
404 Media
Expert article
404 Media is an independent technology news website started by four journalists from Motherboard, the technology section of Vice Media. It began publishing on 22 August 2023. The founders were Jason Koebler, Motherboard’s former editor in chief; Emanuel Maiberg and Samantha Cole, two of its editors; and Joseph Cox, one of its writers. The name plays on the HTTP 404 code for a webpage that is no longer available. Cox said the founders chose it because they expected to “reveal worlds people may not even know exist.”
The group left Vice after the company filed for bankruptcy in May 2023. Vice, valued at $5.7 billion in 2017, was bought for $350 million by a consortium led by Fortress Investment Group. Cox said court documents showing six-figure bonuses for top executives in the months before the filing, alongside delayed severance, stalled freelancer payments, and millions of dollars owed to vendors, pushed him to leave. Maiberg said he wanted more control over how a media company spent its money. Each founder contributed $1,000, they worked from home, and Koebler said they did not take venture-capital funding. Nieman Lab reported in February 2024 that the four each owned 25 percent of the company, that the site was profitable, and that they had repaid those startup contributions.
A subscription was priced at $10 a month or $100 a year. Nieman Lab described additional income from advertising, podcast ads, donations, and merchandise, and said paid subscriptions included events such as forums on filing records requests. In January 2024, after the founders found outside sites scraping their articles, rewriting them with text-generation tools, and sometimes ranking above the originals in search results, 404 Media began requiring an email address to read stories and placed older articles behind a paywall. Koebler told Nieman Lab in 2025 that the change “completely changed our business almost literally overnight,” and that traffic fell after the email requirement. In December 2024 he told Business Insider that revenue was around $900,000 a year, almost all from subscriptions, and that about 7,000 people had subscribed. Nieman Lab reported that paid subscriptions stood at about 3,000 by the end of March 2024 and at more than 11,000 by September 2025.
Maiberg described the site as reporting on how technology affects people, including hacking, sex work, niche online communities, and the right to repair. On its first day it published a Cox investigation into people who posed as private investigators to obtain data from credit bureaus. The Electronic Frontier Foundation later cited reporting on hacking, cybersecurity, cybercrime, sex, artificial intelligence, consumer rights, surveillance, privacy, and broader access to the internet when it named 404 Media a 2024 EFF Award winner, alongside Carolina Botero and Connecting Humanity. The awards, previously called the Pioneer Awards, were presented in San Francisco on 12 September 2024. The founders told The New York Times they were following journalist-owned publications such as Defector Media, started by former Deadspin staff, and Hell Gate, a New York City news site. Koebler later said the subscription model suited a small staff breaking stories that were hard to find elsewhere, and that year-long investigations with an uncertain audience were a better fit for nonprofits and large newspapers.
Founding and ownership
Departure from Vice
Vice Media filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in the United States on 15 May 2023, after years of financial difficulty at a company valued at $5.7 billion in 2017. The filing was built around a sale to lenders that included Fortress Investment Group, Soros Fund Management, and Monroe Capital. That group offered a $225 million credit bid for substantially all of Vice’s assets, plus assumption of significant liabilities, while providing more than $20 million to fund operations during the sale. On 23 June 2023 the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York approved an amended agreement at about $350 million, still structured as a credit bid. The sale closed on 31 July. Among the assets named in coverage of the filing was Motherboard, Vice’s science and technology site.
Four Motherboard journalists left during that period and started their own publication. The New York Times identified them as former editor in chief Jason Koebler, editors Emanuel Maiberg and Samantha Cole, and writer Joseph Cox. Nieman Lab later described Maiberg as Motherboard’s former executive editor and Cole and Cox as former staff writers. Cox told the Times that Vice’s recent problems pushed him to leave, especially court disclosures that top executives had been paid six-figure bonuses in the months before the filing, while the company delayed severance for laid-off workers, stalled on reimbursing freelancers, and owed millions of dollars for services. Maiberg said he “wanted to work somewhere where I had more control over how a media company allocates resources.” TheWrap reported that Koebler and Maiberg had left their Motherboard roles at the beginning of August; on the day the new site began publishing, Cox wrote that he had quit Vice.
