# Gernot Erler

# Gernot Erler

Gernot Erler (born 3 May 1944 in Meißen) is a German historian and politician of the [Social Democratic Party of Germany](/organizations/social-democratic-party-of-germany) (SPD). He was a member of the Bundestag from 1987 until 2017 and Minister of State at the [Federal Foreign Office](/organizations/federal-foreign-office) from November 2005 to October 2009. From January 2014 until 11 April 2018 he was the federal government’s coordinator for intersocietal cooperation with Russia, Central Asia and the countries of the [Eastern Partnership](/organizations/eastern-partnership).

He attended a Gymnasium in Berlin-Steglitz and, from 1963 to 1967, studied history, Slavic languages and political science at the [Free University of Berlin](/organizations/free-university-of-berlin) and the [University of Freiburg](/organizations/university-of-freiburg), taking the state teaching examination in Freiburg in 1967. He later said that seeing [Willy Brandt](/people/willy-brandt)’s 1963 campaign in divided Berlin drew him toward Ostpolitik and détente. He worked as a publishing editor in 1968–1969, as a research assistant and staff member at Freiburg’s Seminar for Eastern European History from 1969 to 1979, and as a publishing director in [Freiburg im Breisgau](/organizations/freiburg-im-breisgau) from 1980 to 1987. He joined the SPD in 1970, after contact through Freiburg peace weeks and the protests against the planned nuclear plant at Wyhl, and then held local and state party offices in Baden-Württemberg.

Elected to the Bundestag in 1987 and returned seven times, he spent about thirty years in parliament. From 1994 to 1998 he chaired the subcommittee on disarmament and arms control, and from 1998 to November 2005, and again from 2009 to 2013, he was a deputy chair of the SPD parliamentary group for [foreign affairs](/organizations/foreign-affairs), security, human rights and development policy. Between those two spells, in the grand coalition, he served as Minister of State to Foreign Minister [Frank-Walter Steinmeier](/people/frank-walter-steinmeier). From 2003 to March 2006 he had already been coordinator for German–Russian intersocietal cooperation inside the Foreign Office.

In January 2014 Chancellor [Angela Merkel](/people/angela-merkel) and Steinmeier agreed that Erler would succeed Andreas Schockenhoff as Russia coordinator. *[Der Spiegel](/organizations/der-spiegel)* wrote that he had argued for more understanding of the Kremlin’s course and an end to what he called “Russia-bashing,” a line that brought both credit for his contacts in Moscow and unease in the CDU/CSU. In 2016 he was special representative of the federal government for Germany’s chairmanship of the [Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe](/organizations/organization-for-security-and-co-operation-in-europe). He declined to stand again in 2017, saying at the age of 72 that he wanted a younger group of SPD deputies from Baden-Württemberg. On 6 September 2022 the state presented him in Freiburg with the Federal Cross of Merit, First Class; the citation noted that he had presided over the Southeast Europe Association from 2000 to 2020.

## Early life and education

### Childhood in Meißen and Berlin

Gernot Erler was born on 3 May 1944 in Meissen, Saxony, during the [Second World War](/facts/world-war-ii). The German integrated authority file lists this Erler, born in Meißen in 1944, as a politician, historian and publisher, and keeps a separate record for another Gernot Erler (27 January 1935 – 7 June 2011), an art historian, teacher and conservator of buildings and art monuments in the district of Soltau-Fallingbostel, born in Münster.

His father, a career soldier with the rank of major, was killed on the Eastern Front a few days or weeks before the end of the war and was buried at Borna, near Leipzig. Erler later said the family could not visit the grave. His mother, a war widow with two small children, and his grandmother kept the household while his grandfather was missing; there was at first no pension, which he put down to his father's insufficient years of service, and the grandmother's wages supported them. He recalled that their position improved only after the Bundeswehr was established and the treatment of war widows was changed, when a pension began to be paid.

He grew up in West Berlin in the 1950s. He described a childhood among bomb sites, with ruined plots as playgrounds, and meals that often consisted of pea-sausage soup or of apples and potatoes cooked together. He attended a Gymnasium in Steglitz. As he became more aware of the city around him, he said, he asked how he had come to live in a divided place, and he watched the Berlin Wall being built in 1961. In 1963 he saw John F. Kennedy's visit to Berlin and, that November, felt the shock of the president's assassination. Money seldom allowed the family out: he remembered only two trips in his whole time as a pupil, riding in the cab of a milk lorry through "the Zone", as it was then called, to a friend of his mother's in West Germany. He has tied that confinement, and his father's death in the war between Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union, to his decision to study how the division had come about.

### Studies in Berlin and Freiburg

In 1963, after the Abitur, Erler began to study history, Slavic languages and political science at the Free University of Berlin. He later said that school and the usual course of study conveyed much more about the West than about the East, and that comparatively few people occupied themselves with Poland, with Czechoslovakia as it then was, or with the Soviet Union; he took that gap as his subject. In a 2017 Bundestag profile he recalled that the tension between East and West was palpable every day in the divided city, and that watching Willy Brandt—governing mayor since 1957—campaign in the walled-in city in 1963, and Brandt's commitment to Eastern and détente policy, had awakened his political interest.

