
CartaCapital
CartaCapital is a weekly Brazilian news magazine, edited in São Paulo, covering politics, the economy and culture.
Expert article
CartaCapital is a weekly Brazilian news magazine, edited in São Paulo, covering politics, the economy and culture. It was founded in 1994 by the journalist Mino Carta with Bob Fernandes, Nelson Letaif and Wagner Carelli, who had worked together at IstoÉ. The publication is registered from 23 August 1994 and is issued by Editora Basset Ltda.; Manuela Carta is the publisher, and the newsroom is at Rua da Consolação, 881.
It began as a monthly of Carta Editorial, with an initial emphasis on finance; the name came from that imprint. In 1996 it became fortnightly and turned toward political analysis, and in 2001 it became a weekly of culture, politics and economics. Mino Carta, born in Genoa on 6 September 1933, had already directed Quatro Rodas, Jornal da Tarde, Veja and IstoÉ, and he edited CartaCapital until his death on 2 September 2025, aged 91, at Hospital Sírio-Libanês in São Paulo. President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, a friend of nearly fifty years, decreed three days of official mourning.
The magazine describes its standard as fidelity to the facts, a critical spirit and the oversight of power. It has also stated electoral preferences: in 2002, and again in 2006, it openly supported Lula, candidate of the Workers' Party, a step that drew varied reactions in the press and that critics have used to question the claim of independence from power. Poder360 has described the title as influential among readers who are socially liberal and on the left in politics, despite a circulation that was never large.
CartaCapital joined the circulation auditor IVC in 2005, when net circulation for June was reported at 40,113 copies. Using later IVC figures, Poder360 recorded an average print circulation of 18,647 in 2015 and 2,130 printed copies a week at the end of 2021, among the steepest declines in its sample, after the publisher said a change of suppliers had made the subscriber file unauditable and reclassified it. After Fernandes, Letaif and Carelli left in 2005, the magazine passed to Editora Confiança, with the economist Luiz Gonzaga Belluzzo as editorial consultant beside publisher Manuela Carta, and the house launched the education monthly Carta na Escola. A masthead updated on 29 October 2025 lists Sergio Lirio as editor-in-chief and Belluzzo still as editorial consultant.
Plea-bargain testimony later put the magazine’s finances in political dispute. Emílio Odebrecht and his son Marcelo Odebrecht said they were asked, by Lula and by former finance minister Guido Mantega respectively, to help CartaCapital, and that Odebrecht arranged about R$3 million through its structured-operations sector, later offset with advertising space; the publisher said the sum was an ordinary advertising advance of R$3.5 million between 2007 and 2009 and had not been brokered by anyone. In February 2009 the São Paulo Court of Justice refused banker Daniel Dantas’s claim for moral damages over a January 2004 editorial.
Founding and early history
Origins and the name
CartaCapital was launched in São Paulo, Brazil, in August 1994 by the journalist Mino Carta together with Bob Fernandes, Nelson Letaif and Wagner Carelli, who had already worked with him at IstoÉ. Carta had left the editorship of IstoÉ in August 1993 after disagreements with Domingo Alzugaray over the magazine’s political and conceptual line. It was prepared inside Carta Editorial, the house his brother Luis Carta had founded in 1976 to publish the Brazilian edition of Vogue. In 1987 Luis had gone to Madrid, at the invitation of Condé Nast, to launch and direct the Spanish edition.
Mino Carta, the journalist who founded CartaCapital in 1994.
In an essay published in 2008, Carta described the negotiations that produced the magazine. Luis’s son Andrea, who called him zio Mino, wanted Carta Editorial to carry a business title. Carta, who had been the first editorial director of Veja from its launch in 1968 until 1976 and a founder of IstoÉ in that latter year, said business journalism was outside his range and proposed instead a magazine that would examine power wherever it appeared, including in business. Luis, still in Madrid, approved the plan at the end of March 1994 and died there of a pulmonary embolism on 20 April, at 57, before a first issue existed. Preparation began in early June with Fernandes and Letaif, companions from Senhor and IstoÉ, and with Carelli, who had been with Carta at IstoÉ in the late 1970s.
The name was not a tribute to the editor. Carta wrote that “Carta” came only from the publishing house, and that in the first issue he glossed “Capital” as meaning principal or decisive and, as a noun, economic value, a country’s administrative center and wealth. The choice, he wrote, “does not indicate delusions of grandeur: it simply explains the purpose of a CartaCapital addressed to the heart of power.” The CPDOC of the Fundação Getulio Vargas records the same origin: the title was suggested by Carta Editorial and also marked an initial focus on finance.
