Ernst Klee
Ernst Klee (15 March 1942 – 18 May 2013) was a German journalist, author, documentary filmmaker and social pedagogue born in Frankfurt.
- Facts0
- Drivers0
- Indicators0
Ernst Klee (15 March 1942 – 18 May 2013) was a German journalist, author, documentary filmmaker and social pedagogue born in Frankfurt.
Ernst Klee (15 March 1942 – 18 May 2013) was a German journalist, author, documentary filmmaker and social pedagogue born in Frankfurt. He spent decades documenting the murder of disabled and mentally ill people in Nazi Germany, medical experiments on prisoners, and the later careers of people who took part in those crimes. The historian Richard J. Evans wrote that Klee entered areas of modern German history that most academic historians had avoided.
He left school early, trained as a heating technician, and later passed the Abitur in order to study Protestant theology and social pedagogy. In the 1960s and 1970s his reporting concerned people pushed to the margins of West Germany, including homeless people, psychiatric patients, prisoners, residents of old-age homes and people with disabilities. From 1973 to 1982 he taught courses on the education of disabled people at a Frankfurt technical college. The jury of the Geschwister-Scholl-Preis later described his 1974 Behinderten-Report as a standard work on what it called the largest marginalized group in West German society.
That reporting led him into the history of Nazi “euthanasia.” „Euthanasie“ im NS-Staat. Die „Vernichtung lebensunwerten Lebens“ (1983) drew on archival material that had been little known and made his name internationally; Evans reported that the book went through eleven German editions within two years. It described doctors’ part in identifying people who were killed in gas chambers at isolated mental hospitals during the Second World War, in the programme known as Aktion T4. Auschwitz, die NS-Medizin und ihre Opfer (1997) documented experiments on concentration-camp prisoners and prisoners of war at Auschwitz and named both the doctors and sponsors in the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, the pharmaceutical industry, and research institutes of the SS and the Wehrmacht. With Willi Dressen and Volker Riess he published Those Were the Days: The Holocaust as Seen by the Perpetrators and Bystanders (1988), the only one of his books translated into English, a collection of letters, diaries and other accounts of killings in eastern Europe during the Holocaust. Das Personenlexikon zum Dritten Reich (2003) contains about 4,300 entries, including postwar lives that many works of reference had omitted.
Klee died at the age of 71 in his Frankfurt apartment after a long illness; S. Fischer Verlag announced the death. His last book, which he had authorized, Auschwitz – Täter, Gehilfen, Opfer. Ein Personenlexikon, was scheduled for August 2013. He received the Geschwister-Scholl-Preis on 24 November 1997 for the Auschwitz medicine book, and in 2001 the Goethe-Plakette of the City of Frankfurt for a book on the postwar careers of Nazi doctors. A school for disabled people in Mettingen, near Osnabrück, was renamed in his honour in 2005. With his wife, Elke Klee, he decided that his papers should go to the memorial at the former Hadamar killing centre; the estate, including notes on about 20,000 people, was transferred there in 2018.
Ernst Klee was born on 15 March 1942 in Frankfurt am Main and died there on 18 May 2013. Those dates are also given in Walter H. Pehle’s obituary in Die Zeit and in Richard J. Evans’s obituary in The Guardian. The Munzinger archive lists him as Protestant and as coming from Frankfurt. Pehle, his editor at S. Fischer from the late 1970s, described the birthplace as a working-class quarter of the city and headed a 2021 lecture “Ernst Klee (1942–2013) aus Rödelheim.”
Evans wrote that Klee left school early and became an apprentice plumber. Munzinger specifies an apprenticeship as a sanitary and heating technician (Sanitär- und Heizungstechniker). Pehle’s 2013 Zeit obituary called the training a plumber’s apprenticeship (Klempnerlehre); in the 2021 lecture he said Klee held that trade’s journeyman’s certificate (Gesellenbrief).
He then took the Abitur as an external candidate. Munzinger states that, while still working, he gained the university entrance qualification (Hochschulreife) by 1966 on the second-chance route (zweiter Bildungsweg).
Before that qualification, the German National Library catalogues him, with Otto Merk, as an author of Damals in Peenemünde: An der Geburtsstätte der Weltraumfahrt. Ein Dokumentarbericht (Gerhard Stalling Verlag, Oldenburg and Hamburg, 1963, 120 pages). The library’s author heading is the Ernst Klee born in 1942. The subtitle presents the Peenemünde Army Research Center as the birthplace of space travel, and the book has a foreword by Walter Dornberger and an afterword by Wernher von Braun. An English edition, The Birth of the Missile: The Secrets of Peenemünde, translated by T. Schoeters, was published in 1965 by E. P. Dutton in New York and by Harrap in London, with an introduction by von Braun.
Munzinger states that Klee then studied Protestant theology and social pedagogy in Mainz and Marburg until 1970. He financed the studies with various jobs and also served as a commissioner of the church in Hesse for guest workers (Beauftragter der Hessischen Kirche). Pehle later wrote that Klee broke the studies off in disappointment, while continuing to take up social questions in practical work. Evans’s Guardian obituary instead places “courses in Protestant theology and social work training” at Frankfurt Technical College, in the same sentence as Klee’s teaching there on the education of disabled people from 1973 to 1982.
