Christchurch Call

Summary
The Christchurch Call, formally the Christchurch Call to Action to Eliminate Terrorist and Violent Extremist Content Online, is a voluntary pledge by governments and online service providers to prevent the upload and spread of terrorist and violent extremist content. It was launched on 15 May 2019 at a summit in Paris co-chaired by New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern and French president Emmanuel Macron.
Expert article
The Christchurch Call, formally the Christchurch Call to Action to Eliminate Terrorist and Violent Extremist Content Online, is a voluntary pledge by governments and online service providers to prevent the upload and spread of terrorist and violent extremist content. It was launched on 15 May 2019 at a summit in Paris co-chaired by New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern and French president Emmanuel Macron. The document says that every step taken under it must be consistent with a free, open and secure internet and with human rights, including freedom of expression, and it creates no legal obligation on those who endorse it.
The Call was a response to the Christchurch mosque shootings of 15 March 2019, in which 51 people were killed and 39 injured at two mosques in Christchurch. The attacker livestreamed the killings on Facebook for almost 17 minutes, and copies of the recording continued to circulate on other services, including YouTube, after platforms tried to remove them. The French presidency described the attacks as designed to go viral.
At the Paris meeting, governments and companies accepted collective commitments on the enforcement of laws against this material, rapid removal, public reporting, review of the algorithms that can amplify it, help for smaller platforms, and a shared crisis protocol. Signatories at the table included Australia, Canada, Indonesia, Ireland, Jordan, Norway, Senegal and the United Kingdom, with the European Commission, Amazon, Dailymotion, Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Qwant, Twitter and YouTube; Germany, India, Japan, the Netherlands, Spain and Sweden were reported as expressing support. The United States said it backed the aims but was not in a position to join, pointing to freedom of speech.
On 7 May 2021 the United States announced that it would join, and said that it would not take steps violating the First Amendment's protections of speech and association or reasonable expectations of privacy. The Call was administered inside New Zealand's Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. On 14 May 2024 it was reconstituted as the Christchurch Call Foundation, a charity outside that department, with Ardern moving from special envoy to patron and New Zealand public funding ending. The digital-rights group Access Now argued that the 2019 text had been drafted behind closed doors and that a hurried focus on online speech could put fundamental rights at risk.
Background
The 15 March 2019 attacks
On 15 March 2019, during Friday prayers, the Christchurch mosque shootings took place at the Al Noor Mosque on Deans Avenue and the Linwood Islamic Centre in Christchurch, New Zealand. New Zealand Police recorded that between 1.40pm and 1.50pm the attacker shot 51 people dead and wounded 89 others—40 by gunshot and 49 otherwise—before a two-officer patrol arrested him on Brougham Street. He wore a helmet-mounted camera, fired inside both mosques, and shot at people and vehicles between the sites. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern called the attacks terrorism. On the livestream the gunman identified himself as Brenton Tarrant, a 28-year-old Australian; he had expressed racist, anti-immigrant views and appeared to have published a document outlining his plans.
Online dissemination
The recording, from the attacker’s point of view, was streamed to Facebook. New Zealand’s Classification Office later measured it at 16 minutes and 55 seconds. Facebook said the live broadcast drew fewer than 200 views and about 4,000 in total before removal; nobody reported it while it was live, and the first user report came 29 minutes after the stream began, 12 minutes after it ended. Police had alerted the company shortly after the livestream started, and Facebook said the video and the attacker’s Facebook and Instagram accounts were removed within minutes of that contact. Before the alert, a user on 8chan posted a link to a copy on a file-sharing site; Facebook said forensic markers on many later copies matched that file. In the first 24 hours the company said it removed about 1.5 million videos of the attack, blocking more than 1.2 million at upload, and shared more than 800 visually distinct variants with other members of the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism.
Re-uploads still outpaced deletion. YouTube said videos arrived at an unprecedented rate, at times one a second, and that it automatically rejected footage of the violence and temporarily stopped searches sorted by upload date. The Guardian found copies still up for hours, including clips left behind warnings and edits with the most explicit violence cut. Twitter said it was removing re-uploads and would work with law enforcement. Reddit banned r/watchpeopledie, where the footage had been reposted, for glorifying violence, and removed the video and the attacker’s document site-wide. MailOnline, the Mirror and the Sun also carried short excerpts or, briefly, the document, and several later took them down. On 18 March 2019 the Classification Office classified the livestream as objectionable under the Films, Videos, and Publications Classification Act 1993, finding that it promoted extreme violence and terrorism.
