The 55% Profit Warning: What a UK-EU Food Deal Would Actually Remove
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed

TL;DR
A Defra survey found 55% of SME food exporters reported lower profits. The proposed SPS deal could remove certificates and checks, but not every trade cost.
Key graph impact
The article explains graph entities; the causal edges belong to the facts and drivers it links to.
- ArticleThe 55% Profit Warning: What a UK-EU Food Deal Would Actually Remove
- mentionsDriverHousehold Purchasing Power
- weakensIndicators (2)Global Consumer Price Inflation (annual %)
Weakens · 40% impact strength
Observed
Indicator reading 5.8 annual % change in CPI, better than normal (Dec 2024)
Better than normal5 indicator readings, 2020–2024: rose from 3.3 annual % change in CPI to 5.8 annual % change in CPI, latest better than normal.
Moving normal line · Lag ~12 mo
- Better
Weakens · 35% impact strength
Observed
Indicator reading 10.4%, worse than normal (2024)
Worse than normal7 indicator readings, 2018–2024: fell from 11.1% to 10.4%, latest worse than normal.
Above normal = worse
Article
A Defra-commissioned survey of 600 small and medium-sized food and drink manufacturers across Great Britain found that 55 per cent of firms exporting to the EU and 47 per cent of importers reported lower profitability after new trading requirements began in January 2021. The result, published on 13 November 2026, is a warning about the cost structure of small shipments — not a controlled estimate proving that Brexit alone caused every firm’s loss. The government is negotiating a UK-EU sanitary and phytosanitary agreement, with a mid-2027 implementation target. It could remove some of the most expensive health certificates, inspections and routine border checks. But it would not erase customs paperwork, rules-of-origin requirements or every regulatory cost. The central question is what a small manufacturer would actually stop paying, what it would still have to do, and whether the savings reach workers, farmers and consumers.
The survey is about margins, not just lost paperwork
The 600-firm survey was carried out by ICF for Defra and covered food and drink manufacturing SMEs in England, Scotland and Wales. It found that 55 per cent of EU exporters and 47 per cent of importers reported lower profitability following the introduction of new trading requirements in January 2021. Among firms that had stopped trading with the EU since 2021, 69 per cent of exporters and 55 per cent of importers said Brexit was a major reason. The survey also found that 58 per cent of manufacturers believed a new UK-EU agreement could help them increase, resume or begin exports within a year; half said the same for imports.
The priorities are specific. For exporters, 79 per cent identified less paperwork as a leading improvement, 78 per cent wanted lower trading costs and 71 per cent wanted fewer border delays. Importers gave similar answers. Those responses point to a fixed-cost problem. A large exporter can spread the cost of a certificate, broker, compliance employee or delayed truck across many consignments. A small manufacturer sending a limited number of pallets can face much the same administrative steps for a far smaller shipment. A fee that is manageable for a multinational can consume a material share of a small producer’s margin.
The survey has limits that should be stated plainly. It records businesses’ own reports and intentions; it is not a controlled before-and-after study with a comparison group of otherwise similar firms. The published government summary does not provide a confidence interval or a causal decomposition separating border requirements from energy, labour, ingredient, finance and demand costs. The 55 per cent figure therefore means that more than half of the sampled exporters reported lower profitability after the new requirements arrived. It does not mean that Brexit alone reduced the profits of 55 per cent of every UK food business by a known amount.
The cost stack on one shipment
The government’s own business guidance gives a more concrete picture of the costs it hopes to remove. An Export Health Certificate for agri-food goods can cost up to £200. A phytosanitary certificate costs around £25, with inspection fees of at least £127.60. Organic Certificates of Inspection for certain exports average about £35. Port Health Authority identity checks on meat and dairy exports add an average of £31 per load. Sampling can add approximately £1,200 to a cheese load, £1,400 to a salmon shipment, £440 to a load of apples or £1,200 to a beef load.