Munzinger dates the start of his journalism to the 1960s, later above all for Die Zeit and the Frankfurter Rundschau. His wife was Elke Klee. In September 1975 he published the Zeit essay “Ich bin eine männliche Pfarrfrau,” describing himself as the husband of a woman pastor. In January 2019 the Frankfurter Rundschau reported that his widow, Elke Klee, had given his papers to the Hadamar memorial, and the same week identified Elke Klee, a former pastor of the Cyriakus congregation, as a speaker at a memorial in Frankfurt-Rödelheim.
By the end of the 1960s Ernst Klee had fixed on the subject of his journalism: realities that majority society in West Germany denied or pushed aside, including those of guest workers, homeless people, patients in psychiatry and disabled people. He wrote above all for Die Zeit and the Frankfurter Rundschau, and for reportage on people then classed as Nichtsesshafte he traveled with them. Hadamar, which holds his papers, and his later editor Walter Pehle list the same groups: homeless people, psychiatric patients, prisoners, disabled people and guest workers. While studying he also served as a commissioner of the Hessian church for guest workers.
Patmos published the guest-worker volume Die Nigger Europas in 1971, its title a racial epithet for the position Klee ascribed to migrant labor; he edited Gastarbeiter: Analysen und Berichte for Suhrkamp in 1972, with Die armen Irren, on people with mental illness. In 1973 came Gastarbeiter-Reportagen, Knast-Reportagen and Resozialisierung, a handbook on work with prisoners and people released from prison; Der Schrotthaufen der Menschlichkeit (Patmos, 1976) was a reader of reports on social reality in the Federal Republic.
A Zeit article of 20 September 1974, “44 Jahre in der Anstalt warum eigentlich?”, followed a woman held for decades whose 1935 papers still asked whether she was “hereditarily ill” and sterilized. Psychiatrie-Report (Fischer, 1978) and Pennbrüder und Stadtstreicher (Fischer, 1979) put the institutional and homelessness reporting into book form.
Disability-rights organizing in the Federal Republic did not begin with Klee. Swantje Köbsell, writing for the Federal Agency for Civic Education, traces an earlier strand in the Clubs of Disabled People and Their Friends, federated from 1971, and treats the Frankfurt courses as one further early politicization. In 1973 the social worker August “Gusti” Steiner, a wheelchair user because of progressive muscular dystrophy, planned a course with Klee and Wolfram Helmer of the Frankfurt Volkshochschule./jubilaum-50-jahre-vhs-kurs-bewaltigung-der-umwelt) “Bewältigung der Umwelt,” for disabled and non-disabled participants together, began in January 1974 and drew about seventy people; its point was to treat barriers as changeable features of the environment, not as a private deficit./jubilaum-50-jahre-vhs-kurs-bewaltigung-der-umwelt)
Gusti Steiner with participants in a Volkshochschule course on disability and barriers.
Actions came quickly. On 1 February 1974 participants tested the inaccessible main post office on the Zeil; the journalist Annedore Smith later recalled the office’s first reply as a question whether disabled people had postal needs at all./jubilaum-50-jahre-vhs-kurs-bewaltigung-der-umwelt) On 18 May, at the Hauptwache, Steiner stopped a tram by placing his wheelchair on the tracks./jubilaum-50-jahre-vhs-kurs-bewaltigung-der-umwelt) Participant Georg Gabler told the Frankfurter Rundschau that a WDR crew was present and that Steiner stayed about half an hour in the rush hour, explaining by megaphone what it meant not to be able to board. Later that year an appeal signed by Helmer and Klee invited people to ride in the baggage car, as wheelchair users had to on trains, and a Christmas satire offered to “rent” disabled people as festive props./jubilaum-50-jahre-vhs-kurs-bewaltigung-der-umwelt)
From 1978 to 1980 the course awarded a mock prize, the “Goldene Krücke,” to people or organizations judged especially hostile to disabled people. The first, in 1978, went to the HUK motor-insurers’ association for a seat-belt slogan, “being crippled for life is worse than death,” which the organizers treated as reviving talk of “life unworthy of life.” Participants included Christa Schlett, whose memoir Klee supported, and Gabler, who later called the course a model beyond Frankfurt. After moving to Dortmund, Steiner joined the January 1981 protest that chained disabled activists to the stage of the Westfalenhalle and blocked Federal President Karl Carstens at the opening of the United Nations International Year of Disabled Persons.
