# Holger Börner

# Holger Börner

Holger Börner (7 February 1931 – 2 August 2006) was a German politician of the [Social Democratic Party of Germany](/organizations/social-democratic-party-of-germany) who served as Minister-President of Hesse from 1976 to 1987. Born in Kassel and raised in a Social Democratic household, he left school early in 1947 because the family was short of money and trained as a construction worker. He qualified as a concrete worker, became chairman of the works council at the Kassel building firm Hermanns, and joined the SPD in 1948.

From 1956 to 1972 he sat on the Kassel city council. In 1957 he entered the Bundestag for the Kassel constituency as its youngest member and remained there until 1976. Between 1961 and 1964 he chaired the Young Socialists in the SPD. In the Bundestag he became chairman of the transport committee in 1965 and, from 1967 to 1972, parliamentary state secretary in the Federal Ministry of Transport. At the beginning of February 1972 he left that post to become the SPD's federal managing director, a role he held until 1976 under party chairman [Willy Brandt](/people/willy-brandt) and, after Brandt's resignation, during [Helmut Schmidt](/people/helmut-schmidt)'s chancellorship. Kurt Beck later said that, as managing director, Börner had a large share in the SPD's Bundestag victories of 1972 and 1976.

On 12 October 1976 the Hessian Landtag elected him Minister-President in succession to Albert Osswald, and the 1978 state election confirmed him in office. He also chaired the Hessian SPD from its reorganisation in 1977 until 1987. In office he pressed ahead with the expansion of Frankfurt Airport against heavy resistance. An interview given on 1 May 1982 to the magazine *Bunte*, and reprinted by *[Der Spiegel](/organizations/der-spiegel)*, quoted him on violent disruptors: "I regret that my high office of state forbids me to punch those fellows in the face myself. In the old days on the building site one settled such things with roof battens." The line became an opposition campaign slogan in the 1982 Hessian election, and Börner disputed the published wording.

After the 1982 election left no majority, he continued in a caretaker capacity; following a further election on 25 September 1983 the Landtag re-elected him on 7 June 1984. In October 1985 he entered a formal coalition with [the Greens](/organizations/the-greens), the first such state government in the Federal Republic, and on 12 December 1985 [Joschka Fischer](/people/joschka-fischer) was sworn in as minister for the environment, the first Green minister in West Germany. The coalition lasted about fourteen months. On 9 February 1987 Börner dismissed Fischer in a dispute over licences for the Hanau nuclear-fuel plants Alkem and Nukem, and he declined to lead the SPD into the election that followed. He chaired the [Friedrich Ebert Foundation](/organizations/friedrich-ebert-foundation) from 1987 until 2003. He died in Kassel in the night of 2 August 2006, aged 75, after a long illness with cancer. Beck called him a "born Social Democrat"; the then Minister-President of Hesse, Roland Koch, called him a statesman who had shaped his time.

## Early life and family

### Childhood in Wolfsanger

Holger Börner was born on 7 February 1931 in Wolfsanger, then a village outside Kassel and not yet part of the city. On 1 June 1936 Wolfsanger was incorporated into Kassel together with several neighbouring villages. Reference works often give the birthplace simply as Kassel; the district of Wolfsanger remained the place he treated as home.

He grew up in a household already bound to the Social Democratic Party of Germany. Biographical accounts place that tradition a generation further back: his grandfather, a supporter of the Social [Democratic movement](/organizations/democratic-movement), is said to have left Berlin for Hesse under the pressure of [Otto von Bismarck](/people/otto-von-bismarck)'s [Anti-Socialist Laws](/facts/anti-socialist-laws). The Hessian biography records the move as something reported rather than as a documented fact.

His father, Hermann Börner, born in Kassel on 25 August 1906, was a construction foreman and chairman of the SPD branch in Wolfsanger. From 1933 to 1936 the authorities of Nazi Germany held him in a concentration camp in the Emsland, part of the Emslandlager. During the [Second World War](/facts/world-war-ii) he worked on bridge construction for the Organisation Todt and was killed by Soviet partisans east of Smolensk on 14 October 1941, when Holger was ten. Börner's mother, Martha, née Bengsohn (1909–1997), later sat as a city councillor in Kassel. Obituaries record that the son grew up with his father's political persecution and that the death in the war left the family in economic difficulty.

### Apprenticeship and the building trade

That hardship cut his schooling short. In 1947 he left middle school early and began an apprenticeship as a construction worker. He had wanted to become a journalist, but, as a half-orphan, he needed wages, and the building sites supplied them. He qualified as a concrete worker (Betonfacharbeiter); the [German National Library](/organizations/german-national-library) classifies the occupation as concrete and reinforced-concrete builder.

