
Parliamentwatch
Parliamentwatch, known in Germany by its German name Abgeordnetenwatch, is an independent website that republishes legislators’ voting records…
Expert article
Logo of Abgeordnetenwatch, the German parliamentary transparency platform.
Parliamentwatch, known in Germany by its German name Abgeordnetenwatch, is an independent website that republishes legislators’ voting records and committee posts and lets users put questions to them in public. It began in 2004 as a volunteer project limited to the parliament of the city-state of Hamburg. Gregor Hackmack and Boris Hekele put the site online on 8 December 2004, for that year’s election to the Hamburgische Bürgerschaft. By 2011 the founders, described in the press as two young entrepreneurs, were employing full-time staff, and the project said it was paid for by donations and regular supporting contributions, with a board of trustees meant to watch over its claim to be non-partisan.
The operating body is the charitable association Parlamentwatch e.V., founded in 2007 and recognized as tax-privileged by the Hamburg-Nord tax office, with its registered office at Nernstweg 32–34 in Hamburg. The same transparency report names Hackmack and Hekele as the unpaid board members and Léa Briand-Gau and Annika Heintz-Saad as managing directors. Questions can be addressed to members of the Bundestag, to members of state parliaments, and to German members of the European Parliament. A moderation code is applied before questions and answers are published. The association’s 2025 transparency note, issued before the annual audit, said more than 23,000 questions were published that year and that the recorded answer rate was 73 percent.
Figures on outside earnings come from disclosures members file with parliament, which newsrooms then tally with the platform. Tagesschau reported in October 2024 that an evaluation by Der Spiegel and Abgeordnetenwatch found 337 of the then 733 Bundestag members had declared at least one payment connected with an outside activity, a company holding, a donation or a covered trip in that legislative term. The share was 63 percent in the CDU/CSU parliamentary group and 59 percent in the FDP, and 22 percent in the AfD. Basic pay was then 11,227.20 euro a month, plus a tax-free expense allowance of 5,051.54 euro, and sums above 1,000 euro a month or 3,000 euro a year had to be reported to the cent. An earlier study with the Otto Brenner Stiftung, made when members reported income in ten bands rather than exact amounts, estimated that 178 of 630 members were above the threshold and put the associated receipts between 26.5 and 48.7 million euro. CDU member Josef Rief, a farmer, told Deutsche Welle that the listing used turnover rather than profit and called it arbitrary.
The group has also sued for records on lobbying under freedom of information law. In 2014 it asked the Bundestag parliamentary groups for the names of lobbyists they had accredited to enter parliamentary buildings. The Greens and the Left published their lists; the CDU and the SPD refused, citing data protection. A Berlin court ruled for the organization in June 2015, after which the Bundestag administration appealed. The SPD then released its accreditations for 2014 and 2015, a list that included Lufthansa, Deutsche Telekom, RWE, EnBW, Rheinmetall and ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems, while still backing the appeal. The association’s 2025 accounts, still awaiting audit, listed 13,303 regular supporters, about 1.74 million euro in donations and other gifts, and 34 permanent employees, equal to 23 full-time posts.
History
Origins in the Hamburg electoral reform
On 13 June 2004, the same day as the European election, voters in Hamburg chose a new electoral law for the Bürgerschaft. The bill of the citizens’ initiative “Mehr Bürgerrechte – Ein neues Wahlrecht für Hamburg” received 256,507 yes votes, 66.5 percent of valid votes, on a turnout of 34 percent, and cleared a quorum of 20 percent of those entitled to vote at the previous Bürgerschaft election. The Bürgerschaft’s own bill did not. The statute that passed used open lists in 17 multi-member constituencies, ten votes per voter—five for constituency candidates and five for state-list candidates—cumulation and vote-splitting, and Sainte-Laguë allocation, with 71 of 121 seats filled in the constituencies and 50 from state lists. Wahlrecht.de called it, relative to other German states, the system that gave voters the greatest say over which individuals sat in parliament.
Gregor Hackmack later traced the website to that campaign. After degrees in international relations and political sociology at the London School of Economics, he had joined Mehr Demokratie in Hamburg; voters, he recalled, welcomed a personal ballot and then said they did not know the candidates. He met Boris Hekele during a 2004 strike at the University of Hamburg against higher fees. Hekele had built a web tool that helped turn out about 5,000 protesters, and Hackmack compared the politician site that followed to a job interview for the people voters were about to hire. They started in September 2004, still freelancing and paying about four euros a month for a server, and put abgeordnetenwatch.de online on 8 December 2004 for the Bürgerschaft. Questions and replies were published, so an answer was a public record rather than a private letter.
