# Peter Hintze

# Peter Hintze

Peter Hintze (25 April 1950 – 26 November 2016) was a German Protestant theologian and a politician of the [Christian Democratic Union of Germany](/organizations/christian-democratic-union-of-germany) (CDU). Born in Honnef, now Bad Honnef, in North Rhine-Westphalia, he sat in the Bundestag from the first all-German election in 1990 until his death, returned on the state list for the Wuppertal I constituency. He was secretary general of the CDU from 1992 to 1998, during the later chancellorship of [Helmut Kohl](/people/helmut-kohl), parliamentary state secretary at the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Technology from November 2005 to October 2013, and a vice president of the Bundestag from 22 October 2013 until his death. Chancellor [Angela Merkel](/people/angela-merkel), whose governments he served and whom contemporaries described as a close political ally, called him one of the Union’s outstanding personalities.

Hintze studied Protestant theology at the [University of Bonn](/organizations/university-of-bonn) and in Wuppertal. He worked as a pastor in Königswinter from 1980 to 1983. In December 1983 Family Minister Heiner Geißler appointed him federal commissioner for civilian service (*Zivildienst*); he held the post for seven years. From January 1991 to May 1992 he was parliamentary state secretary in the new Federal Ministry for Women and Youth, then headed by Merkel.

He succeeded Volker Rühe as CDU secretary general when Rühe became defence minister. After the CDU lost power in 1998, he was held partly responsible because of his “red hands” campaign, a sequel to the earlier “red socks” campaign. Merkel took over the secretary-generalship after that defeat. In the years of opposition he was the CDU/CSU parliamentary group’s spokesman on European policy. He was a vice president of the European People’s Party from 2002 to 2015 and of the Centrist Democrat International from 2001 to 2015, and deputy chairman of the International Democrat Union from 2002 to 2014. From 2007 to 2013, alongside the economics state secretaryship, he was the federal government’s coordinator for aerospace policy.

A former pastor, he argued in public against a ban on preimplantation genetic diagnosis, which he called unmerciful toward couples who wanted a child but carried a serious hereditary disease. In the debate on assisted dying he took a position that *[Der Spiegel](/organizations/der-spiegel)* called liberal and that, the magazine wrote, set the former pastor against the leadership of his own party; [Deutsche Welle](/organizations/deutsche-welle) reported that he wanted terminally ill people to be able to end their lives with legal medical assistance. Bundestag President [Norbert Lammert](/people/norbert-lammert) announced that Hintze had died of a serious illness on Saturday, 26 November 2016, aged 66; a spokesperson for the North Rhine-Westphalian CDU told reporters he had died of cancer in the night leading into Sunday. Lammert described him as a passionate parliamentarian with a gift for building bridges across factions. Merkel said he had shaped CDU and national policy for decades and had been “a man of plain speech, but also of compromise.”

## Early life and theological training

### Family and schooling

Peter Paul Wolfgang Hintze was born on 25 April 1950 in Honnef, now Bad Honnef, in North Rhine-Westphalia, the second child of Wolfgang Hintze (1904–1971), a Landgerichtsrat (judge at a regional court), and Anneliese Hintze, née Overdieck (1917–1976). He belonged to the Protestant church; other accounts describe him simply as the son of a judge. With his sister Dörte, seven years older, he grew up in a Christian household during the West German Wirtschaftswunder. Dörte also studied theology and became a teacher, and a biographical study describes that profession as the course already laid out for her brother as well.

An interest in politics showed itself early. With friends he went to nearby Rhöndorf to greet prominent visitors, among them [Charles de Gaulle](/people/charles-de-gaulle), at the private house of Chancellor [Konrad Adenauer](/people/konrad-adenauer). In 1968 he passed the Abitur at the municipal Siebengebirgsgymnasium in Bad Honnef, in the Siebengebirge.

### Study and ordination

From 1968 to 1977 Hintze studied Protestant theology at the University of Bonn and at the Kirchliche Hochschule, the Protestant church college in Wuppertal. The college had been founded on 14 August 1935, after the Barmen synod of the [Confessing Church](/organizations/confessing-church), so that the church could train its own pastors outside state faculties then being brought into line by the National Socialist regime. It taught at first under cover and reopened on 1 November 1945. From his youth he was active in the local congregation, especially in Protestant youth work.

He passed the first theological examination in 1977. A vicariate followed until 1979, when he passed the second examination. He was ordained a Protestant pastor.

### Parish work in Königswinter

The practical years were spent in the Protestant parish of Königswinter, a few kilometres along the Rhine from Bad Honnef. After the first examination he worked there as a vicar and then in auxiliary ministry; from 1979 to 1980 he was Pastor im Hilfsdienst. In 1980 he was called to the parish’s first pastorate and remained its pastor until 1983.

He regarded credibility, readiness for dialogue, and insight into the problems of modern society as important qualities of a pastor. The essential task of the office, he said, was “to build bridges between biblical tradition and the experiences of people in the modern world.” He gave particular weight to youth work in Königswinter and also served on the confirmation committee of the Evangelical Church in the Rhineland. In late 1983 Heiner Geißler, then federal minister for youth, family and health in the Christian Democratic Union, appointed him Federal Commissioner for Civilian Service. Hintze left the pastorate and took up that office on 1 January 1984.

