Skip to content
Panče Toškovski

Panče Toškovski

Not rated

Panče Toškovski (Macedonian: Панче Тошковски; also spelled Panche Toshkovski) is a lawyer and VMRO-DPMNE politician from North Macedonia.

  • Facts0
  • Drivers0
  • Indicators0

Expert article

Panče Toškovski (Macedonian: Панче Тошковски; also spelled Panche Toshkovski) is a lawyer and VMRO-DPMNE politician from North Macedonia. He has been minister of internal affairs since January 2024, first in a pre-election caretaker government and then in the cabinet of Prime Minister Hristijan Mickoski. He was born in Veles on 14 June 1982.

He completed a law degree in 2005 at the Iustinianus Primus Faculty of Law of Ss. Cyril and Methodius University of Skopje, with a grade-point average of 8.74. The ministry biography records postgraduate study in criminal law and criminology from 2006, a judicial exam in March 2008, the bar (advocate’s) exam in July 2008, and a real-estate appraisal exam in October 2012. The biography filed for his June 2024 appointment, as reported by the Media Information Agency, states that he had completed a master’s degree and both the attorney and judicial exams. He interned at Basic Court Skopje 2 from January to November 2006 and at a law firm until January 2008, then worked as an adviser in the Ministry of Transport and Communications from October 2008 to October 2011. From October 2011 until 2024 he practiced as an attorney in Skopje, handling civil, property, commercial, criminal and administrative cases, and from April 2011 to September 2013 he was a member of the board of the joint-stock company that managed business premises owned by the state.

On 24 January 2024 Mickoski said the party would propose Toškovski as interior minister in the caretaker government that was expected to serve for about 100 days through the election period. Outgoing minister Oliver Spasovski handed over the Ministry of Internal Affairs on 29 January 2024. On 23 June 2024 the Assembly of North Macedonia elected Mickoski’s government by 77 votes to 22, in a coalition of VMRO-DPMNE, the Worth It alliance and the ZNAM movement, and Toškovski was sworn in again as interior minister.

On 16 March 2025 a fire at the Pulse nightclub in Kočani, during a concert, became the deadliest disaster of his tenure. Toškovski said that day that at least 59 people had died and 155 had been hospitalized, and that pyrotechnics had likely ignited a flammable ceiling. A year later, reporting put the death toll at 63, with four court cases and 58 defendants still before the courts, including police officers, former mayors and former economy ministers. The assembly rejected a no-confidence motion brought by The Left on 24 June 2026, by 58 votes to 19. In October 2026 the ministry announced an international arrest warrant for Iva Mihailova of Kočani, who was on trial over a fatal traffic crash and had gone to Bulgaria after a court seized her passports; Toškovski said she had left the country illegally.

Early life and education

Upbringing

Panče Toškovski was born on 14 June 1982 in Veles. The Government of North Macedonia states that date and place, as does a Macedonian Information Agency profile of 23 June 2024, issued as he was due to become interior minister. A longer curriculum vitae on the Ministry of Internal Affairs site, and the English copy circulated in July 2024 by the Migration, Asylum, Refugees Regional Initiative, gives the same date under “date and place of birth” but names no town. None of these biographies records a primary or secondary school, a spouse, or children. The biography filed with the Assembly of North Macedonia, as summarized by the agency, lists Macedonian as his mother tongue and excellent English; the government page says he speaks English fluently.

From 2001 to 2005 he studied on the legal programme at the Iustinianus Primus Faculty of Law in Skopje, part of Ss. Cyril and Methodius University of Skopje. The ministry curriculum records a final average of 8.74 and classifies the award as level VII higher education, the diploma of a graduated lawyer (дипломиран правник). It dates postgraduate study in criminal law and criminology at the same faculty from 2006 and, including on a ministry page archived in December 2025, still described the programme as continuing. In September 2025 he said he had enrolled around 2005–2006 and had passed seven or eight examinations in the field.

He passed the judicial examination (правосуден испит) in March 2008 and the attorneys’ examination (адвокатски испит) in July 2008; an English version of the curriculum labels those sittings a “bar exam” and a “qualification exam for attorneys.” In October 2012 he passed a real-estate appraisal examination, which the parliamentary biography places with the Chamber of Appraisers.

On 10 October 2025 the faculty announced that Toškovski, a second-cycle criminal-law student, would defend a master’s thesis on 22 October at its Criminal Law Clinic, titled “Criminological and comparative aspects of improving safety in public traffic.” Council minutes of 4 June 2025, as reported by Racin.mk, proposed Professor Gordana Lažetiḱ as supervisor. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty later reported that he defended it that day with an average of 9.60, receiving a master of science degree about twenty years after enrolment, on a subject overlapping the ministry’s “Safe City” work. Asked whether writing it while in office was a misuse of public office, he said it was not and that the text used public material, including ministry figures, European comparisons, and material from the European Court of Human Rights.