On 11 October 2006, 62 of the 63 Christian Democratic Union members voted through amendments, in force from 28 October, which Wahlrecht.de judged to have abolished the personalized system in practice: a 30 percent relevance threshold left changes of list order almost without effect on who was elected. Hackmack later said the CDU had cancelled a referendum that both it and the Social Democratic Party had opposed. While the original law was still on the books, the 2005 Grimme Online Award shortlist included the site as “Demokratie per Internet,” with Mehr Demokratie Hamburg named as provider and the concept credited to Hackmack, Jan Hildebrandt and Hekele. The nomination text called it Hamburg’s virtual voter memory: voting records, and public questions to members.
Expansion beyond Hamburg
The 2005 federal campaign was the first step outside the city-state. A companion site, kandidatenwatch.de, profiled 2,061 constituency candidates for the Bundestag; by December 2006 Spiegel Online counted 12,500 questions and more than 8,000 answers since the Hamburg launch. On 8 December 2006 the service opened for sitting Bundestag members, with Spiegel Online as the first national media partner. Profiles listed occupation, party, themes and recorded votes, including on the Bundeswehr deployment in Congo, the value-added-tax rise and the anti-discrimination law. About ten moderators screened out insults and private questions; Hackmack said the point was not a “glass deputy” but a public account of political work. German members of the European Parliament were added on 5 September 2007, when netzpolitik.org reported that the then 99 German MEPs could be questioned in the same way.
Standing coverage of every state parliament lagged those election portals: in 2012 Hackmack told Spiegel the platform was still being extended to all 16 states and to local councils, from a Hamburg office where staff and volunteers already worked side by side, with partnerships that included Spiegel Online, the Süddeutsche Zeitung and the broadcaster NDR.
From a volunteer site to a standing organization
Hackmack described the first years as unpaid. A few days a month of freelance work, at day rates of about 240 to 400 euros, left the rest of the month for the site. By the Bundestag launch that arrangement had already been overtaken: Spiegel reported that money came mainly from BonVenture, a foundation for social responsibility, plus advertising users could click away, and that the moderation team was already at work.
In 2007 the founders decided to operate as social entrepreneurs and borrowed 310,000 euros from BonVenture; by Hackmack’s 2014 interview, all but 130,000 euros had been repaid. A statute dated 18 June 2007 constituted Parlamentwatch as an association to be registered in Hamburg. It limits the body to charitable purposes, names promotion of the democratic polity as its object, requires party-political neutrality, and lists the internet as a means of information and participation at federal, state and local level. In 2008 Ashoka named Hackmack a fellow for the project. The association’s 2025 transparency note, published before the annual audit, named the two founders as the unpaid board, counted 34 permanent employees and 13,303 regular supporters, and described Parlamentwatch e.V. as the body that carries the site.
Organization
Legal form and governance
Parlamentwatch e.V. is the charitable registered association that operates abgeordnetenwatch.de. It gives 2007 as its founding year. A statute signed in Hamburg on 18 June 2007 already provided for register entry and for exclusively charitable purposes under the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung). The association is entered at the Amtsgericht Hamburg as VR 19479, and since 15 March 2025 its address has been Nernstweg 32–34, 22765 Hamburg. The statutes, last amended on 13 November 2020, name promotion of the democratic polity, civic education abroad, international understanding and development cooperation, require party-political neutrality, and confine spending to statutory purposes. The association states that the Finanzamt Hamburg-Nord recognizes it as charitable under tax number 17/450/06236. The Bundestag lobby register lists it as R000199, first entered on 27 January 2022, as a private-law body with charitable status, and records a capital office at Reichenberger Straße 156b, 10999 Berlin, together with the association’s statement that it keeps offices in both cities.
The board admits ordinary and supporting members; only ordinary members vote. The assembly meets at least yearly, elects a board of two or three for two years, approves the accounts and budget, and amends the statutes by a two-thirds majority of votes present. Two board members must act together. The board may be paid and may appoint managing directors for current business, accountable to the board and the assembly. A Kuratorium, named by the board for four years, shares responsibility for the moderation code; ten honorary members were listed for 2024. Dissolution needs three-quarters of the members, after which the assets go to Mehr Demokratie e.V. The lobby register showed nine members, all natural persons, as of 5 June 2025. Since 19 December 2012 the association has signed the Initiative Transparente Zivilgesellschaft.
