
Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission
The Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) is the federal body that regulates nuclear energy and nuclear substances in Canada.
Expert article
The Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) is the federal body that regulates nuclear energy and nuclear substances in Canada. The Parliament of Canada created it in the Nuclear Safety and Control Act (S.C. 1997, c. 9), which received royal assent on 20 March 1997, came into force on 31 May 2000, and replaced the Atomic Energy Control Board. That board had been established when the Atomic Energy Control Act was proclaimed on 12 October 1946, with a mandate to control and supervise the development, application and use of atomic energy and to participate in international controls. Under the 1946 regime the board oversaw early research reactors at Chalk River Laboratories and the Nuclear Power Demonstration reactor at Rolphton, Ontario, the prototype for the CANDU power reactor.
The 1997 Act's stated purpose is to limit, to a reasonable level and consistently with Canada's international obligations, risks to national security, the health and safety of persons and the environment, and to implement international controls, including the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons and nuclear explosive devices. Section 9 gives the Commission the objects of regulating so as to prevent unreasonable risk to the environment, health and safety, and national security; of achieving conformity with measures of control and international obligations; and of disseminating objective scientific, technical and regulatory information to the public. Except under a licence, the Act prohibits possession, transfer, import, export, use or abandonment of a nuclear substance, prescribed equipment or prescribed information; mining, production, processing, transport, storage and disposal of a nuclear substance; and preparing a site for, constructing, operating, modifying, decommissioning or abandoning a nuclear facility. In its 2024–25 departmental results report the CNSC stated that the Commission had issued Ontario Power Generation a nuclear power reactor construction licence for a General Electric Hitachi BWRX-300 small modular reactor at the Darlington New Nuclear Project, which the report described as the first licence to construct a reactor in Canada in more than 50 years.
The Act constitutes the Commission as a body corporate and agent of the Crown, with not more than seven permanent members appointed by the Governor in Council during good behaviour for terms of up to five years and removable for cause. The president is the full-time member and chief executive officer. Pierre Tremblay holds that office. The CNSC describes the Commission as an independent tribunal, separate from the staff who support it, and says it reports to Parliament through the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources; the Act itself defines the responsible minister as the Minister of Natural Resources or another designated member of the Privy Council. The Governor in Council may issue directives of general application on broad policy matters respecting the Commission's objects, and those directives bind the Commission. Decisions of designated officers on licences and orders may be appealed to the Commission, which may also redetermine its own decisions. Headquarters are at 280 Slater Street, Ottawa. In 2024–25 the CNSC reported actual spending of $202,442,088 and 1,015 full-time-equivalent staff, including internal services.
In 1972 Canada signed a comprehensive safeguards agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency, and the CNSC's 2024–25 results report recorded that the Agency's broader safeguards conclusion for Canada was met and that the Commission processed 1,051 import and export licences. The same report said a June 2024 IAEA Integrated Regulatory Review Service follow-up found Canada's nuclear and radiation safety framework strong and closed a number of findings from the 2019 mission. Regulatory decisions have also been politically and legally contested. In January 2008 Natural Resources Minister Gary Lunn removed president Linda Keen, telling a parliamentary committee that she had lost the government's confidence over the shutdown of the National Research Universal reactor at Chalk River, operated by Atomic Energy of Canada Limited, which had interrupted the supply of medical isotopes. In 2026 the Federal Court of Appeal, in Canadian Nuclear Laboratories Ltd. v. Kebaowek First Nation, allowed the proponent's appeal arising from the Commission's approval of a near-surface disposal facility for low-level radioactive waste at Chalk River: the court held that the Commission had met the existing duty to consult and that the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act did not impose further obligations on the Commission.
History
Atomic Energy Control Board
On 12 October 1946 the Government of Canada proclaimed the Atomic Energy Control Act and established the Atomic Energy Control Board. The Act charged the Board with “control and supervision of the development, application and use of atomic energy” and with enabling Canada to participate in measures of international control, so development and control sat in one statute.
The first Canadian reactor, ZEEP, had already gone critical in September 1945 at Chalk River Laboratories, then a National Research Council Canada project; the much larger NRX reactor started there in July 1947 under the Board, and in 1952 the Crown corporation Atomic Energy of Canada Limited took over Chalk River to pursue peaceful research. On 12 December 1952, during a low-power experiment, a power surge melted fuel and heavily damaged the NRX core; a later Chalk River review recorded that no one was injured. The higher-power National Research Universal reactor at the same site reached criticality in 1957.
Power licensing followed. The Nuclear Power Demonstration reactor at Rolphton, Ontario, a prototype of the CANDU reactor built with the province’s hydro-electric utility, operated from 1962 to 1987, and in 1966 the Board issued an interim operating licence for Douglas Point, the first commercial-scale CANDU station. Canada’s safeguards agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency in connection with the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons entered into force on 21 February 1972.
