later called the Act fatally flawed. A history of CARD credits him with a “green document” of amendments favouring complaints committees, and records that the organisation dissolved in 1968.

With Mark Bonham Carter and John Lyttle of the Board, the campaign continued. Lester wrote that he helped Roy Jenkins with a May 1966 speech defining integration as “equal opportunity, accompanied by cultural diversity, in an atmosphere of mutual tolerance,” and that Jenkins announced a wider law in 1967. [James Callaghan](/people/james-callaghan), who succeeded him at the [Home Office](/organizations/home-office), introduced the Race Relations Act 1968. Lester described it as wide in scope but deliberately weak in enforcement, and as the Act that created the Community Relations Commission.

In 1968 Lester and the publisher Jim Rose founded the Runnymede Trust “to counter racist propaganda and to develop programmes for an increasingly diverse society.” The trust names the two as its founders. Nandy has been identified as its first director. Rose chaired it from 1980 to 1990; Lester was chair in 1992, and a *Guardian* obituary gives his term as 1991–93.

### Sex Discrimination Act 1975 and Race Relations Act 1976

In 1974 Lester left the Bar to serve as Jenkins’s special adviser on sex and race legislation, remaining until Jenkins left the Home Office in September 1976. A *Guardian* obituary reported that Jenkins’s memoirs credited Lester with encouraging his commitment to human rights and with “writing much of the legislation almost single-handed.” A 2008 *Guardian* editorial quoted Jack Straw, then Justice Secretary, calling that contribution to race-relations legislation “greater, and more singular … than anyone else in this country.” Jenkins himself moved both bills.

On 26 March 1975 he sought a second reading for the Sex Discrimination Bill as the White Paper *Equality for Women*, published the previous September. Dr Shirley Summerskill, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State at the Home Office, spoke for the government on the detail. The Sex Discrimination Act 1975 received royal assent on 12 November 1975. It made certain sex discrimination, and discrimination on the ground of marriage, unlawful, and established the Equal Opportunities Commission.

On 4 March 1976 Jenkins moved the Race Relations Bill to implement the White Paper on racial discrimination published in September 1975. He said it covered direct discrimination and “unjustifiable indirect discrimination,” and that a new commission would have “a major strategic role in enforcing the law in the public interest.” The Race Relations Act 1976 received royal assent on 22 November 1976 and aligned enforcement of the 1975 Act with the race statute. The Commission for Racial Equality replaced the Race Relations Board and took on the work of the Community Relations Commission. Lester later wrote that he had advised against combining enforcement with that promotional role, and that, after Jenkins left, contract compliance and strategic investigations were not pursued as he had intended.

### Later equality bills

As a Liberal Democrat in the House of Lords, Lester used private members’ bills. On 25 January 2002 he moved a Civil Partnerships Bill, prepared with Stonewall and its director Angela Mason and drafted by the former parliamentary counsel Stephanie Grundy, under which unmarried couples of either sex could register a mutually supportive relationship. It did not pass. A *Guardian* obituary described his civil-partnership work as leading to the Civil Partnership Act 2004, the government’s Act, limited to same-sex couples.

The Equality Bill followed a July 2000 Cambridge report by Bob Hepple, Mary Coussey and Tufyal Choudhury, supported by the Nuffield Foundation and the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust. Grundy drafted a bill from the report; it was published for consultation in July 2002 and revised with the three commissions and Lester’s Odysseus Trust. Introduced on 14 January 2003, it would have prohibited discrimination on grounds of age, gender reassignment, religion or belief, and sexual orientation; recast disability, race and sex law; banned harassment and victimisation; and created an Equality Commission for Great Britain. On 28 February 2003 Lester said the bill should move the government from piecemeal regulations to a single Act. Baroness Buscombe, for the Conservatives, supported its principles, and the Lords gave it a second reading without a division. The Lords passed it on 9 May 2003; on 11 July the Commons did not move it.

