Margaret Ng
Margaret Ng Ngoi-yee (Chinese: 吳靄儀; born 25 January 1948) is a Hong Kong barrister, writer and former legislator.
- Facts0
- Drivers0
- Indicators0
Margaret Ng Ngoi-yee (Chinese: 吳靄儀; born 25 January 1948) is a Hong Kong barrister, writer and former legislator.
Margaret Ng Ngoi-yee (Chinese: 吳靄儀; born 25 January 1948) is a Hong Kong barrister, writer and former legislator. She represented the legal functional constituency in the Legislative Council of Hong Kong from 1995 to 1997 and again from 1998 until she stepped down in 2012, and was not a member during the intervening Provisional Legislative Council.
She took bachelor’s and master’s degrees in philosophy at the University of Hong Kong and a doctorate in philosophy at Boston University, then a law degree at the University of Cambridge and the Postgraduate Certificate in Laws in Hong Kong. She was called to the Bar in 1988. She has said that she spent about ten years on philosophy in Hong Kong and Boston before turning to law in 1981, during the Sino-British negotiations on Hong Kong’s future, and that after call she took an editorial post at Ming Pao rather than entering practice at once, returning to practice in 1990. ChinaFile records her as deputy editor-in-chief of Ming Pao Daily News in 1986–87 and as its publisher from 1988 to 1990, and as the author of more than a dozen books in Chinese.
For 17 years she chaired the Legislative Council’s Panel on Administration of Justice and Legal Services. In late 2002 she was one of the lawyers, with senior counsel Denis Chang, Audrey Eu, Ronny Tong and Alan Leong, who formed the Article 23 Concern Group to oppose a proposed local national-security law under the Hong Kong Basic Law. After that bill was withdrawn, the group became the Article 45 Concern Group, and in March 2006 its members founded the Civic Party.
On 16 April 2021 the District Court sentenced her to 12 months’ imprisonment, suspended for 24 months, over an unauthorised but peaceful assembly on 18 August 2019, in a case that also included Martin Lee and Jimmy Lai. In August 2023 the Court of Appeal set aside her conviction for organising that assembly and left in place the conviction for taking part. On 29 December 2021 police searched her home under a national-security warrant, and, as a former director of Stand News, she was among seven people arrested that day over suspected seditious publications and later released on HK$200,000 cash bail. In 2020 the American Bar Association gave her its International Human Rights Award.
Margaret Ng Ngoi-yee (Chinese: 吳靄儀) was born on 25 January 1948 at her family's home in Tai Wai, then a village in Sha Tin, in the New Territories of Hong Kong. She was the second child. Her grandfather, from Dongguan, had taken part in revolutionary activity with Sun Yat-sen in Guangzhou, fled after being wanted, and opened an eye clinic in Kowloon before moving into Tai Wai, where he and his sons built several houses. Other Ng families in the area included indigenous inhabitants of the New Territories; she said hers was not in a direct line of kinship with them, though there was a connection.
Her father was a seaman. Her mother, brought up in Happy Valley, took the elder daughter to Tai Wai to live with her father-in-law. Ng described three houses—one each for her father and two uncles—with a garden, fields, and a well neighbours used. She lived there until about ten. She called herself a Tai Wai "native" (土著) and a "country girl" (鄉下妹), and said village custom never fully accepted the family, while she did not feel she belonged among city people either. Her mother could read, wore her hair permed, and did not wear a braid, and neighbours turned to her for help. The houses, near the later site of Sin Chi Wan Primary School, were lost when the government resumed the land. A university scholarship she received was tied to the British Army Aid Group; only much later did she learn that it marked her father's undisclosed wartime service with the group in an auxiliary air-force role.
She attended kindergarten in Tai Wai, then Tai Po Government Primary School, recommended by education officials the family knew. The lower years were at Tai Po Old Market and Primary 5 and 6 at a newer campus at Chun Fai Yuen in Tai Po. Her teachers were scholars from mainland China who, she remembered, treated the classroom as a place where Chinese culture had to be kept alive; she concentrated on composition and classical verse, and said a mark of 71 already felt like a disgrace.