By the late 1970s, “Krüppelgruppen” associated with Franz Christoph and Horst Frehe excluded non-disabled people, arguing that expert power and charity kept disabled people as objects of administration. That current also criticized Klee. In Puls in 1981 the Swiss activist Lorenzo Piaggio wrote that a televised Golden Crutch ceremony had “garnished” the stage with wheelchair users while the non-disabled journalist spoke from the podium, and he called the scene paternalism. Klee stepped back as course leader after 1980; former participants, Gabler among them, took over, and the class continued into the early 1980s, by which time the law student Theresia Degener, later central to the 1981 Krüppeltribunal, had joined./jubilaum-50-jahre-vhs-kurs-bewaltigung-der-umwelt)
From 1973 to 1982 Klee held a teaching appointment in disability pedagogy at the Fachhochschule Frankfurt. Randgruppenpädagogik (Matthias-Grünewald and Patmos, 1973) was a pedagogy for work with outsiders. Behinderten-Report appeared in 1974 in the S. Fischer Verlag paperback series “Informationen zur Zeit,” and Patmos the same year published Behindertsein ist schön, which included Steiner’s essay of that title, adapting a slogan of the U.S. civil-rights movement. The second report, “Wir lassen uns nicht abschieben”: Bewusstwerdung und Befreiung der Behinderten, followed in the Fischer series in 1979; a taz obituary later called it an initial impulse for the German disability movement.
S. Fischer published the handbook Behindert: Über die Enteignung von Körper und Bewusstsein in 1980. The same year Klee edited Behinderte im Urlaub? Das Frankfurter Urteil, on a regional-court ruling that had cut a holiday price because other guests’ disabilities were said to have spoiled the plaintiffs’ rest; a demonstration on 8 May 1980 drew about 5,000 people./jubilaum-50-jahre-vhs-kurs-bewaltigung-der-umwelt) Pehle later recalled that by 1980 Klee had written seven books and numerous articles on disabled people’s disadvantage and was, in the editor’s phrase, written out on the subject—the point at which their talks turned to the same groups under National Socialism.
For Verspottet, produced by Sender Freies Berlin, Klee and Bernd Liebner shared book and direction. In 1982 both received an honorable mention (ehrende Anerkennung) at the Grimme-Preis. The jury said the film showed the problems of disabled people in their immediate surroundings, and praised a double structure: a reporter’s observation set against the subjects’ self-presentation. A related 1983 book, Verspottet: als Liliputaner, Zwerge, Clowns, edited by Klee and Liebner from texts by Ortrun and Erhard Schott, took its title from the mockery of people of short stature.
His youth book was the source for Der Zappler (1982/1983), a 72-minute feature directed by Wolfram Deutschmann, not a documentary by Klee. Deutschmann and Reinhild Paul wrote the screenplay, with dramaturgical work by Konrad Schrage; Hessischer Rundfunk was a co-producer. Twelve-year-old Stefan, described as spastically paralyzed, has moved with his mother, played by Monica Bleibtreu, and meets hostility from other children. After learning that a hoped-for operation is hopeless, he leaves the hospital in an electric wheelchair; a near-drowning at a pool then brings a cautious closeness. Shown on 20 February 1983 in the children’s section of the Berlin International Film Festival, it received honorable mentions from the CIFEJ and UNICEF juries, opened in cinemas on 29 April 1983, and was first broadcast on ARD on 12 May 1986.
In 1993 Klee turned to institutions. Catalogs record Hölle von Ueckermünde – Psychiatrie im Osten as his 45-minute color reportage for Hessischer Rundfunk. ARD broadcast it as Die Hölle von Ueckermünde. The taz of 19 April 1993 reported that the 14 April broadcast had condemned conditions in the town’s home for disabled people. The Diakonisches Werk called the filming of naked residents discriminatory, noted that it had taken over the house only in September 1992, and said forty years of neglect had left deep marks. Management announced legal action, and staff rejected the image of a closed institution, which they said no longer existed in the German Democratic Republic. On 23 April the paper reported that patients in Hamburg’s forensic ward at AK Ochsenzoll collected bedding, clothes, and personal objects after the film. It described people crowded into large halls without separated sanitation or privacy, many deformed by years of restraint, in a large clinic of the former GDR three years after the Wende.
On 26 July 1988, at 23:00, ARD showed Alles Kranke ist Last, by Klee and Gunnar Petrich, on the churches and the “destruction of life unworthy of life.” Its listing said that from 1933 to 1945 some 400,000 people labeled hereditarily ill were forcibly sterilized and at least 200,000 disabled people killed by gas, poison, or starvation diet, until Allied troops arrived. Klee and Petrich argued that both the Protestant and the Catholic churches had already denounced the victims as inferior before the National Socialists, that church institutions had assisted the destruction, and that many of the murderers remained church members. The taz noted material not previously shown, including footage it judged very probably filmed by the perpetrators themselves so that the mass murder could be presented as deliverance.
The next year Klee and Petrich made „Judenrein“: die Protestanten und die Judenverfolgung, catalogued as a 1989 Hessischer Rundfunk television recording of 36 minutes, mostly in black and white, on the Protestant churches and the persecution of the Jews. In 1995 the same broadcaster issued Klee’s film report Sichten und Vernichten: Psychiatrie im Dritten Reich, 44 minutes and partly black and white.