A separate company long ran the technical side. In March 2014 Gregor Hackmack described the project as a charitable association with an attached company for commercial business. Parlamentwatch GmbH, founded in 2006 and entered at the Amtsgericht Hamburg as HRB 98928 (Mittelweg 12), was not itself charitable. The founders owned it equally and managed it, supplying programming, administration and servers as an auxiliary (Hilfsperson) under section 57 of the Fiscal Code until the summer of 2023—the association dates the contract to 30 June, the company to 31 July. Liquidation was published on 1 July 2023, a closing balance was set as of 30 September 2024, and the association reports deletion from the register on 7 April 2025, after which server costs lay with the association.
Leadership and staff
The authorized board members are the founders Boris Hekele and Gregor Hackmack, both unpaid since 2023; Hackmack’s board role has been unpaid since 2014. Hackmack, born in 1977, studied international relations and political sociology at the London School of Economics, became an Ashoka fellow in 2008, led Change.org in Germany until 2022, and then joined the managing board of innn.it. Hekele, born in 1978, studied philosophy and media informatics.
Léa Briand-Gau, born in 1989, joined in 2018 to lead communications and has been a managing director since 2023, covering content, strategy and personnel. Annika Heintz-Saad, born in 1988, became the second managing director in September 2024, focused on technology and quantitative work, after campaigns at innn.it and Change.org in Germany. Both are named in the imprint and the lobby register. Martin Reyher, head of research, is the person responsible under section 18 of the state media treaty.
In 2024 the project had 32 permanent employees (23 full-time equivalents), four interns, 12 freelancers and 15 volunteers. For 2025 it reported 34 permanent employees, still 23 full-time equivalents, six freelancers and 12 volunteers, working from the Hamburg and Berlin offices.
Funding and independence
Donations and published accounts
Parlamentwatch e.V., founded in Hamburg in 2007, carries abgeordnetenwatch.de. The Hamburg-Nord tax office treats it as tax-privileged for promoting the democratic state, and the Bundestag lobby register lists it as a charitable private-law organization under the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung). Since 19 December 2012 it has signed the Initiative Transparente Zivilgesellschaft, a disclosure standard of Transparency International Deutschland. It publishes annual reports from 2007 and has submitted its cash-basis accounts to a voluntary independent audit.
The accounts show a shift toward many small gifts. For 2015 the association reported €404,784 in donations and regular contributions, €26,500 from foundations and €10,420 from cooperation grants, €441,704 in all, against expenditure of €408,258, and said no payer exceeded 10 percent of the budget. From 2013 to 2016 OLIN gGmbH, which describes the grant as support for public information about politicians, gave €85,000 to build fundraising.
For 2024 it reported €1,096,640 in regular contributions, €415,980 in other donations and €20,390 in other income (€1,533,010), against expenditure of €1,508,170. It counted 12,508 regular supporters and again no payment above 10 percent of the budget. Preliminary 2025 figures, before audit, were income of €1,775,490, including €1,191,180 in regular contributions, against expenditure of €1,861,340, with 13,303 regular supporters. The 2024 lobby-register entry calls the association donation-financed and records €20,001 to €30,000 spent on interest representation.
Paid profiles and the operating company
In 2006 Gregor Hackmack and Boris Hekele formed Parlamentwatch GmbH as the technical operator. A September 2009 note described supporter circles, hideable advertising and a one-off candidate contribution of €100 in state elections and €200 for the Bundestag. The fee bought a photograph, a self-description, campaign dates and a homepage link; a basic entry was free. Extensions were €67,028 of the GmbH’s €131,509 revenue in 2009, with advertising at €26,458; in 2010 those lines were €13,970 and €11,135 of €86,718.
In August 2009 Sebastian Edathy of the Social Democratic Party, then chair of the Bundestag interior committee, refused the €200 fee. He warned of a commercialization of the service and wrote that if the charge stayed, he was out. The operators described the fee as one strand of mixed funding and said the question service itself was free.
In 2010 the site documented paid speeches and missed votes by former finance minister Peer Steinbrück, research Der Spiegel reported separately. On the ARD programme Beckmann on 20 September, in the organization’s account, he called the project a “commercial bunch” (“kommerzieller Haufen”). It replied that it was a charitable association financed largely by gifts, then from 821 monthly supporters. A 2025 taz column said such charges had recurred, sometimes from parliamentarians the site had contrasted for outside earnings and attendance.
The GmbH was not itself charitable. Its articles required the whole annual result to be donated; the 2009 note assigned 70 percent to the association, 5 percent each to Mehr Demokratie and Mehr Bürgerrechte, and 20 percent to BonVenture gGmbH. BonVenture had pre-financed the company and held about 15 percent, the founders about 42.5 percent each. The loan was repaid in 2015 and the shares bought back in 2016, leaving Hackmack and Hekele with 50 percent each. The company billed the association as an auxiliary (Hilfsperson) under section 57 of the Fiscal Code.