Passage of the Nuclear Safety and Control Act
By the 1990s the 1946 Act no longer matched an industry of power reactors, uranium production, isotopes and waste. The Auditor General of Canada reported in 1994 that the Act “requires updating to reflect current circumstances,” that its primary focus was security of nuclear materials rather than health and safety, and that it lacked clear authority for national health, safety, security and environmental standards, financial guarantees for decommissioning and disposal, adequate remedial powers where no licence existed, and inspector powers and penalties in line with other environmental laws. The audit also found that legislation alone would not fix weaknesses in the Board’s management of compliance and enforcement.
Anne McLellan, then Minister of Natural Resources, tabled Bill C-23 on 21 March 1996. The Parliament of Canada passed the Nuclear Safety and Control Act, which received royal assent on 20 March 1997 and, by order in council under section 127, came into force on 31 May 2000. The Act’s purpose is to limit, to a reasonable level and consistently with Canada’s international obligations, risks to national security, health, safety and the environment, and to implement agreed controls, including non-proliferation of nuclear weapons and other nuclear explosive devices. The Commission’s objects are confined to regulation aimed at preventing unreasonable risk, conformity with those obligations, and dissemination of objective scientific and regulatory information, rather than promotion of nuclear development. Research and utilization stayed with the responsible minister under the retitled Nuclear Energy Act, from which the old Board and its regulatory provisions were repealed.
The Commission since 2000
Licences did not lapse: one in force under the Atomic Energy Control Act was deemed a licence under the new Act for the rest of its term. The Board had 402 staff at 31 March 2000; a year later the Commission had 451, with 392 at headquarters, 24 in regional offices and 35 at power-reactor sites. Agnes J. Bishop was the outgoing president; Linda J. Keen was appointed president and chief executive officer effective January 2001. Michael Binder was appointed in January 2008 and reappointed effective May 2013. Rumina Velshi was appointed in 2018. Pierre Tremblay took up the office on 12 August 2024.
After the attacks of 11 September 2001 the Commission ordered major facilities to raise security, including with armed guards, and the Nuclear Security Regulations were amended in 2006. A 2010 amendment authorized a participant funding program for proceedings under the Act. In 2012, S.C. 2012, c. 19 added an administrative monetary penalty regime. Amendments passed in 2023, still not in force in the consolidation current to 30 September 2026, would place nuclear security officers and high-security sites in the Act. Full-time equivalents, including internal services, stood at 1,015 in 2024–25. The International Atomic Energy Agency held an Integrated Regulatory Review Service mission in Canada from 3 to 13 September 2019 and a follow-up from 4 to 10 June 2024.
Legal framework
Nuclear Safety and Control Act
The Nuclear Safety and Control Act (S.C. 1997, c. 9) is current to 30 September 2026 and last amended on 1 January 2017. Section 3 limits risks to security, health, safety and the environment to a reasonable level consistent with Canada’s international obligations, and provides for agreed controls, including non-proliferation. Section 9’s objects are preventing unreasonable risk to health, safety, security and the environment, meeting those obligations, and disseminating objective information.
The Act binds the Crown in right of Canada or a province, subject to orders under section 5. The Governor in Council may exclude the Department of National Defence or the Canadian Forces. It does not apply to an invited foreign nuclear-powered or nuclear-capable naval vessel.
Except under a licence, section 26 prohibits possession, the fuel cycle, dosimetry and siting through abandonment of a nuclear facility. Section 24 allows classes of licences and their issue, renewal, suspension, amendment, revocation, replacement or transfer only if, in the Commission’s opinion, the applicant or transferee is qualified and will make adequate provision for the environment, health and safety, national security and international obligations. Conditions may include a financial guarantee. With Governor-in-Council approval, section 44 authorizes regulations and the incorporation by reference of a standard under paragraph 44(1)(o). Administrative monetary penalties, added by S.C. 2012, c. 19, are capped at $25,000 for an individual and $100,000 otherwise.
A designated officer may be authorized to license an established class. Inspectors may make protective orders, which the Commission must confirm, amend, revoke or replace. An officer’s licensing decision may be appealed to, or redetermined by, the Commission. There is no appeal to the Minister of Natural Resources or another designated minister. Section 19 directives are general policy; they bind the Commission and must be published in the Canada Gazette and tabled. Licensing decisions are reviewable in the Federal Court under the Federal Courts Act, and a penalty determination is final except for that review.
Regulations and regulatory documents
Regulations under the Act include the General Nuclear Safety and Control Regulations (SOR/2000-202), Radiation Protection Regulations (SOR/2000-203), Class I Nuclear Facilities Regulations (SOR/2000-204), Uranium Mines and Mills Regulations (SOR/2000-206), Nuclear Substances and Radiation Devices Regulations (SOR/2000-207), Packaging and Transport of Nuclear Substances Regulations, 2015 (SOR/2015-145), Nuclear Security Regulations (SOR/2025-219) and Administrative Monetary Penalties Regulations (Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission) (SOR/2013-139). The 2015 transport regulations incorporate International Atomic Energy Agency rules as amended from time to time and require compliance with the Transportation of Dangerous Goods Regulations. SOR/2025-219, in force on 30 October 2025, repealed SOR/2000-209, with a two-year transition.
Regulatory documents are not regulations. They mix “shall” or “must” requirements with “should” or “may” guidance. CSA Group nuclear standards are referenced in that material and in licences; they bind only when a regulation incorporates them or a licence condition requires them.
