Skip to content
eventVerified

2018 Chemnitz protests

2018 Chemnitz protests

Summary

The 2018 Chemnitz protests were several days of far-right marches, street clashes and counter-gatherings in the city in Saxony, beginning on 26 August 2018 after a man was stabbed to death during a fight on the sidelines of the city festival.

Expert article

The 2018 Chemnitz protests were several days of far-right marches, street clashes and counter-gatherings in the city in Saxony, beginning on 26 August 2018 after a man was stabbed to death during a fight on the sidelines of the city festival. Daniel Hillig, a 35-year-old carpenter whose mother was German and whose father was Cuban, was stabbed in the early hours of that Sunday and died in hospital of wounds to the heart and lungs. Two other men who were with him, then aged 33 and 38, were seriously injured. Police dismissed online rumors that Hillig had been defending a woman from sexual assault. A 23-year-old Syrian and a 22-year-old Iraqi were suspected of the killing; investigators said the stabbing was not self-defense, and the two were charged with manslaughter. The Syrian defendant, Alaa Sheikhi, was later convicted, while the Iraqi suspect was not tried and was reported to have left Germany.

On the evening of 26 August a call by far-right football hooligans drew roughly 800 people, and video from the edge of the march showed demonstrators chasing people they took to be foreigners. Police received complaints from a German teenager and her Afghan companion who said they had been attacked, from a Syrian man who said he had been beaten, and from a Bulgarian man who said he had been held and threatened. The next day a rally associated with the right-wing group Pro Chemnitz brought about 6,000 people by the police count, with about 1,500 people in a counter-protest. About 600 officers kept the sides apart until around 9 p.m., when fireworks, bottles and other objects were thrown; police used pepper spray and brought in two water cannon, and as many as 18 protesters and two officers were injured. Several demonstrators gave Nazi salutes, a criminal offence in Germany, and police opened at least ten preliminary proceedings. Saxony’s domestic intelligence service had described an organized right-wing scene in Chemnitz that included hooligan groups around the local football club, and the anti-Islam movement Pegida encouraged demonstrations that weekend in a state that was already a stronghold of the Alternative for Germany.

Chancellor Angela Merkel said there should be no rioting in any square or street, and federal justice minister Katarina Barley said there must not again be “hounding and vigilantism.” Saxony’s minister-president Michael Kretschmer called the far right’s political use of the killing “heinous.” Government spokesman Steffen Seibert described film of people being chased as a Hetzjagd, a hunt. On 3 September a free concert under the slogan “Wir sind mehr” (“We are more”), moved from the Karl Marx monument to make room for a larger crowd, drew tens of thousands; Deutsche Welle reported attendance of between 50,000 and 65,000, and a city estimate published that evening put the crowd at as many as 50,000. The bill included Die Toten Hosen and the Chemnitz band Kraftklub, and the program opened with a minute of silence for Hillig.

The coalition crisis that followed turned on Hans-Georg Maaßen, president of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution. In comments to Bild he doubted that hunts had taken place and questioned the authenticity of video from Chemnitz, contradicting Merkel’s account of the protests. Interior minister Horst Seehofer defended him while the Social Democrats demanded that he go, and on 18 September the government announced that Maaßen would leave the agency to become a state secretary in the interior ministry, a grade German media described as a promotion. In a speech in Warsaw on 18 October he told European intelligence chiefs that the hunts “were made up.” On 5 November Seehofer said Maaßen would be retired from all offices immediately and would not take up the ministry post.

On 22 August 2019 a court sentenced Sheikhi, then 24, to nine and a half years in prison for joint manslaughter and serious physical injury. He denied responsibility, telling the court he hoped the truth would come out, and he had said in an interview that he fled the scene without touching Hillig or the knife. The second suspect, the Iraqi man, remained at large.

Background

City and region

Chemnitz was the smallest of Saxony’s three independent cities at the end of 2017, with 246,855 residents against 581,980 in Leipzig and 551,072 in Dresden. Foreign nationals numbered 18,310 in the city, about 7.4 percent, and 185,737 in Saxony, about 4.6 percent of 4,081,308 people. On 10 May 1953 the ruling party of the German Democratic Republic renamed the industrial city Karl-Marx-Stadt without a popular vote.

The Karl Marx Monument on Brückenstraße is a bronze bust more than 7.1 metres high, by the Soviet sculptor Lev Kerbel, unveiled on 9 October 1971. It was a stop for GDR 1 May demonstrations and, in autumn 1989, for the Monday demonstrations. After a survey in which more than 76 percent favoured the historic name, the city became Chemnitz again on 1 June 1990; the bust, locally the “Nischel,” remained a listed monument and a backdrop for political statements. In late August 2018 the centre hosted the Stadtfest for the city’s 875th anniversary, with stages along Brückenstraße, about 200 stalls and an expected attendance above 200,000 from Friday through Sunday.