Earlier multilateral and industry efforts
The Christchurch Call text published by the French presidency described the attacks as designed to go viral and listed work it said was already under way: the European Commission’s EU Internet Forum; efforts at the G7 and G20; the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism; the Global Counterterrorism Forum; Tech Against Terrorism; and Jordan’s Aqaba Process.
The EU Internet Forum opened in Brussels on 3 December 2015 as a voluntary meeting of European Union interior ministers, Europol, the EU counter-terrorism coordinator and firms including Ask.fm, Facebook, Google, Microsoft and Twitter. The Commission presented it as a public-private partnership for faster removal of terrorist material and online hate speech, and for counter-narratives, while separating illegal incitement from freedom of expression. On 26 June 2017 Facebook, Microsoft, Twitter and YouTube announced the GIFCT to share technical and operational practices, including their existing shared database of hashes of known terrorist images and video, plus research and support for smaller companies. Alongside that, the United Nations Counter-Terrorism Committee Executive Directorate and the Swiss organisation ICT4Peace launched Tech Against Terrorism at RightsCon in Brussels, aimed at smaller platforms that lacked the staff and tools of the largest services.
The Global Counterterrorism Forum, launched in 2011, is an informal grouping of governments that produces non-binding civilian counterterrorism practices, not a content-removal system. The Aqaba Process, started in 2015 by King Abdullah II of Jordan, is a separate high-level forum on terrorism and violent extremism, organised around prevention, coordination and gaps in existing cooperation.
Paris summit
Convening and participants
On 15 May 2019, two months after the Christchurch mosque shootings, New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and France’s President Emmanuel Macron co-chaired a meeting at the Élysée Palace in Paris. The Élysée described it as 10 heads of state and government with technology leaders and other organisations, alongside a G7 digital ministers’ meeting.
Macron said the leaders of Jordan, Senegal, Indonesia, Norway, Canada, the United Kingdom and Ireland, and European Commission president Juncker, joined him and Ardern, among them King Abdullah II, Sall, Solberg, May and Canada’s Justin Trudeau. Firms he named as represented at senior level were Twitter, whose chief executive Jack Dorsey attended, Microsoft, Google and YouTube, Facebook, Dailymotion, Qwant and Amazon, with the Wikimedia Foundation and French and New Zealand internet civil-society groups. Facebook sent Nick Clegg. Mark Zuckerberg had met Macron in Paris the week before; Macron said he missed the summit for personal reasons. No United States representative was there.
The Guardian reported that Britain, Canada, Australia, Jordan, Senegal, Indonesia, Norway and Ireland signed, with the Commission and Amazon, Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Twitter, YouTube, Dailymotion and Qwant (spelled “Quant” in that account). It said the Élysée described Germany, India, Japan, the Netherlands, Spain and Sweden as expressing support rather than signing that day.
Adoption
The meeting adopted the Christchurch Call to Action to Eliminate Terrorist and Violent Extremist Content Online, a voluntary text with no enforcement body. It sets commitments for governments, for online service providers, and for both together, and says measures must stay consistent with a free, open and secure internet and with human rights, including freedom of expression. Macron said officials would meet in Aqaba in June, that France and New Zealand would share a secretariat, and that a first review was planned for September in New York during the United Nations General Assembly.
Immediate response
The same day Facebook, Amazon, Google, Twitter and Microsoft published a nine-point plan beside the Call, covering stricter terms of use, user reporting, detection tools, livestream checks, transparency reports, shared technology for smaller firms, a crisis protocol, public education, and research on hate. Facebook separately announced a “one-strike” limit on Facebook Live for users who shared violating material. Ardern called that a first step and said the Christchurch attacker would not have been able to livestream under it.
The United States did not endorse the Call. The White House said it was “not currently in a position to join the endorsement” but supported the “overall goals,” and would keep countering terrorist content “while also continuing to respect freedom of expression and freedom of the press.” It added that “the best tool to defeat terrorist speech is productive speech,” through “credible, alternative narratives.” Macron called those shared aims “a positive element” and said he would seek a more formal commitment. The United States joined the Call in 2021.
The day before, Ardern hosted a civil-society meeting in Paris, “Voices for Action.” Access Now, which attended, said the draft was negotiated with governments and companies behind closed doors and circulated only two working days earlier, for discussion of implementation rather than wording—a meeting it said Ardern called reportedly over French objections. It welcomed the human-rights and transparency language, and warned that “terrorist and violent extremist content” was undefined and that the text leaned on upload filters. David Kaye, then the UN special rapporteur on freedom of expression, told Politico that these were “matters of public debate” in which governments had a role, but that his concern was “the approach that they decide to take.”