On 22 December 2025 the Faculty of Security in Skopje, part of the St. Kliment Ohridski University in Bitola, ranked him third in an additional doctoral round in security, with Professor Boris Murgovski named supervisor of a three-year programme. He told RFE/RL that the dissertation, still being defined, would concern road-traffic safety and would stay apart from operational ministry projects. Slagjana Taseva of Transparency International said degrees taken where an official’s institution has influence raised an ethics question; the State Commission for Prevention of Corruption did not answer RFE/RL on whether the law treated such cases as conflicts of interest.

Public administration and early practice

Toškovski’s first court work was in Skopje: an internship at Basic Court Skopje 2 from January to November 2006, then training in a law office until January 2008. His curriculum vitae records a bar exam in March 2008, the attorneys’ qualification exam in July 2008, and service from October 2008 to October 2011 as an adviser at the Ministry of Transport and Communications, drafting opinions and acts, a construction-land law and a municipal land-management strategy with the Association of the Units of Local Self-Government (ZELS) and the United States Agency for International Development, and sitting on commissions for land bidding, land policy and concessions. A biography submitted to the Assembly of North Macedonia, as described by Racin, records that post and the concession and bidding commissions.

From April 2011 to September 2013 he sat on the board of the state company that managed publicly owned business premises, and in 2011 the same CV lists him as a trainer for Habitat for Humanity Macedonia on legalising unlawful buildings and for the National Roma Centrum on “Legalization of Roma Housing.”

Independent advocacy

From October 2011 until 2024 he practised from his own Skopje office, Attorney Panche Toshkovski, in civil, property, commercial, criminal and administrative cases before domestic and international courts.

The clients named in reporting were not limited to one party. In March 2020 he said he represented members of VMRO-DPMNE, unaffiliated people, members of the Social Democratic Union of Macedonia, institutions and companies, under lawful contracts, and that he had consulted for Zoran Zaev while Zaev was mayor of Strumica. He also said he remained counsel to a company after the change of government. Racin reported that he advised the state generator Elektrani na Makedonija (ELEM), later Elektrani na Severna Makedonija, while Hristijan Mickoski was its director.

Racin reported that, for ANGO DOOEL, he filed administrative case U-3 no. 20/2021 against an October 2020 decision of the mayor of Centar annulling a 2014 permit for a multi-storey garage beside parliament, and that the Administrative Court found for the company, which had bought the plot at a 2013 ministry auction. In May 2025 The Left, as carried by A1on, said he had acted for Al Dariv in an administrative case in 2020 and questioned a later public-broadcaster contract for that firm. At a June 2026 interpellation, Left leader Dimitar Apasiev alleged that Mickoski had assigned the ELEM work, that Toškovski had represented Mickoski personally, and that a suit against The Left had been dismissed with 20,000 denars in unpaid costs. Toškovski called the motion self-contradictory.

High-profile criminal defenses

Racin described him as counsel for several accused VMRO-DPMNE officials and members in cases opened by the former Special Public Prosecutor’s Office, without naming the files. In the 2026 interpellation Apasiev repeated the claim and added defendants from the 27 April case.

The retainer he discussed on the record was the prosecution of the 2017 storming of the Macedonian Parliament. In July 2019 he spoke as lawyer for Mitko Peshov, a police employee whom nomination coverage later described as head of a special-units department. On 16 October 2018, during a protected witness’s evidence, the panel led by judge Dobrila Kacarska fined every defence lawyer 1,000 euros and removed them after they protested the conditions; contemporaneous reporting said the court ended their right to conduct the defence and would appoint counsel ex officio. Radio Lider wrote that Toškovski was among them and that the Constitutional Court later annulled those decisions.

On 15 March 2019 the Skopje Criminal Court, at first instance, jailed 16 defendants and acquitted one. Peshov and Duško Lazarov each received 15 years for terrorist endangerment of the constitutional order; for police and security staff the case turned largely on an alleged failure to stop a crowd that injured about 100 people. Thirty-three people had been charged, and a December 2018 amnesty covered 15 participants, including five parliamentarians, after VMRO-DPMNE supporters tried to block a new Social Democrat-led majority. After the verdict Toškovski argued that an offence by omission could not stand, and that the prosecution’s own material undid claims that Peshov held a “silver command,” that then-interior minister Agim Nuhiu had ordered him to act, and that Peshov had been in Kavadarci rather than Skopje, Nuhiu having testified, he said, that he gave no order. The 15-year term was a first-instance sentence and could still be appealed.

Party role and path to office

Work inside VMRO-DPMNE

Before he held executive office, Panče Toškovski’s role in VMRO-DPMNE was legal rather than parliamentary. On 24 January 2024, party president Hristijan Mickoski described him as a former member of the Central Committee, a participant in several party congresses, and the head of the party’s commission for legal affairs, still working from a law office. A biography issued with the pre-election nominees called him president of the Republican Legal Commission (Републичка правна комисија).

Antonio Milošoski, a member of the Executive Committee, said the slate was that committee’s collective choice and that Toškovski had given the party advice, suggestions and analyses on legal texts it was preparing. Neither account mentioned a previous police command.