Extension income was €16,235 in 2016 and €7,765 in 2017, when extensions were still offered for two state elections, and zero in 2018, as was advertising. In 2019 the taz reported that a fuller profile had cost €150 and that, since 2017, candidate services were donation-funded. The association says paid services ended in 2018, so the managers liquidated the GmbH, with publication on 1 July 2023. The liquidation balance was dated 30 September 2024, and the company was deleted from the Hamburg commercial register on 7 April 2025. Its only reported income in 2023 was €43,200 from the association; server costs then passed to the association.
The platform and its methods
Public questions and moderation
Parliamentwatch keeps a profile for every member of the Bundestag, for members of the parliaments of the sixteen Länder, and for the German members of the European Parliament, plus directly electable candidates. Ministers without a seat are not listed. In Hamburg, senators may not sit in the Bürgerschaft at all. Members and candidates cannot delete their profiles; former members stay archived, with the question form off.
Questions are entered on the profile. The asker must give a full name and a valid email address. Since 2021 the published surname has been cut to its initial, while the politician sees the full name in the login used for replies. The question is capped at 200 characters, with an optional 1,000 for a justification or sources, and it has to be a question or a request for a position, not a bare opinion.
Moderators read every question and answer first. The codex, last revised on 2 June 2022, withholds advocacy of tyranny, racism, sexism, or persecution, group discrimination, insults, questions on private life or professional secrecy, unsourced claims, mass mailings, too many questions from one person, and, as a rule, more than one follow-up. It also blocks questions from parliamentary or party staff, self-addressed questions, questions between candidates at the same election or members of the same parliament, and false names. Moderators and Kuratorium members may not ask questions themselves. Repeated abuse can mean exclusion after the board is consulted.
A blocked question is still forwarded, unless anonymous, and both sides are told why. Either side may seek a review or go to the Kuratorium, and a politician may ask that a rejected question be published. Cleared questions usually go out by email within a few hours. Answering is voluntary. Replies that only refuse the site, or plead lack of capacity, are marked as standard answers and excluded from the response statistics, which count a substantive public reply, not its quality, and ignore anything never released.
Voting records, outside income and profiles
Profiles show year of birth, list place, committee memberships, behavior in important named votes, and earlier candidacies the organization has on file. Politicians may edit biographical text and photographs themselves. After election, or where someone already held a seat, committees and the named-vote record are added. A structured outside-income section is added only for Bundestag members.
The tables follow the chamber's own procedure. A named vote (namentliche Abstimmung) must be demanded before the sitting begins, by a parliamentary group or by five percent of the members present. Secretaries collect cards marked with the member's name and with "yes," "no," or "abstention." Named votes are barred for specified procedural questions, such as referral to a committee or adjournment.
A Bundestag voting card for a named vote, shown in the parliament's explanation of how the cards are scanned and counted.
The administration publishes the name lists as PDFs and spreadsheets, with the result also in the plenary minutes; its open data include those lists, machine-readable protocols, and biographies. Parliamentwatch copies the individual votes onto the profile. Most decisions are not taken by name, so a blank is not proof that a member missed the sitting. Where older lists exist, profiles also carry named votes from the Bundestag and from state parliaments.
Outside income for Bundestag members is what they file with the President of the Bundestag and what section 47 of the Members of the Bundestag Act orders the parliament to publish. It covers the last job before the mandate, paid outside work, company and association posts, shareholdings above five percent, and agreements about future benefits. Sums above €1,000 a month or €3,000 a year are published to the euro and cent; turnover is entered as profit before tax, and professional secrecy can replace a client's name with a sector, or with nothing if that would identify them. The rules have been in the Act since 19 October 2021. Parliamentwatch places those published notifications on the profile. While outside income was still issued in steps, Der Spiegel reported in 2010 that the platform had turned lecture fees declared by Peer Steinbrück into minimum totals, because each step gave only a floor.
Election coverage
Before Bundestag and state elections the site also runs a candidate check aimed at the first, constituency vote. The Federal Agency for Civic Education's Wahl-O-Mat compares users with parties instead. A February 2025 Deutsche Presse-Agentur account, published by the Süddeutsche Zeitung, described the Abgeordnetenwatch check as that tool's counterpart for the constituency vote: theses, a postcode, and the local candidates, on pages that also carry questions and, where older data exist, votes. The answers are what candidates chose to file. They do not bind later votes, they omit anyone who refused, and they do not fill the holes in a record limited to named votes.