He then transferred to the University of Freiburg, the Albert-Ludwigs-Universität, in Freiburg im Breisgau. Official biographies date the course, taken at the two universities, to 1963–1967. In Freiburg in 1967 he passed the state examination for the teaching profession, the Staatsexamen für das Lehramt. A 2020 Deutschlandfunk interview described the same sequence: studies begun in West Berlin in 1963 and completed four years later in Freiburg.

## Scholarship and publishing

### Seminar for Eastern European History

After the 1967 state examination, Erler worked in 1968–1969 as a publishing editor (*Verlagsredakteur*); the official biographies do not name the firm. From 1969 to 1979 he was a research assistant and research associate (*wissenschaftlicher Assistent* and *wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter*) at the Seminar für osteuropäische Geschichte of the University of Freiburg.

The books tied to those years deal with early Soviet cultural policy and Russian literature after 1917. With Eberhard Knödler-Bunte he edited *Kultur und Kulturrevolution in der Sowjetunion* (1978), volume 1 of the Schriften des Instituts für Kultur und Ästhetik, a 131-page illustrated collection issued by Ästhetik und Kommunikation in Berlin and Scriptor-Verlag in Kronberg (Taunus).

In 1979 the Osteuropa-Institut at the Free University of Berlin published *Von der Revolution zum Schriftstellerkongress: Entwicklungsstrukturen und Funktionsbestimmungen der russischen Literatur und Kultur zwischen 1917 und 1934*, volume 47 of its Slavonic series, sold in commission by Otto Harrassowitz in Wiesbaden (viii + 488 pages). The title page is catalogued as edited by G. Erler and others; union-catalogue headings add Rainer Georg Grübel, Krisztina Mänicke-Gyöngyösi and Peter Scherber. Most of the papers had been read at the University of Konstanz on 1–4 November 1974.

A later volume still came out of the Freiburg chair. The preface of *Stalinismus: Probleme der Sowjetgesellschaft zwischen Kollektivierung und Weltkrieg* (1982) states that the edition was planned at a conference on Stalinism prepared there under Gottfried Schramm. Erler and Walter Süss edited the 675-page book, with a bibliography on pages 657–664, published by Campus Verlag in Frankfurt and [New York](/organizations/new-york) together with Verlag Ästhetik und Kommunikation in Berlin. It appeared after Erler had left the seminar in 1979.

### Dreisam-Verlag

From 1980 to 1987 Erler was a publishing director in Freiburg. The Bundestag biography gives the post and the city; the curriculum vitae of the Social [Democratic Party](/organizations/democratic-party-us) parliamentary group names the house as Dreisam-Verlag.

Its list was political and environmental, including documentation of the campaign against a nuclear plant at Wyhl am Kaiserstuhl. On 23 February 1975 demonstrators occupied the site and held it into November; Freiburg students took part in the protests. The university describes that civil resistance, which prevented the plant from being built, as a founding moment of the West German environmental and anti-nuclear movement. The conflict was also the point of departure for the Öko-Institut in Freiburg. Marking its fortieth year in 2017, the institute traced its origin to Wyhl and to the demand for expertise independent of the authorities’ consultants.

Dreisam’s account of the later protest was *Der Widerstand geht weiter: der Bürgerprotest gegen das Kernkraftwerk von 1976 bis zum Mannheimer Prozess* (1982; 261 illustrated pages), with the cover title *Wyhl, der Widerstand geht weiter*. Christoph Büchele, Irmgard Schneider and Bernd Nössler edited it for the Badisch-Elsässische Bürgerinitiativen, with support from the Bund für Umwelt und Naturschutz Deutschland (BUND). Büchele’s *Fakten gegen den Atomstrom: eine aktuelle Bestandsaufnahme* followed in 1983, issued with BUND and numbered as volume 11 of the series Öko; a further edition appeared in 1986.

Other titles came from the Öko-Institut circle. Rainer Grießhammer’s *Letzte Chance für den Wald? Die abwendbaren Folgen des sauren Regens* (1983) was Öko, volume 9. Uwe Lahl and Barbara Zeschmar’s *Wie krank ist unser Wasser? Die Gefährdung des Trinkwassers*, commissioned by the Öko-Institut, the BBU and BUND, was published by Dreisam in the same series; a 1986 edition is volume 4. Erler is named as redactor of *Arbeiten im Einklang mit der Natur: Bausteine für ein ökologisches Wirtschaften* (1985), prepared by the institute’s working group on ecological economics.

In 1987, the last year of the directorship, Dreisam published *Geschichtswende? Entsorgungsversuche zur deutschen Geschichte* (first edition, 172 pages), with a foreword by Walter Dirks. The German National Library credits Erler on the volume.

## Party career in Baden-Württemberg

### Joining the SPD and local office

Gernot Erler joined the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) in 1970, while a research assistant in Eastern European history at the University of Freiburg. A 2017 Bundestag profile records two lines into the party. Willy Brandt’s Ostpolitik had interested him as a student in divided Berlin, and he described the anti-nuclear movement, ecological initiatives and the peace movement as his bridge to the SPD in Baden-Württemberg. He called the next stage an “Ochsentour”: treasurer of a seven-member local branch, then branch chair and district chair, all of it unpaid, because professional politics had not been his plan.

