
La Civiltà Cattolica
La Civiltà Cattolica is an Italian cultural review edited by the Jesuits.
Expert article
La Civiltà Cattolica is an Italian cultural review edited by the Jesuits. Carlo Maria Curci founded it in Naples in 1850; the Bourbon government regarded it with disfavor, and it was transferred to Rome. Pope Pius IX wanted a journal that would defend traditional “Catholic civilization” against liberal and agnostic ideas in the European press, and the Jesuits took up the project despite misgivings from their superior, Johannes Roothaan, about political involvement. The first issue is dated 6 April 1850 and is described as having appeared at Pius IX’s behest.
A college of writers, constituted by Pius IX in a brief of 1866 and confirmed by Pope Leo XIII in 1890, produces the review. After the capture of Rome it suspended publication for three months in October 1870, resumed in Florence in 1871, and returned to Rome in 1887. Its early line was combative in defense of the pope’s temporal power during the Risorgimento, and in the early twentieth century it campaigned against modernism and socialism as well as liberalism. From its first decades it attacked Freemasonry and Judaism; under Leo XIII the attacks became a systematic campaign that revived the blood libel, and contributors remained anonymous until 1933.
The review is not an official organ of the Holy See, but articles are examined at the Vatican before publication — by the pope himself until the pontificate of John XXIII, and afterward by senior officials of the Secretariat of State — on the understanding that they harmonize with papal positions and church teaching. In 1938 it condemned Nazism as neopagan, anti-Christian, and imperialistic, while in the same decade it also published a Christian antisemitism that it distinguished from Nazi racial doctrine. It was sympathetic to some religious aspects of Italian fascism and increasingly critical of the regime’s totalitarian policies. With the Second Vatican Council it widened its subjects and adopted a more open dialogue with contemporary culture, a turn later credited especially to the directors Roberto Tucci and Bartolomeo Sorge.
In August 2013 the director Antonio Spadaro interviewed Pope Francis at the Casa Santa Marta over three meetings; the Italian text, approved by the pope, was published that September in La Civiltà Cattolica and in other Jesuit journals, including America. Since 1 October 2023 the director has been the Portuguese Jesuit Nuno da Silva Gonçalves, the first non-Italian in the post, working from the review’s seat at Villa Malta. A fortnightly for most of its history, it became a monthly in January 2025, and editions in several other languages appear, usually online. On 1 April 2025 a ceremony at Villa Malta, attended by Cardinal Pietro Parolin and the Italian president Sergio Mattarella, marked the 175th anniversary, with a message from Francis.
Founding and the College of Writers
Origins under Pius IX
After the revolutions of 1848 drove Pope Pius IX from Rome, Italian clerical writers treated the periodical press as the main instrument of liberal opponents and called for a “good press” to answer it. A review written only by Jesuits had been discussed in the Society of Jesus since 1846, but superiors held back until 9 January 1850, when Pius IX, then at Portici, near Naples, ordered the superior general, Jan Roothaan, to have Italian Jesuits start an Italian-language “popular newspaper” defending Catholic doctrine and the interests of the Holy See. Roothaan, back in Naples in mid-January after exile, had not wanted the Society drawn into political journalism; the papal command turned him into the project’s patron.
Carlo Maria Curci, a Neapolitan Jesuit known for polemics against Vincenzo Gioberti, took over a plan already in circulation, fixed its shape, and is regarded as the founder and first director. With Luigi Taparelli d’Azeglio he rejected both a Latin learned journal and daily sheets for a mass public, proposing instead a fascicle of some hundreds of pages every fifteen days, in Italian, for the middle classes. Roothaan, wary of Curci’s polemical temper and of his treating the review as a personal venture, placed beside him Taparelli, Matteo Liberatore, and Antonio Bresciani, and required collective approval of articles and decisions.
The Naples launch and the move to Rome
The first issue appeared in Naples on 6 April 1850 as a periodical “for all Italy,” under the motto Beatus populus cuius Dominus Deus eius. Curci set out the program in that number and circulated a manifesto in about 120,000 copies. The review presented itself as native “from Susa to Malta and from Nice to Trieste,” and professed respect for every government that had legitimacy in its being and justice in its conduct, even though copies still had to cross several states and censors. That national reach, and the commercial network built to sustain it, set it apart from the mostly local Catholic press.
The government of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies, already given to severe preventive censorship and suspicious of independent culture, was alarmed by that claim. Ferdinand II complained to Roothaan that the program showed “indifferentism” and failed to defend what royalists called the divine rights of monarchs. After clashes with the police, and at Liberatore’s urging, Roothaan on 21 September 1850 ordered the writers to Rome, a move settled that month despite fears that the papal capital would constrain them as much as Naples had. They settled at the Jesuit novitiate on the Via del Quirinale; the first issue printed there appeared on 1 November 1850. The staff consulted frequently with the Vatican, but the review was not an official Holy See publication.