Commitments
The Christchurch Call to Action to Eliminate Terrorist and Violent Extremist Content Online, published by the Presidency of France on 15 May 2019, sets out “collective, voluntary commitments” by governments and online service providers. It is not a treaty. It creates no offence, penalty, deadline or enforcement body, does not define “terrorist and violent extremist content,” and requires neither a particular statute nor any named technology. The Observer Research Foundation has called it non-binding and noted that it cannot hold signatories liable for failing to comply. The United States Department of State said in 2021 that cooperation under the Call would remain voluntary and would not include steps violating constitutional speech protections or reasonable expectations of privacy.
Preamble and principles
The preamble calls a free, open and secure internet a means of connectivity, social inclusion and economic growth, while stating that it is open to abuse by terrorist and violent extremist actors. It cites the 15 March 2019 attacks on the Muslim community of Christchurch, which it says were designed to go viral, and states that dissemination harms the human rights of the victims, collective security and people elsewhere. It lists earlier work by the European Commission (including the EU Internet Forum), the G20, the G7 and France’s G7 presidency, the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism, the Global Counterterrorism Forum, Tech Against Terrorism, and the Aqaba Process of Jordan. It calls for cooperation among governments, civil society and online service providers, such as social media companies, to eliminate the content and prevent that abuse from recurring.
All action under the Call must be consistent with a free, open and secure internet, without compromising human rights and fundamental freedoms, including freedom of expression, and should recognise the internet’s role in innovation, economic development and inclusive societies.
Government commitments
Governments commit to counter drivers of terrorism and violent extremism by strengthening resilience and inclusion, including through education, media literacy against distorted narratives, and efforts against inequality. They pledge to enforce laws that already prohibit producing or disseminating the content, consistently with the rule of law and international human rights law, including freedom of expression. They undertake to encourage ethical standards in online depictions of terrorist events, and to support frameworks such as industry standards, so reporting does not amplify the content, without prejudice to responsible coverage. They agree only to “consider appropriate action” against use of online services to spread it: capacity-building for smaller providers, industry standards or voluntary frameworks, and regulatory or policy measures consistent with a free, open and secure internet and international human rights law, none of which the Call itself enacts.
Online service provider commitments
Providers commit to transparent, specific measures seeking to prevent upload and dissemination on social media and similar content-sharing services, including immediate and permanent removal, without prejudice to law-enforcement needs and user appeals, and consistently with human rights. Possible means, not requirements, include technology development, shared databases of hashes and URLs, and notice-and-takedown. Companies pledge to publish the consequences of sharing the content and to describe detection and removal rules; to enforce them by prioritising moderation however the content is identified, closing accounts where appropriate, and offering efficient appeals against removal or a refused upload; and to take immediate measures against livestreamed spread, including real-time review, without prescribing a technical method.
They also commit to regular, methodologically clear public reporting on the quantity and nature of content detected and removed, and to review algorithms and other processes that may drive users toward or amplify the content, changing them where that occurs. That review may include redirection, credible positive alternatives or counter-narratives, and multi-stakeholder reporting that does not compromise trade secrets or effectiveness through unnecessary disclosure. Providers also commit to industry coordination, including investment in and expansion of the GIFCT and the sharing of expertise.
Joint commitments
Governments and providers jointly commit to community-led work with civil society against violent extremism in all its forms, including positive alternatives and counter-messaging, and to redirection based on trusted information about algorithmic and other processes. They pledge faster research and open sharing of technical solutions to prevent upload and to detect and immediately remove the content, with input from academia, researchers and civil society, plus study of offline as well as online effects. Law-enforcement cooperation on illegal activity tied to detected or removed content must stay consistent with the rule of law and human-rights protections.
Other joint pledges are support for smaller platforms, including the GIFCT hash database; help for partner countries through coordination and trusted exchanges that respect data-protection and privacy rules; and rapid, coordinated processes after a terrorist event. Those processes may require a shared crisis protocol, consistent with human-rights protections; the Call does not establish one. Participants commit to respect human rights—and governments to protect them—including by avoiding and addressing adverse impacts of business activities. Civil society is to advise on rights-consistent implementation, work to increase transparency, and, where necessary, support users in company appeals. The text affirms continued work in existing forums and non-duplicative practical steps, and acknowledges, without requiring, further cooperation on a wider range of harmful online content, including discussions then expected at the G7 summit in Biarritz, the G20, the Aqaba Process, the Five Country Ministerial and other forums.
Supporters and the advisory network
Governments
The Christchurch Call sets out collective, voluntary commitments by governments and online service providers; it is not a legally binding treaty. On 15 May 2019 in Paris it was adopted by 17 countries and the European Commission of the European Union. They included the conveners, New Zealand and France, and Australia, Canada, India, Indonesia, Japan, Senegal and the United Kingdom, among others. The United States did not endorse it: the White House cited freedom of expression and of the press while supporting the aims.