The dated offices were in Freiburg-Tiengen. Under an agreement of 16 October 1972, Tiengen was incorporated into Freiburg im Breisgau on 1 January 1973 as an Ortschaft with its own local council (Ortschaftsrat). Erler chaired the SPD branch there from 1973 to 1977 and sat on the Tiengen Ortschaftsrat from 1976 to 1984. From 1977 to 1987 he chaired the Freiburg district association, and from 1980 to 1987 he was on the board of the AfA (Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Arbeitnehmerfragen), the SPD group for employee questions. The posts overlapped the university job until 1979 and, from 1980, his directorship of the Dreisam-Verlag.

### State executive and the peace movement

In 1983 Erler joined the state executive (Landesvorstand) of the Baden-Württemberg SPD and, from 1985 to 1997, its presidium; the executive seat itself lasted until 1997. The state was then led by the [Christian Democratic Union](/organizations/christian-democratic-union-of-germany): Lothar Späth was minister-president from 1978 to 1991. The nuclear dispute around Freiburg was older. In a 1975 government statement Hans Filbinger said that without a plant at Wyhl, on the Kaiserstuhl, the first lights in Baden-Württemberg would go out by the end of the decade.

On 18 February 1975, as site work began, winegrowers and farmers occupied the ground. Police cleared it on 20 February; a second occupation then lasted about nine months. Courts later ruled both ways, and in 1983 Späth suspended the project as unnecessary for the region’s economy. The plant was never built. Erler afterwards said that he had taken part in the Wyhl protests and in Freiburg peace weeks, and he dated his entry into the SPD to 1970, five years before the occupation.

The NATO Double-Track Decision of 12 December 1979 paired talks with Moscow with plans to station new intermediate-range nuclear missiles in Western Europe. In the Federal Republic the decision brought mass protests and split the SPD of Chancellor [Helmut Schmidt](/people/helmut-schmidt). Erler’s Freiburg chairmanship and his first years on the state executive fell in that dispute. What the record lists for the period is the sequence of party offices, not a leading role at Wyhl or in the missile protests. The connection to that milieu is his later account of how he had come to the Baden-Württemberg SPD.

## Member of the Bundestag

### Elections and the Freiburg constituency

Gernot Erler was a member of the Bundestag for eight successive terms, from 1987 to 2017, sitting for the Social Democratic Party of Germany. He was each time the SPD candidate in the Freiburg constituency, covering Freiburg im Breisgau and a changing group of neighbouring municipalities. The seat was numbered 185 through 1998, 282 in 2002 and 2005, and 281 from 2009.

The direct mandate stayed with the Christian Democratic Union of Germany in his first three campaigns. Conrad Schroeder took 75,758 first votes (43.2 percent) in 1987 to Erler’s 59,678 (34.0 percent), and 40.9 percent in 1990 to Erler’s 35.3 percent (60,335 votes). In 1994 Sigrun Löwisch won with 74,296 votes (42.0 percent) against Erler’s 63,116 (35.6 percent). Erler still entered in 1987. With the constituency in CDU hands, that seat, like those of 1990 and 1994, came from the SPD state list in Baden-Württemberg. Federal Statistical Office lists of successful state-list candidates give him tenth place on the SPD’s Baden-Württemberg list in 1990 and fifth in 1994, when he was also the candidate in constituency 185.

On 27 September 1998 he became the first Social Democrat to win Freiburg since 1949; every earlier direct mandate there had gone to the CDU. He received 76,430 first votes (41.5 percent) to Löwisch’s 69,485 (37.7 percent). The SPD also led the constituency’s second vote for the first time, 33.5 percent to the CDU’s 31.8 percent, on a turnout of 83.6 percent.

The district was smaller by 2002, when 163,962 of 200,287 eligible voters took part. Erler’s 78,122 first votes were 48.3 percent, ahead of Angelika Doetsch of the CDU (51,542; 31.9 percent) and [Kerstin Andreae](/people/kerstin-andreae) of Alliance 90/[The Greens](/organizations/the-greens) (20,475; 12.7 percent). In the city of Freiburg itself he had an absolute majority of first votes, 50.8 percent. He held the seat in 2005 with 73,278 first votes (45.1 percent) against Cornelia Mayer of the CDU (55,922; 34.4 percent); turnout was 80.4 percent of 205,189 eligible voters.

In 2009 turnout was 74.9 percent and his first-vote share 33.0 percent (51,192), still ahead of Daniel Sander of the CDU (44,749; 28.8 percent) and Andreae (33,878; 21.8 percent). The SPD’s second-vote share there was 21.0 percent. In the Federal Returning Officer’s seat table this was the SPD’s only direct mandate in Baden-Württemberg. On 22 September 2013 Matern von Marschall of the CDU won with 58,106 first votes (34.9 percent) to Erler’s 50,004 (30.0 percent), a margin of 8,102; Andreae took 34,762 (20.9 percent), and turnout was 76.7 percent of 219,472 eligible voters. Erler returned on the state list. For the 18th term the Bundestag recorded a list seat for constituency 281.