## Party beginnings and civilian service

### Student politics and local office

Peter Hintze joined the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) in 1968, as he began Protestant theology at the University of Bonn and the Kirchliche Hochschule Wuppertal during the West German student movement; he later called himself an "alternative 68er." In the Ring of Christian Democratic Students he entered the federal board in 1971 and in 1972 became deputy to its chairman, Gerd Langguth. The organization later dated that deputy chairmanship, together with the federal treasurership, to 1972–1974. At the CDU congress in Saarbrücken in October 1971 he backed Helmut Kohl for the party leadership and afterwards described himself as a "Kohl man of the first hour."

In Bad Honnef he was chairman of the local Junge Union and a town councillor. In 1975 he was elected to the town council, the Rhein-Sieg district council and the Landschaftsversammlung Rheinland. A bid for the [Landtag of North Rhine-Westphalia](/organizations/landtag-of-north-rhine-westphalia) ended in 1980, when he lost the CDU nomination for the constituency of Bad Honnef, Königswinter and Sankt Augustin to Franz Riscop. That year he took the first pastorate in Königswinter, after serving there as vicar and assistant pastor from 1977.

### Federal Commissioner for Civilian Service

The federal commissionership for civilian service already existed. After a cabinet decision of 5 November 1969, Hans Iven, a former Social Democratic member of the Bundestag, took office on 16 April 1970; a later statute anchored the post. In November 1983 Heiner Geißler, minister for youth, family and health, appointed Hintze, who started on 1 January 1984 and, on the Bundestag's account, served until 1990 — seven years, as Spiegel later put it. Obituaries that called him the first commissioner of the Bonn republic, or the office newly created in 1983, pass over Iven.

The start coincided with the Act of 28 February 1983 reorganizing conscientious objection and civilian service, in force on 1 January 1984. For conscripts who had not yet served, an oral examination of conscience gave way to a written credibility test: the Federal Office for Civilian Service recognized an applicant when formal requirements were met and the stated motives were credible; otherwise, and for soldiers, a hearing before committees remained. Service rose from 16 to 20 months, one third longer than the 15-month basic term of conscription. The governments of Bremen, Hamburg, Hesse and North Rhine-Westphalia, and separately [Hans-Jochen Vogel](/people/hans-jochen-vogel) with 195 other Bundestag members, asked the [Federal Constitutional Court](/organizations/federal-constitutional-court) to strike down parts of the Act, including the longer term. On 24 April 1985 the Second Senate upheld the challenged rules. Judges Mahrenholz and Böckenförde dissented in part, holding the extension to 20 months unconstitutional under Article 12a (2) of the Basic Law.

Recognition stayed with the Federal Office and, where a hearing was required, with committees bound only by law, not with the commissioner. A 1992 Spiegel profile credited him with holding the CDU's defence line and the interests of civilian-service men in balance, with clearing a backlog of about 100,000 applications, and with taking the subject out of the headlines. Answering the SPD in February 1989, the government said that inherited backlog, last above 100,000, had been cleared after 1984 and that complete applications were decided within a month, while still listing 12,467 files open on 30 December 1988.

The appointment drew the complaint that Hintze was too young, inexperienced and little known. Objectors went further. At a Bochum meeting reported by *taz* on 3 March 1987, the chairman of the German Peace Society–United War Resisters, backed by about 180 participants, demanded his dismissal: he did not represent conscientious objectors, they argued, and the post should be filled by the men in service themselves. They called his claim of worse job prospects for civilian-service veterans an attempt to deter applications, and treated some 60,000 objectors in 1986 as a rejection of government military policy.

### Evangelical Working Group

In March 1990 the Evangelical Working Group (Evangelischer Arbeitskreis) of the CDU and the [Christian Social Union](/organizations/christian-social-union-in-bavaria) elected Hintze federal chairman at its conference in Wuppertal, succeeding Albrecht Martin. The meeting, on 23–24 March, followed the East German election and was the group's first with speakers from the GDR. Hintze proposed a "Germany Forum," alternating between west and east, to fix positions "in the good Protestant tradition" that could later enter daily politics. The first met on 4 June 1990 in East Berlin, with further sessions in Bonn, Dresden and Frankfurt am Main through May 1992. Deutsche Welle dates the chairmanship to 1990–1992. He entered the Bundestag in December 1990 and in January 1991 became parliamentary state secretary to Women and Youth Minister Angela Merkel, leaving the chair in 1992 on becoming CDU general secretary.

## Bundestag membership and the Kohl governments

### Elections and the Wuppertal mandate

Peter Hintze entered the Bundestag at the [1990 German federal election](/facts/1990-german-federal-election) of 2 December 1990, the first federal election after [German reunification](/organizations/german-reunification), and remained a member without a break until his death on 26 November 2016. The Bundestag's notice of that death recorded that he had first taken his seat in 1990 as a deputy for Wuppertal.