Nomination

He was proposed under the pre-election “technical” government. It was set out in the Pržino agreement of June 2015, during the crisis that followed leaked wiretaps, used for the 2016 elections, and written into the Electoral Code and the Law on the Government in the summer of 2018. Article 44 of that amending law, in the Official Gazette of the Republic of Macedonia, no. 140/2018, requires the Assembly of North Macedonia, 100 days before parliamentary elections, to elect an interior minister and a minister of labour and social policy on the opposition’s proposal. The interior minister is named by the opposition party with the most deputies, after consultation with the two largest parties, and serves until the State Election Commission publishes the final results. The same party also names deputy ministers for finance, agriculture and administration. As the largest opposition party, VMRO-DPMNE therefore put forward the interior minister to succeed Oliver Spasovski, in a cabinet whose prime minister would come from the governing majority.

Parliamentary elections were set for 8 May 2024 and the presidential election for 24 April, so the 100-day deadline fell at the end of January. On the evening of 24 January, Mickoski told TV Telma’s Top tema that the lawyer Toškovski would be the interior candidate and Gjoko Velkovski the labour candidate, and that the Executive Committee would meet on the names that evening. The party’s account of the interview added that the Central Committee and the Executive Committee had already authorised him to propose names, and quoted him calling the nominees competent and unblemished, with the task of seeing that the vote reflected the electorate’s will. After the meeting, vice-president Timčo Mucunski announced the slate. The party would accept the posts but not vote for a government led by Talat Xhaferi of the Democratic Union for Integration, the speaker named as caretaker prime minister.

On 28 January the Social Democratic Union of Macedonia said VMRO-DPMNE had offered weak and unprofessional cadres. It called Toškovski Mickoski’s personal friend and long-time collaborator, and said personal ties were the criterion in the absence of someone who knew the Ministry of Internal Affairs. The Assembly elected the technical government that day by 65 votes to three. VMRO-DPMNE did not vote, but Toškovski and Velkovski took the oath. Xhaferi became the first ethnic Albanian prime minister of North Macedonia, for the period through the elections. On 29 January Spasovski handed him the ministry.

In an interview aired that day, Toškovski said someone with more police experience could have held the post, and that he believed legal practice was the reason he was chosen. He acknowledged a friendship with Mickoski and said it was not the exclusive basis of the nomination. Asked about two 2016 and 2017 contracts for legal services with the state power company ELEM, then directed by Mickoski, which the interviewer put at 25,000 and 140,000 euros, he said the work had been awarded in an open procedure and that he was paid for the services rather than in those sums.

Technical government

Caretaker cabinet

On 28 January 2024 the Assembly of North Macedonia elected a caretaker government led by Talat Xhaferi by 65 votes to three. Of 111 deputies present, VMRO-DPMNE abstained, and Xhaferi and the ministers were sworn in after the vote. VMRO-DPMNE’s Panče Toškovski became minister of internal affairs and Gjoko Velkovski minister of labor and social policy; most Social Democratic Union of Macedonia (SDSM), Democratic Union for Integration and Alliance for Albanians ministers stayed. It was the third transitional government since 2016, with fair parliamentary elections as its main task.

A 2 June 2015 agreement of the four largest parties provided for this 100-day caretaker cabinet, and the Law on Government requires ministers from the ruling majority and the largest opposition party. The opposition proposes the interior and labor ministers. A ruling-party additional interior deputy must countersign the minister’s acts, and the minister may dismiss or reassign at most 15 managers. The term lasts until the State Election Commission publishes final parliamentary results. Parliament named Mitko Bojmacaliev additional deputy interior minister; Nazim Bushi was deputy minister.

On 29 January Oliver Spasovski handed Toškovski the ministry, and Xhaferi succeeded Dimitar Kovačevski. Xhaferi, the first ethnic Albanian prime minister, said fair presidential and parliamentary elections were the priority. Antonio Milošoski said VMRO-DPMNE would not support a prime minister from a smaller party he linked to corruption scandals, and Pavle Trajanov called the caretaker formula unconstitutional.

Pre-election period

On 14 February 2024 the speaker set parliamentary elections for 8 May and the presidential vote for 24 April, with any runoff also on 8 May. The Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe opened an observation mission on 19 March.

On 9 February Toškovski said missing passport booklets had left December and January applicants without documents, with a large shipment due by month’s end; identity cards stayed valid until expiry under either state name. ODIHR later noted delays after old-name documents were invalidated, and on 7 May the ministry said people who applied for a card by 3 May could collect it before election day.

On 24 March Toškovski said the government had blocked replacement of the Tetovo internal-affairs chief and, in his view, breached the Law on Government. He said the chief had been appointed about a month and a half earlier and that he would still add officers in Tetovo and Gostivar. ODIHR did not record the “great concern” he attributed to it, but it did report that on 24 April the VLEN coalition urged action because the Tetovo chief would not cooperate with a ministry adviser.

On 2 April Toškovski met the election headquarters; the ministry said he ordered vigilance and that the security situation was stable. On 24 April it reported photographed ballots, detentions in Ohrid and Berovo, and no serious disorder. ODIHR assessed voting positively in 99 percent of observed stations and called 8 May generally calm, after the ministry promised more police following threats to observers. Final results came on 30 May. ODIHR found the elections competitive but insufficiently regulated.