He was said to have joined a trade union two hours after starting his first day's work. At the Kassel contractor Hermanns, a firm then employing about 250 people, he worked as an assistant foreman (Hilfspolier) and became chairman of the works council. The Hessian biography lists his trade as that of a mason's foreman (Maurerpolier).

On 27 December 1950, in Kassel, he married Carola Förster, an educator and kindergarten teacher from Hirschberg in the Riesengebirge, in Silesia, and a daughter of Maria Förster. The couple had three children. The Hessian biography names the sons Olaf and Fritjof and the daughter Heike Börner-Pospich; *[Die Welt](/organizations/die-welt)*'s obituary spells the elder son Olav. In 1948, while he was still in the trade, he joined the SPD, the start of a party career that later took him into the Bundestag and the government of Hesse.

## The SPD in Kassel and the Young Socialists

### Entry into the party

In 1946 Börner joined a forerunner of the Socialist Youth of Germany – Die Falken in Hesse. From 1948 to 1956 he chaired the Kassel Falken, and from 1951 to 1956 he was a member of the Falken federal executive. In 1949 he became a member of the executive council of the youth international.

He joined the Social Democratic Party of Germany in 1948. The finding aid to his papers records that in 1949 he entered the board of the Kassel local association and that from 1956 he was its second chairman. The Hessian Biography describes him as a protégé (*Ziehsohn*) of Lauritz Lauritzen, the Social Democratic mayor of Kassel from 1954 to 1963, and states that for years he held all the offices on the party boards in Kassel and the surrounding area.

### City council

Börner was a member of the Kassel city council from 1956 to 1972. The dates of his SPD faction chairmanship differ by source. The Hessian Biography gives 1960–1966, and a centenary account published by the SPD group on the council lists the same span, with Gerhard Kleinschmidt as chair from 1966 to 1968. The finding aid to Börner's papers instead dates the chairmanship to 1960–1969, and the city's portrait of him as an honorary citizen says that he led the faction for nine years.

The SPD group's history describes him, during the reconstruction period, as a pragmatic municipal politician who both voted on new housing settlements, including Mattenberg and Helleböhn, and worked on them as a concrete worker for a Kassel building firm. It records that in the 1964 municipal election the SPD, under his leadership and that of the new mayor, Karl Branner, took 57.9 percent of the vote.

### Federal chair of the Jusos

On 21 October 1961 Börner succeeded Hans-Jürgen Wischnewski as federal chairman of the Young Socialists in the SPD. The finding aid to his papers dates that office to 1961–1963. At the sixth federal congress in Berlin, held on 15–17 November 1963 under the motto "Freiheit in Gemeinschaft" ("Freedom in community"), G. Müller was elected chairman and H. Seefeld secretary. The Hessian Biography extends Börner's chairmanship to 1964, past that congress.

Until 28 August 1963 the federal chairman and deputy were chosen by the Jusos' federal committee, made up of district chairs, rather than by congress delegates; the SPD executive decided on that date that the delegates would elect them. The Jusos' own account adds that, until 1963, the election still required confirmation by the party executive. Börner's term therefore ended as that procedure changed, and before the 1969 Munich congress at which the Jusos resolved to act as a socialist tendency within the party.

## Bundestag and transport policy

### Youngest member of the Bundestag

Holger Börner entered the Bundestag at the federal election of 15 September 1957 as a directly elected member of the Social Democratic Party of Germany for the Kassel constituency. The third Bundestag was constituted on 15 October 1957. Born on 7 February 1931, he was 26, and the Friedrich Ebert Foundation, the Hessian parliamentary biography and later obituaries describe him as the youngest member. The *Hessische/Niedersächsische Allgemeine* counts six direct victories for him in Kassel, including 60.1 per cent of the first votes in 1972. The Bundestag data handbook lists him for the third through sixth legislative periods and for the seventh until 22 October 1976.

In the memorial sitting of 5 September 2006, Bundestag president [Norbert Lammert](/people/norbert-lammert) said that Börner had begun on the petitions committee and the committee for social policy and had sat without a break until 1976. The sixth constituency win came at the election of 3 October 1976, but he did not sit in the eighth Bundestag, constituted only on 14 December. The handbook closes the mandate on 22 October 1976, ten days after the Hessian Landtag had elected him minister-president of Hesse.

### The transport committee

Lammert placed the transport committee after the petitions and social-policy work. In the fifth legislative period, opened on 19 October 1965, the relevant body was the Verkehrsausschuss, with 21 members. The Bundestag chronicle of its transport committees names Börner, an SPD member from Hesse, as chairman and Ernst Müller-Hermann (CDU/CSU) as deputy, and records Hans Stefan Seifriz (SPD) as chairman from 21 June 1967. That chairmanship ran from the opening of the term until June 1967.

