Skip to content
Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association
institution

Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association

The Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA) is a membership organisation of publishers of open access scholarly journals and books…

Expert article

The Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA) is a membership organisation of publishers of open access scholarly journals and books, and of infrastructure and service providers that support that publishing. Its stated mission is to encourage and enable open access as the predominant model of communication for scholarly outputs. The association was launched on 14 October 2008 at an Open Access Day event in London hosted by the Wellcome Trust, after professional open-access publishers and independent scientist- or scholar-led publishers had discussed a joint body during 2007 and 2008. From 2011 it also admitted publishers of open-access books, following discussions with the OAPEN project.

OASPA is a non-profit foundation (stichting) under Dutch law, established on 20 May 2011 with its statutory seat in The Hague, in the Netherlands. The articles of association, set in 2011 and updated in 2013 and 2025, give the legal name as Stichting Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association. The Dutch Chamber of Commerce registration number is 52791092. The foundation is also an overseas company on the United Kingdom register, number FC036514, and opened a UK establishment on 1 April 2019; that register gives the overseas address as Prins Willem-Alexanderhof 5, The Hague. In 2020 OASPA changed its trading name from Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association to Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association.

OASPA names as its founding participants BioMed Central, Co-Action Publishing, Copernicus Publications, Hindawi, the Journal of Medical Internet Research, Medical Education Online, the Public Library of Science, SAGE, SPARC Europe and Utrecht University Library. With the Committee on Publication Ethics, the Directory of Open Access Journals and the World Association of Medical Editors, OASPA issued the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing. The fourth version, dated 15 September 2022, is written for scholarly publications generally and covers websites, peer review, publication ethics, ownership, author fees and marketing.

In October 2013 the journal Science published an investigation by John Bohannon in which a fabricated paper was submitted to open-access journals. Retraction Watch, summarising the study, reported that 304 open-access publishers were targeted and that, by the time of publication, 157 journals had accepted the paper and 98 had rejected it. On 11 November 2013 OASPA said it was ending the memberships of Hikari and Dove Medical Press and placing SAGE’s membership under review for six months, after journals from those three members accepted the paper and OASPA judged their editorial processes insufficiently rigorous. In October 2015 Nature reported a backlash after the open-access publisher Frontiers was added to librarian Jeffrey Beall’s list of questionable publishers.

History

Founding

During 2007 and 2008, publishers of fully open access journals discussed a formal association. OASPA’s account says two groups—professional publishing organisations, and independent scientist- or scholar-publishers—agreed to form one body for business models, tools, and standards. Besides the publishers who became founding members, it says comment was sought from Kevin Haggerty, Lars Bjørnshauge (described as director of Lund University Library), Peter Suber, Jan Velterop, and Heather Joseph of SPARC.

Solomon’s note of 18 September 2008, republished by Suber, places a proposal by himself and Gunther Eysenbach in that spring, running in parallel with work by professional open-access publishers. He wrote that the combined group drafted bylaws and a code of conduct over the summer, thanked Caroline Sutton of Co-Action Publishing for keeping the work moving, credited David Prosser and SPARC Europe with support for the launch, and set the announcement for SPARC’s Open Access Day on 14 October 2008. Unlike OASPA’s later history, his note listed Bjørnshauge and Bas Savenije with SPARC Europe.

The Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association announced the launch on 14 October 2008, with an Open Access Day celebration hosted by the Wellcome Trust in London. The statement, carried the same day on Suber’s Open Access News, described a mission to represent open-access journal publishers through exchange of information, industry standards, business models, advocacy of what it called gold open-access journal publishing, education, and innovation. Voting members had to have signed the Berlin Declaration on Open Access to Knowledge in the Sciences and Humanities or the Budapest Open Access Initiative and to publish at least one fully open-access journal; other supporters were invited as well. The ten founding members were BioMed Central, Co-Action Publishing, Copernicus Publications, Hindawi Publishing Corporation, the Journal of Medical Internet Research (Eysenbach), Medical Education Online (Solomon), the Public Library of Science, SAGE, SPARC Europe, and Utrecht University Library (Igitur). Their representatives were to form an interim board until a general meeting in 2009. The statement noted that the Directory of Open Access Journals then listed more than 3,500 peer-reviewed titles, and cited Springer’s acquisition of BioMed Central and a SAGE–Hindawi partnership. Suber called the launch a “coming-of-age event for gold OA.”