The Equality Act 2006, which received royal assent on 16 February 2006, created the [Equality and Human Rights Commission](/organizations/equality-and-human-rights-commission) and dissolved the three existing commissions. The Equality Act 2010, which received royal assent on 8 April 2010, harmonised equality law and restated most enactments on discrimination and harassment. At the bill’s Lords second reading on 15 December 2009, Lester spoke on homophobic bullying in schools and on religious exemptions. His separate campaign for the Human Rights Act 1998 is distinct from these equality statutes.

## Human rights advocacy

### Interights

In 1982 a group of lawyers, academics and activists established the International Centre for the Legal Protection of Human Rights (Interights) in London, arguing that international human-rights law, then still thinly developed, could be used in court to widen protection and obtain redress. Anthony Lester, a barrister at Blackstone Chambers, was a co-founder and became honorary president. The barrister Jeremy McBride, chair of the board, was also described by the organisation as a co-founder. Registered as charity number 292357, it used international and comparative law in test cases to enforce rights and obtain redress.

On 27 October 2008 the Community Court of Justice of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), sitting in Niamey, held that Niger had failed to protect Hadijatou Mani from slavery and awarded her 10 million CFA francs, about £12,000. Interights recorded itself as a co-applicant, with its litigation director Helen Duffy as co-counsel. [Anti-Slavery International](/organizations/anti-slavery-international) described the conditions of enslavement in Niger to reporters covering the judgment. Interights closed on 27 May 2014. Executive director John Wadham wrote that funding could not be sustained despite redundancies, that pending cases would pass to partners, and that [the centre](/organizations/the-centre)’s work, over 32 years, had included slavery litigation in Niger, detention standards at the African Commission, a minority community in Transdniestria, and cases on disability and on sexual orientation or gender.

### The Human Rights Act 1998

Lester’s parliamentary campaign sought to make rights in the European Convention on Human Rights enforceable in British courts. At second reading in the House of Lords on 25 January 1995 he said that, without a domestic remedy, applicants had to go to the [European Commission](/organizations/european-commission) and the European Court of Human Rights, and that Britain had been found in serious breach more often than any other state. He named earlier sponsors, including Lord Wade, Lord Broxbourne and [Leslie Scarman, Baron Scarman](/people/leslie-scarman-baron-scarman). The white paper *Rights Brought Home* (October 1997) also recorded a 1987 [House of Commons](/organizations/house-of-commons) bill by the Conservative MP Sir Edward Gardner, then Lester’s bills of 1994 and 1996.

His Human Rights Bill, given a first reading on 22 November 1994, was to incorporate section 1 of the Convention and the First Protocol. He proposed an effect like the [European Communities](/organizations/european-communities) Act 1972: courts would read legislation so as to comply with the Convention unless Parliament later said otherwise in plain terms, and public authorities would owe an enforceable duty. Critics called that close to a power to displace Acts and a challenge to parliamentary sovereignty. It was not enacted.

A revised bill had its first reading on 31 October 1996 and its second reading on 5 February 1997. Lester said he had adopted the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990, with help from the New Zealand judge Sir Kenneth Keith, because senior judges had wanted a scheme that did not challenge parliamentary sovereignty. Unlike the 1994 text, courts could not strike down Acts, but ministers introducing bills would have to explain any apparent inconsistency with Convention rights. It was not enacted either. Jack Straw later said that none of these attempts had “borne fruit”, but that they had shown a growing consensus for change.

The Act that passed was the Labour government’s. Straw told the Commons that, after a commitment by Labour leader John Smith, he and [Paul Boateng](/people/paul-boateng) had published *Bringing Rights Home* in December 1996, that Lester helped with the drafting, and that the replies put incorporation into the manifesto. In October 1997 Tony Blair’s government presented *Rights Brought Home* (Cm 3782), with a preface by Blair, and introduced its own Human Rights Bill. Lord Chancellor [Derry Irvine](/people/derry-irvine-baron-irvine-of-lairg) moved the Lords second reading on 3 November 1997 and called Lester a campaigner for such legislation for perhaps 30 years. Straw moved the Commons second reading on 16 February 1998.