After her father came home from sea the family moved to North Point, and the primary-school allocation examination placed her at an English-medium Catholic girls' school that a 2018 profile names as 聖保祿中學. Girls from the school's own kindergarten and primary sat in the A and B classes; allocated entrants, Ng among them, were put in C or D. Coming from a Chinese-medium primary, she said she felt "like a mute," and she sent pieces to The Chinese Student Weekly (《中國學生周報》). In November 1963, aged 15 and in the fifth year, she published there 〈我們不愛國嗎?——一個英文書院學生的自白〉 ("Aren't We Also Patriotic?"), rejecting the charge that pupils at English-medium schools were unpatriotic. An English literature teacher, Mrs Callaghan, had the class read Shakespeare aloud and, in the sixth form, imitate British newspapers.
The Legislative Council's biographical note lists a B.A. and an M.A. from the University of Hong Kong and a Ph.D. from Boston University; a published profile specifies that the degrees were in philosophy. In a statement read in court in April 2021, Ng said indulgent parents had let her spend ten years at university in Hong Kong and then in Boston studying philosophy, where she learned "rigorous intellectual honesty in the pursuit of truth and alleviation of the suffering of mankind."
Writing in 2017 for a volume in honour of Joseph Agassi, she said he had taught in Hong Kong University's philosophy department from 1960 to 1963, that his reputation remained after he left, and that in 1971 she went to Boston University to study with him. She returned to Hong Kong in 1975 after what she called a somewhat unorthodox doctorate, and wrote that she never held a university teaching post and had no significant academic publication in philosophy.
From 1976 to 1979 she worked at the university's Centre of Asian Studies, first as a senior research assistant and then as an administrative assistant, and from 1979 to 1981 as senior assistant academic secretary at the Hong Kong Polytechnic, now the Hong Kong Polytechnic University.
She has dated the switch to law to 1981, when she went to the University of Cambridge to read for a law degree during the Sino-British negotiations over Hong Kong's future, the talks that produced the Sino-British Joint Declaration. Her curriculum vitae dates the Cambridge B.A. course in law to 1982–1984. She then took the Postgraduate Certificate in Laws at the University of Hong Kong and was called to the Hong Kong Bar in 1988, though she did not begin private practice immediately.
Ng’s English-language commentary on Hong Kong public life was already running before she held a newspaper post. The University of Hong Kong Libraries’ Hong Kong Newspaper Clippings Online, compiled for the Department of Political Science and drawn primarily from the South China Morning Post and the Hong Kong Standard, lists 393 clipping records under her name, dated from 1978 to 1997. Separate clippings from 1979, 1982 and 1984 are headed “The Margaret Ng column.” Early signed pieces dealt with immigration, nationality and the approach of 1997, among them “A ‘second class citizen’ is all you will ever be” (11 February 1979) and “The spectre of 1997 hanging over us...” (13 May 1979).
Through the Sino-British talks and the drafting of the Basic Law, the file shows a running argument about passports, elections and how far Beijing’s pledges would bind it. Titles include “Locals must hold Beijing to its Joint Declaration pledges” (31 January 1989), “Fighting for the right to claim a UK passport” (21 March 1989), “A law that gives ICAC the power to gag the press” (5 December 1989) and “The people deserve last say on the Basic Law” (12 December 1989). In the early 1990s, when the catalogue often holds several dozen records a year, the subjects shift to Chris Patten’s governorship, the Legislative Council and the press, as in “Please, Mr Patten, tell us what the words mean” (7 July 1992) and “Shadow over the press” (12 October 1993). A 2005 version of her own site still called her a regular contributor to the South China Morning Post and sorted commentaries under that paper, Ming Pao Daily, Hong Kong Lawyer and Apple Daily. In a 2021 court statement she said that, by the time she was called to the Bar, she already had standing as a political commentator.
The staff appointment came in the middle of that writing. A curriculum vitae she supplied to the Hong Kong Mediation Accreditation Association records her at Ming Pao Daily News from 1986 to 1990, first as deputy chief editor and later as publisher; a ChinaFile contributor note splits the posts into deputy editor-in-chief in 1986–87 and publisher in 1988–90. She was called to the Hong Kong Bar in 1988. She later told a court that she did not go straight into practice: after reading law at the University of Cambridge during the negotiations, she took an editorial post at Ming Pao Daily News because she thought a strong free press essential to Hong Kong’s future, and she returned to the law in 1990.
Before joining the daily she had already written at length for the Chinese monthly associated with the paper. In December 1983, as the talks were being settled, Ming Pao Monthly published “The Forked Path: Compromise or Defiance” (妥協與頑抗——擺在眼前的路). The commentator Lee Yee, introducing a later reprint, read it as a warning not to treat “Hong Kong people ruling Hong Kong” and a high degree of autonomy as secure, on the ground that a Communist Party would not give power away. He quotes her remark that proposals for the future almost all began by saying Hong Kong could never be independent, and reports her conclusion that independence was the only way out, the condition it lacked being that Beijing would not allow it.
