Skip to content

Frances Kissling

Not rated

Frances Kissling (born 1943) is an American activist and writer on abortion, religion, and reproductive ethics.

  • Facts0
  • Drivers0
  • Indicators0

Expert article

Frances Kissling (born 1943) is an American activist and writer on abortion, religion, and reproductive ethics. From 1982 until she stepped down in 2007 she was president of Catholics for a Free Choice, a Washington, D.C., advocacy group later called Catholics for Choice. Before that presidency she managed legal abortion clinics in the New York area and became the first executive director of the National Abortion Federation, the association formed when earlier U.S. provider groups merged. Boston Globe columnist Ellen Goodman called her the “philosopher of the pro-choice movement,” a phrase the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study at Harvard University repeated when naming her a 2007–2008 fellow.

She was born in New York City, spent her first years in Nanticoke, Pennsylvania, while her father was in the war, and grew up in Queens as Frances Romanski, the eldest child of Thomas Romanski. After her parents divorced, her mother married Charles Kissling, who adopted the Romanski children when Frances was about nine. She attended Catholic schools, studied for a year at St. John’s University, and spent about nine months as a postulant with the Sisters of St. Joseph in Brentwood, Long Island, before completing a bachelor’s degree at the New School for Social Research.

After New York legalized abortion in 1970 she ran the Pelham Medical Group clinic in Westchester and then served as executive director of Eastern Women’s Center in Manhattan, where she was working when the Supreme Court decided Roe v. Wade. As president of Catholics for a Free Choice she argued that support for legal abortion and contraception could be compatible with a Catholic identity, including through the Condoms4Life campaign, which criticized Vatican discouragement of condoms. The U.S. bishops rejected the group’s claim to speak as an authentic Catholic voice. In 1995 she was a keynote speaker at the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing. The organization also campaigned to end the Holy See’s status as a permanent observer at the United Nations.

On leaving the presidency she said the next years in reproductive-rights politics should “build bridges” between supporters and opponents of legal abortion, and she intended to write and teach. At Radcliffe her project was a book on fetal status, women’s moral agency, and the roles of parents and men. By 2011 the Daily Pennsylvanian described her as a visiting bioethics scholar at the University of Pennsylvania. Bishop Joseph Fiorenza, then president of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops, stated in 2000 that Catholics for a Free Choice “is not a Catholic organization, does not speak for the Catholic Church,” and “merits no recognition or support as a Catholic organization.”

Early life and education

Family and childhood

Frances Kissling was born Frances Romanski in June 1943 at the Salvation Army Hospital in New York City. Her mother, Florence Rynkiewicz, about eighteen and the youngest of seven in a Polish-American family from Nanticoke, Pennsylvania, came to New York after high school. Kissling later said her mother became pregnant, married Thomas Romanski in February 1943, and gave birth in June. Romanski served during World War II, and Kissling spent her first four years with her mother and maternal grandparents in Nanticoke before the family settled in a working-class household in Queens.

Her parents divorced when she was about five or six. She and a sister, Sharon, were the Romanski children. Her mother remarried Charles Kissling, a German-American Protestant, outside the Catholic Church and without an annulment, and had two more children, Peter William and Kyle Charlene. Around age nine or ten he adopted the Romanski sisters, and the surname became Kissling. A divorced and remarried Catholic could not receive the sacraments. The parents drove the children to Mass; her mother stayed away. A priest told Kissling, then about twelve, that her mother could stay if the couple lived “as brother and sister” and she received Communion only in private. Kissling called the condition an outrage. In 1986 she said her mother accepted it during high school; in a 2002 oral history she said her mother met the priest and never complied. Thomas Romanski was not part of daily life. When Kissling was about sixteen the second marriage ended, and her mother went to work nights as a telephone operator.

She went to public school in first grade and to Catholic schools afterward. Moves meant four grammar schools in Queens, first with the Grey Nuns of the Sacred Heart and then mostly with the Sisters of St. Joseph. By the middle grades, classes were separated by sex, and high school was all girls. She attended two Catholic high schools, commuting by subway from Queens to Brooklyn, and in 2020 named “Bishop McDonald Memorial High School”—Bishop McDonnell Memorial, the diocesan girls’ school at 260 Eastern Parkway, taught by several orders, including the Sisters of St. Joseph, Dominicans, and the Daughters of Wisdom. It was college preparatory, with a dress code and no uniforms. She thought she graduated in 1961, just before the Second Vatican Council. In her junior year she decided to enter a convent; the sisters urged a year of college first.