On 31 May Toškovski handed the ministry to Bushi, who was to serve until a new government and interior minister took office. He wrote that the Law on Government required the handover after the commission’s final results on 30 May, and called the elections the most democratic so far—his view, not ODIHR’s. He was out of office before Hristijan Mickoski’s cabinet.

Ministry leadership under Mickoski

Reappointment

Toškovski’s caretaker term as interior minister ended on 31 May 2024, once the State Election Commission had published the final results of the 8 May parliamentary elections. Under the Law on Government he handed the ministry to his deputy, Nazim Bushi, who was to lead it until a new interior minister took office.

On 23 June 2024 the Assembly of North Macedonia elected the government of Hristijan Mickoski. After a two-day debate the late-Sunday vote in the 120-seat house was 77 in favor and 22 against, with 21 members absent. Mickoski and the ministers were sworn in that evening. The coalition joined VMRO-DPMNE, whose list had won 58 seats, with the ethnic Albanian “Worth It” parties and the ZNAM movement, an Albanian grouping and a leftist party that together held 20 seats. Deputies of the Social Democratic Union of Macedonia and The Left voted no; members of the European Front left before the ballot.

The Macedonian Information Agency named Toškovski as VMRO-DPMNE’s nominee for minister of internal affairs in a government of 24 members, with 15 places for the VMRO-DPMNE-led “Your Macedonia” coalition, six for “Worth It” and two for ZNAM. The vote returned him to the portfolio he had left with Bushi three weeks earlier. He was still interior minister when, on 30 June 2026, Mickoski proposed a limited reshuffle after talks with “Worth It” and ZNAM and listed Toškovski among the ministers keeping their posts. Later motions of no confidence against him are covered separately.

On 19 August 2024 he wrote that he had tested positive for COVID-19 that morning at the Mother Teresa Clinical Center in Skopje and would work from home while isolating. On 17 November 2025 he said he had undergone surgery that day at the same hospital, that he was stable and expected a short recovery, and that the ministry would continue to function in his absence; the account did not name the procedure.

Portfolio and structure

The ministry’s own description of its work, as published on its website in December 2025, covers the system of state and public security; registration of domicile and temporary residence; citizenship and travel documents; movement in the border strip; control of border crossings and certain tasks on border incidents and other border violations; the stay and movement of foreigners; production, trade, storage, protection and transport of flammable liquids, gases, explosives and other dangerous materials; assistance in natural disasters and epidemics; acquisition, possession, carrying and marking of weapons and ammunition; supervision within its competence; and other tasks set by law. Staff may use only coercive measures that statute authorizes, and the ministry gives professional help to citizens, legal persons and state bodies on those duties and on protection of life, personal safety and property.

The Law on Police, in Official Gazette No. 114/2006 as amended in No. 6/2009, places the police inside the ministry. It defines police affairs as protection of life, personal safety and property and of guaranteed rights; prevention of crimes and misdemeanours and detection and apprehension of perpetrators, with measures toward prosecution; public order; traffic; control of foreigners; state-border security and control of crossings; assistance to citizens in cases of utmost necessity; and protection of specified persons and facilities. The same text requires police help to state bodies, municipalities, the City of Skopje and others in rescuing people and property during natural disasters and other calamities. Organizationally, the ministry distinguishes units serving the ministry as a whole from bodies within it.

On 28 June 2024, at the government’s first session, Toškovski said Aleksandar Janev had been chosen to head the Bureau for Public Security in succession to Sašo Tasevski. The news agency reported that day that Janev’s biography was on the ministry site, that he came from the department for suppressing organized and serious crime, and that from 2018 to 2024 he had headed general and joint affairs; Sašo Petruševski, lately director of a public enterprise in Kumanovo, was named state secretary. On 23 July 2024 parliament elected the deputy ministers by 76 votes to 16, including Astrit Iseini as deputy interior minister.

Policing, crime and reform

Crime figures and operations

The Ministry of Internal Affairs under Panče Toškovski has presented 2025 as the year with the fewest registered criminal offences in North Macedonia in two decades. In January 2026 he said the police registered 17,972 offences and cleared 67.2 percent, a rate he called the highest in 20 years. That series is the ministry's. The State Statistical Office counts known perpetrators reported to prosecutors and persons accused or convicted in court. On 28 May 2026 it reported 18,765 known adult perpetrators, 6.5 percent more than in 2024, while accused adults fell 7.7 percent and convicted adults 5.7 percent, to 6,371.

The European Commission, for September 2024 to September 2025, found the country moderately prepared on justice, freedom and security, with limited progress, and still short of capacity against serious and organised crime. Investigations, final judgments and final convictions rose in 2024, while indictments fell. In September 2025 authorities destroyed more than 100 confiscated firearms.