Related federal law
The Nuclear Energy Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. A-16; last amended 21 September 2017) concerns development and use of nuclear energy. The 1997 repeal of sections 3 to 9 removed the Atomic Energy Control Board. The Minister may research and, with Governor-in-Council approval, use nuclear energy and acquire property, apart from section 24 licensing.
The Impact Assessment Act (S.C. 2019, c. 28, s. 1; last amended 29 May 2026) requires a review panel when a designated project includes activities regulated under the Nuclear Safety and Control Act. That impact assessment is the only one the Commission may use for the licence in the terms of reference, and decision-statement conditions may be made part of the licence. The Act replaced the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, 2012 (S.C. 2012, c. 19, s. 52; repealed 28 August 2019), under which section 15 made the Commission the responsible authority for linked designated projects.
The Nuclear Liability and Compensation Act (S.C. 2015, c. 4, s. 120; last amended 1 January 2017) makes operator liability absolute and exclusive, at $1 billion after a phase-in, subject to regulatory increase or reduction by class. Transport is also regulated under the Transportation of Dangerous Goods Act, 1992. Under the Species at Risk Act, section 77 requires consultation and findings on alternatives and mitigation before another federal body authorizes destruction of critical habitat, and section 79 requires notice and mitigation where a mandatory assessment is likely to affect a listed species or its critical habitat. The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act affirms the Declaration and requires the Government of Canada, with Indigenous peoples, to align federal laws with it.
Organization and governance
Commission members
The Nuclear Safety and Control Act provides for not more than seven permanent members, appointed by the Governor in Council. One is designated president and serves full-time; the others may be full-time or part-time. Permanent members hold office during good behaviour for up to five years and may be removed for cause. Temporary members may be appointed, also during good behaviour, for up to three years, and members may be reappointed. The Commission describes itself as an independent quasi-judicial administrative tribunal and a court of record.
Pierre Tremblay’s term as president and chief executive officer began on 12 August 2024. He had been president of AECOM Canada Nuclear Services and chief nuclear operating officer at Ontario Hydro, now Ontario Power Generation. The president supervises members and staff and assigns panels. As listed on the members page updated 31 August 2026, the other permanent members, all part-time for five-year terms, were Timothy Berube (reappointed 19 April 2022; acting president from 14 October 2023 to 11 August 2024), Marcel Lacroix (reappointed 25 March 2022), Victoria Remenda (appointed 18 May 2022), Andrea Hardie and Jerry Hopwood (both appointed 25 September 2023), and Alexander McEwan (appointed 3 February 2026). A member must end any inconsistent interest or employment, or resign, within 120 days.
As a court of record, the Commission may summon witnesses, require records and enforce its orders. Subject to its by-laws and regulations, it must hold a public hearing before issuing, renewing, suspending, amending, revoking or replacing a licence, and it may hold one on any other matter it considers to be in the public interest.
Staff, branches and offices
The Act lets the Commission employ the staff it considers necessary and, in consultation with the Treasury Board of Canada, fix their remuneration. The organization treats the tribunal as separate from the executive team. The Commission communicates with staff only through the Commission Registry and formal proceedings.
Ramzi Jammal is executive vice-president on the team led by the president. That team directs five branches. Regulatory Operations regulates facilities and activities; Technical Support provides scientific and technical expertise; Regulatory Affairs leads communications, regulatory policy and planning; Corporate Services covers finance, human resources, information management, information technology and administration; and Legal and Commission Affairs provides legal services and registry support.
In 2024–25 the Commission reported 1,015 full-time equivalents, 694 in nuclear regulation and 321 in internal services. Head office is at 280 Slater Street, Ottawa. Regional offices are in Calgary, Saskatoon, Mississauga and Laval. Site offices are at the Bruce, Darlington and Pickering stations, Point Lepreau, and Chalk River Laboratories.
Reporting and independence
The Act defines the Minister as the Minister of Natural Resources, or another member of the Queen’s Privy Council for Canada whom the Governor in Council designates. The organization says it reports to Parliament through the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources; the 2024–25 results report names Tim Hodgson in that role. The president reports to the Minister on general administration and management.
Within four months of each fiscal year the Commission must send the Minister an activities report, which section 72 requires the Minister to table. Order P.C. 2026-867 of 25 September 2026 (SI/2026-55) directed, under section 157 of the Financial Administration Act, that tabling be discontinued because the report contains no more information than the Departmental Results Report tabled with the Estimates.
The Commission is an agent of the Crown and may act only in that capacity. It is a departmental corporation named in Schedule II of the Financial Administration Act, which applies subject to the Nuclear Safety and Control Act and its regulations. Governor-in-Council directives are limited to general application on broad policy matters about the Commission’s objects; each must be published in the Canada Gazette and tabled in Parliament. The Commission states that a directive may not concern a particular case, and that its decisions are not overturned by the government and are reviewable only by the Federal Court of Canada. The removal of a president is discussed under Criticism.