The English clippings continue through 1997, overlapping her return to practice and her first years as a legislator, and she went on contributing in Chinese to Ming Pao after leaving the publisher’s chair. On 30 September 2024 the paper ran her article “Kuen, hang in there,” which did not give Chung Pui-kuen’s full name. She wrote that the former Stand News editor had been advised to plead guilty for a shorter sentence but refused, because he wanted to speak clearly about what journalism was, and that he had sat through a long trial in order to leave a public record of how far press freedom reached under the law then in force. The same day, Secretary for Security Chris Tang wrote to Ming Pao’s chief editor calling the piece misleading, accusing her of making a hero of a man convicted after an open trial and of presenting a criminal act as journalistic work, and warning the paper not to let itself be used as a platform for inciting or supporting illegal activity. It was Tang’s second open letter to the paper that month over commentary on the Stand News case.
In 2018 啟思出版社 published 《拱心石下──從政十八年》, listed by Oxford University Press (China) among its humanities titles and later glossed by Ng in English as “Under the Keystone — 18 years in politics.” The title refers to the keystone in an arch of the old Legislative Council building, which the publisher’s note says must sit dead centre if the arch is to hold. It records the legal functional constituency seat she held from 1995 to 2012.
Paperback cover of the 2018 edition of 《拱心石下──從政十八年》.
It follows the handover of the legislature, right-of-abode claims by mainland-born children of Hong Kong residents, Article 23 of the Basic Law, the high-speed railway, and the changing habits of the chamber. 陳文敏’s preface, quoted by the publisher, calls it a political biography and a record of the rule of law over those twenty years. Editor 劉偉成, writing for p-articles, describes a documentary method built from judgments, letters and minutes, and notes that Ng rejected revisions she called unnecessary tears. On 20 June 2019 it was one of eleven titles at the 12th Hong Kong Book Prize, from RTHK and the Hong Kong Publishing Federation; the jury called it a first-person account of crises around the transfer of sovereignty.
In December 2024, 壹壹陸工作室 published The Watching Brief: Annals of a lawmaker from British Colony to China’s SAR (ISBN 9789887029502 hardcover; 9789887029588 paperback). A preface of August 2022 says she rewrote it for non-Chinese readers, under the untried promise of “one country, two systems”, and carried the story through the 2019 extradition protests and her arrest on 18 April 2020 over a march held without police permission.
《不中聽文集——法治篇》 (壹壹陸工作室, August 2021, ISBN 9789887923749) gathers articles and Council speeches, from the 2010 motion on the Chief Justice and a 2012 Court of Final Appeal motion to later pieces on rail-terminus co-location, fugitive surrender and the Umbrella trials, with prefaces by 陳文敏, 陳健民 and 許寶強.
Ng’s writing on Jin Yong began as columns in Ming Pao in the 1980s—his own paper—and was collected as character essays, not as an academic monograph. Ming Chuang Press published 《金庸小說的女子》 in 1989 (187 pages; ISBN 9623570899) and 《金庸小說的男子》 the same year (241 pages). A 2024 preface names two further volumes, 《金庸小說的情》 and 《金庸小說看人生》, more than 150 characters in all, and a 2009 re-editing of the four by 次文化堂. The journalist 鄭明仁 described a complete clipping of the men-and-women serials amounting to 229 pieces.
鄭明仁 quotes her preface: characterisation generally rated first-rate, yet Jin Yong “does not know how to write women,” a “big-man” eye leaving him a layer away even when tender. Jin Yong’s reply puts the gap down to sex, temperament and age: she seemed to want likeable characters, and objected to Yuan Ziyi, Zhou Zhiruo, and the several wives of Duan Zhengchun and Wei Xiaobao. He also praises a fineness he thought men missed, and says he knew of no other criticism devoted to seventy-odd young women, wives, nuns and “demonesses” by one author. The exchange is a disagreement between novelist and columnist, not a ranking of her above other critics. In the 2024 preface she notes that 佟碩之, an early backer of the new-school wuxia of Jin Yong and Liang Yusheng, later accused Jin Yong of confusing right and wrong; she treats that break with a black-and-white frame as part of the novels’ pull.