He was the candidate of the Christian Democratic Union in the Wuppertal I constituency in North Rhine-Westphalia, but the mandate was a state-list seat, not a direct one. The biography for the 14th Bundestag, chosen at the [1998 German federal election](/facts/1998-german-federal-election), states that he was "gewählt über Landesliste" for North Rhine-Westphalia, constituency 69, Wuppertal I. The same formula is used for the 17th Bundestag, constituency 103, and for the 18th, constituency 102. The constituency number changed with redistributions; the link to Wuppertal I did not.

The direct seat stayed with the Social [Democratic Party](/organizations/democratic-party-us). For the [2002 German federal election](/facts/2002-german-federal-election) the Bundestag's return for Wuppertal I, then constituency 103, names Manfred Zöllmer of the SPD as the directly elected member and Hintze as elected on the state list. Zöllmer's first-vote share was 49.9 percent and the CDU's 33.6 percent; the same table's 1998 comparison column shows 54.7 percent for the SPD and 32.7 percent for the CDU. Second votes in 2002 were 42.8 percent SPD and 30.1 percent CDU. At the [2013 German federal election](/facts/2013-german-federal-election) the Federal Returning Officer again recorded the SPD as the party of the successful constituency candidate, with 58,407 first votes (40.7 percent), and the CDU as runner-up with 52,427 (36.6 percent). Turnout in the constituency was 68.5 percent. Hintze's biography for that term once more records election on the North Rhine-Westphalia list for constituency 102.

He was returned at every federal election from 1990 through 2013. In *Der Spiegel*'s roll of CDU members elected in North Rhine-Westphalia in 2002 he appears fifth, after Norbert Lammert, Ilse Falk, Laurenz Meyer and Ursula Heinen.

### State secretary for women and youth

Helmut Kohl's fourth cabinet was presented on 18 January 1991. In that government the former Ministry for Youth, Family, Women and Health was divided: the [Federal Agency for Civic Education](/organizations/federal-agency-for-civic-education)'s cabinet chronology lists Hannelore Rönsch for family and senior citizens, Angela Merkel for women and youth, and [Gerda Hasselfeldt](/people/gerda-hasselfeldt) for health. From January 1991 to May 1992 Hintze was parliamentary state secretary to the minister for women and youth, the post the Bundestag biographies give as "beim Bundesminister für Frauen und Jugend" and a Kohl-era biographical register as service with the minister herself.

He came to the office from the federal commissionership for civilian alternative service (*Zivildienst*), which he had held from 1983 to 1990, and from 1990 to 1992 he was also federal chairman of the Protestant working group (*Evangelischer Arbeitskreis*) of the CDU/CSU. The new ministry's field was federal women's policy and youth policy, separated in the 1991 cabinet from family affairs, policy for older people, and health, in the first Bundestag after reunification. The parliamentary biographies record Hintze's state secretaryship without giving him a separate sub-portfolio. *Der Spiegel*, writing as he left the post, identified him simply as the state secretary in the women's ministry.

He gave up the office in May 1992 because Kohl moved him to the party leadership. On 1 April 1992 Volker Rühe, the CDU's general secretary, became federal defence minister after Gerhard Stoltenberg resigned. By 3 May *Der Spiegel* was already describing Hintze, then 42, as Rühe's successor and as the outgoing state secretary. On 15 June 1992 the CDU federal committee (*Bundesausschuss*), the party's highest body between congresses, confirmed him provisionally by 113 votes to 14, until the party congress could elect a general secretary in the autumn. The Bundestag dates the end of the state secretaryship to May 1992.

## Secretary general of the CDU

### Appointment and party management

In April 1992 Helmut Kohl named Peter Hintze to succeed Volker Rühe as secretary general of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) after Rühe became defence minister. Hintze, 42 and parliamentary state secretary to Angela Merkel, was a third choice: Anton Pfeifer and Reinhard Göhner had declined. *Der Spiegel* called the job a possible political suicide mission—a weakened chancellor and 19 campaigns in 1994—and wrote that Kohl wanted a young Protestant who might appeal in the east and show the party opening a place to a younger generation. Hintze defined the office as keeping the chancellor's back free, not cultivating contradiction as Heiner Geißler had, and as explaining decisions to what the magazine called a sluggish, ageing machine.

The federal committee, meeting in Bonn on 15 June 1992, confirmed him provisionally by 113 votes to 14 until a congress could elect him. Kohl told that session that German reunification still had to be realized "in intellectual community," that the new Länder should have priority, and that a separate party of eastern Germans would achieve nothing. At the federal congress in Düsseldorf in October, delegates elected Hintze, on Kohl's proposal, with 83.3 percent. The same meeting marked the enlarged party: Merkel and Saxony's interior minister Heinz Eggert each took 762 of 968 votes for deputy chair, ahead of the western candidates, while Rühe—resented in the east for his earlier attacks on former "Blockflöten"—received 502 and missed a deputy chair.

### The 1994 campaign

After the 1994 state election in Saxony-Anhalt, the Social Democratic Party (SPD) under Reinhard Höppner formed a minority government with Alliance 90/[The Greens](/organizations/the-greens), tolerated by the [Party of Democratic Socialism](/organizations/party-of-democratic-socialism) (PDS), successor of the [Socialist Unity Party](/organizations/socialist-unity-party-of-germany). Kohl called Höppner's election a trial run for Bonn and said the Bundestag vote of 16 October would be a choice of direction; Hintze said the campaign had found its theme.