He did not chair the committee in the sixth period (1969–1972). It was then the Committee for Transport and for Posts and Telecommunications, with 25 members, under Hans Apel (SPD), with Josef Schmitt (CDU/CSU) as deputy. After Börner left the ministry, the same chronicle names him chairman again for the seventh period (1972–1976), when the committee had 33 members and Karl Heinz Lemmrich (CDU/CSU) was deputy. That second chairmanship covered the enlarged transport, posts and telecommunications remit and ended with his departure from the Bundestag in October 1976; the chronicle records no mid-term successor.

### Parliamentary state secretary

In April 1967 Börner became parliamentary state secretary to the federal minister of transport, Georg Leber. The office had just been created: on 12 April 1967 the chancellor and the ministers for [foreign affairs](/organizations/foreign-affairs), the interior, finance, the economy, labour, defence, transport and posts were each assigned one parliamentary state secretary. Leber had held transport since 1 December 1966, when the Bundestag elected [Kurt Georg Kiesinger](/people/kurt-georg-kiesinger) chancellor of the first CDU/CSU–SPD grand coalition, the Kiesinger cabinet. Börner stayed through the election of 28 September 1969 and into the chancellorship of Willy Brandt. From April 1967 to February 1972, Lammert recorded, he served the minister for transport and, once the title changed, for transport, posts and telecommunications.

In February 1971 *Der Spiegel* described him as the figure immediately behind Leber in the combined transport and posts department. Börner called himself the minister's political deputy and said that he gave the ministerial bureaucracy no instructions, only requests. He told *Spiegel* that he felt obliged to Leber only until the end of the legislative period in 1973.

In the chamber his transport and posts work was largely question time. On 25 March 1971, answering as parliamentary state secretary to the minister for transport and for posts and telecommunications, he said the government would not press the [Deutsche Bundesbahn](/organizations/deutsche-bundesbahn) to extend an early-retiree fare cut to early pensioners. He treated the cuts as a commercial use of spare seats, noted that directing the railway's board would cost the federal budget under the Bundesbahn Act, and listed a planned 30 per cent reduction on midweek days in the summer of 1971 and a 50 per cent reduction for women over 60 and men over 65 in two shorter seasons. The same sitting also had him answer on idle Bundesbahn freight wagons, higher fines for road-traffic offences, and the transmitter "Deutsches Reich".

He left the ministry sooner than the 1973 date he had named. On 24 January 1972 the SPD executive elected him federal managing director; the party chronicle still described him that day as parliamentary state secretary in the transport and posts ministry. *Der Spiegel* had reported on 9 January that Brandt preferred him to the Franconian SPD chairman Bruno Friedrich to run the party organisation and the next federal campaign. He gave up the state secretaryship at the beginning of February 1972 and kept the Bundestag seat.

## Federal managing director of the SPD

### Under Brandt and Schmidt

On 24 January 1972 the executive of the Social Democratic Party of Germany elected Holger Börner federal managing director (*Bundesgeschäftsführer*), succeeding Hans-Jürgen Wischnewski. Wischnewski had resigned after the party congress of December 1971 rejected his demand that delegates, rather than the executive, fill the post. *Der Spiegel* reported that party chairman and chancellor Willy Brandt favoured the 40-year-old parliamentary state secretary for transport and posts, expecting the former concrete worker from Kassel to relieve the leadership and to run a vigorous campaign. Officials at the Bonn headquarters, treasurer Alfred Nau and the Young Socialists were cooler: Börner was counted among the conservative *Kanalarbeiter* in the parliamentary party, and Bruno Friedrich was the organiser they preferred.

Börner stayed in the post after Brandt resigned as chancellor in May 1974 and Helmut Schmidt succeeded him, with Brandt remaining party chairman. During the Guillaume affair, at an SPD meeting in Münstereifel on 4 May, Brandt told Börner and Karl Ravens that his decision to resign was almost fixed; Brandt's notes, published that autumn, record that the two tried to dissuade him. The next day Brandt informed the narrower leadership — Schmidt, [Herbert Wehner](/people/herbert-wehner), Börner and Nau — and nominated Schmidt. Börner later called himself the "lubricant" (*Schmiermittel*) of that Brandt–Schmidt–Wehner trio.