The 1866 brief and collective authorship
A fixed group of writers existed from the start, but it was not yet a separate institute, and Curci proposed that the pope erect, by apostolic authority, a house of Jesuit writers “at the service of the Church,” under the superior general and “according to all the norms” of a Jesuit college. The brief Gravissimum supremi of 12 February 1866 did so in perpetuity: members chosen by the general were to live in their own house, depend entirely on him, and write in defense of the Catholic religion and the Holy See. Leo XIII confirmed the college in 1890. The New Catholic Encyclopedia dates that pontifical statute to 1868 rather than 1866.
Editors under that discipline joined polemic to information, erudition, and entertainment, and with the faculty of the Collegio Romano, later the Pontifical Gregorian University, formed a principal intellectual center of the Italian Jesuits. Articles stayed unsigned until 1933, so publication was the college’s responsibility rather than a named author’s. Andrea Riccardi has called the college a community devoted to a cultural enterprise, not merely a newsroom, recalling Gabriele De Rosa’s phrase “autonomous cultural group.”
The Risorgimento and intransigent Catholicism
Temporal power and Italian unification
During the Risorgimento, La Civiltà Cattolica treated the pope’s civil principate as a condition of the Holy See’s independence: Giacomo Martina notes that it defended temporal power outright and ascribed Italian national aspirations to a sectarian minority, and Oliver Logan classes it with the intransigent press that demanded restoration of that power and refused compromise with the kingdom.
On 20 September 1870 guns under Raffaele Cadorna breached Porta Pia and Rome was occupied. The review wrote that publication then became morally impossible: censorship passed from the Master of the Sacred Palace to an officer of the new government, and leave to print was refused. After a “full quarter” of silence, the issue of 24 December 1870 appeared from Florence, with an 1871 imprint. “Il nodo romano” argued that the breach and the plebiscite of 2 October had bound the Roman question more tightly to the Kingdom of Italy. Quoting Pius IX’s encyclical of 18 June 1859, it held that only a civil principate left the pope sui iuris, and that personal sovereignty or subjection to the common law was not that independence.
The Law of Guarantees (13 May 1871) was parliament’s unilateral settlement of the pope’s prerogatives. The 1911 Catholic Encyclopedia records that accepting it could be read as recognizing the accomplished facts and renouncing the temporal power, and that neither Pius IX nor his two successors drew the endowment of 3,225,000 lire.
The Syllabus, Vatican I, and liberalism
The journal did not draft the condemnations of 8 December 1864. Quanta cura and the Syllabus of Errors, sent that day by Cardinal Antonelli, collected propositions already censured in papal acts. Theses 75–76 concerned the temporal power and 77–80 modern liberalism, including the claim that the pope must reconcile himself to progress, liberalism, and modern civilization. Carlo Maria Curci, harshly conservative on the Roman question in articles of 1850–66, was milder on the Syllabus, using the distinction between thesis and hypothesis; his collaboration ended at the start of 1866.
French letters in the February 1869 number said that most French Catholics wanted papal infallibility defined. Those letters sharpened the dispute and helped draw Ignaz von Döllinger into opposition; the First Vatican Council, not the journal, defined the doctrine, and Pius IX suspended the assembly after Rome fell.
The Florentine chronicles put Freemasonry inside the same anti-liberal polemic, describing Napoleon III as accepted by the heads of the Masonic “sect” and attacking another sovereign for belonging to it. For elections the Holy See required abstention. The Penitentiary’s non expedit of 29 February 1868 told Catholics neither to vote nor to stand; on 11 October 1874 Pius IX tied the rule to the risk that a deputy’s oath would approve the spoliation of the Holy See.
Florence, the Roman Question, and Curci’s break
Publication, suspended for three months from October 1870, resumed at Florence in 1871 and continued there until the end of 1887, when the review returned to Rome. From Florence it kept the Roman question open, arguing in December 1870 that Porta Pia had not solved it. On 30 December 1886 the Holy Office called non expedit a grave precept, not advice for a single election.
Curci had already left the college. In La caduta di Roma (Florence, about a month after 20 September) he wrote, against many intransigents, that the temporal power would not return. In June 1875 he privately urged Pius IX to abandon non expedit: Catholics voting en masse would treat the king as an authority given by God, block irreligious laws, and leave the pope sovereign “not only of Rome, but of Italy.” Pius forbade the text as an “insolence”; it appeared without Curci’s part in the Rivista europea of February–March 1877.
Jesuit general Pieter Beckx demanded a retraction. Curci refused, asked to leave the Society on 16 October 1877, and was released on 22 October. Il moderno dissidio fra la Chiesa e l’Italia (1878) stated his case; three books of 1881–84, including Il Vaticano regio, were put on the Index, and after the second he was suspended a divinis. After Leo XIII’s letter of 28 August 1884 to Archbishop Eugenio Cecconi, Curci retracted on 14 September whatever contradicted faith, morals, discipline, and the Church’s rights. Readmitted on 29 May 1891, he died at Careggi, near Florence, on 8 June, while the review stayed with the Holy See’s line.
