# Antje Tillmann

# Antje Tillmann

Antje Tillmann (born 28 August 1964 in Düsseldorf) is a German tax official, tax adviser and politician of the [Christian Democratic Union](/organizations/christian-democratic-union-of-germany) (CDU). She was a member of the Bundestag from 2002 until 2025 and, in the 20th electoral term, held her seat through the state list of Thuringia while standing in constituency 193, Erfurt–Weimar–Weimarer Land II. From 2014 she was finance-policy spokesperson of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group, succeeding Klaus-Peter Flosbach.

She took the Abitur in 1983, studied at a Fachhochschule für Finanzen and qualified in 1986 as a Diplom-Finanzwirtin (FH). She then worked as a tax official in North Rhine-Westphalia, moved in 1991 to Brandenburg, where she helped set up the state's college of public finance, and transferred in 1993 to Thuringia. Until 1998 she was a finance official in the Thuringian finance ministry and a section head in the tax offices of Weimar and Erfurt. She passed the tax-adviser examination in 1998; the biography published for the 18th Bundestag describes her as having practiced as a freelance tax adviser from then on. She is Roman Catholic, divorced, and has one child.

In parliament she sat on the Budget Committee from 2002 to 2005 and on the Finance Committee from 2005, as deputy chair of that committee from 2011 to 2013, and she was a member of the mediation committee of the Bundestag and the Bundesrat from 2009. The same biography names her as the CDU/CSU rapporteur in the second federalism commission of 2007–2009 and as the group's lead negotiator on the constitutional debt brake. Before the commission's last sitting she argued that the limit mattered for later generations because the state, like a private household, should decide how any new debt would be repaid.

She was directly elected in Erfurt–Weimar–Weimarer Land II in the 18th and 19th terms. In 2009 the Thuringian statistical office recorded her first-vote share at 30.8 percent. The federal returning officer's final results show the CDU winning the constituency with 37.1 percent of the first votes in 2013 and 27.3 percent in 2017. In 2021 [Carsten Schneider](/people/carsten-schneider) of the Social [Democratic Party](/organizations/democratic-party-us) took the seat with 40,183 votes (24.4 percent); Tillmann, with 28,636 votes (17.4 percent), finished second and re-entered through the state list.

On 29 January 2025 she was the only member of the CDU/CSU group to vote against its five-point motion on migration, which [Friedrich Merz](/people/friedrich-merz) had pressed; eight other members of the group cast no vote. She did not stand in the February 2025 election, writing in the *Thüringer Landeszeitung* that she would leave the Bundestag after 22 years. From September 2025 she taught, at first unpaid, at the Otto-Lilienthal-Gemeinschaftsschule in Erfurt's Rieth district and applied to continue as a lateral-entry teacher.

## Early life and education

### Düsseldorf, Neuss and school

Antje Tillmann was born on 28 August 1964 in Düsseldorf. Bundestag biographies record her as Roman Catholic. Her home town was Neuss, on the opposite bank of the Rhine, where she attended the Marienschule, a church gymnasium in a strongly Catholic city. A 2023 profile in the Bundestag newspaper *Das Parlament* described the parental household as not politically active, although her parents voted for the Christian Democratic Union (CDU); she has connected her later interest in social policy with her mother. A separate biographical sketch says that the Marienschule taught Christian social doctrine, built on the principles of personality, subsidiarity and solidarity.

She passed the Abitur in 1983. At 14 she was a co-founder of a group of the Schüler Union at the school. The Schüler Union was founded on 2 July 1972, on the initiative of the then chair of the Junge Union, as a CDU-aligned organization for school pupils and a working group within the Junge Union. In Neuss she worked with the later federal minister [Hermann Gröhe](/people/hermann-grohe) against a draft ordinance of the North Rhine-Westphalia government on the financing of substitute schools (*Ersatzschulen*). The proposal, on that account, would have left some classmates unable to afford to remain at school. The same sketch says that a counter-demonstration called by the Schüler Union drew several thousand pupils and that the ordinance was then withdrawn. *Das Parlament* treated the school campaign as the start of a politics of calculation rather than doctrine, summing it up with the line “Am Anfang standen also die Zahlen.” At the age of 16 she joined the Junge Union.

### Finance studies in Nordkirchen

After the Abitur she studied finance (*Finanzwissenschaften*) at the Fachhochschule für Finanzen and in 1986 qualified as a Diplom-Finanzwirtin. The college was the North Rhine-Westphalian training school for the tax administration, based at Schloss Nordkirchen, a Baroque moated palace in the Münsterland.

The Land leased the palace in 1949 for a nominal sum and bought it in 1958, fitting out lecture rooms, rooms for students and a canteen. Teaching started in 1950 as the Landesfinanzschule, with 115 trainees, a head and eight instructors; in 1976 the school was converted into the Fachhochschule für Finanzen. Tillmann’s own course was dual, combining academic instruction with practical training, the form of preparation long used for entry to the [revenue service](/organizations/revenue-service). The college today describes the path to the Diplom-Finanzwirt (FH) as three years in which study at Nordkirchen alternates with practical periods in a tax office, ending in the qualification for the higher intermediate career of the tax administration—formerly the *gehobener Dienst*, now Laufbahngruppe 2, first entry grade. A 2023 profile records that she had originally intended to take over her father’s tax consultancy rather than follow the administrative route the Nordkirchen diploma opened.