Ärzte ohne Gewissen: Menschenversuche im Dritten Reich (1996), Klee’s 58-minute color documentary for Hessischer Rundfunk, was reviewed by the taz on 22 October 1996 as a Sunday ARD broadcast at 23:10. Writing against what it called the fiftieth anniversary of the Nuremberg proceedings against Nazi physicians, the Doctors’ Trial, the paper described a film without swelling music, moralizing commentary, or sobbing survivors. Names, files, and biographies were set beside photographs of mutilated victims, tissue sections from executed women of the resistance, research papers, and shots of two gas chambers built only for medical research, then beside the physicians’ postwar careers. Klee, the review said, touched the present only by mentioning complaints from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft about obstacles to genetic engineering and embryo research.
In 1983 S. Fischer Verlag in Frankfurt published Ernst Klee’s »Euthanasie« im NS-Staat. Die »Vernichtung lebensunwerten Lebens«, the book that made him internationally known and that Deutschlandfunk later called a standard work on the targeted killing of disabled people. The program it reconstructed was the secret enterprise its staff called “T4,” or Aktion T4, after the coordinating office at Tiergartenstraße 4 in Berlin. Adolf Hitler signed an authorization, backdated to 1 September 1939, meant to shield participating physicians and administrators from prosecution; under Philipp Bouhler and Hitler’s physician Karl Brandt, the office set up six gassing installations for adult patients: Brandenburg, Grafeneck, Bernburg, Sonnenstein, Hartheim and Hadamar.
T4’s own internal calculations, as reported by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, record 70,273 institutionalized patients killed at those six centres between January 1940 and August 1941. The Stiftung Denkmal für die ermordeten Juden Europas states that more than 70,000 people died in that phase before the action was interrupted on 24 August 1941, and that a further 90,000 patients in the German Reich were then killed by starvation, neglect and medication; it treats “T4” as only part of the crime and notes a research estimate of about 300,000 victims in Europe, with reliable figures still lacking especially in the east. At Hadamar, gassings began on 13 January 1941; the memorial records more than 10,000 patients murdered there by 24 August 1941, and nearly 15,000 people killed at the site from 1941 to 1945. Clemens August Graf von Galen, bishop of Münster, denounced the killings on 3 August 1941; the Museum writes that protest led Hitler to order a halt later that month, without ending child killings—at least 10,000 dead—or later murder by overdose and injection.
Klee’s Fischer editor Walter Pehle recalled a manuscript several fingers thick from a writer of social reportage, on ground he had assumed belonged to professional historians. The book sold more than 150,000 copies, pushed research on Nazi crimes, and sharply attacked scientists of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society. In June 1985 Fischer issued Dokumente zur »Euthanasie«, a 342-page volume edited by Klee, printing at greater length texts only briefly quoted in 1983, plus files and photographs from holdings long treated as lost or hidden, and stressing that hundreds had joined the killing voluntarily while thousands had known and stayed silent. Staff who had proved reliable in this first mass-murder program later formed a prominent part of the German personnel at the Operation Reinhard centres of Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka; planners of the murder of the Jews also adapted the gas chamber and crematoria developed for T4.
On 1 November 2010 Fischer issued a fully revised 736-page paperback, »Euthanasie« im Dritten Reich, in which, the publisher stated, anonymized names were identified, gas vans were shown in systematic use against patients from autumn 1939, the psychiatric “disposal” of SS men who broke down and the Wehrmacht’s handover of sick soldiers were described, and short biographies traced specialists later transferred to Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka.
Auschwitz, die NS-Medizin und ihre Opfer appeared from S. Fischer in 1997 as a 526-page hardback. Thomas Gerst, in Deutsches Ärzteblatt, wrote that after the documentations of the Nuremberg Doctors’ Trial by Alexander Mitscherlich and Fred Mielke (1947 and 1949), human experimentation had not again received a comprehensive account. He credited Klee with a minute description of experiments physicians carried out in the concentration camps, Auschwitz among them, and argued that the more disturbing finding was the web of links to renowned researchers, institutes and pharmaceutical companies: the medical elite had known more than it would admit after 1945. Survivors lived with the physical and psychological consequences, while many doctors and scientists involved directly or indirectly continued or built careers in postwar Germany undisturbed. Gerst added that Klee withheld broad explanations and warned against turning the perpetrators into monsters; many were researchers tempted by the chance to experiment on people at a previously unimagined scale, Josef Mengele among them, a twin researcher who used prisoners as laboratory material.
On 24 November 1997 Klee received the Geschwister-Scholl-Preis for the book at Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität Munich. The jury called the documentation sober and meticulous, identified the victims above all as concentration-camp prisoners and prisoners of war, and said the perpetrators were drawn from the elite of German medicine, most of whom continued their careers unhindered after 1945. It added that Klee named not only the physicians but their patrons in the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, the pharmaceutical industry, and the laboratories and institutes of the SS and the Wehrmacht. Deutschlandfunk reported that Mengele regularly sent organ specimens and blood samples to his supervisor, the twin researcher Otmar Freiherr von Verschuer, at the Kaiser Wilhelm Society—reconstituted after 1945 as the Max Planck Society—and that Klee had already in the 1980s pressed that institution’s part in racial research and in the killing of patients, and the successor society’s long silence.