Licensing, compliance and enforcement
Licensing decisions
Subject to the regulations, section 26 of the Nuclear Safety and Control Act provides that no person shall, except in accordance with a licence, possess, transfer, import, export, use or abandon a nuclear substance, prescribed equipment or prescribed information; carry on the mining, production, processing, transport, storage and disposal activities the section lists; produce or service prescribed equipment; operate a dosimetry service; or prepare a site for, construct, operate, modify, decommission or abandon a nuclear facility.
The Commission may establish classes of licences for those activities and for the period the licence specifies. It may issue, renew, suspend, amend, revoke, replace or transfer a licence only if, in its opinion, the applicant or transferee is qualified and will make adequate provision for the environment, the health and safety of persons, national security and Canada’s international obligations. It may attach any condition it considers necessary, including a financial guarantee. Power-reactor authorizations have been granted for multi-year periods.
Class I facilities are divided into Class IA (reactors, subcritical assemblies and reactor-equipped vehicles) and Class IB (certain accelerators, fuel-cycle plants and disposal facilities), and are licensed in stages: site preparation, construction, operation, decommissioning and abandonment. A designated officer may deal with licences of a class the Commission assigns, and must offer a reasonable opportunity to be heard before a refusal or an adverse action the licensee did not seek. When the Commission or a panel proposes to use that licensing power itself, a public hearing is required, subject to by-laws and regulations, and the decision is made on the hearing record.
On 4 April 2025 the Commission issued Ontario Power Generation a licence to construct one GE-Hitachi BWRX-300 small modular reactor beside the Darlington Nuclear Generating Station. The Globe and Mail reported that, after hearings in late 2024 and early 2025, the licence allows construction but not operation, requires Indigenous engagement for the term, and sets hold points before the reactor-building foundation, installation of the pressure vessel, and commissioning. In October 2024, after June hearings, a panel authorized operation of Units 5 to 8 at the Pickering Nuclear Generating Station until 31 December 2026, finding adequate provision for the environment and public safety. It replaced a 120-parts-per-million cap on hydrogen-equivalent concentration in pressure tubes with a requirement for an enhanced fitness-for-service program.
Compliance verification
An inspector may, at any reasonable time, enter a nuclear facility or a place or vehicle believed to hold a nuclear substance, prescribed equipment, prescribed information or a required record, and may enter at any time where contamination, unsafe handling or risky operation is suspected. For Class II facilities and prescribed equipment, Type I inspections examine programs over several days and are followed by a report; shorter Type II inspections are usually scheduled but may be unannounced. An imminent threat may be ordered stopped immediately. A request by the Commission, or a person it authorizes, to test, analyse or inspect, or to review or modify a design, equipment or procedures, must be answered in the time set. An inspector’s order—for protective measures, evacuation or a change in operation—is referred to the Commission, which confirms, amends, revokes or replaces it, but it must be obeyed within the time stated or at once if none is stated. The 2024–25 departmental results report says inspectors carry out compliance and licensing work for nearly 1,650 licensees.
Enforcement
Breach of a designated provision, order, decision or licence condition is a violation that may draw an administrative monetary penalty. The Act says the penalty is to promote compliance, not to punish. For an individual the ranges are $300–$3,000 (Category A), $300–$10,000 (Category B) and $300–$25,000 (Category C); for any other person, $1,000–$12,000, $1,000–$40,000 and $1,000–$100,000, with the amount inside each range set under the penalty regulations. CBC News reported a 20 March 2025 notice assessing NB Power $24,760 over rest rules for safety-sensitive staff at the Point Lepreau Nuclear Generating Station, after 104 breaches in 2023 and 150 in 2024 of a required 72-hour break after three or more night shifts.
Failure to comply with the Act, the regulations, a licence condition or an order is an offence. Not assisting an inspector is punishable on summary conviction by a fine of up to $5,000 or six months’ imprisonment, or both. Unauthorized possession of material that could be used for a nuclear weapon or explosive device is indictable and punishable by up to ten years. Other offences may be tried by indictment (a fine of up to $1,000,000 or five years’ imprisonment, or both) or summarily (a fine of up to $500,000 or eighteen months, or both). Due diligence is a defence except for that possession offence, and each day a continuing offence runs counts separately. On its own motion, and under prescribed conditions, the Commission may also renew, suspend, amend, revoke or replace a licence.
Regulated facilities and activities
Nuclear power reactors
Commercial plants are CANDU heavy-water reactors using natural uranium. In 2026 the World Nuclear Association counted 17 operable units, 12,714 MWe net: eight at Bruce, four at Darlington and four at Pickering in Ontario, and one at Point Lepreau in New Brunswick.
Aerial view of the Bruce Nuclear Generating Station on the Lake Huron shore in Ontario.
Bruce Power, which leases the site from Ontario Power Generation, is licensed for Bruce A and B. Units 1 and 2 were refurbished by 2012. Unit 6 returned in 2023 and unit 3 in June 2026; unit 4 has been out since February 2025. Units 5, 7 and 8 are operating.
OPG holds Darlington’s operating licence. Refurbishment of the four units, started in 2016, ended in early 2026, and in September 2025 the Commission renewed the licence for 20 years, to November 2045.