## Tax administration and consultancy

### Public service in North Rhine-Westphalia and Brandenburg

Tillmann entered the tax administration after qualifying in 1986 as a Diplom-Finanzwirtin, following studies in finance at a Fachhochschule für Finanzen. She then worked as a finance official (Finanzbeamtin) in North Rhine-Westphalia. A portrait published by Erfurt-Lese adds that, after a short posting in a tax office, she was appointed a lecturer at the state’s Fachhochschule für Finanzen in Nordkirchen.

In 1991 she moved to Brandenburg, where the Bundestag biography for the 18th electoral period records her part in building the Land’s Fachhochschule für Finanzen. The college dates that effort to the transfer of tax training after [German reunification](/organizations/german-reunification). In the spring of 1991 the newly constituted Länder took over the training of tax officials; Brandenburg was at first supported by the Fachhochschule für Finanzen in Nordkirchen and by the Landesfinanzschule in Haan. On 1 July 1991 the Brandenburg finance ministry established the predecessor of the Fachhochschule für Finanzen, together with the Landesfinanzschule and a further-training centre, with their seat in Königs Wusterhausen. The Fachhochschule itself was instituted there by a decree of 1 July 1993, inside what was then called the Bildungszentrum der Finanzverwaltung. In 2017 the state finance ministry described the tax administration’s training bodies, including the college and the Landesfinanzschule, as having been based at the Königs Wusterhausen centre since 1991.

### Thuringian finance ministry and tax offices

Tillmann transferred to Thuringia in 1993. From 1993 to 1998 she was a finance official in the Thuringian Ministry of Finance and a section head (Sachgebietsleiterin) in the tax offices of Weimar and Erfurt. The biographies for the 19th term (2017–2021) and the 20th term (2021–2025) list the same ministry post and the same two tax offices under the year 1993, and state that the biographical text rests on the member’s own information. A note published with a January 2025 article in the *Thüringische Landeszeitung* likewise says that she came to Thuringia in 1993 as a finance official.

### Qualification as a tax adviser

In 1998 she passed the examination for the regulated profession of Steuerberaterin. The biography issued for the 18th electoral period (2013–2017) stated that she had worked as a freelance tax adviser since that examination. On 13 September 2013 she described the position differently in a reply on Abgeordnetenwatch: since her first election to the Bundestag in 2002 she had let the freelance practice rest, because she treated the mandate as a full-time job with little room for other work. On 26 November 2020 she wrote that the mandate required her full effort and that she had therefore given up her activity as a tax adviser; she added that she held no seat on a supervisory board. The official biographies for 2017–2021 and 2021–2025 still record the 1998 examination, but they no longer describe an ongoing freelance practice.

In a guest article of 9 January 2025 in the *Thüringische Landeszeitung*, written as she prepared to leave the Bundestag, she did not say that she would reopen a consultancy. She wrote that she wanted to work directly with people, “perhaps as a lecturer in tax law, and in any case as someone who supports people who need help” (“vielleicht als Dozentin für Steuerrecht, auf jeden Fall als Betreuerin von Menschen, die Unterstützung brauchen”).

## Local politics

### Neuss city council

The handbook of Bundestag members records Antje Tillmann as a member of the city council in Neuss from 1989 to 1993. The entry, compiled for her as a parliamentarian of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU), lists no committee post or group office for that council. The dates run alongside her work as a finance official in North Rhine-Westphalia and, from 1991, a move to Brandenburg to help set up a finance college there; the handbook still carries the Neuss seat through 1993, the year it dates her start as a finance official in the Thuringian ministry.

### Erfurt city council and the CDU group

On 12 June 1994 Tillmann stood for the CDU for the 50-seat council of Erfurt, the capital of Thuringia. Seats were allocated to party lists in proportion to votes and, within a list, by personal votes rather than by the printed order. She was fifth on the CDU list, received 554 personal votes and finished ninth among CDU candidates, inside the 17 seats the party won. The CDU took 98,394 of 305,629 valid votes (32.2 percent). The Social Democratic Party (SPD) won 14 seats and the [Party of Democratic Socialism](/organizations/party-of-democratic-socialism) (PDS) 13, on a turnout of 64.2 percent. Three of the elected CDU councillors were women, and the council was to constitute itself on 13 July 1994.

The Bundestag handbook dates her Erfurt membership from 1994 to 2002 and records her as chair of the council group (Fraktionsvorsitzende) from 1998 to 2002, a span that covers only that first period on the council. At the election of 13 June 1999 she was returned with 10,310 personal votes, second among CDU candidates after Manfred Ruge, who received 63,847. Each voter had three votes, which could be given to one candidate, spread across names, or cast for a list. The CDU received 105,963 of 229,179 valid votes (46.2 percent) and 25 of the 50 seats; the city's statistics office stated that the mayor's vote in addition produced a CDU absolute majority. The SPD won 12 seats and the PDS 13, and turnout was 49.5 percent. The handbook ends both the membership and the group chairmanship in 2002.