On 28 July 2016 the *Badische Zeitung* reported that he had told party bodies the previous evening he would not stand again in Freiburg, citing a new phase of life after 20 years in his occupation and 30 in the Bundestag. He did not contest the 2017 election.

### Committees, disarmament and the parliamentary group

From 1994 Erler sat on the executive of the SPD parliamentary group. From 1994 to 1998 he chaired the subcommittee on disarmament and arms control, under the Foreign Affairs Committee. From 1998 until November 2005 he was a deputy chair. The Bundestag’s biography assigns him foreign policy, security policy, human rights and development policy; the group’s own account of those years names foreign, defence and development policy and human rights. That role ended when he became Minister of State in the Federal Foreign Office in November 2005. He was deputy chair again from October 2009 until December 2013. In the 18th term he was a full member of the Foreign Affairs Committee and a deputy member of the Committee on Human Rights and Humanitarian Aid. From January 2014 the mandate overlapped with his separate appointment as coordinator for intersocietal cooperation with Russia, Central Asia and the Eastern Partnership countries.

On 8 November 2001, debating Chancellor [Gerhard Schröder](/people/gerhard-schroder)’s request to make Bundeswehr personnel available after the attacks of 11 September, Erler spoke for the SPD group in favour of a capped contribution—cabinet ceilings adding up to 3,900 soldiers—in what became the [war in Afghanistan](/facts/war-in-afghanistan). He required a geographic limit to Afghanistan or to consenting governments, German command over German forces, and regular reporting to the Bundestag, and said the military share of risk did not replace a political strategy.

On 20 March 2003, the day the [Iraq War](/facts/iraq-war) began, he answered the CDU/CSU in the Foreign Office budget debate. He said the war had already done great damage, rejected blame of those who had tried to keep the peace, and called it a legend that the [United Nations](/organizations/united-nations) had failed to act. Inspectors, he argued, had not been allowed to finish disarmament already under way, citing the destruction of Al-Samud missiles. He said the SPD would seek to raise federal humanitarian-aid funds from 40 million to 80 million euros, while refusing any division of labour that would help carry out a doctrine of preventive first use.

## Minister of State at the Federal Foreign Office

### Appointment in the grand coalition

On 22 November 2005 the Bundestag elected Angela Merkel chancellor, and the ministers of the grand coalition of the Christian Democratic Union, the [Christian Social Union](/organizations/christian-social-union-in-bavaria) and the Social Democratic Party were sworn in, among them Frank-Walter Steinmeier as federal minister for foreign affairs. At the SPD congress in Karlsruhe the party indicated that it would name Erler, then a deputy chair of its parliamentary group, and the European-policy specialist Günter Gloser as ministers of state (*Staatsminister*) in the Federal Foreign Office. The Bundestag’s biography records him as minister of state from November 2005 to October 2009, his deputy chairmanship of the SPD parliamentary group having ended that November. Gloser was presented as the party’s European-policy figure. Erler’s speeches and travel concentrated on eastern and southeastern Europe, the European Union’s contractual relationship with Russia, Central Asia and the Black Sea. The coalition left office on 28 October 2009, when Merkel was re-elected and [Guido Westerwelle](/people/guido-westerwelle) was sworn in as foreign minister. The next day the *Badische Zeitung* reported that Erler had cleared his office and met his successor.

### European and regional policy

In August 2006 Erler told [Deutsche Welle](/organizations/deutsche-welle) that the post-Soviet states would be a focus of Germany’s 2007 presidencies of the EU Council and the G8. The EU–Russia Partnership and Cooperation Agreement was due to expire at the end of 2007, and Berlin had also chosen the European Neighbourhood Policy. Agreements with Belarus were frozen, he said, unless Minsk changed its treatment of the opposition. After a July meeting with President [Islam Karimov](/people/islam-karimov) of Uzbekistan, he said he had raised the Andijan violence of May 2005 and the position of foreign non-governmental organisations, and that Germany would neither subordinate those questions to the Termez airbase nor isolate Tashkent. He linked the region to Eurasian security, to Afghanistan and to the Fergana Valley.

On 7 February 2007, at the Carnegie Endowment in Washington, he said the [European Council](/organizations/european-council) had in December 2006 mandated an EU strategy for Central Asia, to be adopted that June. He rejected a new “Great Game” with Russia, China and the United States, and named stability, the rule of law, minimum human-rights standards and energy diversification, putting the region’s share of global reserves at no more than about 4 percent. Bilateral policies toward Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan were to be joined to regional work on crime, water, borders, education and human-rights dialogues. An EU troika meeting with the five foreign ministers, set for 28 March in Astana, was to open that dialogue. The Council approved the “strategy for a new partnership” on 17–18 June, and on 21–22 June the European Council adopted it, with implementation fitted to each state and a first progress report due by mid-2008. Steinmeier opened the Berlin follow-up on 30 June.