On 18 July in Bonn he presented the "red socks" campaign: 200,000 posters, half a red sock held by a green clothespeg on a blue ground under "Auf in die Zukunft – aber nicht auf roten Socken," and half a flag with "Zukunft statt Linksfront." They did not name the PDS. Hintze called Magdeburg a danger for the whole country and doubted SPD chairman [Rudolf Scharping](/people/rudolf-scharping)'s assurance that he would not become chancellor in a similar arrangement; the CDU said "Linksfront" and left "Volksfront" to the Christian Social Union. Eastern [Christian Democrats](/organizations/christian-democrats) objected. Mecklenburg-Vorpommern's minister-president Berndt Seite would not use the poster, and Brandenburg's Peter-Michael Diestel called a sock on a line "devastating" for the eastern CDU. Hintze answered that the federal party could not drop the message "even if one voice or another seems to advise us against it." Saxon offices in Bautzen and Zittau refused to hang the posters and preferred a campaign around Kurt Biedenkopf. The SPD replied with a leaflet of Kohl beside [Erich Honecker](/people/erich-honecker)—"Da waren wir aber von den Socken, Herr Kohl"—and business manager Günter Verheugen said Cold War enemy-images would fail five years after communism had left Europe.

On 16 October the CDU won 34.2 percent of second votes and the CSU 7.3 percent, together 41.5, against 36.4 for the SPD; with the Free Democratic Party at 6.9 percent, Kohl's coalition continued. The PDS, at 4.4 percent, still took 30 seats. *Der Spiegel* later called the campaign effective at least in that political Germany discussed it for months, while noting that Hintze resisted being reduced to it.

### Women's quorum

At the Karlsruhe congress in October 1995 Kohl and Hintze asked that, until 1999, women fill one third of party offices and candidate lists. Hintze called the quorum indispensable if the CDU was to stay capable of majorities. On the final day it failed: 496 voted yes, 288 no and 31 ballots were invalid, five short of the 501 required. Kohl promised to try again; Rita Süssmuth, chair of the women's union, called the result a false signal, and Hintze refused to resign.

A weaker rule passed in Hanover on 21 October 1996 by 609 of 926 votes, after the chair cancelled the debate. From district level up, group elections had to give women one third of the offices; otherwise the ballot was repeated, but a second ballot stood even without the quorum. Limited to five years, Hintze said, the rule was meant to make associations nominate more women before voting day.

### Defeat in 1998 and resignation

On 27 May 1998 Hintze unveiled a sequel: a red poster printing the SPD line "Wir sind bereit," a stylized handshake—recalling Pieck and Grotewohl on the SED badge—between "SPD" and "PDS," and the close "Aufpassen, Deutschland." "After the red socks come the red hands," he said, arguing that [Gerhard Schröder](/people/gerhard-schroder) would use PDS votes in the Bundestag if he needed them. Eastern branches again withheld the posters. In June the CDU in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern said it would not use them, and Saxony's justice minister Steffen Heitmann warned of a "devastating effect" in the east that would drive sympathizers to the PDS.

On 27 September the SPD took 40.9 percent of second votes, the CDU 28.4 and the CSU 6.7, and Kohl's government ended. Colleagues accused Hintze of contributing to the defeat through mistakes in running the campaign; *Der Spiegel* later wrote that the "red hands" remake was held partly responsible for the loss of power. By 1 October he had said he would give up the office at the congress on 7 November—his term otherwise ran to 2000—so the next chairman would have a free hand. There, Wolfgang Schäuble was elected chairman with 93.4 percent, and Merkel, the first woman in the post, succeeded Hintze as secretary general with 93 percent while keeping the state chair in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern.

## Opposition years and international party offices

### European policy in the Bundestag

After the CDU/CSU left government in 1998, Hintze’s work in the Bundestag shifted to European policy. The archived biography lists him as Europäischer Sprecher of the CDU/CSU group from 1998 to 2005, and as its europapolitischer Sprecher in the 15th electoral term. A notice issued at his death describes him, until 2005, as that spokesman and as chairman of the group’s working group on the affairs of the European Union.

On 13 March 2003 he opened for the CDU/CSU on the Copenhagen European Council, which had closed accession talks with ten states, and on a constitution for the Union. He called 2003 a year of European decisions—the largest enlargement yet, and a constitution meant to give Europe “a new face”—and said success required the community interest to outweigh national particularism, with friendship toward France and a firm link to the United States, a line he traced from Konrad Adenauer through [Willy Brandt](/people/willy-brandt) to Helmut Kohl. He accused Chancellor Gerhard Schröder’s government of breaking that continuity during the Iraq crisis, and he urged the Convention on the Future of Europe to let the Union settle a common line before national contradictions became vetoes. The stenographic report lists him as a rapporteur of the EU affairs committee for the enlargement items.