She sat again while already a member of the Bundestag. On 25 May 2014 she received 3,457 personal votes and placed fourth among the twelve CDU councillors elected. The CDU polled 56,689 votes (24.7 percent) and 12 seats, in a council where the SPD, with 15, was the largest group and [Die Linke](/organizations/die-linke) won 11; turnout was 47.3 percent. The council information system lists her as an ordinary member of the CDU group and of the council from 1 June 2014 to 31 May 2019, with no group office, and as an ordinary member of the committee for social affairs, the labour market and equality from 3 September 2014 until the end of the term. She was also entered as a substitute on the building and transport committee for the whole term and, until 25 May 2016, as fourth substitute for another CDU councillor on the economic-development committee and on the boards of the drainage utility, the sports enterprise, the municipal theatre and the zoo.

Between July 2014 and March 2019 that system records a series of written questions she tabled for the CDU group under § 9 (2) of the council's rules of procedure, placed on the agendas of public sittings. The subjects ran from the local use of federal money made available for childcare from 2015, extra federal support during the arrival of refugees and the calculation of family reunification, to the impending property-tax reform, the federal Baukindergeld grant, broadband programmes for schools, charging points for cars, waiting times at the foreigners' office, and federal funds for the Defensionskaserne on the Petersberg. She is not listed as a member of the council term that began on 1 June 2019.

## Bundestag elections

### Entry in 2002 and the state list

Tillmann sat in the Bundestag from the 2002 federal election through the 20th legislative period (2021–2025), six consecutive terms. In 2021 she stood again, lost the constituency and returned on the state list; she left parliament when that term ended, having declined to run in the snap election of 23 February 2025. Under mixed-member proportional representation, the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) in Thuringia placed her both in a constituency and on the state list: a plurality of first votes (*Erststimmen*) was a direct mandate, and the list place was what seated her when that plurality went elsewhere.

At the 2002 election the seat she contested was constituency 194, Erfurt (city) — not yet the later Erfurt–Weimar–Weimarer Land district. Turnout was 75.0 percent of 161,977 eligible voters. The Social Democratic Party (SPD) took 50,299 first votes (42.1 percent); Carsten Schneider was the SPD candidate elected there with that share. Tillmann, for the CDU, received 33,078 (27.7 percent), and the Party of Democratic Socialism 24,815 (20.7 percent). She entered the Bundestag from fifth place on the Thuringian CDU list, behind Lothar Späth, Claudia Nolte, Bernward Müller and Vera Lengsfeld; *[Der Spiegel](/organizations/der-spiegel)* recorded her among the members elected from that list, while every Thuringian direct seat it tabulated had gone to the SPD.

The 2005 redistribution replaced the city-only district with constituency 194, Erfurt – Weimar – Weimarer Land II. Turnout was 75.8 percent of 223,315 eligible voters. The SPD led with 52,304 first votes (31.5 percent), Tillmann followed with 45,728 (27.5 percent), and the ticket labeled Die Linke. — the alliance that became Die Linke — took 43,520 (26.2 percent). She again missed the direct mandate and returned through the state list, this time from second place, a ranking she kept at every subsequent Bundestag election through 2021.

### Direct mandates, 2005–2017

From 2009 the same named constituency was numbered 193. After the narrow 2005 defeat, Tillmann won it at the next three elections — 2009, 2013 and 2017 — so those mandates were constituency seats rather than list seats. She stayed second on the CDU state list; in 2013 and 2017 that list was headed by Manfred Grund.

On 27 September 2009 the federal electoral committee confirmed the Thuringian result, which the state returning officer then published. In constituency 193, turnout was 67.0 percent of 225,708 eligible voters, and 149,274 first votes were valid. Tillmann received 45,931 (30.8 percent), ahead of Frank Spieth of Die Linke with 43,050 (28.8 percent) and Schneider with 33,488 (22.4 percent). Dieter Lauinger of Alliance 90/[The Greens](/organizations/the-greens) took 12,137 (8.1 percent) and Stefan Feuerstein of the Free Democratic Party (FDP) 8,897 (6.0 percent). The plurality made hers a direct mandate.

In 2013 her first-vote share was the highest of her six campaigns: 56,992 votes, or 37.1 percent, up 6.3 points, with turnout at 69.8 percent of 224,121 eligible voters. The SPD followed on 36,694 (23.9 percent) and Die Linke on 35,917 (23.4 percent). She again entered on the constituency result, still listed second by the state CDU.

In 2017 turnout rose to 75.8 percent of 221,922 eligible voters, and Tillmann’s 45,305 first votes were 27.3 percent, 9.8 points below 2013, but still the largest share. Martina Renner of Die Linke received 30,948 (18.7 percent), Schneider 30,257 (18.2 percent), [Stephan Brandner](/people/stephan-brandner) of [the Alternative](/organizations/the-alternative) for Germany (AfD) 28,960 (17.5 percent), Katrin Göring-Eckardt of the Greens 11,722 (7.1 percent) and [Thomas Kemmerich](/people/thomas-kemmerich) of the FDP 9,975 (6.0 percent). The direct seat was hers for a third time; the list place remained second.