Social teaching and cultural coverage
Taparelli, natural law, and Thomism
Luigi Taparelli d’Azeglio, a Jesuit who was rector of the Collegio Romano—later the Pontifical Gregorian University—from 1824, when the future Leo XIII, Gioacchino Pecci, was among its students, brought to La Civiltà Cattolica a project already set out in the Saggio teoretico di dritto naturale appoggiato sul fatto (1840–43). Written while he taught natural law in Palermo, the treatise set aside contract theories of the state for a scholastic account that joined deduction from natural law to induction from historical fact, and treated society as a nested order of associations rather than a mass of individuals under one sovereign.
Within that order he used giustizia sociale (social justice), a phrase traced to him in 1843, for what is due not only to persons but to the several levels of social life. His diritto ipotattico, or hypotactical right—taken from the grammatical subordination of clauses—held that lesser societies, such as the family, keep their own ends and authority, while larger “protarchies,” typically states, coordinate them toward the common good without absorbing them. Catholic teaching later named that limit subsidiarity; Pius XI used the term explicitly in Quadragesimo anno. From the review’s foundation until his death in 1862 he wrote against liberal centralization and for a return to the metaphysics of Thomas Aquinas as an alternative to liberal and socialist theories of society. He was less a close commentator on Aquinas than a political philosopher using scholastic categories. Pecci’s Aeterni Patris (1879), which directed Catholic schools back to Aquinas, gave that program official force; Taparelli’s own aim had been a Catholic theory of society, not a purely academic revival.
Liberatore and Rerum Novarum
Matteo Liberatore, another Jesuit of the founding circle and a stricter Thomist, used the review, his textbooks, and work for Leo XIII to press the same restoration. He collaborated on Aeterni Patris and, in his last decade, turned to political economy. Principi di economia politica (1889) treated property, wages, and a duty of the state to limit market injury to the vulnerable in terms he then carried into papal drafting.
Rerum novarum, dated 15 May 1891, was not his work alone. Under Leo’s direction he wrote the first Italian schema; Cardinals Tommaso Maria Zigliara and Camillo Mazzella reworked the text, and Liberatore took part in the definitive redaction. The review’s archive holds his autograph of that first schema and proofs of a third schema with Zigliara’s additions and Liberatore’s corrections, documents behind Giovanni Antonazzi’s 1957 edition of the preparatory drafts. Pius XII later called the encyclical the magna carta of Christian social action. It defended private property and workers’ associations while rejecting both socialism and an unconstrained market.
Science, literature, and the modernism crisis
The same college of writers treated fiction and natural science as part of a defense of Catholic civilization. Antonio Bresciani’s historical novel L’ebreo di Verona, opening a trilogy with Della Repubblica Romana and Lionello, ran in installments from the first issues of April 1850. Presented as an intransigent answer to the Risorgimento, which it cast as the work of secret societies, the serial adopted the feuilleton form Bresciani had earlier condemned, circulated widely in translation, and was reprinted into the 1880s; Francesco De Sanctis attacked it in a severe review of 1855.
Giambattista Pianciani, a Jesuit physicist at the Roman College who wrote for the review from 1851, developed a concordist reading of creation. La cosmogonia naturale comparata col Genesi (1862) gathered articles published there from 1858 to 1862 and argued that the physical sciences could be harmonized with Genesis. In a paper of 19 July 1860 he noted Charles Darwin’s On the Origin of Species and, having already rejected Lamarckian transformism, treated species as stable. He stayed out of the College quarrel between strict neo-Thomists, including writers tied to the review, and experimentalists such as his pupil Angelo Secchi; his own natural philosophy opposed Aristotelian hylomorphism.
In the early twentieth century the review was prominent in the campaign against Modernism in the Catholic Church. After Pius X’s Holy Office decree Lamentabili sane exitu (3 July 1907) and the encyclical Pascendi Dominici gregis (8 September 1907), Enrico Rosa, a writer for the review since 1905, published about fifty articles in 1907–08, later collected as L’enciclica “Pascendi” e il modernismo. They defended the condemnation and disputed Ernesto Buonaiuti, while Rosa distinguished his position from the integralism of Umberto Benigni’s Sodalitium Pianum. The review’s Jesuits were not the material drafters of either document; the historian Giovanni Sale has argued that Rosa was nevertheless one of the encyclical’s theological inspirations.
The Jewish question
Campaigns of the 1880s and 1890s
From its early decades the review attacked Freemasonry, liberalism, and the synagogue, treating Jewish dispersion as a consequence of the crucifixion. The Encyclopaedia Judaica dates a sharper turn to the accession of Pope Leo XIII in 1878 and cites 1881 phrasing on “Jewish hatred… against mankind—Jews excepted,” an “anti-social spirit of Judaism,” and the “necessity of hating it.” Simon Levis Sullam calls that intensity a religious answer to modernity, not only a political device. José David Lebovitch Dahl finds antisemitism institutionalized in the 1880s and 1890s, with most of the college not backing the writers who pressed it hardest, and argues that the rhetoric also helped define a Catholic Italy where editorials rejected nationalism.