On 11 December 2003, during what he called a genuine crisis of the constitutional conference, he said his side welcomed the strength of the euro as the fruit of its own policy, but that confidence would last only if the monetary institutions were built to keep it. He objected to dropping non-inflationary growth, which he dated to Article 2 of the 1957 EEC Treaty, and to any wording that made price stability a general Union aim rather than a task of the European Central Bank, citing a Deutsche Bundesbank opinion and Hans Eichel’s breach of the Stability and Growth Pact. He wanted Christianity named among Europe’s sources of value, and he opposed an accession automatism for Turkey.

On 12 May 2005, in the debate on ratifying the [Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe](/facts/treaty-establishing-a-constitution-for-europe), he said the CDU/CSU would vote yes to the treaty and to stronger Bundestag rights. He called the text “a key for a strong Europe in the 21st century,” said its great advance was the “parliamentarisation of Europe,” and thanked the Bundestag’s Convention members Jürgen Meyer and Peter Altmaier.

### European People's Party and sister internationals

The biography also lists three international offices, held with and then beyond that brief: vice president of the Christlich-Demokratische Internationale, the Centrist Democrat International, from 2001 to 2015; deputy chairman of the International Democrat Union (the biography says International Democratic Union) from 2002 to 2014; and vice president of the Europäische Volkspartei from 2002 to 2015. The Centrist Democrat International describes itself as a global organisation of centre and centre-right parties, founded in 1960 to defend democracy, human rights and the rule of law. The International Democrat Union, now styled the International Democracy Union, was formed in 1983 as a forum where like-minded parties exchange views and promote democracy and centre-right policies; its history names Helmut Kohl among the founders. The European People’s Party was established in Luxembourg in 1976 by Christian-democratic parties from European Community countries, including Germany, and describes itself as the EU’s centre-right party. The Bundestag’s death notice still cited the EPP vice-presidency of 2002 to 2015, alongside the spokesman and working-group roles that ended in 2005, as the European standing he held.

### North Rhine-Westphalia Landesgruppe

On the evening of 23 January 2006 the CDU members from North Rhine-Westphalia elected Hintze, the deputy from Wuppertal, chairman of their Landesgruppe, succeeding Norbert Lammert, who had become Bundestag president. Of 37 votes cast he received 35, with one against and one abstention; Norbert Königshofen of Essen became deputy of the 46-member group from the largest Land. The Landesgruppe is the caucus of that Land’s CDU deputies inside the joint CDU/CSU Bundestag group; Deutsche Welle called the North Rhine-Westphalian delegation the largest in the group and said he had led it from 2006. The Bundestag described the chair, held since 2006, as one of his most influential offices and still attributed it to him at his death in November 2016, separate from government office.

## Economics ministry and aerospace policy

### Parliamentary state secretary, 2005–2013

In November 2005 Peter Hintze of the Christian Democratic Union became parliamentary state secretary at the Federal Ministry for Economics and Technology, a post he held until October 2013, when the Bundestag elected him a vice-president on 22 October. The minister was Michael Glos of the Christian Social Union, in the CDU/CSU–SPD cabinet of Angela Merkel; reports assigned Hintze the European brief, beside Hartmut Schauerte (CDU) and Dagmar Wöhrl (CSU).

Glos resigned in February 2009 and was succeeded by [Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg](/people/karl-theodor-zu-guttenberg), also of the CSU. In the CDU/CSU–FDP government formed after the 2009 election, the ministry was led by Rainer Brüderle and then, after a 2011 reshuffle, by [Philipp Rösler](/people/philipp-rosler), whom Merkel also named vice-chancellor, while Brüderle left to chair the FDP's Bundestag group.

### Aerospace coordination, Galileo and Airbus

On 28 February 2007 the cabinet, on a proposal from Glos, also named him federal aerospace coordinator; the post had been vacant. In October 2011 the first two Galileo in-orbit-validation satellites reached orbit on a Soyuz from Kourou after a one-day delay. Hintze called the flight "international cooperation at its finest": a Russian launcher, a French site, and satellites developed and built largely in Germany, with control due to pass to the German Aerospace Center at Oberpfaffenhofen. Reported cost had risen toward €5 billion, and routine services had slipped toward 2014.

*Soyuz flight VS01 lifts off from Kourou on 21 October 2011 carrying the first two Galileo in-orbit validation satellites.*

The launch followed a 2007 rescue of the programme. After a public-private plan failed, EU transport ministers agreed procurement rules for a publicly financed constellation of up to 30 satellites, then costed at about €3.4 billion, meant to spread work across firms and countries. Hintze said Galileo's edge over the American Global Positioning System lay in signal precision, security and extra services. EADS Astrium said it was ready to build the satellites, while Bremen-based OHB, with Britain's SSTL, prepared a rival bid; the European Space Agency was to award the contracts, and a control station at Oberpfaffenhofen was described as secured.