### The 2021 defeat and the 2025 decision not to stand

The federal election of 26 September 2021 was again fought in constituency 193. Schneider took the direct mandate with 40,185 first votes (24.4 percent), 6.2 points more than in 2017. Tillmann fell to 28,639 (17.4 percent), down 9.9 points, and finished second. Sascha Schlösser of the AfD received 27,235 (16.5 percent) and Susanne Hennig-Wellsow of Die Linke 26,972 (16.4 percent); Göring-Eckardt had 19,483 (11.8 percent). Turnout was 76.4 percent of 217,944 eligible voters. CDU second votes in the district, 14.3 percent, ran below her personal share.

The lost constituency did not end the mandate. The state CDU had placed [Christian Hirte](/people/christian-hirte) first and Tillmann second, and she was elected on that list for the 20th Bundestag, again associated with constituency 193.

She did not contest the early federal election of 23 February 2025. In a guest commentary published by the *Thüringer Landeszeitung* on 9 January 2025 she wrote that, after 22 years, she would not stand again for the Bundestag that February.

## Roles in the Bundestag

### Finance Committee and Budget Committee

Tillmann sat in the Bundestag from 2002 until the end of the 20th electoral term in 2025. In the 15th term the Bundestag listed her as an ordinary member of the Budget Committee (Haushaltsausschuss). The biography issued for the 18th term, drawn from her own information, states that she was a member of the Budget Committee from 2002 to 2005 and of the Finance Committee (Finanzausschuss) from 2005.

By the 17th term the balance of those posts had shifted. A biography page captured in June 2011 lists her as deputy chair of the Finance Committee, as an ordinary member of that committee and of the subcommittee on municipal affairs (Unterausschuss Kommunales), and as a deputy member of the Budget Committee. The 18th-term biography dates the deputy chair of the Finance Committee to 2011–2013. The same 17th- and 18th-term accounts also record membership of the executive of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group.

She remained an ordinary member of the Finance Committee and a deputy member of the Budget Committee through the 18th, 19th and 20th terms.

### Finance-policy spokesperson of the CDU/CSU group

On 9 January 2014 *[Die Welt](/organizations/die-welt)* reported, from party circles in the Union and the SPD, that Tillmann would take over as finance-policy spokesperson on the CDU side, succeeding Klaus-Peter Flosbach, as the committees of the new Bundestag were about to be filled. Flosbach’s biography for the 18th term states that he had been finance-policy spokesperson and chair of the CDU/CSU group’s working group on finance (AG Finanzen) from January 2011 to January 2014.

Tillmann’s 18th-term biography describes her as finance-policy spokesperson of the CDU/CSU Bundestag group from 2014. The group’s activity report for 2014 lists her as chair of the working group on finance. The biographies for the 19th and 20th terms still describe her as having held that spokesperson’s post since 2014, including through the 20th term after the 2021 election.

In the Bundestag elected in 2025, the CDU/CSU group on 13 May 2025 chose [Fritz Güntzler](/people/fritz-guntzler) as chair of the AG Finanzen. The group’s website lists him as spokesperson and chair of that working group, the combination of titles Flosbach’s biography had already used for the office.

### Mediation Committee and the federalism commission

The Mediation Committee (Vermittlungsausschuss) is the joint body under Article 77(2) of the Basic Law. Sixteen members are sent by the Bundestag and sixteen by the Bundesrat; once the Bundestag has transmitted a bill, the Bundesrat has three weeks in which it may demand that the committee meet.

Tillmann’s 18th-term biography states that she had been a member since 2009. The June 2011 page and the biographies for the 18th and 19th terms list her as an ordinary member. At the opening of the 20th term the Bundestag, on a joint proposal of the parliamentary groups, elected her one of the CDU/CSU’s ordinary members, with [Thorsten Frei](/people/thorsten-frei), [Hendrik Hoppenstedt](/people/hendrik-hoppenstedt) and [Stefan Müller](/people/stefan-muller) (Erlangen). On 21 March 2024, at the 160th sitting, the House accepted without objection a CDU/CSU proposal to elect Christian Hirte as ordinary member in her place. The archived biography for the 20th term, unlike those for the 18th and 19th, no longer lists the committee.

In the 16th term she was Obfrau of the CDU/CSU Bundestag group in the Commission of the Bundestag and the Bundesrat on the Modernization of Bund–Länder Financial Relations (Föderalismuskommission II, 2007–2009). The commission’s final report says that each Bundestag group named one Obmann or Obfrau to arrange procedure, agendas and the organization of sittings and hearings, and it names Tillmann as the CDU/CSU Obfrau. She was also a full member for the Bundestag side, not a substitute. In July 2008 the commission set up working groups to turn an outline by its chairs into draft texts. She was one of the leads of the group on tax autonomy and tax administration, with Federal Finance Minister Peer Steinbrück, Berlin finance senator [Thilo Sarrazin](/people/thilo-sarrazin) and North Rhine-Westphalia finance minister Helmut Linssen; a separate group dealt with an early-warning system, consolidation aid and a debt limit. The commission’s remit was the financial relationship between the Federation and the Länder, including the borrowing rules later known as the debt brake. For the first federalism commission, in 2003–2004, the 18th-term biography describes her as coordinator of the CDU/CSU Bundestag group in the working group on financial relations.