On 18 September 2009 OASPA announced its first elected board, chosen at the first Conference on Open Access Scholarly Publishing: Sutton as president, Saskia Franken of Utrecht University Library as secretary, and Prosser as treasurer. The other directors were Bo-Christer Björk, Matthew Cockerill of BioMed Central, Eysenbach, Mark Patterson of the Public Library of Science, Paul Peters of Hindawi, and Solomon. On 1 December 2009 the association said the BMJ and Oxford University Press had joined, taking membership to 29 full members and 24 associate members.

Incorporation and expansion to books

The association was established on 20 May 2011 as a non-profit foundation (stichting) under Dutch law, with its statutory seat in The Hague. OASPA states that the articles were set in 2011 and updated in 2013 and 2025; the text it now publishes names the foundation Stichting Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association and defines the objects as support for scholarly open-access journals and books. Companies House records overseas company FC036514 as incorporated in the Netherlands under Dutch Chamber of Commerce number 52791092, in the legal form of a stichting, at Prins Willem-Alexanderhof 5, The Hague. The UK entry still uses Stichting Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association and dates a first UK establishment to 1 April 2019.

OASPA states that book publishers approached it in 2010 and that, after discussions with OAPEN (Open Access Publishing in European Networks), it adapted the application, review process, and standing rules so that open-access book publishers could join from 2011. Separate membership criteria for open-access books were reported in 2013, after a session at the 2012 conference. In December 2013 Palgrave Macmillan joined as a full voting member, having published Fungal Disease in Britain and the United States 1850–2000, a Wellcome Trust-funded monograph under a Creative Commons CC BY licence; OASPA’s then president, Paul Peters, connected that admission to the new book criteria. The same round included the University of Adelaide Press, which had adopted Creative Commons licensing for its open-access books.

Name change and later development

Membership moved beyond the specialist publishers of 2008. In September 2012 InfoDocket reported that John Wiley & Sons and 16 other organisations had joined, among them Ubiquity Press, Pensoft, and library-based publishers. On 9 September 2016 it said membership had reached 100, across scholar-led titles, professional open-access publishers, and service organisations, naming SciELO among recent joiners.

Writing on 29 September 2021, executive director Claire Redhead and board chair Jennifer Gibson said the trading name had changed in 2020 from Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association to Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association—replacing “Publishers” with “Publishing”—because the membership had widened beyond publishers to other agencies concerned with open access. The same article marked Sutton’s departure after 14 years, calling her the founding president and the last founding participant still on the board, and noted that Redhead had been the first member of staff from 2012 and executive director from 2016.

The association’s legal entity is a Dutch foundation (stichting). Statutes filed with Companies House, headed as the text in force on 20 May 2011, name it Stichting Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association (Stichting OASPA), with its statutory seat in The Hague. A notarial deed of 19 September 2013 records the same name and seat and Kamer van Koophandel number 52791092.

Companies House lists it as an active overseas company, FC036514, incorporated in the Netherlands under Dutch law, with the Dutch Chamber of Commerce as parent registry and 52791092 as the home number. The legal-form field reads “Stichting (Dutch Foundation) Limited Liabilty”, and the overseas address is Prins Willem-Alexanderhof 5, The Hague, 2595 BE. A United Kingdom establishment, BR021602, opened on 1 April 2019 at 7 Nelson Street, Southend-on-Sea, SS1 1EH, as an international publishers’ trade association. The filing names Claire Redhead as authorised to represent the establishment and to accept service. The latest UK accounts on the register were made up to 31 December 2017.