Courts were not given power to set aside Acts. The white paper said they would interpret legislation “as far as possible” compatibly with the Convention and, failing that, could declare provisions incompatible, leaving ministers and Parliament to amend the law, if they chose, by statute or a fast-track order. Section 3 requires that compatible reading “so far as it is possible to do so”, without affecting the validity of incompatible primary legislation; section 4 is the declaration of incompatibility; section 6 makes incompatible acts by public authorities unlawful unless primary legislation required them. Irvine said a declaration would not change the law, and that Parliament “may, not must” legislate, though it generally would. Lester backed the bill as an exercise of parliamentary sovereignty rather than a challenge to it, and said declarations should be rare.

The Human Rights Act 1998 received royal assent on 9 November 1998. Its long title is an Act “to give further effect” to Convention rights, not to place them above statute. Straw, as Home Secretary, appointed 2 October 2000 as the day on which the provisions not already in force would come into force.

### Joint Committee on Human Rights and related reforms

*Rights Brought Home* suggested that Parliament establish its own human-rights committee. On 3 July 2001 the Lords named six peers, Lester among them, to join a Commons committee as the Joint Committee on Human Rights, to consider human-rights matters in the United Kingdom excluding individual cases, and to scrutinise remedial orders under section 10 of the 1998 Act. Parliamentary records list his membership from that date until 30 March 2015.

Two later bills of his were followed by government legislation of narrower or different shape. On 9 January 2002 he introduced a Civil Partnerships Bill. At second reading on 25 January he proposed registration for unrelated adult couples, same-sex or opposite-sex, and said it was not marriage. Ministers discussed it with him and with Angela Mason of Stonewall. It was not the measure enacted. The Civil Partnership Act 2004, which received royal assent on 18 November 2004, defined a civil partnership as a relationship between two people of the same sex. A *Guardian* obituary later tied his civil-partnership work to that Act.

In the 2010–12 session he introduced a Defamation Bill, given a second reading on 9 July 2010, concerned with the balance between reputation and freedom of expression. The coalition government’s separate Defamation Act 2013 received royal assent on 25 April 2013. It provides that a statement is not defamatory unless publication has caused or is likely to cause serious harm to reputation and, for a body trading for profit, serious financial loss. The same obituary attributed the Act to his free-speech work; the statute was a government bill, not his private member’s bill.

## Political career

### Labour, the SDP and the Liberal Democrats

Lester was a member of the Labour Party in the 1960s, when he was among the party lawyers pressing for a wider race-relations statute. A committed follower of [Hugh Gaitskell](/people/hugh-gaitskell), he belonged to the Society of Labour Lawyers and chaired the [Fabian Society](/organizations/fabian-society) from 1972 to 1973. His only candidacy for the House of Commons was at Worthing in the 1966 general election, a safe Conservative seat. He received 10,281 votes and finished second to Terence Higgins, the Conservative, who took 29,903; the Liberal candidate polled 8,955 and an Independent Conservative 1,044, on a turnout of 75.7 per cent.

When Roy Jenkins returned as home secretary in 1974, Lester left the Bar to serve as his special adviser, developing new legislation against sex and race discrimination. Official lists recorded him as a part-time special adviser at the Home Office on 21 November 1974 and still in post on 2 August 1976. He later wrote that he returned to practice when Jenkins left the department in September 1976. The notice of his peerage also described him as a former special adviser to the Standing Advisory Commission on Human Rights in Northern Ireland.

His friendship with Jenkins took him into the breakaway Social Democratic Party in 1981. The 1993 peerage announcement called him a founder member of the SDP. After the SDP he joined the Liberal Democrats. By August 1993 he was president of the Liberal Democrat Lawyers Association. Paddy Ashdown, whom he had advised, including on an internal party problem in Tower Hamlets, nominated him for the Lords. He remained a Liberal Democrat peer until 2018.

