Skip to content
News

World Court Finds Myanmar Responsible for Rohingya Genocide

Published Factrail

Peace Palace, seat of the International Court of Justice in The Hague

Summary

The ICJ ordered Myanmar to prosecute suspects and provide reparations after finding it committed genocide against the Rohingya in 2017.

Report

The International Court of Justice found on November 19 that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya during its 2017 military clearance operations in northern Rakhine State. In a 9–6 decision, the United Nations’ highest court held Myanmar responsible under the Genocide Convention. It ordered the country to investigate and prosecute suspected perpetrators, enable safe voluntary return and provide restitution and compensation. For roughly a million Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh, the ruling gives those demands the force of a binding judgment between states.

What the judges ordered

The judgment and the court’s November 19 press release distinguish the acts of genocide from Myanmar’s separate failures to prevent and punish it and to preserve evidence. The judges directed Myanmar to investigate suspected crimes and, where warranted, prosecute. They also required measures for the safe and voluntary return of refugees, restoration of property and compensation for harm. Myanmar must report within two years on restitution and proposed compensation. That reporting deadline gives the parties a date against which to measure progress. It gives no family a scheduled return date or a confirmed payment amount.

The Associated Press reported on November 19 that this was the first time the court had found a country responsible for committing genocide. In the earlier Bosnia case, the judges found that genocide took place at Srebrenica and that Serbia violated its duty to prevent it. Here, they attributed the commission of genocide itself to Myanmar. The Gambia filed the case in 2019, invoking obligations that parties to the convention owe to one another. Individual criminal responsibility remains a separate question for courts with jurisdiction over particular defendants.

What enforcement depends on

The ICJ judgment is binding on the parties. The court depends on states to carry out its orders and has no officers who can make arrests, take possession of land or deliver compensation. Under the UN Charter, The Gambia can turn to the Security Council if Myanmar fails to comply. Any substantive council resolution can face a veto from a permanent member. China’s leadership (opens in a new tab) therefore has influence over the scope of any council action, while Myanmar’s immediate neighbours have influence over diplomatic engagement and humanitarian access.

British Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband (opens in a new tab) announced on November 19 that Britain was expelling Myanmar’s defence attaché, summoning its chargé d’affaires and seeking an urgent Security Council meeting. The UK can take the diplomatic steps directly. Getting the council to agree on consequences requires a separate decision. The Secretary-General’s statement the same day called for compliance with the judgment. ASEAN (opens in a new tab) can use contacts with Myanmar’s authorities and neighbours to press for access and protection, but it has no mandate to enforce the judgment.

Who gains and who bears the cost

Refugees gain a judgment recognising their injuries and spelling out what Myanmar owes. Bangladesh, which has hosted the displaced population for years, gains a stronger basis to press for safe return and continued international support for the camps in the meantime. Myanmar’s authorities face the costs of investigation, restitution and compensation and the political consequences of investigating people associated with the military. Donor governments and Bangladesh still carry the immediate costs of food, shelter and services while families remain displaced.

The next practical questions concern control and safety in Rakhine. Restitution requires an accessible process for families whose homes were destroyed or whose documents were lost. Return depends on whether people can move safely, live where they choose and remain without renewed persecution. The junta’s willingness to investigate military personnel and the ability of independent organisations to observe conditions will help determine whether the court’s orders change those choices. Families in Bangladesh will have to make their own decisions about return as those conditions become clear.

Sources

Context timeline