Despite anonymity until 1933, Levis Sullam assigns the 1880s campaigns to the Jesuit Giuseppe Oreglia di Santo Stefano, including Dell’ebraica persecuzione contro il Cristianesimo (1886–87), and the 1890 articles Della questione giudaica in Europa to Raffaele Ballerini. From 1881 Oreglia wrote that “the devil and the Jew” shared the same fall “for the same fault of having taken it out directly on Christ,” equated Judaism with Freemasonry, and called Jews a “race” seeking “general mastery of the world.” Ballerini wrote that in Italy “Judaism reigns supreme” and that no Italian writer matched Édouard Drumont’s La France juive.
Francesco Crepaldi describes the periodical as placed by statute under close papal control. In Gadi Luzzatto Voghera’s review, Ruggero Taradel and Barbara Raggi’s La segregazione amichevole (2000) places the articles in post-1881 political antisemitism and in a “genealogy of the errors of modern civilization,” from the Reformation to communism.
Blood libel, conspiracy, and proposed restrictions
Crepaldi takes ritual murder as the prototype by which a theological charge became a political theme, running in his account through coverage of the Beilis affair in 1914. The Encyclopaedia Judaica notes that Cardinal Lorenzo Ganganelli, later Pope Clement XIV, had judged the blood libel groundless, yet the review wrote of the Jews of Trent “mingling unleavened bread with Christian blood, every year, at Passover,” invoking Simon of Trent. In 1883 it treated the Tiszaeszlár affair as proof “beyond doubt” of Christian blood “in many rituals of the modern synagogue.” Levis Sullam dates Oreglia’s revival of the charge to 1881. He records that in 1900 the Secretariat of State under Cardinal Mariano Rampolla declined to deny it when English Catholics asked, while an internal note beside a Holy Office consultation called ritual murder “historically certain.”
During the Dreyfus affair, in 1898, the review cast Alfred Dreyfus as necessarily a traitor and France as governed by a Freemasonry controlled by Jews, while arguing against expulsion: a people accursed by God had been scattered to testify to Christianity. Levis Sullam finds the same mix in Italian Catholic comment—Judas, ritual murder, deicide, and liberal “impiety”—and, after an early-twentieth-century lull, a revival aimed at Zionists and “Bolshevik Jews.”
Ballerini’s “exceptional laws” included confiscation of rural property, exclusion from schools and newspaper offices, and loss of civil rights. David I. Kertzer, quoting the Jesuit historian Giuseppe De Rosa on articles by Francesco Saverio Rondina and Ballerini, records the claim that Jews were “a foreign nation” and the demand that “civil equality” be revoked because they had “no right to it.” Kertzer argues that conspiracies of domination, economic predation, and special restrictions were modern antisemitism, not a separable religious anti-Judaism. Levis Sullam likewise treats the racial wording, beside deicide and the blood charge, as antisemitism proper.
Twentieth-century continuity and the postwar change of tone
The Encyclopaedia Judaica says the “blood” charges were later dropped but hostility was not. In the mid-1930s the review distinguished a Christian antisemitism from Nazi racial doctrine, yet still wrote that Jews “have become the masters of the world” and that “their prototype is the banker.” In 1937 it asked whether a Zionist state would end a “messianic aspiration to world domination,” and treated conversion as the only solution. Levis Sullam finds the same line in Enrico Rosa’s review of a Nazi edition of Theodor Fritsch’s Handbuch der Judenfrage, which granted a “basis of truth” on the Talmud, Kabbalah, and ritual murder, and in Mario Barbera’s 1937 choice of “friendly” segregation over “elimination,” the latter rejected as contrary to charity and natural law. After the 1938 Italian laws Rosa again separated the Church from Fascist racism while still asking for laws “of exception, not of persecution.”
Wartime silence on the fate of the Jews is described as echoing Pope Pius XII. A 1946 article noted the “unprecedented cruelty of the massacres of Jews and Poles” and the camps, gas, and torture, yet questioned the Nuremberg trials and wrote that Germany, even if it had “set the gunpowder on fire,” had been “historically” compelled to do so. Taradel and Raggi carry the stereotypes through the Nazi and Fascist years and past the Shoah.
The Encyclopaedia Judaica dates a “more dispassionate attitude,” in line with Vatican reconciliation, from the 1950s. De Rosa, in the journal’s 2000 history as quoted by Kertzer, places the change in 1965, after the Second Vatican Council, and calls the earlier articles anti-Judaism—opposition “for religious and social reasons”—rather than racial hatred, while still listing ritual murder, control of governments, and usury. Kertzer treats that distinction, also used in the Holy See’s 1998 reflection We Remember, as a postwar defense that the journal’s political campaign does not support. Luzzatto Voghera cites Giovanni Miccoli for a structural role in Holy See strategy, while doubting that the review stood for the whole Church.