Organized far right before August 2018

A militant scene around Chemnitzer FC predated the newer protest groups. One perpetrator in the 1999 killing of 17-year-old Patrick Thürmer, attacked on the way home from a punk festival near the city, belonged to HooNaRa (“Hooligans, Nazis, Racists”), which formally dissolved in 2007; former members said the network could still assemble quickly. The NS-Boys, formed in 2004 with about 50 people and a Hitler Youth image as a logo, and Kaotic Chemnitz, whose wider circle was put at about 100, were barred from displaying themselves in the stadium, though members still attended matches. In March 2014 Saxony banned Nationale Sozialisten Chemnitz, a core of 14 people that the interior ministry said wanted a state modelled on historical National Socialism and that had, under changing names, rallied against an initial reception centre for asylum seekers.

Saxony’s 2017 domestic-intelligence report put the state’s right-wing extremist potential at about 2,600 people, roughly half assessed as violence-oriented, and described a continuing decline of the National Democratic Party of Germany. The same account recorded growth in the small neo-Nazi party Der III. Weg, from about 60 to about 90 members, and about 40 people in Saxony for the Identitarian movement. In Dresden, Pegida—Patriotic Europeans Against the Islamisation of the West—had marched weekly since October 2014 and drew a reported 25,000 people on 12 January 2015. In Chemnitz, Pro Chemnitz, founded in 2009 by Martin Kohlmann, a former Republikaner councillor, and Reinhold Breede, a former Christian Democratic Union member, again won three council seats in 2014 and stayed under about 6 percent; it was not in the 2017 intelligence report. At the September 2017 federal election the Alternative for Germany took 27.0 percent of second votes in Saxony, 0.1 points ahead of the CDU and 20.3 points above 2013.

Immigration and crime in public debate

The dispute was national. During the 2015 European migrant crisis, Chancellor Angela Merkel said on 31 August 2015, “Wir schaffen das” (“we can do this”). The Federal Office for Migration and Refugees recorded 476,649 asylum applications in 2015, 745,545 in 2016 and 222,683 in 2017. At the end of 2017 about 10.6 million residents of Germany held only foreign citizenship, 5.8 percent more than a year earlier, a rise back near the pace of 2013.

The New Year’s Eve sexual assaults of 2015–16, centred on Cologne, became the sharpest exhibit for a link between asylum and street crime. A Federal Criminal Police Office draft reported in July 2016 counted more than 1,200 victims of sexual offences that night, about 650 of them women in Cologne, and estimated that about 2,000 men had taken part, 120 of them identified; more than half of those identified had been in Germany for less than a year. In the 2017 police crime statistics, people without German citizenship were 599,357 of 1,974,805 suspects once immigration-law offences were excluded, about 30 percent, while recorded crime overall was the lowest since 1992. A separate count found 167,268 suspects in a narrower “Zuwanderer” category—asylum seekers, recognised refugees, people with a tolerated stay and people present without permission—slightly fewer than in 2016, and noted that most people in the category were not suspects. These are police suspects, not convictions, and “non-German” includes EU citizens and visitors. Chemnitz and Saxony, at about 7.4 and 4.6 percent foreign nationals, were not the parts of the country with the largest immigrant populations; the figures both sides cited were federal.

Killing of Daniel Hillig

The stabbing

In the early hours of 26 August 2018, during Chemnitz’s street festival, a fight broke out on Brückenstraße in Saxony. Police said that at about 3:15 a.m. several people of different nationalities went from words to blows and that three men were injured, some seriously. Daniel Hillig, 35—a carpenter and a German with Cuban roots, identified by authorities and most German media only as Daniel H.—died in hospital that night; two other men were seriously hurt. Organizers closed the festival at 4 p.m. rather than 8. Investigators treated the case as suspected manslaughter (Totschlag), not murder (Mord). State police president Jürgen Georgie said on 28 August that two groups of men had fought and that knives were used; prosecutors said there had been no self-defence.

The indictment filed on 8 January 2019 alleged that the Syrian national Alaa S. and the Iraqi national Farhad R. A., still at large and also carrying a knife, acted together without lawful justification. Alaa S. was accused of stabbing Daniel H. four times in the chest and once in the upper arm, and Dimitri M. once in the back, while at least accepting the risk of killing both. Daniel H. suffered punctures of the heart and a lung and died immediately, the indictment said; Dimitri M.’s stab, about 3 to 4 centimetres deep on the left side of his back, was potentially life-threatening. Prosecutors said Farhad R. A. argued with Daniel H. and fell in a scuffle, after which Alaa S. came from a nearby döner shop and joined him. They had not established what the argument was about.

Suspects and the investigation

Officers stopped two men leaving the scene: Alaa S., then 23, and a 22-year-old Iraqi, called Yousif A. or Jussif A. in the press and later Yousif I. A. by prosecutors. On 27 August the Chemnitz district court issued arrest warrants against both for joint manslaughter. On 18 September it lifted the warrant against Yousif I. A. Prosecutor Ingrid Burghart said no witness had seen him stab anyone, his DNA was not on a knife found between the scene and the arrest, and no objective trace tied him to the killing. His lawyer, Ulrich Dost-Roxin, said a witness placed him metres away. Prosecutors then named Alaa S. and a fugitive Iraqi, Farhad A.; in January they dated the detention to 15 September and left Yousif I. A.’s case separate and undecided.