The 2011 object was to support and represent publishers of scholarly open access journals. The 2013 English articles added scientific and scholarly open-access books and allowed commercial services only where any profit financed the object. The association says the articles were updated again in 2025; the version it publishes uses “Publishing” rather than “Publishers” in the name, says the foundation does not aim to make a profit from its activities as a whole, limits assets to what those activities reasonably require, and applies any surplus on dissolution to the objectives.

Board, officers and staff

That text sets a board of seven to thirteen executive and non-executive members under article 2:291a of the Dutch Civil Code; requires that at least half, rounded up, be employed by participants deriving at least 50 percent of their income from fully open-access journals and books; allows one or two employee executive members beside at least five non-executives; has the board appoint a chair, secretary and treasurer each year from the non-executives; has the council of participants nominate non-executives and the officers nominate executives; limits a term to three years; and leaves non-executives unpaid apart from expenses while they set executive pay. The 2013 articles already contained the 50 percent rule, but the council of members—the filed translation says “counsel of members”—appointed the board, pay was limited to expenses and an attendance fee, and the board could appoint an executive director to draft the budget and carry out decisions, meeting at least twice a year.

Companies House still listed other directors, including Juan Pablo Alperin, Caroline Edwards and Susan Murray, and records Redhead’s appointment as a director on 15 February 2022 and Melvin Kasanrokijat’s on 25 November 2025. Library Journal infoDOCKET reported in May 2016 that the board had made Redhead executive director; she had joined in 2012 as membership and communications manager.

Committees

The 2013 articles placed working groups and committees under standing orders and gave two members of an executive committee, acting jointly, power to represent the foundation, which could also grant powers of attorney. Under the published articles the board may create or end committees and working groups; it decides by an absolute majority when a majority of members are present or represented, with a conflicted member not voting; amendment, merger and dissolution need a three-quarters majority of the full board with no vacancy, and an amendment must be made by notarial deed and filed in the trade register; the foundation is represented by the board or by two board members jointly; and a council of participants gives non-binding advice and has no vote, while the board reports to it at least once a calendar-year financial year.

Membership

Categories

Membership is held by organisations, not by individual journals. OASPA admits professional publishing organisations, scholar publishers, and infrastructure and services providers.

Professional publishing organisations employ at least one full-time paid staff member to manage open-access scholarly journals or books. They may be for-profit or nonprofit, including university presses and libraries that employ publishing staff. Scholar publishers are individuals or small groups, usually running a single journal and often relying on volunteer labour. Infrastructure and services members provide significant services or support for open-access publishing.

Criteria and the application process

Applications are accepted only from publishers of open-access journals or books, or from organisations that provide significant services or support to that publishing. The board revises the criteria, which OASPA says draw on the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, developed with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) and the World Association of Medical Editors (see the standards section).

An applicant’s name must not mislead users. The website must identify ownership and a named contact at a business address, disclose the main sources of revenue, and keep direct marketing, including manuscript solicitation, within the code of conduct. Publishers must state any fees, describe preservation and peer review, and leave content readable without registration, with licence, copyright and citation details on the work. Referees must be independent and external, not publisher staff, and owners must not decide acceptance. Misconduct procedures are to follow COPE or an equivalent. A journal publisher must have at least one fully open-access journal using only a Creative Commons CC BY or CC BY-NC licence, and at least one title in DOAJ, with a findable waiver policy if it charges. Book publishers must use a Creative Commons licence.

The membership committee—board members supported by the secretariat—screens each application, with at least two members reading the file and the full board able to comment. OASPA says it often requires website or licensing changes and has declined applications.