Investigations and court cases
Lobby access and official records
Interest representatives could obtain a permanent pass to the Bundestag through a public register of associations or, less visibly, with the countersignature of a parliamentary group's managing director. In 2014 Parlamentwatch e.V., the association behind Abgeordnetenwatch, asked under the Informationsfreiheitsgesetz for the number of passes issued that second way and the names of the organizations that received them. The administration refused, calling this parliamentary business outside the Act. On 18 June 2015 the Berlin Administrative Court (VG 2 K 176.14) held that issuing a pass is an exercise of the Bundestag President's control of the buildings and is therefore covered by the Act. It ordered the numbers and the organizations disclosed: the request did not seek personal data, and any inference to named members or lobbyists was too uncertain to justify refusal. The Bundestag appealed at the end of October 2015.
Der Spiegel reported that month that Abgeordnetenwatch had published 607 companies and associations then known to hold passes. Die Linke, Alliance 90/The Greens and the SPD had named the groups they sponsored; the CDU and CSU had not. Administration figures cited by the site put faction-sponsored passes at about 1,000 over the two preceding years. Der Tagesspiegel asked which organizations had received passes that term on a faction's recommendation, how many, and which faction sponsored each. On 20 November 2015 the Higher Administrative Court of Berlin-Brandenburg (OVG 6 S 45.15) upheld an unappealable interim order to answer. It did not require any account of whom the holders met.
From 2015 Abgeordnetenwatch asked whether non-private dinners in the Federal Chancellery with guests holding no political office had recurred since Angela Merkel took office in November 2005, after a 2008 dinner there for Deutsche Bank chief executive Josef Ackermann. The Chancellery refused, citing the core of executive responsibility, guests' rights and security. On 23 June 2017 the Berlin Administrative Court (VG 27 L 295.17) ordered, interim, the dates and social occasion of such dinners. It treated the site as a journalistic telemedium and held that finished events lay outside inner executive decision-making. On 8 September 2017 the higher court quashed that order (OVG 11 S 49.17). It doubted that a website could use the Interstate Broadcasting Treaty against a federal authority, and said interim relief would decide the case without a clear enough prospect of success. Merkel did not have to answer before the 2017 election. The interim order having been quashed, the dinner record was not released before the vote.
In August 2022 the association asked the Federal Ministry of Finance, under the Environmental Information Act, for text messages between Finance Minister Christian Lindner and Porsche chief executive Oliver Blume on a planned European Union ban on new combustion-engine cars and an e-fuels exception. The ministry said the messages were not material to a decision, were not environmental information, and partly concerned Lindner only as chair of the Free Democratic Party. On 27 March 2025 the Berlin Administrative Court (VG 2 K 60/23) ordered access. The messages related to the Council's June 2022 "Fit for 55" decision and Regulation (EU) 2023/851, and the ministry held them on the minister's official phone. Public interest in a possible close tie between government and the car industry outweighed data-protection interests. Leave to appeal remained open. In May 2025 the ministry sent twelve messages from June and July 2022. ZDF, which also obtained them, reported that on 28 June Lindner asked Blume for "argumentative support" on e-fuels and Blume answered, "volle Unterstützung von Porsche Seite." Porsche had called an earlier claim of influence on the coalition agreement exaggerated; the FDP said Lindner's e-fuel position was long-standing.
Outside income, donations and conflicts of interest
Der Spiegel and Abgeordnetenwatch have jointly compiled outside earnings members must report to the Bundestag President. Tagesschau, on their count of 19 October 2024, reported that 337 of the then 733 members had declared at least one payment from an outside activity or office, a company holding, a donation or a reimbursed trip. The share was 63 percent in the CDU/CSU group, 59 percent in the FDP, 43 percent in the SPD, 40 percent in the Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht group, 36 percent in the Left group, 32 percent among the Greens and 22 percent in the Alternative for Germany. The work is lawful if the mandate stays "the centre of the activity"; above €1,000 a month or €3,000 a year it must be reported to the cent. The Berliner Morgenpost, using the same figures, put the declared total since the 2021 election at €51 million, and noted that the largest sums are often business turnover rather than personal profit.
Spiegel and Abgeordnetenwatch reported in April 2023 that Deutsche Vermögensberatung gave the CDU €100,000 on 14 March, which the company said was handed to party chair Friedrich Merz when he met DVAG lobbyist Helge Lach. The party told the administration the gift was a cheque, not cash. Weeks earlier Merz, then CDU/CSU group leader, had questioned a possible EU ban on commission-based investment advice. Both denied a connection. In December 2024 tagesschau and the ARD capital studio counted donations above €35,000, which must be notified at once. In the month after the coalition fell on 6 November, the CDU received €1,952,000, the FDP €820,000, the Greens €245,000, the SPD €220,000 and the CSU €100,000; the AfD and the Left received none. Many gifts were still exactly €50,000, the old publication threshold.