Was sie taten – Was sie wurden. Ärzte, Juristen und andere Beteiligte am Kranken- oder Judenmord (Fischer Taschenbuch, September 1986, 356 pages) closed the trilogy; the publisher said it drew almost exclusively on court files and some perpetrators’ letters, following doctors, lawyers and administrators who lived on unrecognized or unmolested—some shielded by lenient judges or by certificates that blocked prosecution, others restored to ministries, the bench, practice or medical training.
Deutsche Medizin im Dritten Reich. Karrieren vor und nach 1945 followed from S. Fischer on 19 September 2001 (416 pages). The publisher described little-known crimes and their cover-up, naming about 750 people from the wider perpetrator milieu, from racial hygiene through Hadamar, Auschwitz and Treblinka, including psychiatry, brain research, blood-group studies and Mengele’s experiments, and wrote that the DFG and figures in the Max Planck Society had minimized their role while perpetrators were courted and victims disparaged again. Robert Jütte, in Deutsches Ärzteblatt, treated part of this as familiar from the earlier books but reset in a larger frame and extended with new archival finds. He summarized Klee’s through-line as the claim that victims remained despised and insufficiently acknowledged, whereas perpetrators were seldom prosecuted and sometimes highly respected, returning to practice through whitewashing certificates (“Persilscheine”) or changes of name. Jütte also noted Klee’s evidence that the German Medical Association had not examined carefully enough some recipients of its Paracelsus Medal, including physicians who had prettified their role under the Third Reich or who belonged to the narrower circle of perpetrators left unpunished.
In Allied denazification, a Persilschein was the colloquial name for a certificate that someone had nothing to answer for. The Duden traces it to the detergent Persil and the image of washing clean, originally a certificate of the denazification authorities. Under the American-zone liberation law of 5 March 1946, respondents were sorted into five groups, from major offenders to the exonerated, with Mitläufer liable only to fines. On Bavaria, Paul Hoser writes that both churches opposed the purge early; that Catholic clergy, including bishops, issued exoneration certificates so freely that the practice amounted to sabotage; and that the Protestant church was generous as well.
Klee’s Persilscheine und falsche Pässe: Wie die Kirchen den Nazis halfen (Fischer Taschenbuch, 1 November 1991) was based on the manuscript of a television film of that title. The publisher reprints a Publik-Forum report of 17 May 1991: representatives of the two large churches had agreed to act together against Klee’s “especially unpleasant” documentaries for Hessischer Rundfunk, which the paper said exposed church entanglement in “euthanasia” and antisemitism and organized help sending Nazi figures to Latin America. The same report said the films broke a smoothed picture of unified official resistance, and that scoffers in higher church ranks called the new cooperation a “Reinwasch-Ökumene.”
How far church offices directed the escapes remains disputed. In a 2014 Deutschlandfunk feature, Karl-Joseph Hummel described Franz Stangl, commandant of Sobibor and Treblinka, arriving in 1948 at Santa Maria dell’Anima in Rome, where Bishop Alois Hudal took a curriculum vitae that omitted the camps and supplied a visa and a travel paper of the International Committee of the Red Cross; Stangl reached Syria, then Brazil. Hummel called “Odessa” a fiction and said the Vatican itself did not issue false passports: a chain of recommendations ran from South Tyrol to Rome and Genoa, and the Red Cross issued papers to people already vouched for. Hudal, quoted there, said he was a priest, not a policeman, obliged to shield refugees from communism. Reviewing Gerald Steinacher, Richard J. Evans wrote that priests around Hudal arranged “denazification through conversion” and that Pius XII looked away, the Vatican archives for those years still being closed. The broadcast quoted Klee’s line that resistance the Catholic Church had not offered under the Nazi Party it made up after 1945, on the perpetrators’ side.
Was sie taten – Was sie wurden: Ärzte, Juristen und andere Beteiligte am Kranken- oder Judenmord (Fischer Taschenbuch, 1 September 1986, 356 pages) closed Klee’s trilogy on the killing of people labeled “life unworthy of life,” using court files and some perpetrators’ letters to follow doctors, lawyers and officials in West Germany. The publisher states that some lived on unrecognized or undisturbed, that others found lenient judges or physicians whose certificates blocked prosecution, that some participants were later employed in criminal prosecution, and that named people returned to ministries, the highest courts, practice and teaching.
A jurist Klee treated outside that medical frame was Harry Haffner. After Roland Freisler was killed on 3 February 1945, Haffner, general public prosecutor at the higher regional court in Kattowitz, was named in March 1945 to succeed him at the People’s Court. In Die Zeit in 1987 Klee wrote that Haffner, born on 28 May 1900, received the Kattowitz post in 1944 and the presidency from Adolf Hitler at 44, then lived from 1945 or 1946 in Sontra, Hesse, as Heinrich Hartmann. The town, the ministry, domestic intelligence and the judiciary kept the secret, Klee wrote, and locals who knew still would not speak.
In 1988 S. Fischer Verlag published »Schöne Zeiten«. Judenmord aus der Sicht der Täter und Gaffer, edited by Klee with Willi Dreßen and Volker Rieß. A 1992 New York Times review of the English edition said the title comes from the private photo album of Treblinka commandant Kurt Franz.