Company structure
The business was organized as Dark Mode LLC, a California limited liability company filed on 17 July 2023 under document number 202358212311. A compilation of California Secretary of State records lists the entity as active, gives its business type as “journalism media subscriptions,” lists a Los Angeles principal address, and names Maiberg, Jason T. Koebler, Cox, and Samantha L. Cole as managers. A federal complaint filed in 2025 styles the plaintiff as “Dark Mode LLC d/b/a 404 Media” and uses that same Los Angeles address. Nieman Lab reported that the four cofounders each own 25 percent of the company.
Startup capital was $1,000 from each founder, meant to cover initial costs such as hosting and payments. The Times reported that they would work from home rather than rent an office, and that a subscription would cost $10 a month or $100 a year, with salaries deferred until they saw how many people signed up. Koebler said it was “important for us not to take on V.C. investment to start,” setting the site apart from digital publishers financed by venture capital. The founders told the Times they were drawing on journalist-owned sites such as Defector, started by former Deadspin staff, and Hell Gate.
Launch and the name
404 Media began publishing on Tuesday, 22 August 2023. The name plays on the HTTP 404 status code returned when a webpage is no longer available. Cox said, “Since we’re revealing worlds people may not even know exist, we felt it fit.” The first story the Times noted that day was a Cox investigation into people who pose as private investigators in order to obtain data from credit bureaus.
Maiberg said the site would start with the four of them and stick to subjects they already knew, including hacking, sex work, niche online communities, and right to repair. He called it “a website by humans for humans about technology,” concerned with effects on “real people in the real world” rather than the technology business. Koebler said refusing outside capital was meant to show from the outset that the reporting was “worth paying for and worth supporting.” Cole’s stated hope was narrower: if the project worked, it would show that a newsroom of this kind “can work in a way that doesn’t grind people down.”
Editorial scope and methods
Beats and audience
At launch, the founders told The New York Times that 404 Media would cover subjects they had reported at Vice’s Motherboard—hacking, sex work, niche online communities, and the right to repair—rather than the business of technology. Emanuel Maiberg called it “a website by humans for humans about technology,” concerned with “how it impacts real people in the real world.” Jason Koebler later told Nieman Journalism Lab that the newsroom looks for communities and reports what they care about, are excited by, or are angry about, aiming for an account those readers would recognize as accurate without writing only for them.
Surveillance, cybersecurity, artificial intelligence, and consumer technology sit in that frame. The Verge reported a 404 Media story drawn from a leaked Samsung contract that required independent repair shops, in exchange for genuine parts, to send Samsung a customer’s name, contact details, device identifiers, complaint, and repair information, and to strip aftermarket parts from devices. Early pieces Nieman Lab cited included New Jersey’s use of COVID-19 relief money to buy banned surveillance cameras and Amazon Web Services’ shutdown of the Wickr app. The Lab later described an eight-month investigation by Samantha Cole into large language models and child sexual abuse material.
Records requests, leaks, and testing
Public-records reporting is routine, and the newsroom also teaches it. Paid subscriptions include “FOIA forums,” live sessions in which staff show participants how to file requests; more than 40 people attended the first. Maiberg said stories grounded in public documents “will always be free because it’s based on public documents that everyone has a right to access,” often with a note asking readers to subscribe or donate.
In an October 2025 discussion hosted by the Freedom of the Press Foundation, Joseph Cox said the site does not want to “get in the way” of readers seeing a government document obtained through the Freedom of Information Act or a lawsuit. He said leaving that reporting and the underlying records outside the paywall—as with coverage of Flock Safety license-plate readers—had also led sources to contact reporters on Signal.
Leaked material is used when reporters say they can check it. The Verge’s Sean Hollister wrote that 404 Media said it had verified a leaked Samsung repair contract and that he had independently seen a copy; Samsung had not confirmed or denied the document when he published. Hands-on access is part of the same practice. A Condé Nast release, republished by Editor & Publisher, said the first story co-published with Wired followed Cox into forums where “traffers” hired others to spread infostealer malware. The founders have also said subscriber money covers direct tests, including trying an AI image service and then reporting on it, and sending a reporter to the DEF CON hacking conference.
Formats and partnerships
The site publishes long investigations and shorter, more voice-driven posts. Cole’s essay on freezing her eggs, which she described to Nieman Lab as the most personal thing she had written there, is one of the shorter pieces: a first-person account of how technology shapes a medical decision.