Convent and university

After a year of English literature at St. John's University in Queens, she entered at nineteen the Sisters of St. Joseph in Brentwood, Long Island. She was a postulant for about nine months, one of about seventy. Required marriage papers showed she had been conceived before her parents married. She said the order accepted her only reluctantly, after priests intervened, because of that fact. Postulants took no vows and wore a plain black habit; formation was still pre–Vatican II. She rejected church teaching on sexuality, birth control, and divorce, and she questioned racially separate communities of sisters. She decided she could not represent the institution. Asked if she wanted to go home, she said yes. The next morning the mother superior told her the community had never wanted her, and she left before the novitiate.

She stopped churchgoing and did not regard herself as Catholic, a change she described as loss of interest rather than anger. A second year at St. John’s produced a C in theology after a professor told her to sit on her hands. She transferred to The New School for Social Research—she had seen its sign from the subway and had also considered Barnard College—and received a bachelor’s degree in English literature. In the mid-1960s she lived in Greenwich Village. There she joined Students for a Democratic Society and studied poetry with LeRoi Jones, later Amiri Baraka. Still calling herself conservative, she accepted a place on an early trip to Cuba so that a skeptic could report what she saw. Her stepfather notified the authorities. In June 1964, a week short of twenty-one, the State Department refused Frances Mary Kissling a passport unless she swore not to go to Cuba. The American Civil Liberties Union sued Secretary of State Dean Rusk; she later said the passport in Kissling v. Rusk, handled in part by Leonard Boudin, arrived after the trip and that there was no ruling. The same year she was arrested at an anti–Vietnam War demonstration at the United Nations and said the charges were dropped.

Abortion clinics and the National Abortion Federation

New York clinics

Governor Nelson Rockefeller signed New York’s abortion reform on April 11, 1970, and Kissling later dated the start of legal practice to that July. That fall, physicians opening a freestanding clinic hired her to run it. She identified it as the Pelham Medical Group, in Pelham, Westchester County: a doctor-owned office where patients came for abortion, not as family-planning patients. She said she stayed about two years.

In People v. Hatchamovitch (1972), the Appellate Division lifted a temporary injunction against an unlicensed Westchester abortion practice of M. Hatchamovitch and others—the court’s spelling of a physician she later called a Pelham owner. A dissent recorded a 1971 inspection—three examining rooms and a seven-bed recovery area—and noted that as many as 300 abortions a month, many for out-of-state patients, were not disputed; a brochure claimed more than 17,000 in about a year and a half. The majority found no proof of likely injury and cited papers showing a high standard of care.

She then became executive director of Eastern Women’s Center, an abortion clinic in Manhattan, and was there when Roe v. Wade was decided. She later said the ruling changed little immediately in New York, and that she left in late 1973 or early 1974. She has said Planned Parenthood affiliates were late and reluctant abortion providers; she did not run a Planned Parenthood clinic. A Pittsburgh affiliate’s director later referred her to International Pregnancy Advisory Services, later Ipas.

As an Ipas consultant in Italy, where abortion was still illegal, she met Emma Bonino and other Radical Party and feminist figures about money for clandestine clinics; they refused it. In Austria, abortion by a physician after counseling ceased to be punishable within three months on January 1, 1975, but she found almost no services. With a Pelham physician she helped open a Vienna practice she called the country’s first legal abortion clinic, then left it with Ipas. She also said that around 1975–76 she helped Ipas open an illegal clinic in Mexico once a willing doctor was in place.

National Abortion Federation

On March 7, 1976, providers met in Knoxville, Tennessee, at what the National Abortion Federation later called the first national symposium on abortion after Roe. Advertised in the February 1976 American Journal of Public Health, it led to a committee for the National Association of Abortion Facilities (NAAF). Kissling joined the steering committee, then resigned at a May 1976 meeting in Cleveland. NAF’s history says she wanted standards of care and access for all women, not mainly a service group for owners, and that for-profit clinics had felt shut out by nonprofits such as Preterm and Planned Parenthood. A 2007 NAF report dates the Knoxville meeting and the resignation to 1975; its timeline and the 1976 advertisement place them in 1976.

She chaired the rival National Abortion Council; its first office was her home in Huguenot, New York. A merger committee that included Christopher Tietze, Jeannie Rosoff, Judy Widdicombe, Merle Hoffman, and Kissling agreed on weighted board seats for profit-making clinics, nonprofits, physicians’ offices, feminist clinics, and Planned Parenthood. On January 29, 1977, the boards voted in Washington to form the National Abortion Federation; members approved by mail.

Kissling was the first executive director; Judith Widdicombe was the first board president. The 1977 Denver meeting drew 75 institutional members. Early work covered standards, training, legal rights, and public education; she also recalled a consumer guide for patients. She later said the post lasted about a year and a half to two years. Uta Landy became the second executive director in 1978, when NAF published its first Standards for Quality Abortion Care.