## Tax and fiscal policy

### The debt brake

As CDU/CSU Obfrau in the commission on federal–state finance, Tillmann negotiated the constitutional debt brake. On 5 March 2009 she told Deutschlandfunk Kultur that the state should borrow only with a repayment decision, like a private household, so later generations would not pay the interest. She called the effects “massive”. The Länder, she said, had refused tax powers the federal side would have ceded. FDP deputy chair Ernst Burgbacher called the rest a waste of tax money; she defended the outcome.

Articles 109 and 115 of the Basic Law require federal and state budgets in principle to balance without credit. The Federation may run a structural deficit of at most 0.35 percent of gross domestic product; from 2020 the Länder were to run none. A natural disaster or an extraordinary emergency can justify a breach, but only with a repayment plan.

Tillmann treated that clause as built in, not as a reason to reopen the rule. In the Bundestag on 2 October 2020 she said the debt ratio had fallen from 82.4 percent when the brake was written into the constitution to 59.8 percent in 2019, and that without it the [COVID-19 pandemic](/drivers/covid-19-pandemic) would have begun nearer 100 percent of GDP. Reopening it was, she said, “absurd”; the new debt should be repaid in this generation. Green budget politician [Sven-Christian Kindler](/people/sven-christian-kindler) disagreed. A wealth levy, or higher tax above €200,000, would on her figures raise only €3 billion to €4 billion.

In opposition the same rule was the Union’s case against the traffic-light budgets. Members of the CDU/CSU group, whose finance-policy spokesperson she was, challenged the Second Supplementary Budget Act 2021. On 15 November 2023 the [Federal Constitutional Court](/organizations/federal-constitutional-court) declared it void: €60 billion of unused 2021 pandemic credit lines had been moved into the Climate and Transformation Fund for later years, without a sufficient link to the emergency and in breach of annual budgeting.

On 18 March 2025 she voted for a CDU/CSU–SPD bill, backed by most of Alliance 90/The Greens, amending Articles 109 and 115 and adding Article 143h. The vote was 512 to 206. Only [Mario Czaja](/people/mario-czaja) broke the Union line; the FDP, Die Linke, the AfD and the BSW voted no. Friedrich Merz said defence spending above 1 percent of GDP would leave the brake, and a special fund could borrow up to €500 billion over twelve years for infrastructure — “a large draft on the future” of later generations.

### Income tax, the solidarity surcharge and family-related relief

Tillmann argued that “cold progression”, the rise in the average rate when inflation pushes nominal pay up the scale, had been offset from 2016 and that the tariff need not be rebuilt. She said so on 14 February 2019 against FDP and AfD motions; the coalition left it unchanged. SPD deputy [Wiebke Esdar](/people/wiebke-esdar) said there was no problem and defended progression as ability to pay. Fabio De Masi of Die Linke wanted a 53 percent top rate and 75 percent above €1 million. Green deputy [Anja Hajduk](/people/anja-hajduk) said relief in the progressive income tax should stay with lower and middle incomes. Tillmann described the rates then in force — 42 percent, then 45 percent, plus surcharge and any church tax — as what high incomes already contributed.

In October 2020 she said family-relief laws had cut burdens by €12 billion, with €7 billion still to come; that child benefit was up €25 a month per child in two years; and that the single-parent allowance had been doubled, alongside a higher child tax allowance and an eighth yearly offset of cold progression.

On 14 November 2019 the Bundestag exempted about 90 percent of solidarity-surcharge payers in full from 2021, and another 6.5 percent in part. The 5.5 percent rate remained for the highest incomes, companies and much investment income. The Finance Ministry put the first-year loss at about €10.9 billion. Tillmann said the Union still wanted the charge abolished. [Olaf Scholz](/people/mig-olaf-scholz) called payment by high earners fair. The FDP said the middle was not relieved; Greens and the Left said non-payers gained nothing. Business groups prepared complaints after Solidarity Pact II. On 26 March 2025 the Federal Constitutional Court upheld both the 2020 charge and the partial cut: the extra federal burden of reunification had not evidently ended, though parliament must keep watching it.

She defended joint assessment of spouses on the same ground. In July 2024, after Family Minister Lisa Paus called splitting outdated, Tillmann told the *Neue Osnabrücker Zeitung* that it mattered most “in the most vulnerable phase”, when one partner cared for very young children and worked less or not at all. SPD deputy Leni Breymaier called splitting a relic of the single-earner model. Finance Minister Christian Lindner said it would not be abolished. Tillmann also rejected a one-off wealth levy for pandemic costs, citing a May 2021 opinion of the finance ministry’s academic advisory council that warned of damage to confidence and of constitutional doubts.

### Financial-market rules and crisis measures

On 25 September 2014, at first reading of the bank-recovery and resolution-fund bills, Tillmann backed the European banking union but said decisions on German taxpayers’ money belonged in the Bundestag. Owners, creditors and a bank-financed fund should pay before the taxpayer; an 8 percent hit to owners was not, she said, the point at which the taxpayer stepped in. Savings banks and cooperatives should not be overburdened, and the [European Stability Mechanism](/organizations/european-stability-mechanism) was only a last resort.