On 24 September 2019, during United Nations General Assembly week, the Call's timeline records 31 further countries joining. The Association for Progressive Communications, present at that meeting, put support at 48 countries and three international organisations. On 7 May 2021 the Biden administration announced that the United States would join. Both the State Department and White House press secretary Jen Psaki said the United States would not take steps violating First Amendment freedoms of speech and association, or reasonable expectations of privacy; the State Department added that cooperation would remain voluntary. By 22 June 2022 New Zealand's foreign ministry described over 55 governments plus the European Commission.
The Christchurch Call Foundation's community page lists 56 government supporters, a figure that includes the European Commission and spans Europe, the Americas, Africa, the Middle East and the Indo-Pacific. A joint French–New Zealand note of 14 May 2024 used the same count of 56, as did the Federation of Islamic Associations of New Zealand in a Newstalk ZB interview the next day.
Online service providers
Eight companies endorsed the text in Paris: Amazon, Dailymotion, Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Qwant, Twitter and YouTube. On 22 June 2022 France and New Zealand announced Zoom and Roblox, bringing online service providers to 12. The Foundation's current list names 20. It keeps the original firms—Meta Platforms in place of Facebook, and X in place of Twitter—and adds later supporters such as Discord, OpenAI and Anthropic. The May 2024 joint note counted 19 providers, matching a Newstalk ZB interview that week which cited 19 technology companies. As with governments, the undertakings are voluntary. The Foundation says providers commit to keep their services from hosting or spreading terrorist and violent extremist content, consistently with human rights and a free, open and secure internet.
Christchurch Call Advisory Network
The Christchurch Call Advisory Network was announced at the 24 September 2019 leaders' meeting, alongside the new government supporters. It brings together civil society, academia and technical experts to advise on the commitments. The Association for Progressive Communications, a member from the start, described that advice as covering human rights, freedom of expression, digital rights, counter-radicalisation, victim support and public policy, and said it had joined to argue for a human-rights-based approach even though it did not endorse every aspect of the Call.
The network's terms of reference say it began with about 40 organisations and individuals who answered a 2019 invitation from the New Zealand and French governments. Membership is limited to non-governmental, not-for-profit organisations and to individuals who are independent of governments and companies. Their role is advice consistent with a free, open and secure internet and international human rights law; they do not themselves adopt the governmental and company commitments. New members are admitted by the network's core committee in consultation with France and New Zealand. The May 2024 joint note referred to more than 50 civil-society organisations in the wider community, which the Foundation still lists apart from the signatories.
Partner organisations
Partner organisations are a further category, separate from governments, companies and the advisory network. The Foundation describes them as bodies that support the Call's objectives through their own work, rather than as makers of the original pledge. The May 2024 note listed 13; the community page now lists 16, including the Council of Europe, UNESCO, the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism, Tech Against Terrorism, the Global Community Engagement and Resilience Fund, and VOX-Pol. Like the rest of the community, they participate voluntarily: the Call gives them no power to bind states or platforms.
Governance and the Foundation
Secretariat and summits
From its adoption in 2019, the Christchurch Call was co-led by New Zealand and France, with day-to-day administration inside the New Zealand government. Radio New Zealand reported that the initiative sat within the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. A 2023 Cabinet paper described the Christchurch Call Unit as a joint venture of that department and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade: the department supplied convening authority and digital-policy staff, and the ministry handled communications, country engagement, the Call website, and summit support through its posts.
Leaders' meetings set the direction between those officials. On 24 September 2019, during the high-level week of the United Nations General Assembly in New York City, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and President Emmanuel Macron reported on implementation at a meeting at the United Nations. The COVID-19 pandemic then prevented an in-person gathering. On 15 May 2021 (14 May in France) they co-chaired a virtual summit on the second anniversary, which New Zealand's foreign ministry called the first leaders' meeting since September 2019. It recorded 34 governments, eight companies and 30 civil society organisations, and said participants endorsed a work plan into 2022.
The community met again in New York on 20 September 2022, for leaders from government, online services and civil society to set priorities, including incident response and the Call's future focus. On 10 November 2023, during the Paris Peace Forum, Macron co-chaired what the Élysée described as the fifth leaders' summit, at the Élysée Palace, with Ardern by then special envoy. The joint statement said the co-founders would work with the community and potential funders on a more resilient secretariat, better able to draw contributions from across the multistakeholder group, with structural decisions before the fifth anniversary in 2024.
