
Phoenix New Times
Phoenix New Times is an alternative newspaper published in Phoenix, Arizona, with a weekly print edition and a website covering local politics, business…
Expert article
Phoenix New Times is an alternative newspaper published in Phoenix, Arizona, with a weekly print edition and a website covering local politics, business, music, and the arts, plus an annual Best of Phoenix issue. It was founded in 1970 as the Arizona Times by Michael Lacey, a dropout from Arizona State University, and a group of counterculture students in Tempe, in response to the Kent State shootings during the Vietnam War. The first press run was 16,000 copies. Jim Larkin, also a college dropout, joined as business manager in 1972.
Lacey and Larkin left after the paper went public, then regained control in 1977 and took the company private with an $800,000 loan from a local savings and loan. Lacey became executive editor and Larkin president. They moved the offices from the Tempe campus to Phoenix and renamed the paper Phoenix New Times. Circulation had dropped from 40,000 in 1976 to 17,000 in 1977; placed free in suburban stores, gas stations, and restaurants as well as downtown, it reached about 140,000 copies a week by the early 1990s.
The Phoenix paper was the start of New Times, Inc., which bought Denver's Westword in 1983 and added other city papers through the 1990s. A company history published in 2002 described New Times as the largest chain of alternative weekly newspapers in the United States by circulation. In October 2005 New Times Media, owner of 11 alternative newspapers, agreed to buy Village Voice Media. The merged company kept that name, with Larkin as chief executive and Lacey continuing as executive editor, and the companies said it would field free weeklies and websites in 17 large markets, with a combined weekly circulation of 1.8 million.
On September 24, 2012, Voice Media Group, a Denver holding company led by Scott Tobias, then chief operating officer of Village Voice Media Holdings, announced an agreement to buy the chain's newspapers, websites, and national advertising business. Phoenix New Times was one of 13 weeklies in the purchase. Backpage, the classifieds site then owned by Village Voice Media Holdings, was left out and was to continue under separate ownership.
The paper's conflict with Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio became a national press story in October 2007. In 2004 Phoenix New Times had reported on Arpaio's real-estate holdings and published his home address; an Arizona law makes it a felony to post a law-enforcement officer's address on the internet, and county prosecutors spent years weighing charges. On October 18, 2007, after Lacey and Larkin published an article disclosing grand-jury subpoenas, including a demand for internet records of people who had viewed the paper's website, sheriff's deputies arrested the two owners on a misdemeanor charge of illegally disclosing grand-jury proceedings. The next day County Attorney Andrew Thomas dropped the charges, ended the investigation, and removed special prosecutor Dennis Wilenchik, saying the inquiry had gone in a direction he would not have authorized. Voice Media Group, the paper's later owner, has said the county paid $3.75 million to settle claims arising from the arrests.
Founding and early years
Student origins and the first issues
The weekly that became Phoenix New Times began in Tempe, Arizona, in the weeks after the Kent State shootings of May 4, 1970, when Ohio National Guard troops killed four students during a protest against the Vietnam War. Michael Lacey, an Arizona State University dropout who had come to Tempe from the New York area, and other students and dropouts around the campus started a counterculture paper for readers they believed the Arizona Republic was not serving.
The paper's initial print run in 1970 was 16,000 copies. Lacey later said that anyone who contributed labor expected a say in the paper.
Jim Larkin, also a college dropout, joined in 1972 as business manager. By February 1974 The New York Times described The New Times as a four-year-old weekly of about 40,000 circulation, read mainly on college campuses around Phoenix and in Tucson and run by separate groups in the two cities. Coverage included Arizona prisons—one reporter held a grant from the Fund for Investigative Journalism—and the dismissal, later undone, of drunken-driving charges against U.S. Senator Paul Fannin. The company, New Times, Inc., was also prosecuted in Tempe for abortion advertisements banned by state law. On July 3, 1973, after Roe v. Wade, the Arizona Court of Appeals set the conviction aside and held the statute unconstitutional.
Financial crisis and the 1977 reorganization
Advertising did not pay the bills. In an intrastate offering licensed by the Arizona Corporation Commission, the company agreed to refund buyers unless it sold 35,000 shares at $1 within six months. It narrowly did so by January 25, 1974, raising $35,000 from more than 200 subscriptions of $10 to $10,000, including a home builder and inmates at the state prison. The Times called the sale what was believed to be the first successful public offering by a paper from the late-1960s underground press. The prospectus said that "maximation of profit" was "no more important than other objectives." Randall Holdridge, 27, of the Tucson group, called the floor an "expansion equation": investors would share the risk or get their money back.