Staffing, equipment and the police law

On 31 July 2026 the ministry promoted 496 officers at Idrizovo from a modular course: 364 in general policing and traffic, 78 on the border and 54 in special units. Toškovski described the renovated centre as internationally accredited and said it was becoming a police academy; he also cited new stations, equipment, vehicles and digital services. On 26 December 2025, with Prime Minister Hristijan Mickoski, it presented 120 new cars, which Toškovski called the first such purchase in more than 15 years. He said they had TETRA radios for checks on ministry data, and that a scheme estimated at about 232 million denars had cost 202 million.

The Assembly adopted a Law on the Ministry of Interior and amendments to the Law on Police on 29 July 2025. On 17 July, while the police bill was in procedure, Social Democratic Union of Macedonia spokesperson Bogdanka Kuzeska demanded its withdrawal. She said top posts could go to people without suitable education or management experience, and that deleting a six-year service rule for sector chiefs, four years of it in leadership, would let a new trainee be appointed. Regional border centres would be merged into internal-affairs sectors, against European Union border standards as she read them; the hiring age would rise to 30; and deleting a clause on convictions and work bans would leave convicted officers in service. She called the bill a VMRO-DPMNE plan for a "party militia." The Gender Equality Platform, citing the Istanbul Convention, opposed deleting the rule on equal hiring of women and communities.

Toškovski said that account was false. No one without the required service could become a chief; promotion was limited to two steps and to officers who met professional and ethical conditions; and command posts would for the first time require training and an elimination test. A deputy director of the Bureau for Public Security would cover the director's absence, not create a political job. Further internal-affairs amendments passed in shortened procedure in January 2026. After SDSM asked the Constitutional Court in April to review the law, Toškovski said on 7 May 2026 that he would propose delaying the new law and the police amendments, due on 1 July, until after the next elections, so the vote would use the old rules. SDSM leader Venko Filipče called the announcement a check on what he termed partisan control of the police.

Organized crime and corruption

The Commission said the police, the State Audit Office, investigative centres and the organised-crime prosecution lacked resources, and that only 18 financial investigations ran alongside organised-crime and money-laundering cases in 2024. Seizures were about €6 million, against about €4 million in 2023; confiscation exceeded €5 million, against about €0.5 million. Toškovski stressed detection: 126 corruption and economic-crime offences and 185 perpetrators in 2023, 206 and 363 in 2024, and 290 and 678 in 2025, many of the last, he said, older crimes newly found. Alleged damage in the complaints rose, on his figures, from €5.7 million to €24 million and then €380 million, with prosecutors and courts still to act.

On 16 December 2024 he announced lottery charges against eight people, including a former prime minister, a former deputy prime minister, a former director and a former secretary-general. Searches found €40,000 and €20,000. The next day the Skopje prosecutor's office said six people were under reasonable suspicion on complaints from the ministry and the Financial Police. It did not dismiss charges against former prime minister Dimitar Kovačevski and former secretary-general Metodija Dimovski, but said they concerned another period. Two lottery officials were investigated over about 500 million denars (about €8.1 million); detention was sought for two suspects once found. On 13 August 2026 prosecutors indicted eight people for abuse of office, alleging a loss of €8.25 million in 2023–2024. Former deputy prime minister Artan Grubi, arrested at Blace in February 2026 after more than 14 months on the run, was under house arrest. Former manager Perparim Bajrami was still sought.

On 18–19 September 2025, around Berovo, Pehčevo and Delčevo, 15 people were detained, including ministry, forestry and agriculture staff. Prosecutors investigated all 15 for an alleged 2025 logging group, six for association and abuse of office, and two also for bribery. They put the loss at about 6,000 hectares and 1.5 million cubic metres, about 6.4 billion denars (€104 million), and alleged patrol tip-offs by officers and a €6,100 bribe to start cutting before a tender. About €185,000, 318,000 denars and several firearms were seized, and detention was requested.

Kočani nightclub fire

The fire

The Kočani nightclub fire began in the early hours of 16 March 2025 at the Pulse nightclub (Пулс) in Kočani, a town of about 25,000 in eastern North Macedonia, during a concert by the hip-hop duo DNK. Authorities reported at least 59 dead and more than 155 injured, and the government declared seven days of mourning.

Interior Minister Panče Toškovski said sparks from stage pyrotechnics caught a flammable ceiling; Chief State Prosecutor Ljupčo Kocevski later put the fountains at about 2:32 a.m. Pulse, in a former light-industrial building, had one working exit and a back door later described in court as padlocked and unusable from inside.

Early reports put the crowd near 1,500, but Toškovski said it was at least twice the licensed capacity of 250, and Kocevski said staff had admitted about 650 people, including at least 31 minors, without stopping unlicensed pyrotechnics. By 17 March the interior ministry counted three of the dead and more than 20 of the wounded as under 18, and members of DNK, including both frontmen, were among those killed.

On 19 March Toškovski still cited 59 deaths and 196 seriously injured; on 21 March Kocevski cited 59 dead and 197 injured, 25 of them teenagers, and the health ministry had named 59 dead on 20 March. By 13 June the toll was reported as 62 dead and close to 200 injured, including two patients who died in Lithuania; a July account of the indictment put injuries above 220, with 20 minors. From November, Balkan Insight reported 63 deaths — 59 at the scene or soon afterwards — and more than 200 injured, figures it still used a year later. Prime Minister Hristijan Mickoski called the loss irreparable. On 1 April parliament banned indoor pyrotechnics, with government and opposition support.