He left the office after his election as minister-president of Hesse on 12 October 1976. In a farewell letter to the presidium he wrote that the once efficient machine now worked worse than the [Christian Democrats](/organizations/christian-democrats)' and that the organisation needed reform. On 22 November the executive elected [Egon Bahr](/people/egon-bahr) as his successor with 29 of 31 votes. *Der Spiegel* described Börner as a diligent organiser who nonetheless lagged behind CDU general secretary Kurt Biedenkopf in inventiveness.

### The 1972 and 1976 campaigns

The snap Bundestag election of 19 November 1972 was the first campaign of his tenure. In September he told *Der Spiegel* that Brandt was "the asset with which we will make the most" ("das Pfund, mit dem wir wuchern werden") and that the party would drive home the line "Whoever votes CDU votes for unemployment." The SPD won 45.8 per cent of the second votes, ahead of the CDU and the CSU on a combined 44.9 per cent, with turnout at 91.1 per cent; the coalition with the FDP (8.4 per cent) continued.

For 1976 an extraordinary congress in Dortmund on 17–18 June adopted a government programme in which Schmidt presented further work on a "Modell Deutschland" as a third way between unrestrained capitalism and dictatorial communism. Two weeks before polling day *Der Spiegel* wrote of a run of campaign mishaps and reported that Schmidt's circle blamed the headquarters: after 17:00, it was said, nobody in the Baracke answered the telephone. On 3 October the SPD fell to 42.6 per cent, the Union reached 48.6 per cent and the FDP 7.9 per cent; turnout was 90.7 per cent, and the coalition kept a majority of seats. After Börner's death in 2006, SPD chairman Kurt Beck said that, as federal managing director, he had had a large share in the party's election successes under Brandt and Schmidt at the Bundestag elections of 1972 and 1976.

## Minister-President of Hesse

### Succession after the Helaba scandal

On 3 October 1976, the day of the federal Bundestag election, Albert Osswald announced his resignation as Minister-President of Hesse minutes after the polls closed. He accepted political responsibility for a donations and finance scandal at the [Hessische Landesbank](/organizations/helaba) (Helaba), whose administrative board he chaired. The bank had been driven into difficulty by speculative investments; it had also made large loans to the Hessian SPD, and illegal donations to the party were alleged to have come from the same source. The government he left was an SPD–FDP coalition. In the Landtag elected in 1974 the SPD held 49 seats, the FDP eight and the CDU 53.

The Hessian SPD districts agreed that Börner, then the party's federal managing director, should succeed Osswald. On 12 October 1976 the Landtag in Wiesbaden elected him with 49 SPD votes and eight FDP votes. The CDU faction voted for its state chairman, Alfred Dregger. Reporting before the sitting had expected all 57 coalition deputies to support Börner and Dregger to have only his 53 Christian Democrats; the *[Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung](/organizations/frankfurter-allgemeine-zeitung)* reported the next day a closed vote of SPD and FDP, with speculation about defections proved unnecessary, and Dregger the first to congratulate him. Börner kept the SPD–FDP coalition and gave up the federal manager's post. He was not yet a state deputy: he left the Bundestag on 22 October 1976 and entered the Landtag only in 1978, for Kassel-Stadt II, remaining a member until 1987.

Osswald resigned as SPD state chairman on 19 April 1977. On 16 October 1977 a constitutive congress in Fulda formed one statewide SPD association out of the district organisations and elected Börner its chairman, the party office he held alongside the minister-presidency.

### Elections and the Hessian conditions

The election of 8 October 1978 confirmed the coalition. The CDU stayed the largest party, with 46.0 percent and 53 seats, ahead of the SPD on 44.3 percent and 50 seats and the FDP on 6.6 percent and seven; turnout was 87.7 percent. On 1 December the new Landtag re-elected Börner with 57 of 110 votes, and on 14 December he appointed a fresh SPD–FDP cabinet.

The election of 26 September 1982 left no governing majority, the deadlock known as the Hessian conditions (*Hessische Verhältnisse*). Of 110 seats the CDU won 52 (45.6 percent), the SPD 49 (42.8 percent) and the Greens nine (8.0 percent), their first entry into the Wiesbaden parliament; the FDP, at 3.1 percent, missed the five-percent hurdle. Dregger, the CDU's lead candidate for a fourth time, resigned the state chair on election night. Börner rejected a grand coalition and any arrangement with the Greens.

Under the state constitution the government must resign when a newly elected Landtag meets, but it continues current business until a successor takes over, and a minister-president needs more than half the statutory membership. At the sitting of 1 December 1982 Börner did not stand. Walter Wallmann, the CDU's designated state chairman and mayor of Frankfurt, received 53 votes—one more than the CDU's 52 seats—and 57 against, short of the 56 required. Börner therefore remained head of a caretaker SPD minority government.