Early writing

Rosaura Jiménez, 27, died on October 3, 1977, in McAllen, Texas, leaving a five-year-old daughter and an uncashed scholarship check. The New York Times later called hers the first recorded death from an illegal abortion after federal Medicaid funds were cut off. The limit was section 209 of Public Law 94-439, enacted September 30, 1976: no money in that Labor–HEW appropriation was to pay for abortions except where the mother’s life would be endangered. That rider is the first Hyde Amendment.

Kissling, then NAF’s executive director, told the feminist writer Ellen Frankfort, and they went to McAllen. Early reports, including what Kissling described as a finding by the Center for Disease Control, had Jiménez going to Mexico. The Times review of the later book reported the opposite: she had previously had a Medicaid abortion, and poverty after the cutoff sent her to a local woman still practicing illegally in McAllen.

Rosie: The Investigation of a Wrongful Death, by Ellen Frankfort with Frances Kissling, was published by Dial Press in 1979 (173 pages, $8.95). Five percent of the royalties were to go to the Rosie Jimenez Fund for poor women in Texas seeking abortions. Jennifer Dunning called it “an absorbing, poignant and sometimes maddening reconstruction of a life,” faulted “maddening excesses” and overdrawn characters, and wrote that “her Rosie is a slovenly enough saint.” Kissling said she left NAF to write the book and later thought it sold perhaps a couple of thousand copies. She remembered the publisher as Doubleday; the book was issued by Dial.

Leadership of Catholics for Choice

Presidency, 1982–2007

Catholics for Choice was founded in 1973, as Catholics for a Free Choice, by Joan Harriman, Patricia Fogarty McQuillan, and Meta Mulcahy, to argue for legal abortion in the language of Catholic tradition. In 1979 Patricia McMahon became president and shifted the group from a lobby to an educational nonprofit; the Internal Revenue Service recorded a 501(c)(3) exemption that August (employer identification number 52-1154418). Its office was in Washington, D.C.

Frances Kissling said in 1996 that she joined the board in 1978; the group’s finding aid at Smith College dates that appointment to 1980. She became president in 1982 and held the post until February 2007. She later described taking over as executive director of a few employees, including an editor of Conscience, with a budget of about $250,000 to $275,000 from the Sunnen, Ms., Playboy, and Veatch foundations, plus a first Ford Foundation grant she remembered as $19,960 for interviews with Catholic women in clinics. About fifteen activists in ten states made up the state network, by her account.

Foundation grants remained the main income. Ford Foundation files at the Rockefeller Archive Center include $710,000 in general support from June 1986 through December 1993 for U.S. education and policy work on reproductive choice, and $2.1 million from 1994 through 1998 for programs that also covered reproductive health and Latin America. In 1996 Kissling said there was no formal membership: about 8,000 to 10,000 contributors gave roughly $100,000 of a budget near $2 million, with 15 headquarters staff and volunteer spokespeople elsewhere. At her departure The New York Times reported a budget of about $3 million, largely from secular foundations, including Ford. The National Conference of Catholic Bishops had already said the group did not speak for the Catholic Church. In May 2000 its president, Bishop Joseph A. Fiorenza—the conference was later combined into the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops—repeated that statement and noted the private-foundation funding.

The 1984 advertisement and Vatican response

The advertisement that fixed the organization in national coverage ran in the 1984 presidential campaign. After bishops, including Archbishop John O'Connor of New York, criticized Catholic politicians who supported legal abortion—especially Representative Geraldine Ferraro, running for vice president with Walter Mondale—Catholics for a Free Choice bought a full page in The New York Times for October 7, 1984. Kissling said she, Daniel Maguire, and Marjorie Maguire drafted it in 1983 at the Society of Christian Ethics and published the collected signatures once Ferraro’s nomination drew the bishops into the campaign.

“A Catholic Statement on Pluralism and Abortion” carried 97 names. It said that “a large number” of Catholic theologians believed abortion “can sometimes be a moral choice,” that a “diversity of opinion” existed in the church, that abortion had not “always been treated as murder in canonical history,” and that priests, nuns, and brothers who publicly dissented “should not be penalized by their religious superiors, church employer or bishops.” Kissling later said signers were not asked to call themselves proponents of abortion; she considered the claim of more than one legitimate Catholic position the sentence most in dispute.

On December 18, 1984, the Vatican said the Sacred Congregation for Religious and Secular Institutes—now the Dicastery for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life—had ordered every religious who signed to retract publicly or face proceedings for “obstinate insubordination,” which could mean dismissal. The Associated Press reported that the order went to superiors of 24 nuns, one brother, and a Franciscan priest; another priest’s case was left to his bishop. Kissling said the priests and brothers withdrew quickly and the women religious did not.