Cum-ex trades, she wrote, were not planning but crime: a second refund of withholding tax paid once could not be lawful. On cum-cum trades the judgment was still open case by case, but the investment-tax reform had restricted them, partly retrospectively. On the 2022 Future Financing Act she said the CDU/CSU welcomed plans to drop separate loss-offset limits for futures, total losses and share-sale losses.

In the pandemic she defended the temporary value-added-tax cut, a wider loss carry-back and faster depreciation as stimulus rather than consolidation. Christian Dürr of the FDP called the VAT cut nonsense; she said the retail figures showed it working. The [ifo Institute](/organizations/ifo-institute-for-economic-research) estimated in July 2020 that the six-month cut would raise GDP that year by €6.5 billion, or 0.2 percent — about a third of the revenue lost — because some extra spending would be imported and firms might not pass the cut on in full.

## Positions on equality and migration

### The 2017 vote on marriage equality

On 30 June 2017 the Bundestag adopted, by [roll call](/organizations/roll-call), a Bundesrat bill giving two persons of the same sex a right to marry. Of 630 members, 393 voted yes, 226 no and four abstained; seven did not vote. In the CDU/CSU group of 309, 75 voted yes, 225 no and four abstained, and five did not vote. Tillmann voted yes. Chancellor [Angela Merkel](/people/angela-merkel) voted no.

On 24 July 2017, on abgeordnetenwatch.de, she pointed to a piece in the church paper *Glaube + Heimat*. She had voted, she wrote, not for “marriage for all” but for a civil right of two persons of the same sex to marry; the sacrament was untouched. Life partnerships had already been extended, last by successive adoption. She said she had rejected the name “marriage” until talks showed her it was no answer for the couples. Her worry over adoption was not that same-sex couples could not be good parents, but that the row not be fought over children, who were already protected by a case-by-case welfare test. She criticised the rush, yet called a lasting bond a value-conservative choice amid “Belanglosigkeit, Werteverfall und Bindungslosigkeit.”

A constituent wrote the same day that a yes was a vote against Merkel and against the Basic Law, and asked how she could then reject polygamy, marriage between siblings, surrogacy and the marriage of minors. She answered that none of those followed from her argument and that she rejected them. She defended a marriage age of 18 and called paid surrogacy “moderner Menschenhandel.”

### Guardianship and statements on refugees

In 2015 Tillmann became legal guardian of an unaccompanied minor from Syria who, she later wrote, had arrived alone in Erfurt at the age of 15. Reporting added that she took him into her home. In 2016 she told *Bild* that, whatever number Germany could admit, “müssen wir uns um die, die hier sind, intensiv kümmern.”

In a *Thüringer Landeszeitung* essay of 9 January 2025 she called 2015, despite “die Gewalttaten,” “eine Erfolgsgeschichte.” Citing figures she attributed to the [Bundesanstalt für Arbeit](/organizations/bundesagentur-fur-arbeit), she wrote that more than 60 percent of Syrians who had fled to Germany were in work, and 85 percent of the men. Her 25-year-old Syrian “Ziehsohn,” she wrote, was starting a master-craftsman course as an industrial mechanic, so blanket demands for return should be handled with caution.

### The January 2025 migration motion

On 22 January 2025 a 28-year-old national of Afghanistan attacked five children with a knife in Schöntal park in Aschaffenburg. A two-year-old boy and a 41-year-old man who intervened were killed; a girl of two, a man of 72 and a woman of 59 were hurt, and police arrested the suspect nearby. Bavarian interior minister Joachim Herrmann said the attack on a kindergarten group was sudden and deliberate, that no Islamist motive had appeared, and that the man — in psychiatric treatment, with earlier violent offences, in Germany since November 2022 — had his asylum case closed after announcing he would leave. He was obliged to leave. Friedrich Merz, CDU chairman and the Union’s chancellor candidate, said this could not continue.

On 29 January the Bundestag voted on CDU/CSU printed paper 20/14698, which did not bind the government. It demanded permanent controls on every neighbouring border; turning back people without valid documents, including those seeking protection, if they were outside European free movement; immediate detention and more deportations; open-ended custody of offenders and persons classed as dangerous until they left; and a Federal Police power to apply for detention orders. It placed Aschaffenburg with Mannheim, Solingen and the Magdeburg Christmas-market attack, called the Dublin Regulation, Schengen and Eurodac “erkennbar dysfunktional,” and said national law should prevail where European rules failed.

The final result was 348 yes, 344 no and 10 abstentions, from 702 votes. Thirty-one members did not vote. The yeses were 187 CDU/CSU, 75 AfD, 80 FDP and six without a group. Eight BSW members and two FDP members abstained. Tillmann was the only CDU/CSU no. Not voting were [Annette Widmann-Mauz](/people/annette-widmann-mauz), Sabine Weiss, Marco Wanderwitz, [Astrid Timmermann-Fechter](/people/astrid-timmermann-fechter), Yvonne Magwas, [Roderich Kiesewetter](/people/roderich-kiesewetter), [Thomas Heilmann](/people/thomas-heilmann) and [Monika Grütters](/people/monika-grutters), who told *[Der Tagesspiegel](/organizations/der-tagesspiegel)* a red line had been crossed. Widmann-Mauz wrote that she stayed away so AfD votes would not decide the result, though she wanted the policy change made without the AfD.