Special envoy
After Ardern left office, Prime Minister Chris Hipkins appointed her Special Envoy for the Christchurch Call. He announced the unpaid role on 4 April 2023: she would be New Zealand's senior representative, work closely with France, report directly to him, and have the appointment reviewed at the end of the year. The Cabinet paper records that he established the post on 23 March 2023, informed Cabinet on 27 March, and that she would take it up on 17 April 2023 through the end of 2023. She declined pay. Cabinet approved up to NZ$625,000 over 2022/23 and 2023/24, from the Prime Minister's Emerging Priorities Contingency, for staffing, travel, communications, events and related support, with a review in December 2023. Her duties were outreach to government, industry and civil-society leaders, convening gatherings, and oversight of the work programme. The role continued after the change of government. The May 2024 joint announcement by Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Macron said her term ended on 30 June 2024, and that she had advised and represented both Hipkins and Luxon.
Christchurch Call Foundation
On 14 May 2024 Luxon and Macron announced the Christchurch Call Foundation, a non-governmental organisation to coordinate the Call's work. Their statement said the step gave effect to the November 2023 summit, where leaders had endorsed a resilient secretariat ahead of the fifth anniversary. The foundation would be headquartered in Wellington, with points of presence elsewhere. New Zealand taxpayer funding would end on 30 June 2024; a secretariat funded by the foundation, which had pledges from Call community members and philanthropic donors, would operate from 1 July.
Radio New Zealand reported that the Call would continue as a charity outside the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet and would no longer receive public funding. Ardern said the move was meant to make the body more fully multistakeholder, and that she would cease to be special envoy and become patron of the organisation. The joint statement described the patron role as voluntary and unpaid, covering dialogue with leaders and outreach. It also said decisions on direction would remain with leaders from across the community, while the foundation coordinated support for civil society, industry and governments. The foundation's site describes the body as a charitable trust governed by a board of trustees.
Crisis response and industry coordination
Crisis Response Protocol
The May 2019 Call committed governments and online service providers to processes for a rapid, coordinated response when terrorist or violent extremist content spreads after an attack, and said this might require a shared crisis protocol consistent with human rights protections. On 23 September 2019, at meetings around the United Nations General Assembly, New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern and president Emmanuel Macron of France said that protocol was operationally ready. The New Zealand government said the framework, developed with companies, civil society, and law enforcement, would set thresholds for action and transparency standards, and that it would complement a European Union crisis framework then being developed with Europol. Companies in the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism were to act inside it through their own content-incident process, and Google was to host a first test in New Zealand that December.
The Call arrangement is separate from GIFCT's industry mechanism. The Christchurch Call Foundation describes the Crisis Response Protocol as a round-the-clock information-sharing network of more than 160 organisations, used dozens of times, and run alongside protocols operated by GIFCT, Tech Against Terrorism, and the EU Internet Forum. From 2 December 2024 an update made the Foundation the coordination point for the wider community, including the Christchurch Call Advisory Network: it was to circulate situational awareness, summarise responses, and flag gaps on human rights, access, and transparency.
Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism
GIFCT was formed in 2017 by Facebook, Microsoft, Twitter, and YouTube to share technology and knowledge on terrorist use of their services. Its main shared tool is a hash-sharing database of numerical fingerprints of images, video, and later other files. Members query the database and decide under their own rules whether to remove a match. GIFCT says the hashes are not user data and that it does not dictate enforcement. Inclusion originally tracked entities on the United Nations Security Council consolidated sanctions list and, from 2019, perpetrator recordings of offline attacks. The companies said the database held more than 200,000 unique hashes by September 2019.
At the same United Nations meetings, GIFCT said it would become an independent organisation, with an executive director, an industry operating board, and an advisory committee that governments could join. Amazon, LinkedIn, and WhatsApp were named as new participants, and the mission was widened from terrorist content to violent-extremist exploitation of platforms. France and New Zealand were to sit on the advisory committee.
A 2024 Wired investigation reported that the database had grown to millions of hashes and was hosted on servers of Facebook's parent, Meta Platforms. Members did not publish how many items they removed after a hash match, the board had not allowed an outside audit, and in 2022 hashes matched copies of a non-violent music video. Civil-society researchers had argued in 2019 that GIFCT's first transparency report left error rates, appeals, and the contents of hashes unclear, and that most entries sat under a broad "glorification" label.
Incident protocols and later revisions
GIFCT's Content Incident Protocol, introduced with the 2019 restructuring, was for cross-company communication when an attack might put perpetrator video online. It was first used after the Halle synagogue shooting of 9 October 2019, streamed on Twitch. GIFCT said founding companies were in contact from about 5:00 a.m. Pacific Time, the board declared the protocol at 10:09 a.m., and it ended at 8:17 a.m. the next day, after hashes of 36 visually distinct videos were shared and the German government and Europol were notified. GIFCT called the spread much smaller than after the Christchurch mosque shootings. Reuters reported that the companies withheld view and automatic-removal figures, which critics said made the first live test hard to assess.