At Pickering, units 2 and 3 are in safe storage and units 1 and 4 were permanently shut down in late 2024. Units 5 to 8 had been authorized only until 31 December 2026. In September 2026 they began coming offline for a refurbishment Ontario had approved in November 2025, estimated at C$26.8 billion.
NB Power operates Point Lepreau’s CANDU-6, refurbished between 2008 and 2012.
A pre-licensing vendor design review is not a licence to site, build or operate. About ten small modular reactor designs, up to 300 MWe, and some larger designs have been assessed that way. The power-reactor construction licence is for one GE Vernova Hitachi BWRX-300 at Darlington, issued to OPG in April 2025. The first hold point, on the reactor-building foundation, was lifted in late March 2026, and first nuclear concrete followed on 26 June 2026. In March 2026 OPG applied for an operating licence, which the construction licence does not include.
Uranium mining, milling and fuel fabrication
Operating mines are in the Athabasca Basin of northern Saskatchewan. Cameco operates McArthur River (69.8 percent) and the Key Lake mill, with Orano as minority partner. The mine was suspended in January 2018 and restarted in November 2022; ore is milled at Key Lake. Cigar Lake, also operated by Cameco (about 57.4 percent, the rest Orano), sends slurry to the McClean Lake mill, operated by Orano Canada (70 percent, with Denison Mines at 22.5 percent). Mining at McClean Lake North resumed in June 2025. Rabbit Lake has been in care and maintenance, with no production, since 2016.
In February 2026 the Commission licensed Denison to prepare the site and construct an in situ recovery mine and mill at Wheeler River’s Phoenix deposit. The licence runs to 28 February 2031 and does not authorize operation.
Cameco refines concentrate at Blind River, licensed for 24,000 tonnes of uranium a year, and at Port Hope converts it to uranium hexafluoride for export and to natural uranium dioxide for CANDU fuel.
Research reactors, isotopes and nuclear substances
Chalk River Laboratories, owned by Atomic Energy of Canada Limited and operated by Canadian Nuclear Laboratories, is the main licensed research site. The National Research Universal reactor was shut down in March 2018; a ZED-2 reactor at the site is still operable. Also licensed and operating are a pool reactor at McMaster University and SLOWPOKE-2 reactors at the Royal Military College of Canada and École Polytechnique de Montréal. A Saskatchewan Research Council SLOWPOKE-2 was decommissioned in 2021.
In 2024, 1,447 licensees held 2,034 licences for nuclear substances, radiation devices, Class II equipment and a few waste-substance activities: 452 medical, 1,152 industrial, 182 academic and research, and 248 commercial. They cover nuclear medicine and radiotherapy, gauges, radiography, oil-well logging, and isotope production and distribution.
Waste management and decommissioning
Low-level, intermediate-level and used-fuel wastes are regulated separately from uranium-mine tailings and waste rock. Used bundles cool in pools, then go to dry storage at the stations. As of 2025 about 3.4 million bundles were stored, with about 90,000 added a year.
The Nuclear Waste Management Organization, under the 2002 Nuclear Fuel Waste Act, implements Adaptive Phased Management: a deep geological repository for used fuel. In November 2024 it selected the Wabigoon Lake Ojibway Nation and the Township of Ignace as potential hosts. The NWMO, not the Commission, selects the site. The Commission may license a repository only after the federal impact assessment. A project description was filed in January 2026, a review panel was set in March, and the assessment began in July.
Low- and intermediate-level waste from the reactors is stored above ground by the utilities and by CNL. OPG withdrew a proposed repository for that waste at Bruce in 2020 after the Saugeen Ojibway Nation voted no. A 2023 federal strategy assigns low-level waste to near-surface facilities and a second NWMO repository, with siting from 2028, to intermediate-level and non-fuel high-level waste.
Gentilly-1, Douglas Point and the Nuclear Power Demonstration reactor at Rolphton, AECL prototypes now with CNL, shut down in 1977, 1984 and 1987. Hydro-Québec’s Gentilly-2 closed on 28 December 2012, was defuelled in 2013 and is in safe storage, with used fuel in dry storage by December 2020. Its decommissioning licence was renewed in June 2026 for 20 years, to 2046. Whiteshell Laboratories in Manitoba, including the WR-1 reactor shut down in 1985, is also under CNL decommissioning.
The Commission regulates packaging and transport of nuclear substances with Transport Canada. About 760,000 shipments a year move to, from and within Canada, some 95 percent of them routine loads in medicine, industry, research and commerce. Those sectors reported 61 transport events in 2024, 47 involving vehicle collisions.
Environmental protection and radiation safety
Environmental assessment and monitoring
The Nuclear Safety and Control Act provides for limiting risks to the environment and to health and safety. No licence may be issued, renewed, amended, or replaced unless, in the Commission’s opinion, the applicant will make adequate provision for the protection of the environment and of health and safety. A 2019 International Atomic Energy Agency review found that licensing of Class I facilities and uranium mines and mills covers an environmental risk assessment, effluent and environmental monitoring, and groundwater protection. Derived release limits for airborne and liquid radioactive effluents used effective-dose criteria of 0.05 to 1 mSv per year; for nuclear power plants the criterion was the 1 mSv public dose limit rather than a lower dose constraint.