Distribution runs through the site, email, and a weekly podcast. Apple Podcasts lists The 404 Media Podcast as a show in which Cox, Cole, Maiberg, and Koebler discuss that week’s articles; the listing says subscribers get an ad-free feed and bonus episodes. Nieman Lab reported podcast advertising as a revenue line and said the newsroom was starting to adapt some features as podcasts or documentaries. Koebler told the Lab that TikTok and Instagram mattered, but that reporting would come first if time ran short. The Times reported at launch that a newsletter was planned alongside the podcast. A year in, the founders wrote that they were already sending different newsletters to different parts of the audience through the week. By the second anniversary they had added The Abstract, a Saturday science newsletter by Becky Ferreira, meant as a change of tone from the site’s usual investigations.
Some reporting is published with other outlets. Nieman Lab described a partnership with Court Watch in which Seamus Hughes shares documents, 404 Media writes the story with him or separately, and both publications can run it. On November 9, 2023, The Capitol Forum ran a Labcorp working-conditions investigation with the note “This piece is published in collaboration with 404 Media.” In November 2024, Editor & Publisher carried Condé Nast’s announcement that Wired would co-publish two exclusive 404 Media articles a month, on hacking, cybersecurity, cybercrime, AI, consumer rights, surveillance, privacy, and related subjects, with later room for joint investigations, events, or special projects. The first piece, published that day, was Cox’s “Inside the Massive Crime Industry That is Hacking Billion Dollar Companies.” Wired global editorial director Katie Drummond said the reporting fit Wired’s priorities; the 404 Media team said some of its investigations would run beside Wired’s own work.
Business model
Revenue and subscriptions
404 Media launched on August 22, 2023, with subscriptions at $10 a month or $100 a year, The New York Times reported. The four cofounders, former Motherboard journalists at Vice Media, each put in $1,000, took no venture capital, and planned to set salaries only after seeing early sign-ups. Jason Koebler later told Business Insider that about 600 people subscribed in the first days—enough to show an audience, he said, but not enough to know the site would last—and that further subscribers tended to arrive with major stories.
By February 2024 he told Nieman Lab the company was profitable and that the founders had been repaid, without giving revenue totals. The lab listed advertising, podcast advertising, donations, merchandise, and paid subscriptions, which it said started at $100 a year and included forums on filing Freedom of Information Act requests; more than 40 people attended the first. Direct sponsorships were working, he said, alongside smaller lines such as merchandise and an Apple News switch-on he guessed might bring $20 to $100 a month. Feature-to-podcast and documentary work was still early. Emanuel Maiberg said viral news often converted few readers, while investigations converted a higher share of a smaller audience.
Advertising was a chosen stream. Marketing Brew reported in December 2023 that, through BuySellAds, the site had run programmatic ads since mid-October—a “very small portion” of revenue, Koebler said—and direct deals, on which BuySellAds took a cut, with Codeword and DeleteMe. He preferred brands that opted in over random programmatic placement. The article noted that Defector Media had drawn about 95 percent of first-year revenue from subscribers and had largely dropped site and newsletter ads. Koebler said 404 Media’s coverage of sex, surveillance, and artificial-intelligence material that could be categorized as child sexual abuse imagery created brand-safety hurdles, but that advertising could back reporting “in a way that is not gross and in a way that doesn’t influence the journalism.”
The published subscriber and revenue totals are the founders’ figures, not audited filings. In December 2024 he told Business Insider that about 7,000 people had subscribed and that revenue was around $900,000 a year, almost entirely from subscriptions. Peter Kafka wrote that the model would not work for every kind of journalism; Koebler called the four jobs “a tiny, tiny drop in the bucket.” Nieman Lab in April 2025 quoted the company saying growth had slowed and might level off or shrink if the economy worsened, while thousands of subscribers still supplied most revenue, with advertising and merchandise among the rest. At a September 2025 panel he said paid subscriptions were about 3,000 at the end of March 2024 and more than 11,000 by the time of the panel, helped by a free email list.
Operating costs and compensation
The Times reported that the founders would work from home, skipping office rent, and needed little more at first than hosting, a content-management system, and payment processing. Nieman Lab added that they paid Ghost for hosting, bought litigation insurance, made their own story art, used a free Slack channel, and did not plan to take an office. Koebler shipped merchandise from his garage in Los Angeles; the reporters modeled it.