《誰是大英雄——金庸正邪人物選評》 (壹壹陸工作室, March 2024, ISBN 9789887029519) selects 113 essays on 121 characters from the men and women volumes and sorts them into seven moral classes. An appendix reprints her Ming Pao essay, written after his death in November 2018, separating the novelist from the public man Louis Cha. 《情為何物——金庸小說的情與人生》 (March 2025, ISBN 9789887029540) re-edits the other two volumes, cutting pieces tied to the news of their day. She argues that the plots turn on more than romantic love—Guo Jing’s choice between Huang Rong and Hua Zheng as affection against a promise; Qiao Feng’s refusal of a quiet life with Ah Zhu as the cost of a duty. She writes that she often told him he made love the whole of a woman’s life; he partly agreed, then answered that those women were ancient and had little scope, while a man’s duty there was benevolence and righteousness first.
Margaret Ng was called to the Bar in Hong Kong in 1988. A profile filed with the Hong Kong Mediation Accreditation Association Limited records a law degree at the University of Cambridge in 1982–1984 and the Postgraduate Certificate in Laws at the University of Hong Kong. In a statement read in the District Court on 16 April 2021, she said she had turned to law in 1981, during the Sino-British negotiations, and had not begun practice immediately after call. She took an editorial post at Ming Pao Daily News, which she attributed to the importance of a free press during the transition and to her existing standing as a commentator. The profile and a ChinaFile note place her at the paper from 1986 to 1990, as deputy editor and later publisher, and date her return to practice as a barrister to 1990.
The same profile listed her at Sir Oswald Cheung’s Chambers, 10th floor, New Henry House, 10 Ice House Street, Central, with an email address on the chambers’ domain. It recorded private practice from 1990, overlapping her years in the Legislative Council, a CEDR-accredited mediation course completed in January 2013, and fluency in Cantonese, Mandarin and English. Later judgments style her as counsel rather than Senior Counsel. In August 2026 the Hong Kong Bar Association told the High Court, in papers reported by Hong Kong Free Press, that Ng, then 78, had retired from the profession at the end of 2025.
Published judgments show legally aided criminal appeals and argument on legislative privilege, and a later appearance at a national-security sentencing. In HKSAR v Chan Kam Shing she was instructed by Cheung, Chan & Chung, assigned by the Director of Legal Aid, for a defendant convicted in 2014 of murder and of acting as a triad member. The Court of Appeal heard the leave application on 19 and 20 May 2015 and refused it on 30 June 2015.
In Secretary for Justice v Leung Kwok Hung she represented Leung Kwok-hung, charged with contempt after, on the prosecution case, he took a folder of confidential papers from an under secretary at a joint meeting of two Legislative Council panels on 15 November 2016 and handed it to another member. In the Court of Appeal she led Carter Chim and Jason Lee, instructed by Ho Tse Wai & Partners on legal aid. On 2 June 2020 the court held that section 3 of the Legislative Council (Powers and Privileges) Ordinance did not cover disorderly conduct within the contempt offence in section 17(c), that section 17(c) was constitutional, and that the trial should continue. On the further appeal she appeared with David Pannick, then Queen’s Counsel, again assigned by the Director of Legal Aid, while Chim and Lee acted pro bono. The Court of Final Appeal dismissed the appeal unanimously on 27 September 2021: conduct that is not part of speech or debate attracts no immunity under sections 3 and 4 or article 77 of the Basic Law, and the non-intervention principle does not bar the criminal court.
The reasons for sentence in the Hong Kong 47 case, [2024] HKCFI 3298, dated 19 November 2024, list Margaret Ng with Jason Ko, instructed by Bond Ng Solicitors, for Gary Fan Kwok-wai, a defendant sentenced for conspiracy to commit subversion. In the 2021 statement she said she had come late to the law and had grown old in its service.
Margaret Ng represented the legal functional constituency in the Legislative Council of Hong Kong after the general election of 17 September 1995, and again from the first Legislative Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region through the 2008–2012 term. She was not among the members of the Provisional Legislative Council published by the Council in 1998. That interim body formally ceased work on 30 June 1998, after which the first Legislative Council of the SAR sat.
The legal seat returned one member. In the 1995 arrangements it was one of the pre-existing functional constituencies, each of which, other than Labour, returned a single member. For the Council’s second term, the Legislative Council Ordinance, as set out in the Registration and Electoral Office’s 2000 nomination notes, composed the constituency of members of The Law Society of Hong Kong entitled to vote at the Society’s general meetings, members of the Hong Kong Bar Association entitled to vote at the Association’s general meetings, legal officers, persons appointed under the Legal Aid Ordinance, certain officers deemed to be legal officers, and the Council Secretariat’s legal adviser and qualifying assistants. The rolls in her contests were of individual electors. The Electoral Affairs Commission recorded 3,539 electors on polling day in 1998, 4,181 in 2000, 5,073 in 2004 and 6,111 in 2008.