GIFCT later said the protocol had been activated only three times through mid-2022: Halle; Glendale, Arizona, in May 2020; and the 2022 Buffalo shooting. A 2021 revision made it the top tier of an Incident Response Framework: ongoing events with perpetrator or accomplice video of murder or attempted murder, on a member platform or so widely available that spread was treated as inevitable. Lower tiers covered other perpetrator media and cases with a significant but unclear online element. Hash sharing applied to the upper two tiers.
For Buffalo, GIFCT activated the protocol at 4:52 p.m. Eastern time on 14 May 2022 and closed it at 6:31 p.m. the next day, after alerting members, the United States government, and its advisory committee. Members added about 870 items, about 740 images and 130 videos, including manifesto material. Wired reported that staff contacted YouTube, Meta, Twitter, and Microsoft, and that at least three of those board companies had to approve an alarm issued about two hours after the shooting.
On 24 September 2025 GIFCT retired those tiers for three non-hierarchical types, after an independent review and a multi-stakeholder working group. A Perpetrator Content Incident covers attacker-produced media of an event. A Digital Footprint Incident covers a substantial online presence without attack media. An Incident Advisory is for unclear or not obviously time-limited events and can shift to another type. GIFCT said the change was meant to cover a wider range of online activity around offline violence.
Algorithms, research and technology
Algorithms and redirection
The 2019 Call asked online service providers to review algorithms that might drive users toward, or amplify, terrorist and violent extremist content, and to change them where that occurred. It allowed redirection or positive alternatives, and a joint pledge to base interventions on trusted information-sharing, without exposing trade secrets. Both were voluntary undertakings, not a shared standard or a finished redirection tool.
YouTube’s recommendation changes are not documented as products of the Call. From January 2019, before the attacks, the company said it had made more than 30 changes to reduce recommendations of “borderline” content, and that U.S. watch time of that material from non-subscribed recommendations had fallen by about 70 percent. The Verge reported the claim and noted that YouTube did not publish the underlying counts.
In September 2022, Jacinda Ardern announced the Christchurch Call Initiative on Algorithmic Outcomes with New Zealand, the United States, Twitter (later operated by X Corp.), Microsoft, and OpenMined. A first project of about US$1.5 million was to let researchers study outcomes without taking raw data off company systems.
By November 2023 the system had been tested, and France, Dailymotion, and Georgetown University’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology had joined with a further US$1.3 million. An October 2024 report described remote audits, by four independent researchers, of recommender data at LinkedIn and Dailymotion using OpenMined’s PySyft and differential privacy. It was a proof of concept, not a study of terrorist content: LinkedIn posts in high tech, law, and finance were over-represented against a U.S. employment baseline, and on Dailymotion the top 10 percent of videos drew about 75 percent of recommendations, against closer to 25 percent in the LinkedIn distribution they compared.
Research, transparency and smaller platforms
The 2019 text also pledged faster technical research with academia and civil society and help for smaller services through shared tools and databases. In 2023 leaders cited researcher-access rules and a Transparency Initiatives Portal. In 2023 they also welcomed a Microsoft and Tech Against Terrorism pilot meant to extend AI-assisted detection to smaller platforms, and Altitude, a free tool from Google’s Jigsaw and Tech Against Terrorism developed with the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism. These were capacity pilots, not a Call-run recommender.
Design, gender-based radicalisation and artificial intelligence
In 2023 leaders welcomed a report on misogynistic pathways prepared by the Institute for Strategic Dialogue with the Call community. An ISD working-group paper, which said it did not speak for every participant, recommended public-data access, gender-disaggregated transparency, and safety by design. The summit did not adopt a binding code.
On artificial intelligence, the 2023 summit, which welcomed Anthropic and OpenAI, said foundation models could aid detection and be misused for propaganda. Leaders endorsed red-teaming and dialogue with other AI forums, as process commitments. In November 2026 the Foundation and Digital Public Square launched Elevate, testing how large language models handle synthetic conversations about glorifying violence or arguing for it. The release covered 124 scenarios—incel, right-wing, nihilistic, and jihadist—and 11 models in 1,364 conversations of up to eight turns. It did not set a standard or show that models changed because of the Call.
Law, regulation and human rights
Binding rules alongside the Call
The Christchurch Call is a voluntary political commitment: it creates no offences, deadlines, or penalties. Governments that support it undertake to enforce applicable laws consistently with the rule of law and international human rights law, and to consider further regulation only where that regulation fits a free, open, and secure internet.