The National Library contents list divides the documents into public killings around the Einsatzgruppen and the extermination centers. The first part includes Johannes Blaskowitz’s notes on occupied Poland, Franz Stahlecker on a pogrom in Kaunas, the Jäger report, Babi Yar, gas vans, statements on the “legend” of Befehlsnotstand (that refusal to shoot would have been punished), Felix Landau’s diary, executions watched as a public show, and the murder of children at Bjelaja-Zerkow, with reports by Wehrmacht chaplains. The second covers Chełmno, Bełżec, Sobibor and Treblinka, including statements by Kurt Franz, and Auschwitz: Maximilian Grabner’s claim that he joined in killing about three million people only out of consideration for his family, the diary of SS physician Dr. Kremer, and Rudolf Höss on gassings and the removal of mass graves.
The Internet Archive lists the 1991 New York Free Press translation as “The Good Old Days”: The Holocaust as Seen by Its Perpetrators and Bystanders, crediting Klee, Willi Dressen and Volker Riess. The Times review, noting a foreword by Hugh Trevor-Roper and Deborah Burnstone’s translation, called the book horrible but necessary, and said the editors documented men who refused to kill Jews and were not severely punished.
From 2003 until a book issued after his death, Klee published three biographical dictionaries with S. Fischer Verlag in Frankfurt. Each asked what its subjects had done before 1945 and, where the record allowed, what became of them afterward.
Das Personenlexikon zum Dritten Reich. Wer war was vor und nach 1945 appeared in 2003 (ISBN 978-3-10-039309-8). Bernd-A. Rusinek counted 731 pages and Armin Nolzen 735; both reported 4,300 entries. Richard J. Evans, in The Guardian, cited the same figure and “startling details about the postwar lives of its subjects, which had been hidden from view by many academic works of reference.” A paperback in Die Zeit des Nationalsozialismus followed on 1 November 2005 (Fischer Taschenbuch, ISBN 978-3-596-16048-8, 736 pages), still listing 4,300 entries.
Rusinek called the volume 25 years’ work and Klee’s account of the “societal elite” of Nazi Germany. Entries, Nolzen wrote, gave birth and death dates, Nazi Party membership and functions, the role in the Nazi state, and the post-1945 career when known, often quoting the subject or a superior. Sources were not always named; some were unpublished files. Literature, court files and, for science, files of the German Research Foundation supplied the material, and a bibliography and glossary of Nazi institutions closed the book. The preface, as Rusinek summarized it, began with the physiologist Rudolf Thauer, whom Klee tied to human experiments and whose name had been given to a street in Bad Nauheim: ordinary encyclopedias, Klee argued, had “radically completed” a failed denazification by omitting Nazi pasts.
Coverage was uneven. In Rusinek’s sample of 433 names under “B,” about 31.5 percent were physicians and life scientists, 15 percent administrators, civil servants and lawyers, and 12 percent the apparatus of repression, including the Gestapo and the camps; smaller groups were SS leaders, natural scientists, humanities scholars, theologians, party officials, Wehrmacht personnel and businessmen. Post-1945 data existed for about three quarters, with many continuities in West Germany and some in East Germany. Nolzen judged medicine and science the strong side—the anatomist Robert Herrlinger returned to a chair in Kiel—and resistance, film and propaganda the weak one. Without a count of who remained in office, he wrote, the book suggested that Nazi elites had passed largely unscathed into both postwar states.
Das Kulturlexikon zum Dritten Reich. Wer war was vor und nach 1945 (S. Fischer, 2007, ISBN 978-3-10-039326-5) was advertised, in the jacket text carried by Perlentaucher, as 715 pages and 4,000 entries; Anselm C. Heinrich’s review counted 720 pages. A revised paperback of 1 September 2009 (ISBN 978-3-596-17153-8, 650 pages) was described as updated to about 3,600 entries, with a glossary. It covered leading figures in the nobility, archives and libraries, the visual arts, film, scholarship, literature, music (including light and military music), radio and theater, plus hundreds of people banned, exiled or murdered, and postwar careers where they could be traced. Selection drew on specialist literature and on Joseph Goebbels’s 1944 Gottbegnadeten-Liste of favored artists, which brought material privileges. Klee called the book a “lexical memorial” (lexikalisches Mahnmal); Rudolf Walther, in the Frankfurter Rundschau, thought the phrase no understatement.
Heinrich summarized the method as short notices from obituaries, newspapers, files and Goebbels’s diaries, concerned to expose injustice and careers in both German states rather than to stay neutral. Examples ran from Heinz Rühmann and Herbert von Karajan to Kurt Knittel, an SS junior leader who organized entertainment at Auschwitz from 1941 and later joined the board of a music college. Frank-Rutger Hausmann found the tone “enlightening and not always neutral.” Heinrich thought tags such as “front poet” and “art thief” sometimes too blunt, and exiles less fully treated than perpetrators; Walther questioned people outside culture or long dead before 1933.