REGDOC-2.9.1 (version 1.2) cites CSA N288.1, N288.5, and N288.7 for those limits and for effluent and groundwater monitoring; distinguishes impact assessment of designated projects, led by the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada with the CNSC, from Nuclear Safety and Control Act review of other proposals that may interact with the environment; and, with Fisheries and Oceans Canada, addresses fish, fish habitat, the Fisheries Act, the Species at Risk Act, and acute lethality of certain effluents. If a designated project includes activities regulated under the Nuclear Safety and Control Act, the Minister must refer the impact assessment to a review panel.
Independent CNSC sampling does not replace licensees’ own environmental monitoring, and its results are published. The Independent Environmental Monitoring Program samples air, water, soil, sediment, vegetation, or local food in publicly accessible areas for radiological and hazardous substances and compares the results with guidelines and natural background.
Radiation protection standards
The Radiation Protection Regulations (SOR/2000-203), current to 30 September 2026 and last amended on 1 January 2021, require every licensee to keep effective dose and equivalent dose as low as reasonably achievable, social and economic factors considered, through a radiation protection program. Effective dose is limited to 50 mSv in a one-year dosimetry period and 100 mSv over a five-year dosimetry period for a nuclear energy worker, including a breastfeeding worker and a pregnant worker before written notice; to 4 mSv for the balance of the pregnancy after notice; and to 1 mSv in a calendar year for anyone else. Equivalent dose for a nuclear energy worker is limited to 50 mSv to the lens of an eye and 500 mSv to the skin and to the hands and feet in a one-year dosimetry period, and for any other person to 15 mSv and 50 mSv respectively in a calendar year.
A licensed dosimetry service is required when a nuclear energy worker has a reasonable probability of exceeding 5 mSv effective dose, or 50 mSv to the skin or the hands and feet, in a one-year dosimetry period. The service reports doses and radon-progeny exposure to the National Dose Registry of the Department of Health. Health Canada operates that registry; the 2019 review noted its 200 Bq/m³ action level for radon in dwellings, for which there is no federal exposure regulation, and the inclusion of radon progeny in dose at CNSC-licensed work.
The Integrated Regulatory Review Service mission of 3–13 September 2019 recommended dose constraints for all Class I facilities (R2), consistency with IAEA safety standard GSR Part 3 (R3), and consistent derived-release-limit practice (S9). The follow-up of 4–10 June 2024 closed two of four recommendations and ten of sixteen suggestions but left R2, S9, and R3 open. REGDOC-2.9.2 (2024) sets facility-specific dose constraints without fixed numbers, at once for new applications and later for existing facilities, at licence renewal or environmental-risk-assessment updates. Skin and hands-and-feet limits matched GSR Part 3; the lens limit of 50 mSv in a single year did not (GSR Part 3 uses 20 mSv a year averaged over five-year periods, with no year above 50 mSv). The 4 mSv balance-of-pregnancy cap remained, with no separate embryo or fetus limit at the public level of protection GSR Part 3 requires for the embryo, fetus, or breastfed infant.
Indigenous consultation and public participation
Hearings and participant funding
The Commission is a court of record under the Nuclear Safety and Control Act. It is not bound by the legal rules of evidence and may receive information it considers appropriate, and refuse what it does not consider relevant or trustworthy. Subject to limited exceptions, it must hold a public hearing before issuing, renewing, suspending, amending, revoking, or replacing a licence. Under the Rules of Procedure, members of the public, Indigenous peoples, and others with an interest, expertise, or useful information may intervene in writing or with a written submission and an oral presentation. Hearings are open and webcast.
Public Commission meetings are separate. They conduct the Commission's affairs under its by-laws rather than the Rules of Procedure. Attendance and webcasts are open, but formal intervention is invited only for specified items. Section 9(b) also requires the Commission to disseminate objective scientific, technical, and regulatory information about its activities and about the effects, on the environment and on health and safety, of nuclear development, production, possession, and use.
The Participant Funding Program, cost-recovered from licensees, pays eligible individuals, Indigenous groups, and not-for-profit organizations for environmental assessments, licensing reviews, and Commission proceedings. Eligibility requires a direct local interest, Indigenous or community knowledge, a possible effect on rights, or value-added information. For-profit parties and non-Indigenous governments are excluded. An outside committee may fund professional fees, travel, honoraria, and legal advice, but not representation, with each offering set case by case. The 2025–26 departmental plan forecast $1.4 million in contributions for 2024–25 and $2 million a year from 2025–26 through 2027–28, and the program also funds regulatory-oversight meetings and Indigenous-knowledge studies. In 2025 a two-part hearing renewed Ontario Power Generation's licence for the Darlington Nuclear Generating Station for 20 years, to 30 November 2045, after submissions from the licensee, staff, and 79 intervenors, with performance updates and a condition of continued Indigenous engagement.