### Life peerage and Lords roles

On 13 August 1993 [the London Gazette](/organizations/the-london-gazette) recorded the Queen's intention to confer a life peerage on Anthony Paul Lester QC. Letters patent dated 13 October 1993 created him Baron Lester of Herne Hill, of Herne Hill in the London Borough of Southwark. He was introduced to the House of Lords on 3 November 1993, in his robes, between Lord Jenkins of Hillhead and [Lord Woolf](/people/harry-woolf-baron-woolf).

In the Lords he was the Liberal Democrats' spokesman on human rights. He also introduced private members' bills aimed at making government more open. He was a member of the Procedure and Privileges Committee from 23 November 1994 to 17 October 1996, and of the Constitution Committee from 12 June 2013 to 12 May 2016.

### Adviser on constitutional reform

In [the week](/organizations/the-week) before Gordon Brown's statement of 3 July 2007 on constitutional reform, press reports suggested that Lester might be made attorney general or a minister for constitutional reform. Two ministers told him that he would first have to rejoin Labour. He refused, later writing that he had no wish to betray Liberal Democrat colleagues or to become a minister, and was then asked to see Jack Straw, the justice secretary and lord chancellor, about an advisory post.

Lester agreed to advise Straw on four conditions: that he be unpaid and wholly independent; that he advise rather than serve as a junior minister; that he see Straw often enough for the relationship to be useful; and that he see the relevant papers and attend cabinet committees where necessary. Straw accepted. Lester afterwards wrote that the appointment had been Brown's idea rather than Straw's, and that he had entered what he called Brown's "big tent", the "government of all the talents". A contemporary profile treated the choice as a use of his constitutional-law work and of those open-government bills.

He spent about 15 months in the Ministry of Justice, with the junior minister Michael Wills and civil servants, on the programme set out in the *Governance of Britain* green paper. He later wrote that, beyond being unpaid and independent, none of his conditions was met: he rarely discussed policy with Straw, some key papers arrived too late for him to influence them, and he was never asked to a cross-departmental meeting or a cabinet committee. He called the period a "waste of effort" and described himself as a "tethered goat".

He resigned in November 2008. The Liberal Democrats said he disagreed with some proposals for a British bill of rights and with parts of the government's constitutional-reform plans. The Conservative front bench presented the resignation as another outsider leaving Brown's government, and as a sign of trouble for Straw's ideas of adding rights to the Human Rights Act 1998. On 10 December 2008, in a speech marking the sixtieth anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Lester said he had stopped being a "government-tethered goat" because of what he called a "dismal and deeply disappointing" human-rights record and a failure of political leadership to match the green paper. He attacked an interview in which Straw was reported as addressing the complaint that the Human Rights Act was a "villains' charter", which Lester called a departure from earlier lord chancellors who had defended the Act. In July 2009 he described the Constitutional Reform and Governance Bill that followed as a "mouse of a bill", noting that it left ministers' prerogative powers, the decision to go to war, electoral reform, and stronger legal protection of rights outside the statute.

## Publications, teaching and honours

### Books and lectures

Lester’s publications ran from a 1964 Amnesty report on the American South to *Five Ideas to Fight For* (2016) and a memoir issued after his death.

*Cover of Anthony Lester’s Five Ideas to Fight For ([Oneworld Publications](/organizations/oneworld-publications), 2016).*

*Justice in the American South* (1964) was published by Amnesty International after its executive sent him, unpaid, to the southern United States to inquire into the imprisonment of Black people and civil-rights workers; he was chosen for knowledge gained at Harvard Law School. He was co-editor of the third edition of *Shawcross and Beaumont on Air Law* (1966) and, for the Fabian Society, of *Policies for racial equality* (1967), and he edited a 1967 Collins volume of essays and speeches by Roy Jenkins. In 1968 he gave a Fabian lecture calling for human-rights legislation, later described as the start of a thirty-year campaign to incorporate the European Convention on Human Rights into domestic law. The society published his 24-page tract *Democracy and Individual Rights* (Fabian tract 390) in 1969.

