Skip to content
Herbert Reul

Herbert Reul

Not rated

Herbert Reul (born 31 August 1952 in Langenfeld) is a German politician of the Christian Democratic Union and, since 30 June 2017…

  • Facts0
  • Drivers0
  • Indicators0

Expert article

Herbert Reul (born 31 August 1952 in Langenfeld) is a German politician of the Christian Democratic Union and, since 30 June 2017, minister of the interior of North Rhine-Westphalia, the sixteenth person to hold that office. The Bundesrat lists him as a Roman Catholic, married, with three children; he still lives in Leichlingen with his wife and three adult daughters. He studied social sciences and educational science, passed the first state examination in 1979 and the second in 1981 after a traineeship at the Marienschule in Leverkusen-Opladen, and taught from 1981 to 1985 as a Studienrat at the municipal Gymnasium in Wermelskirchen.

He joined the Young Union in 1970 and the CDU in 1971, sat on the Leichlingen council from 1975 to 1992, and was a member of the Landtag of North Rhine-Westphalia from 1985 to 2004 and again from 2022. From 1991 to 2003 he was secretary-general of the state CDU. Between 2004 and 2017 he sat in the European Parliament in the European People's Party Group, and from 2012 he chaired the German CDU/CSU delegation. As chair of the Parliament's energy committee he argued for keeping nuclear power in the mix, a stance that put him at odds with Chancellor Angela Merkel and brought him the nickname "Atom-Herbert".

After Armin Laschet's victory in the 2017 state election, Reul entered the cabinet to take charge of internal security and became one of the minister-president's closest political allies. In 2018 he advanced a police bill described as the state's sharpest anti-terror package, covering electronic ankle monitors, surveillance of services such as WhatsApp, suspicionless checks and preventive custody of up to a month; after lawyers, the data-protection commissioner and the coalition partner raised constitutional objections, he postponed the vote so the draft could be revised. He was a full member of the German Bundesrat from 30 June 2017 until 30 June 2022 and has been a deputy member since, sitting on its internal-affairs and defence committees. In a ruling of 14 November 2024, published in January 2025, the Federal Constitutional Court held that the combined use of long-term observation and covert imaging under the state police act was incompatible with the right to informational self-determination, and allowed those powers to continue only until the end of 2025 and only where there was at least a concretised danger.

The July 2021 floods killed 49 people in North Rhine-Westphalia. A Landtag committee of inquiry later criticised the interior ministry for not issuing a statewide severe-weather warning although it had the legal power to do so, and recorded that government and opposition members could not agree that there was unambiguous evidence of defective crisis management by the state government as a whole. On 23 August 2024, at a Festival of Diversity in Solingen, Issa Al Hasan killed three people and seriously injured eight; the Higher Regional Court in Düsseldorf sentenced him to life imprisonment for three murders, ten attempted murders and membership of the Islamic State group, finding particular gravity of guilt and ordering subsequent preventive detention. The killings fed a national argument about asylum rules, and the state then adopted a security package.

Journalists have described him as a hardliner who is popular with police officers and a particular adversary of criminal extended-family networks, a role the Neue Zürcher Zeitung summed up as the sheriff among Germany's interior ministers; Reul has said he does not see himself as a "hard man". An SPD interior spokesman told the same newspaper that success against so-called clan crime was difficult to measure, because there was no settled definition of which offences counted.

Early life and education

Family and schooling

Herbert Reul was born on 31 August 1952 in Langenfeld in the Rhineland and grew up in neighbouring Leichlingen, in the Rheinisch-Bergischer Kreis, where official biographies also give his residence. He was raised in a Roman Catholic family; the Bundesrat lists his confession as Roman Catholic.

His father, Karl Josef Reul (6 November 1922 – 5 October 2015), had lived in Leichlingen since 1945. He taught at the Catholic primary school on Kirchstraße, became its rector in 1964, and was a long-serving member of the Christian Democratic Union: a town councillor from 1957 to 1999 and honorary mayor from 1975 to 1994. The Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger later described him as a committed Catholic whose public life also ran through church, carnival, shooting clubs and choral singing. He died suddenly at home on the evening of 5 October 2015, aged 92. He was survived by his wife Emilie, whom he had married in the summer of 1951, and by five children and ten grandchildren. Herbert Reul was one of the children; a sister, Barbara Reul-Nocke, later held a senior municipal post in Remscheid. Munzinger’s biography describes the Leichlingen household in which he grew up as politically conservative.

Reul was himself a pupil at the Catholic primary school on Kirchstraße, where his father taught. Recalling his first days there, he said his mother had worried that he was too light for the school medical examination, and that his father had been satisfied with his dictations even when the handwriting was hard to read. In 1972 he passed the Abitur. A Leverkusen biographical register places that examination at the Landrat-Lucas-Schule II, a Gymnasium in Opladen.

University and teaching

From 1972 to 1979 he studied for a grammar-school teaching qualification in social science and educational science at the University of Cologne, and he passed the first state examination in 1979.

He then completed the Referendariat, the practical training stage for the teaching profession, from 1979 to 1981 at the Marienschule in Opladen, a Catholic private school. In 1981 he passed the second state examination and was appointed a Studienrat. From 1981 to 1985 he taught social sciences and pedagogy at the municipal Städtisches Gymnasium in Wermelskirchen. When members of the school’s 1984 leaving class met in 2019, a former pupil, Astrid Ludwig, described him as a good and fair teacher of pedagogy.

The classroom career lasted only those four years. In 1985, on his election to the Landtag of North Rhine-Westphalia, he left full-time teaching for politics.

Local politics and the Landtag

Council, Junge Union and party entry

Herbert Reul's party career began in Leichlingen, in the Rheinisch-Bergischer Kreis. He joined the Junge Union in 1970 and the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) in 1971. In a Landtag profile he later traced that step to youth work in his home town: after joining the CDU he stood for the Leichlingen council, on which he sat from 1975 to 1992, the same year his father was first elected mayor. That father, Karl Reul, was honorary mayor of Leichlingen from 1975 to 1994 and a member of the town council from 1957 to 1999.

Inside the Junge Union, Reul was district chairman for the Rheinisch-Bergischer Kreis from 1976 to 1983 and, from 1980 to 1987, a member of its state executive in North Rhine-Westphalia. The CDU's state biography notes that until 1986 that body was still the executive of the Junge Union Rheinland. His JU membership ended in 1987.

Member of the Landtag, 1985–2004

Reul entered the Landtag of North Rhine-Westphalia on 30 May 1985 and remained a member until 3 September 2004. From 1985 to 1991 he was the CDU parliamentary group's spokesman on school policy. In June 1999 the parliamentary magazine Landtag intern identified him as a deputy chair of the CDU group; a biography carried by the European People's Party group in the European Parliament dates the end of that deputy chairmanship to 2000. The Landtag years overlapped his term as secretary-general of the state CDU, which ran from 1991 to 2003.

For the election of 14 May 1995 he was second on the CDU state reserve list, behind Helmut Linssen of Geldern; the list was published in Landtag intern on 3 May 1995. At the election of 14 May 2000 he was the CDU candidate in constituency 24, Leverkusen II – Rheinisch-Bergischer Kreis I. North Rhine-Westphalia then used a one-vote system, in which the vote for a constituency candidate also counted for that candidate's party; a separate list vote was introduced only for the 2010 election. In the constituency the Social Democratic Party (SPD) received 19,133 votes (43.0 percent) and the CDU 15,654 (35.2 percent), on a turnout of 58.5 percent. Gisela Ley of the SPD, like Reul a resident of Leichlingen, won the direct seat. Reul, fourth on the CDU state list, was returned through the list. He left the Landtag on 3 September 2004; from 2004 to 2017 he was a member of the European Parliament.

Return to the Landtag in 2022

At the state election of 15 May 2022 Reul won a direct mandate in constituency 22, Rheinisch-Bergischer Kreis II. The constituency comprises Burscheid, Kürten, Leichlingen (Rheinland), Odenthal, Overath and Wermelskirchen. He received 34,895 first votes, 51.1 percent of 68,300 valid first votes; the SPD followed on 20.0 percent. Turnout in the constituency was 61.8 percent. His membership of the Landtag resumed on 1 June 2022.

Herbert Reul at the presiding desk during the constitutive sitting of the Landtag in Düsseldorf on 1 June 2022.

That day, as the oldest member of the new house, he opened the constitutive sitting in Düsseldorf and presided until the members elected André Kuper of the CDU as president. Article 37(2) of the state constitution assigns that opening chair to the oldest member, or the next oldest if that member declines or is unable to serve, until the new president or a deputy takes over. WDR reported Reul's age as 69. Addressing the 195 members, he said he was troubled that many citizens were distancing themselves from politics and the democratic process, a distance also visible in statewide turnout of 55.5 percent, which the Rheinische Post described as a historic low. He said that everyone had the right to express an opinion, to assemble and to demonstrate — "Aber Hass ist keine Meinung mehr" ("But hatred is no longer an opinion") — and that too many people felt alienated from parliamentary politics. He sat again as the directly elected member for the constituency while continuing as interior minister, the office he had held since 30 June 2017.

Offices in the CDU

Secretary-general of the state party

Reul was secretary-general (Generalsekretär) of the CDU in North Rhine-Westphalia from 1991 to 2003. On 30 January 1991 state chairman Norbert Blüm, then federal labour minister, named the 38-year-old Landtag member and the faction’s education spokesman to succeed Helmut Linssen. The taz called the search protracted and costly for Blüm. At the state congress in Bielefeld at the start of March, delegates elected him with 90.06 percent; Blüm, re-elected chair, received 84.2 percent. The taz reported that the state party had shed 37,472 members since 1983 and that younger members looked to Reul to open its structures.

Welt am Sonntag later called him “the General,” the organizer of the state campaigns. While Blüm was taken up with federal politics, Reul had wide latitude over organization, programme and strategy; that room narrowed after Jürgen Rüttgers, state chairman from 1999, also led the Landtag faction in Düsseldorf. Reul announced early in 2003 that he would step down. On 5 April a congress in Bochum elected Hans-Joachim Reck, a former CDU federal executive director then at Deutsche Telekom, with 79.2 percent.

Welt reported local gains under his campaign direction, notably 50.3 percent in 1999, when the CDU took 29 of 31 Landrat offices, 14 of 23 lord mayorships and 249 of 396 mayoral posts. The party’s European vote in the state rose, on the paper’s figures, from 35.7 percent in 1989 to 47.3 percent in 1999, while Landtag results stayed near 37 percent (36.7 in 1990, 37.7 in 1995, 37.0 in 2000). In 2000 the SPD fell to 42.8 percent without a CDU gain, which Welt tied to the federal donations scandal. The 1994 Bundestag vote in the state still helped keep Helmut Kohl; in 1998 a weak state result contributed to the national defeat.

The same profile recorded the accounts moving from a 3.4 million Deutsche Mark deficit in 1991 to a 3.8 million euro surplus, and a shift of headquarters and local offices toward service and communication centres. Congresses accepted wider citizen participation, including referendums, and more privatization of public services. Welt also reported that, after Reul announced a CDU petition should the SPD keep blocking direct elections of mayors and Landräte, the SPD yielded, and that the 1999 turnover in town halls followed. It called the balance mixed.

District, state and federal posts

From 1990 to 2007 Reul chaired the CDU in the Rheinisch-Bergischer Kreis, and he has been honorary chairman since. Since 2004 he has chaired the district association CDU Bergisches Land — Düsseldorf, Remscheid, Solingen, Wuppertal and the districts of Mettmann, Rheinisch-Bergisch and Oberbergisch. Delegates re-elected him in 2019 with 92.5 percent and on 20 January 2025 with 61 of 63 votes.

He has been on the state executive since 1987. On 23 October 2021, at the Bielefeld congress that elected Hendrik Wüst state chairman after Armin Laschet, Reul became one of five deputy chairs with 91 percent. He did not stand when the board was renewed in Hürth on 28 October 2023; the Landtag biography dates the deputy chairmanship to 2021–2023.

The Konrad Adenauer Foundation’s lists name him among the additional members of the federal executive elected at Düsseldorf on 26–28 October 1992, and not on the board chosen in Bonn on 28 November 1994. He was not then in the presidium. The Landtag biography also records federal-executive and presidium membership from 2012 to 2022, a span that opens with his chairmanship of the CDU/CSU group in the European Parliament, 2012–2017. The Rheinische Post reported that in December 2018, at the Hamburg congress which elected Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer federal chair, he won one of 26 additional seats. The state CDU’s biography ends that elected membership in January 2022, when a federal congress chose a new executive under Friedrich Merz.

Member of the European Parliament

Terms, committees and delegations

Herbert Reul, of the Christian Democratic Union of Germany (CDU), was a Member of the European Parliament from 20 July 2004 until 7 July 2017, across three parliamentary terms. He sat in the European People's Party Group, styled EPP-ED until 2009.

He was a full member of the Committee on Industry, Research and Energy (ITRE) throughout and chaired it from 16 July 2009 to 18 January 2012. He was a substitute on the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs through the sixth term and until March 2012, a member of the Temporary Committee on Climate Change from 10 May 2007 to 4 February 2009, and a substitute on the Committee on Transport and Tourism for most of the eighth term.

He belonged to the delegation for relations with China from September 2004 until February 2012, and was at other times a substitute on the delegations for Israel, for parliamentary cooperation with Russia, and for the United States. From 16 February 2012 until the end of that term he chaired the delegation for the Korean Peninsula, covering South Korea and North Korea, and remained a member until 2017. In July 2013 he spent five days in North Korea with a 14-member delegation, meeting parliamentarians and vice-ministers; the group saw Kaesong but not the joint industrial zone, closed that April. He found Pyongyang strikingly clean and heavily policed, noted more cars and phones than earlier visitors had described, and said nuclear rearmament would keep talks difficult.

Energy and industrial policy

For about three years before the ITRE chair he was energy spokesman for the German Christian Democrats in the Parliament. His 2007 own-initiative report, Conventional Energy Sources and Energy Technology, was adopted on 24 October 2007 by 509 votes to 153, with 30 abstentions. It called nuclear power "indispensable if basic energy needs are to be met in Europe in the medium term" and said that, as then the largest low-carbon source in Europe, abandoning it would make greenhouse-gas targets impossible. He was also rapporteur for the March 2009 resolution "Facing oil challenges" and, from July 2011, for the Parliament's recommendation on the EU–US agreement covering Galileo and GPS.))

Appointed on 4 July 2012, he reported on renewable energy in the internal energy market; the Parliament adopted the text on 21 May 2013.) As the group's shadow on the Energy Roadmap 2050, he told ITRE in May 2012 that national subsidy schemes for renewable energy were wasteful "Kleinstaaterei" and should be run at European level. Supply, he said, must not rest on one carrier — "sun, wind, water, coal, gas and nuclear" — and the Commission's scenarios still gave nuclear a decisive role; efficiency, he argued, would come chiefly from technology and from consumers' own costs.

A September 2009 profile quoted him doubting "whether mankind actually contributes as much to climate change as is commonly assumed," which the article said put him at odds with Chancellor Angela Merkel and with much of the committee. He asked, "What is wrong about the industry committee acting as the lobby group for European industry?"

Chair of the CDU/CSU delegation

On 18 January 2012, during the Strasbourg session, the CDU/CSU delegation elected him chairman by 23 votes to 19 over Klaus-Heiner Lehne, replacing Werner Langen, who had stepped aside for personal reasons. Markus Ferber of the CSU stayed co-chairman, and Reul left the ITRE chair to take the post, which he still held in February 2017.

When it was disputed whether Parliament president Martin Schulz, of the Social Democratic Party of Germany, would stay beyond the informal rotation between the two largest groups, Reul's office compiled a file later titled "Sammlung zu Martin Schulz." On 13 February 2017, after Schulz had left to run for chancellor, Reul circulated an updated nine-page version on aides' jobs, the mixing of the presidency with the 2014 Commission campaign, and positions conservatives called contrary to German interests. SPD general secretary Katarina Barley called it a dirt campaign; Reul said it had been written for the earlier argument over Schulz staying in office, then updated.

Armin Laschet appointed him interior minister of North Rhine-Westphalia on 30 June 2017, and the European mandate ended on 7 July. The Parliament nevertheless paid a full July allowance of €6,611.42, which its administration said could not be repaid. Reul told the Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger he would give the money to the Polizei-Stiftung NRW, a charity for officers left seriously ill or unfit for duty; the Rheinische Post reported that he had.

Outside interests and RheinEnergie

In May 2011 LobbyControl, drawing on a Corporate Europe Observatory study, listed Reul among German members whose outside income it treated as a possible conflict of interest: while chairing ITRE he was, it wrote, a paid supervisory-board member of RheinEnergie AG, a Cologne utility in which RWE held 20 per cent. The groups called this a risk, not proven misconduct, and urged a ban on paid posts at companies with a stake in a member's legislation.

The Observatory's June 2011 report Europe's Resource Grab repeated the board seat and the RWE holding and called Reul a vice-president of the European Energy Forum, whose corporate members included RWE and other energy firms. Citing German press reports, it said he had tabled lobby-drafted amendments on the energy market and car CO2 rules. That account was the NGO's, not a parliamentary finding.

RheinEnergie's 2014 report still listed him on the supervisory board, as an MEP, until 5 September 2014. GEW Köln AG held 80 per cent of the €400 million share capital and RWE Deutschland AG 20 per cent; the accounts do not show a stake for the business later separated as innogy. Members were paid €500 per meeting attended, and Reul's 2014 fee, to 5 September, was €3,500. His declaration of 4 June 2014 listed the supervisory-board seat; one dated 7 June 2017 listed RheinEnergie's Cologne advisory board, and the European Energy Forum, both as unpaid. Neither the NGO reports nor those disclosures record a parliamentary sanction over the posts.

Interior minister of North Rhine-Westphalia

Appointment and reappointment

Herbert Reul has been Minister of the Interior (Minister des Innern) of North Rhine-Westphalia since 30 June 2017, when Minister-President Armin Laschet appointed the state cabinet in Düsseldorf. The Landtag of North Rhine-Westphalia had elected Laschet on 27 June 2017, after the election of 14 May gave the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) 72 seats and the Free Democratic Party (FDP) 28 in a chamber of 199, a majority of one. Reul, a member of the European Parliament from 2004 until he took the post, succeeded Ralf Jäger of the Social Democratic Party (SPD), minister for the interior and municipal affairs from July 2010 to June 2017. The state government counts him as the 16th holder of the interior portfolio.

The change of government also recast the department. A decree of 13 July 2017, issued by Laschet under the state constitution, renamed the Ministry for the Interior and Municipal Affairs (Ministerium für Inneres und Kommunales) the Ministry of the Interior (Ministerium des Innern). Municipal constitutional law and local-government finance passed to the new ministry for homeland, municipal affairs, building and equality; sport other than school sport went to the minister-president; and immigration, asylum and nationality moved to the ministry then responsible for integration. A consolidated allocation of 29 March 2018 left the interior ministry with the police, the state Office for the Protection of the Constitution, elections, general public order (including association, assembly and weapons matters), registration and identity documents, parts of public-service law, data protection, and civil defence, fire protection and disaster protection.

Reul remained when Laschet resigned on 25 October 2021. The Landtag stated that the office of minister-president is incompatible with a Bundestag seat, which Laschet took at that chamber’s constitutive sitting, and on 27 October it elected Hendrik Wüst by 103 votes to 90, with three abstentions. The CDU–FDP coalition continued as the first Wüst cabinet. On 3 November 2021 the Landtag swore the ministers in again; Reul took the oath as Minister des Innern, and Ina Brandes became transport minister, the post Wüst had held in the Laschet cabinet.

After the state election of 15 May 2022, the Landtag re-elected Wüst on 28 June 2022 by 106 of 181 votes, to lead the state’s first coalition of the CDU and Alliance 90/The Greens. The next day, at the K21 Ständehaus in Düsseldorf, Wüst gave Reul a new deed of appointment as interior minister in the second Wüst cabinet, and the Landtag administered the oath. The title remained Minister des Innern. A decree of 11 July 2022 expressly placed cybersecurity in the interior ministry and did not rename it; municipal affairs and sport stayed outside the remit. His record on police powers and staffing, organized crime and extremism, protest, and disaster response is treated in later sections.

Bundesrat and intergovernmental roles

As a member of the Land government, Reul represents North Rhine-Westphalia in the Bundesrat. That body’s profile records him as a full member from 30 June 2017 to 30 June 2022 and, from that day, as a deputy member (stellvertretendes Mitglied). The full membership therefore ran through the Laschet government and the first Wüst cabinet, and the change of status is dated the day after the second cabinet was sworn in. The same profile places him on the Committee on Internal Affairs (Ausschuss für Innere Angelegenheiten) and the Committee on Defence (Ausschuss für Verteidigung).

He is also listed as a member of the Innenministerkonferenz, the standing conference of the Länder interior ministers and senators. Its membership entry identifies him as Minister des Innern of North Rhine-Westphalia and repeats the deputy Bundesrat status and the two committee seats.

Police powers, staffing and accountability

The 2018 police act and later court rulings

In October 2018 Interior Minister Herbert Reul, of the Christian Democratic Union, and the CDU–Free Democratic Party coalition in North Rhine-Westphalia removed “drohende Gefahr” (“impending danger”) from a draft police act and narrowed preventive custody and covert surveillance. Reul said the change limited the chance of a constitutional defeat while still updating powers against terrorism. Thousands protested, and former FDP politicians Burkhard Hirsch and Gerhart Baum threatened a constitutional complaint. Data-protection commissioner Helga Block called the draft “extremely critical,” objecting to wider video surveillance and to telecommunications monitoring as a grave interference with the Basic Law, and warning of intelligence-style powers used, as a rule, against uninvolved people.

On 12 December 2018 the Landtag passed the Gesetz zur Stärkung der Sicherheit in Nordrhein-Westfalen. The SPD voted with the coalition; Alliance 90/The Greens voted no and again threatened a constitutional lawsuit; the Alternative for Germany abstained because it wanted the changes to go further. The act of 13 December let a judge authorize intrusion into a device to read ongoing, including encrypted, communications, but not a general search of stored data, and only given a present danger to the state or to life or limb, or concrete signs of a foreseeable terrorist offence. Courts could order electronic location monitoring of terrorist suspects and, in extreme cases, of sex offenders, stalkers or serious domestic abusers; open video observation was widened; and suspicionless “strategic” stops were allowed for an occasion such as a burglary series. Custody to prevent an immediately impending felony could last up to 14 days, extendable once by up to 14 days.

On 14 November 2024, published on 3 January 2025, the First Senate of the Federal Constitutional Court held in 1 BvL 3/22 that long-term observation combined with covert imaging and recording violated the right to informational self-determination. A belief that someone meant to commit serious offences was too low and vague a threshold; a concrete danger, or at least a “concretized” one, was required. The provisions continued only on that condition, and only until 31 December 2025. The case began with a woman photographed in 2015 during observation of a man treated as a right-wing extremist threat.

Orders of 24 June 2025, published on 7 August 2025, upheld the state’s preventive source-telecommunications power. In 1 BvR 2466/19 the Senate found section 20c, so far as the complaint was admissible, compatible with the Basic Law. In 1 BvR 180/23 it partly struck down federal source-interception rules and held the federal online-search power unconstitutional in part.

Recruitment, equipment and identification

In October 2017 the Landtag, by the votes of the CDU, FDP and AfD, abolished individualized numbers that the previous SPD–Green government had required from December 2016 on public-order and alarm units. Reul called the duty unnecessary and introduced “without need.” On 25 September 2019 the ministry announced about 9,000 body-worn cameras by the end of 2020, at about seven million euros, after a pilot it said had shown a de-escalating effect; recordings were to be kept 14 days. Conducted-energy devices trialled from January, after a mid-2020 decision, in Dortmund, Düsseldorf, Gelsenkirchen and the Rhein-Erft district were then bought for the five largest forces: 620 devices, four million euros with accessories. Of 140 pilot uses, the ministry counted 114 threats and 26 discharges. From 1 September 2023 it accepted 3,000 officer candidates, called its largest intake, from 11,335 applications.

Misconduct, deaths in custody and oversight

In July 2018, during an antisemitic assault in Bonn, officers mistook the victim for the attacker. Police said a man with Palestinian roots had knocked the kippa from a US-based Israeli philosophy professor and shouted “No Jew in Germany,” then pinned and struck him when he did not stop. Police president Ursula Brohl-Sowa called it a “terrible and regrettable misunderstanding” and apologized. In 2019 prosecutors dropped the case against four officers as a lawful response to resistance. The professor, Jitzchak Jochanan Melamed, said he had been passive and was struck dozens of times.

After 26-year-old Syrian Amed A. died following a cell fire at Kleve prison, Reul told a special committee sitting on 5 October 2018 that officers had, contrary to instructions, failed to verify his identity. He had been held for Amedy G., a Malian man sought in Hamburg who did not resemble him, and died two weeks after the fire in a Bochum hospital. Reul apologized; the officers were investigated but not suspended. Green deputy Stefan Engstfeld called it a police and justice scandal.

In September 2020 Reul suspended 29 officers from five WhatsApp groups, mostly a Mülheim patrol team, over far-right images including Hitler, swastikas and, in his description, a fictional refugee in a gas chamber. Eleven faced criminal investigation. He called it a disgrace that hit the police “to the core,” rejected a structural problem, but said these were no longer isolated cases, and ordered a special inspection and a commissioner. In November 2021 he suspended five Cologne officers over suspected dangerous bodily harm in office after a 24 April struggle in Cologne-Bickendorf with a 59-year-old Italian man who died two months later; whether the injuries caused the death was unclear. Reul said private boasts of violence were not far-right, but had no place in the police.

On 8 August 2022 officers fatally shot Mouhamed Dramé, a 16-year-old Senegalese refugee, in a Dortmund youth-facility courtyard while he held a knife, possibly intending suicide. Body cameras were off. WDR reported pepper spray within two minutes, then a conducted-energy device, then six submachine-gun rounds, four of them hits, and no warning; the state FDP said the spray created the dynamic. On 12 December 2024 the Dortmund regional court acquitted all five officers for mistaken self-defense. The judgment was not yet final.

Organized crime, extremism and major attacks

Clan crime

As interior minister of North Rhine-Westphalia, Herbert Reul of the Christian Democratic Union ran a “Politik der 1000 Nadelstiche” against Clankriminalität: repeated checks, with order offices and tax authorities, of shisha bars and similar premises, plus longer investigations. He called the raids a marathon after thirty years of inaction.

Since 2018 a name-based Lagebild has counted offences by suspects with surnames classed as relevant, limited to criminal members of Turkish-Arab extended families linked to Lebanon or the Mhallamiye. In 2024 the list held 118 names. About 6,700 offences were recorded, about 300 fewer than in 2023, mainly because cannabis legalisation cut drug-consumption cases from 579 to 337. Suspects rose from 4,213 to 4,282. About 700 raids checked about 1,700 premises; assets provisionally secured rose from about €960,000 to about €1.75 million. Clan-linked brawls fell from 12 in 2019 to one.

In October 2025 he told Bild that Lebanese clans were “simply more stupid, to put it briefly”, than groups that worked in secret, because they displayed strength openly, and that many immigrants preferred “the law of the family” to a legal order they did not know. The Federal Criminal Police Office defines a clan by descent and norms, not ethnicity, but state reports locate the phenomenon in Turkish, Kurdish and Arab communities. Deutschlandfunk reported that every assault and fine against one of 118 such surnames entered the 2023 count of about 7,000 offences. Mahmoud Jaraba has said most people in those families are not criminal; Astrid Jacobsen has urged dropping the label for systematic discrimination. Reul says many suspects are German citizens and that family and clan cannot be cleanly separated.

Islamist extremism and the Solingen attack

In the 2024 domestic-intelligence report, presented on 9 April 2025, the extremist Salafi potential was about 2,700, about 600 of them violence-oriented, inside a wider Islamist potential of about 4,010. The attack risk was “abstractly high”, above all from lone actors radicalising online. Reul called Islamist terrorism the greatest danger to life and limb, right-wing extremism the greatest threat to democratic coexistence, and Solingen the point at which that risk became an attack.

On the evening of 23 August 2024, at the Festival of Diversity on the Fronhof, the Syrian national Issa al H. killed three people with stabs to the neck and injured eight others. On 10 September 2025 the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court convicted him of multiple murder and attempted murder and of membership of the Islamic State, imposed life imprisonment with a finding of especially grave guilt, and ordered preventive detention. It found he had adopted the group’s ideology from 2019, entered as an asylum seeker in late 2022, been encouraged on Telegram, and sent claim videos beforehand. The Federal Court of Justice rejected his appeal on 12 May 2026 and restated the findings as three treacherous murders from base motives and attempts on ten further people, eight of them injured. The judgment is final.

A Dublin Regulation transfer to Bulgaria had failed in June 2023: he was not in his room at the Paderborn shelter, no second attempt followed, the deadline lapsed, and he received subsidiary protection. The shelter had not reported a multi-day absence. Josefine Paul of Alliance 90/The Greens, then refugees minister, called Dublin dysfunctional. Nancy Faeser, the federal interior minister from the Social Democratic Party, told the inquiry that not announcing the removal had forfeited a twelve-month extension, and that attendance lists were opened to the foreigners authorities only after the attack.

The Landtag opened an all-party inquiry on 14 November 2024, proposed by the governing parties. Paul, in France, was unreachable until Sunday midday and, unlike Reul and minister-president Hendrik Wüst, did not go to Solingen. She said she had no secured knowledge until Sunday morning that her ministry was involved, and resigned at the end of January 2026, citing polarisation around her. The opposition won an order for withheld messages. By August 2026 the committee had sat 39 times without a report. Reul said there was still no sign of an Islamist network in Germany and that radicalisation had mainly been online, though the files showed contact with two Islamist Gefährder. A roommate’s report of Islamic State videos, relayed by a social worker, remained unresolved: Reul could not say if it reached the police, and the committee had no file.

Right-wing extremism and Reichsbürger

The same report put the right-wing extremist potential at 4,010, up from 3,745, including 1,840 classed as violence-oriented. Right-wing politically motivated offences rose from 3,549 to 5,461, 78 per cent of them propaganda or incitement, with violent offences up from 116 to 154. Reul said the milieu was younger — trainers and “Active Clubs”, not “bald heads and combat boots”. Reichsbürger and Selbstverwalter are counted separately, at about 3,700 (about 3,400 a year earlier): people who deny the Federal Republic, only a smaller part of whom are also classed as clearly right-wing extremist.

On 7 December 2022 the Federal Public Prosecutor General had 25 suspected members and supporters of a Reichsbürger group arrested, and more than 130 sites searched in eleven states, over a plan to overthrow the constitutional order by force, including killings. Heinrich XIII Prinz Reuss was an alleged ringleader. Searches in the state, but no arrests, included the home of a non-senior police officer; the intelligence report lists an officer from the state among the accused, and trials of 26 defendants opened in 2024. Reul called them “a gang of terrorists” and said he was shaken that some came from the military and the security services.

From early 2017 to 29 February 2024 the ministry logged 370 far-right indications in the state police; 17 of 83 sanctioned cases ended the civil-service relationship, and eight officers had come to notice since 2016 over suspected Reichsbürger ties. After chats that included a swastika made from service ammunition, Reul in November 2020 created a staff unit on right-wing tendencies in the police. The 7 April 2018 attack in Münster, in which Jens R. drove into a crowd and shot himself, was not classed as extremist. By Reul’s 19 April briefing two people were dead and more than 20 injured; he reported no far-right contacts or texts.

Protest, disaster response and civil liberties

Assembly law and climate protest

Until 2022, outdoor protest in North Rhine-Westphalia was still governed by the federal assembly statute. On 15 December 2021 the Landtag passed a state law with the votes of the CDU and the FDP; the statute is dated 17 December 2021, was promulgated on 6 January 2022 and took effect the next day. Herbert Reul called it a way of balancing the freedom of assembly with police work. The Act restates that right under Article 8 of the Basic Law and adds a ban on disrupting assemblies, powers to restrict or dissolve outdoor gatherings, rules against masking and intimidation, and a flat rule that no assembly takes place on a federal motorway.

The January 2021 draft treated the Federal Constitutional Court's 1985 Brokdorf decision as limiting the legislature. Its memorandum discussed pit-edge roads at the Garzweiler mine as places that might be closed to assemblies, citing remarks Reul made in committee on 4 July 2019, and grouped same-coloured overalls at the 2019 Garzweiler demonstrations with the "black bloc" and neo-Nazi groups. The SPD said the bill seemed meant to prevent assemblies; the Greens said it treated every assembly as a danger. An alliance of about 180 organisations called it the most authoritarian assembly law in Germany. On 4 January 2023 the Gesellschaft für Freiheitsrechte and that alliance filed a constitutional complaint against the new offences, wider video surveillance and the motorway ban, arguing that those rules were aimed at climate protest.

After Munich-led searches on 24 May 2023, in seven Länder other than North Rhine-Westphalia, Reul urged a federal check on whether the Last Generation was a criminal organisation. He said the gluing actions were an imposition and that a structure lay behind them, a review Union interior ministers had sought in late 2022. His ministry said the group was not then a domestic-intelligence case, but that by the end of April 2023 it had logged 16 unregistered assemblies, 184 people detached from the road and 19 taken into temporary custody, plus attempts to close oil-pipeline valves. Justice minister Benjamin Limbach said he would not instruct prosecutors to examine the question.

Pandemic public order

In the early COVID-19 pandemic, a decree of 9 April 2020 told police that assemblies should as a rule stay strictly forbidden. The ministry said Reul had "no understanding at all" that demonstrations should continue while schools, culture, sport and churches were closed. A report to the Landtag counted 102 assemblies registered since the Corona protection ordinance: 44 withdrawn, 51 banned and seven allowed under conditions such as marked distances. Police broke up nine unregistered gatherings. By December 2021 Reul said many protests were unregistered, police were surprised by the numbers, and the scene was being infiltrated. The state, he said, had chosen "zero tolerance" and would draw a line early.

The 2021 flood

The floods of mid-July 2021, caused by the low "Bernd" and part of the wider 2021 European floods, killed 49 people in North Rhine-Westphalia. Damage was later put at about 13 billion euros.

Reul was on holiday near Lübeck. He told the inquiry that the drive to Leichlingen on 15 July took eleven hours on flooded motorways, and that he refused a police helicopter so it could be used for rescues. He reached the ministry that evening and later asked whether he should have ended the holiday a day sooner. The SPD said the key information had reached him on 13 July and that he issued no broad warning through the public broadcaster.

The state did not convene a crisis staff of the interior minister and state secretaries. It used a coordination group of liaison officers and outside specialists in the interior ministry. Armin Laschet, then minister-president, said in December 2021 that he had consulted Reul, that he had not known of an internal proposal for a full staff, and that nothing had gone wrong for lack of one. Reul said in March 2022 that changing the structure mid-operation would have lost time, but that the large staff would have been a clearer public signal, and that the 2016 law leaving disaster management to counties and cities did not fit a regional disaster.

The final report, adopted in June 2025 by the CDU, the Greens, the SPD and the FDP, with the AfD abstaining, and presented on 9 July 2025, found poor situation reporting, an underestimate of the danger, and no statewide severe-weather warning from the interior ministry although the law allowed one. The government, it said, reacted clearly too late. The coordination group began work only on 15 July, after many people had died; people in the Eifel could still have been warned on the 14th. The committee did not agree that there was unambiguous proof of faulty crisis management, while treating improvement as undisputed. It criticised environment minister Ursula Heinen-Esser, then on Mallorca, for not speaking to Reul in the critical phase; she resigned in 2022.

Sirens had often failed or been removed. A civil-protection team Reul appointed produced a 15-point plan; within a year about 400 extra sirens were installed, to warn residents rather than also to call out firefighters. He said the death toll meant mistakes had been made. By 2025 the parties noted new flood posts and sirens; the committee still wanted a real-time situation picture, more gauges, a non-police coordination centre and a statutory rule for crisis staffs.

Personal life and public standing

Family, faith and residence

Herbert Reul was born on 31 August 1952 in Langenfeld and has called Leichlingen, in the Rheinisch-Bergischer Kreis, his hometown. He is married to Gundula Reul and is the father of three daughters. The Bundesrat lists him as Roman Catholic, and the interior ministry of North Rhine-Westphalia gives Leichlingen as his place of residence.

His father, Karl Reul, a Christian Democratic Union member, taught at the Catholic primary school on Kirchstraße, became its rector in 1964, sat on the town council from 1957 to 1999 and was honorary mayor from 1975 to 1994. He died in 2015, aged 92. The Landtag biography lists Herbert Reul on the advisory board of the Karl Reul Foundation in Leichlingen.

Honours and reputation

In 1999 Ulrich Schmidt, president of the Landtag of North Rhine-Westphalia, presented Reul, then deputy chairman of the CDU parliamentary group, with the Cross of Merit on Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany. The parliamentary magazine reported the ceremony, conferred by the federal president, in its issue of 8 June 1999; Gundula Reul and CDU group leader Laurenz Meyer were present. On 1 August 2018 the Office of the Federal President announced that Reul, of Leichlingen, had received the Cross of Merit, 1st Class.

He was a full member of the broadcasting council of Westdeutscher Rundfunk, sent by the Landtag, after the body was reconstituted on 4 December 2003 for a six-year term. In the next term, from 2 December 2009 to 2 December 2016, the WDR listed him as a deputy member.

News outlets have called him the "schwarzer Sheriff". The Süddeutsche Zeitung used the phrase in a headline on 28 May 2024, and a WDR commentary on 3 April 2024 concluded that the "black sheriff" had failed against crime. That commentary also said he was often the most approved member of the state government and was valued for humour and plain speech, while treating lines such as "zero tolerance" as close to populism. In an Infratest dimap poll for WDR, taken from 22 to 25 April 2024 among 1,181 eligible voters, 51 percent were satisfied with his work, up three points and above the 47 percent for minister-president Hendrik Wüst.

Assessments from police unions, the opposition and civil-liberties groups are more critical. In May 2025 Ernst Herget of the Gewerkschaft der Polizei in NRW called Reul's claim that the criminal police were not under permanent statewide overload "neither comforting nor helpful". In August 2025 Social Democratic Party interior spokesperson Christina Kampmann called a plan to record suspects with more than one passport a dead end and rejected any split between first- and second-class Germans. On 4 January 2023 the Gesellschaft für Freiheitsrechte, with the alliance "Versammlungsgesetz NRW stoppen!", asked the state constitutional court to annul parts of the assembly law in force since January 2022, including new offences, wider surveillance and a ban on motorway assemblies, which the complainants said deterred the use of the freedom of assembly.

Evidence & methodology

How the record is sourced and how the score is derived.

The score is formula-derived (Factrail formula v1, version 1.0.0), not an editorial verdict. Read the methodology.

By the · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed

Dispute a fact on this pageNamed here, or represent someone who is? Request a right of reply.