Pay was revisited against cash on hand. Each month the four met and set what they could pay themselves; Nieman Lab reported that the sum changed but that each person received the same amount. By April 2024 Koebler told the Columbia Journalism Review he had stopped spending down savings each month and could cover rent, while the group still reviewed revenue before deciding outlays, including salaries. In December 2024 he agreed that, after technology and legal costs, the revenue he described supported what Business Insider called “grown-up journalism salaries,” and said hiring was becoming possible. The four remained equal 25 percent owners. Those figures describe this newsroom’s reported results, not a general test of whether the structure can fund larger staffs or slower investigations.
Access controls and AI scraping
Until January 2024, Nieman Lab reported, most stories were free. The founders then required an email address—explained in a January 26 article—and began placing older stories behind a paywall. Maiberg said Google News was degrading and that automated mills were rewriting their stories and outranking the originals. He said records-request reporting would stay free because it rests on public documents, usually with a subscribe-or-donate note, while other pieces would be open at publication and limited later.
Koebler later tied the shift to one case. An eight-month investigation by Samantha Cole, on large language models taking in child sexual abuse material, was passed through an AI spinner by Nation World News, which changed quotations and facts, kept her byline, and appeared on Google News when the original did not. Similar copies followed. He said distribution on platforms the company did not control would not sustain the jobs, and that requiring email “completely changed our business almost literally overnight.” He had expected complaints—he disliked paywalls and logins—and some social-media users did object, while other readers shared the site’s explanation. Traffic dropped as people left at the prompt. The staff later set the wall deeper in articles, which he said cost some sign-ups but reached more readers, and gave subscribers a full-text RSS feed as a hedge if tools such as Gmail summarized newsletters and cut opens. He said that had started but was not yet an “apocalypse.”
Staff and governance
Founders
404 Media is run by four journalists who previously worked at Vice Media’s technology site, Motherboard, and who each own 25 percent of the company. Jason Koebler had been Motherboard’s editor in chief. Emanuel Maiberg and Samantha Cole—also referred to as Sam Cole—were editors, and Joseph Cox was a writer.
The New York Times reported that the four intended to cover subjects they already knew, including hacking, sex work, niche online communities, and the right to repair. Maiberg, identified by Nieman Lab as Motherboard’s former executive editor, said the site would deal with how technology affects people rather than with the technology business.
Cole was a Motherboard senior editor by late 2022. Mother Jones discussed her book How Sex Changed the Internet and the Internet Changed Sex, which treats sex, consent, and deepfakes—images that place one person’s face on another’s body—as part of internet history. On 404 Media’s first day, Cox published an investigation of people who posed as private investigators to obtain credit-bureau data. Kirkus Reviews, reviewing his 2024 book Dark Wire, called him an investigative journalist and a 404 Media co-founder and described the book’s account of criminals using supposedly secure phones. Koebler has kept reporting as well as editing; for 404 Media he wrote from Las Vegas about casino operations during a ransomware attack on MGM Resorts.
Fellows, contributors, and audio
In April 2024 the company named Jules Roscoe its first fellow. Roscoe, referred to with they/them pronouns in the announcement, had interned at Motherboard in 2022 as a labor reporter and social-video producer. The paid post, set to run through June 2024, covered labor and automation—including how artificial intelligence was changing work—and distribution of stories on social platforms. Columbia Journalism Review described Roscoe, a Motherboard alumnus, as the outlet’s first new writer.
Other journalists have written for the site without joining the ownership group. In September 2024 Nieman Lab’s reading roundup highlighted a 404 Media report by Matthew Gault on a Hawaii newspaper’s use of AI-generated newscasters.
The four co-founders host The 404 Media Podcast, a weekly podcast in which they discuss that week’s reporting. Apple Podcasts carries an ad-free version and bonus episodes for paying subscribers. Early in 2024, Nieman Lab reported that podcast advertising was already a revenue stream and that the founders were starting to adapt some features for podcasts and documentaries.
Decision-making
The four owners do not settle questions by majority vote. Koebler told Business Insider in December 2024 that any one of them can veto a proposal: if one person objects, the group does not proceed. He said management had been easier than expected, but that hiring would require decisions about supervising new employees and about whether they would receive ownership.
Pay is equal and changes with revenue. The four meet virtually each month, decide what the company can pay them, and give each person the same amount. Columbia Journalism Review described that monthly review as covering earnings and spending, including salaries. By December 2024, Koebler confirmed that the four were paying themselves what the Business Insider interviewer called “grown-up journalism salaries,” and said he thought they could add employees.