In July 1986 the Vatican said it had accepted “public declarations of adherence to Catholic doctrine on abortion” from 25 religious signers and was concentrating on Sisters Barbara Ferraro and Patricia Hussey of the Sisters of Notre Dame de Namur, who worked at a shelter in Charleston, West Virginia, and refused to recant. Eleven other nun signers, including Sister Maureen Fiedler, answered that they had not retracted “one syllable” and objected to the use of their cases to isolate Ferraro and Hussey. On June 4, 1988, the order’s General Government Group in Rome said it would “not proceed with the process to dismiss,” because dismissal “would not be in the best interest of the church or the religious congregation at this time.” Kissling released the sisters’ statement calling that decision “an enormous victory.” They resigned on July 13 and announced it on July 21, saying colleagues had shunned them, and continued as lay Catholics at Covenant House in Charleston. The order’s Roman administration said they had “done what the situation and their own integrity demanded.”

Organization, publications, and succession

Conscience (ISSN 0740-6835), published in Washington by Catholics for a Free Choice, began with the September/October 1980 issue: six times a year through 1983, bimonthly from 1984 to 1991, and quarterly from 1992, according to library records. Kissling remembered the 1982 version as a newsprint broadsheet with its own editor. By 1996 she was writing in the quarterly on whether church teaching fixed when a fetus becomes a person, and the group also issued booklets on abortion in Catholic history and on conservative Catholic organizations. A Sunnen Foundation grant under McMahon had paid for an earlier series, Abortion in Good Faith.

It remained a staffed advocacy body, not a dues-paying association: a board, paid staff, foundation grants, and contributors, with state chapters limited to a small volunteer network.

She left at the end of February 2007. The New York Times reported on February 27 that she would step down the next day after 25 years. Jon O’Brien, executive vice president and former communications director—previously communications director of the Irish Family Planning Association in Dublin—succeeded her. Coverage of the handover still used Catholics for a Free Choice; Smith College catalogs the same records under the later name Catholics for Choice.

International advocacy

Latin America, Europe, and global networks

As president of Catholics for a Free Choice, Kissling worked with Catholic feminists in Latin America who organized as Católicas por el Derecho a Decidir. The Mexican group dates its start to 3 August 1994 and credits the initiative to Kissling and Sarita Hudson, building on work by Silvia Marcos and Julián Cruzalta, under director María Consuelo Mejía, and describes itself as defending legal abortion from a Catholic position at odds with the hierarchy. In March 1995 the Holy See tried to bar Catholics for a Free Choice and three allied Catholic women’s groups from United Nations preparations for the Beijing conference, saying they were not truly Catholic and misrepresented church teaching on abortion and the family. Kissling said the aim was to hide Catholic disagreement.

In Europe she spoke as an advocate, not an envoy. The Irish Times reported on 31 January 1996 that she was to address an all-party Westminster committee that evening on responses to the church’s agenda, and that she had just spoken in Belfast, for the Alliance for Choice, on a pro-choice Catholic case for the primacy of conscience. In 1998 she joined a Barcelona colloquium on women and fundamentalisms and told El País that Pope John Paul II was deeply conservative on women, and that conscience could prevail because neither abortion nor the ban on contraception had been declared infallible.

She also helped plan the Global Fund for Women. At the 1987 Council on Foundations meeting, Anne Firth Murray, leaving the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, told Kissling and Laura Lederer of the Skaggs Foundation that she wanted her own foundation. Kissling proposed that if each gave $1,000 and they made three grants of that size, they would already be one. The next morning Murray told Dame Nita Barrow, later governor-general of Barbados, who joined the board and helped raise money.

United Nations conferences and the Holy See

Kissling’s main international role was as a nongovernmental critic of the Holy See at United Nations meetings, not as a national delegate.

At the International Conference on Population and Development in Cairo in September 1994, Archbishop Renato Martino condemned abortion and contraception for the Holy See, and dispute over an abortion paragraph returned that text to committee. At a news conference Kissling asked, “How come this is the only religion with a permanent observer seat at the U.N.?” and said the dispute was about “the role of women in church and state.” At the NGO Forum in Huairou during the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing the next year, she spoke for Catholics for a Free Choice and helped gather signatures asking the United Nations to review the Vatican’s status. taz reported that the Holy See had tried to exclude the group. A later Radcliffe Institute biography called her a Beijing keynote speaker; reporting then placed the speech at the NGO forum, not the governmental plenary.

