Florian Toncar
Florian Toncar (born 18 October 1979 in Hamburg) is a lawyer and a politician of the Free Democratic Party (FDP).
- Facts0
- Drivers0
- Indicators0
Florian Toncar (born 18 October 1979 in Hamburg) is a lawyer and a politician of the Free Democratic Party (FDP).
Florian Toncar (born 18 October 1979 in Hamburg) is a lawyer and a politician of the Free Democratic Party (FDP). He was a member of the Bundestag from Baden-Württemberg, returned on the state list for the Böblingen constituency, from 2005 to 2013 and again from 2017 through the 20th electoral term of 2021–2025. From 2021 to 2024 he was Parliamentary State Secretary in the Federal Ministry of Finance in the Scholz cabinet.
He took the Abitur in 1999 at the Goldberg-Gymnasium in Sindelfingen and then did basic military service with signals regiment 220 in Donauwörth. From 2000 to 2005 he studied law in Regensburg, Cambridge and Heidelberg, passed the first state examination in 2005 and the second in 2007, and in 2012 received a doctorate in law from the University of Tübingen. He practised as a lawyer from 2009. Before he re-entered the Bundestag he worked at Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP in London, and the record for the 20th term lists him as a practising lawyer until December 2021.
In the 16th Bundestag (2005–2009) he was the FDP group's spokesperson on human rights and humanitarian aid and a full member of the financial-market panel; in the 17th (2009–2013) he sat on the Budget Committee, chaired that panel, and from 2011 to 2013 was a deputy chair of the FDP parliamentary group. After the FDP returned to parliament in 2017 he was a parliamentary managing director of the group, its finance-policy spokesperson and a member of the Finance Committee, and from 2020 a deputy member of the committee that selects federal judges. He was the FDP's Obmann on the third committee of inquiry of the 19th Bundestag, which the chamber set up on 1 October 2020, on a motion of the FDP, the Left and the Greens, to examine what the federal government, public authorities and auditors knew about suspected balance-sheet fraud, market manipulation and money laundering at the payments company Wirecard.
At the 2025 Bundestag election he again stood in Böblingen and received 12,438 first votes, 6.1 percent. The FDP took 4.3 percent of second votes nationwide and won no seats. His term as parliamentary state secretary had already ended in 2024: on 6 November 2024 Chancellor Olaf Scholz dismissed Finance Minister Christian Lindner, and the coalition broke apart. He later confirmed to Focus Money, as reported by the insurance trade magazine procontra, that from 1 June 2026 he would join the management of Deutsche Vermögensberatung as the executive responsible for markets and regulation, after the statutory cooling-off period that follows departure from political office.
Mark Florian Martin Toncar, known publicly as Florian Toncar, was born on 18 October 1979 in Hamburg. The German National Library's authority record gives his birth year as 1979 and his birthplace as Hamburg, and it lists "Mark Florian Martin Toncar" as a variant of the preferred name Florian Toncar. Published parliamentary biographies, which the Bundestag says rest on members' own statements, do not name his parents or describe a childhood household.
They place his secondary schooling in Sindelfingen, in the Böblingen district of Baden-Württemberg: he passed the Abitur, the university-entrance examination, at the Goldberg-Gymnasium there in 1999. A curriculum vitae on the Bundestag site in 2006 also listed him as a member of the Verein der Freunde des Goldberg-Gymnasiums, the association of friends of that school.
After the Abitur he performed basic military service (Grundwehrdienst) with Fernmelderegiment 220, a signals regiment of the Bundeswehr, in Donauwörth. His biographies date that service to 1999 and the start of university study to 2000.
From 2000 to 2005 Toncar studied law at the University of Regensburg, the University of Cambridge and Heidelberg University, the sequence given in his Bundestag curriculum vitae. The 2006 biography names him as a member of the Selwyn College Association, the alumni body of Selwyn College, Cambridge. During his studies he held a scholarship from the Friedrich Naumann Foundation for Freedom. In a December 2023 interview published by the foundation, he said its financial and non-financial support had made study abroad considerably easier and had taken his education beyond the law syllabus. He also said that he had already been active in the Free Democratic Party before applying, and that he met Christian Lindner when Lindner spoke at a foundation seminar.
He passed the first state examination in law in 2005. The Bundestag then listed him as a Rechtsreferendar, a trainee lawyer, at the Landgericht Stuttgart, the regional court at which he did the practical training that follows the first examination. He passed the second state examination in 2007, the examination that completes qualification for the German bar.
On 1 October 2012, in the law faculty's winter semester 2012/13, the University of Tübingen examined his dissertation, entered under the name Mark Florian Martin Toncar. The title was Die Rule of Reason-Analyse vertikaler Mindestpreisbindungen im US-Kartellrecht ("The rule-of-reason analysis of vertical minimum resale-price maintenance in United States antitrust law"). The faculty list names the examiners as Wernhard Möschel and Stefan Thomas, with Möschel recorded first. The Bundestag biography records the resulting degree as a doctorate in law (Dr. jur.), awarded in 2012. He was already a member of parliament when the faculty examined the thesis.