The sale did not steady the paper. Lacey and Larkin left in the mid-1970s, keeping their voting shares. Lacey studied architecture in Boston; Larkin went into printing; an accountant and other shareholders ran New Times. Circulation fell from about 40,000 to about 17,000 by 1976–77.
In March 1977, after planning the step in Mexico, Lacey, Larkin, and allies used their stock and proxies from other dissatisfied holders to call a meeting at the office in the old Casa Loma Hotel on Mill Avenue. They amended the articles of incorporation, named themselves the operating officers, and moved the files to the Westward Ho in downtown Phoenix. The weekly was retitled Phoenix New Times and left the campus for a city paper. Former staff member Renz Jennings, later an Arizona corporation commissioner, said it took another year or more before the paper dropped the premise that it should still be run with an "alternative consciousness." Public shareholders stayed on the books until 1987, when Lacey and Larkin borrowed $800,000 from Western Savings, headed by Gary Driggs, and bought them out at $33 for each dollar share.
Expansion into a national chain
Acquisitions from Westword onward
Phoenix New Times was the base of New Times Inc., the Phoenix company run by executive editor Michael Lacey and president Jim Larkin. The first purchase outside Arizona was Denver's Westword, in May 1983. Founding editor Patricia Calhoun stayed and later said she sold so she could write rather than run the business. Westword was a biweekly of about 40,000 circulation; a company history put the price near $67,000. New Times made it a weekly, added staff, and pushed it from arts coverage toward investigations, and circulation later reached about 100,000.
In September 1987 New Times bought Miami's Wave for a few thousand dollars, renamed it Miami New Times, and spent about $1.4 million on longer investigations. The Dallas Observer, bought in the fall of 1991 for an estimated $3 million, was already profitable at about 85,000 circulation; the four-paper chain then had about 410,000 copies, more than The Village Voice's 172,000. In 1993 an estimated $2.75 million bought the Houston Press, an indebted 1989 startup of about 80,000 circulation.
In January 1995 Scott Price agreed to sell San Francisco's SF Weekly, about 90,000 circulation, with closing set for January 31. New Times replaced editor Andrew O'Hehir with Jack Shafer and said it would hire more writers; Shafer denied criticism that the chain forced a Phoenix template on acquired papers. The same year New Times bought the Ruxton Group, a Chicago firm selling national advertising for alternative weeklies. In 1996 it bought L.A. View and the Los Angeles Reader, dismissed most of both staffs, and combined them as New Times Los Angeles, launched at 100,000 circulation against the LA Weekly's 195,000. Lacey said Los Angeles could support two weeklies.
Later papers were mostly existing weeklies: Broward-Palm Beach New Times, started in 1997; Cleveland Scene and St. Louis's Riverfront Times in 1998, with founder Ray Hartmann kept as editorial chairman while columnists were cut for hard news; and Kansas City's Pitch Weekly in 1999. The chain then had 11 papers and combined distribution of about 1.1 million. In 2001 it added Berkeley's East Bay Express. By year's end New Times had about 950 employees and estimated sales of $120 million.
In October 2002 New Times and Village Voice Media agreed to close rival papers—New Times Los Angeles and the Cleveland Free Times—so each would be alone in one city. On January 27, 2003, the Justice Department's Antitrust Division sued, calling the swap a per se violation of the Sherman Act. A consent decree ended the agreement, let affected advertisers cancel contracts, and required the closed papers' assets to be sold to new publishers. California and Ohio filed parallel cases.
Merger with Village Voice Media
On October 24, 2005, Phoenix-based New Times Media agreed to acquire Village Voice Media, publisher of The Village Voice and five other weeklies. The combination would be 17 free papers with circulation of 1.8 million. No cash changed hands. People involved said the companies together were worth about $400 million, with revenue of roughly $180 million. New Times shareholders would own 62 percent and five of nine board seats, and the business would keep the Village Voice Media name. Larkin would be chairman and chief executive, Lacey would remain executive editor, and David Schneiderman would run the websites. A trust controlled by Larkin and Lacey would hold 53 percent of the shares.
Since 2000 the Voice papers had been owned by investors including Schneiderman and affiliates of Goldman Sachs, Weiss, Peck & Greer, and Trimaran Capital Partners, after earlier owners that included Rupert Murdoch. The Voice, with circulation of about 250,000, was to be the flagship. The other Voice papers were LA Weekly, OC Weekly, Seattle Weekly, City Pages, and the Nashville Scene. Larkin said the merger would let the papers "get stronger and to have stronger content," and that it was not "a financial play." The titles would be about a quarter of the 7.6 million weekly circulation the Association of Alternative Newsweeklies counted among 126 members. Richard Karpel, the association's executive director, said the deal was controversial and that members had no consensus. In Denver, Calhoun said she expected little change at Westword because the paper was local.