From monthly to weekly
Published by Carta Editorial, the magazine began as a monthly concerned with business, the economy, politics and behavior. In March 1996 it became fortnightly, still with a heavy stress on macro- and microeconomics; Carta later recalled advertisements in the business magazine Exame telling readers to “refuse imitations.” The political accent grew over the rest of the decade. He pointed to the first issue of January 1999, whose cover, in his account, placed President Fernando Henrique Cardoso in a circle of fire under the line “quebramos!” (“we are broke”), after the real was devalued at the start of Cardoso’s second term—a cover that, he wrote, angered advertising executives gathered that week.
In August 2001, seven years after the monthly launch, CartaCapital became a weekly and defined itself as a magazine of politics, economics and culture. Maurício Stycer, hired that April by Fernandes for the culture section while the title was still fortnightly, later said the change was meant to put it in competition with Veja and IstoÉ. The Arquivo Público do Estado de São Paulo holds the issue of 24 October 2001—year 8, number 162—and catalogs the magazine as a São Paulo weekly of politics, economics and culture. By then, he wrote, only he and Fernandes remained of the founders, though not, he added, in a way that erased Carelli and Letaif, and the newsroom had been enlarged for the heavier schedule. The editorial of the first weekly restated a formula he dated to the launch: fidelity to factual truth, an open critical spirit, and scrutiny of power.
The 2005 reorganization
The CPDOC entry compresses the next change into a single year. It states that in 2005 Fernandes, Letaif and Carelli left, and that the magazine was then published by Editora Confiança, with the economist Luiz Gonzaga Belluzzo as editorial consultant beside the publisher Manuela Carta, Mino Carta’s daughter, while Mino remained editorial director.
Carta’s own essay places the company earlier and separates the exits. He wrote that, with the move to a weekly, Editora Confiança had been created to house CartaCapital and to consider other titles, and that inside it he and Belluzzo—friends, he said, for four decades—formed a business partnership. Manuela Carta, as publisher, and Belluzzo kept him off the commercial side, which he presented as protection against his lack of vocation for business. The same essay says Carelli and Letaif were already gone by 2001 and dates Fernandes’s departure to December 2005. Stycer recalled the break differently: Fernandes left at the end of 2004, and Stycer became editor-in-chief at the beginning of 2005, holding the post through 2006. The reference accounts converge on the structure that followed: Confiança as the publishing company, Belluzzo beside the editor, Manuela Carta as publisher, and Mino Carta still directing the newsroom.
Ownership, circulation and finances
Publishers and corporate structure
CartaCapital began as a monthly edited by Carta Editorial, the firm from which the title's name was suggested. In 2005, after Bob Fernandes, Nelson Letaif and Wagner Carelli left, it was edited by Editora Confiança, with Luiz Gonzaga Belluzzo as editorial consultant and Manuela Carta, daughter of editorial director Mino Carta, as publisher. Editora Confiança Ltda. (CNPJ 04.735.670/0001-07), registered on 24 October 2001, remains an active limited company in São Paulo. The federal registry classifies it as a holding of non-financial institutions, with stated capital of R$13,216,763 and its office at Rua Bela Cintra, 1,786, apartment 151-B, Consolação.
Its registered partners are Demetrio Carta and Luiz Gonzaga de Mello Belluzzo, both partner-administrators since 2001, and, from 21 June 2017, Cartabelluzzo Participações Ltda., represented by Belluzzo. Folha de S.Paulo reported that Mino Carta had been baptized Demétrio Carta. CNN Brasil reported that he died in São Paulo on 2 September 2025. An October 2026 registry extract still listed Demetrio Carta. Cartabelluzzo Participações Ltda. (CNPJ 14.511.626/0001-77), opened on 6 October 2011 with stated capital of R$16,072,142, lists Demetrio Carta, Belluzzo and Eduardo da Rocha Azevedo.
In November 2011 Meio & Mensagem reported that Azevedo, a former president of the Bovespa and the BM&F, had bought 30 percent of Editora Confiança and joined Mino Carta and Belluzzo as a controller. The registry still lists Azevedo as a partner of Cartabelluzzo, but it does not publish quota percentages.
The masthead updated on 29 October 2025 says the weekly is published by Editora Basset Ltda. Basset (CNPJ 08.190.328/0001-20), incorporated on 18 July 2006, is listed as an active microempresa whose main activity is magazine editing integrated with printing, with stated capital of R$1,269,174, at Rua da Consolação, 881, suites 100 and 101, Consolação, CEP 01345-900. The masthead places the newsroom on the 10th floor of that building, CEP 01301-000, and names Manuela Carta as publisher and Mara Lúcia da Silva as director of finance and personnel. Those two are the registered partner-administrators, Carta since 2006 and Silva since 11 August 2020. Confiança is not a partner of Basset, though both use the telephone (11) 3474-0163. From 2021 through 2024 the registry shows Basset on the real-profit tax regime.