In late March 1999 her organization led more than 70 groups in asking Secretary-General Kofi Annan to review the Holy See’s permanent non-member-state observer status, granted in 1964 by Secretary-General U Thant. Kissling urged a challenge to “the Vatican’s pretense to be a state” and asked why “a few acres of office space and tourist attractions in the center of Rome” should shape United Nations policy, arguing for the same nongovernmental standing as the World Council of Churches. The Vatican mission declined to comment. The coalition also sent Annan postcards asking for the review. By March 2000 the drive, called See Change, was described as more than 450 groups, including the International Planned Parenthood Federation. Kissling said granting “state status and special privileges to this religion over all others is simply unfair.” Peter C. Smith of the International Right to Life Federation said NGOs had no authority to seek a delegation’s removal and called the Holy See a mediator across political blocs.

In June 1999 Martino said the status rested on long acceptance of the pope and his headquarters as a sovereign international entity, already understood by states in diplomatic relations with the Holy See. He called the campaign “ridiculous” and “a strange way of understanding democracy.” On 10 May 2000 Bishop Joseph Fiorenza of Galveston-Houston, president of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops, said Catholics for a Free Choice was not a Catholic organization and was “practically speaking, an arm of the abortion lobby,” funded to promote abortion as population control. He called the effort a drive “to end the official presence and silence the moral voice of the Holy See,” in language “reminiscent of other episodes of anti-Catholic bigotry,” and repeated a 1993 statement that the group “merits no recognition or support as a Catholic organization.” On 11 July 2000 the U.S. House passed a concurrent resolution objecting to removal of that status. The Holy See remains a non-member state invited to participate as an observer, with a permanent mission at headquarters.

Ideas on abortion, conscience, and religion

Catholic identity and dissent

Kissling has argued that support for legal abortion can be a position inside the Catholic Church. In a 1999 Irish Times column she wrote that officials, “especially the Vatican,” hold there is “only one authentically Catholic position on abortion,” while “millions of Catholics… including clergy, theologians and laity, disagree with—or at least question—that official position.” She grounded that dissent in a duty to follow a considered conscience even against official teaching; in the claim that there is no definitive church account of when the fetus becomes a person; and in probabilism, under which a doubtful law does not bind if there are solid reasons for another course. On contraception and abortion, she wrote, the sensus fidelium does not support the hierarchy, and a woman’s health and existing children may be weighed against “the potential value of developing foetal life.”

In the Journal of Medical Ethics (2001) she repeated that case for Catholics for a Free Choice: the ban “is not infallible,” and “only the woman herself can make the abortion decision.”

The Catechism of the Catholic Church reaches the opposite conclusion. Human life “must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception”; from the first moment a human being has “the rights of a person”; and direct abortion is “gravely contrary to the moral law,” a teaching it calls unchanged since the first century, with automatic excommunication for a completed abortion. Conscience “must be informed” and “guided by the authoritative teaching of the Church,” not used to “reject authoritative teachings.”

In May 2000 Bishop Joseph A. Fiorenza, president of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, repeated a 1993 statement that Catholics for a Free Choice “merits no recognition or support as a Catholic organization,” “does not speak for the Catholic Church,” and contradicts the Holy See. The moral theologian Daniel Maguire argued a similar pluralism, telling U.S. bishops in 2006 there is “no one position on contraception and abortion” that is Catholic. In 2007 the bishops’ Committee on Doctrine said his views “are not those of the Catholic Church and indeed are contrary to the Church’s faith,” and that the pope and bishops are not one voice among others.

Kissling pressed the same point on HIV/AIDS. Around World AIDS Day 2001 her group ran Washington transit ads—“Because the bishops ban condoms, innocent people die”—and she said the Vatican and bishops bore “significant responsibility for the death of thousands of people who have died from AIDS.” The Archdiocese of Washington called the claim false: bishops teach, they do not “ban.” Pope Paul VI’s Humanae vitae (1968) calls deliberately contraceptive intercourse “intrinsically wrong,” and that July southern African bishops condemned condoms as an immoral HIV defense.

Fetal value, later abortion, and moral responsibility

She had made a version of the point in 1990, asking advocates in The Christian Century to value fetal life without personhood or absolute legal protection, and to treat Roe v. Wade as a policy framework rather than a ban on regulation.

In the Winter 2004–2005 Conscience essay “Is There Life After Roe? How to Think About the Fetus,” she asked why opponents should own respect for fetal life: “Are we not capable of walking and chewing gum at the same time; of valuing life and respecting women’s rights?” She urged advocates to call the loss “sad, unfortunate, tragic” and still affirm the decision, and she called abortion “a profoundly moral question.”

In Salon in 2006 she asked why, if abortion were “a morally neutral act” or “an unambiguous moral good,” anyone should try to make it rare. What advocates defended, she wrote, was both “central to human freedom and autonomy” and the ending of “a form of human life,” and a “presumption in favor of life” should cover the fetus even if it is not a person. With Kate Michelman, in the Los Angeles Times in 2008, she wrote that the “moral high ground” required admitting “the real conflict between life and choice, between rights and responsibility.”