Investigations and reported impact
Surveillance, data brokers, and policing
In 2025, reporting on Flock Safety automatic license-plate recognition cameras described local searches tied to immigration enforcement and federal access to private plate-reader networks. On May 27, Jason Koebler and Joseph Cox wrote that logs from a public-records request to police in Danville, Illinois, showed more than 4,000 nationwide or statewide lookups by local and state agencies whose reason fields cited immigration or U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The outlet described that as side-door access without a Flock contract, and said the cameras were in more than 5,000 communities. In November, the Associated Press reported that the U.S. Border Patrol had used data from private vendors including Flock.
The AP said Border Patrol or U.S. Customs and Border Protection had used Rekor, Vigilant Solutions, and Flock, and that Flock alone had for a time covered at least 1,600 readers in 22 states, including lookups for CBP in California and Illinois. A Flock spokesperson said the company had “for now” paused pilots with CBP and Homeland Security Investigations, and that no agency then listed Border Patrol as a Flock recipient.
An earlier story concerned transit payments. On August 30, 2023, The Verge described a 404 Media investigation of OMNY, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority system for New York City subway and bus fares: a public “trip history” page showed seven days of entries, with time and station, to anyone with a rider’s card number and expiration date. The MTA said it stored a token rather than the full card number, recorded entries rather than exits, and would consider advice from safety experts. The New York Daily News called 404 Media the first to report the feature and quoted New York Civil Liberties Union strategist Daniel Schwarz, who said the records “would really be a gold mine for stalkers or anyone with malicious intent.”
Commercial phone location was the subject of reporting on October 23, 2024. KrebsOnSecurity was one of five outlets, with 404 Media, Haaretz, NOTUS, and The New York Times, invited to watch recordings of Babel Street’s Locate X, which plots mobile-advertising identifiers inside a user-drawn map boundary. Atlas Data Privacy said a salesperson offered a private investigator a trial after a mention of possible government work, calling that “good enough” and saying “they don’t actually check.” Recordings showed devices at an abortion clinic, a mosque, and a juror lot. In a statement shared with those outlets, Senator Ron Wyden said data brokers were “selling Americans’ deepest secrets and exposing them to serious harm, all for a few bucks.”
Airline ticket records were sold through a different broker. The Airlines Reporting Corporation, an airline-owned firm that settles tickets between carriers and travel agencies, says its Travel Intelligence Program began shortly after the September 11 attacks and gave U.S. intelligence and law-enforcement agencies basic itineraries from agency-booked tickets, searchable by name or form of payment, without dates of birth, addresses, or passport numbers.
Artificial intelligence and nonconsensual imagery
In April 2024, 404 Media reported Instagram advertisements for apps promoted as tools to create nonconsensual nude images. The Verge reported that Apple then removed three of the apps from the App Store, and that Google removed similar titles from Google Play. Quoting 404 Media, The Verge wrote that Apple took the listings down only after it was given links to the apps and ads, “indicating the company was not able to find the apps that violated its policy itself.”
On November 25, 2024, Representatives Debbie Dingell and August Pfluger, with other members of Congress, wrote to Apple chief executive Tim Cook about deepfake pornography. The letter said Apple had removed three deepfake apps “after an independent report by 404 Media provided links to the apps and their related ads,” and that it was “concerning that Apple was not able to identify the apps on their own” despite App Store review. The members asked how the company detected such material, how quickly violating apps were removed, and what remedy a person had if an image was used, and they cited the proposed TAKE IT DOWN Act.
Platforms, consumer technology, and cybercrime
On November 4, 2024, Wired published Cox’s “Inside the Massive Crime Industry That’s Hacking Billion-Dollar Companies,” labeled as copublished with 404 Media. The article described infostealer malware, often bundled with pirated software, that copies passwords and browser cookies and feeds a market of developers, people paid to spread the programs, and buyers who use the stolen logins. Cox reported that a person using the name Dark X claimed to have taken personal data of 350 million Hot Topic customers with a developer’s Snowflake password from an infostealer log. The article argued that intrusions at AT&T, Ticketmaster, Santander, Neiman Marcus, and Electronic Arts were likewise tied to infostealer-stolen credentials rather than isolated break-ins.