At the Black Sea Economic Cooperation summit in Istanbul on 25 June 2007, Erler said the accession of Bulgaria and Romania had made the Union a direct neighbour of the sea, that the Council had adopted conclusions on the initiative, and that every littoral state had to be included. On 29 May 2008 he described the concept, developed with the Commission and other member states, as a regional layer on bilateral policies, cited a foreign ministers’ meeting in Kyiv attended by Steinmeier, and called Turkey indispensable.

On 30 June 2006 he welcomed Montenegro’s referendum of 21 May—55.5 percent for leaving the state union—the declaration of 3 June and United Nations membership on 28 June. The Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe had cleared the vote, and Serbia had opened diplomatic relations on 22 June. He called cooperation with the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia non-negotiable: talks with Belgrade, opened on 10 October 2005, had been suspended on 3 May 2006, while [The Hague](/organizations/the-hague) was satisfied with Podgorica. On 2 October 2007 he was in Tirana for the twentieth anniversary of relations with Albania, discussing the EU perspective, Kosovo and regional ownership of the Stability Pact. In February 2008 he told Deutsche Welle, before a visit to Montenegro, that an association agreement signed the previous 15 October gave Montenegro a good European prospect, and that Kosovo was no threat if [Martti Ahtisaari](/people/martti-ahtisaari)’s plan was implemented. In July 2008 he said moving police, justice and customs from UNMIK to EULEX would not partition Kosovo, noted donor pledges of €1.2 billion, and put Germany’s KFOR contingent at 2,700 of about 16,000 troops. On 29 June 2009 he argued that the European perspective would keep driving reform only if conditionality stayed strict and disputes left by Yugoslavia, above all in Bosnia and Herzegovina, were settled.

On 16 November 2007 the University of National and World Economy in Sofia awarded him an honorary doctorate, and the Bulgarian president conferred the Order of Stara Planina, first class, for his part in German–Bulgarian relations. In the lecture “Bulgaria’s European coming of age,” he linked Bulgaria’s accession on 1 January 2007, and Romania’s, to the two states’ role in Black Sea Synergy.

## Coordinator for intersocietal cooperation

### German–Russian civil-society ties

In February 2003 Foreign Minister [Joschka Fischer](/people/joschka-fischer) appointed Gernot Erler, a Social Democratic member of the Bundestag, coordinator in the Federal Foreign Office for societal contacts with Russia. The ministry said the post, introduced at the start of 2003, was meant to underline German–Russian relations and to strengthen cooperation between the two civil societies. Erler, deputy chair of the SPD parliamentary group and chair of the Bundestag’s German–Russian parliamentary group, already sat in the leadership of the Petersburg Dialogue, the forum Chancellor Gerhard Schröder and President [Vladimir Putin](/people/vladimir-putin) had launched in 2001 so that non-state organizations, including critical groups, would meet regularly.

In February 2007 he recalled pressing, from his seat on the Dialogue’s German board, for human-rights groups to attend; only in October 2006, he said, were two representatives of Memorial included, after years of invitations to established specialists on Germany. *Der Spiegel* recorded that he held the coordinator’s office from 2003 to 2006, overlapping his service as minister of state in the Foreign Office from 2005 to 2009. Andreas Schockenhoff of the Christian Democratic Union was the incumbent replaced in January 2014.

### The expanded mandate after 2013

On 9 January 2014 the Foreign Office announced Erler’s return as Russia coordinator of the new grand coalition. Chancellor Angela Merkel and Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier appoint the post jointly. *Spiegel* reported that Schockenhoff had not wanted to leave, and that the choice was disputed because Erler was associated with a more Moscow-friendly line: Schockenhoff had pressed a Bundestag resolution criticizing Moscow’s treatment of the opposition, from which the SPD had abstained.

The argument had been set out in Erler’s 2013 essay in *[Die Zeit](/organizations/die-zeit)*, “Schluss mit dem Russland-Bashing!”. Western frustration, he wrote, had a counterpart in Moscow, where NATO and European Union enlargement, the “colour revolutions” in Ukraine and Georgia, missile defence and the recognition of Kosovo were read as exploitation of post-Soviet weakness. He called that account selective, but said it shaped behaviour, including Putin’s Eurasian Union of Russia, Belarus and Kazakhstan. What was required, he wrote, was not “salesmen of a ‘model Europe’” but a modernization partnership “on an equal footing”, alongside practical solidarity with groups forced to register as “foreign agents”.

*Spiegel* quoted his formula, “not the raised index finger, but partnership”, and his reply at the Petersburg Dialogue in Kassel in December 2013 to talk of a “war of values”: values accepted by treaty could not be the subject of a war, and a modern industrial society needed civic engagement. Arseny Roginsky of Memorial, praising Schockenhoff, warned that the task was coordination of civil societies, “not governments”.

In December 2014 the Foreign Office called him coordinator for societal cooperation with Russia, the countries of the Eastern Partnership and Central Asia; the Bundestag later used “intersocietal cooperation” with Russia, Central Asia and the EU’s Eastern Partnership countries, Ukraine, Belarus, Moldova, Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan. From 1 January 2015 until 31 December 2016 he was also special representative for Germany’s 2016 chairmanship of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, while remaining coordinator. On 11 April 2018 the Foreign Office announced that Dirk Wiese would succeed him.