The 2003 decree required later deals to be submitted to the government, and the merger also needed review under the Hart–Scott–Rodino Act. On November 28, 2005, the companies announced that the Justice Department had closed its investigation and cleared the merger, which they expected to complete in the first quarter of 2006, and they put combined readership at 4.3 million. Schneiderman said the Voice had lost millions of dollars in classified revenue to Craigslist; the plan reported at the time was to connect the papers with New Times's free-ad site, Backpage, and to sell national advertising through Ruxton.
Ownership, advertising, and the Backpage separation
The 2012–2013 management buyout
On September 23, 2012, Michael Lacey and Jim Larkin, owners of Village Voice Media Holdings, told The Arizona Republic that they had agreed to sell all 13 of the company’s alternative weeklies and leave journalism. The buyer was Voice Media Group, a new company owned by editors and publishers from the chain, incorporated in Colorado, with editorial direction set in Denver. The next day both sides announced that Voice Media Group would buy the weeklies, their websites, and the national advertising division, which it would rename VMG National. Financial terms were not disclosed, and Village Voice Media’s lawyer, Liz McDougall, said the agreement would be finalized later. Phoenix New Times later dated the employees’ purchase to 2013; Voice Media Group says the new owners took control in 2012.
The Republic identified Scott Tobias, then Village Voice Media’s president and chief operating officer and publisher of Westword, as the new chief executive. The company’s announcement named Christine Brennan, executive managing editor for more than 19 years, as executive editor, and Jeff Mars, vice president of financial operations, as chief financial officer. The 13 titles included Phoenix New Times, the Village Voice, LA Weekly, Westword, the Dallas Observer, Miami New Times, New Times Broward-Palm Beach, and six others. Lacey, then 64, called selling to peers less painful than selling to outsiders and described the move as “a retirement from journalism,” saying Backpage litigation had kept him from the newsrooms. He called the site a distraction rather than a liability for the papers; the Republic reported boycotts and lost advertising in some markets.
Classifieds, Backpage, and the founders’ later cases
Backpage.com was excluded from the sale. Lacey and Larkin kept it, and Village Voice Media said it would be the centerpiece of a separate online classified company; Voice Media Group said the site would have separate ownership. The Republic reported that Backpage had grown out of paid classifieds on the back page of the New Times papers, and that its adult listings had drawn lawsuits, protests, and accusations of promoting sex trafficking. Lacey denied that the company knowingly promoted crime, said staff screened illegal ads and answered subpoenas within 24 hours, and declined to disclose revenue; the Republic said some observers estimated tens of millions of dollars a year.
The Associated Press later reported that Lacey and Larkin sold their Backpage interest in 2015, while prosecutors said they retained control. A federal grand jury in Phoenix charged Backpage principals in March 2018, and the United States Department of Justice said the United States seized the site that April, calling it the leading online forum for prostitution ads from September 2010, after Craigslist closed that section, until the seizure. The Republic reported a 93-count indictment that April charging Lacey and Larkin with facilitating prostitution and money laundering, and a Justice Department seizure notice on the site. Carl Ferrer, Backpage’s chief executive, pleaded guilty in April 2018 to conspiracy to facilitate prostitution and money laundering; Backpage.com LLC and related companies pleaded guilty to money-laundering conspiracy. The department’s account named Backpage executives and companies, not Voice Media Group.
Larkin died by suicide on July 31, 2023, at 74, in Superior, Arizona, days before an August 8 retrial; police told the Republic he died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound, and the Justice Department later noted that he died before trial. A 2021 trial had ended in a mistrial after Judge Susan Brnovich found that prosecutors had emphasized child sex trafficking, which was not charged. On November 16, 2023, a Phoenix jury returned verdicts the department announced the next day, saying Lacey, Scott Spear, and John “Jed” Brunst were convicted on multiple counts in a scheme that earned more than $500 million. The Associated Press reported a narrower result for Lacey alone: one count of international concealment money laundering, a deadlock on 84 other counts, Judge Diane Humetewa’s later acquittal of dozens of charges for insufficient evidence, and about 30 counts still pending. On August 28, 2024, Humetewa sentenced him to five years in prison and a $3 million fine. His lawyers said he had run the newspaper chain rather than Backpage day to day; the judge said he knew of the allegations and did nothing.