Fascism, racial laws, and war
Accommodation after the Lateran Pacts
The Society of Jesus review did not oppose Italian fascism once the movement held power. Jan Nelis finds negotiation and accommodation: Catholic and Fascist politics overlapped, and no durable Catholic party remained. Writers still treated the sacralization of politics, and some Fascist control of associations, as a “political heresy,” but he finds no rupture, and some commentary suggests an unstable merger of religious and totalitarian aims.
The Lateran Treaty of 11 February 1929 closed the Roman Question, yet the review soon challenged Benito Mussolini’s reading of it. In the 20 July issue, editor Enrico Rosa’s unsigned “Tra ratifiche e rettifiche. La parola del Papa” likened the pacts to the 1801 French concordat and Napoleon’s Organic Articles, and treated Pope Pius XI’s May statements—threatening annulment and correcting what he called erroneous assertions—as the agreements’ authentic sense. On 23 July the prefect of Rome seized that issue for its “general and specific anti-Italian and anti-fascist content.”
The argument over education continued. In May 1931 the regime dissolved the youth groups of Catholic Action; Pius XI answered on 29 June with Non abbiamo bisogno. A 2 September agreement restored the groups but confined them to the spiritual sphere. That protest against a total claim on the young stood beside, rather than in place of, the review’s longer accommodation of the regime.
The 1938 racial turn and press censorship
Before the racial laws, the review separated what the Encyclopaedia Judaica calls Christian antisemitism from Nazi racial theories. It cites 1936 articles calling Jews “masters of the world,” whose prototype was the banker, and a 1937 discussion of Zionism that doubted they would drop an alleged drive to domination; the remedy offered was conversion, not race. That is not Pius XI’s opposition to Nazi racism, which the review did not simply make its own.
In the summer of 1938, as the Manifesto of Race appeared and the Italian racial laws were prepared, two signed articles diverged. Mario Barbera’s “La questione dei giudei in Ungheria” (16 July) said Hungary’s measures had “no connection, either of principles or of procedures,” with National Socialist racial antisemitism, and treated professional quotas as defense of a Christian nation rather than persecution. Antonio Messineo’s “Gli elementi costitutivi della nazione e la razza” (6 August) called reducing the nation to race a materialist theory, defended with “pseudo-historical and pseudo-scientific” arguments by writers of “the racist myth of the new Germany.”
The review’s consultation diary, quoted by its historian Giovanni Sale, records the stop. On 8 August the Rome police, for the Interior Ministry, ordered the printer not to publish further articles against Italian or German racism, even reprints from L’Osservatore Romano, on pain of closure. Comments on race that diverged from the government were also forbidden, and a ban on Pius XI’s speech of 28 July was later lifted by the Ministry of Popular Culture. The director reported the prohibitions to the Secretariat of State. Sale takes the lack of an explicit condemnation of the September laws as obedience to that order. David Kertzer and Roberto Benedetti argue that Church publications, including this Vatican-supervised review, explained support for the laws by rejecting biological distinctions as unchristian while grounding the measures in religion, and that the Fascist press used that authority to build consent. From 1938 the laws defined Jews, removed them from state jobs, teaching, and the mass media, barred marriages with non-Jews, and interned foreign Jews. Enforcement was uneven, but thousands emigrated.
Wartime silence, deportation, and early postwar commentary
From 1939 to 1945 the review’s public silence on the fate of the Jews echoed that of Pope Pius XII. After Italy’s surrender announcement of 8 September 1943, German forces occupied the center and north and in October and November rounded up Jews in Rome and other cities for deportation in the Holocaust. Of about 10,000 Jews in Rome, fewer than 1,100 were deported; from Italian transit camps 4,733 were sent to Auschwitz-Birkenau, of whom 314 survived. The encyclopaedia records no wartime article in the review on those killings.
A 1946 article on the Nuremberg trials (volume 97, issue 2297) named “the unprecedented cruelty of the massacres of Jews and Poles” and “the horror of concentration camps, gas and torture chambers,” while doubting “the very principle and objectivity” of the trials and stating that, even if Germany had “set the gunpowder on fire” diplomatically, “historically, they had been compelled to do so.” Sale’s later reconstruction stresses the August 1938 critique and the censorship that cut it short. That is the journal’s own account. It does not replace the 1936–38 texts, the note of a print ban, or the finding that Catholic papers helped legitimize the Italian laws by separating them from Nazi racism.