On 4 September, Saxony’s attorney general, Hans Strobl, announced a warrant and a public search for Farhad Ramazan A., a 22-year-old Iraqi asylum seeker named by witnesses and by one of the other suspects. The Interior Ministry said Alaa S.’s identity was still being checked: he had been recognized as a refugee in September 2015 on his own statements.

In August 2019 the Chemnitz regional court, sitting in Dresden for security reasons, convicted Alaa S. of joint manslaughter and dangerous bodily harm (gefährliche Körperverletzung) and sentenced him to nine years and six months. Presiding judge Simone Herberger said he and the still-fugitive Farhad A. attacked Daniel H. beside the festival, and that Alaa S. stabbed him in the abdomen. The trial is covered later.

The victim’s family and early rumors

Hillig left a wife and a child. Early reporting found no sign that he supported a right-wing group. His Facebook profile “liked” pages of Die Linke and anti-fascist groups, and had written, of Nazis, that the city still had “too many of those cranks.” Spiegel found friends divided: one urged people to demonstrate and “clean up” the city; another wrote that Daniel would be appalled at attempts to instrumentalize his death.

On 28 August, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung reporters described candles and flowers where he had collapsed, a few hundred metres from the Karl Marx Monument. They wrote that right-wing groups were using his death while the crime and the victim went largely undiscussed.

Bild and Tag24 first reported that the fight followed a sexual harassment, then said police could not confirm it. That afternoon Saxony police said nothing indicated harassment had come first. Burghart told Correctiv there were “absolutely no indications” of it, and interviews had not described it; officials also rejected a claim that Hillig had been defending a woman from rape. On 27 August police wrote that, contrary to rumours, there was no second death. The wife of one injured survivor told the Freie Presse the groups had quarrelled over cigarettes; the indictment did not adopt that.

Street demonstrations

26 and 27 August

On 26 and 27 August 2018, assemblies in Chemnitz drew football ultras, far-right activists and crowds larger than Saxony police had staffed. Officers logged assaults, missiles and illegal salutes, and video of people being chased fed a dispute over whether there had been “hunts.”

On Sunday 26 August, police said online calls brought people downtown. A gathering of about 100 around 15:00, which Der Spiegel reported the Alternative for Germany had called, stayed peaceful. A second assembly at 16:30, attributed by the Freie Presse to the right-wing ultra group Kaotic Chemnitz, drew about 800 on the police count; its appeal, as reported in the press, was to show “who has the say in this city.” About 50 officers were present at the start, the Freie Presse reported, with reinforcements later from Dresden and Leipzig. Police said the crowd ignored them and moved off suddenly. Witnesses told Spiegel that marchers broke a cordon and that a hard core sprinted at people who “did not look German.” A police spokeswoman would neither confirm nor deny a hunt, saying there had “certainly” been contact with bystanders and that video was still under review. The city ended its festival early. Police were handling four complaints: assaults reported by a person from Germany and one from Syria, a threat reported by a Bulgarian national, and resistance to officers. Deutsche Welle added complaints from a 15-year-old German and her 17-year-old Afghan companion, an 18-year-old Syrian who said he was beaten, and a 30-year-old Bulgarian who said he was threatened.

On Monday 27 August, Pro Chemnitz had registered a march for about 1,000 people from the Karl Marx Monument, and Die Linke a rally for about 500. Police counted about 6,000 and about 1,500, including arrivals from several states whom they placed in “the right-wing spectrum and the violence-prone football scene.” Five hundred and ninety-one officers tried to keep the sides apart. The Pro Chemnitz column left without agreeing the move with police, Spiegel reported; some chanted “Wir sind das Volk,” fireworks and bottles were thrown, and reporters were insulted. From that assembly police documented unconstitutional slogans and Hitler salutes and opened ten investigations for use of unconstitutional symbols. A larger group reached and attacked counter-demonstrators until officers used force and two water cannons. Eighteen demonstrators and two officers were injured. Forty-three complaints included two for breach of the peace, eleven for assault, the ten symbol cases and three under the state assembly law. After the rallies, police said about 200 masked people with sticks attacked departing participants in Hartmannstraße, injuring at least two. Federal interior minister Horst Seehofer offered federal police support.

Rallies in the following week

On Thursday 30 August, about 900 people followed another Pro Chemnitz call during a citizens’ dialogue with minister-president Michael Kretschmer and mayor Barbara Ludwig. The federal government later said the party Die Rechte had also mobilized for that rally.

On Saturday 1 September, AfD associations and Pegida called a march whose invitation, Deutsche Welle reported, mourned “the dead and victims of illegal migration policy.” People from a separate Pro Chemnitz event joined it. Assembly authorities first counted about 4,500 on the AfD–Pegida march and nearly 4,000 at a “Herz statt Hetze” counter-gathering. Police later put the AfD, Pegida and Pro Chemnitz events at about 8,000 and the counter-gathering at about 3,000, 11,000 in all. Björn Höcke took part. ARD’s Monitor, as reported by taz, also placed Pegida’s Lutz Bachmann there with Götz Kubitschek and Martin Sellner of the Austrian Identitarian movement, in a crowd it put at about 6,000. About 1,800 officers, including water cannons, mounted police and armored vehicles, with support from other states and the federal police, were deployed; police later said the situation was in hand. Interior minister Roland Wöller called the day largely peaceful, though some arrivals had come intending trouble.