Compliance, complaints and the membership today

Members agree to a code of conduct that bars practices OASPA considers likely to discredit the association or open-access publishing, requires truthful communications, and aligns marketing with the General Data Protection Regulation or equivalent national law, including an unsubscribe option. It also commits members to immediate, registration-free dissemination of peer-reviewed scholarship and strongly encourages CC BY, while allowing a non-commercial restriction for some journals.

A complaint must identify the sender and give specific evidence. The committee assesses it, tells the board before contacting the member, and allows 14 days for a reply. A satisfactory answer leaves status unchanged; an unsatisfactory one can be recommended for termination. If fixes are likely to take months, the committee can recommend “under review” status, usually for six months and shown on the public directory, after which failure to improve ends membership if the board agrees. Appeals to the full board are final, and investigations may cover scholarly publishing beyond open access. The published committee list names Juan Pablo Alperin (Public Knowledge Project), Susan Murray (African Journals Online), Claire Redhead (OASPA), Xenia van Edig (TIB Open Publishing) and Sofie Wennström (Stockholm University Press).

Think. Check. Submit. treats current membership as one checklist item beside COPE and DOAJ, not a sufficient test on its own. Library funds have sometimes used it as an eligibility filter: the 2023 FAQ for Harvard University’s HOPE fund required membership or adherence to the code, and the University of Idaho Library’s fund requires membership or compliance, alongside DOAJ, and excludes hybrid journals.

Standards for publishing practice

Principles of Transparency and Best Practice

The Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing are a joint statement of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), the Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA) and the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME). The version in force is the fourth, published on 15 September 2022 and called a work in progress; earlier versions appeared in 2013, 2015 and 2018. UKSG reported that the revision added detail on websites, peer review, ethics and fees, and was meant to stay achievable for journals of any size, place or discipline.

Sixteen principles, in four groups—journal content, journal practices, organisation and business practices—are said to cover all content, including special issues and conference proceedings; editors must explain any departure. Publishers and editors are told to support accessibility, diversity, equity and inclusivity, and to decide on scholarly merit rather than an author’s nationality, ethnicity, political beliefs, race or religion. A name must be unique and not misleading about origin, scope or associations. The website must use HTTPS, be maintained, and must not copy another journal’s site, design or logo. It must show aims and scope, readership, manuscript types, authorship criteria and ISSNs, keep a stated schedule except in exceptional circumstances, and describe preservation, with PubMed Central and the Keepers Registry as examples.

Copyright terms must be separate from the website’s copyright, with the holder named on the full text. One principle covers licensing: terms on the website and on articles; an open licence for content designated open access; a stated repository policy; and a link from any Creative Commons licence to its terms. Ownership and management must be identified, without misleading names, and any society, institution or sponsor linked. Boards should list recognised experts who have agreed to serve, and be reviewed “to avoid being associated with predatory or deceptive journals.” Editors’ names and a full office address are required. Author fees, such as article processing charges, must be easy to find early, or the journal must state that it charges none; future charges and waivers must be disclosed, and neither may affect decisions. Other revenue, advertising and direct marketing, including solicitation of manuscripts, must be described truthfully. Revenue and advertising must not drive decisions, and advertisements must stay separate from content. OASPA states that the principles feed into every membership assessment, that its board reviews the criteria, and that members must continue to meet them and the association’s code of conduct.

Peer review and publication ethics

Peer review is defined as advice from subject experts who are not part of the editorial team, with details allowed to vary by journal and discipline. Sites must state whether content is reviewed, by whom, and of what type; policies on recommended reviewers, masking, supplements and signed or posted reviews; how decisions are made; and any exceptions, which should also be noted on the article. Acceptance must not be guaranteed, speed claims should match published timeframes, authors must be told of delays and may withdraw, and research should show a publication date, preferably with submission and acceptance dates. OASPA also requires applicants to say how reports are handled and who decides. Review must be external, by experts outside the publisher’s staff; owners should not decide; and OASPA may contact board members or authors about whether practice is rigorous.