At the 1995 count the Boundary and Election Commission recorded 723 votes for Ng, 444 for Alfred Donald Yap and 159 for Li Wai-ip, and declared Ng elected. On 24 May 1998 she received 1,741 votes, Sylvia Siu Wing-yee 394 and Francis Chong Wing-charn 138. Turnout that day was 2,320, or 65.56 percent of 3,539 registered electors.
In the 2000 election the government announced 1,520 votes for Ng and 982 for Anthony Chow Wing-kin; the Commission’s results appendix records the same totals and her return. In 2004 she received 2,597 votes, Kwong Ka-yin 598 and Judy Tong Kei-yuk 280, with turnout of 3,666, or 72.26 percent of 5,073 electors. On 7 September 2008 she took 2,468 votes to 1,286 for Junius Ho Kwan-yiu. Turnout was 3,872, or 63.36 percent of 6,111 electors. The Council’s annual report for 2008–09 listed her political affiliation as the Civic Party.
Ng chaired the Panel on Administration of Justice and Legal Services in the 1996–97 session. At its first meeting, on 3 October 1996, members elected her chairman and Andrew Cheng Kar-foo deputy chairman. The post-handover Council formed the panel by a resolution of 8 July 1998 to monitor and examine policy on the administration of justice and legal services, consistently with maintaining the independence of the judiciary and the rule of law. A report tabled on 14 June 2000 recorded that Ng and Jasper Tsang had been elected chairman and deputy chairman of a panel of eight members. Minutes of meetings on 14 October 2008, 14 October 2010 and 13 October 2011, and the panel’s report for 2011–12, again list her as chairman; in the 2011–12 session Priscilla Leung Mei-fun was deputy chairman. That session’s work included continued scrutiny of the administration’s proposals to widen the Supplementary Legal Aid Scheme.
She was deputy chairman of the Committee on Rules of Procedure for the period covered by its progress report from July 2011 to July 2012, with Tam Yiu-chung as chairman. The committee reviews the Council’s Rules of Procedure and its committee system, and examines questions of practice and procedure referred to it.
On legislation, members elected her chairman of the Bills Committee on the Legal Practitioners (Amendment) Bill 1999 at its first meeting on 24 January 2000. She was chairman of the Bills Committee on the Civil Justice (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2007 when it met on 6 July 2007. In 2003 she sat on the Bills Committee on the National Security (Legislative Provisions) Bill, chaired by Ip Kwok-him. The Executive Council had advised that the bill be introduced to implement Article 23 of the Basic Law; it was gazetted on 14 February 2003 and lapsed on 22 July 2004 at the end of the Council’s term.
In June 2012 the South China Morning Post reported that Ng would not seek re-election in September and that Dennis Kwok Wing-hang, a 34-year-old barrister, Civic Party colleague and founding member of the party, was actively considering the legal seat. The government announced on 10 September 2012 that Kwok had been elected with 2,528 votes to 1,970 for Albert Wong Kwai-huen.
Article 23 of the Hong Kong Basic Law requires Hong Kong to “enact laws on its own” against treason, secession, sedition, subversion of the Central People’s Government, theft of state secrets and certain foreign political ties. A Security Bureau paper of September 2002, open for comment until 24 December, called this a practical and legal duty under “one country, two systems”: national security laws had not been extended to Hong Kong because the socialist system was not to be practised there, so the territory should legislate itself, using common-law statutes where it could and staying within Articles 27 and 39. The paper was an outline, not a draft bill, and it proposed new offences, a power to proscribe organisations, and emergency police powers of entry, search and seizure.
The South China Morning Post reported in October 2002 that Ng, the legal-constituency legislator, had issued “seven noes,” including opposition to importing the mainland concept of national security and to wider police powers, and that she wanted a “white bill” so people could comment on actual wording. Late that year she joined senior counsel Denis Chang, Audrey Eu, Ronny Tong and Alan Leong in the Article 23 Concern Group. The government instead introduced the National Security (Legislative Provisions) Bill in February 2003. Ng later said colonial treason and sedition laws were “very draconian” and largely obsolete under the Hong Kong Bill of Rights Ordinance, that subversion, sedition and treason were left unclear, and that even the critics’ amendments would have left “a very threatening piece of legislation.”