The federal government told the Bundestag that the National Democratic Party of Germany, Der III. Weg and Die Rechte had posted calls for the 1 September rally, and that a leading figure of the Austrian Identitarians had urged attendance. It estimated that about 20 to 30 percent of participants on 26, 27 and 30 August and at that rally were right-wing extremists, including NPD members and its Junge Nationalisten youth wing, and that most were not. Open calls for 26 and 27 August, it said, came mainly from outside the extremist spectrum, and it reported no findings, in the sense of the question, on who joined the AfD–Pegida demonstration itself. Police revised an early count of nine injured and at least 25 offenses to 18 injured, three of them officers, and at least 37 complaints, including assault, property damage, resistance, unconstitutional symbols and assembly-law breaches. Four masked people lightly injured a 20-year-old Afghan man away from the rallies; an MDR crew was attacked in a flat; and SPD deputy Sören Bartol said a visitors’ group was beaten on the way to its bus. Investigations were opened, including for dangerous bodily harm.

Violence, salutes and alleged hunts

Government spokesman Steffen Seibert said the cabinet would not accept “mobs, hunts on people of another appearance or origin, or the attempt to spread hatred in the streets.” Chancellor Angela Merkel said there was footage “that there were hunts, that there were mobs, that there was hatred in the street,” incompatible with the constitutional state. Kretschmer answered that there had been “no mob, no hunt and no pogroms in Chemnitz,” and called far-right use of the killing “abhorrent.”

Senior prosecutor Wolfgang Klein, of the Dresden general prosecutor’s office, said “hunt” is not a legal term. In film reviewed so far he found “no hunt”—several people chasing someone through the city to beat them—while saying the review was unfinished. His office, which took over the Monday demonstration, was limited to the rally; other city incidents belonged to local prosecutors and police. The footage was then disputed: domestic-intelligence chief Hans-Georg Maaßen told Bild he had no reliable information that hunts had occurred and, without evidence, suggested one video might be deliberate misinformation. The federal prosecutor opened observation proceedings on 26 and 27 August and on 1 September; the government said in November 2018 that those inquiries were still open.

Counter-mobilization

Counter-demonstrations

Street counter-protests in Chemnitz began while the first large marches were still under way. On 27 August police said about 1,500 people joined a left-oriented demonstration, against about 6,000 on a march called by Pro Chemnitz, with roughly 600 officers trying to keep the sides apart.

The main counter-rally of the next weekend was “Herz statt Hetze” (“heart instead of hate”) on 1 September, called by the alliance “Chemnitz nazifrei.” The Süddeutsche Zeitung described the organizers as trade unions, parties, cultural workers, Chemnitzer FC and private individuals. It occupied a car park in front of the Johanniskirche, with short sets by Madsen and Egotronic. Speakers included Annalena Baerbock of Alliance 90/The Greens, Dietmar Bartsch of Die Linke, several figures from the Social Democratic Party and mayor Barbara Ludwig; Saxony CDU general secretary Alexander Dierks had joined the appeal. People came from Dresden, Leipzig and Berlin.

Counts differed by source and timing. Spiegel, citing police, reported about 9,500 people across the day’s protests, about 3,500 of them at “Herz statt Hetze,” and about 1,800 officers drawn from across Germany. The assembly authority put the counter-rally at about 3,500 and the combined march of the Alternative for Germany, Pegida and Pro Chemnitz at about 4,500. Counter-demonstrators blocked the route registered for the AfD march, which was then called off, while police repeatedly separated the camps. Saxon police later said 18 people were injured, including three officers, and that at least 37 possible offences were under examination. An MDR crew was also assaulted.

On 2 September the Protestant church district held a rally on the Neumarkt, “Wir in Chemnitz – aufeinander hören, miteinander handeln.” The Evangelical Church in Germany reported about 1,000 people, including minister-president Michael Kretschmer and regional bishop Carsten Rentzing. The call was backed by the theatre, business chambers, the trade-union confederation, the Jewish community, Caritas and the Saxon Refugee Council. The church district condemned what it called the violent use of the killing by radical demonstrators.

On 7 September police counted about 1,000 people at a further “Chemnitz nazifrei” rally, twice the number registered, and about 2,350 at the parallel Pro Chemnitz event. A spokeswoman called the evening “almost free of disturbances”: six masking offences, no injuries, and barriers held by Saxon police with reinforcements from six other states and the federal police. The same night the city’s cultural institutions filled 4,500 seats, plus several hundred standing places, for an open-air performance of Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony, presented against xenophobia and violence.

The “Wir sind mehr” concert

The largest gathering was a free concert on 3 September. Felix Brummer of the Chemnitz band Kraftklub called other musicians after the marches; the acts said they had agreed the show within about 24 hours. Under the slogan “Wir sind mehr” (“we are more”), a post for the event said racism should not go unchallenged in the streets and that people attacked by neo-Nazis should see they were not alone.