The administration's review files did not stay open. From 2015 the association sought the correspondence on the 2013 and 2014 statements of account. The Berlin courts ordered release. On 17 June 2020 the Federal Administrative Court reversed those judgments (10 C 16.19 and 10 C 17.19). The Political Parties Act, it held, already states what the public may see—published accounts and the Bundestag President's reports—and excludes a further individual freedom-of-information claim. The internal files stayed withheld.
Transparency rules and campaigns
Rules on members' outside income
Until 2021, conduct rules for members of the Bundestag stood in the rules of procedure, where they had sat since 1972. Outside income was published in steps, and company holdings only from a 25 percent stake. In 2019 the Group of States against Corruption of the Council of Europe still judged supervision of members' declarations unsatisfactory. During the mask scandal the sponsoring groups wrote that members had gained personally from consultancy on medical procurement, then still lawful despite the conflict with an independent mandate.
On 11 June 2021 the Bundestag passed a bill from the Christian Democratic Union, the Christian Social Union, the Social Democratic Party, Die Linke and Alliance 90/The Greens. The Alternative for Germany and the Free Democratic Party abstained, and a motion from the Free Democrats, the Left and the Greens failed. The Bundesrat approved the package. The Gesetz zur Verbesserung der Transparenzregeln für die Mitglieder des Deutschen Bundestages und zur Anhebung des Strafrahmens des § 108e des Strafgesetzbuches, of 8 October 2021 (BGBl. I S. 4650), took effect on 19 October 2021 and moved the rules into the Members of the Bundestag Act. Abgeordnetenwatch and Transparency International Germany testified on 5 May 2021; the text adopted was the four groups' draft.
LobbyControl and Campact ran a parallel appeal for stricter rules. The Act banned paid interest representation and required cent-precise sums above new thresholds. It did not require meeting logs or an outside monitor.
Section 44a still permits outside work. It forbids benefits given because representation in the Bundestag is expected, fees for lectures tied to the mandate, paid interest representation toward the Bundestag or the federal government, and cash donations that stay with the member. Impermissible benefits are owed to the federal budget; the President of the Bundestag may claim them.
Under § 45 the member notifies the President within three months of joining and of any later change. For opinions, publications and lectures the duty lapses if agreed income does not exceed 1,000 euro a month or, if not, 3,000 euro a year. Above those thresholds the amount of a notifiable activity, contract or holding is stated as a gross sum. Holdings of more than 5 percent in a capital or partnership company must be notified, including stakes above 5 percent held through a holding company. Where secrecy law applies, a sector may replace the client's name. Particulars are published to the euro and cent on the member's biography.
The President may demand further information and admonishes a minor case, such as a deadline missed by at most three months. Otherwise the Presidium, after hearing the member, finds whether there was a breach, publishes that finding and may fine up to half the annual allowance; the President collects the fine. At the hearing Philipp Austermann called publication to the cent disproportionate beside the ten-step scale; Heinrich Wolff said parts of the bill neared the constitutional limit. The finding and the fine remain decisions of the Presidium, whose members are themselves parliamentarians.
The federal lobby register
The Lobbyregistergesetz of 16 April 2021 (BGBl. I S. 818), in force on 1 January 2022, created a public Bundestag register for interest representation toward the Bundestag or the federal government. Registration is required if the activity is regular, lasting or commercial for a third party, commissioned for a consideration, or if there were more than 30 distinct contacts in three months. The amending act of 15 January 2024 (BGBl. 2024 I Nr. 10), in force on 1 March 2024, lowered that figure from more than 50; a further amendment followed on 12 June 2024. The Social Democratic, Green and Free Democratic groups introduced the bill.
Section 2 exempts activity only "if and insofar as" it falls in a listed class, among them employers' and employees' associations influencing working and economic conditions under Article 9(3) of the Basic Law, churches and other religious or philosophical communities, parties, and journalism under Article 5. From March 2024 contacts with members' staff and with ministerial heads of unit are covered, and named representatives report roles in the Bundestag, the government or the federal administration over the previous five years. Which member was met is still not listed.
Tagesschau, summarizing the registry office, reported that declared spending for 2024 understated the total because employer organizations, trade unions and religious communities need not register, and that three of 20 regulatory-offence proceedings had ended in a fine. A failure to register, or to update an entry correctly and on time, is an offence under § 7, with up to 50,000 euro if intentional.
Transparency International Germany welcomed the 2023 draft and still called the deficits large: the footprint would not reach ministerial desk officers, there would be no independent lobby commissioner, and exemptions should be limited to activity the Basic Law directly protects.
Reception and research
Criticism from politicians
Complaints have followed both reporting on outside earnings and the site's own financing. On the ARD talk show Beckmann on 20 September 2010, Peer Steinbrück called abgeordnetenwatch.de a "kommerzieller Haufen" ("commercial bunch") after a clip on missed Bundestag votes and paid lectures. Fellow guest Joachim Gauck defended citizen associations that pressure politicians to justify themselves; the platform rejected the label. Der Spiegel had reported in August, from the portal's figures, that since the 2009 election Steinbrück had given at least 29 paid speeches—most disclosed only as at least €7,000, a floor of about €199,500—had missed sittings on lecture days, skipped 12 of 19 votes the site treated as important, and answered none of 15 questions there. He and the Social Democratic Party did not comment.
Before the 2009 election the site asked candidates for €200 for an extended profile—photograph, self-description, campaign calendar and homepage link—while questions stayed free. Sebastian Edathy, then chair of the Interior Committee, warned of a "Kommerzialisierung Ihres Dienstes" and refused to pay in order to keep answering: "Wenn Sie das so handhaben, dann ohne mich!" He circulated the letter to other members. Co-founder Gregor Hackmack told the Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger that the fee, with supporting members and individual donors, was meant to avoid commercial or public dependence. He cited a €72,000 deficit in 2008 and said that without candidate contributions the project might have to close; only the campaign upgrade was charged.
Wolfgang Kubicki of the Free Democratic Party questioned the platform's claim to speak for the public. In a 2013 interview with die tageszeitung he recalled an edition of maybrit illner on ZDF at which someone from Abgeordnetenwatch appeared, describing a private body with its own staff that presumed to speak for society. It angered him, he said, when "kleine Gruppierungen mit einem großen Namen" believed they represented society's will, and he had become "sehr böse" with "dem jungen Mann da."
In April 2010 Peter Hauk, floor leader of the Christian Democratic Union in the Baden-Württemberg Landtag, warned his members off the new state section and called its "vermeintliche" transparency "sehr fragwürdig," saying parliament, the faction and email already sufficed. Hackmack replied that members had been written to on 22 April and given a week to correct profiles. In late 2011, before any Wiesbaden section existed, 25 of 27 CDU city councillors had a lawyer demand that their public details not be listed, or the matter would go to an "erfolgssichere formale Klärung"—a suit, as Der Spiegel reported. After the local Pirate Party said it would pass on council addresses, the councillors cited personality rights, a public tally of unanswered questions and the burden on unpaid members. Hackmack told Spiegel that no municipal politician on the site had received more than two questions in several months, and that a launch would not depend on individual consent.
Scholarship on responsiveness
A 2010 study for the Bundestag's Office of Technology Assessment, by Steffen Albrecht and Matthias Trénel, is the main early content analysis. In the 16th Bundestag (2005–2009), citizens submitted 40,481 questions and members or their staff answered 86 percent; replies were usually prompt, lengthy and polite. Some members, the preface noted, saw a burden and a pillory; others linked to their answers. Users were skewed—about 80 percent men, relatively highly educated and politically active—and the authors asked whether focusing on the individual member obscured factions and committees.
Aron Buzogány took that question up in 2016 in the Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft, using the annual ranking for the 17th Bundestag. Opposition membership, a federal-government role and absence from the chamber were associated with response rates, and poorly ranked members were especially concerned to improve the next year. The article then discusses how far such rankings fit a parliament built on a division of labor. The score counts replies, not their substance. Reporting the 2024 table, the Lüdenscheid daily Come-on wrote that placement "hängt allein von der Anzahl der Antworten und Fragen ab" and that "Qualität spielt keine Rolle."
Later work keeps that yes-or-no measure and asks what reelection incentives do to it. Marco Frank, Nicola Maaser and David Stadelmann, in the Journal of Comparative Economics (2026), used 115,252 questions from 2005 to 2021 to members who served a full term; 16.5 percent went unanswered. Those not standing again answered about 5.2 percentage points less often, a gap that exceeded 13 percentage points in the final quarter. The authors tie the fall to lost standing in the party: members leaving for age or health did not answer less, while those leaving under party pressure or for another career did. A direct mandate was not linked to a higher rate. Staff may draft replies, but the statistic is still whether a question was answered.
Formal prizes have been occasional. The Grimme Online Award nominated the project in 2005, in the knowledge-and-education category, as "Demokratie per Internet," then a Hamburg service, and again in 2007 in the information category, once every Bundestag member could be questioned in public. In December 2013 the National Democratic Institute honored 21 civic innovators from 13 countries in Washington; Gregor Hackmack, identified as co-founder of Parliament Watch in Germany, was among the recipients.
International activity and comparable monitors
Projects abroad and the Parliament Watch Network
The public question format built for Hamburg, and later the Bundestag, was adapted abroad by separate projects rather than run as one franchise. Deutsche Welle has referred to the group in English as Parliament Watch. In August 2008, before Austria’s National Council election, Peter Merschitz and Peter Parycek presented meinparlament.at in parliament: a postcode brought up candidates, and named users could submit questions, with abusive or private ones filtered. They pointed to participation on the German sites. Ahead of the June 2009 European Parliament election in Ireland, the think tank TASC hosted CandidateWatch.ie, where voters questioned candidates in public, submissions were moderated, and answers stayed online. Gregor Hackmack told The Irish Times that the archive was meant to show later whether candidates had kept what they said, and that the approach was already in use in Austria and Luxembourg. Candidates could add a photograph and statement for a voluntary €100. The Irish site was an election service, not a standing monitor of the Oireachtas.
In Luxembourg, politikercheck.lu, founded in 2009, took questions to deputies, ministers, local councillors and members of the European Parliament, showed how many each had answered, and published votes. A moderation code screened insults and private matters but not criticism. Jerry Weyer told woxx in 2012 that Abgeordnetenwatch had been the model and had helped build the site, which kept statements and votes as a “virtual voter memory.” After the 2011 uprising in Tunisia, Al Bawsala’s Marsad.tn tracked the constituent assembly. Deutsche Welle reported in September 2012 that a question tool adapted from the German site, with Media in Cooperation and Transition and with Hackmack advising, had been added, and that a correspondent recorded answers because many members had no office internet.
In Greece, Vouliwatch was set up in Athens in March 2014 amid post-crisis disillusionment with parliament. Founder Antonis Schwarz told cafebabel in 2015 that it followed Abgeordnetenwatch: moderated questions to members, voting records, and comparisons of party programmes. International IDEA’s 2025 profile also lists profiles, an asset-declaration monitor and a news observatory, says the group’s research and litigation have been followed by legislative changes and disclosures of misconduct, and describes Vouliwatch as a co-founder of the ParliamentWatch Network. The Yemen Polling Center’s Parliament Watch, begun in 2009 with European Union and MEPI funding, was later described by the center as halted after institutions collapsed and war began.
Other parliamentary monitoring organizations
The category is older than that network. A 2011 survey by the National Democratic Institute and the World Bank Institute examined 191 such organizations watching 82 national parliaments. In a brief of 9 November 2025, Lotte Geunis, for International IDEA and Inter Pares, defines them as groups whose core work is parliamentary monitoring and for which parliament is a main interlocutor. She sorts them, with overlaps, into thematic “classic” monitors—Transparency International chapters are the example—often seeking open-parliament plans with the Open Government Partnership; process-focused monitors of bills, attendance, votes, expenses and assets, sometimes hosting questions to members; and volunteer-heavy data projects that turn records into public material.
TheyWorkForYou, launched in 2004 and run by mySociety, the main project of UK Citizens Online Democracy, is the archival comparison. It covers members across the United Kingdom with debates, expenses, registers of interests and votes grouped into policy positions, and is presented as non-partisan; mySociety also offers email alerts on a phrase or a representative. Arthur Edwards, Dennis de Kool and Charlotte van Ooijen argued in Information Polity (2015) that TheyWorkForYou mainly supports “monitorial” citizenship through that record, in a House of Commons under tight party discipline, while Abgeordnetenwatch paired a thinner vote file with public questions and a reform agenda on transparency, lobbying and outside income. On mySociety’s sites, writing to a representative was a separate tool, WriteToThem. Their French case, NosDéputés.fr, tracked activity but then lacked comparable individual votes. Vouliwatch is closer to the German pattern—questions, votes and campaigning—than to a pure archive.
In Germany the nearest organizations do different work. LobbyControl, a Cologne nonprofit, researches lobbying networks and political finance in Germany and the European Union and campaigns for rules on influence, without a question desk for members. FragDenStaat, a project of the Open Knowledge Foundation Deutschland, files and publishes freedom-of-information requests and adds campaigns and lawsuits when authorities refuse. Abgeordnetenwatch’s distinguishing method remains the moderated, archived exchange with named parliamentarians and candidates, set beside voting and outside-income records.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Related people
Related organizations
Linked pages by kind
Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.
- People2
- Organizations10