A February 2011 Washington Post essay set a limit. As the National Catholic Reporter recorded it, advocates “can no longer pretend the fetus is invisible,” must drop “the fiction that an abortion at 26 weeks is no different from one at six weeks,” and should “firmly and clearly reject post-viability abortions except in extreme cases”—immediate risk to the woman’s life, conditions “incompatible with a good quality of life,” or a serious health threat worsened by pregnancy. “It may not have a right to life, and its value may not be equal to that of the pregnant woman, but ending the life of a fetus is not a morally insignificant event.” She told the Reporter she was not seeking criminalization, but recognition of two values—women as moral agents, and fetal life—and public support for contraception and for continuing a pregnancy. The paper noted that this is not Catholic teaching. On On Being she said she still defended a legal and a moral right to abortion, yet rejected a view in which “the only value” is “what the woman wants”: “I think fetuses have value… The abortion decision is a conflict value decision.”

Dialogue and public ethics

She separated understanding an opponent from agreeing. On On Being she said she was “not a big believer in common ground” where differences are deep, because pressure to agree “works against really understanding each other.” The test she borrowed from Sidney Callahan was to name what is good in the other side; such talks, she said, had changed some of her views “without giving up mine.”

Writing in Salon in 2010 about a conference at Princeton University organized with help from Peter Singer, she gave each side an “Achilles’ heel”: forcing women to stay pregnant, or admitting that abortion “does take life—human life, and sometimes well into the fifth month of pregnancy.”

Academic work and later career

Radcliffe fellowship

For 2007–2008 Frances Kissling held a journalism and nonfiction fellowship at the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study at Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Its profile for that year said she had recently left the presidency of Catholics for a Free Choice to examine rights, morality, and responsibility in the U.S. abortion debate, and noted that Boston Globe columnist Ellen Goodman had called her the “philosopher of the pro-choice movement.”

The project was a book, described as using a feminist ethical lens, on fetal status, women’s moral agency, and the roles of parents and men, with writing and semistructured interviews of intellectuals and activists. The profile did not title the manuscript. In a June 2020 oral history she said she also wrote a weekly Salon column that year, but that the book was not finished.

Teaching and institutional roles

She said the Hewlett Foundation then gave her $200,000 over two years, which she used to convene a mid-career leadership group in reproductive health, and that she arranged a fellowship at the University of Pennsylvania Center for Bioethics in Philadelphia. She described that affiliation as lasting about three years and as having little structured work after the first six months, until the center asked her to teach reproductive-health ethics in its master’s program. The center’s site listed her among visiting scholars in August 2009. In September 2011 the Daily Pennsylvanian still identified her as a visiting bioethics scholar, at a Penn Democrats talk on Catholic teaching and abortion.

A syllabus from the philosophy graduate program of the National Autonomous University of Mexico names her as instructor of “Reproductive Health Ethics,” eleven sessions in October–November 2018 on fetal status, abortion, contraception, assisted reproduction, and population policy, with Peter Singer as a video guest. In October 2019 she began as a visiting researcher at UNAM’s Instituto de Investigaciones Filosóficas in Mexico City. The institute’s historical roster calls her president of the Center for Health Ethics and Social Policy and says she had taught at Penn’s Center for Bioethics. In 2020 she described herself as a visiting professor at UNAM, teaching reproductive-health ethics to graduate students.

Published board lists from the same era place her on two reproductive-health organizations. The Alan Guttmacher Institute’s 2002 update included her among its directors. A Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice board page archived in March 2007 listed her as president of Catholics for a Free Choice.

Center for Health, Ethics and Social Policy

Kissling is president of a small Washington, D.C., nonprofit, EIN 13-3869293, whose federal tax exemption dates to October 1996. A 2017 return gives 1997 as the formation year and reports one employee. Filings have used both Center for Health Ethics and Social Policy Inc. and, in 2022 and 2024, Center for Health and Social Policy Inc., at 2701 Connecticut Avenue NW. Recent returns also list Maria Consuelo Mejia as an at-large officer, Ethel Klein as secretary, and William Kramer as treasurer.

The returns describe research, training, and commentary rather than clinical care. In 2017 the stated mission was to promote sexual and reproductive health ethics through publications, workshops, and education of medical and policy audiences, including work with organizations in Africa and Latin America. Reported programs that year included a role in a leadership transition at the Global Fund for Children and training in Mexico on emergency care after rape. Earlier returns also described provider workshops, work on the Women Deliver conference, mid-career leadership training, school support for African students, and a transplant-policy project, with most revenue then reported as program-service fees.

