Elton John Presses Australia to Give Artists a Say Over AI Training
Published Factrail

Summary
An appeal at the ARIA Awards puts pressure on Labor to say who can license Australian creative work for AI training.
Report
Elton John has urged Australia to protect artists’ right to decide whether artificial intelligence companies can use their work for training. ABC News carried the appeal on November 19 after a video message played at the previous evening’s ARIA Awards. The British musician backed the Not AI’s To Take campaign at a moment when the government of Anthony Albanese (opens in a new tab) is weighing how to give creators control and payment when software developers want to use their work.
Acting Prime Minister Richard Marles (opens in a new tab) said Labor wanted creators and news organisations properly remunerated. In a November 18 interview on ABC Afternoon Briefing, he argued that scraping already occurs without adequate compensation and that the government needed to engage with the industry to improve the position of creators. The Nightly reported his response on November 19. Independent senator Jacqui Lambie accused Albanese of remaining on the sidelines. The fight has put pressure on ministers to explain whether creators would have the power to withhold permission, and how payment would work if they did agree.
Three different ways to pay
The approach Elton John is pressing for would put permission first. An AI developer would seek approval from the relevant rightsholders before using protected material for training where permission is required. For music, the rights in a recording and those in the underlying composition can belong to different parties. Knowing whom to approach and how to divide a payment matters as much as agreeing on the headline price. Large labels and publishers can negotiate access to catalogues. Independent musicians and writers often have less leverage on their own.
An opt-out route would move some of that burden onto rightsholders. Under a broad version, developers could use qualifying online material unless the owners reserved their rights in the required way. The details would determine how much control exists in practice. A notice on an author’s site might protect a copy published there while leaving uncertainty about copies elsewhere. Transparency about what companies collect would help a creator work out whether an opt-out had been respected. Discussion of such a route is a policy debate. Marles’s comments gave no commitment to a final bill.
Collective licensing or a negotiated payment framework offers another route. An intermediary could bundle rights, give technology companies a single point of contact and distribute proceeds to creators. A framework could make it easier to license large collections, but its value would depend on who is covered, how payments are set and whether creators can decline to participate. A payment scheme that leaves permission unclear would address only part of the objection raised at the awards.
The UK and EU offer different precedents
In March 2026 the UK government said a broad opt-out exception was no longer its preferred approach after consultation. In the European Union, Article 4 of the 2019 copyright directive provides a text-and-data mining exception for lawfully accessible works when rights have not been expressly reserved, with machine-readable means contemplated for online material. The choices facing Australia therefore concern both access to works and how creators can exercise their rights across borders. They also show why Microsoft (opens in a new tab) and other model providers may face different licensing conditions in different markets.
Musicians, writers and media companies stand to gain if rights they hold generate a new licensing income. How much reaches individual creators depends on their contracts and the distribution rules. AI firms would pay for rights clearance, licences and record-keeping, costs that smaller model builders may find harder to absorb. Data-centre investors benefit from demand for local computing and from clear rules, but hosting a model and having permission to train it are separate commercial decisions. The choice for Labor is who must make the first move when a company wants to use a work, and who has enough information to enforce the outcome.
Sources
- ABC News, November 19 (opens in a new tab)
- Australian Defence Ministers, Marles interview, November 18 (opens in a new tab)
- The Nightly, November 19 (opens in a new tab)
- The Australian, November 18 (opens in a new tab)
- UK government, copyright and AI report, March 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- European Union, Directive 2019/790 (opens in a new tab)