Voice Media Group and the paper today
Voice Media Group, still privately held and based at 1278 Lincoln Street in Denver, says the 2012 change of control was followed by sales of the Village Voice, SF Weekly, and Seattle Weekly and by the 2013 launch of V Digital Services, a digital-advertising agency. It lists Phoenix New Times, Westword, the Dallas Observer, Miami New Times, and New Times Broward-Palm Beach among its publications. Scott Tobias remains chief executive and president, the office the company says he has held since the buyout. Kurtis Barton, executive vice president of sales strategy and based in Phoenix, is listed as the paper’s publisher. The staff page names no local editor-in-chief; it lists Daryl Kahn as senior editor for news and Jennifer Goldberg as senior editor for culture, and it lists Chelsey Dequaine-Jerabek as the company’s executive editor and Sam Eifling as national editor.
Format, staff, and coverage
Print weekly and the newsroom
Phoenix New Times is the alternative weekly in Phoenix, published by Voice Media Group. In 1996, Editor & Publisher described the New Times papers—the Phoenix weekly was the first of six to open a website—as distributed free, and said many readers used them as entertainment guides, for listings and dining as well as investigative stories local dailies were not pursuing. A Ruxton advertising kit, citing a 2018 Alliance for Audited Media audit, called the Phoenix paper a weekly whose issues were dated Thursday and distributed Wednesday, through racks and street boxes. The paper has described those boxes as red-and-yellow newsracks, says its journalism is free to readers, and says a late-1990s decision to publish on the web first turned the operation into a daily newsroom while the print issue continued.
Editing has rested with a small local staff under the chain’s executives. In October 2007 the New York Times identified Michael Lacey as executive editor and Jim Larkin as chief executive of Village Voice Media, the owner of the weekly. Patti Epler has written that she took an editor’s job at the paper in 1997 and left in 2004 for the East Valley Tribune. Rick Barrs joined New Times in 2002 after a decade as an editor at the Los Angeles Times; when the Tribune named him managing editor in April 2018, it said he had been editor-in-chief at Phoenix New Times and Los Angeles New Times. Stuart Warner, a Pulitzer Prize winner then coaching writers at The Arizona Republic, became Phoenix editor-in-chief on January 23, 2017. Amy Silverman has written that she spent 25 years there as a staff writer and editor and edited Best of Phoenix.
Arizona Mirror reported in January 2020 that David Hudnall had become editor at the start of that year, and that the Phoenix editorial staff of about a dozen had asked the company to recognize a NewsGuild-CWA unit shared with Miami New Times. A directory current as of September 2026 named no local editor-in-chief. It listed Kurtis Barton as publisher, Daryl Kahn as senior editor for news, Jennifer Goldberg as senior editor for culture and Best of Phoenix editor, and Tirion Boan as food and drink editor.
Arts, music, food, and cannabis
Arts and leisure copy has been part of the ordinary paper, not only the annual guide. Columbia Journalism Review described New Times papers as known for vivid cultural criticism as well as investigations. Staff seeking a union in 2020 said their work included telling readers where to eat, hear live music, and see art. The site groups that reporting under food and drink, arts and culture, music, and cannabis, alongside news.
Best of Phoenix
Best of Phoenix began as a 1979 supplement. The paper’s archive of the 2000 edition calls that issue the 22nd annual and dates the first supplement to 1979. It is a once-a-year print and online package of staff choices, not a single ranked poll.
Staff picks and a readers’ poll have run as separate parts of the package. A 1996 trade-press account described such guides as the way free alternative weeklies competed with dailies on entertainment and dining, not as an official civic ranking.
Investigative reporting
Early investigations and the Arizona Project
On June 2, 1976, Don Bolles, an investigative reporter for The Arizona Republic and a founding member of Investigative Reporters and Editors, was mortally injured when a bomb exploded under his car outside a downtown Phoenix hotel. He died on June 13. IRE sent journalists to Arizona to continue his land-fraud and organized-crime reporting, not to solve the killing. Robert W. Greene of Newsday led the team. IRE later counted 38 journalists from 28 news organizations. The New York Times and The Washington Post declined to participate, and some journalists criticized the project as a crusade.
The 23-part series debuted on March 13, 1977. The Republic did not run it. A front-page statement said the paper had not obtained sufficient documentation and proof for the series' "statements and allegations." Greene told The New York Times the decision showed that in Phoenix "people are not given an opportunity to know what's going on there." He said the Republic and the Phoenix Gazette had offered files, supplies, and three reporters, two of whom helped write the series; the Republic said neither paper was a participant. The opening articles alleged widespread corruption and charged that Senator Barry Goldwater had condoned organized crime in the state.