Audited circulation
A Poder360 compilation of 2021 figures from the Instituto Verificador de Comunicação covered seven magazines in Brazil, among them Veja, Exame and CartaCapital. CartaCapital's print circulation fell 76 percent, by 5,804 copies, to 2,130 a week, the steepest print drop in the group; its digital circulation fell 91 percent and its combined circulation 83 percent. Veja closed the year at 92,850 printed copies, down 36 percent. Poder360 put CartaCapital's 2015 average circulation at 18,647 copies.
The title was outside the institute, then the Instituto Verificador de Circulação, until 2005. The first report, as recorded by the CPDOC of the Fundação Getulio Vargas from a trade item that September, showed net circulation of 40,113 copies in June 2005. Print run is a different measure: BDO Trevisan, identified as the auditor of the print run, put the 13 February 2008 issue at 74,100 copies, and the 500th issue that year was a special run of 85,000.
In 2011, among Veja, Época, IstoÉ and CartaCapital, paid circulation fell most at CartaCapital, by 9.4 percent, against 2.6 percent at IstoÉ, 2.3 percent at Época and 1.1 percent at Veja. Digital copies then moved the other way. Meio & Mensagem, citing the IVC, reported CartaCapital's average digital circulation rising from 3,324 copies in 2017 to 10,503 in 2018, and combined print-and-digital circulation rising 51 percent. Época's combined circulation rose 83 percent in the same comparison, and Veja's fell 24 percent.
CartaCapital disputed the 2021 count. It told Poder360 that changes of suppliers in October 2021 led it to declare the subscriber file "não auditável," which the IVC counts as free circulation. The magazine said the January–September 2021 averages were 7,088 printed copies, down 22.16 percent from 2020, and 8,549 digital copies, up 7.75 percent, rather than the 2,919 printed copies and 789 digital copies it said Poder360 had published.
Advertising and revenue
Advertising revenue in the first half of 2005 was 43 percent above the same period of 2004, a figure the CPDOC recorded with the first circulation audit. In 2023 a Poder360 count of the federal executive's Sicom media-planning database, adjusted for inflation, attributed R$1.1 million in official advertising to CartaCapital, more in that cut than the sums it listed for O Globo, Folha de S.Paulo or O Estado de S. Paulo. The Secretariat of Social Communication had not replied before publication; in an earlier note it said placements follow technical criteria and warned of possible distortions in Sicom, without supplying another series.
In November 2025 the Diário da Manhã reported a public appeal in which the magazine said it had no financing from banks, large business groups or foundations and depended mainly on subscriptions, smaller advertisements and contributions from readers. Without more subscribers and donations, it said, the title might not keep its editorial products.
Editorial stance
Declared principles
In a 2002 interview later carried by the Observatório da Imprensa, Mino Carta said objectivity should not be asked of a journalist, because "o homem é ele mesmo até que deposita uma vírgula em uma folha em branco," and that the proper demand was honesty: precision about what one had seen, and an effort to hear all sides. He named three principles—fidelity to factual truth, the exercise of a critical spirit, and oversight of power "onde quer que ele se manifeste."
The Fundação Getulio Vargas CPDOC entry records the refrain of the editorials, especially Carta's, as a "fidelidade canina" to factual truth and a claim of independence from holders of power. It notes that critics often ironize that formula because of the open support for Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in 2002 and 2006, and that they suggest an alignment with the Workers' Party government. Carta, the entry reports, denied a "chapa-branca" coverage and pointed to criticisms the magazine had made of that government.
The case for declaring a side is set out in the editorial of 6 September 2006, which Alberto Dines quoted. The magazine said it stated its preference "com transparência e sem hipocrisia," called such choices common in what it termed the world's best media, and described as hypocrisy an "equidistância inexistente" claimed by outlets that took no side. It cited O Estado de S. Paulo, which in 2002 had openly backed José Serra.
Electoral endorsements and government coverage
On 2 October 2002 an editorial, reproduced in a later Observatório commentary, said CartaCapital "declara sua escolha pela candidatura Lula" and saw in him a chance to change an economic policy that had led "ao desastre." After the first round, the 9 October issue said: "Escolhemos Lula há muito tempo. Carta Capital continua com ele no segundo turno." Folha de S.Paulo, reprinting that line in December 2005, noted that Lula spoke at the magazine's anniversary in 2004 and, in November 2005, called it journalism at once independent and of "caráter nítido." On 7 December 2005 he gave the magazine an exclusive interview at the Palácio do Planalto.
In 2006 the magazine again backed Lula. Dines wrote on 8 September that it was the first national title to assume an overt preference for that October. He called the step laudable and, "de certa forma, desnecessária," because support for the president, the government and above all the party had in his view been "quase irrestrita," and more visible after the mensalão revelations of May 2005. The editorial he quoted conceded that "o governo Lula ficou longe daquele que teríamos desejado," and rested the choice against Geraldo Alckmin on the election of a former metalworker. CPDOC records that the 2006 declaration drew varied reactions in the press.