On 1 July 2003, the sixth anniversary of the handover, organisers of a march against the bill claimed up to 400,000 people that day; later accounts put the crowd at about 500,000. Premier Wen Jiabao said Article 23 “absolutely will not affect” rights, including those of reporters, and Secretary for Security Regina Ip called such fears “totally unfounded.” In the Legislative Council on 4 July, Ng said the marchers wanted the bill put back and democracy brought forward, and that a law passed against demonstrable opposition “can have no legitimacy.”
Liberal Party legislator James Tien resigned from the Executive Council and withdrew his party’s votes, and Chief Executive Tung Chee-hwa postponed the second reading. Ip, who had resigned citing personal reasons, left on 25 July saying she regretted that the Article 23 work was unfinished and that she had a duty, as a Chinese national, to promote it. On 5 September Tung withdrew the bill. He called legislation a constitutional obligation and “a representation of the Central Government’s trust,” said the community accepted the principle but still doubted the details, and set no timetable so that Hong Kong could concentrate on recovery after SARS.
The lawyers’ group then became the Article 45 Concern Group and pressed for universal suffrage. In March 2006 Ng, Eu, Leong, Tong and others founded the Civic Party, with more than 100 members and six legislators; Eu was its first leader, and it was often called the barristers’ party. It was one group in a wider camp whose largest party was the Democratic Party, criticised by Renmin Ribao in 2003 for “distorting facts.” The League of Social Democrats, formed the same year, took a more confrontational line, while the Liberal Party remained pro-business and outside the camp.
In 2007 Leong became the first pro-democracy nominee in the small-circle chief executive election, debating Donald Tsang and taking 123 votes to Tsang’s 649. The camp divided in 2010, when the Civic Party and the League resigned five legislators—including Leong, Tanya Chan, Leung Kwok-hung, Raymond Wong and Albert Chan—to force by-elections they called a referendum on abolishing functional constituencies. The five were returned without pro-Beijing opponents. Critics called the poll a waste of money; the Democratic Party refused to join and negotiated with the government instead, and all five Civic Party legislators, Ng among them, voted against the package that resulted.
Ng was not among the defendants when, in 2021, four former members—Alvin Yeung, Kwok Ka-ki, Jeremy Tam and Lee Yue-shun—were charged with conspiracy to commit subversion over an unofficial primary and urged the party to disband. Members voted to dissolve it on 27 May 2023.
Articles 45 and 68 make universal suffrage for the chief executive and for every legislator an “ultimate aim,” to be reached gradually “in the light of the actual situation,” with the chief executive nominated by a broadly representative committee and appointed in Beijing. On 29 December 2007 the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress ruled out that aim for 2012, kept an equal split between functional and geographical seats, and said the chief executive might be elected by universal suffrage in 2017 and, after that, the whole legislature might be.
The 2012 package enlarged the chief executive election committee from 800 to 1,200 and the legislature from 60 to 70, still half functional and half geographical. Tsang said the Executive Council had accepted a Democratic Party change under which the five new functional seats would be nominated by elected district councillors and chosen by voters who had no other functional vote. He said the change fitted the Basic Law and the 2007 decision, and that the original plan lacked the 40 LegCo votes required. Ng said functional seats could be pressed toward pro-Beijing positions, and that “we must have a roadmap to genuine universal suffrage which abolish all functional constituencies.”
In 2017 the dispute shifted to a joint checkpoint for the Guangzhou–Shenzhen–Hong Kong Express Rail Link. Chief Executive Carrie Lam said it should not be politicised, and that Hong Kong would “fall quickly behind” if it stayed off the national high-speed network. Ng, in a Co-location Concern Group of legislators and academics, replied that it was “not just mine, but everyone’s concern,” citing bookseller Lam Wing-kee. She contrasted Shenzhen Bay, where Hong Kong law applied outside the boundary, with mainland law inside Hong Kong, and set minutes saved on a journey against “life under the continued protection of Hong Kong—rather than mainland—laws.” The government said both sides had required consistency with “one country, two systems” and the Basic Law, and that convenience alone would not justify a breach. It pointed to a Standing Committee decision of 27 December 2017 and argued that mainland law would be confined to a port area deemed to lie on the mainland, not applied across Hong Kong under Article 18.
On 18 April 2020, Hong Kong police arrested 15 pro-democracy figures, including the barrister Margaret Ng, on allegations of unlawful assembly. Local media reported that the allegations concerned unapproved protests on 18 August, 1 October and 20 October 2019; the case later tried against Ng was the procession of 18 August.