With Geoffrey Bindman he wrote *Race and Law* (Penguin, 1972), a 491-page account of British race-relations legislation, especially in employment and housing. A catalogue of his papers at [University College London](/organizations/university-college-london) also lists work on nationality and immigration in the fourth edition of *Halsbury’s Laws of England* (1973). In 1990 the Institute for Public Policy Research published his pamphlet *A British Bill of Rights*.

He and Dawn Oliver were consultant editors of *Constitutional Law and Human Rights* (Butterworths, 1997), first published in 1996 as volume 8(2) of *Halsbury’s Laws of England*, with a foreword by Lord Woolf. *The Telegraph* lists *Human Rights Law and Practice* (1999) among his books; a substantially rewritten third edition, edited with David Pannick and Javan Herberg, was published by LexisNexis Butterworths in April 2009. *Five Ideas to Fight For: How Our Freedom is Under Threat and Why it Matters* was issued by Oneworld in hardback on 5 May 2016 and in paperback in 2017. Obituaries describe it as arguing that human rights, equality, free speech, privacy and the rule of law still needed defence, including against a Parliament asserting its sovereignty. Biteback published the posthumous memoir *Talking to Myself: A Life in Human Rights* on 18 January 2022.

### Academic posts and awards

He was honorary visiting professor at University College London from 1983 and visiting professor of public law there from 1992. From 2005 he was an adjunct professor in the law faculty at [University College Cork](/organizations/university-college-cork), taking seminars on the European Convention in Irish courts, on forced marriage, and on the prohibition of Sikh turbans in the [Garda Síochána](/organizations/garda-siochana). He sat on the Board of Overseers of the [University of Pennsylvania](/organizations/university-of-pennsylvania) Law School from 1978 to 1989 and was a member of the American Law Institute from 1985. Lincoln’s Inn made him a bencher in 1985.

The [American Academy of Arts and Sciences](/organizations/american-academy-of-arts-and-sciences) elected him a foreign honorary member in 2002. France appointed him a Chevalier of the Legion of Honour in 2009. At the 2007 human-rights awards sponsored by Liberty and JUSTICE, he received the judges’ award “for a lifetime of achievement in the service of human rights.”

## Conduct investigation and resignation

### Complaint and the commissioner's findings

In November 2017 Lucy Scott-Moncrieff, the House of Lords Commissioner for Standards, received a complaint that Lord Lester of Herne Hill had sexually harassed a woman, offered her a corrupt inducement to have a sexual relationship with him, and warned her of unspecified consequences if she refused. The published report did not name her. She was later identified as the campaigner Jasvinder Sanghera, who told *The Times*, as reported by the BBC, that the events were in 2006, while she was working with Lester on legislation to make forced marriage a civil offence.

Her statement said that after a meeting at the Lords she missed her train, and that Lester invited her to stay at his London home, telling her his wife would be there. She alleged that he repeatedly placed his hand on her thigh in the car; that the next morning, after his wife had left, he put his arms around her and pursued her around the kitchen; and that at a later meeting he said, "if you sleep with me I will make you a Baroness within a year", spelling her surname into the title. She said that when she refused he warned he would see to it that she never had a seat in the House and that there would be other repercussions, and that she was then dropped from the relevant meetings.

Lester denied every allegation and said the contact had been purely professional. He told the commissioner the accounts were "a pack of lies told by her and her supporters". Publicly he called the claims "completely untrue", said the events of 12 years earlier had not happened, and described the investigation as flawed.

The conduct was outside the usual four-year limit, so the Sub-Committee on Lords' Conduct had to agree to an inquiry. It did so on 6 February 2018, without then knowing the identities, because the allegations engaged the Code of Conduct duty to act on personal honour. In the first sexual-harassment investigation by the commissioner or her predecessor, she applied the balance of probabilities, required strong and cogent evidence, and rejected Lester's argument for a higher civil standard. Six witnesses for the complainant, including a judge, said she had described the events at the time; four for Lester, including Lady Lester, said they had not seen such behaviour. Scott-Moncrieff found the harassment, the inducement and the threat more likely than not to be true, held that his challenges did not significantly weaken the evidence, and upheld a breach of paragraph 8(b) of the Code.