Chancellor Olaf Scholz said the plan would break European law and that AfD votes ended a consensus, from the founding of the republic, against joint action with the extreme right. Merz said a majority “in der Mitte” was for the SPD and the Greens to give, and that he would no longer table only what they had cleared. Victims, he said, were owed limits on irregular migration and a move to “endlich abzuschieben.”

Tillmann did not explain the vote when asked. MDR Thüringen reported that she did not wish to comment on her reasons. People present at the CDU/CSU executive on the Monday before told *Stern*, as reported by *[t-online](/organizations/t-online)*, that she had warned there against a majority reached with the AfD.

## Civic commitments

Side offices Antje Tillmann reported under the rules of conduct for members of the Bundestag appear in the official biographies and, for later terms, on Abgeordnetenwatch. None carries a published income bracket.

### Disability organizations and church bodies

In the 20th electoral term she was honorary chair of the board of Lebenshilfe für Menschen mit geistiger Behinderung – Landesverband Thüringen e.V. in Jena. It works for people with intellectual disabilities and their families as part of Lebenshilfe, the national self-help organization in that field. On 23 May 2024, before local elections in Thuringia, federal chair [Ulla Schmidt](/people/ulla-schmidt) and Tillmann, named as state chair, asked voters to back candidates who would defend those rights.

She sat on the Kuratorium of Trägerwerk Soziale Dienste, a charitable stock corporation in Weimar that represents affiliated social-service bodies and assigns the Kuratorium their substantive oversight. It appears in the 19th- and 20th-term biographies, the latter marking it honorary, and on the company's Kuratorium page.

The Katholische Schulstiftung im Bistum Erfurt supports Catholic general schools and says its organs, including a bishop-appointed advisory board, are unpaid. Her seat runs from the 16th-term disclosure through the mandates from 2013 and, in the 20th-term biography, ends on 30 November 2021.

At the friends' association of the Protestant Augustinian monastery in Erfurt, a Lutheran site, a biography of 4 March 2010 calls her deputy chair from 2006, and the 18th-term disclosure a board member. Abgeordnetenwatch keeps the entry only for 2013–2017.

### Other honorary offices

The 19th- and 20th-term biographies list honorary membership of the parliamentary advisory board of the Bundesverband Deutscher Vermögensberater e.V. (BDV), registered in Marburg with its office in Frankfurt am Main. It says its members give all-finance advice and that it seeks political conditions for the profession. On 3 March 2023 the BDV reported that at its 15th parliamentary evening the board was almost fully present, naming Tillmann of the CDU with members of the CSU, FDP, Greens and SPD. In November 2023 Bürgerbewegung Finanzwende called the board an example of what it termed the opaque lobbying power of [Deutsche Vermögensberatung](/organizations/deutsche-vermogensberatung): the BDV, it wrote, claims about 15,000 self-employed intermediaries but is dominated by DVAG advisers, and chair Helge Lach also sits on the DVAG board. Tillmann is listed with finance-committee members of other parties. No payment is published for her seat.

The 20th-term biography also lists the senate of the Deutsche Industrieforschungsgemeinschaft [Konrad Zuse](/people/konrad-zuse) e.V. in Berlin, an association of independent nonprofit industry-research institutes whose senate, it says, gives science-policy advice. That seat is not marked honorary. It also names honorary membership of the advisory board of the Staatswissenschaftliche Forum e.V. in Erfurt, which the [University of Erfurt](/organizations/university-of-erfurt) describes as an exchange between scholarship and business, dated by Abgeordnetenwatch from 18 December 2017.

Earlier disclosures, later dropped, include honorary chair of the Erfurt district association of the [German Red Cross](/organizations/german-red-cross) until May 2007. A 17th-term note instead dates a local chair from 2003 to 2007 and says DRK Ortsverband Erfurt. She was honorary chair of the Arbeitskreis Thüringer Familienorganisationen e.V., a state-level alliance of family organizations, placed by that note in 2004–2009. In March 2010 she was a deputy member of the Kuratorium of the [Federal Agency for Civic Education](/organizations/federal-agency-for-civic-education). Until 16 September 2015 she sat on the Verbandsrat of the Sparkassenzweckverband Mittelthüringen, disclosed as an office in a public-law body.

## After the Bundestag

### Reasons for leaving

Tillmann did not leave the Bundestag in 2021. She remained a member for the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) through the 20th electoral term. On 20 September 2024 the *Thüringer Allgemeine* reported that, after 22 years in parliament, she would not stand again and wanted to give a younger candidate the chance to work in Berlin, and that a possible successor was already in view. On the evening of 16 December 2024 the CDU district associations nominated [Michael Hose](/people/michael-hose), then 40, a grammar-school teacher of civics and history who headed a comprehensive school and had chaired the CDU group on the Erfurt city council since 2014, as direct candidate in constituency 192 (Erfurt, Weimar and parts of the Weimarer Land).