Investigation and personnel decisions

Toškovski said the operator had no legal licence and that the paperwork, “as many other things in Macedonia in the past,” was connected with bribery and corruption. Fifteen of more than 20 people under investigation were in custody. With three suspects still in hospital, a Kočani court on the night of 17 March ordered 48-hour detention for eight others, including former economy minister Kreshnik Bekteshi, former market-inspectorate director Goran Trajkovski and former rescue-directorate director Bekim Maksuti, over a cabaret licence of 13 March 2024 suspected of being falsified or corruptly issued.

On 18 March Toškovski removed the Kočani and Štip police chiefs and commanders — internal-affairs, station and criminal-police posts in both towns — and replaced them with officers from Skopje, saying the move did not prejudge guilt but would keep the inquiry “free of pressure, doubt or influence.” The next day a Skopje court ordered 30 days’ detention for seven officers from the two towns, whom he accused of approving a cabaret licence for an unfit building.

On 21 March Kocevski opened an investigation of 27 people and three legal entities for grave crimes against general safety, alleging a chain of omissions from 2012 to the night of the concert. He alleged a bribe to an economy-ministry official between February 2024 and February 2025, and named three former mayors and economy, inspectorate and rescue officials among those who left the club operating. Police officer Toše Todorovski, born in 1988 and named among the dead, died while on duty; at a Probištip memorial on 27 September 2025, which Toškovski attended, colleagues called him a hero.

On 17 March, after mayor Ljupčo Papazov resigned, mourners blocked from the town hall threw eggs and bottles, and a café linked to the owner was attacked.

Trials and the responsibility debate

On 13 June 2025 Kocevski charged 34 people and three legal entities, most with “grave acts against public security” and one also with soliciting bribes for forged licences. They included owners and managers of Klasik DM and its subsidiary MMM Kafe, which ran Pulse, three former mayors, two former economy ministers, inspectors, guards and fireworks operators. Thirteen officers had been arrested the day before over the concert security plan. Eleven earlier suspects, including two other former economy ministers, were not charged for lack of evidence; a manager who died in hospital was dropped, and one injured suspect’s case was paused. The trial of 35 people and three companies opened on 19 November 2025 at Idrizovo prison, near Skopje, before judge Diana Gruevska-Ilievska, with 15 prosecutors seeking up to 10 years. On 2 December every defendant pleaded not guilty. Owner Dejan Jovanov said he did not feel guilty and his lawyer blamed DNK and the institutions; prosecutor Borče Janev called the club a “death trap.”

By March 2026 there were four proceedings and 58 defendants, with no conviction in the main case, still in evidence. Parents and survivors had testified, the accused had largely stayed silent, and defence lawyers argued that earlier officials were not co-perpetrators. Other indictments covered 13 officers due on 1 April 2026 over the night of the fire, three on trial over incorrect reports about minors, and nine due on 25 March 2026 over the licence — 23 police defendants in Balkan Insight’s count — with 11 more people, including revenue inspectors, still under investigation.

Families held weekly marches, including Saturday “Belated Reaction” protests in Kočani from 12:05, blaming a corrupt system. In Skopje they asked why some officers on duty had not been detained; Toškovski said he had wanted to resign but stayed so as not to interrupt the investigation. The Social Democratic Union of Macedonia demanded his resignation because the fire happened on his watch, and on 3 April other opposition MPs urged him to go for moral reasons. He said complaints already covered 34 people, 31 of them detained and drawn from SDSM, VMRO-DPMNE and the Democratic Union for Integration, plus three companies. On 29 April The Left (Levica), backed by SDSM and DUI, tabled a no-confidence motion citing lack of control over the club and the pyrotechnics. He said he would stay “to come to the truth,” denied ministerial failure, and said that with a falsified licence and no pyrotechnics request filed to the ministry, “the police acted in line with the law and there were no shortcomings.”

Borders and cross-border cases

Border management

At the Salzburg Forum in Zagreb in June 2025, Toškovski said a Frontex mission and European Union help on infrastructure, asylum and anti-smuggling work had strengthened border control in North Macedonia. From 1 January to 12 June 2025, he said, police prevented 1,956 illegal-crossing attempts, about 30 percent fewer than a year earlier.

At Blace, on the border with Kosovo, police of the Ministry of Internal Affairs staff the crossing. On 18 August 2024 a wedding convoy linked to Assembly speaker Afrim Gashi crossed in about two minutes, six vehicles in all. The Foreign Ministry had notified the trip on 16 August. Toškovski said Gashi and announced relatives were not in the passenger register and that not everyone was recorded. He pointed to a short relaxed regime under the border-control law when lanes are few, and said the shift manager would face measures.