Lester admitted telling another member that the complainant had caused his suspension by his party since February 2018, and apologised, while denying responsibility for what followed. The commissioner found a breach of the Guide to the Code's confidentiality rules and noted that he had given no explanation. The report anonymised her, and the Committee for Privileges and Conduct said that identifying her or the witnesses could be a contempt; she later waived anonymity so that, she told the BBC, others might feel able to complain.

### Committee reports and the House debate

The sub-committee, which recommends sanctions without reopening findings, called the offer, the threat and the loss of invitations a "grave abuse of power" and unanimously recommended expulsion. It considered expulsion available under the House of Lords (Expulsion and Suspension) Act 2015 because, in its view, the pre-2015 conduct had not been public knowledge.

Lester appealed against the findings and the sanction. In its second report of session 2017–19, HL Paper 220, ordered to be printed on 7 November 2018 and published on 12 November, the Committee for Privileges and Conduct unanimously endorsed the finding that he had failed to act on his personal honour by sexually harassing the complainant and offering corrupt inducements to sleep with him. It did not reopen the inquiry. On sanction it allowed the appeal, because expulsion had not been available at the time and the maximum penalty then was suspension to the end of a Parliament, and recommended suspension until 3 June 2022, tied to the timetable in the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011. The BBC reported that this would have been the longest suspension of a member of either House in modern parliamentary history.

On 15 November 2018 the Senior Deputy Speaker, [John McFall, Baron McFall of Alcluith](/people/john-mcfall-baron-mcfall-of-alcluith), moved agreement to the report. David Pannick, Baron Pannick, an independent peer and QC who had advised Lester, moved to remit it for breach of paragraph 21 of the Code on natural justice and fairness, chiefly the lack of cross-examination. After about two and a half hours the amendment passed by 101 votes to 78, and the suspension was not imposed.

Some speakers questioned Sanghera's credibility, including by reference to a later book inscription. [Jenny Jones, Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb](/people/jenny-jones-baroness-jones-of-moulsecoomb), said she walked out and called parts of the debate "misogynistic" and "victim-blaming"; the Liberal Democrat peer Meral Hussein-Ece spoke of an "old boys' network". Sanghera said she felt "victimised all over again". McFall said the commissioner had followed the agreed process. Seventy-four Lords staff wrote on 19 November that the debate left them without confidence complaints would be handled fairly.

Its further report, HL Paper 252, ordered to be printed on 10 December 2018, again recommended endorsement of the findings and suspension until 3 June 2022. It said fairness required notice and a chance to answer, not cross-examination, and that the commissioner had tested the delay, the timelines and the inscriptions. Newspapers reported the report on 12 December.

### Resignation and later party affiliation

Lester resigned from the House on 12 December 2018, telling *The Times* that the case had "taken a serious toll on my health", while continuing to deny the allegations. A Liberal Democrat spokesman called this "the right decision" and said the leadership had supported the original report. He had already been suspended by the party, and had resigned the whip, earlier in 2018; the commissioner's report dated the suspension from February.

On 17 December 2018 the House considered the further report. Pannick repeated his objections but did not force a division, and the motion was agreed; *[The Guardian](/organizations/the-guardian)* reported the result as a censure, which could not impose the suspension because Lester had left. Lord McNally's suggestion that Sanghera had delayed for "political reasons" rather than trauma drew shouts of protest. [Lola Young, Baroness Young of Hornsey](/people/lola-young-baroness-young-of-hornsey), called the remarks inappropriate, and [Helena Kennedy, Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws](/people/helena-kennedy-baroness-kennedy-of-the-shaws), said the debate had relied on tropes implying that women were not to be relied on. McFall asked peers to agree the report for Sanghera's sake and for confidence in the process.