Ethics policies must be visible. The principles point to COPE’s Core Practices and ask for statements on authorship, complaints and appeals, misconduct allegations, conflicts of interest, data sharing and reproducibility, ethical oversight, intellectual property, post-publication discussion, and corrections and retractions. Editors and publishers must set procedures for plagiarism, citation manipulation and data falsification or fabrication, must not encourage or knowingly allow that conduct, and should follow COPE’s guidance or an equivalent. OASPA requires the same policies of applicants.

In a 2019 Insights article, Emily Ford argued that posting process information, as the principles suggest, still falls short of a “praxis of transparency,” in which communication and training follow from stated values rather than from a checklist. A 2019 audit of 781 society journals in the Science Citation Index Expanded found that 185 described a detailed review process and 596 did not; single-blind review was the commonest method stated, then double-blind. Ten of 33 items from the 2018 principles were poorly or rarely practised, including revenue sources, disclosed on no more than 20 percent of homepages.

Joint work with COPE, DOAJ and WAME

Each body uses the text with its own tests. DOAJ tells applicants to adhere to the principles and requires a homepage account of peer review, licensing, copyright and author charges, or a statement that there are none. OASPA considers applications only from open-access publishers and from organisations that provide significant open-access services; journal publishers must have at least one fully open-access journal and one DOAJ title. WAME publishes the principles among its policies for medical editors. The United States National Library of Medicine looks for conformance with the principles, which it calls a joint statement of the four organisations, for PubMed Central.

In Ethics in Progress in 2024, Jaime A. Teixeira da Silva and Salim Moussa concluded that the principles give broad guidance but that most remain excessively broad, sometimes vague, or short of examples, despite a slight improvement from 2018 to 2022, limiting practical use. They also wrote that, until September 2022, consequences for members that did not abide by the principles had not been made transparent.

Licensing and definitions of open access

The association’s definition

Members of the Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association acknowledge a common interpretation of open access: peer-reviewed manuscripts are disseminated immediately, at no charge, and without registration or other access barriers. For journals, copyright holders let users copy, distribute, display and adapt the work in any digital medium for any responsible purpose, with attribution.

The reuse clause follows what is often called the BBB definition. The Budapest Open Access Initiative (2002) defined open access as free availability on the public internet for any lawful purpose, with no barriers beyond access to the internet and with copyright limited to integrity and attribution. The Bethesda Statement on Open Access Publishing, released on 20 June 2003 after a meeting at the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, and the Berlin Declaration on Open Access to Knowledge in the Sciences and Humanities of 22 October 2003, kept by the Max Planck Society, require a licence to make derivatives “for any responsible purpose” and deposit of a complete version in an open repository. Bethesda adds that this status belongs to works, not necessarily to journals. The association uses the access and reuse conditions and does not require deposit.

Writing in the 2008 SPARC Open Access Newsletter, Peter Suber called removal of the price barrier alone gratis open access: free to read, with further use left to exceptions such as fair use. Libre open access also removes at least some permission barriers. The BBB statements are one kind of libre open access; a ban on commercial use, or on derivatives, is libre on that scale but not BBB.

Journal and book licence rules

Creative Commons publishes six standard licences. CC BY allows distribution, adaptation and commercial use with attribution. The others add ShareAlike, NoDerivatives, a NonCommercial condition, or a combination.

The association calls CC BY the closest match to its definition and strongly encourages it, but allows a non-commercial restriction for journals where the reasons are compelling. A journal publisher must have at least one fully open-access journal using only CC BY or CC BY-NC, and at least one title in the Directory of Open Access Journals. The licence must be on the website and in every full text, reading must not require registration, and the association may ask why a restriction was chosen.

DOAJ is wider on the licence: it indexes only journals whose entire contents are immediately free, with no embargo and no registration, under a Creative Commons licence or an equivalent, without prescribing which Creative Commons licence.