Nomos published the dissertation in 2013 in Baden-Baden as volume 266 of the series Wirtschaftsrecht und Wirtschaftspolitik, a first edition of 268 pages (print ISBN 978-3-8487-0057-8), with the author line "RA Dr. Florian Toncar". The publisher's summary says that vertical minimum-price restraints had drawn fresh debate after the Supreme Court of the United States, in 2007, treated them as potentially permissible, and that the book sets out the background of that shift. Its contents are organised around the Court's judgment in Leegin Creative Leather Products, Inc. v. PSKS, Inc., including a chapter on the decision's prehistory.
From 2009 the Bundestag biographies describe Toncar as a Rechtsanwalt, the title of a lawyer admitted to practise in Germany, and they carry that description through to December 2021. His own profile dates a sole practice ("eigene Kanzlei") from January 2009 to February 2014, overlapping the mandate he held until October 2013. The Members of the Bundestag Act allows that: the mandate is to stand at the centre of a member's activity, but outside professional work remains generally permitted and, above set thresholds, must be disclosed.
The published returns do not show reportable fees from the practice. In October 2011 Die Zeit wrote that he had no side earnings which had to be published. A March 2013 snapshot of the 17th-term disclosures likewise listed none from legal practice. The only paid outside activity there was a 2012 lecture for Paramount Group Inc. in New York, entered as Stufe 2. Income was then published only above 1,000 euros in a month or 10,000 euros in a year, and Stufe 2 meant more than 3,500 euros and up to 7,000.
After he returned to parliament in 2017 he was still described as a lawyer, but the register of outside activities does not show a continuing practice. The paid item with a legal subject in that term was a single 2018 lecture for AnwaltService Stuttgart GmbH, a training session titled "Aktuelle Regulierung von Banken und Finanzdienstleistern", published as Stufe 1. Abgeordnetenwatch records the fee as one payment of 1,000 to 3,500 euros. The 20th-term biography, and Kürschners Volkshandbuch in the edition current on 15 June 2023, both close the entry "Rechtsanwalt" in December 2021. That is the month he became Parliamentary State Secretary at the Federal Ministry of Finance. Parliamentary state secretaries are covered by the incompatibility rules for federal ministers and may not, beside the office, practise a profession or a trade or hold another salaried post.
Between the two periods in the Bundestag he worked at Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer. The profile dates a post as lawyer at Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP from March 2014 to October 2017. In the 19th-term disclosures, archived in January 2021, the activity before that membership is given as "Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP, London, Rechtsanwalt." The place entered is London, in the same "employer, city" form used for his other disclosed activities; the filing does not name a German office. The trade publication procontra later stated that the 2014–2017 work concerned banking and financial-supervision law. A 2021 WirtschaftsWoche sketch of the Wirecard inquiry, without naming the firm, said that before the Free Democratic Party returned to the Bundestag he had worked at a large commercial law firm, and tied that to his questions on the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority and on auditors. The register treats the Freshfields post as employment before the mandate, not as a side activity, and later disclosures do not record fees from the firm.
Toncar joined the Free Democratic Party (FDP) in 1998. In 2001 he stood as its second-placed candidate for the Landtag of Baden-Württemberg in the Leonberg constituency. His first leadership post was in the Young Liberals (Junge Liberale), the party's youth organization in Baden-Württemberg. After months of internal disputes, delegates meeting in Rottenburg am Neckar on 18 October 2003 elected a new state chairman; the Badische Zeitung reported that 86 percent of 118 delegates voted for the 24-year-old Toncar. At the state congress in Staufen im Breisgau on 6–7 March 2004 he was confirmed, with 93 percent of the vote. His Bundestag biography dates the state chairmanship to 2003–2006 and, with it, membership of the Young Liberals' extended federal executive; a biography captured in October 2006 still listed him in the post.
The 2006 biography already placed him on the FDP state executive in Baden-Württemberg and on the executive of the Stuttgart regional association. The biography for the 19th Bundestag specifies that regional seat as running from 2003 to 2011 and again from 2015, the chairmanship of the Böblingen district association from 2008 to 2014, and a seat on the Böblingen district council (Kreistag) from 2009 to 2014. At a district-association election reported in December 2012 he received 88.1 percent of the votes. The same biographies name him chairman of the state specialist committee on interior affairs and law (Landesfachausschuss Innen und Recht), a post still recorded for the 20th Bundestag. After the party left parliament in 2025 he stayed tied to the district: on 16 December 2025 the Sindelfinger Zeitung listed him, still described as a federal-executive member, among the co-opted members of the Böblingen district executive.