National statutes are separate. Australia’s Criminal Code Amendment (Sharing of Abhorrent Violent Material) Act 2019 commenced on 6 April 2019, weeks before the Call. It is an offence for content and hosting providers not to expeditiously remove, or stop hosting, perpetrator-produced recordings or streams of terrorist acts, murder, attempted murder, torture, rape, or kidnapping that a reasonable person would find offensive, where the material can be accessed in Australia. Individuals face up to three years’ imprisonment; corporations the greater of 50,000 penalty units or 10 per cent of annual turnover. The offence requires recklessness, not routine scanning of every upload. New Zealand’s Films, Videos, and Publications Classification (Urgent Interim Classification of Publications and Prevention of Online Harm) Amendment Act 2021, in force from 1 February 2022, created an offence, punishable by up to 14 years’ imprisonment, of livestreaming objectionable content or sharing it during a livestream to promote crime or terrorism, and authorised take-down notices.
In the European Union, the European Commission proposed Regulation (EU) 2021/784 on 12 September 2018, before the attacks and the Call, already requiring removal or disabling of access within one hour of a removal order. Adopted on 29 April 2021 and applicable from 7 June 2022, the regulation says it complements voluntary cooperation begun in 2015 and Commission Recommendation (EU) 2018/334; it does not name the Call. Providers must comply with an order across the Union within one hour, with narrow exceptions; member states set the penalties. The Digital Services Act (Regulation (EU) 2022/2065) is without prejudice to that regulation. Article 8 forbids a general monitoring obligation, while Article 34 requires very large platforms and search engines to assess systemic risks, including illegal content and effects on rights in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.
Definitions and freedom of expression
The Call does not define “terrorist and violent extremist content.” It requires action to respect a free, open, and secure internet and human rights, including freedom of expression. Access Now, ARTICLE 19, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and European Digital Rights argued that the category varies by country and has been used against opponents, journalists, and protesters; that company terms do not decide legality; and that preventing uploads means filters which miss context, over-block, and can delete footage that documents abuses or supports prosecutions.
Regulation 2021/784 does define “terrorist content,” tied to Directive (EU) 2017/541: material that incites or solicits terrorist offences or participation in a terrorist group, glorifies terrorist activities including by depicting an attack, or gives instructions for them, including risky live transmissions. Educational, journalistic, artistic, research, and counter-terrorism uses, including polemic debate, are excluded where that is the true purpose. The Call’s “violent extremism” is wider and is enforced mainly through provider rules.
Providers commit to “transparent, specific measures seeking to prevent the upload,” including shared hash and URL databases, “in a manner consistent with human rights.” Article 5(8) of Regulation 2021/784 says required measures must not impose general monitoring or active fact-finding under Article 15(1) of the Electronic Commerce Directive, nor compel automated tools, though providers may use them. The Digital Services Act repeats that ban. Checking every upload against a hash database is therefore not an EU duty; critics say it is still the monitoring the law forbids authorities to impose.
Enforcement, appeals and privacy
Where criminal law does not apply, removal under the Call rests on community standards or terms of service. Providers commit to publish the consequences of sharing the content, describe detection and removal, enforce the rules consistently with human rights, and give users an efficient complaints and appeals process against removal or a refused upload. European Digital Rights argued that company judgements lack a public-law remedy for over-removal.
Regulation 2021/784 lets hosting and content providers challenge a removal order in the courts of the issuing member state, and requires a decision within two weeks on complaints about content removed under “specific measures.” Removed content and related data must be kept for six months for review and investigation, with safeguards. The Call limits law-enforcement cooperation and “trusted information exchanges” to applicable data-protection, privacy, and human-rights rules. When the United States joined on 7 May 2021, the White House said it would not take steps violating freedoms of speech and association under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, or reasonable expectations of privacy; the State Department added that cooperation would stay voluntary and that extremist speech should be met with more speech.
Evaluation and criticism
Early critiques
Digital-rights groups criticised the Call within days of its 15 May 2019 publication. Access Now said France and New Zealand drafted it behind closed doors. A Paris “Voices for Action” meeting, which Access Now said Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern convened despite reported French objections, came a day before release: attendees had the text for two working days, were asked about implementation rather than wording, and met apart from governments and companies. European Digital Rights wrote that Ardern had called consultation “sacrificed” for speed, and that missing anti-racism and Global South groups was a major gap.