On 3 July 2010 the PCdoB site Vermelho reproduced "Por que apoiamos Dilma?," in which Carta backed Dilma Rousseff as "a candidatura melhor" and as continuity of a government the magazine called victorious, "com a mesma disposição" as in 2002 and 2006. The text also listed disagreements under Lula: environmental policy, Central Bank interest rates, a social policy it thought too cautious, the removal of an Abin director, the amnesty law and the Cesare Battisti affair. A 2011 study in Estudos em Jornalismo e Mídia found that, in the 2010 pre-campaign, CartaCapital constructed Serra negatively while Veja framed Dilma negatively.
On 4 July 2014 Portal Imprensa reported an editorial opening "Escolhemos Dilma para a reeleição." It said the magazine would respect Aécio Neves and Eduardo Campos but that both were destined to represent "a pior direita," and it granted criticisms of the Workers' Party in office—alliances, communication, the global crisis and the World Cup—while arguing that Lula's social effort had not slackened. In Folha on 5 April 2014, Demétrio Magnoli, answering a piece that cast critics of those governments as heirs of 1964, called the move a classic of the "imprensa chapa-branca" and described Carta as "lulo-dilmista até o fundo da alma."
A study in Em Debate of the issues after the 2014 runoff concluded that both weeklies took a side—Veja the opposition, CartaCapital, avowedly, the incumbent—and sharpened the polarization visible in the streets; Veja, in that reading, never declared an ideological line. In issue 1190 (6 January 2022), an editorial signed by Carta with Luiz Gonzaga Belluzzo said the magazine supported Lula "incondicionalmente" and that he was then "a única esperança para afastar de vez Jair Bolsonaro e seu bolsonarismo."
Reporting and investigations
The Cardoso years and privatization
Folha de S.Paulo, in its obituary of Mino Carta, wrote that CartaCapital acquired its left-aligned reputation first through critical coverage of privatizations under President Fernando Henrique Cardoso, and later through open support for Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.
The 2001 electricity shortage was an early set piece. Observatório da Imprensa reprinted, from the 6 June 2001 issue, Bob Fernandes and Mino Carta’s “Trevas, mentiras e videoteipe,” which argued that Cardoso was not telling the truth when he said the crisis had caught him by surprise. The column quoted former senator Antônio Carlos Magalhães — “All the ministers in the area showed him the problem and said investment was needed” — and former mines and energy minister Rodolfo Tourinho, who a year earlier had privately foreseen a blackout.
A December 2002 Folha account of the privatizations, not of the magazine, drew a similar split: telecommunications “worked” but was “stained by accusations of attempts to favor private groups,” while the electricity sell-off was “disorganized” and led to the first nationwide rationing since Furnas, the South excepted.
Daniel Dantas and the financial sector
The banker the magazine pursued for a decade was Daniel Dantas, of the Opportunity group. Folha, at his July 2008 arrest, reported that Cardoso-era allies had drawn him into the Telebrás sale, that he formed the Opportunity Fund with his sister Verônica Dantas and the economist Pérsio Arida, and that the contest for Brasil Telecom ran through political access under Collor, Cardoso and Lula.
In a June 2007 profile, piauí reported his account of a meeting at which Mino Carta, he said, asked him to advertise. Opportunity placed one ad; by his count the magazine still used him on 37 covers, “always negatively.”
The Fundação Getulio Vargas CPDOC entry records that in July 2008, just after the Federal Police of Brazil arrested him in Operation Satiagraha, CartaCapital posted a dossier of more than 90 texts from the previous ten years on his role since the late-1990s telephone privatizations. Observatório da Imprensa reproduced the 18 July newsroom note listing earlier stories the magazine said other outlets were only then treating as fresh, including a 29 June 2005 report tying him to Marcos Valério and asserting that Workers' Party figures, among them José Dirceu, had defended Opportunity, plus 2006 articles, using 2004 Operation Chacal files, on dossiers against judges during the mensalão scandal.
Mino Carta’s editorial that week cast judge Fausto De Sanctis and delegate Protógenes Queiroz as having pulled the case onto “the main street.” In September Dirceu answered a later story, “Endredo dantesco,” in a post Observatório also ran, calling it infamous and denying he had weakened corruption investigations.
The damages suit that reached appeal was narrower. Dantas challenged an editorial in issue 275 (January 2004) that, he said, accused him of blackmailing the Cardoso government and of living by “maneuvers” in the Brasil Telecom fight. On 19 February 2009 the São Paulo Court of Justice unanimously upheld dismissal, treating the wording as criticism of how corporate control is sought. In May 2010 the Superior Court of Justice refused a further appeal because it may not reweigh evidence.