Responses by companies and officials
The day after the OMNY story, the MTA told The Verge it had disabled the unauthenticated trip-history page. Spokesman Eugene Resnick said the feature was meant to show paid and free tap-and-go history without an account, and that the agency turned it off “while we evaluate other ways to serve these customers.”
On August 25, 2025, Illinois Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias said an audit found CBP had reached Illinois plate data, calling it “a clear violation” of a 2023 law limiting sharing for investigations of out-of-state abortions or undocumented immigrants. Flock chief executive Garrett Langley said pilots with CBP and Homeland Security Investigations were aimed at trafficking and fentanyl, that the company had “communicated poorly,” and that federal users lacked separate permissions. The Associated Press reported that Flock paused those pilots, limited federal users to one-to-one sharing, and—after a Texas sheriff sought a missing woman through data that included Mount Prospect, Illinois, whose family feared for her after a self-administered abortion—had since late June blocked searches using “abortion,” “immigration,” or “ICE.” Senator Ed Markey later called the Border Patrol program an “invasive surveillance network” that posed “a serious threat to individuals’ privacy and civil liberties.”
On December 3, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission announced a proposed order against Gravy Analytics and its subsidiary Venntel. The complaint said they took location data from other suppliers, claimed more than 17 billion signals a day from about a billion phones, and sold non-anonymized data that could track visits to medical facilities and places of worship and infer health, politics, or religion, without verified consent. The proposed order would bar sensitive-location sales except for limited national-security or law-enforcement uses, require deletion or customer notice, and require supplier-consent checks. The Commission voted 5–0 and called it the agency’s fifth such case against data aggregators. The announcement did not say any news report prompted the case.
ARC says it ended the travel program in 2025 because it no longer fit a focus on airlines’ and agencies’ commercial work, that remaining products no longer contain individually identifiable personal information, and that personal data now goes to law enforcement only with a subpoena or court order. A letter from chief executive Lauri Reishus, quoted by the travel site One Mile at a Time in an account of a 404 Media report on lawmakers’ questions, said government customers were told on November 12, 2025, that the program was “sunsetting this year.” Wyden said it “shouldn’t have taken pressure from Congress” to stop the sales.
Legal disputes
Dark Mode LLC, the California company that publishes 404 Media, has sued federal agencies for records and been subpoenaed for its own reporting. A February 2024 Nieman Journalism Lab profile reported that the newsroom had arranged litigation insurance.
Public-records litigation
On September 22, 2025, Dark Mode sued Immigration and Customs Enforcement under the Freedom of Information Act in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, No. 1:25-cv-03357, before Judge Amit Mehta. The complaint alleged a constructive denial of an October 22, 2024 request for invoices, contracts, other procurement records, and statements of work for Award ID 70CTD024P00000012, described there as a one-year, $2 million no-bid contract with Paragon Solutions (US), Inc., a subsidiary of Paragon Solutions, which the complaint said was known for Graphite spyware. Dark Mode sought a declaration that the records were public, an order for unredacted release, and fees. ICE answered on December 30, 2025, admitting it is an agency covered by the statute and denying any violation or any right to relief.
In a March 16, 2026 joint report, ICE said it had processed 673 potentially responsive pages and sent them to the contractor, but that a lapse in appropriations had furloughed its FOIA staff. Dark Mode opposed a stay. ICE reported an interim release of about 77 pages on May 26, 2026. Dark Mode said 295 pages were duplicates and four were nonresponsive, leaving 374, and objected to another submitter review. The final release was reported as July 2, 2026. On August 28, Dark Mode narrowed the dispute to eight records totaling 102 pages and challenged withholdings under Exemptions 4, 5, and 7(E); ICE said it would not withdraw the Exemption 4 claims and was still reviewing the others. An October 29, 2026 order granted a consented extension and set ICE’s summary-judgment motion for November 13, 2026, with Dark Mode’s opposition and cross-motion due December 11.
On September 24, 2025, the Freedom of the Press Foundation and Dark Mode sued the Department of Homeland Security and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, No. 1:25-cv-03387, before Judge Carl J. Nichols. Each had requested, on July 17, 2025, an agreement the complaint said would let the Medicaid agency share personal data on nearly 80 million Medicaid patients with ICE. The complaint alleged that neither defendant had made a timely determination and sought unredacted disclosure and fees. On January 13, 2026, the agencies said the plaintiffs had the record and had opened talks that included fees, and the court stayed the deadline to answer. On July 10, 2026, the parties stipulated to dismissal with prejudice under a settlement. The stipulation does not state any fee amount.