On 4 August 1983 the Landtag dissolved itself, SPD and CDU voting in favour and the nine Green deputies against. Dissolution needs more than half the statutory members, and the new election must follow within 60 days. On 25 September 1983 there was again no majority: the SPD took 51 seats (46.2 percent), the CDU 44 (39.4 percent), the FDP eight (7.6 percent) and the Greens seven (5.9 percent). Börner stayed on as caretaker. The tolerance agreement that followed, and his re-election on 7 June 1984 with SPD and Green votes, belong to the making of the first red-green state government.

### President of the Bundesrat

On 1 November 1986 Börner became President of the Bundesrat, succeeding [Ernst Albrecht](/people/ernst-albrecht), Minister-President of Lower Saxony, in the annual rotation among the Länder. The Landtag election of 5 April 1987 ended the term early. The CDU and FDP together won 56 of 110 seats, and on 23 April the new Landtag elected Wallmann minister-president; Börner did not stand. The Bundesrat's list of presidents records Börner's tenure as ending on 24 April 1987. Wallmann, also from Hesse, then held the presidency from 15 May to 31 October 1987 and completed the state's turn.

## Social, economic and environmental policy

### Industry and employment

Börner's SPD governments in Hesse coincided with the second oil-price shock and the early-1980s recession, which hit the Rhine-Main car industry and northern Hesse around Kassel. The Hessian Court of Audit put the Land debt at 15.27 billion DM at the end of 1976, 18.68 billion at the end of 1980 and 21.65 billion at the end of 1982. Net new borrowing in 1982 was about 1.67 billion DM, and net debt service that year took about 25.6 per cent of gross tax revenue.

At Opel in Rüsselsheim, *Der Spiegel* reported in June 1980 that, after months of short-time working, some 5,000 jobs were described as surplus and that management had suggested voluntary transfers to Bochum. The works council raised the alarm; the government in Wiesbaden was described as startled, and the social-affairs minister as deeply concerned.

### Social legislation and equal opportunities

In schools Börner checked the comprehensive-school expansion of the early 1970s. *Der Spiegel* reported in 1979 that he had stopped further *Gesamtschulen*, withdrawn framework guidelines the article called carelessly drafted, and kept a statewide *Förderstufe* in grades 5 and 6; 52.7 per cent of pupils in those grades were already in one. The CDU wanted [the stage](/organizations/the-stage) optional. Where it held local majorities from 1977, including Frankfurt and Wiesbaden, introduction had been delayed, and a CDU-aligned parents' association prepared a referendum bill.

On care, the federal bill of 9 October 1986 listed a Hessian Bundesrat draft, BR-Drucksache 81/86, for a law on the risk of long-term care, alongside later drafts from Rhineland-Palatinate (137/86) and Bavaria (138/86) and a Greens bill in the Bundestag. The Bundesrat did not take up Hesse's model. It sent on a narrower "Pflegehilfe" inside statutory health insurance, aimed first at severely dependent people over 65. A *Die Welt* obituary in 2006 called Hesse the first Land to initiate long-term care insurance in the Bundesrat; that "first Land" wording is the obituary's, though the draft numbers place Hesse ahead of the other Länder texts cited that autumn.

In 1978 Börner made Vera Rüdiger the first woman in a Hessian cabinet, as minister for federal affairs; from 1984 she was minister for science and the arts, and from 1985 also commissioner for women's affairs, with a brief covering equal opportunities. The obituary also credited the governments with securing public-service broadcasting. The [Federal Constitutional Court](/organizations/federal-constitutional-court) later recorded a narrower fact: from 1985 [Hessischer Rundfunk](/organizations/hessischer-rundfunk) was the only public broadcaster advertising on its third television channel, using the revenue for a fourth radio service, hr4, on air from 6 October 1986.

### Nature conservation and energy

The Hessian Nature Conservation Act, passed in 1980 and in force on 1 January 1981, replaced the Reich Nature Conservation Act after fifteen drafts and after the deadline for filling out the 1976 federal framework law. A history of conservation in Hesse says associations shaped the disputed right of action in sections 34 to 36, links part of the delay to the rise of the Greens, and notes that the CDU in 1982 demanded that right be abolished. It says understaffed authorities limited the act until the mid-1980s, and presents Hesse as the first Land to introduce such an action.

The Energy Saving Act of 3 July 1985, effective from 1 July 1985, was a grant statute: section 8 said there was no legal entitlement to support. It backed lower use of non-renewable energy in existing housing, district heat and renewables, with priority for municipal and co-operative investment in decentralised plant, and it funded local energy concepts with public participation. The economics ministry's 1985 report said conservation had been neglected, argued that northern Hessian lignite could be used more in combined heat and power, and rejected a plutonium economy of reprocessing, plutonium recycling and fast breeders.