Satiagraha did not survive. On 7 June 2011 the Superior Court of Justice’s Fifth Panel, by 3 votes to 2, annulled the proofs over what the majority called irregular, clandestine participation by Brazilian Intelligence Agency agents in wiretaps and email tracking, and held that the taint voided the case in which De Sanctis had sentenced Dantas to ten years for corruption. On 24 June 2015 Supreme Federal Court justice Luiz Fux denied the prosecutor-general’s extraordinary appeal, RE 680.967, as “manifestly uncognizable,” so the annulment stood.
Operation Car Wash and later politics
Operation Car Wash, run from the 13th Federal Court in Curitiba, turned the magazine from the investigated toward the investigators. On 4 March 2016, the day federal police carried out a coercive conduction of Lula, CartaCapital published a legal commentary arguing that evidence-gathering must follow the statute, and quoting his description of the measure as “a show, a pyrotechnic spectacle.”
On 18 March 2016 Folha de S.Paulo reported that, in a telephone intercept from the inquiry, Lula told then minister Jaques Wagner on 14 March that he had just spoken with Mino Carta “pra ele escrever um artigo mostrando que teve duas coisas nesse movimento,” referring to the street protests of 13 March. The same day Carta published a text on the magazine’s site criticizing judge Sergio Moro and the conduct of the investigation.
The archive that reset the debate came from another newsroom. On 9 June 2019 The Intercept, in reporting by Glenn Greenwald, Leandro Demori and colleagues, began publishing private messages among Car Wash officials, which it said showed systematic misconduct. El País reported the next day that the cache showed Sergio Moro — by then justice minister under Jair Bolsonaro — messaging lead prosecutor Deltan Dallagnol during the inquiry that imprisoned Lula: suggesting the order of phases, passing informal leads and anticipating at least one decision, including in the Guarujá triplex case tied to alleged OAS bribes on Petrobras contracts.
The Supreme Federal Court did not issue a single holding “on Vaza Jato.” On 23 March 2021 the Second Panel, by 3 votes to 2, granted habeas corpus 164493, found Moro partial in the triplex case and annulled all of his decisions in it, including pre-trial acts. Justice Cármen Lúcia, who made the majority, cited the 2016 conduction, ordered without a prior summons, and wiretaps of Lula’s lawyers; the court noted that her vote did not use the published chats, which dissenting justice Nunes Marques called illegally obtained. On 23 June 2021 the full bench kept the result, 7 to 4; dissenters, including Chief Justice Luiz Fux, said the panel should not have ruled after Edson Fachin had declared Curitiba incompetent, and that the bias finding used hacked recordings. The BBC reported that the rulings restored Lula’s political rights for 2022 unless a new second-instance conviction came first, with the cases restarted in Brasília.
CPDOC had already recorded support for Lula in 2002 and 2006, and the charge from critics that coverage was government-aligned, against Mino Carta’s reply that the magazine had also criticized his administration. The 2019 messages and the 2021 annulments came from The Intercept and the Supreme Federal Court, not from a CartaCapital investigation.
Staff, contributors and related publications
Newsroom leadership
CartaCapital was founded in São Paulo in 1994 by Mino Carta, Bob Fernandes, Nelson Letaif and Wagner Carelli, journalists who had worked together at IstoÉ. Mino Carta remained diretor de redação until his death on 2 September 2025, at 91, at Hospital Sírio-Libanês. Fernandes was redator-chefe when he left at the end of 2004; Maurício Stycer, hired by Fernandes in April 2001 to edit culture, held the post through 2005 and 2006.
In 2005 the magazine passed to Editora Confiança, with Manuela Carta, Mino’s daughter, as publisher and the economist Luiz Gonzaga Belluzzo as editorial consultant. Sergio Lirio was redator-chefe by December 2012. Nirlando Beirão, whom G1 and Folha de S.Paulo identified as a redator-chefe, died on 30 April 2020. By December 2019 Lirio was again identified as editor-in-chief.
The masthead updated on 29 October 2025 lists Mino as founder (1933–2025), Lirio as redator-chefe, Bruna Monteiro de Barros as editora-executiva, Belluzzo as editorial consultant and Ana Paula Sousa and Carlos Drummond as editors, with Rodrigo Martins as content director of the site and Manuela Carta as publisher of Editora Basset Ltda., named there as the weekly’s publisher, at Rua da Consolação, 881.
Columnists and regular contributors
The physician and footballer Sócrates wrote for the magazine for more than ten years. In December 2012 Editora Confiança published Sócrates, Brasileiro, 216 pages with 87 of those pieces and an interview, prefaced by Juca Kfouri.