Subpoenas and source protection
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton subpoenaed 404 Media on October 22, 2024, in the state’s Midland County case against Google, the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker reported after reviewing the filings. The demand sought communications and documents tied to a June 2024 article by Joseph Cox, including unpublished drafts and a copy of an internal Google database the article described as tracking six years of potential privacy and security issues. Paxton’s 2022 suit alleged that Google captured biometric data of Texas users without consent. Dark Mode objected on December 6, 2024. The outlet quoted counsel calling the subpoena oppressive and asserting absolute protection under California’s shield law, with unpublished information also protected by the First Amendment and article I, section 2(a) of the California Constitution. The Tracker, which reviewed that filing, said the objection also invoked Texas law and quoted the founders’ statement that the subpoena sought to turn the newsroom into “an arm of law enforcement.” The outlet’s attorney told the Tracker that prosecutors withdrew the subpoena after the objection; the Tracker dated the withdrawal December 10, 2024.
Reception and awards
Press coverage
On August 22, 2023, the day 404 Media began publishing, Katie Robertson of The New York Times profiled the founders among journalist-run sites, naming Defector, Hell Gate, Discourse Blog, and Racket. Emanuel Maiberg called it “very much a website by humans for humans about technology,” and Joseph Cox said the HTTP 404 name fit a site “revealing worlds people may not even know exist.”
In February 2024, Hanaa' Tameez of Nieman Journalism Lab, a project of the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard University, reported the outlet profitable after six months and described an email gate adopted after automated tools republished paraphrased versions of its stories. Maiberg told her that readers who paid after a smaller investigation mattered more than unread work at Vice Media, and Samantha Cole said answering to readers and colleagues rather than to investors “feels like the future.”
That April, Justin R. Silverman in the Columbia Journalism Review described Jason Koebler’s report from ransomware-disrupted Las Vegas casinos, which other outlets picked up, and Koebler’s “sense of agency” in owning the articles. Margot Susca of American University cautioned that reporters are not automatically managers, while saying she would bet on worker-owned sites over private-equity-owned ones. Silverman wrote that it was still too early to know whether 404 Media would last.
In December 2024, Peter Kafka of Business Insider, drawing on his Channels podcast, quoted Koebler on a rule that any founder can veto a decision. Koebler said investigations lasting many months were better left to nonprofits and large newspapers, and that subscriptions depended on stories readers could not find elsewhere.
Awards
On July 25, 2024, the Electronic Frontier Foundation named 404 Media for its annual EFF Awards, formerly the Pioneer Awards, with Carolina Botero, honored for digital-rights work in Latin America, and Connecting Humanity, a Cairo project sending eSIMs to restore internet access in Gaza. The prizes were presented on September 12, 2024, at the Golden Gate Club in San Francisco’s Presidio.
The citation for “Fearless Journalism” credited “incisive investigative reports, deep-dive features, blogs, and scoops” on hacking, cybercrime, sex, artificial intelligence, consumer rights, surveillance, privacy, and internet access. EFF pointed to a New York subway tracking feature that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority then disabled, an AI tool for nonconsensual pornography whose operator later limited abuse, and inaccurate AI-generated books that Amazon removed. Executive director Cindy Cohn said the winners were “ensuring technology advances us all.” Investigations director Dave Maass presented the award, and Koebler accepted on video, saying readers wanted journalism “written by humans for other humans.” EFF’s account of the night also tied the reporting to Apple’s ban on apps for nonconsensual sexual imagery.
Criticism
In December 2024, on Hacker News, the forum run by Y Combinator, moderator dang wrote that 404media.co was “banned on HN because its articles are behind a signup wall.” Commenters asked why paid-paywall outlets were treated differently; others answered that those outlets stay allowed when a public bypass works. The exchange is a moderation rule and an audience reaction, not a finding about accuracy.
Media Bias/Fact Check lists 404 Media as “Left-Center” (−3.4) and “Mostly Factual” (2.1), with “High Credibility” and no failed fact checks, in an entry updated on September 16, 2025. It cited story selection that “slightly favors the left” and “occasional sensational and clickbait-type” headlines. The rater’s method uses at least ten headlines and five stories and states that bias scoring “necessarily involves human judgment” and that “no universally accepted scientific formula exists.” In 2018 the Poynter Institute called that project widely cited “despite the fact that its method is in no way scientific,” so the label is one rater’s judgment, not a consensus of press critics.