The concert had been planned near the Karl Marx Monument and was moved to the square and car park by the Johanniskirche when the crowd grew; DJs also played at the monument. It opened in the late afternoon with a minute’s silence for the man who had been killed. The bill included Trettmann, Feine Sahne Fischfilet, K.I.Z, Kraftklub, Marteria and Casper, and Die Toten Hosen. Expectations beforehand ran from about 10,000 to around 30,000. The city of Chemnitz estimated about 65,000, the figure given by tagesschau, the BBC and CNN; reporting earlier that evening had put an official estimate as high as 50,000. Police said 5,000 people arrived by train from Leipzig alone.

Campino of Die Toten Hosen said the evening was not a contest of left against right but a stand against a “far-right mob,” and that staying non-violent would be a clear win. A police spokeswoman said the area around the concert was free of disturbances, and the Neue Zürcher Zeitung reported that police called the evening calm and peaceful. The assembly authority banned further spontaneous rallies in the centre, including one by the Thuringian Pegida group Thügida. Organizers later said donations came to €22,106.41, half for the dead man’s family and the rest split between “Chemnitz nazifrei” and the counselling group RAA Sachsen. CDU general secretary Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer criticized President Frank-Walter Steinmeier for publicizing the concert, because Feine Sahne Fischfilet had for a time been monitored by the domestic intelligence service in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern over lyrics about violence against police.

Government and the Maaßen affair

Official and party responses

On 27 August 2018, the day after the demonstrations in Chemnitz, government spokesman Steffen Seibert said the federal government would not accept "Zusammenrottungen, Hetzjagden auf Menschen anderen Aussehens, anderer Herkunft" — gatherings and hunts aimed at people of a different appearance or origin — or attempts to spread hatred in the streets. He called the killing terrible, said police were working to bring suspects to court, and, answering a tweet by Alternative for Germany Bundestag member Markus Frohnmaier, said Germany had no place for vigilante justice, intolerance or extremism. On 30 August he added that mobs, hate speech and threats against people who looked different had nothing to do with mourning or protest.

Chancellor Angela Merkel took the same line on 28 August, saying video showed hunts, gatherings and hatred in the street, "und das hat mit unserem Rechtsstaat nichts zu tun", and that such riots must not occur anywhere. The government said Interior Minister Horst Seehofer had offered federal police to Saxony if the state asked.

The Christian Democratic Union did not speak with one voice. On 5 September Saxony's minister-president Michael Kretschmer told the Landtag that right-wing extremism was the greatest danger to democracy, but that there had been "keinen Mob", "keine Hetzjagd" and "keine Pogrome". People angry about the killing were not, he said, right-wing extremists; those who had joined the riots would be opposed. Merkel said the same day that the pictures had shown hatred and the pursuit of innocent people, and that this answered AfD co-leader Jörg Meuthen's call for an apology and for Seibert's dismissal.

Seehofer, chairman of the Christian Social Union, criticised assessments made before reliable information was available, and in a Rheinische Post interview called migration "die Mutter aller politischen Probleme". He said outrage at the killing was understandable and that, were he not a minister, he would have demonstrated as a citizen — "natürlich nicht gemeinsam mit Radikalen" — while insisting on zero tolerance for incitement or violence, including against police. Saxony's Social Democratic deputy minister-president Martin Dulig said refugees had been driven through the city. Social Democratic Party leader Andrea Nahles said Seehofer's remarks, and those of the domestic-intelligence chief, cast doubt on their fitness to protect the constitution; general secretary Lars Klingbeil called the migration phrase right-wing-populist talk. AfD co-leader Alexander Gauland said Seehofer was right about the effects of the asylum crisis.

Hans-Georg Maaßen and the coalition crisis

On 7 September Hans-Georg Maaßen, president of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, told Bild that the service had no reliable information that hunts had taken place, that there was no proof a widely circulated video of an alleged incident was authentic, and that there were good reasons to regard it as "gezielte Falschinformation", possibly meant to distract the public from the killing.

Senior Social Democrats demanded evidence or his removal: Thomas Oppermann pointed to Hitler salutes and attacks; Ralf Stegner called the post untenable; Klingbeil said a service chief who contradicted the chancellor had to produce proof. Anton Hofreiter of Alliance 90/The Greens said the claims had to be proved. For Die Linke, Thuringia's minister-president Bodo Ramelow said that without evidence the comments sided with Pegida and the AfD. Gauland called the accusations politically motivated. Dresden senior prosecutor Wolfgang Klein told Zeit Online there was no sign the video was a fake and that investigators were using it; Saxon interior minister Roland Wöller said the prosecutor general nonetheless had no findings of hunts or of pursuits across the city.

Seehofer required a written account. The paper of 10 September said Maaßen had never claimed the clip was forged or manipulated: it showed one person following another for about five to seven metres, probably on Bahnhofstraße, and did not prove hunts, while the uploader's heading "Menschenjagden in Chemnitz" was, the office argued, deliberately false. On 12 September he faced the Bundestag's parliamentary control panel and its interior committee. The CDU, the CSU and the Free Democratic Party backed him; CDU interior politician Armin Schuster called resignation demands disproportionate. Green deputy Konstantin von Notz called the episode bizarre, and SPD member Uli Grötsch said trust rebuilt after the NSU murders had been badly damaged.