From Vatican II to the end of the twentieth century
The conciliar turn under Tucci and Sorge
The Jesuit Roberto Tucci entered the college of writers in 1956 and directed La Civiltà Cattolica from 1959 to 1973, through the Second Vatican Council. A council peritus, he worked on Gaudium et spes, briefed journalists on the texts, and in 1968 became the first Catholic priest to address an assembly of the World Council of Churches. Federico Lombardi later described his task as turning the review from an organ of doctrinal defense into a journal of dialogue, over resistance from older Jesuits. Tucci published little and was remembered chiefly as an editor who set themes. With Vatican II the magazine began a more tolerant exchange with modern culture and widened its subjects to cinema, literature, hell, and animal vivisection. In the same decade the Vatican chose four writers from the college to review thousands of confidential Holy See documents of 1939–45 on whether Pius XII had done enough to help Jews under Nazi persecution. Bartolomeo Sorge joined the college in 1966 and directed the review from 1973 to 1985. A later director, Antonio Spadaro, called him a standard-bearer of the council in Italian public life. At the Church’s first national ecclesial conference, “Evangelization and human promotion” (30 October–4 November 1976), he gave the concluding report on dialogue, the laity, and mission in a secular society, and later said that path had not been followed through.
Italian politics after 1945
After the Second World War the review called for Catholic unity at the Italian polls against the Italian Socialist Party and the Italian Communist Party. Before the 1974 vote on repealing the divorce law, Vatican reviewers judged an editorial prepared under Sorge too sympathetic to Catholics who wanted the statute kept; it was rewritten and then dropped, while the Holy See’s public line remained support for repeal. On 12–13 May the referendum failed to abrogate the law: 59.26 percent of valid votes were against repeal and 40.74 percent in favor.
Spadaro has said Sorge favored “national solidarity,” including cooperation with the Communist Party, over a single confessional party. On 5 April 1982 John Paul II told the college that dialogue should distinguish an error from the person in error, but that the review must avoid “dangerous compromises” and keep separating truth from error. Citing Gaudium et spes, he said the writers should judge political events morally when human rights, the common good, or the Church’s freedom were at stake.
Editors, circulation, and papal review practice
GianPaolo Salvini, who had directed Aggiornamenti Sociali from 1977 to 1981, led the review from 1985 to 2011, twenty-six years and its longest directorship, spanning much of the pontificates of John Paul II and Benedict XVI. In the 1990s circulation was about 16,000 copies in more than 100 countries.
It was never an official Holy See publication, but articles were read at the Vatican before they appeared. Until John XXIII the pope reviewed the drafts; the work then passed to senior officials of the Secretariat of State, and pieces on theology, faith, and morals also went to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Articles were to “harmonize” with Vatican positions, and the pages were sometimes used for diplomatic trial balloons, including on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.
Issues appeared on the first and third Saturday of each month, after proofs had gone to the Vatican and the director had received comments ranging from binding orders to suggestions he could ignore. Pius XII gave those instructions in person to director Giacomo Martegani; John XXIII handed the task to Secretary of State Domenico Tardini. Paul VI still read drafts but left revision to the Secretariat. Under John Paul II the meetings were held by the heads of internal and external affairs; from 1991, with Angelo Sodano secretary of state, lower-ranking officials met Salvini instead. After Tarcisio Bertone took the Secretariat in 2006, control tightened: he blocked articles, including one on the Church in China ahead of a letter from Benedict XVI, and at times commissioned pieces himself.
Organization and publishing
The college, the director, and who may write
The review is produced by a resident community of Jesuits, the Collegio degli Scrittori (College of Writers). Pius IX’s brief Gravissimum supremi of 12 February 1866 erected that college “in perpetuity,” “completely and in everything” dependent on the superior general of the Society of Jesus, for the periodical and other writings in defense of Catholic doctrine and the Holy See. The college and the director remain jointly responsible for what is published. The director is named by the superior general with the Holy See’s approval, and articles other than reviews are signed only by Jesuits.
On 1 October 2023 the Portuguese Jesuit Nuno da Silva Gonçalves, appointed by Superior General Arturo Sosa, became director—the first non-Italian in the post—succeeding Antonio Spadaro, director since 2011, whom Pope Francis named an undersecretary of the Dicastery for Culture and Education. Gonçalves told Avvenire in December 2024 that reviews of books, film, music and art, and also interviews and joint articles, may involve non-Jesuits, but that articles signed only by non-Jesuits were not then planned.
Secretariat of State review
The review is not an official publication of the Holy See. In the early Roman years the paginated issue was usually shown to the pope, who often suggested subjects, without what the review’s history calls a formal prior censorship. By the mid-twentieth century pre-publication reading was routine. The New Catholic Encyclopedia records that articles were examined at the Vatican before publication—by the pope himself until John XXIII, then by senior officials of the Secretariat of State—so that they would “harmonize” with Vatican positions and church teaching, with a further reading, for theology, faith and morals, by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (now the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith).