In March 2012 *[Die Welt](/organizations/die-welt)* reported that Hintze had written to Tom Enders, then Airbus chief executive and soon to head the parent company EADS, demanding "parity staffing of vacancies on the top five hierarchy levels" by 1 January 2017, levels that together covered about 30,000 employees. The company called that filling jobs "by flags rather than by qualifications." Enders had proposed moving EADS administrative headquarters from Ottobrunn, near Munich, and from Paris toward Toulouse. Horst Seehofer said the CSU would not let the state, through KfW, buy a Daimler stake in EADS and give up leadership at the same time. EADS was reported as ready to forgo a remaining €500 million loan for the A350, while government spokesman [Steffen Seibert](/people/steffen-seibert) said Enders still had the government's confidence. Reuters, citing *Handelsblatt*, added that the letter called the concentration of research and development in Toulouse unacceptable and warned that German sites could become an extended workbench; Airbus rejected "games" over proportion and balance, and Hintze told Reuters he would press for a fair German share without confirming the letter's details.

On 10 October 2012 EADS and [BAE Systems](/organizations/bae-systems) dropped a merger that would have created a group with about €70 billion in annual sales and 220,000 employees. An EADS spokesperson said it was "first and foremost the German government that allowed the deal to fail." Hintze said he was convinced EADS could "best show its strengths on the global market independently." He later told *Bild* that protecting key technology and jobs was "the duty of the federal government." Enders wrote to employees that he had not expected such resistance, "especially not from Berlin," and an analyst quoted by Deutsche Welle argued that site guarantees might have been easier inside a merger.

On 16 January 2013 Hintze presented the cabinet's aviation strategy to the Bundestag, linking growth in world air transport to jobs in Hamburg, Lower Saxony, Bremen and Bavaria and to more efficient aircraft, including carbon-fibre structures on the A350. He put federal aeronautics-research spending for roughly 2007 to 2016 at about €1 billion and said research, development and production had to stay in one chain. On the abandoned merger he said works-council representatives at Airbus Hamburg had backed the original Franco-German balance, and that a BAE combination would have produced the world's largest arms group without clearly equal gains. SPD and Green members called the paper thin on airlines and airports; he replied that those were for the transport ministry, not this cabinet decision.

### Coalition talks

In the October 2009 negotiations with the FDP, *Der Spiegel* listed Hintze on the CDU/CSU side of the working group on [foreign affairs](/organizations/foreign-affairs), defence, development and Europe, with Franz Josef Jung and [Werner Hoyer](/people/werner-hoyer) among others.

In the 2013 talks with the SPD he was no longer a minister. Elected a Bundestag vice-president days earlier, he sat in the large Union–SPD round. At the opening on 23 October he called it "a memorable day." During the 26–27 November session he waited outside the smaller leadership group; after talking with the SPD's [Ralf Stegner](/people/ralf-stegner) he said Stegner "would never have thought it possible," and that the evening mattered most "for the human cohesion of the coalition."

## Vice president of the Bundestag

### Election and presidium

At the constitutive sitting of the 18th Bundestag on 22 October 2013, the house elected Peter Hintze one of its vice presidents. The senior member, [Heinz Riesenhuber](/people/heinz-riesenhuber), opened the sitting; Norbert Lammert of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) was re-elected president and took the chair.

Article 40 of the Basic Law has the Bundestag elect its president, the president's deputies and its secretaries, and adopt its rules of procedure. Applied that day, those rules left the number of deputies to the house, required each parliamentary group to be represented in the presidium by at least one vice president (a provision dating from 1994), and made the ballot secret. Election needed the votes of a majority of members, put from the chair at 316. The CDU/CSU and the Social Democratic Party (SPD) proposed six vice presidents, two for each of the two largest groups and one each for [Die Linke](/organizations/die-linke) and Alliance 90/The Greens. Drucksache 18/2 passed on a show of hands, the proposers against the two opposition groups. [Petra Sitte](/people/petra-sitte) (Die Linke) called the timing—announced the day after coalition talks opened—a poor signal on opposition rights. Michael Grosse-Brömer (CDU/CSU) described the split as representation by group strength.

The nominees were Hintze and Johannes Singhammer of the Christian Social Union, [Edelgard Bulmahn](/people/edelgard-bulmahn) and [Ulla Schmidt](/people/ulla-schmidt) for the SPD, [Petra Pau](/people/petra-pau) for Die Linke, and [Claudia Roth](/people/claudia-roth) for the Greens, all on one paper. Of 626 ballots, Hintze received 449 votes in favour, 122 against and 51 abstentions; four marks on his name were invalid. He accepted. The Bundestag records that, until this election, he was parliamentary state secretary in the Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology (from November 2005) and the federal government's coordinator for aviation and space (from 2007).

Vice presidents serve for the electoral term. With the president they form the presidium, which meets in sitting weeks on the conduct of the house, and they are members of the Council of Elders (Ältestenrat). Chaired by the president, it consists of the president, the vice presidents and 23 further members named by the groups in proportion to strength; a representative of the federal government attends. It sets sitting weeks, agendas and the length of debates, takes up disputes, including criticism of a presiding officer, decides internal matters left to it, and drafts the Bundestag's budget estimate. Standing commissions prepare its decisions. In the 18th term Hintze chaired the commission on the legal status of members until 26 November 2016.

### Parliamentary practice

In plenary the president and the vice presidents normally take the chair for about two hours at a time. The acting president opens and closes the sitting, calls the business, gives the floor and keeps order, including by a warning, withdrawal of the floor, or exclusion for up to 30 sitting days.