At Biblis, *Der Spiegel* reported in December 1981 that Börner and FDP economics minister Klaus-Jürgen Hoffie split over a permit for the first stage of a third block: Hoffie wanted it that year, while Börner called that unrealistic because he had promised the SPD it would wait on a partial permit for a repository or on long-term storage away from the station. Hoffie followed guidelines that treated on-site compact storage, or French acceptance of the waste, as enough.

## Frankfurt Airport and the roof-batten remark

### Startbahn 18 West

Startbahn 18 West was a take-off-only runway, 4,000 metres long and aligned north–south, at the western edge of Frankfurt Airport. On 28 December 1965 the operator, Flughafen Frankfurt/Main AG, applied to lengthen the parallel runways and to build the new strip. The stated case was capacity: Lufthansa had made Frankfurt its base, jet aircraft and their wake turbulence needed more separation than the propeller-era layout allowed, and the parallel runways lay too close for simultaneous movements. A ministerial permit followed on 23 August 1966. Plan approval, begun in February 1967, drew 3,849 objections over noise and forest. The Darmstadt administrative court quashed the decision of 26 March 1968; an identical decision of 23 March 1971 also fell, and in March 1974 the [Federal Administrative Court](/organizations/federal-administrative-court) sent the case back. In 1976 the Hessian Higher Administrative Court allowed changes to the parallel runways but forbade the western runway.

The social-liberal government in Hesse and the opposition CDU still backed the project, above all with a promise of about 12,000 jobs. The airport was then Europe's second-largest hub, with 17.7 million passengers and 3,200 employees, and the state's third-largest employer. Airport chief Erich Becker said national interests were at stake and that German air transport would be seriously damaged without more flights. Minister-President Börner, of the SPD, called construction unavoidable. In December 1978 the state sold the company 303 hectares; expected felling was put at 499 hectares, of which 129 had been cleared by autumn 1980. On 22 July 1980 economics minister Heinz-Herbert Karry of the FDP ordered immediate building. On 21 October 1980 the higher administrative court held that the project could no longer be challenged, and clearing began about a week later. On 12 April 1984 the runway opened without ceremony. The first passenger aircraft was a Lufthansa Airbus for Paris; the operator reported 108 movements that day.

### Protest and policing

Opposition was older than Börner's term. On 27 April 1965 residents around the airport founded an anti-noise association, with the Mörfelden pastor Kurt Oeser as its central figure. From a hut erected in the Flörsheim forest in the spring of 1980, opponents built a settlement of about 60 huts, including a church, on the line of the runway.

On 2 November 1980 about 15,000 people demonstrated against the felling of roughly seven hectares. On 11 October 1981, while a construction fence about 2.5 metres high was going up, police and more than 10,000 demonstrators clashed in fighting later called the "Blutsonntag". Early on 2 November 1981 police from several states cleared the Flörsheim settlement. WDR reported that more than 10,000 largely peaceful demonstrators entered the wood and that officers used tear gas and batons. Other settlements were cleared into 1982.

On 14 November 1981 an estimated 120,000 to 150,000 people marched in Wiesbaden, the largest demonstration in the city's history, and filed a popular-initiative application with 220,765 signatures. The Protestant Church in Hesse and Nassau asked Börner to pause the felling; he objected to what he treated as one-sided partisanship. The next day, after Frankfurt official Alexander Schubart called for the airport to be shut unless a pause was offered, traffic there stopped amid violence. The government refused the initiative in November. A Christmas halt, suggested by the president of the state [constitutional court](/organizations/constitutional-court), ended on 15 January 1982, when the court held the initiative inadmissible. Inside the SPD, Landtag deputy Frank Breucker said in 1981 that the runway was no longer politically enforceable; Börner brought in party chairman Willy Brandt to hold the group.

Protest then narrowed to weekly "Sunday walks" at the concrete wall. About 15,000 people demonstrated there on 14 April 1984, two days after the opening. The walks ended on the evening of 2 November 1987, the sixth anniversary of the clearance, when shots killed officers Klaus Eichhöfer and Thorsten Schwalm. Andreas E. was later sentenced to 15 years in prison, and organised protest stopped.

### The Bunte interview

On 1 May 1982 Helmut Böger of *Bunte* interviewed Börner during a drive through Hesse. The passage on violent disruptors, published weeks later and reprinted by *Der Spiegel*, read: "Ich bedauere, daß es mir mein hohes Staatsamt verbietet, den Kerlen selbst eins in die Fresse zu hauen. Früher auf dem Bau hat man solche Dinge mit Dachlatten erledigt."