On 15 December 2024 former deputy prime minister Artan Grubi left for Kosovo in a consular-plated Mercedes, just before a State Lottery raid over an alleged €8.1 million. The ministry filed a criminal complaint against exit officer B.J. for abuse of office: a detain-and-notify order was active, but at 09:06 he returned the documents without waiting for the system and logged the pair as pedestrians. He was suspended. In January 2025 Toškovski said prosecutors were still testing a lone lapse against an organized exit, and that other units had not been told the target.

On 16 December 2024 he said North Macedonia was not a Swiss watch and had been reduced to “Swiss cheese,” though professional officers remained. On 23 December he told Telma the ministry had been inherited in that state, citing backlogs in documents and licences.

The Mihajlova departure

Iva Mihailova (Mihaylova in Bulgarian reports), a dual citizen of Bulgaria and North Macedonia from Kočani, was charged over a 7 October 2025 crash on the Kočani–Štip road that killed a 33-year-old man and injured others, including her. Prosecutors alleged speed and a swerve into oncoming traffic; the defense blamed the other driver for avoiding a parked police car. The Kočani trial opened on 6 July 2026, with no final judgment by mid-October. Both passports were seized and she was barred from leaving. Courts in Kočani and, on 20 August 2026, in Štip refused to return them for treatment in Bulgaria. Toškovski said she had been reporting to police in Kočani.

In October 2026 she was in Sofia. She and lawyer Nikolay Dimitrov said they crossed legally on identity cards. The ministry found no legal exit, and Bulgarian border police reported no legal entry; her last logged trips were into Bulgaria in September 2025 and back that October. Toškovski said Safe City footage showed her in North Macedonia on the evening of 10 October, called the lawyer’s account false, and said there was no 2026 record at an official crossing. He described the green border with Bulgaria as “Swiss cheese,” said that whoever works also errs, reported a criminal complaint against the lawyer for unlawful help, and said internal control was checking whether officers were involved. He accused the opposition of blocking an interior-law reform and called Bulgaria a refuge for people fleeing prosecution.

On 13 October the Kočani court ordered 30 days’ detention. Toškovski said an international notice would follow and urged Bulgaria to apply the European Convention on Human Rights. Bulgarian authorities said they could not hand her over because she is a Bulgarian citizen, and that no Interpol red notice had been issued. The Foreign Ministry summoned Bulgaria’s ambassador. Prime Minister Hristijan Mickoski said those involved were under investigation and that he would raise the case with NATO and EU partners.

On 12 October The Left said the borders were “Swiss cheese” and the security system had hit bottom, and demanded that Toškovski answer. On 15 October Social Democratic Union of Macedonia leader Venko Filipče called the minister’s remark scandalous after more than two years in office, recalled Gashi and Grubi, and said responsibility was the least he could take. He asked Bulgaria to extradite Mihailova and questioned security-agency director Bojan Hristovski over what Filipče called a forged Bulgarian certificate. The party said Mickoski was shielding Toškovski, alleged a deal “under the radar,” and demanded a resignation.

Parliamentary scrutiny

From January 2025 to June 2026 the Assembly of North Macedonia rejected three interpellations against Interior Minister Panče Toškovski, each reported by the state news agency as a no-confidence motion, and he remained in office. In October 2026 opposition parties called for his resignation over Iva Mihailova’s departure while she faced charges. By 22 October that call had not come to an Assembly vote.

January 2025 motion

On 10 January 2025 the Assembly rejected a motion from the European Front, the coalition led by the Democratic Union for Integration, by 63 votes to seven, with no abstentions.

European Front MP Elmi Eziri said Toškovski was not doing his job and should take responsibility. The motion accused him of ethnic discrimination over 28 November 2024, Albanian Flag Day, of failing to guarantee equality and security, of unfairness, and of rhetoric that deepened division, and centered on desecration of the flag of North Macedonia and the later burning of an Albanian flag. Toškovski replied that anyone shown to have burned a state or community flag would go to prison. He said the Macedonian who burned the Albanian flag was taken into custody, as were the three Albanians who burned the Macedonian flag, and he called the motion a distraction from the fight against crime and corruption. Pavle Arsoski of the ZNAM movement called the text spin and said interethnic relations were intact. The Social Democratic Union of Macedonia left the sitting, saying new ethnic divisions were unnecessary.

April 2025 motion

On 14 April 2025 The Left filed an interpellation, backed by the Social Democratic Union and the Democratic Union for Integration. MP Saško Jančev said ten grounds were listed, five tied directly to the Kočani nightclub fire at Pulse on 16 March 2025, which killed 62 people and injured about 200. On 29 April the Assembly rejected the motion, 72 to 20, with no abstentions.

The grounds were lack of Ministry of Internal Affairs control over Pulse; illegal pyrotechnics; officers who gave no help; unprosecuted Facebook threats against government critics; a drone ban the party said was aimed at protests; arrests near Gostivar of people cleaning an old church; inaction after the Macedonian flag was burned; theft of marijuana held by police; a prime minister’s bodyguard disclosing a secret; and nepotism and cronyism. Jančev said VMRO-DPMNE-linked officials had been kept out of the inquiry and that Toškovski had command responsibility. Toškovski said he would stay to establish the facts, regretted every death, and denied a ministry failure: the licence was falsified, no pyrotechnics request had been filed, and blame lay with those who brought the devices in. He said the other cases, including marijuana stolen at Karbinci and the church at Galate, were being handled, and accused parts of the two opposition parties of trying to destabilize the country. During a break he met parents of the dead, who marched in Skopje that day. The Left asked that they enter the chamber; Speaker Afrim Gashi refused, calling it an attempt to manipulate the public.