Hintze took turns in the chair during the term. On the morning of 19 June 2015 he opened the 113th sitting, which included the request to continue Germany's part in the international security presence in Kosovo. During the [roll-call](/organizations/roll-call) on that mandate, an open microphone caught him and Peter Altmaier, head of the Federal Chancellery, asking whether there was time before the next vote to eat sausages. Die Welt reported the exchange.

Diana Kinnert later told taz that she had headed Hintze's Bundestag office until his death. He remained vice president until he died on Saturday, 26 November 2016, aged 66; Lammert announced the death the next day.

## Bioethics and church relations

In the 17th and 18th Bundestag, Hintze led cross-party group bills on preimplantation genetic diagnosis and physician-assisted suicide. Named votes on both cut across the CDU/CSU, the SPD, the FDP, Alliance 90/The Greens and Die Linke.

### Preimplantation genetic diagnosis

On 6 July 2010 the [Federal Court of Justice](/organizations/federal-court-of-justice) held, in 5 StR 386/09, that blastocyst biopsy was not punishable in the case before it. On 7 July 2011 the Bundestag’s 120th sitting took three group bills on genetic testing of embryos from in vitro fertilisation before transfer. Drucksache 17/5450, from Katrin Göring-Eckardt, Volker Kauder and others, including Angela Merkel, would have made the test a crime for implying a distinction between lives worth and not worth living. Drucksache 17/5452, from René Röspel, Priska Hinz, Patrick Meinhardt, Norbert Lammert and others, would have allowed it only where an embryo could not develop. Drucksache 17/5451, headed by Ulrike Flach, Hintze, Carola Reimann, Petra Sitte and Jerzy Montag, would have allowed it in licensed centres after counselling and an ethics-commission vote, where a parent carried a serious hereditary predisposition or a miscarriage or stillbirth was expected.

Of 596 valid ballots, 306 supported 17/5451, 228 the ban and 58 the narrower allowance; one member rejected all three and three abstained, so the Flach–Hintze draft passed second reading. The final vote adopted it by 326 to 260, with eight abstentions, of 594 cast; Hintze voted yes. He said that forbidding the avoidance of abortion, where abortion was already lawful on stated conditions, was “rechtlich unhaltbar und moralisch verwerflich”, and asked for “eine Ethik des Helfens” rather than an ethic of punishment. *Der Spiegel* later wrote that he had called it “unbarmherzig” to deny such tests to couples who wanted a child but carried a serious hereditary risk.

### Assisted suicide legislation

On 6 November 2015 the Bundestag again chose among group texts. Hintze was already ill: *Spiegel* later reported that he had been found in spring 2013 to have lung cancer. With Reimann, Karl Lauterbach, Burkhard Lischka and others, Drucksache 18/5374 would have added a civil-law rule, not a crime: an adult patient with capacity, whose incurable illness irreversibly led to death, could receive a doctor’s voluntary help in a self-performed ending of life, after advice on alternatives and confirmation by a second doctor.

[Renate Künast](/people/renate-kunast), Petra Sitte and others (18/5375) would have left non-commercial assistance lawful; Patrick Sensburg, [Thomas Dörflinger](/people/thomas-dorflinger) and others (18/5376) would have criminalized both incitement and assistance, with no exceptions for doctors or relatives. [Michael Brand](/people/michael-brand), [Kerstin Griese](/people/kerstin-griese), [Kathrin Vogler](/people/kathrin-vogler), Harald Terpe and others (18/5373) proposed § 217 of the Criminal Code, punishing the *geschäftsmäßige* promotion of suicide—conduct aimed at repetition, not necessarily profit—by up to three years or a fine, while excluding close persons acting only in an individual case. On one ballot Brand and Griese received 309 votes, Hintze’s group 128, Künast and Sitte 52, and Sensburg and Dörflinger 37; 70 rejected all four and three abstained, so a motion by [Katja Keul](/people/katja-keul) and others against any new offence was not put. The final vote passed the Brand–Griese bill by 360 to 233, with nine abstentions, out of 602 votes.

Hintze said *geschäftsmäßig* would already cover a pain specialist who helped twice, and called help toward a peaceful death, once palliative care had reached its limit, a requirement of neighbourly love; *Deutsches Ärzteblatt* reported his line that the core of human dignity is self-determination. Asked in *Christ & Welt* on 4 October 2015 why he did not contemplate assisted suicide for himself, he answered, “Ich habe eine starke Liebe zum Leben”, and hoped, for the moment, never to face that situation. On 26 February 2020 the Federal Constitutional Court held § 217 void because it largely emptied the possibility of assisted suicide.

### Relations with the Protestant churches

Obituaries still identified Hintze, a former pastor in Königswinter, as an “evangelischer Pfarrer” in these debates. *Der Spiegel* wrote that, with what it called his liberal position on assisted dying, he stood against his party leadership, most of his group, and both his own church and the [Catholic Church](/organizations/catholic-church).