Börner said he had not spoken the lines in that form. The state chancellery called the quotation alleged and unauthorised, and said he had only shown his feelings. Before the Landtag election of 26 September 1982 the batten became an opposition slogan. The *Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung* wrote of a "Dachlatten-Syndrom"; the *Frankfurter Rundschau* ran a leader; the *[Süddeutsche Zeitung](/organizations/suddeutsche-zeitung)* called the remarks violent male fantasies. Börner was heckled as "Dachlatten-Django". The citizens' initiative sold pieces of wood at three marks, lettered "Börners schlagende Argumente", and battens were held up at SPD meetings.

Frank Schwalba-Hoth, a spokesman for the Greens, said the episode would finish the SPD and lift his party over five per cent. The SPD fell from 44.3 per cent and 50 seats in 1978 to 42.8 per cent and 49 seats. The CDU took 45.6 per cent and 52 seats, the Greens entered the Landtag for the first time with 8.0 per cent and nine seats, and the FDP, on 3.1 per cent, lost its seats. Turnout was 86.4 per cent. Neither large party had a majority.

## The first red-green state government

### Minority government and tolerance

The Landtag election of 26 September 1982 left no party in Hesse able to govern alone. The CDU won 45.6 per cent and 52 of 110 seats, the SPD 42.8 per cent and 49, and the Greens 8.0 per cent and 9; the FDP, at 3.1 per cent, lost its seats. Börner stayed on as caretaker. The SPD would join neither the CDU nor the Greens, who had not clearly broken with militant protest against the Startbahn West runway.

An election on 25 September 1983, after the Landtag dissolved itself, again made the SPD the largest party: 46.2 per cent and 51 seats, against the CDU on 39.4 per cent and 44, the FDP on 7.6 per cent and 8, and the Greens on 5.9 per cent and 7. SPD and Greens together held 58 seats, just over half the house, but Börner stood by his campaign pledge of no coalition with either. Within about six weeks talks began anyway. Fundamentalists around Jutta Ditfurth opposed taking office; Realos around Joschka Fischer favoured it; the SPD was unsure the Greens would keep an agreement.

After about nine months the Greens agreed to tolerate an SPD minority government from outside the cabinet. On 7 June 1984 the Landtag in Wiesbaden re-elected Börner with 57 votes; the ministers were sworn in on 4 July. Some five months later the Green group withdrew its support over Nukem and Alkem, the fuel plants in Hanau, which it wanted closed as possible parts of a nuclear-weapons economy. The SPD refused, but the dispute did not end the experiment. After both parties gained in the local elections of March 1985, Finance Minister Hans Krollmann said in mid-May that the SPD had offered the Greens an environment ministry.

### Coalition with the Greens

The parties agreed on 16 October 1985 to form the first red-green coalition in a West German Land. Business associations threatened to take investment elsewhere; Börner treated that as an attack on the legitimacy of an elected government. *Bild* wrote that it feared for Hesse, while SPD chairman Willy Brandt was reported to have accepted the arrangement despite doubts in the party.

*The Hessian cabinet after the Landtag vote of 12 December 1985 in Wiesbaden; Joschka Fischer, in jeans, stands with the ministers.*

On 12 December the Landtag confirmed the cabinet. Fischer took the oath as minister for the environment and energy, and as deputy minister-president, in jeans and white trainers — the first Green minister in the Federal Republic. The substance was more limited. Licences for Nukem and Alkem were to be delayed or withheld, which industry took as the start of a phase-out; *Der Spiegel* remarked that the Greens had been left with birds rather than nuclear power.

The Chernobyl disaster in April 1986 sharpened the quarrel. Fundamentalists accused Fischer of failing and demanded a nuclear exit before the end of the year; the SPD refused, treating the industry as a question of jobs in Hesse.

### The Hanau dispute and collapse

What ended the coalition was a licence. On 5 November 1986 Börner told the Landtag that the Hanau plants would not be closed, because Social Democrats would not cut the jobs there. In early January 1987 Economics Minister Ulrich Steger was reported to be preparing a permit for Alkem. According to *Der Spiegel*, he informed Federal Environment Minister Walter Wallmann on 8 January of a partial licence for a plutonium throughput of 460 kilograms. Börner said Hesse would not allow expansion into a "plutonium state", but that under Article 85 of the Basic Law the Land was executing federal law, so a refusal would only move the decision to Wallmann in Bonn.