### Ukraine, sanctions and dialogue

On 4 March 2014, with Russian forces in control of Crimea, Erler told *Spiegel*, “I am shaken”, and that much of what was happening was beyond him: world opinion, which he had thought the Russian leadership valued, “no longer seems to play any role”. He read the reaction as shock at the Maidan, treated in Moscow as another colour revolution, and said he had not expected a military answer. Annexation of part of Ukraine would, he warned, be a catastrophe for Russia’s international position; sanctions at that moment risked closing a narrow window for diplomacy, which should be pursued “until the last minute”. In April the Petersburg Dialogue still met, in Leipzig, but *Spiegel* found the war kept off the programme, and a mild criticism by Erler of both governments was quickly passed over.

On 17 March he told *Das Parlament* he had no problem with the label “Russlandversteher”: understanding motives was not agreement. He repeated Moscow’s charge that the EU and NATO had enlarged “contrary to earlier assurances”, and said staged sanctions had to leave an “exit” even if sharper steps followed an annexation—the word he noted Russian officials avoided in favour of “reunification”. He put Germany’s exposure at 6,200 firms in Russia, €20 billion of investment, €76 billion of trade in 2013 and at least 300,000 jobs. Crimea, he said, might be “only the beginning”.

In October *[Der Tagesspiegel](/organizations/der-tagesspiegel)* headed a profile “Once upon a time there was a Putin-understander”, calling him a notorious Russlandversteher now disappointed in Moscow, and quoting his remark that Merkel still spoke more hopefully than he did of partnership. Further Dialogue meetings were cancelled on the German side amid demands, including from Schockenhoff, to open the forum to critics.

On 12 February 2015 he said a new Minsk text would carry “a different authority” from the accord of 5 September 2014 because the Ukrainian, Russian, French and German leaders were signing it, and that Moscow had a growing interest in stopping the sanctions spiral. On 24 August he would not call the second of the Minsk agreements empty—parts of the line of contact were quiet—but described “a kind of positional war” in the Donbas. “At the moment we have nothing other than the Minsk agreement,” he said, and Russian support for the armed groups would continue. In December he told Deutsche Welle that Moscow blamed Ukraine for delays on decentralization and elections while still owing the handover of the border, and that Crimea was being set aside so the fighting could be stopped first.

Ukrainian commentary was sharper. On 28 November 2015 [Vitaly Portnikov](/people/vitaly-portnikov) wrote on Radio Svoboda that Erler, interviewed by Deutsche Welle’s Russian service, was doing “Putin’s work” by blaming Ukraine rather than Russia for the state of Minsk. He quoted Erler as calling Russian claims—that Ukraine, not Moscow, was failing the agreements—“not that mistaken”, and as treating Crimea as playing no current political role. Writing under his own name, Portnikov called the remarks political corruption and asked whether Erler meant to follow Gerhard Schröder, whom he called Germany’s shame.

## Germany’s OSCE chairmanship

### Special representative, 2015–2016

At its Basel meeting on 5 December 2014, the Ministerial Council of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe designated Germany to hold the chairmanship in 2016. From 1 January 2015 it joined the OSCE Troika, with Serbia in the chair and Switzerland as the previous chair.

On 15 December 2014, after a cabinet decision, Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier appointed Gernot Erler Special Representative of the Federal Government for the OSCE Chairmanship in 2016. From 1 January 2015 until 31 December 2016 he held the post alongside his Russia and Eastern Partnership coordination work, planning the chairmanship and representing Steinmeier, including in the Troika. Steinmeier called him an Eastern Europe specialist and an “experienced bridgebuilder between East and West,” and said the crisis in Ukraine had revived the OSCE’s role in Europe’s security order. In 2016 Steinmeier was Chairperson-in-Office. Germany took the chair from Serbia on 1 January under the heading “renewing dialogue, rebuilding trust and restoring security.”

### Priorities and the Ukraine conflict

In *Security and Human Rights*, Erler listed five priorities: crisis management, above all in and around Ukraine and in other protracted conflicts; stronger OSCE crisis response; dialogue on arms control, transnational threats and common principles; the economic and environmental dimension, including connectivity; and human-dimension questions such as tolerance, freedom of expression and of the media, and minority rights.

Steinmeier presented the programme to the Permanent Council in Vienna on 14 January 2016. Dialogue, he said, could not conceal breaches of OSCE commitments, “for example, in Crimea and eastern Ukraine,” and there was no alternative to full implementation of the Minsk agreements. With France, Germany continued mediation in the Normandy Format. He demanded a strict ceasefire and unrestricted access, without threats or intimidation, for the unarmed civilian OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine.

On 18 March 2016, the second anniversary of Russia’s annexation of the peninsula, Erler said that by annexing Crimea, which in international law belonged to Ukraine, Russia had broken international law and fundamental OSCE principles, “in particular the inviolability of international borders and respect for the sovereignty of all states.” Both that annexation and the conflict in the east, he said, endangered security in the OSCE area. Restoring Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity remained the demand, and the Minsk agreements the most urgent step; he called on Russia in particular to meet its obligations.