During the fortnightly years, Sandro Magister wrote in 2007, proofs went to the Vatican in multiple copies and, on the Monday before publication, the director received observations graded as binding, negotiable or discretionary. Pius XII marked proofs himself; John XXIII gave the task to Secretary of State Domenico Tardini; Paul VI still read them but left changes to the Secretariat. After 1991 the meeting was often delegated downward; when Tarcisio Bertone became secretary of state in 2006, articles were again blocked, rewritten or commissioned. Subjects stayed with the Jesuits. What appeared was understood not to contradict the Holy See, not to speak in its name. In January 2025 Adista reported that, after the review became monthly, the Secretariat still cleared proofs and could require amendments.
Periodicity, languages, and Villa Malta
Each issue is a quaderno, numbered continuously from 1850. The review was fortnightly, on the first and third Saturday of the month, and a year was bound in four volumes, until quaderno 4188 of 21 December 2024. From quaderno 4189, in January 2025, it became monthly: twelve issues a year, in three volumes rather than four, each issue sixteen pages longer, with a new design and sections on society and politics, theology and spirituality, church life, the human sciences, science and technology, and the arts and literature. Gonçalves said the slower cycle was meant to leave day-to-day news to other media. The Italian union catalogue of serials lists print ISSN 0009-8167, issued by the Uffizio della Civiltà Cattolica, first in Naples and then in Rome, fortnightly from 1850 through 2024 and monthly thereafter.
Foreign editions are mostly online. Vatican News in September 2023 counted eight, including Japanese, added while Spadaro was director. In December 2024 Gonçalves listed seven besides Italian—Chinese, Korean, French, English, Portuguese, Russian and Spanish—“almost always only online.”
The writers work at Villa Malta, via di Porta Pinciana 1, on the Pincian Hill in Rome. After years in via di Ripetta, director Giacomo Martegani, having consulted the Jesuit general, decided in 1950 to buy the villa, beside Villa Medici, for the community and a library that Corriere della Sera in 2010 described as holding about 600,000 volumes.
Public role in the twenty-first century
The 2013 interview and media influence
The review’s widest audience in the 2010s came from an interview that Antonio Spadaro, its director since 2011, conducted with Pope Francis over three meetings in August 2013 at the Domus Sanctae Marthae in Rome. Spadaro acted for La Civiltà Cattolica, the U.S. Jesuit review America, and other Jesuit journals. The Italian text was approved, then translated, and on 19 September 2013 it appeared in 16 Jesuit publications at once, the English version under the title “A Big Heart Open to God.”
Francis called the church “a field hospital after battle” and said it could not “insist only on issues related to abortion, gay marriage and the use of contraceptive methods,” even though “the teaching of the church… is clear and I am a son of the church.” Pastoral ministry, he said, “cannot be obsessed with the transmission of a disjointed multitude of doctrines.” The New York Times and The Guardian led with that passage. The National Catholic Register printed the longer formulation, including the claim that the teaching was already clear. John L. Allen Jr., in the National Catholic Reporter, wrote that senior officials and bishops then in Rome learned of the text as it broke, and that some pro-life advocates feared a retreat; the next day Francis told Catholic gynecologists that the right to life was a primary value.
Articles in the review are ordinarily read by the Secretariat of State before publication. Allen reported that the editors treated the pope’s approval as making that step unnecessary, and that some bishops resented hearing of the text from reporters. In English, America omitted “It is necessary to broaden the opportunities for a stronger presence of women in the church,” present in the Italian and in the French, German, and Spanish versions. Phyllis Zagano identified the gap; editor Matt Malone called it an inadvertent production error and restored the line online. The British Jesuit site Thinking Faith had the same omission.
Directors, anniversaries, and international editions
On 1 April 2025 the review marked 175 years at Villa Malta, its Rome headquarters, with Italian president Sergio Mattarella and Cardinal Secretary of State Pietro Parolin present.
A message from Francis, read at the opening, called the review a “friendly presence” offering “useful pointers for interpreting world events in the light of faith,” and encouraged “good journalism that listens to all voices.” Parolin recalled its accompaniment of papal teaching since Pius IX, including at the Second Vatican Council, and asked the writers “to dare to open up new paths.”
Spadaro left the directorship on 1 October 2023 after twelve years. Arturo Sosa, superior general of the Jesuits, appointed the Portuguese Jesuit Nuno da Silva Gonçalves, born in Lisbon in 1958, former rector of the Pontifical Gregorian University. Gonçalves told the Italian bishops’ news agency that the directors had always been Italian while the review was only an Italian journal, and that a non-Italian appointment was meant to mark the international turn taken under Spadaro. By then the review, still based on the Italian edition, also appeared in Chinese, Korean, English, Spanish, French, Japanese, Russian, and Portuguese. The same month Francis named Spadaro an undersecretary of the Dicastery for Culture and Education.
