Skip to content
News

Australian Tourism Warns Visa Ballot Could Cost $2.5bn

Published Factrail

Barron Valley Hotel in Atherton, Queensland, whose owner lobbied government over working holiday visas

Summary

Tourism businesses warn Australia's proposed backpacker visa ballot could put A$2.5bn in annual activity at risk. What ministers may change.

Report

Australia's tourism industry sharpened its opposition to the federal government's planned Working Holiday Maker visa ballot on Saturday, November 14, with a commissioned economic estimate warning that the restrictions could put A$2.5 billion in annual activity at risk. The government is considering revisions, but neither the ballot's final timing nor its replacement rules have been formally settled.

The dispute is about much more than backpacking holidays. Regional farms, restaurants, hotels and attractions use temporary workers to cover seasonal jobs that can be hard to fill locally. The proposed lottery would replace the predictable path by which many working holiday-makers can extend their stay after completing specified regional work.

What the new numbers suggest

The Tourism & Transport Forum's economic estimate, reported by The Australian, put potential annual losses at A$719.2 million in New South Wales, A$637.4 million in Queensland, A$492.6 million in Victoria and A$461.2 million in Western Australia. Those figures are estimates of economic exposure under a policy scenario, not losses already measured or a government budget forecast.

Working holiday-makers were reported to have spent A$4.4 billion in the previous financial year, including A$1.1 billion in regional areas. Tourism groups argue that travelers who stay longer often work in places that would otherwise struggle to attract staff. The industry also points out that short-term visitors spend money on accommodation, restaurants and tours even when not employed.

In Cairns, a Chamber of Commerce survey of 31 businesses found 84% feared the proposal would make the region less competitive and 70% expected lower annual revenue. It is a small, non-random business survey, so its percentages should not be mistaken for a national economic forecast. The concern it captures is still concrete: employers must roster staff months before a peak visitor season begins.

Tourism Tropical North Queensland reported that 180 staff had left a group of 12 major employers, roughly 30% of their working-holiday workforce. The Courier-Mail also described staffing gaps on the Atherton Tablelands. Those departures reflect reports from affected employers and cannot all be conclusively attributed to one proposed regulation.

The proposed policy and the uncertainty

Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke (opens in a new tab) had proposed a cap of 45,000 second-year visa places and 5,000 third-year places. Reports now suggest a possible delay of the new ballot until February and an increase in third-year capacity to 25,000, paired with longer specified regional work requirements of four to six months rather than 88 days.

These revisions have been discussed, not enacted. Earlier reporting offered a different possible third-year cap of 20,000. The variation is precisely why employers and visa holders should rely on published immigration rules rather than media predictions. Burke has maintained the government's goal of reducing overall working holiday-maker numbers as part of its migration policy.

The British arrangement adds another layer. A free trade agreement gives eligible UK travelers broader access to multi-year working holidays without the same regional-work obligations. Australian officials have raised the possibility of negotiating changes with London, but the outcome depends on the bilateral agreement. Industry advocates ask why non-British workers should face a lottery after completing regional jobs while British visitors enjoy different conditions.

A pressure test for Albanese

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese (opens in a new tab) faces a choice between tighter migration numbers and the regional labor supply that farms and tourism businesses say they need. Migration policy is not only an aggregate headcount. It allocates opportunities across regions, sectors and nationalities, and the outcome can alter the cost-of-living pressure (opens in a new tab) that households face through prices and wages.

A tightening could reduce competition for some domestic jobs or ease pressure on housing in particular locations, depending on actual arrivals. Businesses counter that removing short-term workers could force reductions in opening hours, lost harvests or higher prices. Neither claim can be settled without observing wages, vacancies and housing conditions after implementation.

Who gains and who pays

Employers gain certainty if people who complete required regional work receive a predictable extension rather than a random chance. Migrant workers gain clearer incentives and more confidence about whether to stay. Regions gain spending and labor supply when workers remain. But a larger visa intake may impose local housing and service pressures, and governments have a legitimate interest in managing numbers.

A lottery could benefit applicants who receive places despite being unable to commit to the longer work requirement; unsuccessful people lose the opportunity despite completing work. The federal government gains a tool for meeting immigration targets but risks backlash in rural electorates. The distribution matters more than any simple claim that all visas are either good or bad.

What comes next

The next decision should establish a firm transition date, caps, regional requirements, treatment of workers already in Australia and the status of British applicants. Watch the final Home Affairs instruments, actual visa grants and regional vacancy rates. Saturday's new industry estimates explain the pressure for a reversal. They do not establish that the A$2.5 billion worst-case exposure will occur.

Sources

Context timeline