Antônio Delfim Netto, a former minister and federal deputy, appeared with Belluzzo at the May 2009 seminar on Brazil and the global crisis. The oncologist Drauzio Varella, author of Estação Carandiru, still writes on health; columns through October 2026 covered passive smoking, polio and isolation.
Djamila Ribeiro began in 2014 on the collective blog Escritório Feminista and had her own column from 2015. In March 2017 she and Guilherme Boulos, then a coordinator of the Movimento dos Trabalhadores Sem Teto, were announced as alternating a fortnightly print column in the section Seu País. In 2018 Portal Imprensa reported that she won its prize for best newspaper or magazine columnist for the CartaCapital work, and that Quem tem medo do feminismo negro? gathered articles from the magazine and elsewhere.
Carta na Escola, partnerships and events
Also in 2005, Editora Confiança launched Carta na Escola, a monthly for secondary education. Manuela Carta said the house had offered the government a classroom title early that year and, rather than wait, put it on newsstands in September; by June 2006 it was on its sixth issue and carrying ads. That month the Fundo Nacional de Desenvolvimento da Educação hired Veja, Época, IstoÉ and CartaCapital, at R$500,000 each and without a tender, to send editions of 32,300 copies to more than 16,000 high schools. Lawyers called the no-bid deal legally fragile; an FNDE director answered that every weekly had been invited, while Manuela said the publisher had not expected to share a project it proposed alone or to accept the contract’s advertising limits.
FNDE lists for the PNBE Periódicos program include Carta na Escola, ten editions a year, among titles bought in 2013 and 2014 for schools with the last years of fundamental education and high school, and a sister title, Carta Fundamental, for younger pupils.
A content deal with The Economist began with a combined year-end issue in 2008. In the editorial, Mino Carta called it an unprecedented partnership and put the British weekly’s world circulation at about one million, a little over 200,000 of them in the United Kingdom. The arrangement was consolidated in 2009, with selected articles each week and nine special supplements. In May 2009, for the fifteenth anniversary, the magazine held the seminar “O Brasil e a crise econômica mundial,” with Nouriel Roubini, Aluísio Mercadante, Belluzzo and Delfim Netto.
On 14 August 2024, President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s schedule included the magazine’s Diálogos Capitais series at the Confederação Nacional da Indústria in Brasília.
Awards and recognition
Honors for CartaCapital and its journalists include association recognitions, juried reporting prizes and online polls. Many name editor Mino Carta. The Associação Brasileira de Comunicação Empresarial (Aberje) states that the magazine was Mídia do Ano in the magazine category of the Prêmio Aberje in 1998, 2001, 2003 and 2004. In 1998 the Faculdade Cásper Líbero gave Carta a doctorate honoris causa.
In 2006 the Associação dos Correspondentes da Imprensa Estrangeira no Brasil (ACIE) gave him the Prêmio Imprensa Estrangeira, created in 1989 for the Brazilian journalist who had most stood out in the year and, from 2004, again given to working journalists. An Observatório da Imprensa article includes Carta among them. The Núcleo Piratininga de Comunicação reported the ceremony, as Jornalista do Ano, on a Thursday the 7th at the Caesar Park hotel in Rio de Janeiro. Carta said he was “honrado e consolado” while the magazine was “atingida por flechas” over its editorial line during the political crisis and the presidential campaign. Later profiles call it the prize for the “Jornalista Brasileiro de Maior Destaque no Ano.”
A juried prize for a reported story is the 30th Vladimir Herzog Award. On 27 October 2008, at the TUCA theatre of the Pontifical Catholic University of São Paulo, “Um torturador à solta,” by Gilberto Nascimento and Rodrigo Martins, won the magazine category; the jurors were Paulo Cannabrava, Ivan Seixas and Ary Normanha. Reprinted by the Observatório da Imprensa, the magazine’s account said the cover of issue 501 followed a civil action over torture at São Paulo’s DOI-Codi in 1970–76, under the Brazilian military dictatorship, and found delegate Dirceu Gravina still working in Presidente Prudente.
The Troféu Dia da Imprensa, run by the magazine and portal IMPRENSA, was a reader poll, not a jury. For Press Day on 1 June 2006, with one vote a day per computer, CartaCapital was second among weekly news magazines: 31 percent (173 votes) behind Veja’s 35 percent (195), with IstoÉ at 28 percent and Época at 5 percent (557 votes). In 2007, after an electoral-college shortlist, nearly 20,000 open votes gave CartaCapital 75.01 percent, ahead of Veja (18.69 percent), Época (3.79 percent) and IstoÉ (2.51 percent).