Demonstrators with umbrellas fill a street and a footbridge in heavy rain during the 18 August 2019 Hong Kong procession.
The Civil Human Rights Front had notified police of a meeting in Victoria Park, a procession to Chater Road and a further assembly; police allowed only the park meeting, an appeal board upheld the objection to the rest, and a procession left the park on the banned route anyway. In HKSAR v Lai Chee Ying and Others (DCCC 536/2020), Ng was tried in the District Court with Jimmy Lai, Lee Cheuk-yan, Leung Kwok-hung, Cyd Ho, Albert Ho, Leung Yiu-chung, Martin Lee and Au Nok-hin. Under the Public Order Ordinance they faced organising an unauthorised assembly and knowingly taking part in one, contrary to sections 17A(3)(b)(i) and 17A(3)(a). The contesting defendants denied the charges, saying they were dispersing the crowd under a “water flow” plan and that the offences disproportionately limited assembly; the prosecution called the march planned and sought a deterrent sentence.
On 1 April 2021 Judge Amanda Woodcock convicted the seven who had pleaded not guilty of both counts; Au had pleaded guilty to both, and Leung Yiu-chung to participation only. She found that they had led it under a banner, that the dispersal account circumvented the ban, and that the march, though peaceful, disrupted traffic and carried a latent risk of violence; freedom of assembly under the Hong Kong Basic Law, she held, was not absolute.
Before sentence Ng discharged her counsel and read a statement, later published by Hong Kong Free Press, saying the rule of law had to be defended in the streets as well as in court and the Legislative Council, and that she had to stand with people she called peace-loving and well-disciplined. Adapting words associated with Thomas More, she concluded: “I stand the law’s good servant but the people’s first. For the law must serve the people, not the people the law.” On 16 April 2021 Woodcock rejected fines in favour of deterrence. For Ng, then 73, she cited age, good character and public service and imposed 12 months for organising and nine months for taking part, concurrent, suspended for 24 months. The others received between eight and 18 months, immediate for Lai, Lee Cheuk-yan, Leung Kwok-hung, Cyd Ho and Au, and suspended for Martin Lee, Albert Ho and Leung Yiu-chung.
On 14 August 2023 the Court of Appeal quashed the organising convictions and those sentences, and upheld the convictions for knowingly taking part. It held that a place at the front with a banner was not evidence of organisation, that the “water flow” account was a ruse, and that section 17A was constitutional. Ng, Martin Lee and Albert Ho had appealed conviction only, so Ng’s remaining sentence was the nine-month participation term, suspended for 24 months from 16 April 2021; immediate terms for the others were reduced to their participation sentences.
On 12 August 2024 the Court of Final Appeal unanimously dismissed the appeals in [2024] HKCFA 24, limited to whether two United Kingdom Supreme Court decisions required an “operational proportionality” review before conviction. Chief Justice Andrew Cheung and Mr Justice Ribeiro held that they should not be followed, and that no further review was required once the offence was valid and knowing participation proved.
Ng was a trustee of the 612 Humanitarian Relief Fund, formed in June 2019 to pay legal, medical and other costs of people arrested or injured, with Cardinal Joseph Zen, Cyd Ho, the scholar Hui Po-keung and the singer Denise Ho; Sze Ching-wee was secretary. The fund announced its dissolution in August 2021. In May 2022 national security police arrested the trustees on suspicion of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces under the Hong Kong national security law; they were bailed, and by November no such charge had been laid.
The charge that was tried arose under the Societies Ordinance. On 25 November 2022 Principal Magistrate Ada Yim convicted all six of failing, from 16 July 2019 to 31 October 2021, to apply to register the fund or seek exemption, contrary to section 5C(1). She held that the fund was political rather than a purely charitable trust, that the defendants were office-bearers, and that registration did not disproportionately restrict association, and fined each trustee HK$4,000 and Sze HK$2,500. Ng said the case, which she described as the first of its kind, concerned freedom of association beyond the six defendants.
On 3 September 2026 the Court of Appeal (Jeremy Poon CJHC, Barma JA and Pang JA) dismissed the trustees’ appeals in HCMA 446/2022. It held that the fund, under a trust deed of 28 June 2019, was a society—with common purposes, a governing structure and mutual obligations—whose trustees were office-bearers, and that registration was a proportionate limit on association for which an honest-belief defence was unavailable. Ng said the five would seek leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal, because requiring people who come together to register with the police, or to seek exemption, would affect civil society widely; by early October 2026 the applications were listed as forthcoming.