Consultation with Indigenous nations
Where a decision may adversely affect potential or established Aboriginal or treaty rights under section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, the Crown's duty to consult applies. In Haida Nation v. British Columbia (Minister of Forests) (2004), the Supreme Court of Canada held that the Crown may delegate procedural aspects of consultation to proponents, but that the honour of the Crown cannot be delegated and ultimate responsibility remains with the Crown. REGDOC-3.2.2, Indigenous Engagement, version 1.2, states that the Commission keeps the duty but may leave procedural steps to licensees, and that Indigenous knowledge, gathered with the community and read in its worldview, may show effects on land use, rights, and cultural sites. The Act's evidence rule lets the Commission receive that knowledge, including oral evidence.
The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act was tested over Canadian Nuclear Laboratories' near-surface disposal facility for low-level radioactive waste at Chalk River Laboratories, near Deep River, Ontario, about a kilometre from the Ottawa River. The Federal Court allowed Kebaowek First Nation's application in part, did not set the licence aside, and returned the matter because it found that the Act imposed additional consultation obligations. On 16 October 2026, in Canadian Nuclear Laboratories Ltd. v. Kebaowek First Nation et al., 2026 FCA 174, the Federal Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and dismissed the cross-appeal. It held that the Commission had met the duty to consult. Articles of the Declaration inconsistent with Canadian law were not given immediate effect; the Act instead directs the Government of Canada, in consultation and cooperation with Indigenous peoples, to align the laws, and the Commission is not that government for resolving an inconsistency. The Act did not authorize an added free, prior and informed consent standard beyond the existing duty to consult.
Kebaowek Councillor Justin Roy called the result disappointing and "extremely unfortunate," and counsel Robert Janes said that, if upheld, it would reduce the Declaration to a future checklist. Ten of the 11 federally recognized Algonquin nations opposed the facility. The Algonquins of Pikwakanagan gave consent and entered a partnership with the laboratories that includes monitoring, while Chief Lance Haymond said Kebaowek had been brought in after studies and decisions were already taken. Canadian Environmental Law Association executive director Theresa McClenaghan said the design was "tantamount to an ordinary domestic landfill" that would eventually leak contaminants hazardous for thousands of years. Ottawa city staff, in March 2022, supported the facility as improved engineered storage for low-level waste while recommending measures to protect the Ottawa River, the city's primary drinking-water source.
Security, safeguards and international cooperation
Domestic security and export controls
The Nuclear Safety and Control Act limits, consistently with Canada’s international obligations, risks to national security, health, safety and the environment, and implements agreed controls on nuclear energy, including non-proliferation of nuclear weapons and nuclear explosive devices. The Commission’s objects include preventing unreasonable risk to national security and conformity with those obligations. The role is regulatory, not intelligence collection: possession, import and export require a licence, and designated inspectors enforce the Act, including by orders for national security or international obligations.
The Nuclear Security Regulations (SOR/2025-219), registered on 30 October 2025, replaced the 2000 regulations with more performance-based rules aimed at physical, cyber and insider threats and at international guidance. A high-security site is a nuclear facility where Category I or Category II nuclear material is produced, processed, used or stored. The licensee must normally keep an on-site nuclear response force—nuclear security officers, or police or Canadian Armed Forces members, permanently stationed there—able, with the off-site force and other measures, to intervene against the design-basis threat; equivalent measures may be substituted on 90 days’ written notice. The security plan must include a cyber-security program for computer systems and electronic components. At facilities already licensed, the former regulations continue for two years.
Category I, II or III nuclear material moved outside the area where it must be handled under those regulations requires a CNSC transport licence under the Packaging and Transport of Nuclear Substances Regulations, 2015. Import or export of a nuclear substance, prescribed equipment or prescribed information likewise requires a CNSC licence. The Nuclear Non-proliferation Import and Export Control Regulations, made under the Act, prescribe the application for a licence covering controlled nuclear substances, equipment and information. Permits under the Export and Import Permits Act are separate. Global Affairs Canada’s export-controls handbook states that Groups 3 and 4 of the Export Control List are controlled under that Act and that nuclear and nuclear-related exports are also controlled by the CNSC, so both an export permit and a CNSC licence may be required.
Safeguards and peer review
Canada’s comprehensive safeguards agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency, INFCIRC/164, has been in force since 21 February 1972, and an additional protocol since 8 September 2000, under the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons. The CNSC implements both through legislation, regulations and licences, keeps the national nuclear-material accountancy system, and requires access for IAEA safeguards inspectors; CNSC inspectors separately enforce the Act. In September 2005 the IAEA drew the broader safeguards conclusion for Canada, and the CNSC’s Canadian Safeguards Support Program develops safeguards equipment and methods for the Agency and for Canadian facilities.
Canada is a party to the Convention on Nuclear Safety (in force for Canada on 24 October 1996), the Joint Convention on the Safety of Spent Fuel Management and on the Safety of Radioactive Waste Management (18 June 2001), and the Convention on the Physical Protection of Nuclear Material (8 February 1987) and its 2005 amendment (8 May 2016). The tenth national report under the Convention on Nuclear Safety, covering April 2022 to March 2025, was produced for the government by a CNSC-led team.