IRE's history calls the Arizona Daily Star in Tucson the sole Arizona newspaper to publish the series, with many other outlets using Associated Press copy from March 18. Michael Wendland of the Detroit News, a participant, wrote in his 1977 book The Arizona Project that KTAR-TV featured the stories, KOY radio read them nearly verbatim, and New Times devoted two entire issues to them. Former Republic columnist Jon Talton later wrote that New Times ran the series and kept reporting on the case for decades, including work by Jana Bommersbach, John Dougherty, Tom Fitzpatrick, and Paul Rubin.
Maricopa County law enforcement
From the 1990s the paper's longest law-enforcement subject was Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio and the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office. A 1998 American Journalism Review profile quoted editor Jeremy Voas on staff writer Tony Ortega, who tested Arpaio's claim that pink inmate underwear saved thousands of dollars and, Voas said, found internal sources the Republic had not used. Voas said inmates were dying in the jails, settlements were costing the county millions, and the weekly had pushed the daily toward tougher coverage. Republic editors did not comment.
In July 2004 Dougherty reported that Arpaio had invested $690,000 in cash in commercial real estate while earning $72,000 and a modest federal pension, and that details of the commercial holdings had been removed from public records. Posted on the web, the article included his home address. The New York Times later noted an Arizona statute barring online publication of an officer's address when it poses "an imminent and serious threat." That article later drew a criminal inquiry from the county attorney's office.
The paper also sued for records. In Phoenix New Times, L.L.C. v. Arpaio (2008), the Arizona Court of Appeals held that the sheriff's office violated the public-records law by subjecting nine New Times requests to arbitrary delays, often beyond 100 days, and sent the case back for a ruling on bad faith and fees. The Times, describing the same feud, quoted an East Valley Tribune count that more than 60 county jail inmates had died since 2004, many of illnesses treatable in ordinary medical settings.
Other major local stories
The sheriff was not the only subject. The same journalism-review profile said New Times had been "beating up on" Governor Fife Symington long before the Republic. A grand jury indicted Symington on June 13, 1996, on 23 counts of fraud and extortion, alleging false net-worth statements used to obtain or renegotiate development loans and pressure on union pension funds over a $10 million obligation. He denied the charges. On September 3, 1997, a jury convicted him of seven felony fraud counts, and he resigned. The Ninth Circuit overturned the convictions in 1999 because the trial judge had dismissed a holdout juror, and on January 20, 2001, President Bill Clinton pardoned him.
Another series concerned a charity. Christianity Today reported in 1999 that the shaky finances of the Baptist Foundation of Arizona, tied to the Arizona Southern Baptist Convention and the Southern Baptist Convention, had come to light in a Phoenix New Times investigation the magazine dated to 1997. Reporter Terry Greene Sterling described more than 60 corporate shells, insider loans, and land deals kept from a board of pastors. President William Crotts called the paper "quite anti-Christian" and tied the reports to "attacks from Satan." Regulators halted securities sales in 1999. In July 2006 a county jury convicted former president William Pierre Crotts and former counsel Thomas Dale Grabinski of three fraud counts each and of running an illegal enterprise, in what prosecutors called the largest fraud aimed at a religious group: about 11,000 investors and about $585 million. They were acquitted of 23 theft counts. Auditor Arthur Andersen agreed in 2002 to pay Arizona $217 million over its foundation audits.
The 2007 arrests and press-freedom litigation
Subpoenas and the October arrests
The dispute began with 2004 reporting on Joe Arpaio, then sheriff of Maricopa County. John Dougherty’s “Sheriff Joe’s Real Estate Game” questioned Arpaio’s cash investments in commercial property; a follow-up printed his home address, which remained available online after he had redacted it from some county records. Arpaio sought charges under an Arizona law against posting a peace officer’s personal information on the web when doing so poses an imminent and serious threat reasonably apparent to the publisher. Prosecutors did not file. County Attorney Andrew Thomas later said he referred the file to the Pinal County Attorney’s Office because of his conflict with the paper and, when that office did not act, hired Phoenix lawyer Dennis Wilenchik in 2007 as special prosecutor.
In August 2007 Wilenchik served demands styled as grand jury subpoenas. As later recounted by the Ninth Circuit from the publishers’ complaint, they sought confidential sources and reporters’ notebooks on critical Arpaio stories, and information about website visitors since 2004. The New York Times reported requests for domain names, browsers, and other reader data since January 1, 2004; the Reporters Committee, citing the Associated Press, added identities, browsing and buying habits, and reporters’ notes. A county grand jury was sitting, with Judge Anna Baca presiding, but these subpoenas were not its work. On November 28, 2007, she found Wilenchik had neither obtained the grand jury’s consent nor given the ten-day notice to its foreperson and the presiding judge required when a prosecutor subpoenas alone. She wrote that no grand jury had approved them and that he had “acted as a one-man grand jury.” She had already quashed the subpoenas and imposed no further penalty.