The Prêmio Comunique-se was also a journalists’ vote on that portal, for a period of work rather than one piece. In September 2005 Carta wrote that he had won Executivo de Veículo de Comunicação in 2003 and again that year, citing 82,000 users. Consultor Jurídico lists him there for 2007 as well. Caras reported that, at the fifth edition at Tom Brasil in São Paulo, Ana Paula Souza of CartaCapital won print culture journalist (spelled Ana Paula Sousa by Consultor Jurídico).
On 6 June 2025 the sixth Troféu Audálio Dantas — Indignação, Coragem e Esperança was set for Carta, Caco Barcellos and the Profissão Repórter team, at the São Paulo city council. The Instituto Vladimir Herzog described it as a career honor chosen by a curatorial council of the Dantas family, journalism unions and writers.
Controversies and legal disputes
Odebrecht payments
Plea-bargain testimony in Operation Car Wash described payments by the construction group Odebrecht to Editora Confiança, publisher of CartaCapital. In the 2016 agreement of executive Paulo Cesena, reported by O Globo, Cesena said Marcelo Odebrecht told him in 2007 that the company would support the magazine, then short of cash, because finance minister Guido Mantega had asked. Cesena said he took the transfer as a request from the federal government and the Workers' Party. He described a R$3 million loan through Odebrecht's structured-operations sector and a further R$500,000 in 2009, and said about R$3 million had been offset by sponsorship of the publisher's events from 2010 to 2012.
In April 2017 Folha de S.Paulo reported testimony by Emílio Odebrecht and Marcelo Odebrecht that the group provided R$3 million through the sector that handled bribes and off-books cash, repaid with advertising space. They said it was not a formal loan: Emílio said Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva asked him to help the magazine, while Marcelo said Mantega asked him. Supreme Federal Court justice Edson Fachin summarized the collaborators in those terms and sent the file to federal prosecutors in São Paulo to check for illegality, Veja reported. Mantega's lawyer, José Roberto Batochio, told Folha the accounts conflicted on who had asked and that both men had always denied the request; the Instituto Lula said the former president would not comment.
The publisher told Folha that between 2007 and 2009 Odebrecht advanced R$3.5 million for advertising, a normal market operation negotiated directly by Mino Carta and Luiz Gonzaga Belluzzo, with no intermediary, and repaid with advertisements and event sponsorships. The note said the magazine did not know the origin of the money and that it was bad faith to treat its advance as bribery-department cash while treating similar spending on other outlets as lawful. To O Globo, administrative director Manuela Carta said the contract was an advertising advance, already settled, including sponsorship of Diálogos Capitais and Fórum Brasil. She and Belluzzo denied any role for Mantega; Belluzzo said the house had sought Marcelo Odebrecht, carried a loan on its balance sheet, and later paid with advertising pages.
Marcelo Odebrecht described similar credits, later converted into advertising, for other Brazilian newspapers. In testimony reported by Folha on 20 April 2017 he named Correio Braziliense, Estado de Minas, A Tarde, papers in Bahia and, earlier, Jornal do Brasil, and said the Correio deal had not followed a request from Lula. For CartaCapital, which he called strongly pro-PT and loss-making, he said support began as an off-books fund that looked like a minority investment and was later swapped for an advertising credit. The published record is those plea statements, the publisher's denial of political intermediation, and Fachin's referral; the reports do not record a charge or a judgment finding a crime by the magazine or its owners.
Court cases
Banker Daniel Dantas sued over the editorial in edition 275, January 2004, which he said falsely accused him of blackmailing the government of Fernando Henrique Cardoso and of living by "maneuvers." The magazine answered that the text was opinion on that economic model and on the public contest for Brasil Telecom. The 5th Civil Court of the São Paulo capital dismissed the claim. On 19 February 2009 the São Paulo Court of Justice unanimously affirmed: rapporteur Teixeira Leite held that the language was criticism of a matter of public interest and that neither "chantagem" nor "manobras" was defamatory. In May 2010 Superior Court of Justice justice Massami Uyeda denied Dantas's special appeal because that court may not reexamine evidence.
Mino Carta and Editora Confiança also sued Diogo Mainardi and Editora Abril over columns in Veja of 7 December 2005 and 10 May 2006. The columns said Carta answered to Carlos Jereissati, with a brief to attack Dantas and to defend a Lula-aligned circle around Luiz Gushiken, and compared the magazine to defendants in the mensalão scandal, citing an issue Mainardi said was nearly 70 percent filled with federal advertising. In a decision reported on 14 November 2006, judge Camila de Jesus Gonçalves Pacífico ordered Mainardi and Abril to pay Mino Carta R$35,000 and rejected the publisher's own claim. In a 2013 ruling the Court of Justice reversed that award. Rapporteur Flavio Abramovici held that the columns, though extreme, were not malicious, that "mensaleiro" was a figure of speech, and that a magazine which called the rest of the press anti-Lula could not claim injury at being called pro-Lula.