The code asks them to approach the journal reuse principles where they can, and accepts other practices where the most liberal licences are difficult, as in art history.

Hybrid publishing and non-commercial licences

A hybrid open-access journal keeps a subscription and makes some articles free. The interpretation applies to manuscripts, so a paywalled article fails it and a free article meets it only if the reuse terms fit. Membership requires one fully open-access journal on CC BY or CC BY-NC, not that every title qualifies. A hybrid title meets neither that test nor the DOAJ rule, which admits a former hybrid journal only after a flip to fully open access.

CC BY-NC is therefore accepted for membership while falling short of “any responsible purpose.” Plan S, the cOAlition S funder policy, is tighter. It requires an open licence, preferably CC BY, to meet the Berlin Declaration: CC BY 4.0 is the default, CC BY-SA and CC0 are accepted, and CC BY-ND needs the author’s justification and the funder’s approval. The funders do not support hybrid publishing except, for a defined transition, inside transformative arrangements.

Programs, data and convening

Annual conference

The Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association’s annual conference is its main meeting on open access publishing. The ISSN International Centre describes the event as bringing the open-access community together. After several online years, the 2024 meeting was held in person in Lisbon on 16–18 September at the Altis Grand Hotel. The Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) described an equitable-open-access theme and a discount for DOAJ-indexed publishers. The European Association of Science Editors’ listing named speakers from a U.S. library consortium, Creative Commons and Indian open-access bodies.

Toolkits and joint initiatives

Think. Check. Submit. is a cross-industry campaign, not an OASPA service. It launched on 1 October 2015, coordinated by the Association of Learned and Professional Society Publishers (ALPSP), DOAJ, INASP, the International Association of Scientific, Technical, and Medical Publishers (STM), the ISSN International Centre, the Association of European Research Libraries (LIBER), OASPA, UKSG and individual publishers. Its tools help researchers assess journals, publishers, and books and chapters, and to recognise predatory publishing. Contributors now also include the Association of University Presses, the Committee on Publication Ethics, the OAPEN Foundation and the Society for Scholarly Publishing.

Think. Check. Attend. is a separate conference checklist introduced by Knowledge E and endorsed by Think. Check. Submit. as a sister project on predatory conferences. OASPA does not run it.

The Open Access Journals Toolkit, owned by OASPA and DOAJ, went live in June 2023 after a 2022 consultation managed with Research Consulting. It covers starting and running a journal, indexing, staffing, policies and infrastructure; an editorial board reviews it about every two years, and a 2025 revision added artificial intelligence and accessibility. English, French, Arabic, Portuguese and Spanish texts are online under a Creative Commons Attribution licence except where noted.

Output data and equity recommendations

Each year OASPA surveys member organisations on the volumes they publish in fully open-access journals and hybrid open-access journals, and on the licences used.

For 2015–2024, Delta Think found CC BY on almost 75% of OASPA open-access output, against about 46% in its wider OpenAlex estimate, CC BY-NC-ND on about 15% in both, and Creative Commons licences on more than 99% of member content. Excluding fully open-access journals, CC BY was about 54% and CC BY-NC-ND above 30%, and more than 85% of other content was all-rights-reserved. Elsevier joined in 2022 and Springer Nature left; Delta Think said those shifts change the ratio, the samples are not strictly comparable, and CC BY still dominates on a like-for-like view.

On 3 December 2024 OASPA deposited “(In)equity in open access: OASPA’s recommended practices on financial and workflow barriers” on Zenodo (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.14261488), by Malavika Legge and licensed CC BY 4.0. Five goals cover publishing without author-facing fees; prices and funding matched to ability to pay; plain accounts of how open access is financed; lighter workflows, including waivers; and contact among researchers, publishers and payers. Items are tiered “suggested,” “more helpful” or “better still,” do not all apply—book workflows least of all—and treat money and workflow as only part of equity.