On 9 April he said reports of more ceasefire violations and of heavy weapons were worrying, and that a durable ceasefire was needed if Minsk’s political provisions were to advance. A mission vehicle coming under fire, and a patrol threatened at gunpoint in separatist-held territory, were “utterly unacceptable.” All sides had to guarantee the monitors’ safety and “free and unrestricted access to the entire conflict area.” In Kyiv the following month, OSCE Secretary General Lamberto Zannier said monitors had been threatened, shot at, harassed and blocked, mainly on the separatist side; the mandate remained that of unarmed civilians.

The chairmanship closed with the 23rd Ministerial Council in Hamburg on 8–9 December 2016. Steinmeier said no mission could enforce a ceasefire without political will, and added: “Despite all our efforts in eastern Ukraine, we won’t forget Crimea. It was annexed in violation of international law, and to this very day OSCE institutions aren’t being granted access.” There was no joint closing declaration. Steinmeier spoke of “marked differences”; ministers deplored breaches of international law and OSCE principles, while agreeing other texts, including a structured dialogue on arms control.

## Publications

### Academic editions

The [German National Library](/organizations/german-national-library) files these volumes under the historian and politician born in 1944. In 1979 he edited *Von der Revolution zum Schriftstellerkongress: Entwicklungsstrukturen und Funktionsbestimmungen der russischen Literatur und Kultur zwischen 1917 und 1934*, published by the Osteuropa-Institut in Berlin and, on commission, by Harrassowitz in Wiesbaden as volume 47 of the Slavic series of the Free University of Berlin (VIII + 488 pages; “hrsg. von G. Erler …”). Rainer Grübel and Krisztina Mänicke-Gyöngyösi wrote the introduction. Erler’s essay treats political and socioeconomic limits on cultural life in Soviet Russia; later chapters follow the avant-garde toward socialist realism.

With Walter Süss he edited *Stalinismus: Probleme der Sowjetgesellschaft zwischen Kollektivierung und Weltkrieg* (1982; Campus, Frankfurt am Main and New York, and Verlag Ästhetik und Kommunikation, Berlin; 675 pages, bibliography on pp. 657–664), classed under Stalinism and Soviet society from collectivization to the Second World War.

### Books on Russia, peace and world order

Later books, written as a Bundestag member, turn from the post-Cold War order to Russia and German foreign policy, up to the 2018 essay *Weltordnung ohne den Westen?*.

*Cover of the 2018 Herder edition of Gernot Erler’s essay Weltordnung ohne den Westen?*

*Global Monopoly. Weltpolitik nach dem Ende der Sowjetunion* (Aufbau-Taschenbuch-Verlag, Berlin, 1998; 128 pages; foreword by Wilhelm von Sternburg) runs from a missing “peace dividend” through Bosnia, the United Nations, NATO enlargement and the United States to whether a “global monopoly” is a dead end. Deliana Popova wrote that the book saw little hope unless the stronger power also played “the role of the good.”

*Russland kommt. Putins Staat – der Kampf um Macht und Modernisierung* (Herder, Freiburg, Basel and Vienna, 2005; Herder-Spektrum 5566; 190 pages) asks, in the publisher’s text, whether Vladimir Putin’s Russia is an authoritarian great power or a democratic departure. Chapters on Beslan, [Mikhail Khodorkovsky](/people/mikhail-khodorkovsky) and Yukos, and the [Orange Revolution](/facts/orange-revolution) in Ukraine end in a plea for “Einbindung statt Ausgrenzung.” Natalie Wohlleben called it a realist stocktaking shaped by Germany’s energy dependence, close to change through rapprochement; Perlentaucher lists no national-newspaper review.

*Mission Weltfrieden. Deutschlands neue Rolle in der Weltpolitik* (Herder, 2009; 260 pages), with a foreword by Frank-Walter Steinmeier, treats Kosovo, the Iraq War, Russia, China and Afghanistan—including a civilian “German model”—and argues, in the publisher’s text, that security requires a more just world order. Perlentaucher’s note on Gunter Hofmann’s *Die Zeit* review (8 April 2009) says he expressed “respect” for the account of Germany’s new role and for Erler’s path out of the peace movement, but wanted more self-criticism on Central Asia and Uzbekistan.

*Das Versagen nach 9/11. Mit besseren Strategien gegen den Terror* (edition Körber-Stiftung, Hamburg, 2011; Standpunkte; 105 pages) also appeared in English as *Failure in the wake of 9/11* (Körber Policy Paper No. 14; 61 pages). Marius Hildebrand reported a largely negative balance a decade after the [September 11 attacks](/facts/september-11-attacks): domestic measures had been largely necessary, but Iraq, Afghanistan, Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo and pre-emption had, on this account, sidelined anti-poverty policy and raised support for al-Qaeda. [The alternative](/organizations/the-alternative) Erler offered was the European Union’s broader approach and the Arab uprisings then underway.