Notes of repudiation
Issue 1081, the printed edition dated 20 November 2019, carried an article titled "Mulheres que envergonham as mulheres." That month the National Secretariat for Policies for Women, in a note on the website of the Ministry of Women, Family and Human Rights signed by secretary Cristiane Britto, repudiated the piece as disrespectful, depreciatory and sexually suggestive, and as a public attack on 14 women in prominent posts. The note quoted lines on a woman's appearance—"55 anos com corpinho de 65" and "passou a trajar de modo espantoso"—said the text reduced the women's positions to a supposed sexual need, called that political violence, and asked authorities to investigate.
On 19 November 2019 the Association of Federal Judges of Brazil (Ajufe) repudiated personal comments about women judges and other women in power. Ajufe said sexist references to appearance, marital status and sexuality were being used to discredit judicial decisions rather than their content. On 21 November the Women's Secretariat of the Chamber of Deputies issued a parallel note and said it would take the steps the case required.
Reception and place in the Brazilian press
Influence and critics
Political scientist Fernando Antônio Azevedo placed CartaCapital, with Veja, Época and IstoÉ, among the weekly news magazines that formed the national mass media in Brazil, alongside the main newspapers in Brazil and the open television networks. The list did not mean a common line. On the 2002 presidential election he found the weeklies split: Veja backed the candidate of the Brazilian Social Democracy Party, CartaCapital the candidate of the Workers' Party, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, and Época and IstoÉ stayed neutral.
The CPDOC dictionary of the Fundação Getulio Vargas records the criticism that followed open endorsements of Lula in 2002 and 2006. Critics mocked the editorial claim of a “canine fidelity to factual truth” and of independence from power, and read the magazine as aligned with the PT government; Mino Carta denied “chapa-branca” coverage and cited criticisms it had made of the administration. In the Observatório da Imprensa, Alberto Dines called the September 2006 endorsement laudable but “in a certain sense unnecessary”: the magazine, he wrote, had already supported “almost without restriction” the president, his government and above all his party, a position clearer after the mensalão revelations of May 2005. The editorial he quoted answered that such choices were ordinary “in the best media in the world,” and accused rivals of claiming an equidistance they did not practice, pointing to O Estado de S. Paulo’s support for José Serra in 2002.
Poder360 later described CartaCapital as prestigious with readers socially liberal and left-wing on politics: it “never had a large circulation” — an average of 18,647 copies in 2015 — “but always enjoyed a great deal of influence.” Audited peaks were still far below the mass weeklies. The first IVC report after affiliation, for June 2005, gave a net circulation of 40,113, and a BDO Trevisan figure cited on 13 February 2008 was 74,100 copies; Veja, of Editora Abril, had long printed more than a million copies a week.
Digital audience and the print decline
Audited digital copies widened that gap before the weeklies contracted together. Meio & Mensagem, citing 2018 IVC averages, reported that CartaCapital’s digital circulation rose from 3,324 copies in 2017 to 10,503, and that combined print-and-digital circulation rose 51 percent. Veja’s digital average was 366,180, up 2.9 percent, and its overall average remained 915,095 despite a 24 percent fall; Época’s digital average of 253,189 reflected its insertion for subscribers of O Globo and Valor Econômico, and its combined circulation rose 83 percent.
In 2021 the fall was shared. From IVC data on seven titles — Veja, Quatro Rodas, Época, Exame, Vogue, piauí and CartaCapital — Poder360 reported drops of 28 percent in print, 21 percent in digital editions and 25 percent combined. The steepest print losses were CartaCapital (down 76 percent, or 5,804 copies, to 2,130 a week), Exame (down 44 percent) and Veja (down 36 percent, to 92,850 paper copies); the sharpest digital drops were CartaCapital (91 percent), Quatro Rodas (23 percent) and Veja (22 percent). On the combined count the worst results were again CartaCapital (minus 83 percent), Veja (minus 29 percent) and Exame (minus 21 percent). Época, of Grupo Globo, ended as a separate magazine in May 2021 and became a section of O Globo; IstoÉ was outside the audit, so its print run was unknown.
CartaCapital contested those 2021 figures. It told Poder360 that changes of suppliers had made the IVC’s rules for paying subscribers impractical, so the list was reported as “non-auditable,” which the institute counts as free circulation. The publisher said January-to-September averages were 7,088 print copies, down 22.16 percent from 2020, and 8,549 digital copies, up 7.75 percent, rather than the 2,919 print and 789 digital copies it said had been published. Its 2026 media kit, a sales document rather than an IVC audit, claims 66,000 copies a month in print and digital, about 4.02 million unique monthly visitors, daily newsletters to more than 100,000 readers, and 600,000 YouTube subscribers.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Related people
Related organizations
Linked pages by kind
Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.
- People2
- Organizations10