Worker-owned digital journalism
Comparable publications
In August 2023, The New York Times placed 404 Media in a recent group of small sites owned and run by their journalists, after venture-backed digital companies had stumbled and technology firms had taken most advertising revenue. It named four earlier examples: Defector, from former Deadspin staff; Hell Gate, started by journalists frustrated with New York City news organizations; Discourse Blog, begun in 2020 by journalists from the politics site Splinter after G/O Media shut it down; and Racket, a Twin Cities outlet from former editors of City Pages.
The legal forms were not identical. Deadspin’s staff left in the fall of 2019 after private-equity-owned G/O Media told the site to “stick to sports.” They announced Defector on July 28, 2020, and launched it on September 10 as a worker-owned cooperative whose original 19 cofounders split the equity evenly, about 5 percent each. Venture-capital offers dried up in the pandemic, and the site opened without outside investors. Hell Gate began publishing in May 2022. Founding worker-owners Christopher Robbins, Max Rivlin-Nadler, Nick Pinto, and Sydney Pereira had worked at Gothamist; Esther Wang had been at Jezebel when G/O Media took over in 2019. The site cited Defector, Discourse Blog, and Racket as models and began with grants from the Harnisch Foundation and the Vital Projects Fund as well as a later paywall. Splinter had closed in October 2019, with its owner citing trouble building an audience. Racket, scheduled to launch on August 18, 2021, was a mostly member-supported site owned by four former City Pages editors—Jessica Armbruster, Jay Boller, Keith Harris, and Em Cassel—after Star Tribune Media closed City Pages in October 2020 as economically unviable. In February 2026 Nieman Lab counted at least 18 U.S. digital news cooperatives launched in five years and treated Defector’s scale as unusual.
Sustainability arguments
The argument for the model is low overhead, reader revenue, and distance from investors. The Times reported that several of the new publications needed little beyond hosting, a content system, and a way to take payments, with founders working from home. Jason Koebler told Nieman Lab that 404 Media was meant to drop consultants, surplus software, and offices and spend on reporting. Defector’s first-year figures, as reported by Nieman Lab, were more than 40,000 paying subscribers, $3.2 million in revenue—about 95 percent from subscriptions—and 23 full-time employees. By year five Nieman Lab reported $4.2 million in revenue and about $100,000 in profit, including $3.8 million from subscriptions in 2024–25, with the rest from podcast advertising, events, merchandise, sponsorships, and streaming. In 2024 the Columbia Journalism Review wrote that reports posted by Defector, Racket, and Hell Gate showed subscription and advertising income close to operating costs, while calling longer-term survival unclear. Margot Susca, an American University professor who has studied private equity in newsrooms, told CJR that strong reporters are not automatically managers, but that she was cautiously optimistic and would bet on a worker-owned site over a private-equity-owned one.
Constraints of the model
The sites are small, tied to a beat with a defined audience—sports and culture, one city, Twin Cities news and arts, or technology—and they depend on readers who will pay. In a December 2024 Business Insider interview, Peter Kafka wrote that the self-funded model “isn’t going to work for everyone and everything.” Koebler said it had created four jobs at 404 Media and a few dozen more elsewhere, still “a tiny, tiny drop in the bucket,” and that spending three, six, or twelve months on one investigation was “a model we’re not even trying to do,” better suited to nonprofits and to papers such as the Times and The Washington Post. Worker-owners also absorb business labor. Hell Gate’s Nick Pinto told Nieman Lab that horizontal governance means meetings that replace reporting, and Aftermath’s Riley MacLeod said the hope of large investigations collides with jobs other people used to do. Defector’s Jasper Wang has written that worker ownership “is not a silver bullet for saving journalism,” and the company’s fifth-year report called its launch conditions “Easy Mode” compared with the later market. That market had already contracted. Pew Research Center estimates put U.S. newspaper advertising at about $12.9 billion in 2019 and $9.6 billion in 2020, and City Pages closed after its owner said the pandemic had made the ad-supported weekly unviable.
No description, affiliated people, facts, or drivers are mapped for this organization yet.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Related people
Related organizations
Facts mentioned
Linked pages by kind
Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.
- People2
- Organizations12+
- Facts1