On 29 December 2021 national security police arrested Ng, a former director of Stand News, and six others on suspicion of conspiracy to publish seditious publications under the Crimes Ordinance, raided the newsroom and froze about HK$61 million; the outlet then closed. The next day the parent company and former editors Chung Pui-kuen and Patrick Lam were charged with conspiracy to publish or reproduce seditious publications and refused bail, while Ng and three other former directors were released on police bail without charge.
The Hong Kong Bar Association referred to a Barristers Disciplinary Tribunal a complaint that Ng’s assembly conviction was misconduct, and also inquired into Martin Lee over the same case. On 8 June 2026 a three-member tribunal held by a majority that the complaint against Ng was not substantiated. Reports of the reasons said the majority found her criminality not so “morally culpable, disgraceful or dishonourable” as to bring the profession into disrepute or diminish public confidence in it.
In August 2026 the association sought judicial review (HCAL 1407/2026) of that decision, with the tribunal as respondent and Ng, who had retired at the end of 2025, as an interested party. It argued that the conviction was itself misconduct under the Code of Conduct, citing Woodcock’s finding that the defendants had flouted the law and challenged police authority, and said the tribunal had wrongly downplayed the link with practice because Ng had spent most of her time on politics. It asked the court to quash the decision and find the complaint proved; reporting of the filing said that, even if successful, only a private admonishment would be sought. On 10 September 2026 a High Court judge granted leave, listing the hearing for 9 November 2026.
In 2019 the International Bar Association jointly gave Ng and Martin Lee its award for an outstanding contribution by a legal practitioner to human rights, the first time the prize, conferred since 1995, had been shared..pdf) The Hong Kong Bar Association said it recognised their "tireless dedication to the protection of human rights and the pursuit of justice" in Hong Kong..pdf) The award was presented on 26 September 2019 at the association's conference in Seoul..pdf) Ng and Lee said they accepted it not for themselves but for members of the Hong Kong Bar "doing their absolute best in upholding the rule of law in the very trying circumstances in Hong Kong.".pdf) IBA president Horacio Bernardes Neto called that commitment admirable "particularly given the current state of unrest.".pdf)
The American Bar Association lists Margaret Ngoi-Yee Ng as the 2020 recipient of its International Human Rights Award. Its note on past recipients describes her as a barrister, journalist and former politician active in opposition to the 2019 extradition bill, which would have allowed Hong Kong to detain and transfer people wanted in places with no formal extradition agreement, including Taiwan and mainland China. In April 2021, after Ng and six others were sentenced over assemblies held since 2019, ABA president Patricia Lee Refo cited that award and said the convictions threatened the rule of law.
At the Seoul ceremony she said that in 18 years in the Legislative Council, before and after the handover, "we had only one mission in mind: ensuring the safe transition of the rule of law," and that she "came to democracy reluctantly" because "unless we fight for democracy, there is no protection for freedom." Calling herself "only one of the worker bees," she added that written guarantees would not preserve freedom after Hong Kong was "handed over to one of the world's largest totalitarian regimes."
Official and pro-establishment commentary has treated the same record as unlawful politics. On 21 April 2020, after police arrested Ng among 15 people on suspicion of unlawful assembly, a spokesman for the Hong Kong and Macao Affairs Office of the State Council called the arrests ordinary, evidence-based enforcement to uphold the rule of law, order and social justice. He accused the United States and the United Kingdom of treating "illegal assemblies" as free speech while ignoring what he said was their turn to extreme violence.
On 9 August 2018 Wen Wei Po, drawing on a BBC Chinese interview, highlighted an early-1980s essay in which Ng wrote that keeping Hong Kong's special rights, freedom and autonomy left "only one feasible path, and that is independence." Lawyers and a legislator quoted by the paper accused her of distorting the Basic Law and beautifying talk of independence. In the interview she said a proposed ban on the Hong Kong National Party had no legal basis; the BBC also reported her line that "1,000 reasons to oppose Hong Kong independence do not constitute one reason to prohibit discussion" of it.
How the record is sourced and how the score is derived.
The score is formula-derived (Factrail formula v1, version 1.0.0), not an editorial verdict. Read the methodology.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Dispute a fact on this pageNamed here, or represent someone who is? Request a right of reply.
Linked because the text names them, not because anything was measured.
People and organizations as listed in the Related section of this page; facts, drivers and the pages that name it as listed in the blocks here. Counts, not a rating.