On October 18, 2007, executive editor Michael Lacey and chief executive Jim Larkin published the subpoenas in Phoenix New Times, then owned by Village Voice Media. They wrote that authorities might treat publication as illegal, “but there are moments when civil disobedience is merely the last option.” That night plainclothes sheriff’s deputies arrested both men at their homes for the misdemeanor of disclosing grand-jury information. Larkin told the New York Times there was no warrant; spokesman Capt. Paul Chagolla said Wilenchik had requested the arrests.
Lucy Dalglish of the Reporters Committee called the reader demands “breathtaking in its flouting of the Constitution,” and Clint Bolick of the Goldwater Institute called the subpoena “a gross abuse of government power.” On October 19 Thomas dropped the charges, ended the investigation, and removed Wilenchik. He said the case had “gone in a direction that I would not have authorized” and that there had been “serious missteps,” while still calling the address story “wrong and possibly illegal,” and said he had not known of the arrests or the subpoena’s breadth. In 2008 the University of Oregon named the paper a co-winner of its Ancil Payne Award for Ethics in Journalism.
Civil suit, appeals, and settlement
In April 2008 Lacey, Larkin, and Phoenix New Times, LLC sued Arpaio, Thomas, Wilenchik, and the county under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and state law. After removal, District Judge Susan R. Bolton dismissed the federal claims and returned the state claims to superior court. A divided panel affirmed in part and reversed in part, Lacey v. Maricopa County, 649 F.3d 1118 (9th Cir. 2011); the court then granted en banc review, 663 F.3d 1032 (9th Cir. 2011).
On August 29, 2012, Judge Jay S. Bybee’s en banc opinion affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded, accepting the complaint as true. Lacey v. Maricopa County, 693 F.3d 896 (9th Cir. 2012). Wilenchik had no absolute immunity for subpoenas issued without grand-jury or court approval, or for ordering or advising the warrantless arrests, which the court treated as advice to police rather than advocacy. The complaint stated First Amendment retaliation, Fourth Amendment false arrest, and Fourteenth Amendment selective-enforcement claims against Wilenchik and Arpaio, and qualified immunity did not bar them on the pleadings. Of the allegations, the court wrote that it was “hard to conceive of a more direct assault on the First Amendment than public officials ordering the immediate arrests of their critics.” It dismissed malicious-prosecution claims because the plaintiffs alleged an arrest but not a later criminal case, dismissed federal racketeering claims, and held Thomas absolutely immune for the appointment. It reversed only the with-prejudice dismissal of a conspiracy claim against Thomas, with leave to amend, and remanded county liability and the state claims. Chief Judge Alex Kozinski, and Judge Richard C. Tallman joined by Judges Bea and Ikuta, dissented in part.
The claims were not tried. On December 20, 2013, the county agreed to pay Lacey and Larkin $3.75 million, the Associated Press reported, within more than $7 million in settlements that day in suits accusing Arpaio of abuse of power, including $3.5 million for former supervisor Don Stapley. In December 2014 Lacey said on Arizona PBS that $2 million would endow the Mike Lacey–Jim Larkin Chair in Borderlands Issues at Arizona State University’s Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication, for bilingual reporting on immigration and Latino communities, and that other settlement money was going through the Frontera Fund to migrant-rights groups.
Awards and influence
Phoenix New Times has not won a Pulitzer Prize. Pulitzer results sometimes grouped with its publishing chain belong to other papers. In 2007 Jonathan Gold of LA Weekly won the Pulitzer for Criticism for restaurant reviews, the first Pulitzer for that Los Angeles alternative weekly. Film critic Peter Rainer was a 1998 finalist in Criticism for writing at New Times, then a Los Angeles weekly, not for work published in Phoenix.
The Phoenix paper’s national honors have come from other contests. In 2008 the University of Oregon School of Journalism and Communication named it a winner of the Ancil Payne Award for Ethics in Journalism in the news-organization category, shared with Spokane’s Spokesman-Review. Poynter and the university’s Daily Emerald reported that the award recognized the paper’s refusal to turn over to a grand jury detailed information about visitors to its website.