These figures are not a single average bill. They apply to different products, certificates and inspection regimes, and should not simply be added together as if every shipment incurs every charge. They do show why the problem is not just a form that takes an extra hour to complete. A small business may need a veterinary or official certificate, laboratory sampling, a broker, a border appointment and staff time to coordinate documents. If a shipment is delayed, the cost can extend to refrigerated storage, missed delivery slots, spoilage risk and a customer who turns to another supplier.
The costs also vary by product. Meat, dairy, fish, eggs, plants and organic goods face different requirements. A mixed load may need separate certification for different product categories. A business exporting cheese and meat does not necessarily face the same paperwork as a company sending packaged biscuits. The final SPS agreement will determine which checks disappear, which remain and what transition rules apply. Until those details are settled, the published government figures are estimates of costs expected to be removed, not a guaranteed saving for every firm.
What the SPS agreement changes — and what it does not
The UK and EU are negotiating a sanitary and phytosanitary agreement covering food safety, animal health and plant health. The government is working toward implementation by mid-2027. The proposed model is dynamic alignment: Great Britain would apply relevant EU SPS rules in defined areas, subject to a limited number of exceptions that remain under negotiation. The Food Standards Agency says around 80 pieces of legislation within its own remit are expected to be affected, out of approximately 500 pieces of legislation across the wider programme.
For covered goods, the aim is to remove much of the need for export health certificates and routine SPS checks at the border. That should reduce repeat inspections and paperwork for businesses moving qualifying products between Great Britain and the EU. It should also reduce friction for many importers and for businesses supplying domestic customers with ingredients or goods affected by the same regulatory framework. The government estimates that about 500,000 businesses could be affected, including companies operating entirely within Great Britain that do not trade directly with the EU.
But this is not a general free-trade reset. Customs declarations and rules-of-origin requirements do not disappear simply because SPS checks are reduced. Tariff-free access under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement still depends on meeting origin rules. VAT, excise, transport, commercial contracts and non-SPS product requirements remain. Imports from countries outside the agreement will not automatically receive the same treatment. Nor does the deal remove the need for businesses to comply with food-safety rules; it changes how the UK and EU recognise and administer those rules across the shared area.
Dynamic alignment is the trade-off. Once the agreement is in force, Great Britain would update relevant rules in line with EU changes within the agreed scope. The Food Standards Agency says the UK would be involved early in the development of relevant EU legal acts and consulted in the process, but it would not regain a vote in EU institutions. A limited set of exceptions may preserve specific UK rules, but the scope and operation of those exceptions depend on the final negotiation. Businesses that have invested in a distinct UK formulation, authorisation or compliance route may need to adjust. The FSA has warned that some firms could need 12 to 24 months to adapt processes, supply chains or products, and that transitional arrangements cannot be assumed before they are agreed.
The trade numbers show the market, not the cause
The latest HMRC-based Defra statistics provide a current scale for the trade relationship. In 2025, UK food, feed and drink exports to EU countries were worth £14.861 billion in real 2025 prices; imports from the EU were £47.025 billion. Across all destinations, UK food, feed and drink exports were worth £25.7 billion in current prices, up 5 per cent from 2024, although they fell 0.8 per cent in real terms after adjusting for trade-price inflation. These figures show that the EU remains a major market and supplier. They do not prove that the entire trade gap is caused by Brexit or that the proposed agreement will close it.
The data also contain a comparability warning. In 2021, the source for Great Britain-to-EU export data changed from Intrastat to customs declarations. Defra explicitly says that figures before and after that point are not directly comparable. That makes sweeping claims based on a single pre- and post-EU Exit comparison unreliable. The survey’s firm-level evidence and the official trade series answer different questions: one records what a sample of manufacturers says happened to profitability; the other records the value of trade across the whole sector.
Who gains, who pays and where savings may go
Small exporters with low shipment volumes stand to gain most if certificates, sampling and routine border checks are genuinely removed. Importers may benefit from fewer delays and lower inspection costs. Producers could use the savings to protect margins, hire staff, invest in equipment or return to markets they abandoned. Consumers may benefit if lower costs are passed through into prices and if fewer shipments are delayed or spoiled. None of those outcomes is automatic. A business can keep the savings as margin; a retailer can negotiate a lower wholesale price; a distributor can retain part of the benefit. The agreement itself does not dictate who captures the gain.