The coalition leaders found no formula on 13 September. On 18 September Merkel, Seehofer and Nahles agreed that Maaßen would leave the intelligence presidency for a state secretary's post in the interior ministry, widely treated as a promotion and one that would not put the service under him. After protests inside the SPD, Nahles on 21 September asked for the decision to be reopened. On 23 September the three agreed instead that he would become a special adviser on international questions, at the rank of a head of department, keeping his existing pay and therefore not promoted. The next day Merkel said she regretted having thought too little about how the public would take news of a promotion. He stayed president until a successor could take over.

That posting never began. On 18 October, speaking to the Berner Club of European domestic-intelligence chiefs, Maaßen defended his Chemnitz remarks. According to a text that then circulated on the office intranet, he spoke of "linksradikale Kräfte" in the SPD using his case to try to break the coalition, and of a naive, left-wing policy on foreigners and security. On 5 November Seehofer said he had asked the federal president to place Maaßen in temporary retirement (einstweiliger Ruhestand) with immediate effect. He named three grounds: reopening a matter the coalition had closed, after Maaßen had regretted the Bild interview before the interior committee; the allegation of radical-left forces inside the SPD; and the undifferentiated attack on a "naive and left" policy. Seehofer said he was, in part, personally disappointed. Vice-president Thomas Haldenwang took charge in the interim, and the cabinet later approved his appointment as president.

Criminal proceedings

The manslaughter trial

On 22 August 2019 the Chemnitz regional court, sitting for security at the higher regional court on the outskirts of Dresden, convicted the Syrian defendant Alaa S. of manslaughter and dangerous bodily harm and sentenced him to nine years and six months. It found that, during the city festival in the early hours of 26 August 2018, he and a separately prosecuted acquaintance attacked Daniel Hillig after a dispute. Alaa S. stabbed him repeatedly in the upper body with a knife whose blade was about eight centimetres long, at least accepting death, while the other man stabbed from the side and behind. Hillig died of chest, back and arm wounds; fleeing, Alaa S. stabbed a second man in the back.

Presiding judge Simone Herberger said there were “no doubts” and that the court was “unmoved by the political dimension.” Prosecutors had asked for ten years and the relatives’ lawyers for eleven; the defense sought an acquittal. Alaa S. was silent until a closing statement in which he hoped not to be “the second victim of the real perpetrator.” No DNA tied him to the knife or the victim. The judges relied on overlapping witnesses and on autopsy and blood-pattern evidence that the fatal wounds were struck while Hillig was standing, preferring a witness’s first account of stabbing motions over later talk of punches because he had been pressured. Defense lawyer Ricarda Lang called the verdict “a sad day for the rule of law.”

The Federal Court of Justice dismissed the appeal on 14 April 2020 (5 StR 14/20). On 8 May 2020 it found no legal error against the defendant, including the refusal to answer defense questionnaires about bias, and the sentence became final.

The co-suspect was not tried. Saxony police name him as the Iraqi Farhad Ramazan Ahmad, then 22, wanted on a Chemnitz district-court warrant for suspected joint manslaughter; he had left his surroundings and might be armed. The appeal judgment says this man, called F. there, fled that night and was not traced. In 2023 investigators were reported to suspect he was in Turkey.

On 30 October 2019 the Dresden local court convicted justice officer Daniel Z. of breaching official secrecy and sentenced him to eleven months, suspended for two years, plus 150 hours of community service, after a plea agreement. He had photographed a warrant naming a suspect and witnesses; Pro Chemnitz, an Alternative for Germany district association and Pegida founder Lutz Bachmann published it. Prosecutors alleged racism, citing a chat that used a racist expression about assaulting foreigners. He was suspended, and further inquiries concerned suspected assaults on foreign prisoners.

Offenses during the protests

By early September 2018 the Dresden public prosecutor general’s office had 120 investigations from the disturbances, including breach of the peace, bodily harm, insult and Hitler salutes. Six people had been identified for salutes, with accelerated proceedings sought against three. Figures from the Federal Criminal Police Office later put right-wing-motivated offenses in Chemnitz at 112 between 26 August and 11 October 2018.

In accelerated hearings the Chemnitz local court gave a previously convicted 34-year-old five months’ immediate imprisonment for repeated Hitler salutes at a Pro Chemnitz rally on 27 August, and an eight-month suspended sentence to a 33-year-old for a salute, an attack on police and attempted bodily harm. In September 2021 it convicted a 30-year-old from Lower Saxony of dangerous bodily harm and breach of the peace for the stone-and-bottle attack on the Jewish restaurant Schalom; his DNA was on a stone. The combined sentence was one suspended year and was not yet final; prosecutors had called the attack racist.

By August 2023 the Chemnitz prosecutor had closed all 142 of its cases, discontinuing 97. Across offices there were more than 240 investigations against 235 suspects. Three indictments of 27 people, over violence after a 1 September 2018 event of the AfD, Pegida and Pro Chemnitz, remained open in Dresden.