On 18 May 2013 S. Fischer announced that Klee’s last authorized book would appear that August as Auschwitz – Täter, Gehilfen, Opfer. Ein Personenlexikon. It was published the same year as Auschwitz. Täter, Gehilfen, Opfer und was aus ihnen wurde. Ein Personenlexikon (ISBN 978-3-10-039333-3), again in Die Zeit des Nationalsozialismus. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum catalog records 506 illustrated pages, a bibliography on pages 493–499, an index, and a list of SS members whose duties were barely known.
Christoph Kopke counted more than 4,000 short lives: several thousand SS men of every rank in the Auschwitz complex, from Oswald Pohl and Enno Lolling, called in the review the camps’ chief physician, down to clerks, guards and camp doctors, plus about 400 prisoners, including functionaries and victims of medical crimes. Barbara Möller, in Die Welt, gave 4,043 profiles, 3,621 of them perpetrators, running from the Jewish Sonderkommando prisoner Mois Aaron to the SS rifleman Stefan Zwolinski, with an appendix of further SS men by birth date and rank. The point, quoted by Kopke from page 10, was that prisoners had been known by number and guards by rank. Möller described the method as cross-reference among survivor memoirs, including Ruth Klüger and Primo Levi, trial files and prisoner records. From the preface she quoted his line, “What we can hardly bear to have to describe, people had to experience in their own bodies.”
In a 2013 obituary, the historian Richard J. Evans credited „Euthanasie“ im NS-Staat (1983) with breaking a West German medical claim that only a “perverted handful” of doctors had joined the killing of disabled and mentally ill people. He wrote that the book named a wide circle of participants, became a bestseller and went through eleven German editions in two years. Evans set him against the “conventional German professor,” an informal outsider who, he argued, had entered subjects many academics avoided and become “something akin to the conscience of a reunited Germany.”
Michael Burleigh, reviewing Auschwitz, die NS-Medizin und ihre Opfer in Die Zeit in 1997, called Klee’s work the most impressive German contribution to the literature on Nazi medicine since the late 1970s, and likened the three-volume account of the euthanasia programme to Raul Hilberg’s Die Vernichtung der europäischen Juden. He praised the book’s archival range, but wrote that it still lacked an ethical frame and an explanation of why the physicians acted as they did. For H-Soz-Kult, Bernd-A. Rusinek treated the 2003 Personenlexikon as the work of a non-historian who had opened that medical-crime research, and judged its merits far greater than its defects.
Readers of the Personenlexikon questioned proportion more than the careers it recorded. In sehepunkte, Armin Nolzen called the roughly 4,300 entries a Herculean compilation, strongest on doctors and scientists, but only conditionally recommendable: resistance figures such as Dietrich Bonhoeffer were thin or reduced to evidence of cooperation, many SS biographies looked copied from secondary glossaries, and Hitler received about eighteen lines, with no synthesis of who actually continued after 1945. Rusinek’s sample of the letter “B”—433 names, 429 of them men—put about 31.5 percent in medicine and the life sciences and about 3.5 percent in business, a skew he tied to Klee’s own research rather than to Nazi elites. He also objected to setting later victims beside perpetrators—the émigré Charlotte Bühler near camp guards, and Bonhoeffer and Martin Niemöller included—yet found the charge of career continuity hard to refute.
The churches answered the 1991 ARD film Persilscheine und falsche Pässe, shown on Good Friday, more sharply. An NDR feature of 1992, quoting Publik-Forum of 17 May 1991, reported that representatives of the German Bishops’ Conference and the Council of the Evangelical Church in Germany had agreed on joint action against Klee’s “besonders unangenehme” documentaries; scoffers in senior ranks, the paper said, called that cooperation “Reinwasch-Ökumene.” In an open letter read on the broadcast, the Protestant theologian Jürgen Fangmeier wrote that even if part of the documentation were right, the film had pilloried the church, mixed pastoral care with false passports and named Niemöller with Nazi perpetrators, without a right of reply.
Parts of the disability rights movement had already disputed his right to speak for disabled people. Raphael Rössel records that from 1980 Krüppelgruppen activists accused him of talking “in the name of” disabled people and of profiting from the subject; Franz Christoph called him a “strange friend,” and a writer in Puls called the televised Golden Crutch ceremony, with Klee at the podium, paternalism.
Das Kulturlexikon zum Dritten Reich (S. Fischer Verlag, 2007), about 4,000 entries on cultural life before and after 1945, divided reviewers who had valued the earlier lexicon. Die Welt on 2 March 2007, under “Ein geistiges Armutszeugnis,” called it a scandal for Klee, the publisher and journalists who had first praised it, and said Fischer should withdraw and rewrite it. Perpetrators, fellow travellers, blameless contemporaries and victims were mixed without a rule, the review argued: princely NSDAP members appeared, often only via Klee’s “besonders pikante NS-Liste,” while Hubertus Prinz zu Löwenstein and Otto von Habsburg did not; an amateur magician who once performed at Auschwitz was in, and Ernst Kantorowicz was not. The same review cited a hostile, misquoted note on Karl Kraus and a double entry for one writer under two spellings.