Before the 2011 vote, Nikolaus Schneider, chair of the Council of the [Evangelical Church in Germany](/organizations/german-evangelical-church), told the *Hamburger Abendblatt* he could accept a narrow allowance where an embryo would not survive pregnancy. That report said the Council’s February 2011 statement favoured a ban while splitting over exceptions, and that the Catholic Church sought a general prohibition. After the vote Schneider called the statute “zu weit gehend”, preferring an exception only for probable miscarriage or stillbirth. Archbishop Robert Zollitsch and Bishop Gebhard Fürst wrote to deputies that the procedure selected embryos as “lebenswert” or “lebensunwert”.

In the 2015 interview he said a God who fixed the manner of death like a puppeteer would be cruel and merciless, and that theology had idealized suffering by tying it to the crucifixion: “Aber wir sind nicht Jesus.” After the November vote, Cardinal [Reinhard Marx](/people/reinhard-marx), Alois Glück, Council chair Heinrich Bedford-Strohm and synod president Irmgard Schwaetzer called the ban “eine Entscheidung für das Leben und für ein Sterben in Würde”.

## Illness, death and assessments

### Cancer and final years

Hintze remained a vice president of the Bundestag from 22 October 2013 until his death. A Spiegel reconstruction of September 2017, based on his doctors and colleagues, reported that the non-smoker was found in spring 2013 to have lung cancer and was given twelve to eighteen months. He continued treatment, often returning to his office in Berlin, and the account dates his last day in the chamber to 8 July 2016. The Bundestag biography lists him as Protestant, married and the father of one child. Spiegel's obituary called the marriage his second and mentioned a son, without naming his wife.

On Sunday 27 November 2016, Bundestag President Norbert Lammert said Hintze had died the day before, Saturday 26 November, aged 66, of a serious illness. The member biography gives the same date. A spokesperson for the CDU in North Rhine-Westphalia told Spiegel that he had died of cancer "in der Nacht auf Sonntag," and [Der Tagesspiegel](/organizations/der-tagesspiegel) "in der Nacht zum Sonntag." Deutsche Welle, citing federal and state spokespeople, reported the night leading into Sunday; its English service said early Sunday. Those reports named no place of death. Spiegel's 2017 account stated separately that he died at 19:50 on 26 November, in a hospital ministers had visited, and did not name the hospital.

Dr. Mathias Edwin Höschel, entered on the Bundestag list as CDU/CSU, succeeded him in the seat on 7 December 2016. On 19 January 2017 the chamber elected Michaela Noll (CDU) vice president, with 513 votes in favour, 27 against and 29 abstentions. Spiegel reported that most files from his parliamentary office went to the archive of the [Konrad Adenauer Foundation](/organizations/konrad-adenauer-foundation) in Sankt Augustin.

### Funeral and honors

The Evangelical Church in Germany reported a memorial service at the Berlin Cathedral on 1 December 2016, and burial on 3 December in his birthplace, Bad Honnef, after a funeral at the Protestant Erlöserkirche. Citing press reports, it expected several hundred guests, among them Chancellor Angela Merkel, Lammert, [European Commission](/organizations/european-commission) president [Jean-Claude Juncker](/people/jean-claude-juncker) and North Rhine-Westphalia's minister-president Hannelore Kraft, and said he was survived by his wife and a son. Spiegel later described the Bad Honnef service as not a state ceremony, while recording that Merkel, CDU ministers, a former federal president and the Bundestag president attended.

In 2006 he received the Officer's Cross (Bundesverdienstkreuz 1. Klasse) of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany. The [European People's Party Group](/organizations/european-people-s-party-group) lists him as a recipient of its [Robert Schuman](/people/robert-schuman) Medal on 19 January 2012.

### Contemporary assessments

Merkel said the Union had lost "one of its outstanding personalities," a man of plain speech and of compromise who had shaped the CDU and the country for decades, one of its outstanding intellects, alert to social change and drawing strength from his faith; she called his six years as general secretary unforgettable. Lammert, for the Bundestag, called him a passionate parliamentarian, valued across party lines and gifted at building bridges, spoke of a friendship of openness and respect, and counted him among the defining CDU figures of the previous 25 years. Volker Kauder, chairman of the Union group, said he argued sharply while respecting other views.

Obituaries set the 1990s campaigns beside the later career. Spiegel's "Ein leidenschaftlicher Streiter" called him a passionate fighter, courteous in disagreement, who disliked being reduced to the 1994 "Rote Socken" campaign. Johannes Leithäuser wrote in the [Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung](/organizations/frankfurter-allgemeine-zeitung) that Hintze, Helmut Kohl's general secretary from 1992 to 1998, had helped set the CDU's course for two decades and was one of Merkel's closest confidants, but that the 1994 campaign earned him a reputation as a conservative polarizer and succeeded only moderately, while four years later it failed and he gave the post to Merkel. Tagesspiegel and Spiegel added partial blame for the 1998 defeat over the "Rote Hände" campaign, and noted that his support for pre-implantation genetic diagnosis and a more liberal assisted-dying law set him against party leaders, much of his group, and the churches.

## Dated facts

_No published facts on this page yet._

## Methodology

https://factrail.ai/methodology

Canonical: https://factrail.ai/people/peter-hintze