A *Telegraph* obituary later recorded that in 2019 Lester left the Liberal Democrats for the Independent Group, the pro-EU grouping of MPs that became [Change UK](/organizations/change-uk).

## Death and assessments

### Death

Anthony Lester died on 8 August 2020, aged 84. *The Times* and *[The Jewish Chronicle](/organizations/the-jewish-chronicle)* stated that the cause was heart disease. Julia Langdon, in *The Guardian*, wrote that he had said he lacked the strength and health to go on contesting the allegation investigated by the House of Lords in 2018, and that friends suggested the case hastened his death. He was survived by his wife, the barrister and former asylum judge Catherine “Katya” Wassey, whom he had married in 1971; their son Gideon, a theatre director in the United States; and their daughter Maya, a Queen’s Counsel. *[The Irish Times](/organizations/the-irish-times)*, describing a marriage of 49 years, also recorded three grandchildren. Blackstone Chambers, which he joined in 1963, confirmed the date of death.

Maya Lester gave his papers to University College London Special Collections. Cataloguing, finished in December 2023, reduced 59 banker’s boxes to 30 (reference LESTER, 1964–2015). The catalogue lists a posthumous memoir, *Talking to Myself: A Life in Human Rights* (2022). Biteback Publishing issued an ebook on 18 January 2022 and quoted David Pannick calling it “an informative, provocative and deeply personal account of a distinguished life in law and politics.”

### Assessments of the legal and political record

The obituaries set the legislative record beside the 2018 findings. Langdon called Lester the author of the 1970s racial and gender equality legislation and “the single most influential voice” in the domestic recognition of human rights in 1998. She wrote that Roy Jenkins, in his memoirs, credited Lester with much of the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 and the Race Relations Act 1976, and she also linked him to the Civil Partnership Act 2004, the Defamation Act 2013, and the thalidomide, *Spycatcher* and Diane Blood cases. She added that colleagues found him pernickety but willing to take risks, and that his year advising Gordon Brown on constitutional reform ended because he had never been a team player.

*The Times* (10 August) called him “the godfather of much of the legislation” and quoted Pannick, his former junior, on counsel asking judges not to join Lester’s “Cook’s tour of the legal world.” *[The Daily Telegraph](/organizations/the-daily-telegraph)* (12 August) wrote of a career “driven by an intense dislike for discrimination and inequality,” then of the 2018 complaint, which it said exercised the House’s lawyers and ended in resignation for lack of health.

*The Irish Times* (22 August) stressed the Irish Bars, an adjunct professorship at University College Cork, the Albert Reynolds libel appeal, and distress at the 2016 vote for Brexit, which the paper said he saw as a repudiation of his life’s work. It recorded his denial, his claim of an unfair hearing, and retirement because his health was failing. Emma Klein, in *The Jewish Chronicle* (30 October), called him a “staunch promoter of race, gender and human rights legislation” and “a man of complexity, foresight and many talents,” covering both the Jenkins statutes and the allegation he contested before leaving the Lords.

Eduardo Reyes, in the *Law Society Gazette* (10 August), described an architect of equality law and a Liberal Democrat front-bench voice, and quoted a Lords standards sub-committee on “the tragic irony” that Lester had long been among the most admired campaigners for racial and sexual equality. It also reported [Michael Cashman](/people/michael-cashman) saying that many people owed Lester “an enormous debt of gratitude.” In the *New Law Journal* (8 January 2021), Geoffrey Bindman wrote that the contribution “has not received the credit it deserves,” tracing it from the Race Relations Act 1965 to the Human Rights Act 1998 and advocacy in the European Court of Human Rights, without discussing the conduct findings.

## Dated facts

_No published facts on this page yet._

## Methodology

https://factrail.ai/methodology

Canonical: https://factrail.ai/people/anthony-lester-baron-lester-of-herne-hill