Revolution Chemnitz

On 10 September 2018 Christian K. opened the chat “Planung zur Revolution,” shown as “Revolution Chemnitz,” on a messenger service he thought was surveillance-proof.

The court found the aim was to abolish the free democratic basic order, beginning on German Unity Day, 3 October 2018, with armed and possibly lethal attacks meant to produce civil-war-like conditions. Members were drawn from neo-Nazi, skinhead and hooligan circles and discussed semi-automatic pistols and a submachine gun. A text he posted said the National Socialist Underground should look like a “kindergarten preschool group”; the defense called the terrorism charge excessive.

On 14 September 2018 five members and others attacked youths and then mostly foreign nationals in Chemnitz, a “trial run” classed as breach of the peace and bodily injury and placed on the Schlossteichinsel. Police arrested them before further offenses, and in October they were brought before a federal judge.

On 24 March 2020 the Dresden higher regional court convicted eight men, aged 22 to 32, of membership in a terrorist organization, five also of further offenses, with terms from two years and three months to five years and six months. Christian K. was also convicted as founder and received the longest sentence. The Public Prosecutor General had asked for three to five and a half years. Five men were also convicted of serious breach of the peace and one of bodily injury, and three were released. On 20 May 2021 the Federal Court of Justice rejected the two remaining appeals (3 StR 418/20), others including the federal prosecutor’s having been withdrawn, and the judgment became final.

Media and public debate

Reporting in Germany and abroad

Early accounts of the fatal stabbing in Chemnitz included claims investigators did not support. Bild and Tag24 reported that the fight began with the sexual harassment of a woman; Bild later changed the article after police said they could not confirm it. Saxony police wrote on 26 August that nothing indicated a harassment had come first, and denied a rumored second death; senior prosecutor Ingrid Burghart told Correctiv the interviews did not support the harassment account. ARD's Faktenfinder noted further claims—25 knife wounds, a "massacre" of three Germans, and a defense of a woman from sexual assault—and repeated police denials, attributing the false story's reach in part to Bild. The BBC reported the dismissal and named the dead man as Daniel H.

Coverage of the demonstrations centered on the far right. The Guardian quoted Angela Merkel's spokesman, Steffen Seibert, condemning "the hunting down of people who appear to be from different backgrounds," and reported assaults, a banned straight-arm salute and chants of "Lügenpresse." The BBC described pictures of the Nazi salute and of demonstrators "chasing and attacking people of foreign appearance," though with few details, and said police were investigating alleged assaults on an Afghan, a Syrian and a Bulgarian. For the New York Times, Katrin Bennhold wrote of a crowd "chasing after dark-skinned bystanders" and quoted a Syrian refugee who said marchers were "hunting in packs… like wolves."

German newsrooms split on the word "Hetzjagd." On 30 August Torsten Kleditzsch of the Chemnitz paper Freie Presse wrote that his newsroom refused it: reporters saw attacks and short pursuits, not people driven a long distance, and knew of no video of that. He said the refusal should not be read as claiming the violence was invented. Michael Kretschmer, Saxony's minister-president, said there had been "no mob, no Hetzjagd." In the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, Michael Hanfeld argued that a clip from "Antifa Zeckenbiss" had drawn media and politics into a contest over attribution, not only over facts. The German Press Council's 2018 report said complaints denying the hunts were unfounded: people had chased other people, and the label was secondary to checkable facts.

Footage and fact-checks

The clip in that argument, called the "Hase" or "Hasi" video, runs about 19 seconds. Spiegel reported that "Antifa Zeckenbiss" posted it on Twitter at 20:56 on 26 August. Matched to the Bahnhofstraße near Johannisplatz, it shows several men moving toward two others, with shouts including "Haut ab" and "ihr Kanaken"; one man runs at one of them, and a woman says "Hase, du bleibst hier." The Süddeutsche Zeitung wrote that the voice appears to be the person filming, telling a companion not to join, and that the start of the confrontation is missing; a shirt in frame reads "Tradition statt Invasion."

Zeit, Spiegel and the Süddeutsche Zeitung treated the file as genuine because other footage matched it. Zeit found the same man—shaved head, sunglasses, turquoise shirt, blue jacket at the waist—in the clip, in a video posted at 20:18 from across the street, and in an unpublished recording from the phone of Alihassan S., whom Dresden prosecutors treated as a victim. Phone data and the Johanniskirche placed the scene on the Bahnhofstraße on 26 August, and the clip was uploaded in daylight. Spiegel noted that the second angle showed several of the same people, and that witnesses had already described attacks nearby. Alihassan S. told ze.tt he had been filming, was struck with a beer bottle, and filed a complaint. Chief prosecutor Wolfgang Klein told Zeit there was no sign of a fake and that investigators were using the video. He said "Hetzjagd" was not a legal term.

Hans-Georg Maaßen, then president of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, said authenticity was unproven. In a Bild interview published on the night of 6 September he said there was "no reliable information" that such hunts had occurred, no evidence the video was authentic, and good reasons to see it as "targeted misinformation," possibly to distract from the "murder" in Chemnitz. Spiegel noted that he had not given the government those grounds, and that prosecutors were investigating joint manslaughter, not murder. He later wrote to Interior Minister Horst Seehofer, ARD reported, that the video was not forged and that he had been misunderstood: the doubt was whether it "authentically" showed a manhunt.