Antonia Noori Farzan and Joseph Flaherty shared the 2017 George Polk Award in immigration reporting, conferred by Long Island University, with Maria Perez of the Naples Daily News. The citation was for revealing that Motel 6 locations in Phoenix had given guest rosters to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents; the Sidney Hillman Foundation had given the same reporting its October 2017 Sidney Award. Investigative Reporters and Editors listed John Dickerson of Phoenix New Times/Village Voice Media as a finalist, not a winner, in the 2008 contest’s local-circulation weeklies category, for “Prescription for Disaster,” on physician oversight, and “Arpaio Jails,” on jails under Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio.
Dickerson and Sarah Fenske also won Livingston Awards recorded by the Wallace House at the University of Michigan. Dickerson’s 2009 award for local reporting was for “The Doctor is Out”; Fenske’s 2011 local-reporting award was for “Mr. Big Stuff,” on the housing director of Maricopa County.
In the contests of the Association of Alternative Newsweeklies, later the Association of Alternative Newsmedia, Phoenix entries have won alongside sister papers such as Miami New Times and LA Weekly; those sister-paper prizes are not Phoenix New Times prizes. For work in the Phoenix paper, John Dougherty’s “Dark Days on Black Mesa” was first in environmental reporting among papers over 54,000 circulation in 1998. Paul Rubin’s “Rent a Patient” was first in in-depth news story, over 50,000 circulation, in the 2004 contest. Dickerson’s “Prescription for Disaster” was first in investigative reporting, circulation 50,000 and over, in 2009, when Sarah Fenske also took first place in the large-circulation column category. In 2010 Amy Silverman was first in health reporting for “The Lost Kids” and Fenske was again first in columns; Lauren Saria was second in food writing, circulation 45,000 and over, in 2016 for “Wok Away”; and Valeria Fernandez was first in immigration coverage in 2018. Saria’s placement is an alternative-press contest result, not a James Beard Award, and it is separate from Gold’s criticism Pulitzer at LA Weekly.
In Arizona the comparable field is the Arizona Press Club, where the weekly is judged with The Arizona Republic and other state outlets. In 2013 the club’s Virg Hill Arizona Journalist of the Year award went to the Republic’s Bob Ortega; John Dougherty, credited to InvestigateMEDIA and Phoenix New Times, was first runner-up. In the club’s 2017 contest, Farzan and Flaherty won the Don Bolles Award for investigative reporting. Those statewide prizes have gone to the weekly, the Republic, and smaller Arizona newsrooms in different years, while Dickerson, Fenske, Farzan, and Flaherty did Phoenix reporting later recognized by Livingston, Polk, Hillman, and alternative-press juries.
Digital publishing and circulation
The website and daily news
Phoenix New Times was the first of New Times Inc.’s six alternative weeklies to open a website. Editor & Publisher reported on March 11, 1996, that the Phoenix, Arizona, paper had gone online the previous week in a soft launch. Director of electronic publishing Braxton Jarratt’s staff built the site in-house and served it from the company’s own computer on a T-1 line into the Phoenix office. The strategy he described was an advertising-supported entertainment guide, with movie times, ticket prices, dining listings, and reviews stored so readers could search them, aimed at daily newspapers he said were weaker on listings. The company’s other papers—Westword in Denver, San Francisco Weekly, the Dallas Observer, the Houston Press, and Miami New Times—were to follow at about one title a month on the same model.
The paper has said that in the late 1990s it shifted to web-first publishing and that the change “turned us into something we’d never been: a daily newsroom,” while the print edition stayed weekly. On the same page it reports that phoenixnewtimes.com draws more than one million monthly active users and that a reader-membership program, begun in 2020, has not put the site behind a paywall. A sales kit from advertising representative Ruxton has described the site as giving a daily account of local stories and has named a music blog, Up on the Sun. In September 2012, managers of Village Voice Media bought the weeklies, Phoenix New Times among them, and formed Voice Media Group. Backpage, the online classifieds business, was not included and remained with founders Jim Larkin and Michael Lacey. The Pew Research Center likewise reported that Backpage was excluded from that sale. TheWrap described the publishing side as struggling with the downturn in print advertising.
Print distribution and readership
The paper is free. A company history in the International Directory of Company Histories says that, after copies were racked at suburban convenience stores, gas stations, and restaurants and later in downtown Phoenix, weekly circulation reached 140,000 by the early 1990s. The chain’s papers relied on advertising rather than a cover price.
