Germany’s Top Court Rejects BSW Bid to Reopen the 2025 Count
Published Factrail

Summary
The Constitutional Court dismissed a challenge to the count that left BSW 9,529 votes short of entering parliament.
Report
Germany’s Federal Constitutional Court announced on November 18 that it had rejected an election complaint brought by four voters, including Sahra Wagenknecht, who challenged the count that kept her BSW party out of parliament. The decision, dated October 20 and released on November 18, leaves the February 23, 2025, Bundestag result intact. The party received 4.981 percent of valid second votes and fell 9,529 votes short of the 5 percent threshold, according to the Bundestag’s account of the ruling.
The complainants wanted the authorities to reopen the count. The dispute concerned Germany’s second vote, which voters cast for a party and which largely determines the distribution of seats. BSW received 2,472,947 valid second votes in the final official count confirmed in March 2025. At that scale, a small percentage-point gap can still require evidence involving thousands of ballots. Finding that an individual vote was misclassified and establishing grounds to reconsider the composition of parliament are distinct tasks.
Why the complaint fell short
The court declared the complaint inadmissible because the voters had failed to substantiate a concrete error capable of affecting the allocation of seats. As Legal Tribune Online reported on November 19, they relied on estimates extrapolated from partial recounts, anomalies in voting patterns and sworn statements from individual voters. The judges found that the submissions fell short of the evidence required to proceed. A pattern can identify where investigators might look, but its national significance depends on how representative the selected districts are and whether errors elsewhere point in the same direction.
Election scrutiny in Germany begins in the Bundestag, with constitutional judicial review available afterward. The decision therefore leaves a second argument alive about whether lawmakers should make the initial decision on challenges to the election that put them in office. CDU legal policy lawmaker Martin Plum proposed starting future reviews directly at the Constitutional Court, according to the November 19 legal press roundup. That would change who hears the first challenge and where challengers have to present their case. The rules on what evidence merits a recount would still matter.
Wagenknecht attacked the ruling, while politicians from the SPD, CDU and the Left welcomed the outcome, according to German coverage summarized by Legal Tribune Online. The parties have different stakes in election review, but the immediate result is common to all of them. The February 2025 count continues to determine who sits in the Bundestag (opens in a new tab).
What was at stake for Merz
The CDU and CSU together won 208 seats and the SPD won 120 in the 630-seat chamber. That gave the coalition headed by Chancellor Friedrich Merz (opens in a new tab) 328 seats, 12 above the 316 required for an absolute majority. A recount alone would have left that arithmetic open. Had a corrected result put BSW over the threshold, including the party in the allocation would have redistributed seats among qualifying parties and could have deprived the coalition of its majority. The exact result would have depended on the corrected totals and the resulting allocation.
Merz and his coalition partners retain the seats on which their government was formed. BSW voters lose the prospect of federal parliamentary representation through this complaint, and the party must build its influence through state politics, public campaigning and the next federal election. A nationwide recount would have put substantial work on local election officials. Voters would have gained a further check on ballot handling, with its value depending on whether the review could resolve the specific allegations at issue.
The remaining issue for democratic resilience (opens in a new tab) is how readily a party or voter can get reliable evidence of a close counting error. A change in who hears complaints could shorten the route to court. Access to polling-station records and clear standards for demonstrating a material discrepancy would determine how effectively challengers can use that route.
Sources
- Federal Constitutional Court, November 18 announcement (opens in a new tab)
- Bundestag, November 18 case summary (opens in a new tab)
- Legal Tribune Online, November 19 (opens in a new tab)
- Tagesschau, November 18 (opens in a new tab)
- Deutschlandfunk, November 18 (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Returning Officer, 2025 final results (opens in a new tab)
Sources & evidence
| Source | Publisher | Type |
|---|---|---|
| bundestag.de/dokumente/textarchiv/2026/kw47-bundesverfassungsgericht-1233738 | — | government |