From 2011 to 2013 he was a deputy state chairman of the FDP in Baden-Württemberg. That term coincided with the rebuilding of the state leadership after the March 2011 Landtag election, in which the FDP only narrowly remained in parliament. At an extraordinary congress in Stuttgart on 7 May 2011, Birgit Homburger was re-elected state chair in a runoff against Michael Theurer, 199 votes to 192, after a first ballot tied at 180 each.
He reached the federal executive (Bundesvorstand) by by-election. At the congress in Berlin on 19 September 2020, delegates chose him as an assessor (Beisitzer) with 88.28 percent. At the 72nd ordinary congress, whose postal ballot was counted on 4 June 2021, he was returned in the second group of assessors with 474 votes in favour, 10 against and 9 abstentions. The party's activity report lists him on the federal executive from May 2021 to April 2023, and the 20th-Bundestag biography, current into March 2025, still called him a member. On 16 May 2025 the 76th ordinary congress elected him an assessor of the narrower presidium (Präsidium) with 71.98 percent, in the ballot that also made Christian Dürr federal chairman with 82.25 percent.
On 23 June 2025 the federal executive created a commission to draft a new basic program, thirteen years after the Karlsruhe Freedom Theses, and put Toncar in charge. A steering group under his chair, with Nicole Büttner as deputy and Maximilian Reiter for the Young Liberals, was to produce a single text; the resolution linked the exercise to the defeat of 23 February 2025 and to a participatory process with members and outside contributors. He did not stand again for the presidium. At the 77th ordinary congress in Berlin at the end of May 2026, where Wolfgang Kubicki was elected federal chairman, the Böblingen paper reported Toncar's farewell from the presidium, which he left for professional reasons.
Toncar entered the Bundestag at the 2005 federal election on the Baden-Württemberg state list of the Free Democratic Party (FDP), for constituency 261, Böblingen. In that constituency the FDP received 9,621 first votes (5.0 percent) and 27,218 second votes (14.0 percent); the direct mandate went to Clemens Binninger of the Christian Democratic Union, with 49.8 percent of the first votes. Across Baden-Württemberg the FDP took 11.9 percent of the second votes (693,835). Born in 1979, he was among the youngest members of the 16th Bundestag: the parliament's data handbook places him fourth on its list of the ten youngest at the start of the term, after Anna Lührmann of Alliance 90/The Greens, Jens Spahn of the CDU and Cornelia Hirsch of the Left.
In the 16th electoral term the Bundestag recorded him as a secretary of the house (Schriftführer) and as a full member of the Committee on Human Rights and Humanitarian Aid, the Petitions Committee and the body under section 10a of the Financial Market Stabilization Act, and as a deputy member of the Budget Committee. A later official biography, drawn from the member's own information, also describes him as the FDP group's spokesperson for human rights and humanitarian aid. On 16 December 2005 he spoke for the FDP in the debate on the federal government's human-rights report, arguing that human rights should not be outweighed by other foreign or economic interests and criticizing the previous government's handling of China and Russia. The same sitting took up an FDP motion he introduced calling for human-rights observers to accompany peace missions mandated by the United Nations, and a motion he co-sponsored demanding that human rights be raised with Uzbekistan. In April 2008 he was the lead signatory of an FDP motion on Tibet after that spring's protests. It asked the government to press Beijing to open a dialogue with the 14th Dalai Lama, to apply the religious and cultural autonomy set out in the Chinese constitution, and to treat detained Tibetans according to recognized human-rights standards; the motion noted that Chancellor Angela Merkel had met the Dalai Lama in 2007.
He was returned at the 2009 election, again on the Baden-Württemberg list, for the renumbered constituency 260, Böblingen. In Böblingen the FDP's first-vote share rose to 13.0 percent (23,717 votes) and its second-vote share to 20.9 percent (38,125); the direct seat again went to Binninger. Statewide the FDP reached 18.8 percent of second votes, against 14.6 percent in Germany as a whole. In December 2009 the Bundestag listed him as a full member of the Budget Committee and as a secretary, with deputy membership of the Finance Committee and the Committee on Legal Affairs. On 19 January 2010 he spoke in the plenary on the justice chapter (Einzelplan 07) of the 2010 federal budget law.
For the remainder of the 17th term his official biography listed him as an ordinary member of the Budget Committee and as chair of the Parliamentary Financial Market Panel (Parlamentarisches Finanzmarktgremium). He had already sat, in the previous term, on the panel created under section 10a of the Financial Market Stabilization Act during the 2008 financial crisis. The 17th-term biography also recorded membership of the body under section 3(3) of the Stabilization Mechanism Act, the deputy chair of the German–Israeli Parliamentary Group, and a vice-presidency of the German–Israeli Society, together with deputy seats on the Election Scrutiny Committee, the Committee on Legal Affairs, the Finance Committee and the Parliamentary Advisory Council on Sustainable Development.
On 10 May 2011 the FDP parliamentary group elected him a deputy chair. Economics Minister Rainer Brüderle became group chair with 86 votes in favour, two against and two abstentions, after Birgit Homburger stood aside, saying she did not want an internal contest to burden the start of Philipp Rösler as party chair. Toncar, from Baden-Württemberg, was elected with no opposing candidate: 78 votes in favour, two against and nine abstentions. Volker Wissing and Martin Lindner were the other new deputy chairs. The Bundestag's later biography dates his deputy chairmanship of the group from 2011 to 2013.
At the 2013 federal election the FDP fell to 4.8 percent of the national second vote (2,083,533 ballots), 9.8 points below 2009, and missed the five-percent electoral threshold. The Federal Returning Officer's final allocation gave seats to the CDU, the SPD, the Left, the Greens and the CSU, and none to the FDP, so the party formed no Bundestag group. In Baden-Württemberg the FDP's second-vote share dropped from 18.8 to 6.2 percent. In Böblingen it fell from 20.9 to 7.1 percent of the second vote, and the party's first-vote share from 13.0 to 3.4 percent (6,501 votes). Toncar's membership, which the Bundestag dates from 2005 to 2013, ended with that parliament; he did not sit again until the FDP returned in 2017.
The Free Democratic Party re-entered the Bundestag at the federal election of 24 September 2017 with 10.7 percent of second votes nationwide, 4,999,449 votes. In Baden-Württemberg it received 762,008 second votes, 12.7 percent. In the Federal Returning Officer's final allocation the state FDP had no constituency seats and 12 seats in all. Toncar was fifth on the state list elected at a party delegate meeting in Donaueschingen on 19 November 2016. The Bundestag recorded the seat as a state-list mandate for constituency 260, Böblingen. There the FDP took 24,867 first votes, 12.8 percent, behind the Christian Democratic Union on 38.8 percent and the Social Democratic Party on 19.6 percent, and 29,510 second votes, 15.1 percent; turnout was 80.0 percent. His membership of the 19th Bundestag ran from the opening of that parliament on 24 October 2017.
On 25 September 2017, at the first meeting of the new FDP members, the group elected Christian Lindner as its chair and three parliamentary managing directors (Parlamentarische Geschäftsführer): Marco Buschmann as first managing director, with Stefan Ruppert and Toncar. In the 19th Bundestag Toncar was a member of the Council of Elders and deputy chair of the Committee on Election Scrutiny, Immunity and Rules of Procedure. He was also an ordinary member of the Joint Committee and a deputy member of the Mediation Committee and of the Committee on the Interior and Homeland. A Deutschlandfunk interview during the Brexit debates introduced him as well as deputy chair of the German–British parliamentary group.
On 22 March 2018 the Bundestag elected him one of the FDP's substitute members of the committee that proposes justices of the Federal Constitutional Court for election by the plenary. The same sitting filled the separate Richterwahlausschuss, which with the responsible federal minister appoints judges of the supreme federal courts; Toncar was not among the FDP members or substitutes elected to it that day. His Bundestag biography, which the parliament states is based on members' own information, records him as a deputy member of the Richterwahlausschuss from 2020. The parliament's list of offices also names him as the FDP's Obmann on the third committee of inquiry of that Bundestag. The Bundestag had set up the committee on 1 October 2020, on motions from the FDP, The Left and Alliance 90/The Greens, to examine the conduct of the federal government and its agencies in the Wirecard affair.
For the following election the Baden-Württemberg FDP, meeting in Friedrichshafen on 17 October 2020, again placed Toncar fifth on the state list, with 87.1 percent of the votes cast. On 26 September 2021 the party received 908,039 second votes in the state, 15.3 percent, and 16 seats in the Federal Returning Officer's final allocation. In Böblingen the FDP's first-vote share was 16.6 percent (32,184 votes) and its second-vote share 18.1 percent (35,082); the CDU held the constituency with 29.7 percent. Toncar's archived biography for the 20th Bundestag records him as a member from that parliament's opening on 26 October 2021. In the subsequent coalition talks of the FDP, the Social Democratic Party and Alliance 90/The Greens, the FDP named him to its working group on finance and the budget, led by Christian Dürr and also including Otto Fricke, Christian Grascha, Katja Hessel and Moritz Körner, with papers due by 10 November 2021.
For the whole of the 19th Bundestag Toncar was an ordinary member of the Finance Committee. The parliament's biography for the period also lists him as the FDP parliamentary group's spokesperson on financial policy. That designation was already in public use on 12 September 2018, when the Bundesverband Lohnsteuerhilfevereine reported a meeting with him in that capacity. Apart from his committee seats, the Bundestag's register of members' disclosable activities records that he sat on the administrative board of KfW until 31 March 2020.
On 1 October 2020 the Bundestag established its third committee of inquiry of the 19th electoral term, into Wirecard, insolvent since 25 June 2020. The motion, printed paper 19/22240, came from the Free Democratic Party, Die Linke and Alliance 90/The Greens. After referral on 11 September 2020, Florian Toncar reported it with Fabio De Masi and Danyal Bayaz. An amendment by the Social Democratic Party fixed nine full members—three for the CDU/CSU, two for the SPD and one each for the Alternative for Germany, the FDP, the Left and the Greens—against those four groups. The plenary adopted the amended mandate, printed paper 19/22996, with the opposition in favour and the coalition abstaining.
Article 44 of the Basic Law limited the inquiry to the period from 1 January 2014 until establishment. The committee was to examine what the federal government and its agencies, above all the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin), knew of suspected accounting fraud, market manipulation and money laundering, whether supervision and the auditors had met their duties, and whether officials had promoted Wirecard in Germany or abroad.
The committee constituted itself on 8 October 2020 under Bundestag President Wolfgang Schäuble. The AfD held the nomination for the chair. On a motion by the FDP and the Greens, with the AfD abstaining, a secret ballot elected Kay Gottschalk by five votes to four; Hans Michelbach (CDU/CSU) became deputy chair. The Obleute were Matthias Hauer (CDU/CSU), Jens Zimmermann (SPD), Gottschalk, Toncar for the FDP, De Masi and Bayaz, whom Lisa Paus replaced on 8 June 2021 after Bayaz left parliament. Before the committee sat, Toncar, De Masi and Bayaz had worked through confidential files together and aligned questions to the government.
From 19 November 2020 to 8 June 2021 the committee held 105 oral examinations in 32 sittings and put written questions to twelve further people. Former chief executive Markus Braun, heard first, refused to testify because of the criminal investigation; the committee accepted the refusal and sought no fine.
On 22 April 2021 Finance Minister Olaf Scholz said the government bore no responsibility, that BaFin had acted "within its possibilities," and that it had not been well enough equipped. Toncar answered that the law had allowed more, both at BaFin and in the ministry. Chancellor Angela Merkel, heard the next day, said she had not followed the reporting before she argued in Beijing in September 2019 for Wirecard's entry to China. In March Toncar spoke of "a culture of non-responsibility." Bayaz described a "collective failure" of authorities and supervisors; De Masi said public bodies had been willing to be taken in; Hauer alleged an "egregious culture of looking away" at BaFin and the finance ministry.
Printed paper 19/30900, more than 2,000 pages, was handed to Schäuble on 22 June 2021 and noted unanimously on 25 June. Toncar was a rapporteur, with Zimmermann, Hauer, De Masi and Paus. The CDU/CSU–SPD assessment found "unmistakably" a collectively executed balance-sheet fraud, with controls kept deliberately ineffective. Most witnesses, it said, had taken the Financial Times allegations of October 2019 seriously, but clean opinions from Ernst & Young had repeatedly dispersed suspicion. The majority saw no special treatment by the chancellery and no shown effect from Merkel's remark in China, and wrote that the ministry had to respect BaFin's independence and quickly dropped a rescue in early summer 2020.
The joint minority opinion of the FDP, the Left and the Greens called the case "much more than a balance-sheet scandal": the largest post-war stock-market and financial scandal, enabled by "collective supervisory failure," a German Wagenburgmentalität toward non-Germans, a political network and the desire for a digital national champion in China. They said the inquiry was needed to break a "cartel of silence," and wrote that Scholz's promised "maximum transparency" had failed where relevant emails were not filed. The AfD's separate opinion said the coalition had softened findings and its own responsibility. Toncar told the plenary that authorities had "played on the wrong side for years," that the fraud "should have been prevented early," and that the failure at BaFin and the Financial Intelligence Unit was "government failure," for which Scholz should draw consequences.
On 2 December 2021, as the Social Democratic Party of Germany, Alliance 90/The Greens and the Free Democratic Party assembled the Scholz cabinet, Christian Lindner said that his parliamentary state secretaries would be Florian Toncar and Katja Hessel, both FDP members of the Bundestag. On 8 December, the day the Bundestag elected Olaf Scholz chancellor, Hessel and Toncar were listed as the two parliamentary state secretaries at the Federal Ministry of Finance. The post is held by a member of parliament, appointed by the Federal President on the chancellor's proposal and with the minister's agreement, and it ends when that minister leaves office. Toncar's archived Bundestag biography records the office as running from 2021 to 2024.
An organisation chart dated 17 April 2024 assigned Toncar departments II, VII, VIII and E: the federal budget, financial-market policy, federal holdings and privatisations, and European and international financial policy. Hessel was the ministry's other parliamentary state secretary. The Bundestag's register of outside activities listed him, unpaid and by virtue of office, as chair of the interministerial steering committee under section 4 of the Stabilisation Fund Act and as a member of the advisory board of KfW Capital, the development bank's venture-capital subsidiary.
On 6 September 2022 Toncar introduced the 2023 federal budget bill and the finance plan for 2022 to 2026. The cabinet draft of 1 July 2022 set spending at €445.2 billion, about 10 percent below the 2022 plan, and net new borrowing at €17.2 billion, against €138.9 billion in 2022, without a further suspension of the constitutional debt brake, which had been used from 2020 through 2022. Toncar called inflation the central problem and said a return to the debt brake was compatible with relief measures and with investment, which the draft put at €58.4 billion.
Florian Toncar speaking in the Bundestag during the 2022 federal budget debate.
The main capital-markets statute of the term was the Future Financing Act. Toncar defended the government draft at first reading on 21 September 2023, and the Bundestag passed the bill on 17 November 2023. The draft would have raised the annual tax-free amount for employee share ownership from €1,440 to €5,000; the text adopted set the allowance at €2,000 from 2024 and extended the deferral of tax on employee equity. It also lowered the minimum market capitalisation for a listing from €1.25 million to €1 million, dropped the requirement of a bank as co-applicant in parts of the regulated market, and provided for electronic registered shares.
In March 2023 the finance ministry and the education ministry, led by Bettina Stark-Watzinger, opened a financial-education initiative aimed at a national strategy, a public platform and more research. In September 2024 the OECD gave Lindner and Stark-Watzinger a proposed national strategy. In October 2023 the cabinet adopted a draft federal office against financial crime, combining intelligence analysis, investigation of significant international cases and supervision outside the financial sector. Toncar said in June 2024 that delay was running out the time for that reform; it was not enacted before the coalition ended.
On 29 May 2024 the cabinet adopted Rentenpaket II, the pension-level and generational-capital bill associated with labour minister Hubertus Heil and with Lindner. It would have held the statutory pension level at 48 percent and built a capital stock from federal loans and federal assets, not from contributions, invested globally by an independent public-law foundation using the nuclear-waste fund KENFO, with average annual transfers to the pension insurance of €10 billion from 2036. Toncar had argued the finance ministry's case for that stock in its March 2024 monthly report. The government later recorded that the bill won no parliamentary majority and did not take effect in the 20th legislative period.
The holdings portfolio produced the sharpest dispute. On 3 September 2024 the stabilisation-fund steering committee, chaired by Toncar, decided to cut the fund's stake in Commerzbank from 16.49 percent to 12 percent by selling 4.49 percent, placed with UniCredit in an accelerated bookbuilding. The ministry told the Bundestag that a placement agreement signed at about 17:30 on 10 September could no longer be unwound, and that it learned only later that evening — in a call at about 20:13 from UniCredit's Germany chief, Marion Höllinger, to Toncar — that UniCredit had already bought about 4.5 percent in the market. On 20 September the committee stopped further sales and said it would back Commerzbank's plan to stay independent. The CDU/CSU questions printed with that answer described the sale as poorly prepared for one strategic buyer taking the whole packet.
On European Union policy, Toncar said in an August 2023 ministry interview that the Capital Markets Union still had to move faster, including through easier securitisation, and he presented the national financing law as part of that agenda. In May 2024 he told Bloomberg that EU governments needed to be braver on banking rules if cross-border business was to become easier.
On the evening of 6 November 2024, after coalition talks on the 2025 budget and economic policy failed, government spokesman Steffen Hebestreit said Scholz would ask President Frank-Walter Steinmeier to dismiss Lindner. Lindner had proposed an early election, on the ground that the parties no longer had enough common ground on economic and fiscal policy. On 7 November Steinmeier gave Lindner, Justice Minister Marco Buschmann and Stark-Watzinger their letters of dismissal and appointed Jörg Kukies finance minister. Toncar said that day that Lindner's dismissal had ended his own term as parliamentary state secretary, and he urged a confidence vote soon rather than an election delayed into 2025. He remained a member of the Bundestag.
On 29 May 2009 the Bundestag wrote the debt brake into the Basic Law. Of the Free Democratic Party members present, 47 abstained with the group, three voted no and one voted yes; the amendment passed by 418 votes to 109, with 48 abstentions. In April 2024 Toncar told Stern that the yes was his. Not taking on too much debt, and not overloading the social-security systems, were why he had entered politics, and a once-in-a-lifetime chance to set a limit had to be taken “if necessary even against my group.”
On 27 February 2022 he backed a €100 billion special fund for the Bundeswehr so Germany would meet NATO’s 2 percent benchmark at once. On 4 March 2025, after Friedrich Merz and the SPD announced a wider package, he wrote that strengthening the Bundeswehr was defensible with credit, but that Merz was using the Russian threat as a pretext for debt “for almost everything else.” On 18 March the outgoing Bundestag passed, 512 to 206, an amendment placing outside the brake defence spending above 1 percent of gross domestic product, a credit-financed fund of up to €500 billion for infrastructure and climate investment, and extra borrowing by the Länder. Toncar voted against. An FDP alternative, a Bundeswehr fund of up to €300 billion, failed.
On 15 July 2021, writing for the FDP Bundestag group, he called for a lower corporation tax, higher income-tax rates starting later, and abolition of the trade tax in favour of a municipal multiplier on corporation and income tax, with retained-earnings relief for smaller partnerships. He was one of six FDP politicians who challenged the solidarity surcharge in their own assessments, telling tagesschau it should have been temporary: “Temporary is now already 30 years, although the costs of reunification, the so-called Solidarity Pact, have in the meantime expired.” On 26 March 2025 the Federal Constitutional Court dismissed the complaint (2 BvR 1505/20), finding the reunification burden had not evidently disappeared but requiring Parliament to keep watching. Deutschlandfunk headlined his description of the ruling as a “warning judgment.”
In June 2010 he preferred an internationally coordinated tax on financial-sector profits and bonuses to a financial transaction tax, which he said taxed every trade regardless of risk and would not stabilise markets. In August 2021 he rejected product bans and forced bank splits, and said supervision should be stricter for large cross-border firms than for small regional ones. In March 2021 he wrote that fully taxed gains require fully recognised losses; raising the futures-loss cap from €10,000 to €20,000 was not enough. He opposed reporting bitcoin and other crypto transactions from €1,000, citing no evidence on terrorist financing. He also rejected a stablecoin ban, wanting consumer, money-laundering and stability rules that did not set “significant” thresholds too low. In November 2024, after Olaf Scholz ended the coalition, he said he would try to revive the draft law on financial crime.
In September 2023 he told t-online that a personal depot of funds and shares, locked until retirement, should stand beside the statutory pension and occupational schemes. The public “Generationenkapital” should give the statutory scheme a stock filled each year and used only in the 2030s, invested globally, so contributions need not rise and the pension could be financed “for all eternity” more broadly.
In July 2024 he told the Süddeutsche Zeitung, from the Federal Ministry of Finance, that reordering Federation–Länder finances was “the most important reform in Germany at all,” and that he wanted fewer, larger Länder on the model of the 1952 merger into Baden-Württemberg. Länder and municipalities should set their own taxes and justify them to voters. “Municipal self-government inevitably means a certain inequality,” he said, and “in this financial tangle in Germany we are doing more things wrong than right,” because grants and central standards—his example was a legal claim to daycare for children under three—hide who is responsible.
In 2021, for the FDP group, he said the European Union emissions trading system should cover all emitters, not only power, heavy industry and intra-European flights. In February 2025 he told the Stuttgarter Zeitung that the car industry and its suppliers were his Böblingen priority: “technology openness instead of the combustion-engine ban.” In 2017 he rejected leaving NATO, calling it “a security alliance successful without rival,” and backed defence spending of at least 2 percent of GDP. In 2011, as deputy chair of the German-Israeli parliamentary group, he told the Sindelfinger Zeitung/Böblinger Zeitung that arms deliveries to Israel followed because “we as Germans have a historical responsibility.”
Toncar was the Free Democratic Party (Germany) candidate in constituency 260, Böblingen, and second on the party's Baden-Württemberg list for the Bundestag election of 23 February 2025. A state delegate assembly in Karlsruhe on 23 November 2024 elected Judith Skudelny as lead candidate and placed Toncar second.
With turnout at 84.3 percent, the seat went to Marc Biadacz of the Christian Democratic Union of Germany, with 76,033 first votes (37.3 percent). Toncar received 12,438 first votes (6.1 percent), 10.5 percentage points below the FDP's 2021 result there, and the party took 14,311 second votes (7.0 percent), down 11.1 points. The Stuttgarter Zeitung reported that he, like Tobias Bacherle of Alliance 90/The Greens, would not return from the district.
Nationally the FDP won 2,148,757 second votes, 4.3 percent, against 11.4 percent in 2021. The final result, certified on 14 March 2025, gave the party no seats: it stayed under the five-percent threshold of the national second vote and carried no constituency. Toncar's membership of the Bundestag ended with that term in March 2025.
On 26 February 2026 Focus reported that Toncar had confirmed he would join the management of Deutsche Vermögensberatung (DVAG) on 1 June 2026 as Bereichsvorstand for market and regulation, and take a leadership role at the Deutscher Unternehmensverband Vermögensberatung (DUV). DAS INVESTMENT repeated the account on 9 March 2026 and said DVAG had not commented. Both pieces appeared before the date they gave for the start.
They treated a June start as observance of the cooling-off rules for parliamentary state secretaries. The Federal Ministers Act, applied to those secretaries by statute, requires written notice of private-sector work begun within 18 months of leaving office. The government may forbid it, where public interests would be harmed, for up to 18 months. Toncar had left the Federal Ministry of Finance (Germany) in November 2024. Focus wrote that the period would end in May 2026. The reports did not quote a published prohibition decision.
Focus described a full-time sales force of about 18,000. The Pohl family holds the majority and the insurer Assicurazioni Generali about 40 percent; Andreas Pohl, son of the founder Reinfried Pohl (1928–2014), is chief executive, and Reinfried Pohl founded the DUV as an occupational association. Focus named former finance minister Theo Waigel and MEP Markus Ferber among advisory-board members, and noted that Friedrich Bohl, once head of Helmut Kohl's chancellery, sat for about two decades on the executive and supervisory boards.
The nonprofit Bürgerbewegung Finanzwende called the move a revolving door. Daniel Mittler wrote that Toncar would start during legislation on private pensions from which DVAG could benefit, and cited company gifts of more than €300,000 to the CDU, the Christian Social Union in Bavaria, the Social Democratic Party of Germany, the FDP and the Greens. He pointed to a 2023 letter in which Helge Lach, then DUV chairman and a DVAG board member, asked state secretary Toncar, serving under Christian Lindner, for support against a general European ban on commissions in investment advice. Finanzwende said Lindner then wrote to European Commission member Mairead McGuinness opposing such a ban, and that she drew back from a general prohibition. A Finanzwende dossier called DVAG Germany's largest financial distributor, argued that commissions steer sales toward costly or unsuitable partner products, and described the hierarchy as pyramid-like. Since large gifts had to be disclosed in 2002, it put donations from the company and its lobbying network at about €8.4 million, 64 percent to the CDU and 27 percent to the FDP.
The Bundestag biographies for the 19th electoral term (2017–2021) and the 20th (2021–2025) state that Toncar is Protestant (evangelisch), married, and the father of three children. The parliament notes that these entries rest on members' own statements, and neither biography names his spouse or his children. A biography captured in February 2006, early in his first term, instead described him as unmarried (ledig) and gave his birthplace as Hamburg. The parliamentary transparency project Abgeordnetenwatch lists Böblingen, in Baden-Württemberg, as his place of residence, separately from the Böblingen constituency for which he stood.
The February 2006 biography also recorded voluntary work and memberships outside party office. It named him as a youth supervisor (Jugendbetreuer) with the Weil im Schönbuch local group of the German Life Saving Association (Deutsche Lebens-Rettungs-Gesellschaft, DLRG), in the municipality where the same text says he attended primary school from 1986 to 1990. It further listed membership of the Deutsche Atlantische Gesellschaft, the Deutsch-Israelische Gesellschaft, the Literarische Gesellschaft Scheffelbund, named for the poet Joseph Victor von Scheffel, the association of Selwyn College, Cambridge, the friends of the Goldberg-Gymnasium in Sindelfingen, the automobile club ADAC, and the groups Liberale Hochschulgruppe, Liberale Juristen and Liberale Senioren.
A shorter biography from September 2008, and the biography for the 17th electoral term, still included the DLRG, the Deutsche Atlantische Gesellschaft and the Deutsch-Israelische Gesellschaft. The 17th-term page, dated 9 January 2013, additionally described him as vice-president of the Deutsch-Israelische Gesellschaft and as deputy chairman of the Deutsch-Israelische Parlamentariergruppe, the Bundestag's parliamentary friendship group with Israel. In the mandatory disclosure of outside posts on that page, the vice-presidency was entered as unpaid, as were seats on the boards of trustees of the Theodor Heuss Foundation in Stuttgart and of the federal foundation "Mutter und Kind – Schutz des ungeborenen Lebens". The narrative biography of the same period also called him an unpaid member of the board of Help – Hilfe zur Selbsthilfe and a member of the alumni association of Heidelberg University and of the friends of the University of Regensburg.
Help's report for 2012 states that Toncar left its board at his own request and that, at the members' meeting of 21 March 2012, Christiane Ratjen-Damerau was elected in his place as the representative of the Free Democratic Party parliamentary group. The biographies for the 19th and 20th terms do not repeat this list of associations or the vice-presidency.
How the record is sourced and how the score is derived.
The score is formula-derived (Factrail formula v1, version 1.0.0), not an editorial verdict. Read the methodology.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Dispute a fact on this pageNamed here, or represent someone who is? Request a right of reply.
People and organizations as listed in the Related section of this page; facts, drivers and the pages that name it as listed in the blocks here. Counts, not a rating.