Aftermath

Elections, policing and extremism policy

Chancellor Angela Merkel visited Chemnitz on 16 November 2018, her first trip there since the killing. After a youth basketball session she spoke at a Freie Presse reader forum. Police put a simultaneous Pro Chemnitz march at 1,000 to 1,200 people, some chanting “Merkel muss weg,” and used thousands of officers to separate it from a counter-demonstration.

The 1 September 2019 election to the Landtag of Saxony was a statewide vote, not a measure of the protests. In the final official list-vote result, turnout was 66.5 percent of 3,288,643 eligible voters: the Christian Democratic Union 32.1 percent, the Alternative for Germany 27.5 percent, Die Linke 10.4 percent, Alliance 90/The Greens 8.6 percent, the Social Democratic Party 7.7 percent, and the FDP 4.5 percent, short of the five-percent threshold. The 119 seats were divided 45 CDU, 38 AfD, 14 Left, 12 Green, and 10 SPD. Deutsche Welle reported the CDU share as 7.3 points below 2014 and quoted Minister-President Michael Kretschmer that “the friendly Saxony” had won. It described AfD strength in the former East as built on discontent over immigration, and mentioned Chemnitz as one of Saxony’s main cities rather than as the cause of the result.

The campaign still treated the previous August as unfinished business. In June 2019 the Saxon CDU adopted its election program in Chemnitz and confirmed Kretschmer as lead candidate; he continued to rule out a coalition with the AfD. Der Spiegel also returned to his 2018 statement that Chemnitz had seen “no mob, no hunt, and no pogroms,” writing that it created the public impression he meant to play down racist attacks. On 20 December 2019 the Landtag re-elected Kretschmer, on a joint nomination by the CDU, Greens, and SPD, by 61 votes to 57, and the new ministers were sworn in the same day.

In 2019 Interior Minister Roland Wöller and state police president Horst Kretzschmar presented a new Soko Rex inside the state criminal police’s counterterrorism center: 45 investigators for right-wing-motivated crimes, 33 officers in mobile search groups, and outposts in all five directorates, including Chemnitz, plus more online investigation and a “radicalization radar” developed with Saxony-Anhalt and Thuringia. They cited 56 such offenses per 100,000 inhabitants in Saxony in 2018, against about 25 nationwide. When Interior Minister Horst Seehofer and Thomas Haldenwang, president of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, presented the 2018 report, Der Tagesspiegel wrote that the service treated Chemnitz as a warning: anti-asylum agitation on social networks had quickly drawn both far-right followers and people outside that scene onto the streets.

Commemoration and later developments

On the morning of 20 December 2018 the city set a metal plaque into the Brückenstraße pavement where Daniel Hillig, called Daniel H. in German reporting, was killed. Officials said it was laid with the family and at their wish, after friends cleared months of flowers and candles, and that the family asked nothing more be left there.

In March 2019 the Chemnitz business-development company CWE cancelled the city festival planned for 23 and 24 August. It said the 2018 festival had become bound up with Hillig’s death, and that the event no longer had an economic basis or its intended role in shaping the city’s image. On the evening of 25 August 2019, near the first anniversary, police counted about 450 people at a demonstration registered by Pro Chemnitz and up to 300 at a counter-gathering called by the alliance “Chemnitz nazifrei.” About 600 officers were deployed. Police said they were investigating one case of insult and one display of the Hitler salute.

On 16 January 2025 the Chemnitz Regional Court decided to free Alaa S. early. Sentenced in August 2019 to nine and a half years for joint manslaughter and dangerous bodily harm, he had reached the two-thirds point; the Sächsische Zeitung reported a positive social and criminal prognosis. On 24 January the State Directorate of Saxony told MDR he would not for the time being be deported to Syria, citing a 30 September 2021 Chemnitz Administrative Court judgment: a ban under section 60(5) of the Residence Act, corresponding to Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights and independent of the offense. Senior prosecutor Ingrid Burghart said conditions included a reporting duty and probation assistance, and gave no address. On 6 February 2025 prosecutors confirmed to MDR that he was to leave Waldheim prison that day, with a probation officer and a duty to report any change of address. The Iraqi man accused with him had still not been caught.

Who was responsible

Contribution type and responsibility level for each recorded actor — not sole-author shorthand.

No public contributors are listed for this fact.

What changed

Fact → Driver → Indicator. Relationship strength orders the paths; it is not the observed indicator movement.

No public driver impacts are listed for this fact.

Causal path

How this event connects to drivers and indicators in the graph.

No causal path is recorded: this fact is not linked to a driver.

Linked pages by kind

Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.

  • People10
  • Organizations5

Cite this page

Factrail. (2026). 2018 Chemnitz protests. Factrail. https://factrail.ai/facts/2018-chemnitz-protests

https://factrail.ai/facts/2018-chemnitz-protests

Accessed 19 November 2026.

By the · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed

Dispute this factNamed here, or represent someone who is? Request a right of reply.