Later challenges

On 24 June 2026 the Assembly rejected another motion from The Left, 58 votes to 19. MP Amar Mecinovikj said the country was unsafe because the ministry was using the security apparatus to employ party staff rather than to guarantee security. Opposition members demanded a resignation over scandals and what they called zero accountability, while Toškovski and VMRO-DPMNE members cited results and suppressed criminal groups. He called the motion a cheap stunt, the third challenge from The Left in under two years, and an attempt to protect former officials.

On 12 October 2026, after Mihailova appeared in Bulgaria while charged over a fatal crash, the Social Democratic Union demanded his resignation. It contrasted her claim of a legal crossing on an identity card with statements that neither side’s border records showed a legal crossing, although both passports had been seized, and alleged an arrangement inside the government. On 13 October Toškovski said she had left illegally and that an international warrant would follow, and he asked Bulgaria to respect international rules. The ministry said a joint check with Bulgarian border police found no record of a legal entry. On 16 October Prime Minister Hristijan Mickoski said the claim of an agreed escape had collapsed and that some evidence would be shown first to NATO partners. He said warrants covered Mihailova and her father, whom he described as finally convicted, and that both should face Macedonian institutions. The opposition still demanded Toškovski’s resignation. Those were public calls, not an interpellation the Assembly had voted on by 22 October 2026.

International cooperation

Regional and European partners

On 9 May 2025 he and Serbia’s interior minister, Ivica Dačić, signed joint controls at Tabanovce–Preševo: host-state officers carry out both their own check and the neighbor’s exit check. The system opened at Tabanovce on 4 July 2025.

On 18 November 2024 he and Kosovo interior minister Xhelal Sveçla signed a protocol for joint controls at Blace–Elez Han and Jazince–Globochica. On 4 October 2024, Albania’s interior minister, Ervin Hoxha, and he discussed the same model and cooperation against organized crime, irregular migration and smuggling. On 5 June 2025 he and Greece’s interior minister, Theodoros Livanios, marked an IPA III project of more than €7.7 million for a Markova Noga–Lemos crossing at Prespa. A 28 February 2025 meeting with Bulgaria’s ambassador, Zelyasko Radukov, produced no reported agreement. The Ministry of Internal Affairs said they discussed a cooperation programme, that he invited Interior Minister Daniel Mitov, and that both sides saw border work as one way of easing wider difficulties.

On 25 June 2024, at the Salzburg Forum in Austria, he and Interior Minister Gerhard Karner agreed to continue work on migration and smuggling, and he credited joint operations with Frontex. On 28 August 2025, Slovenia’s interior minister, Boštjan Poklukar, said cooperation through Europol and Frontex was already close and restated support for North Macedonia’s European Union membership, citing the 2015–2016 migration response as a reference for accession.

On 28 October 2024 in Budva, before Home Affairs Commissioner Ylva Johansson, he signed an administrative arrangement with the European Commission making North Macedonia an observer in the European Migration Network. A delegation representing him, not the minister in person, signed a Frontex memorandum in Warsaw, reported on 26 November 2025, on sharing information between complaint mechanisms for allegations of fundamental-rights violations; Montenegro and Serbia signed comparable texts. At the Berlin Process interior ministers’ meeting in Germany on 17 September 2024, the ministry described the format as joint preparation for accession. On 4 April 2025, at a “Friends of MARRI” briefing, he linked the Migration, Asylum, Refugees Regional Initiative to EU integration and said North Macedonia would remain its host.

United States and multilateral work

With the United States, the dated public record is mainly cybercrime. On 22 September 2025 he opened in Skopje a session of the FBI National Academy Associates’ European chapter, an alumni body rather than an operational unit of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. CyberScoop reported that authorities disrupted the OLVX marketplace in April 2026 and later charged a 20-year-old, E.A., over sales since 2023 of stolen data and attack tools. The FBI Cyber Division said on LinkedIn, as quoted there, that it had supplied intelligence and that this was its first coordinated cyber operation with North Macedonia. On 15 October 2026 he wrote on Facebook, as reported by the Macedonian Information Agency, that this recognition confirmed the police’s work.

On 14 October 2026 he told a United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime meeting on foreign victims of human trafficking that the Western Balkans were a region of origin, transit and destination and that the response had to be multidisciplinary. On 10 December 2025 he attended the Global Alliance to Counter Migrant Smuggling conference in Brussels, where the Commission, Frontex and Europol were also listed.

Evidence & methodology

How the record is sourced and how the score is derived.

The score is formula-derived (Factrail formula v1, version 1.0.0), not an editorial verdict. Read the methodology.

By the · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed

Dispute a fact on this pageNamed here, or represent someone who is? Request a right of reply.