Role in scholarly-communication policy

Advocacy and funder policy

The Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association (OASPA), a membership body of open access publishers, answers funder consultations rather than writing the rules. In 2012 a UK group chaired by Dame Janet Finch recommended gold open access—papers free to read because publication costs are paid—and the government accepted that model, including upfront article processing charges. Research Councils UK’s policy, for articles submitted from 1 April 2013, preferred immediate access and broad reuse. An APC-funded paper had to use a Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) licence; repository deposit could use a non-commercial licence and an embargo, longer in the humanities and social sciences and where APC funds were lacking.

UK Research and Innovation’s policy of 6 August 2021 requires articles submitted from 1 April 2022 to be immediately open as the version of record, including in a hybrid open-access journal, under CC BY, or as the accepted manuscript in a repository with no embargo. Books and chapters from 1 January 2024 were timed separately.

On 25 August 2022 the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy sent federal research agencies updated public-access guidance. The National Institutes of Health policy that followed, effective 1 July 2025, requires accepted manuscripts of funded articles in PubMed Central with no embargo, replacing the 2008 limit of 12 months.

Plan S and cOAlition S

On 4 September 2018 national research funders, with the European Commission and the European Research Council, launched cOAlition S around Plan S, developed with Science Europe. From 2021, publications from participating grants must appear in open-access journals or on open-access platforms, or be available immediately in repositories with no embargo. An intended 2020 start was delayed, and the rules were revised, before aligned mandates began in 2021.

Responses to the implementation guidance, as summarised by The Scholarly Kitchen, included wide concern about the effect on small publishers and learned societies.

“How Equitable Is It?” is not an OASPA tool. A working group convened by cOAlition S, Jisc and PLOS released a beta at OASPA’s conference on 18 September 2024 and an update on 14 May 2025. Users score an arrangement on seven criteria—reading access, immediate open access, participation, reuse, price transparency and open research practices—with no database of journals. The convenors traced it to “How Open Is It?”, the guide SPARC, PLOS and OASPA made so that reader rights, reuse, copyright, posting and machine readability could be compared, rather than treating open access as yes or no.

Relation to other publishing associations

The International Association of Scientific, Technical, and Medical Publishers (STM) is a global trade association of scholarly publishers, about 160 members across commercial, society and university presses and service firms. The Association of Learned and Professional Society Publishers (ALPSP) is the international trade association for not-for-profit scholarly and professional publishers and those who work with them. The Society for Scholarly Publishing, founded in 1978, connects publishers, librarians, editors, technologists and service providers for education and debate, rather than as a trade body for one model.

SPARC, founded in 1998, is a nonprofit with more than 230 library and academic-organisation members in North America, campaigning for open systems in research and education. SPARC Europe is a separate Dutch foundation advocating open access, open science and open education in Europe.

STM and ALPSP speak for a wider publisher interest, including subscriptions and societies; SSP is a cross-sector forum; SPARC and SPARC Europe advocate from the library and policy side. The openness guide is one such collaboration, not a claim that OASPA represents open access as such.

Controversies and criticism

The 2013 Science investigation

On 4 October 2013, Science correspondent John Bohannon reported a sting of fee-charging open-access journals. He had sent 304 versions of a fabricated cancer-biology paper whose flaws, he wrote, any competent reviewer should have seen. By press time, 157 journals had accepted it and 98 had rejected it. Targets came from the Directory of Open Access Journals and from librarian Jeffrey Beall’s list of what he called predatory publishing. Of publishers that finished review, about 82 percent on Beall’s list and 45 percent in the DOAJ group accepted the paper, and about 60 percent of completed decisions showed no sign of peer review. Journals from SAGE Publishing and Elsevier accepted versions; PLOS One rejected the paper after ethics checks, and Hindawi’s Paul Peters told Science that his company’s screening had caught it.