There are also businesses that may lose revenue or need to change. Veterinary certifiers, laboratories, customs brokers and port-health services may see less work in areas where checks are removed, although other compliance services will remain. UK farmers and manufacturers could benefit from easier access to EU customers but also face stronger competition from EU products entering Great Britain under a smoother SPS regime. Food-safety regulators must maintain standards while implementing a more integrated system. The FSA says the purpose is to maintain food safety and standards while reducing friction; the final text and exceptions will determine whether that balance works in practice.
The political responsibility is divided. The UK government negotiates and implements the agreement through Defra, the Food Standards Agency, the devolved administrations and other departments. The European Commission negotiates for the EU, with the political framework set by both sides. Maroš Šefčovič is relevant to the wider EU-UK trade relationship, while Ursula von der Leyen leads the Commission that sets the EU’s negotiating direction. The 2025 reset began under the government of Keir Starmer; the present government must now complete the technical agreement and its domestic implementation. The effects will be felt through Household Purchasing Power, but Factrail’s Global Consumer Price Inflation series is not a UK food-price index. A dedicated UK food-price indicator is needed to test whether lower border costs actually reach shoppers.
The test is the bill that disappears
The 55 per cent figure makes the political case for action, but the test of the deal is not whether ministers announce that red tape has been cut. It is whether a small exporter can send a qualifying shipment without paying for a certificate, inspection or sampling regime that the agreement has removed; whether the border process becomes more predictable; whether firms can understand the rules early enough to prepare; and whether the savings are large enough to change a decision to export. The government should publish the final list of covered goods, exceptions, transition dates and expected cost savings by business size and product category. It should then track actual certificate use, border delays, shipment rejection rates and the number of SMEs returning to EU trade.
The survey is evidence that many small manufacturers feel the burden. It is not a complete causal account of the last five years. The SPS agreement could remove a substantial set of recurring costs, but it will not erase every trade barrier or guarantee higher profits. The most defensible conclusion is that a narrower, well-implemented SPS deal could make low-volume food trade viable for more firms — while dynamic alignment and the transition to new rules create their own costs. The winners will be the businesses that can actually use the simplified route, not those that merely appear in a government forecast.
Sources
- Defra: New business survey finds Brexit barriers hit profits for more than half of small and medium UK food and drink manufacturers (opens in a new tab)
- GOV.UK: Businesses urged to take simple steps for smoother trade with the EU (opens in a new tab)
- Food Standards Agency: Programme update on preparations for a UK-EU SPS agreement (opens in a new tab)
- Defra: UK trade in Food, Feed and Drink, 2025 updated (opens in a new tab)
- Food Standards Agency: Progress against economic growth goals, September 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- Defra: Improving EU trade — what businesses need to know (opens in a new tab)
- UK-EU Common Understanding, 19 May 2025 (opens in a new tab)
Evidence
The sources this article cites, claim-bearing material first.
- gov.uk · Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs, survey of small and medium food-and-drink manufacturers, 13 November 2026
- gov.uk · GOV.UK: Businesses urged to take simple steps for smoother trade with the EU
- gov.uk · Food Standards Agency: Programme update on preparations for a UK-EU SPS agreement
- gov.uk · gov.uk/government/statistics/uk-trade-in-food-feed-and-drink-2025-updated/uk-trade-in-food-feed-and-drink-2025-updated
- defrafarming.blog.gov.uk · Defra: Improving EU trade — what businesses need to know
More analysis
Ranked by shared facts, drivers and people — never by publication date alone.
Articles12
- UK-EU Electricity Access: The Cohesion-Fund PriceShares the driver: Household Purchasing Power · 15 November 2026
- Europe's €30bn AI Build Faces a €500bn QuestionShares the driver: Household Purchasing Power · 15 November 2026
- Italy's Affordable EV Bet Now Runs Through LeapmotorShares the driver: Household Purchasing Power · 13 November 2026
- VW's Salzgitter Battery Bet Meets the Brexit DeadlineShares the driver: Household Purchasing Power · 13 November 2026