In 2014 he edited *Warum Frieden machbar ist. Kriegsverhütung und Friedensstrategien seit dem 1. Weltkrieg* (Herder; 220 pages), classed as proceedings of a conference in Freiburg im Breisgau. The publisher’s description says the contributors balance peace efforts around the First World War and after 1945—including Willy Brandt’s détente—call world politics as a “repair shop” an overload, and conclude that forward-looking policy can make peace possible.

*Weltordnung ohne den Westen? Europa zwischen Russland, China und Amerika* (Herder, 2018; a political essay; 207 pages) sets Putin’s Russia, [Xi Jinping](/people/env-person-xi-jinping)’s China and [Donald Trump](/people/mig-donald-trump)’s “America first” United States against a European Union in crisis, in the publisher’s wording. Chapters cover Ukraine and sanctions, the New Silk Road, a standing conference of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, and a new arms race. In Deutschlandfunk’s *Andruck* (18 June 2018), Gregor Peter Schmitz wrote that none of those powers came off well, that the account of estrangement showed a “Russlandversteher in the best sense,” and that Erler wanted a stronger Europe but doubted disunity would allow it.

## Civil society, honors and later life

### Southeast Europe Association and bilateral societies

Erler presided over the Südosteuropa-Gesellschaft (Southeast Europe Association) from 2000 to 2020. Founded in Munich in 1952, it cultivates ties with Southeast Europe, and its president has thanked the Federal Foreign Office for financial support. On 25–26 February 2000, at the annual meeting in Berlin, members elected him to succeed Walter Althammer, president for 35 years. On 21 February 2020 the members’ assembly in Munich elected Manuel Sarrazin of Alliance 90/The Greens, then a member of the Bundestag, as president, and made Erler honorary president and an honorary member. On 4 July 2024 the association marked his 80th birthday with a discussion in the Bundestag’s Paul Löbe House, where he gave a keynote.

He also worked through bilateral forums. On 22 April 1996 he co-founded the German–Bulgarian Forum in Bonn, later seated in Berlin, and chaired it until December 2018, when Volker Berresheim was elected. In 2022 the government of Baden-Württemberg called him the forum’s honorary chairman, noted earlier board service with the German–Kazakh Society and the foundation council of the Institute for East and Southeast European Studies, and described him as a member of the steering committee of the Petersburg Dialogue, a German–Russian civil-society forum. The federal association of German West–East societies lists him as chairman of the West-Ost-Gesellschaft Südbaden in Freiburg im Breisgau, a post he said in 2017 he would keep after leaving parliament.

### Decorations and activity after 2017

On 25 July 2016 Erler, then 72 and a Bundestag member for thirty years, said he would not stand again in Freiburg, so that younger deputies of the Social Democratic Party of Germany from Baden-Württemberg could follow. He left the Bundestag at the end of that term but remained coordinator for inter-societal cooperation with Russia, Central Asia and the Eastern Partnership until 11 April 2018, when the Foreign Office named Dirk Wiese his successor. On 18 May 2019 Minister-President [Winfried Kretschmann](/people/winfried-kretschmann) conferred the Order of Merit of Baden-Württemberg on Erler and seventeen others in Mannheim.

The SPD group’s biography lists the Cross of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany on ribbon, dated June 1998, and records one daughter. On 16 November 2007 in Sofia he received an honorary doctorate from the University of National and World Economy and, from the Bulgarian president, the Order of Stara Planina, First Class, which the Foreign Office called Bulgaria’s highest order, for work on German–Bulgarian relations. The Federal President’s office listed Gernot Siegfried Erler, Dr. h.c., of Freiburg, for the Cross, First Class, on 1 January 2022. On 6 September 2022 [Theresa Schopper](/people/theresa-schopper), the state’s education minister, presented that class in Freiburg as a higher grade of an order he already held, citing foreign and peace policy and East–West civil-society ties. For his 80th birthday the city gave him its Golden City Seal; [the gazette](/organizations/the-gazette) of 25 May 2024 reported that Mayor Martin Horn presented it for a career that began on the Tiengen local council in 1976.

He continued to comment on Russia and Ukraine. On 24 February 2022, the day of the full-scale invasion, he told the *Badische Zeitung* he was shocked—“The unthinkable has happened”—called the attack a war of aggression contrary to international law, a painful day for advocates of dialogue, and urged Western unity. On 17 February 2024, the day after [Alexei Navalny](/people/alexei-navalny) died, he told Deutschlandfunk that the death symbolized an opposition that had been shut down, and that he saw no failures, looking back, in his mediating role. The station noted that he had been called a “Putin-Versteher” and still expected “the hour of diplomacy” to return. On 23 February 2024 he told the *Badische Zeitung* that the West shared responsibility for Ukraine’s setbacks, that he could not imagine much larger Russia being forced to give back all the ground it had taken, and that diplomacy would grow from talks already held, including on grain, rather than a war of many further years.

## Dated facts

_No published facts on this page yet._

## Methodology

https://factrail.ai/methodology

Canonical: https://factrail.ai/people/gernot-erler