On 11 November 2013 the association published the review. It dropped African Journals Online as a misidentification: AJOL hosted journals and was not the publisher. Three members did have accepting journals—Hikari’s Clinical and Experimental Medical Sciences, Dove Medical Press’s Drug Design, Development and Therapy, and SAGE’s Journal of International Medical Research. The subcommittee found “a lack of sufficient rigour in editorial processes” at all three and said the problems at Hikari and Dove might go beyond one title. It terminated those memberships, with no reapplication for 12 months, and placed SAGE “under review” for six months. It cited that journal’s atypical process, a remaining technical edit likely to catch the flaws, SAGE’s halt on submissions and public explanation, and SAGE’s reputation. The association also added application questions on who assigns reviewers, assesses reports, and accepts papers.

Interviewed the next day by Phil Davis, Bohannon called the SAGE outcome perhaps “a ‘too big to fail’ moment,” while saying the investigation and OASPA president Paul Peters had impressed him. The Bookseller reported on 29 April 2014 that SAGE had been reinstated after adding a peer-review stage at the journal.

Beall’s list and high-volume members

Beall, of the University of Colorado Denver, kept a public list of open-access publishers he considered questionable. After he added MDPI in February 2014, OASPA’s membership committee examined the complaints, including disputed papers in Life and Nutrients, editorial-board listings, and the company’s offices. On 11 April 2014 it said it was “satisfied that MDPI continue to meet the OASPA Membership Criteria.”

Nature reported in October 2015 that Beall had added Frontiers Media journals and that researchers were divided. Associate editor Daniël Lakens said the listing rested on intuition rather than solid data. Beall told Nature he had received dozens of emails alleging bad practice and cited contested papers in Frontiers in Psychology and Frontiers in Public Health. Frontiers answered that it belonged to the Committee on Publication Ethics and to DOAJ, and called Beall a longstanding opponent of open access.

Later argument turned to volume, guest-edited special issues, and research paper mills. Times Higher Education reported in March 2023 that economist Paolo Crosetto had counted 55,985 MDPI special issues with 2023 closing dates across 98 journals with impact factors, including more than 3,500 each at Sustainability and the International Journal of Molecular Sciences. He asked how review could be maintained if one journal were drawing on the order of dozens of papers a day. MDPI’s Giulia Stefenelli said scholars proposed the issues, journals assessed them, and the 2022 rejection rate was near 50 percent. At Hindawi, bought by Wiley in 2021, the breakdown was more specific. Retraction Watch reported that in March 2023 Clarivate removed 19 Hindawi titles from Web of Science after Wiley paused special issues over “compromised articles,” a pause Wiley priced at about $9 million in one quarter. Hindawi later said it retracted more than 8,000 articles in 2023—more, Retraction Watch wrote, than the site had recorded from all publishers combined in any earlier year—from guest-edited issues infiltrated by paper mills.

Quality signalling and conflicts of interest

OASPA has treated membership as a quality signal as well as a trade credential. In November 2013 it cast OASPA and DOAJ as marks of reliable publishing whatever the business model. Davis noted a concrete use of that signal: Harvard’s HOPE Fund, which he described as a model for other library funds, would pay article processing charges only for DOAJ-listed journals whose publishers belonged to OASPA. He told Bohannon the sting showed those conditions were not sufficient.

Bohannon’s “too big to fail” line was a charge that a publisher association would expel small members and only review a large one. The association’s reply was that it had terminated memberships, would do so again when poor practice was shown, and was tightening the questions used at entry. Subsequent cases cut both ways. OASPA investigated MDPI and said the publisher still met its criteria; it did not treat Beall’s listing of MDPI as grounds for removal. Bohannon had described that market as “driven by author publication fees”; Crosetto’s objection was that special-issue volume strains review. Retraction Watch’s account of the Hindawi retractions described Wiley’s cleanup and Clarivate’s delistings, not an OASPA decision to end that membership.

By the · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed