
Samyukta Karnataka
Samyukta Karnataka is a Kannada-language daily newspaper published from Hubballi (Hubli), in the Indian state of Karnataka.
Expert article
Samyukta Karnataka is a Kannada-language daily newspaper published from Hubballi (Hubli), in the Indian state of Karnataka. The Loka Shikshana Trust (Taking Over of Management) Act, 1982, describes the Loka Shikshana Trust, also called the People's Education Trust, as a body registered under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950, which published the Kannada daily from Hubli and Bangalore. The statute, passed on 10 March 1982 and deemed to have come into force on 31 August 1981, vested management of the trust in the state government for a limited period, on the stated ground that protracted disputes and litigation had produced mismanagement.
The paper grew out of the nationalist Kannada press in the Bombay Presidency. Ranganath Ramachandra Diwakar, born in Dharwad on 30 September 1894, founded the Kannada weekly Karmaveer in 1921 and was imprisoned for a year in 1923 on a charge of sedition; he later sat in the Constituent Assembly of India for Bombay and was Union minister of state for information and broadcasting from 1949 to 1952. A 2016 study of Kannada journalism states that Samyukta Karnataka itself began as a weekly in Belgaum in 1929, shifted to Hubli, and became a daily in 1933, with Kabbur Madhwa Rao, Rama Rao Hukkenkar and Diwakar among its sponsors. A deed of 19 February 1962, reciting an earlier trust of 15 July 1935, records that the trustee took over the Karnatak Prakashana Mandal press at Belgaum on 17 July 1935, later conducted it at Hubli, and published a daily titled Samyukta Karnatak and a weekly of the same name that was afterwards called Karmaveer.
H. R. Mohare edited the daily for more than 25 years and, on that account, made it a widely read nationalist paper in north Karnataka during the Indian independence movement. The same study says he was imprisoned during the Salt Satyagraha, that readers raised money when the paper faced a financial crisis in 1940, and that he worked for swaraj and a united Karnataka, both of which were achieved in his lifetime. After independence, during the 1948 police action in Hyderabad State, the Nizam's administration banned the paper in Gulbarga and other districts; Mohare is reported to have had copies smuggled across the border. He later presided over the Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society and sat as a director of the Press Trust of India, and he died in 1960, after which the paper was involved in litigation that lasted for years.
In Sole Trustee, Loka Shikshana Trust v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Mysore, decided on 28 August 1975, the Supreme Court of India refused the trust an exemption under the Income-tax Act, 1961, for assessment year 1962-63. The majority held that "education" in the Act meant systematic instruction, not the dissemination of news, and that the trust's newspaper business involved the carrying on of an activity for profit, taking it outside the definition of charitable purpose in section 2(15). The trust deed quoted in the judgment lists, among the objects, supplying Kannada-speaking people with "an organ or organs of educated public opinion."
The Indian Readership Survey for the third quarter of 2010, as reported in the 2016 study, gave Samyukta Karnataka an average issue readership of 11.31 lakh, third among Kannada dailies that quarter, behind Vijaya Karnataka at 34.25 lakh and Prajavani at 29.10 lakh, and slightly ahead of Kannada Prabha at 11.15 lakh. A Bangalore edition dated 5 July 2024 was offered through the digital newsstand Magzter, and the paper's e-paper site was still online in 2026.
Origins in the nationalist press
Karmaveera and the Dharwad circle
Kannada journalism in the Kannada-speaking districts of the Bombay Presidency was already a nationalist press by the time the papers associated with Samyukta Karnataka appeared. The Karnataka State Gazetteer (1983), edited by Suryanath U. Kamath, groups several weeklies that backed the freedom movement: Kannada Kesari (Hubli, 1906), Chandrodaya (Dharwad, 1913), Kerur Vasudevacharya’s Shubhodaya (Dharwad, 1917), Sachitra Bharata (Dharwad, 1913), Vijaya (Dharwad, 1921) and Kannadiga (Bagalkot, 1925), together with Karmaveera. A 2016 survey by A. Yogeesh places the same Dharwad cluster—Chandrodaya, Sachitra Bharata, Shubhodaya, Karmaveera and Vijaya—in that nationalist field, and notes the influence of Bal Gangadhar Tilak on Bombay-Karnataka journalists, among them Aluru Venkata Rao, who founded Jayakarnataka in 1922. The press was older still outside that circle. Yogeesh dates the first Kannada newspaper, Mangaloora Samachara, to Mangalore in 1843, and the first Kannada daily, Suryodaya Prakashika, to Bangalore in 1888; D. V. Gundappa had been publishing from Bengaluru since 1907.
Karmaveera (also spelled Karmaveer) was a weekly started at Dharwad in 1921, not the Hubli daily of the 1930s. Ranganath Ramachandra Diwakar, who left college teaching during the non-cooperation campaign associated with Mahatma Gandhi, is described in a Centre for Law and Policy Research profile as its founder; the profile calls the weekly known for radical views and strong language, and records that he was imprisoned for a year in 1923 on a charge of sedition. Yogeesh names Diwakar as editor and Madhwa Rao as publisher, and says Diwakar was at one point arrested over the paper’s anti-government line. The same town was already in open conflict with the district administration. On 1 July 1921 police fired on people picketing a liquor shop near Jakani Bhavi, killing three; Deccan Herald’s centenary account names Diwakar and Madhawarao Kabbur among Dharwad campaigners jailed more than once in those years, and notes that local dailies compared the collector, Painter, with General Dyer. Diwakar also started an English weekly, Nava Shakti, at Dharwad in 1923. Yogeesh says Karmaveera later moved to Hubli.
The Belgaum weekly and the Hubli daily
Samyukta Karnataka was a separate title, and the statement that the daily was founded in 1921 by the Loka Shikshana Trust is not what the gazetteer or Yogeesh report. The gazetteer says the paper began as a weekly in 1929 at Belgaum, started by “a group of energetic men,” and that control soon passed to Kabbur Madhava Rao, Rama Rao Hukkerikar and Ranganatha Ramachandra Diwakar. It was then shifted to Hubli and became a daily in 1933. Yogeesh agrees on those dates and on the move, and lists Kabbur Madhwa Rao, Rama Rao Hukkenkar and R. R. Diwakar as the sponsors from the outset—a small difference from the gazetteer’s “soon transferred,” not a different chronology. The title, “United Karnataka,” named the unification demand already argued in the north Karnataka press, including by Aluru Venkata Rao, but the paper was one journal among several, not the first Kannada newspaper or the first Kannada daily. In Mysore, P. R. Ramaiya’s Tainadu, begun as a weekly in 1926, had already been converted into a Bangalore daily in 1929.
A later legal record fixes the trust, not the weekly’s first issue. In Sole Trustee, Loka Shikshana Trust v. Commissioner of Income Tax (1975), the Supreme Court of India recited a 1962 redeclaration of a deed of 15 July 1935, the National Literature Publications Trust. Under that deed Diwakar took over the Karnatak Prakashana Mandal at Belgaum on 17 July 1935, ran a press there and afterwards at Hubli, and printed the daily Samyukta Karnatak and a weekly called Weekly Samyukta Karnatak, “which was later called Karmaveer.” That recital supports a Hubli daily continued by a trust formed in 1935; it does not date the newspaper to 1921. It does conflict with the gazetteer and with Yogeesh on the weekly: those accounts keep Karmaveera as the separate Dharwad paper of 1921, which the gazetteer says was later taken over along with the management of Samyukta Karnataka, rather than as a renamed weekly edition of the Belgaum title. A single “founded in 1921 by the Loka Shikshana Trust” therefore runs together the 1921 weekly, the 1929 Belgaum weekly and 1933 Hubli daily, and a trust whose deed, on the court’s record, is of 1935.
Role in the freedom struggle and Karnataka unification
Nationalist reporting and repression
In the Kannada districts of the Bombay Presidency, the Press Commission's 1955 history records that nationalist weeklies were prosecuted for criticism of the government and that, during the non-cooperation phase of the Indian independence movement, they reached their highest circulation. Samyukta Karnataka began in that setting, at Belgaum (now in Belagavi district), as a weekly propagandist organ of the Karnataka movement after agitation had ebbed in the mid-1920s. The Commission names B. V. Belvi, Narayanrao Joshi and B. N. Datar as founders. It became a daily in 1933, and in 1934 H. R. Moharay—editor and proprietor of the Bijapur weekly Karnataka Vaibhav since Jayarao Deshpande's death in 1922—was invited to take the managing editorship. After R. R. Diwakar's release that year, the daily passed to the National Literature Publication Trust, discussed in 1929 by Diwakar, Moharay, Hanamantrao Kaujalgi and others, and in 1937 it moved to Hubli, called a better distributing centre.
It was one paper among several. Diwakar and R. S. Hukerikar had started the weekly Karmaveer in 1921; its writing brought Diwakar a year's imprisonment for sedition in 1923, and the Commission later listed it under the Loka Shikshan Trust at Hubli. In the Kingdom of Mysore, T. T. Sharma turned the Mysore Chronicle into the Kannada weekly Vishwa Karnataka in 1925 and a daily in 1932; police raided it, government advertising was withdrawn, and Sharma was arrested during the Quit India Movement./v2-i2(2)-a007.pdf) Tainadu, a Bangalore daily the Commission dates to 1927 under T. R. Ramaiyya, is described in a later survey as a nationalist paper whose proprietor, P. R. Ramaiya, and a later editor, P. H. Srinivas, courted imprisonment in 1943.
That survey places the Hubli daily at the front of nationalist campaigning in north Karnataka and says that under Moharay, jailed during the Salt Satyagraha, it carried the movement's leaders to a wide local readership. It also states that when the paper met a financial crisis in 1940, readers in north Karnataka raised a fund to cover its commitments, and that Moharay's stated objects were swaraj and an akhanda, or united, Karnataka.
The campaign for a united Karnataka
Kannada-speaking territory was then split among Mysore, the Bombay and Madras presidencies, Hyderabad State and Coorg. The unification of Karnataka, or Ekikarana, was argued in print before this daily existed. Aluru Venkata Rao started Jaya Karnataka in 1922 for that purpose, and Dharwad hosted Ekikarana conferences in 1936 and 1944. Diwakar was the Karnataka Provincial Congress Committee's only speaker on a single Kannada province before the 1928 Nehru Committee, and he published United Karnataka. Sharma's Vishwa Karnataka used its columns for the same demand./v2-i2(2)-a007.pdf)
The Hubli paper's name stated the programme directly. The States Reorganisation Act, 1956 formed a new Mysore State, later renamed Karnataka, from existing Mysore, Coorg, and named districts and taluks of Bombay, Hyderabad and Madras, including Belgaum except Chandgad taluka, Bijapur, Dharwar and North Kanara, and Gulbarga, Raichur and Bidar with stated exceptions. The later survey records that Moharay, editor for more than twenty-five years, lived to see both independence and that state; he died in 1960.
The Hyderabad police action
Gulbarga, Bidar and Raichur lay inside the Nizam's Hyderabad, outside the presidency where the Hubli paper was printed. After Mir Osman Ali Khan had not joined the Indian Union, Indian troops entered on 13 September 1948 in the police action known as Operation Polo. V. P. Menon, quoted by The Hindu, notes that the advance came on the 13th rather than the 15th, before bridges could be demolished, and that the army overran the dominion within 109 hours.
On 18 September the Hyderabad commander, Major General Syed Ahmed El Edroos, surrendered to Major General J. N. Chaudhuri. The Kannada-journalism survey says that during the police action Samyukta Karnataka took a prominent part; that the Nizam banned its entry into Gulbarga, now Kalaburagi, and other parts of Hyderabad; and that Moharay had copies carried in despite the ban. Those districts were among the Hyderabad territories moved to Mysore in 1956. Inside the region, a Gulbarga weekly edited by Raghu Jahagirdar spoke for local campaigners against the Nizam, and a handwritten journal, Udaya (1947–50), reported Razakar violence. The Hubli daily was one channel, printed outside the state, not the only press in that campaign.
The Loka Shikshana Trust
Formation and objects
The property later used to publish Samyukta Karnataka was settled on 15 July 1935 as the National Literature Publications Trust, with a corpus of Rs 4,308, 10 annas and 9 pies. Ranganath Ramachandra Diwakar, its only trustee, took over on 17 July 1935 a printing concern, the Karnatak Prakashana Mandal, at Belgaum, and then moved the press to Hubli. Under that trust he printed a daily, named in the later deeds Samyukta Karnatak or Samyuktha Karnataka, a weekly first called Weekly Samyukta Karnatak and later Karmaveer (also spelled Karma Veer), and books, pamphlets and other literature. The presses, buildings and land built up by that work were treated as trust property.
A deed of 10 April 1947 redeclared the settlement. Clause 2 stated the objects as educating the people of India in general and of Karnatak in particular: by establishing, conducting or helping institutions to spread knowledge on matters of general interest and welfare; by founding reading rooms and libraries, keeping printing houses, and publishing or aiding books, pamphlets and magazines in Kannada and other languages, for the education of the people; by supplying Kannada-speaking people with an organ or organs of educated public opinion and conducting journals for news and for public opinion on matters of general public utility; and by helping societies with any of those objects.
The Supreme Court of India, on the assessment for 1962–63, recited a further deed of 19 February 1962 by which Diwakar, still sole trustee, redeclared the 1935 trust after doubts about the original instrument. The schedule, which Khanna J. identified with the deed of 10 April 1947, valued the assets at Rs 2,97,658, including printing machines, motor cars, buildings and paper stocks, against liabilities of Rs 1,24,086, a net of Rs 1,73,571, 14 annas and 4 pies.
A Karnataka statute dealing with the trust's management described it as the Loka Shikshana Trust (Peoples' Education Trust), registered under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 (Bombay Act 29 of 1950), and as publisher of the Kannada daily Samyukta Karnataka from Hubli and Bangalore. A scheme later set out by the High Court, and reproduced in a 2013 judgment, named the body "Loka Shikshana Trust Hubli-Bangalore" and took its objects from clause 2 of the deed, adding libraries, educational institutions and scholarships.
Trustees and control of the press
The deeds left control in one man. Diwakar could spend the fund for any trust purpose "in such manner as to him may appear proper" and could operate every bank account. He could take over concerns he thought conducive to the objects; mortgage, sell, lease or otherwise deal with the property; borrow; and invest in authorised trust securities or in shares and debentures of companies in India or abroad. He could transfer the assets and liabilities to another charitable institution which, in his opinion, had similar objects. He was not to be paid for acting as trustee, but the deed allowed payment from the fund for work on its institutions or on "the business of printing, publishing or other activities", and it allowed his expenses.
The newspapers were not held through a company. The 1962 preamble, as quoted by the Court, stated that the presses, buildings and land were themselves trust property, accumulated by printing and publishing since 1935. The High Court found the trust's receipts came from immovable property, the Hubli press, and the daily and weekly. The trustee could appoint managers, editors and other staff for any newspaper, weekly, monthly, magazine or book, and could delegate banking, receipts, purchases of paper, ink and machines, contracts with agents, and the hiring and removal of workers. The scheme reproduced in 2013 replaced sole trusteeship with a board of five, the first headed by B. D. Jatti, and left publication a business of the trust, with investments governed by section 35 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950.
Editions, printing and sister publications
The Bangalore edition and multi-centre printing
For most of its life as a daily, Samyukta Karnataka was printed at the publisher's own press in Hubli. In a 1970 income-tax reference, the Karnataka High Court recorded that the Loka Shikshana Trust, under a deed of 10 April 1947 that redeclared a National Literature Publications Trust created on 15 July 1935, conducted a printing press at Hubli and there printed the Kannada daily. The Press Registrar General of India still enters the registered press as Samyukta Karnataka, Koppikar Road, Hubli 580020, in Dharwad district, with Lok Shikshana Trust as owner; that registration is dated 13 December 1994 and does not itself date the paper.
A Bangalore edition is dated to 26 January 1959. On 28 January 2019 the management marked sixty years of that edition at Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan on Race Course Road, and used the occasion to honour journalists associated with the city printing. Among them were Prahlad Kulali, who had joined as a Hubli reporter about a year before the Bangalore edition and retired in 1997 as resident editor after more than forty years, and the family of H. R. Nagesh Rao, who had been resident editor for twenty-seven years until his retirement in 1985. The Karnataka Act of 1982, which vested management of the trust in the state, described the trust in its preamble as publishing, among other things, the Kannada daily Samyukta Karnataka from Hubli and Bangalore. That is the two-centre arrangement fixed in the statute. Later city printings are not set out in the Act or in the registrar's current Hubli title entry.
Karmaveera, Kasthuri and other titles
A 2016 survey of Kannada journalism dates the weekly Karmaveera to 1921 in Dharwar, with R. R. Diwakar as editor and Madhwa Rao as publisher, and says that it later moved to Hubli. The same account names H. R. Purohit as its most notable editor and gives him a tenure of thirty years. Describing the trust's business rather than those first years, the High Court stated that the 1935 trust published the daily Samyuktha Karnataka and a weekly called Weekly Samyuktha Karnataka, afterwards called Karma Veer, and that the Loka Shikshana Trust printed both at the Hubli press, along with books, pamphlets and other literature.
The monthly from the same office was Kasturi (also spelled Kasthuri). The September 1956 number, digitised from a copy the trust allowed to be scanned, is marked issue 1. Its imprint names Mohare Hanumantharaya as chief editor, the Loka Shikshana Trust of Hubli as publisher, the Samyukta Karnataka office in Hubli as the magazine's office, and the Samyukta Karnataka press in Hubli as the printer.
The editor's column in that first number said that knowledge, science and literature were accumulating beyond the reach of the ordinary Kannada reader, and that the magazine would gather material from many languages and sources. In the assessment year 1962–63 an income-tax officer wrote to the trust that its only activity was the printing, publication and sale of a newspaper, a weekly and a monthly journal. The Supreme Court of India set out that description in 1975, when it held that the trust's publishing business did not qualify for exemption as a charitable educational purpose. The court's three categories line up with the daily, with Karmaveera, and with Kasturi, the monthly whose Hubli imprint is on the 1956 file.
Management disputes and state intervention
Private takeovers and litigation
The Loka Shikshana Trust, registered under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950, with its office at Hubli, published the Kannada daily Samyukta Karnataka from Hubli and Bangalore. The Karnataka High Court described it as established in 1935 by Ranganatha Ramachandra Diwakar. A judgment of 9 December 1976 recorded that R. R. Diwakar was then sole trustee and that Karnataka Patrika (P.) Ltd. had taken over the newspaper.
The Division Bench that later heard the constitutional challenge recorded a sale by the trustees to Karnataka Patrika (Pvt.) Ltd. of the publishing right, the press and allied machinery for Rs 67 lakh, dating it once as 27 November 1974 and later in the same judgment as 21 November 1974. A 1995 judgment gives 21 November 1974 and states that on 12 December 1977 Jaya Karnataka Newspapers Private Limited took the paper over, assets and liabilities passing with it. The 1983 judgment calls that purchaser Jaya Karnataka Newspaper Printers (Pvt.) Ltd. and says that, during the suit, it bought the rights and properties for Rs 75 lakh and was added as the eighth defendant.
Five persons interested in the trust filed Original Suit No. 4 of 1977 before the District Judge at Dharwar, alleging mismanagement and seeking removal of the trustees, a scheme, and possession from the alienees. Karnataka Patrika was the seventh defendant. Issues included whether the alienations breached section 36 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act. On 17 September 1979 the District Court appointed the eighth defendant itself receiver and recorded its assurance that the daily would not close. The Bangalore edition nevertheless closed on 31 January 1980. In the appeal from that receivership, M.F.A. No. 263 of 1979, the High Court on 14 January 1980 appointed the Tahsildar of Hubli receiver of rents and later recorded that the appeal was dismissed for default. In September 1980 the Charity Commissioner replaced the company and restarted the Bangalore edition from 20 December 1980. On 18 April 1981 the court released him and, by consent, appointed Jiginni, a retired District Judge, receiver of the publications and movable property.
The 1982 takeover Act
The Government of Karnataka promulgated the Loka Shikshana Trust (Taking over of Management) Ordinance, 1981 (Karnataka Ordinance 16 of 1981). The replacing Loka Shikshana Trust (Taking over of Management) Act, 1982 (Karnataka Act No. 9 of 1982), dated 10 March 1982, was deemed in force from 31 August 1981, and action under the ordinance was saved. The preamble states that protracted disputes and litigation had resulted in mismanagement, and that a limited takeover was expedient in the public interest and to secure proper management. Management vested in the State for two years from the appointed day, extendable by not more than one year at a time to a maximum of five. Management contracts ended, and trustees, court receivers and other managers were deemed to have vacated office notwithstanding any judgment. An administrator then exercised the governing body’s powers, including disposal of property, under government control. No compensation was payable for loss of office or for premature termination of a management contract. An explanation deemed property in O.S. No. 4 of 1977 and in M.F.A. No. 263 of 1977, where it was with the court receivers, to be part of the trust, without affecting any person’s rights.
R. K. Joshi and others, and the trust represented by A. R. Diwakar, who claimed to be sole trustee, challenged the Act. On 3 June 1983 K. Jagannatha Shetty and S. G. Doddakale Gowda JJ. upheld it except the explanation so far as it covered property sold to Karnataka Patrika (Pvt.) Ltd. and held by the receiver in the Dharwar suit. That part was declared invalid, with a direction to return the property to the receiver if the suit was pending, or otherwise to the person entitled. The Bench held the Act to be legislation on trusts and trustees. On 26 June 1985 the High Court recorded that management of the newspaper was vested in the court receiver.
Restoration of the board
When the State’s management ended, the Act required the trust to vest under any court order or, failing one, in its governing body. In R.F.A. No. 331 of 1984, Dheerendra D. Jamble v. R. R. Diwakar, the High Court framed a scheme under section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, identified in later proceedings in that appeal as dated 28 February 1986. The scheme placed the office at No. 2, Residency Road, Bangalore, and vested the property then with the receiver in five trustees: B. D. Jatti, of Sadashivanagar, Bangalore, as chairman, with K. S. N. Adiga, R. A. Mundkur, S. P. Bhat and G. M. Patil. That board took over the paper on 10 March 1986.
Tax, labour and related litigation
The Supreme Court charitable-purpose case
The sole trustee of the Loka Shikshana Trust sought exemption for the assessment year 1962-63 under section 11 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, read with section 2(15). The deed of 19 February 1962, redeclaring a trust of 15 July 1935, stated an object of educating people in India and in Karnataka by printing and publishing in Kannada and by supplying Kannada readers with an organ of educated public opinion. Printing moved from Belgaum to Hubli, where the daily Samyukta Karnataka was published. The Income-tax Officer refused the claim as an activity for profit; the appellate authorities allowed it. On 12 February 1970 the High Court, on a reference, held that the income was not exempt. Until 1961-62 the income had been exempt under section 4(3)(i) of the 1922 Act.
On 28 August 1975 the Supreme Court of India dismissed the appeal, reported as (1976) 1 SCC 254 and 101 ITR 234. H. R. Khanna J., with A. C. Gupta J., held that “education” in section 2(15) means systematic instruction, schooling or training of students, not knowledge gained from newspapers. As in the Privy Council case In re Trustees of the Tribune, an organ of educated public opinion was an object of general public utility, not education. That residual head also had to involve no activity for profit. The trust’s printing and publishing business yielded, or was likely to yield, profit, and the deed did not restrict profit. Receipts that year were Rs 22,55,077, and “profit” was not confined to private profit. The majority left open whether those words also qualified the first three heads. M. H. Beg J. agreed in the result. The refusal was for 1962-63 alone.
Employment and other disputes
In Management of Samyukta Karnataka v. M. L. Satyanarayana Rao (26 June 1985) the Karnataka High Court set aside a Labour Court award of 23 June 1984. M. L. Satyanarayana Rao, a news agent at Holenarasipura also appointed a correspondent on 12 August 1971, had been held a working journalist entitled to a correspondent’s pay on a reference under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and the Working Journalists (Conditions of Service) and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1955. The Court held that a correspondent is a working journalist only if that work is the principal avocation, and remitted that question.
On 14 February 2008 the High Court restored damages under section 85-B of the Employees’ State Insurance Act, 1948, which the Employees' State Insurance Court at Hubli had set aside: Rs 2,278 for November 1980 to March 1985, and Rs 8,553 for December 1976 to September 1980. The Act was held to fix no limitation for such damages; delay in levying them was not a waiver; and section 93-A made a transferee jointly and severally liable. A plea that the trust took the newspaper’s properties only from 10 March 1986 was rejected. On 29 July 2008 the Court also rejected a workmen’s petition against a 4 December 2007 refusal, in O.S. No. 12802 of 1999 before the Additional City Civil Judge at Bangalore, to add a party under Order I Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure in a suit already brought in a representative capacity.
In O.S. No. 1158 of 2007 the trust sued to avoid a lease of 2 March 1972 by trustee R. R. Diwakar, of about 12,000 square feet at No. 2, Residency Road, Bangalore, for 42 years, and a 27 December 1995 extension in favour of Janardhan Corporation, and to recover possession. On 30 January 2021 the City Civil Court held the challenge time-barred, found the Charity Commissioner’s ex post facto sanction and the extension not shown to be non-binding, and dismissed the suit with costs.
Editors and the journalism tradition
H. R. Mohare
Mohare Hanumantharaya, rendered in English as H. R. Mohare or H. R. Moharay, was born on 12 November 1892 at Devar Hipparagi in what is now Vijayapura district and died on 27 July 1960. A note issued with Karnataka’s journalism awards describes him as a freedom-movement participant who was imprisoned, and as a journalist remembered for stern reporting. He was sub-editor and then editor of Karnataka Vaibhava, a Vijayapura weekly. In 1934, while Samyukta Karnataka was published from Belagavi, he joined as editor and later managing editor, and he retired in 1958. A survey of Kannada journalism calls him the paper’s most famous editor, credits him with more than twenty-five years in the post, and says he came from a family of journalists connected with Karnataka Vaibhava.
That survey says he made the daily a voice of freedom-struggle leaders, widely read in northern Karnataka, and that readers raised a fund when it faced a financial crisis in 1940. It records imprisonment during the Salt Satyagraha, and says that during the annexation of Hyderabad he had copies carried into Kalaburagi and other areas from which the Nizam had banned the paper. The award note credits him with starting, in September 1956 for the Loka Shikshana Trust, the monthly Kasturi, which it calls Kannada’s first digest.
In 1957–58 he was president of the Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society — the publishers’ body that deleted “Eastern” from its name in 1988 and is now the Indian Newspaper Society — as Samyukta Karnataka’s representative. R. R. Diwakar, who edited the daily as well as Karmaveer and Kasturi, held the same office in 1962–63, again listed against the paper. The journalism survey also describes Mohare as a director of the Press Trust of India.
Later editors and state honours
Later responsibility is recorded in an official biography, a court order, and news reports rather than in one public succession list. Khadri Shamanna (6 June 1925 – 11 May 1990) was news editor of the Bengaluru edition from 1960 to 1963 and editor-in-chief of the Samyukta Karnataka group from 1974 to 1978, in a career his Legislative Council biography puts at about forty years. That biography also records work at Prajavani and as editor of Kannada Prabha, the chairmanship of the Karnataka Press Academy from 1984 to 1987, and nomination to the council from 9 August 1984 until his death.
In a 2013 Karnataka High Court order transferring a defamation case, Hunasavadi Rajan Rao was described as editor of the daily and A. C. Gopal Bhat as publisher for the Lok Shikshana Trust; the complaint concerned a 4 March 2012 article alleged to have called advocates “rowdy advocates.” In June 2017 Rajan received that year’s Khadri Shamanna journalism award from the Khadri Shamanna Memorial Trust.
Vasant Nadiger, from Ranebennur, began at the paper in the 1980s after a chemistry degree at Dharwad. He later worked at Kannada Prabha, was news editor of Vijaya Karnataka from 1998 to 2015, and worked at Vishwavani. He had been editor of Samyukta Karnataka for about two years when he died of a heart attack in Bengaluru on 9 September 2024, aged 59; reports noted his headlines, and he had received Karnataka Media Academy and Khadri Shamanna awards. Chief Minister Siddaramaiah’s condolence message referred to that editorship.
The Mohare Hanumantharaya Journalism Award is not a prize for work on this paper. Since 2010 the Department of Information and Public Relations has given it, alongside the T. S. Ramachandra Rao (TSR) Memorial Award, for establishing a Kannada newspaper or group, with at least thirty years as owner or administrator. The purse was ₹1 lakh in 2017 and ₹2 lakh when nominations for 2019–2023 were invited in 2024. Recipients have included proprietors of other titles, among them K. B. Ganapathy of Star of Mysore and Mysooru Mithra (2013), Gangadhara Hiregutti of Munjavu (2016), and Rajeev Kidiyoor of Navodaya (2019). The TSR award, given since 1993 for long service in Kannada journalism, has also gone to people who worked here. Srikantacharya R. Manoor, the 2020 recipient, joined in 1973, served forty-four years, and retired as executive editor of the Kalaburagi edition.
Circulation and the Kannada newspaper market
Readership surveys
The Indian Readership Survey estimates readers rather than copies sold. In the Karnataka market for the third quarter of 2010, exchange4media reported average issue readership—the survey’s average number of readers of an issue, which the site distinguished from total readership over a longer recall—as 3,425,000 for Vijaya Karnataka, 2,910,000 for Prajavani, 1,131,000 for Samyukta Karnataka, 1,115,000 for Kannada Prabha and 890,000 for Udayavani. The same report listed the five largest dailies in the state, all of them Kannada, in that order, so Samyukta Karnataka was third. A companion table of Kannada-language average issue readership in the same quarter left Samyukta Karnataka, Prajavani and Kannada Prabha unchanged at 1,131,000, 2,910,000 and 1,115,000, but gave Vijaya Karnataka 3,430,000 and Udayavani 951,000.
For the fourth quarter of 2010, exchange4media’s Karnataka report put Vijaya Karnataka’s average issue readership at 34.75 lakh and numbered Prajavani second. It gave Samyukta Karnataka a readership of 11.92 lakh, against 11.31 lakh in the third quarter, and did not state a rank.
Published tables were shorter after the survey was relaunched. BestMediaInfo’s account of the 2019 first-quarter round used total readership on a one-month recall for people aged 12 and over, urban and rural, and set the 2017 figures beside it. The five Kannada dailies in that table were Vijaya Karnataka (6,925,000 in 2017 and 7,910,000 in 2019 Q1), Vijayavani (6,482,000 and 7,230,000), Prajavani (6,435,000 and 7,177,000), Udayavani (3,109,000 and 3,324,000) and Kannada Prabha (2,263,000 and 2,662,000). Samyukta Karnataka is not in that top five for either year, and the article publishes no total-readership or average-issue figure for it. An exchange4media summary of the 2019 results for southern dailies likewise named Vijaya Karnataka first among Kannada titles, with more than 9.8 lakh readers added since 2017, and did not mention Samyukta Karnataka.
Position among Kannada dailies
Audited circulation, a count of copies rather than readers, is published for fewer Kannada titles. MediaNews4U’s report of language-wise data from the Audit Bureau of Circulations (India) for January–December 2023 named three Kannada dailies: Vijayavani with 548,452 copies, Vijaya Karnataka with 491,280 and Kannada Prabha with 101,989. Samyukta Karnataka was not among the Kannada titles named there, so that account gives it no certified circulation.
Figures used for central-government advertising are edition-wise. The Central Bureau of Communication site reproduces the Directorate of Advertising and Visual Publicity panel for Karnataka as on 12 August 2021; its circulation column is headed for an RNI, ABC or chartered-accountant figure, without saying which basis applies to each row. On that panel Samyukta Karnataka was listed at 25,000 copies for Hubballi, 19,700 for Bengaluru, 4,239 for Kalaburagi and 3,794 for Davanagere; those four edition rows sum to 52,733 copies, a total the panel itself does not print. The same list gave the Bengaluru editions of Vijaya Karnataka, Vijayavani, Prajavani and Kannada Prabha as 280,192, 250,589, 236,214 and 63,106 copies, and Udayavani’s Manipal edition as 160,903. In Hubballi it listed Vijayavani at 100,797, Prajavani at 72,813 and Vijaya Karnataka at 60,942, against Samyukta Karnataka’s 25,000.
The spread belongs to a longer growth of Indian-language dailies. Robin Jeffrey’s India’s Newspaper Revolution, on the Indian-language press from 1977 to 1999, is described in a Frontline review as an account of how localisation, and the use of circulation as the measure of success, accompanied a readership explosion.
Editorial character and public reception
Political orientation
Writers locate what the paper argued for in nationalist and Congress politics in the Kannada districts of the Bombay Presidency, and in the unification of Karnataka. R. R. Diwakar, editor of the daily for the People’s Education Trust, had founded Karmaveera in 1921 and was jailed for sedition in 1923. In 1928 he spoke for the Karnataka Provincial Indian National Congress Committee before the Nehru Committee on one Kannada province, and from 1930 he was its president. A 2016 survey of Kannada journalism says that under H. R. Mohare the Hubli daily was “the authentic voice of the leaders of the freedom struggle,” with “immense popularity in north Karnataka,” and that his objects were swaraj and a united Karnataka, and that he was jailed during the Salt March.
“An organ or organs of educated public opinion” is the trust’s object, not a critic’s praise. In Sole Trustee, Loka Shikshana Trust v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Mysore (28 August 1975) the Supreme Court of India recited clause 2(c) of the deed of 19 February 1962, on journals for news and “the ventilation of public opinion on matters of general public utility,” and treated the business as a profitable object of general public utility, not as education.
No Press Council finding or opened study labels the later paper “right-leaning” or “centre-left.” C. G. Manjula’s 2002 note on the Bangalore edition (28 February–16 March) records both the banner “Agnikunda Gujarat” and editorials urging a halt to the Ram Mandir agitation, without stating a party line.
Criticism and standing
Criticism on record covers management, labour claims, reporting, and readership. The preamble of the Loka Shikshana Trust (Taking Over of Management) Act, 1982, says protracted disputes and litigation resulted in mismanagement of the trust, publisher of the Hubli and Bangalore daily, warranting a limited public-interest takeover. The 2016 survey adds that after Mohare’s death in 1960 litigation “continued for a long time.” In Management of Samyuktha Karnataka v. T. S. Ranganna (28 March 1995) the Karnataka High Court held that sales to private companies in 1974 and 1977, and a court-made board from 10 March 1986, did not cut gratuity back to the last change of control.
A complaint said a 4 March 2012 article called advocates “rowdy advocates”; in January 2013 the High Court moved it from Bijapur after the bar refused to appear for editor Hunasavadi Rajan Rao or the publisher. In 2023 Justice V. Srishananda quashed decade-old cases against this paper and three others for reports using “Taliban” and “goonda,” after apologies, remarking that many readers took the press as “gospel truth.”
Citing the Indian Readership Survey for the third quarter of 2010, the 2016 article ranked the paper third among Kannada dailies, at 11.31 lakh average issue readers, behind Vijaya Karnataka (34.25 lakh) and Prajavani (29.10 lakh). BestMediaInfo’s table of Kannada total readership for 2017 and early 2019 listed Vijaya Karnataka, Vijayavani, Prajavani, Udayavani and Kannada Prabha, and omitted this title. N. Usha Rani and Nesara Kadanakuppe, using Audit Bureau of Circulations (India) figures, report a fall from 1.50 lakh copies in 2010 to 0.73 lakh in 2018 (−7.69 per cent a year), against 6.99 lakh for Vijaya Karnataka and 7.52 lakh for Vijayavani in 2018, and rank the paper sixth of seven, still strongest around Hubballi–Dharwad.
Contemporary operations
Editions and the e-paper
Samyukta Karnataka is published as a Kannada morning daily in Karnataka. The Hubballi (Hubli) issue of Sunday, 18 October 2026, was priced at ₹5, ran to 12 pages plus two, and carried the imprint “RNI.REG.NO.3544/1957”. The Press Registrar General of India records number 3544 for SAMYUKTA KARNATAKA, a Kannada daily owned by Lok Shikshana Trust, published in Dharwad district, with a registration date of 13 December 1994 and no revised date.
The e-paper at epaper.samyukthakarnataka.com is configured as Samyuktha Karnataka. Its catalogue lists main editions for Bengaluru, Hubballi (Hubli), Kalaburagi (Kalaburgi), Davanagere (Davangere) and Mangaluru (Mangalore), and sub-editions for Belagavi (Belgaum), Vijayapura (Bijapur), Gadag, Hassan, Tumakuru (Tumkur), Kolar, Mysuru (Mysore), Mandya, Karwar, Haveri, Ballari, Koppal, Bagalkot and Chikkaballapura, plus another Mangaluru sub-edition. The same list includes Saptahika Sourabha, Jaanara Guru, Kasturi and Karmaveera. Issues for 18 and 19 October 2026 were posted for the five city editions, Jaanara Guru, and the sub-editions other than Chikkaballapura and the extra Mangaluru sub-edition. That day’s Hubballi front-page strip named Hubballi, Bengaluru, Kalaburagi, Davanagere, Mangaluru, Bagalkot and Belagavi.
The Central Bureau of Communication’s Karnataka list of publications on the DAVP panel as on 12 August 2021 empanels four morning Kannada editions: Hubballi (code 430007, classed Big), Bengaluru (430008, Medium), Davanagere (430201, Small) and Kalaburagi (430141, Small).
Organisation and premises
The registration names Ashok Narayan Shanbhag as publisher and Vasanth Nadiger as editor, and the press as Samyukta Karnataka, Koppikar Road, Hubli 580020. Nadiger, editor for about two years after starting his career on the paper, died of a heart attack at his Bengaluru home at about 3:30 a.m. on 9 September 2024. The title record still named him in October 2026, and the 18 October 2026 Hubballi masthead did not name another editor. A report published on 5 September 2024 identified Mohan Hegde as chief executive officer of Samyukta Karnataka at a newspaper-hawkers’ meeting in Hubballi.
On 11 October 2025 the paper reported that the Hubballi office, which it said had worked from Koppikar Road since before independence, would move that morning into premises it owns on the second floor of Stellar Mall in Vidyanagar, to be inaugurated by Pralhad Joshi, described as Union minister for food and public distribution, with Loka Shikshana Trust president Ashok Haranahalli presiding and trustees U.B. Venkatesh, Gururaj Karajagi, Keshav Desai and D.R. Patil attending. The registrar’s press address remained Koppikar Road. A supplement line in the 18 October 2026 Hubballi e-paper still gave Post Box 30, Koppikar Road, Hubballi, as a postal address.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Related people
Related organizations
Linked pages by kind
Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.
- People2
- Organizations8