Later filings were contribution-funded and more narrowly reproductive. The 2022 return described ethics workshops in Mexico with the health ministry and the organization DKT, training for ethicists and clinicians, and media commentary. The 2024 return said the center is committed to “research and education that promotes legal access to reproductive health care including abortion,” and reported filmed oral histories with ethicists and researchers in Mexico and the United States, five workshops for Mexican doctors, and work with authors and the media on religious positions on abortion. Receipts have stayed small: postcard filings, for gross receipts under $50,000, appear in several recent years, while 2022 reported $191,114 in revenue and $95,856 in expenses and 2024 reported $155,000 and $79,641.

Writings and public commentary

Books and essays

By her 2007–2008 fellowship at the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study at Harvard University, Kissling had published more than 120 articles, among them pieces in the Guardian, the Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion, The Nation, and the New York Times. That year’s fellow note described a book on fetal status, women’s moral agency, and parents’ and men’s roles. She later said she wrote a weekly Salon column during the year but “didn’t accomplish a book, which was one of my goals.” Her first book, with Ellen Frankfort, was Rosie: The Investigation of a Wrongful Death (1979). In 2000 Catholics for a Free Choice issued her 42-page How to talk about abortion: a guide to successful communications.

She contributed an essay to Robin Morgan’s 2003 anthology Sisterhood Is Forever. With Mary E. Hunt she published “The New York Times Ad: A Case Study in Religious Feminism” (1987), on the 1984 advertisement “A Catholic Statement on Pluralism and Abortion.” In the Journal of Medical Ethics (2001), “The place for individual conscience” argued that the Catholic Church has no firm position on when a fetus becomes a person, that probabilism leaves that question to conscience, that an absolute ban is not infallible, and that only the woman can decide. Conscience carried “Is there life after Roe? How to think about the fetus” in 2004.

Journalism and lectures

In Salon in 2006 she asked why prevention would matter if abortion were morally neutral, and wrote that leading opponents of legal abortion were only marginally interested in contraception. After Gonzales v. Carhart (2007) she argued that the majority opinion dwelt on intact dilation and extraction and gave health risks little space, and likened that to prohibiting condoms against HIV because a condom is also a contraceptive. In 2009 she wrote that a legal abortion can still be one a clinician should refuse; at a Planned Parenthood panel she had declined a case sought to avoid another son. Her November 2010 essay “How to think about abortion” described an October conference at Princeton University, “Open Hearts, Open Minds and Fair-Minded Words,” which she helped organize, and said abortion “does take life—human life.”

In the Washington Post in February 2011 she wrote that the arguments that won Roe v. Wade were failing, that the fetus could no longer be treated as invisible or morally trivial, and that its value was still not equal to the woman’s. She urged rejecting most abortions after viability, then about 24 to 26 weeks, except for immediate risk to life, a serious health threat, or a fetal condition incompatible with a good quality of life.

In The Nation in 2006 she warned against God-based public policy from the left as well as the right. With Kate Michelman she argued in 2008 that the abortion-rights movement had to change its approach, and in the New York Times in November 2009 that the Stupak-Pitts amendment let a minority view of abortion’s morality set health policy. In February 2013 she wrote that no new pope would matter unless infallibility ended, and that in Africa opposition to birth control and to condoms against AIDS contributed to maternal death and HIV. That September she asked whether the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops would follow Pope Francis, and told the Times that threats to deny Communion, refusals to let pro-choice speakers appear at Catholic universities, and Holocaust comparisons marginalized the bishops more than his interview. In September 2015 she wrote that women who have abortions are not automatically excommunicated, against the impression left by his Jubilee-year grant letting any priest absolve the sin.

Interviewed by Claudia Dreifus in May 2022, after Politico published Samuel Alito’s draft overturning Roe, she called the draft’s silence on women “horrifying and predictable” and said personhood from conception is not infallible dogma. She spoke with David Gushee on 26 September 2012 at the University of Minnesota in Krista Tippett’s Civil Conversations Project. The Radcliffe biography also lists a 1995 keynote at the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing.

Reception, criticism, and legacy

Catholic hierarchy and conservative critics

U.S. bishops treated Catholics for a Free Choice as outside the church. In 1993 the Administrative Committee of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops said the group, which Kissling and others called a “church reform group,” had “no affiliation, formal or otherwise, with the Catholic Church” and could “in no way speak for” it. The committee called it “associated with the pro-abortion lobby,” funded mostly by “secular organizations supporting legal abortion,” and said that, because it opposed “the human rights of some of the most defenseless members of the human race” and contradicted “essential teachings of the Catholic Church,” it “merits no recognition or support as a Catholic organization.”