Criticism and readership
On 13 July 2017 Spadaro and Marcelo Figueroa, a Presbyterian pastor and editor of the Argentine edition of L’Osservatore Romano, published “Evangelical Fundamentalism and Catholic Integralism in the USA: A Surprising Ecumenism” after Vatican approval. It described an “ecumenism of hate” joining some Catholic integralists and evangelical fundamentalists in the United States. Archbishop Charles J. Chaput of Philadelphia called the essay an exercise in “dumbing down” cooperation on religious freedom, abortion, and marriage, and said that dismissing attacks on religious liberty as a “narrative of fear” sounded “willfully ignorant.” Samuel Gregg, in Catholic World Report, argued that the authors showed an amateur grasp of American religious history and that Secretariat of State oversight had not caught the conflations. Spadaro told America the target was “fringe groups,” and that the question was the mutual manipulation of religion and politics.
The episode fits a wider pattern: a small subscriber base, and argument far beyond it. In his farewell Spadaro called the review a journalistic rather than academic paper that “expresses ‘opinions’” open to debate. Critics have treated those opinions as more than a magazine’s precisely because drafts normally pass the Secretariat of State, so contested editorials are often read as signals from Rome whether or not the pope wrote them.
Historiography
Studies of antisemitism
Much of the scholarship concerns the review’s antisemitism. David I. Kertzer’s The Popes Against the Jews (2001) uses Vatican archives and the Catholic press, especially La Civiltà Cattolica, to argue that Church publications carried religious hostility into a modern political antisemitism of ritual murder, conspiracy, and racialized exclusion. Against the distinction in the 1998 Vatican text We Remember, he holds that this culture helped make the Holocaust possible even though the Vatican never endorsed extermination.
Critics accepted much of that file and rejected the causal step. Owen Chadwick called the evidence on the ghetto, the blood libel, and the Jesuit journal formidable, but wrote that Kertzer had not proved a path from Rome to the Holocaust, which Chadwick placed in German nationalism. José M. Sánchez, in America, called the leap “from Rome to Auschwitz” unproved, while treating the papal restrictions and the review’s campaigns as indefensible. Giovanni Sale, a historian of the review, called the Italian edition a “pamphlet”: selective, and wrong to equate religious anti-Judaism with a racial ideology he said Pius XI, from 1934, had told the journal to oppose.
Ruggero Taradel and Barbara Raggi’s La segregazione amichevole (2000) reads 1850–1945 as “friendly segregation,” placing Jews in a genealogy of modern errors and reusing blood libel, deicide, and greed as political stereotypes. A review for the Società italiana per lo studio della storia contemporanea credited the reconstruction, including chapters on 1930s Spain and prewar Hungary, but doubted that the wider Church matched the journal. Giovanni Miccoli, commenting on We Remember, argued that nineteenth-century Catholic anti-Jewish politics fought emancipation and liberalism together, so that condemning Nazi racism was not the same as condemning antisemitism. Simon Levis Sullam’s 2011 Treccani survey puts Giuseppe Oreglia’s “racial” language and Raffaele Ballerini’s proposed exceptional laws at the center of Italian Catholic antisemitism, from the late nineteenth century through 1938 to the partial break of Nostra aetate.
José David Lebovitch Dahl’s 2003 article and 2008 thesis follow a traditional “image of the Jew,” turned against Italian nation-building, and treat antisemitism as routine by the 1880s; the thesis adds that most of the college did not back the writers who pressed it hardest. A 2013 chapter returns to that disagreement inside the order.
Political and intellectual histories
Francesco Dante’s Storia della «Civiltà Cattolica» (1850–1891). Il laboratorio del papa (1990) pairs a narrative, with Thomism as a reading of modernity, and documents on Luigi Taparelli d’Azeglio and Matteo Liberatore. Émile Poulat described a journal neither fully official nor unofficial, tied to the Secretariat of State under Pius IX and later Pius XII. Roberto Romani reads the tax polemics of 1850–1876 as an anti-Risorgimento theory drawn from Taparelli. Thomas C. Behr’s Social Justice and Subsidiarity (2019) traces Taparelli’s social justice and subsidiarity into later Catholic social thought. Roberto Sani’s Da De Gasperi a Fanfani (1986; revised 2004), the first study of the journal’s postwar archive, places the director—received by the pope every two weeks—and Fathers Martegani and Lombardi beside Andrea Riccardi’s conservative “partito romano.”
The review’s own historical writing
The college has also narrated itself. Poulat noted Giuseppe De Rosa’s anthology of major articles, an internal canon rather than an outside history. Giovanni Sale, a member of the college, used its archive for La Civiltà Cattolica nella crisi modernista (1900–1907) (2001): early pluralism on biblical criticism, closed after Pius X’s election, then a split between political opening and Enrico Rosa’s doctrinal integralism in the modernist crisis. A SISSCO review called the research balanced, while noting Sale’s insider role and a weaker political section. His 2002 reply to Kertzer concedes that anti-Judaism fed intolerance and separates it from racial antisemitism, which he says the Holy See opposed.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Related people
Related organizations
Linked pages by kind
Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.
- People5
- Organizations6