The poll was then brought forward independently of that decision. On the request of Chancellor Olaf Scholz, Federal President [Frank-Walter Steinmeier](/people/frank-walter-steinmeier) dissolved the 20th Bundestag on 27 December 2024 under Article 68 of the Basic Law and set the election for Sunday, 23 February 2025, instead of 28 September 2025. The outgoing Bundestag kept its rights and duties until the new House met; the 21st Bundestag held its constituting sitting on 25 March 2025, and Tillmann, who was not a candidate, left with the end of the 20th term.

In a guest essay in the *Thüringer Landeszeitung* on 9 January 2025 she wrote that in February, after 22 years, she would not stand again. Looking back as a finance politician, she credited decisions from the eurozone debt crisis of 2010—rescue mechanisms, assistance programmes and regulation—with making European financial markets safer, though not invulnerable, and she named unequal chances for children, despite spending on education, childcare and all-day schooling, among the omissions. She counted local projects in Erfurt and Weimar, including the Petersberg restoration, the Federal Garden Show and the Bauhaus Museum, among the successes. A reason she gave for seeking work outside parliamentary politics was the tone of political life, and she called for listening rather than condemnation. She said she wanted a more direct effect, perhaps as a lecturer in tax law and in any case by supporting people who needed help, and that she would remain “a political person.”

### Teaching in Erfurt

On 20 October 2025 [Mitteldeutscher Rundfunk](/organizations/mitteldeutscher-rundfunk) reported that from the beginning of September Tillmann had been teaching without pay at the Otto-Lilienthal-Gemeinschaftsschule in Erfurt’s Rieth district, four hours on Mondays and six on Thursdays. She taught economics and law in project lessons, without marks or tests: the economic cycle, how banks decide credit, how the Bundestag works, how young people can take part in democratic processes, and debating with a fifth-year class. She told the broadcaster that leaving parliament did not mean giving up her commitment to democracy or to Germany. Head teacher Alexander Dorst said the school needed more teaching on practical subjects such as money, saving and pensions, and that she kept political neutrality, with no party advertising.

She called the unpaid role the niche she had looked for after leaving the Bundestag, and said that about two months with family, the garden and travel, once the Berlin office had been cleared, had not been enough. She also said she had completed a pedagogical training about 40 years earlier and had lectured at a college of public finance. She had applied to the school authority to continue as a lateral-entry teacher and hoped for approval; Dorst said insurance for the unpaid work had been a difficulty until the authorities agreed.

## Public profile and reception

### Standing in the CDU/CSU

For most of her later years in parliament Tillmann was the finance specialist who spoke for the CDU/CSU on tax, but the spokesperson's post did not come at the first attempt. When it fell vacant in 2011 she applied. The *[Süddeutsche Zeitung](/organizations/suddeutsche-zeitung)* reported that faction insiders gave her no chance, because the North Rhine-Westphalia state group claimed the job for one of its own, and that Klaus-Peter Flosbach was the candidate to be elected. In January 2014 *Die Welt* reported that she would succeed him. She kept the brief until she left the Bundestag in 2025.

The vote of 29 January 2025 changed her standing inside the Union. Tillmann, a CDU member from Thuringia who was not seeking another term, was the only member of the group to vote against the five-point migration motion associated with Friedrich Merz; eight other Union members did not vote. The *taz* headed its account "Die letzte Merkelianerin": she might not be the last figure in the group in the manner of Angela Merkel, it wrote, but she was the only one to follow that stance with a clear No. The paper linked the dissent to Christian social teaching and noted respect from outside the Union, including from Martina Renner of Die Linke, more than from her own group.

### Media coverage and criticism

n-tv reported the January 2025 vote as a break in a group that otherwise largely backed a stricter migration course. The *taz* treated the No as what made the 60-year-old widely known, after 22 years in the Bundestag and a decade as finance spokesperson—she had led the group's talks on the debt brake—and set it beside a guest article in the *Thüringische Landeszeitung* warning against blanket demands that people be sent back.

Criticism of the fiscal line she represented was older, and came from the SPD, Die Linke and the Greens. When the Bundestag in November 2019 ended the solidarity surcharge for about 90 percent of those who had paid it, Finance Minister Olaf Scholz said that relieving high incomes would not be just, and SPD deputy Wiebke Esdar said top earners were rightly left out. [Fabio De Masi](/people/fabio-de-masi), then of Die Linke, called the cut socially unfair: almost half the population gained nothing, because they earned too little to owe the surcharge, while the beneficiaries were above all childless people and higher earners. Lisa Paus said any abolition should be tied to an income-tax reform with a higher basic allowance for low earners and a higher top rate. Tillmann and Union rapporteur [Olav Gutting](/people/olav-gutting) called the same law, in a joint statement, the largest tax cut in two decades and only a first step toward removing the surcharge altogether.

In April 2020 she told *Die Welt* that she rejected a one-off levy on wealth which SPD co-leader [Saskia Esken](/people/saskia-esken) had suggested for sharing the fiscal cost of the coronavirus crisis. After a crisis, Tillmann said, the debate should be about tax cuts and stimulus, not tax rises, and such a levy would hit many medium-sized firms. Esken had argued that a fair sharing of burdens required Germany's "strong shoulders" to contribute strongly.

## Dated facts

_No published facts on this page yet._

## Methodology

https://factrail.ai/methodology

Canonical: https://factrail.ai/people/antje-tillmann