Fritz J. Raddatz, a long-standing admirer, wrote in Die Zeit that the aim was excellent—it recalled compromised careers and a republic long “ein Land ohne Gedächtnis”—but that the book was “gänzlich zerbrochen,” without a clear order. Anselm Heinrich, in H-Soz-Kult, called it an indispensable survey and a record of continuities from Heinz Rühmann and Herbert von Karajan to provincial directors, marred by labels such as “Frontdichter” and by fuller work on perpetrators than on missing émigrés. In literaturkritik.de, Walter Delabar accepted the aim of a “lexikalisches Mahnmal” but called the result only a first orientation, with exiles such as Bertolt Brecht weakly justified. Jan Süselbeck defended the archival labour, arguing that an entry for William Shakespeare recorded Nazi attempts to annex canonical figures, while still finding the scattering of victims through a perpetrator lexicon disturbing.
In 1982 Klee and Bernd Liebner received an ehrende Anerkennung (honourable mention), not a gold, silver or bronze award, at the 18th Adolf Grimme Prize for the Sender Freies Berlin film Verspottet (script and direction). The jury said it showed disabled people in their immediate surroundings through a double structure of reportage and self-presentation. Later accounts often call this simply the 1982 Adolf Grimme Prize.
The Geschwister-Scholl-Preis, awarded by the Bavarian publishers’ association and the city of Munich in memory of Hans and Sophie Scholl and the White Rose, went to Klee in 1997 for Auschwitz, die NS-Medizin und ihre Opfer, published that year by S. Fischer Verlag. On 24 November 1997 Mayor Christian Ude and Christoph Wild presented the certificate in the Great Hall of Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich; Ellis Huber’s laudation was titled “Wege durch Trauer und Scham.” The jury cited the documentation of experiments on camp prisoners and prisoners of war, the naming of doctors and of sponsors in research bodies, industry and the SS and Wehrmacht, and Klee’s work on taboo subjects for disadvantaged and disabled people.
In December 2001 Frankfurt mayor Petra Roth presented the city’s Goethe Plaque for his research on National Socialism. Referring to „Euthanasie“ im NS-Staat (1983), she said the book had prompted continuing research into those aspects of what she called the greatest crime against humanity. The city’s statement described his work as evidence of intellectual independence, suited to encouraging civic freedom and moral and intellectual courage. Richard J. Evans’s obituary later tied the plaque to Klee’s book on the postwar careers of Nazi doctors.
On 1 December 2007, Hessian Constitution Day, Minister-President Roland Koch awarded the Wilhelm Leuschner Medal, Hesse’s highest honour for service to freedom, democracy and social justice, named for the resister Wilhelm Leuschner, executed in 1944. Jutta Fleck, Irmgard Heydorn and Benno von Heynitz received it the same day; Koch said the four had stood up for other people and for freedom and democracy. Coverage tied Klee’s medal to the Behinderten-Report and to his accounts of doctors who had taken part in killing disabled people and had kept practising after 1945. In 2005 the Westfälische Schule für Körperbehinderte in Mettingen, near Osnabrück, was renamed the Ernst-Klee-Schule.
Klee died on 18 May 2013, aged 71, in his Frankfurt apartment after a long serious illness. S. Fischer Verlag announced the death that day, calling his name a mark of civil courage: he had opened archives, identified perpetrators and restored names and histories to victims. His last authorized book, Auschwitz – Täter, Gehilfen, Opfer. Ein Personenlexikon, was due that August.
Before his death he and his wife, Elke Klee, decided that his papers should go to the memorial at the former Hadamar killing centre. On 15 March 2018, when he would have turned 76, she formally handed the estate to the Landeswohlfahrtsverband Hessen at the Protestant Academy in Frankfurt; it was then moved to Hadamar. She said at the handover that her father had been shot there.
The holdings include notes on about 20,000 people, a cabinet of working papers, a library of 1,454 volumes, pre-1945 books and magazines, 50 video cassettes (mostly his own productions) and files on doctors’ trials and the disability-rights movement. Catalogued in 2019–2024 as LWV fonds N 21—257 units, about 15 linear metres, dated 1868–2007—they have been searchable since 2025 on Arcinsys and are read at Hadamar by appointment.
Klee followed the early Hadamar memorial critically, writing on weak prosecutions, slow remembrance and conditions in psychiatric institutions. The memorial links his research to the difficulty of placing the Nazi murder of sick and disabled people—under Aktion T4 and the later decentralized killings—in public memory, and uses the estate for that history and for exclusion after 1945. At the handover, LWV deputy Andreas Jürgens said Klee had brought Nazi medicine and its West German afterlife out of obscurity and had offered disabled people an idea of emancipation; director Jan Erik Schulte said the papers would serve education and research because the work continued past 1945. The Mettingen renaming and scholarly use of the holdings are the clearest public traces of that influence.
How the record is sourced and how the score is derived.
The score is formula-derived (Factrail formula v1, version 1.0.0), not an editorial verdict. Read the methodology.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Dispute a fact on this pageNamed here, or represent someone who is? Request a right of reply.
People and organizations as listed in the Related section of this page; facts, drivers and the pages that name it as listed in the blocks here. Counts, not a rating.