At Langgöns on 8 February 1987 the Realos narrowly won a Green assembly for an ultimatum rather than an instant break. Fischer said that if the SPD held its ground he had probably given his last account as minister, and that the coalition would be over by the end of [the week](/organizations/the-week). On 9 February Börner treated that as a resignation and dismissed him. He said he wanted new elections and, citing his health, must hand over; the next day he announced he would not stand again. He presented the withdrawal as separate from the row — a circulatory illness had already made another full term impossible — and called the break a victory for the fundamentalists.

The coalition had lasted about fourteen months. Börner planned a confidence vote for 17 February; the Greens wanted dissolution. On 5 April 1987 the CDU won 42.1 per cent and 47 seats, the SPD 40.2 per cent and 44, the Greens 9.4 per cent and 10, and the FDP 7.8 per cent and 9. On 23 April Walter Wallmann became the first CDU minister-president of Hesse, ending 42 years of SPD-led government. Börner did not lead the SPD list. He later called the cooperation right. Fischer still sought agreements with the SPD where they pointed to a nuclear exit, and [Gerhard Schröder](/people/gerhard-schroder), opposition leader in Lower Saxony, continued to treat a red-green government as an option.

## Later years

### Chair of the Friedrich Ebert Foundation

On 4 December 1987, after he had left the Minister-President’s office, the board of the Social Democratic Party of Germany-aligned Friedrich Ebert Foundation elected Börner chairman. He succeeded Heinz Kühn, the former Minister-President of North Rhine-Westphalia, who had resigned for reasons of health. Börner held the chair from December 1987 until January 2003 and was then honorary chairman. In late January 2003 Anke Fuchs, a former vice-president of the Bundestag, was elected in Berlin as his successor after he gave up the office, which a news report described him as having held for fifteen years.

A later account by the foundation credits him, during the opening of the Soviet Union under [Mikhail Gorbachev](/people/mikhail-gorbachev), with pressing the creation of offices in Eastern Europe, including a Moscow office opened in 1989. At that opening he said the foundation did not want to make “high politics”, which it left to parties and governments, but that its work could contribute to understanding between peoples and become part of the basis on which relations between states developed. The same account says an office in Leipzig opened shortly after the fall of the Berlin Wall, and treats German unification and political education in the new Länder as the main test of his years at the foundation. In June 1990 the foundation opened its representation in East Germany in Leipzig; the office head, Winfried Schneider-Deters, said it intended to work in adult political education.

### Honours

In 1987 Börner received the Grand Cross of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany. The same year the Austrian Presidential Chancellery recorded the award, on the proposal of the Foreign Ministry, of the Grand Decoration of Honour in Gold with Sash for services to the Republic of Austria (*Großes Goldenes Ehrenzeichen am Bande*) to the former Minister-President of Hesse. The Hessian biography lists that decoration as a Grand Cross, First Class, of the Republic of Austria. On 26 February 1988 the city of Kassel made him an honorary citizen. On 1 December 1993 the state of Hesse conferred the Wilhelm Leuschner Medal.

### Death and memory

Börner died in the night of 2 August 2006 in Kassel-Wolfsanger at the age of 75, after a long illness with cancer. The Hessian state chancellery and the city of Kassel announced the death.

Kurt Beck, then federal SPD chairman, called him a “born Social Democrat” who under difficult conditions had opened the way for the party to cooperate with the Greens, and said he had been able to take leave of Börner in a moving conversation shortly before the death. Beck added that, as a trained skilled worker, Börner had stood for employees’ share in both prosperity and decision-making, and that as federal managing director he had had a large part in the SPD’s Bundestag election victories of 1972 and 1976 under Willy Brandt and Helmut Schmidt. Roland Koch, the [Christian Democratic](/organizations/christian-democratic-union-of-germany) Minister-President of Hesse, called him a statesman “who shaped his time” and a man who for many decades had placed his abilities unreservedly at the service of the democratic community, and announced a state ceremony. Fuchs, by then chair of the foundation, said Börner’s work for its ideals of freedom, [social democracy](/organizations/social-democracy) and international cooperation would not be forgotten.

A memorial service was held in Kassel on 10 August 2006; the foundation had announced that the former SPD chairman [Hans-Jochen Vogel](/people/hans-jochen-vogel) would speak. Börner was buried in the cemetery of Wolfsanger. In March 2017 the city added the grave to its honorary graves, raising the number it maintained from 63 to 71; the stone bears the motto “Wer keine Politik macht, mit dem wird sie gemacht” (“Those who do not make politics will have politics made for them”). The forecourt of the Stadthalle is named Holger-Börner-Platz.

## Dated facts

_No published facts on this page yet._

## Methodology

https://factrail.ai/methodology

Canonical: https://factrail.ai/people/holger-borner