On 10 May 2000, during the group’s campaign against the Holy See’s observer status at the United Nations, Bishop Joseph A. Fiorenza of Galveston-Houston, president of the bishops’ conference, said its claim to an “authentic Catholic voice” was “false.” He repeated that it “is not a Catholic organization, does not speak for the Catholic Church,” and called it, “practically speaking, an arm of the abortion lobby,” funded by private foundations “to promote abortion as a method of population control.” He then quoted the 1993 conclusion. L’Osservatore Romano reprinted the statement that month.

Later actions restated that rejection. On 19 March 1996 Bishop Fabian W. Bruskewitz of Lincoln, Nebraska, signed a decree the Los Angeles Times described as excommunicating diocesan Catholics who would not leave 12 groups he called “perilous to the Catholic faith,” including Catholics for a Free Choice and Planned Parenthood. In September 2016 Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan, chairman of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Committee on Pro-Life Activities, called a Catholics for Choice advertisement for taxpayer-funded abortion “deceptive,” writing that the group “is not affiliated with the Catholic Church in any way,” has “no membership,” and “rejects and distorts Catholic social teaching.”

Conservative organizations used harsher labels. When Kissling retired on 28 February 2007, Catholic League president Bill Donohue called the group an “anti-Catholic front group” with “no members” and said it had been “[t]wice condemned as a fraud by the Catholic bishops’ conference”—his characterization of the 1993 and 2000 statements, which did not use the word “fraud.” In Crisis Magazine on 1 April 2002, Kathryn Jean Lopez set Fiorenza’s language against Kissling’s 1999 insistence that, because no bishop or pope had declared her excommunicated, she remained “in good standing with the Church.”

Assessments within feminism and bioethics

Journalists inside the abortion-rights debate often treated Kissling as its moral critic as well as its advocate. A biographical note to her 2002 oral history, and Harvard’s Radcliffe Institute in describing her 2007–2008 fellowship, both record that Boston Globe columnist Ellen Goodman called her the “philosopher of the pro-choice movement.” As she stepped down, Catholic News Service reported that former NARAL Pro-Choice America president Kate Michelman and board chair Marysa Navarro-Aranguren were organizing a 2 March dinner in Washington in her honor.

Her 2011 writing made that philosophical role explicit, and contentious. In the Washington Post on 20 February, as a visiting scholar at the Center for Bioethics at the University of Pennsylvania, she argued that advocates still relied on the privacy claims that won Roe v. Wade while opponents gained ground. “We can no longer pretend the fetus is invisible,” she wrote, and must “end the fiction that an abortion at 26 weeks is no different from one at six weeks.” The movement, she said, should “accept its existence and its value” and “firmly and clearly reject post-viability abortions except in extreme cases,” a shift she called “a necessary evolution,” not “mere strategic concessions.” The next day she told NPR that the side able to speak about both “fetuses and their value and about women” would win over most Americans.

Catholic journals split over whether that was dialogue or an unauthorized claim to speak for the faith. Commonweal called her a “prochoice heavyweight” among the organizers, with Charles Camosy, Jennifer Miller, and Peter Singer, of Princeton’s October 2010 conference “Open Hearts, Open Minds, and Fair-Minded Words,” and reported that she closed by saying she did “not discern much in the way of common ground.” In America in June 2009, Michael Sean Winters answered her criticism of Alexia Kelley’s federal faith-based appointment by calling Kissling “ill-equipped” to judge a “faith leader” and the essay “a predictable rant.” After a leaked draft overturning Roe, The Nation interviewed her in May 2022 as a bioethicist. She told Claudia Dreifus that the draft applied “the most conservative version of Catholicism on abortion” to secular law, while Catholicism contained “multiple positions” and fetal personhood from conception was not “infallible dogma.”

Archives and honors

The paper record is concentrated at the Sophia Smith Collection of Women’s History at Smith College. The Catholics for Choice records, SSC-MS-00742, dated 1970–2020, document the organization’s U.S. and international work and include Kissling’s writings. The Population and Reproductive Health Oral History Project holds her interview with Rebecca Sharpless, recorded in Washington on 13–14 September 2002. It fills seven 60-minute cassettes; the transcript she approved has no restrictions, and its biographical note states that her papers are at the Sophia Smith Collection.

The organization later put her name on a prize of its own. On 14 June 2024, at its 50th-anniversary celebration, Catholics for Choice gave inaugural Frances Kissling Awards to former House speaker Nancy Pelosi and to Marta Alanis, founder of Argentina’s Católicas por el Derecho a Decidir, for what the group called the work of “exemplary pro-choice Catholics.” Pelosi accepted with “reverence for Frances Kissling’s lifetime of leadership.”

Evidence & methodology

How the record is sourced and how the score is derived.

The score is formula-derived (Factrail formula v1, version 1.0.0), not an editorial verdict. Read the methodology.

By the · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed

Dispute a fact on this pageNamed here, or represent someone who is? Request a right of reply.