Public figures after that are lower. For 2012, Pew reported a Phoenix New Times circulation of 91,355, up 0.14 percent, and called it the only increase that year among the largest alternative weeklies. In the same account, combined circulation of the top 20 free papers in the Association of Alternative Newsmedia, a group that included Phoenix New Times, fell 8 percent, and Pew noted that Phoenix New Times and several sister papers had moved to glossy covers. For 2014, Pew listed a publisher’s statement of 67,096, down 16 percent from 2013; the table cited the Alliance for Audited Media, Verified Audit Circulation, the Association of Alternative Newsmedia, and the Circulation Verification Council. For 2015, Pew placed the paper with audited titles at 69,187, using the most recent 2015 statements (or the matching 2014 month) from those same organizations.
A Ruxton kit, citing an Alliance for Audited Media audit and a summer 2018 Media Audit, said the paper then distributed 36,000 controlled copies a week across the Phoenix market, including Mesa, Tempe, Chandler, Avondale, Goodyear, Glendale, and Peoria, from more than 2,400 racks and street boxes. The kit dated issues Thursday, listed distribution as Wednesday, and gave weekly print readership as 108,000. No later public audit was found. The paper’s membership page states that it still distributes 32,000 free copies a week and that funding comes from print and digital advertising together with reader contributions, with the site kept free of a subscription fee.
Criticism and controversies
Editorial disputes and competitive practices
In March 1990, Washington Post columnist Richard Harrington reported that Phoenix New Times writer David Koen interviewed state senator Jan Brewer by phone after identifying himself as Doug MacEachern, a Mesa Tribune political columnist, and recorded her reciting explicit lyrics. The weekly played that recording, set to a rap track, at a rally outside the Arizona Capitol protesting her bill to ban sales of explicit recordings to minors and to require warning labels. Harrington wrote that the paper was being criticized for breaching journalistic ethics by allowing the impersonation.
The chain that published the paper also drew federal antitrust action. In October 2002, NT Media, whose weeklies included Phoenix New Times, and Village Voice Media agreed to shut each other’s papers in Los Angeles and Cleveland. In January 2003 the Department of Justice sued, calling the swap a per se violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act, and proposed a consent decree requiring them to end the agreement, let advertisers cancel contracts, and sell the closed papers’ assets.
New Times, which had grown out of Phoenix New Times, bought SF Weekly in 1995, and the San Francisco Bay Guardian later alleged below-cost ad sales meant to drive it out of business. A 2008 jury found that SF Weekly and its parent had sold advertising below cost with intent to harm the Guardian and had caused financial injury; the court set the award at $16 million. The parent appealed, refused to pay or post bond, and the Guardian seized assets, including delivery vans and half of SF Weekly’s monthly advertising revenue.
Reputation after the founders’ prosecutions
In 2012 Lacey and publisher Jim Larkin sold the newspapers, including Phoenix New Times, to executives who formed Voice Media Group, and kept Backpage. Voice Media Group did not own Backpage. The sale announcement said Backpage was “not part of the buyout” and would continue under separate ownership. Lacey said he and Larkin were not investors in the buyer and answered “absolutely not” when asked about any business or advisory tie. They called the site’s legal fights “an enormous distraction” to the papers.
In April 2018 a 93-count federal indictment included charges against Larkin and Lacey for facilitating prostitution and money laundering, and authorities seized the site. Chief executive Carl Ferrer pleaded guilty and admitted Backpage had been designed to facilitate prostitution. The founders invoked publisher protections in the Communications Decency Act. Larkin said they had “never, ever broken the law” and described the case as a free-press fight, arguing prosecutors had targeted them for the newspapers’ journalism.
U.S. District Judge Susan Brnovich declared a mistrial in 2021, ruling that prosecutors had emphasized child sex trafficking rather than the charges. Larkin, 74, died on July 31, 2023, of a self-inflicted gunshot wound in Superior, Arizona, days before an August 8 retrial, and was not tried to a verdict. Superior police confirmed the death.
At a 2023 retrial a jury convicted Lacey, then 76, of one count of international concealment money laundering and deadlocked on 84 other counts. Judge Diane Humetewa acquitted him of dozens of charges for insufficient evidence; about 30 remained. On August 28, 2024, she sentenced him to five years and a $3 million fine. Prosecutors alleged $500 million in prostitution-related revenue and said moderation concealed the ads; Humetewa told Lacey he had known of the allegations and “didn’t do a thing.” His lawyers said he ran the newspaper chain and not Backpage’s daily operations. Co-defendants John Brunst and Scott Spear each received 10 years. In November 2024 the Ninth Circuit granted Lacey, who had surrendered on September 11, bail pending appeal on a $1 million bond. The panel found a substantial question of whether a reported $16.5 million transfer to a bank in Hungary was concealment, and it denied bail to Spear and Brunst.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Related people
Related organizations
Facts mentioned
Linked pages by kind
Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.
- People3
- Organizations12+
- Facts1