Integrated Regulatory Review Service missions were held in Ottawa from 31 May to 12 June 2009 and, on a full scope, from 3 to 13 September 2019, the latter with the CNSC, Natural Resources Canada and Health Canada. The 2019 review recorded six good practices, four recommendations and 16 suggestions. The follow-up of 4 to 10 June 2024 closed two recommendations and ten suggestions and described the regulatory framework as comprehensive and robust. Findings still open concerned explicit legal incorporation of IAEA principles on justification and prime responsibility for safety, dose constraints for all Class I facilities, and alignment with IAEA General Safety Requirements Part 3.
Criticism and judicial review
Independence and licence terms
Kebaowek First Nation Chief Lance Haymond has called the Commission "a captured regulator" with "no independence," citing members who had worked at Chalk River Laboratories or for SNC-Lavalin, a partner in Canadian Nuclear Laboratories. Lawyer Kerrie Blaise traced the complaint to the Atomic Energy Control Board's combined promotional and regulatory mandate, and said reporting through the minister for Natural Resources Canada, which also promotes nuclear development, still leaves "a perception of a lack of independence." Then-president Rumina Velshi told MPs in 2022 that the Commission reports to Parliament through the minister, who "exerts no control" over decisions, and that there is "no political interference."
The Nuclear Safety and Control Act limits the objects to preventing unreasonable risk and disseminating objective information. Permanent members hold office during good behaviour and may be removed only for cause, and the Governor in Council may issue only general policy directives, not orders on a particular licence. A 2019 International Atomic Energy Agency mission called Natural Resources Canada "the administrative channel" to Parliament, wrote that decisions "are not subject to review by the Minister" and that directives "cannot inhibit" case-by-case authority, and named waste policy and standard GSR Part 3 as the challenges. Only the Federal Court of Canada may review a decision.
In September 2025 the Commission renewed Ontario Power Generation's Darlington Nuclear Generating Station licence for 20 years, to 30 November 2045, with two performance updates, after the utility sought 30 years and staff recommended that term. Staff, quoted by the Canadian Environmental Law Association, acknowledged "a risk of eroded trust" but called duration "largely a legal/administrative matter" with "no bearing on safety performance," because oversight reports, periodic reviews and the power to amend or revoke a licence would continue. The association said those steps are not hearings. Its October 2026 report, Acknowledged and Deferred, found that at Darlington, Pickering and Point Lepreau concerns were usually deferred and rarely changed the outcome.
The 2008 isotope crisis
On 18 November 2007 the Commission kept the National Research Universal reactor at Chalk River shut because emergency power was not connected to cooling pumps, contrary to the licence. Run by Atomic Energy of Canada Limited, it supplied about two-thirds of the world's medical radioisotopes, and the outage caused a global shortage.
It refused a 10 December directive to restart until the backup was connected; on 11 December the Commons authorized 120 days by emergency legislation, and the reactor restarted on 16 December. On 15 January 2008 Natural Resources Minister Gary Lunn removed president Linda Keen for a "lack of leadership," saying the dispute was about licensing, not safety, and that otherwise "people invariably would have died." Liberal critic Omar Alghabra called it "blatant political interference," and Prime Minister Stephen Harper called her course "extremely ill advised." Keen, who remained a commissioner, accused Lunn of improper interference, insisted the safety condition be met first, and resigned that seat in September 2008. In Keen v. Canada (Attorney General), 2009 FC 353, the Federal Court upheld removal of the president at pleasure—unlike membership during good behaviour—while saying a for-cause test would not have been met.
Waste approvals and the courts
In January 2024 the Commission approved a near-surface disposal facility at Chalk River for up to one million cubic metres of low-level waste, about a kilometre from the Ottawa River. Kebaowek and nine other federally recognized Algonquin First Nations opposed it; the Algonquins of Pikwàkanagàn consented. In 2018, 82 Montreal-area mayors voted unanimously against it over drinking water, while the laboratories said studies showed no appreciable effect on Aboriginal or treaty rights.
On 19 February 2025, in Kebaowek First Nation v. Canadian Nuclear Laboratories, 2025 FC 319, Justice Julie Blackhawk held that consultation "was not adequate," found the Commission wrong to disclaim jurisdiction under the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, and ordered further consultation by 30 September 2026 aimed at agreement and the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples standard of free, prior and informed consent. She did not quash the licence, upheld the finding of no likely significant environmental effects, and wrote that the duty "is a right to a process, not a particular outcome."
On 16 October 2026, in Canadian Nuclear Laboratories Ltd. v. Kebaowek First Nation, 2026 FCA 174, the Federal Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, dismissed the cross-appeal and the judicial review, and held that the existing duty to consult had been met. Justice Wyman W. Webb wrote that the Act "does not implement the articles of UNDRIP immediately" and that the Commission is not "the Government of Canada" for resolving any inconsistency with existing law, so no added consent standard applied. Kebaowek called the outcome heartbreaking; the laboratories and the Commission said consultation would continue. Separately, 2026 FCA 106 returned a Species at Risk Act permit because the reasons did not show that reasonable alternatives reducing harm to listed species had been considered. Used fuel is a different project, given by the Nuclear Fuel Waste Act to the Nuclear Waste Management Organization for a deep geological repository.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Related people
Related organizations
Linked pages by kind
Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.
- People2
- Organizations4