Access Now called the Call more measured than a proposed European Union terrorist-content regulation or an Australian law criminalising social-media executives, and welcomed human rights as both an aim and a limit. It still argued that “terrorist and violent extremist content” was vague enough for arbitrary use, citing prosecutions of journalists in Jordan, and that an undefined duty on “online service providers” could reach DNS operators and carriers. It said the pledge leaned on upload filters unable to judge context, with risks for freedom of expression and privacy, and that states should not outsource speech rules. The Electronic Frontier Foundation called the text a “mixed bag”: resilience, transparency and appeals were welcome, but upload filters were “inherently inconsistent with fundamental freedoms.” EFF added that platforms were not separated from internet infrastructure, and that vague terms were left to companies and to governments, naming signatories Jordan and Spain as users of anti-terror measures against speech. ARTICLE 19 executive director Thomas Hughes warned of “unintended consequences for freedom of expression,” of lost evidence from live video, and of pre-broadcast filters while “terrorism” and “violent extremism” stayed undefined. EDRi argued filters “can be turned into censorship” and are error-prone, and that the text avoided large platforms’ advertising models.
Pilot evaluation and publication dispute
In 2022 the Christchurch Call Advisory Network (CCAN) evaluated ten early supporters: Australia, Canada, France, India, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, Google (officials’ list said Google/YouTube), Meta Platforms, Microsoft and Twitter, later X. From May 2022, members and outside researchers used a survey, conversations and public sources through December 2022. The November 2023 summary, shared before that month’s Paris summit, said supporters had affirmed the Call and that it had spurred coordination, including laws, research funding and oversight bodies. Evidence beyond “declarations of intent” was much harder to find: work was rarely labelled as Call-related, sat across agencies, and human-rights assessments were often delayed. There was no shared definition of “violent extremist content,” and some measures could stigmatise communities or restrict information. Eight of ten answered the survey; Canada and Meta did not. The founding companies of the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism had, in ways hard to measure, aligned policies, and GIFCT described its 2019 move to an independent body as “institutionalizing the spirit of the Call.”
Individual reports were not published. The Internet Governance Project (IGP) at the Georgia Institute of Technology said more senior officials pushed back, and that the secretariat “strongly discouraged” release, warning some countries would refuse future engagement and others would become “more senior, more formal and more strained.” A CCAN majority voted to withhold the reports. Dated 6 November 2023 and effective 9 November, IGP’s withdrawal called independence “fatally compromised” and the process only “the appearance of accountability.” On 30 April 2024 Newstalk ZB, using a Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet reply under the Official Information Act, reported that officials confirmed the ten names, said the secretariat feared lost trust, and withheld the objections as drafts that could prejudice international relations. IGP founder Milton Mueller called participation “pointless” without a public audit. A Call spokesperson said the pilot was voluntary and pointed to the November 2023 leaders’ endorsement of a wider evaluation. On 2 May 2024 CCAN’s co-chairs said the majority chose a summary, shared individual evaluations privately, and recorded both progress and gaps.
Assessments of effect and scope
The Center for Democracy and Technology, a founding CCAN member, wrote in September 2024 that work was rarely tied to the Call, so impact was hard to measure. It also said the voluntary forum had brought governments and companies in, that many had formalised terrorism and human-rights policies, and that after the 2022 Buffalo shooting Call companies removed livestreams and other depictions within minutes. CDT argued some used membership as “window dressing,” and that network throttling and takedowns without judicial review conflicted with the Call; without oversight, it warned, the initiative could become “a marketing exercise.”
Scope drew a separate argument. On 2 February 2024 the Free Speech Union of New Zealand told Prime Minister Christopher Luxon that Official Information Act papers showed “significant ‘mission creep’” into “gender-based ‘hatred’ (including anti-LGBTQIA+ speech),” which it said could suppress opinions “such as the view that individuals can change their sex.” It said the unit had an adviser for “gender issues” and none “specifically delegated for either extremist violence or terrorism.” The Christchurch Call Foundation has described its Catalyst programme, and a September 2026 Oxford forum, as work on misogyny “as a pathway to terrorist and violent extremism,” stating that gendered harms “are not adjacent to extremist violence – they are deeply intertwined,” and reporting Ardern’s view that the problem is defined too narrowly to be only a question of content moderation.
Who was responsible
Contribution type and responsibility level for each recorded actor — not sole-author shorthand.
No public contributors are listed for this fact.
What changed
Fact → Driver → Indicator. Relationship strength orders the paths; it is not the observed indicator movement.
No public driver impacts are listed for this fact.
Causal path
How this event connects to drivers and indicators in the graph.
No causal path is recorded: this fact is not linked to a driver.
Related people
Related organizations
Facts mentioned
Linked pages by kind
Each bar counts the pages of that kind listed in the blocks here (a full list is shown as "N+"). Counts, not a rating.
- People5
- Organizations8
- Facts2
Cite this page
Factrail. (2026). Christchurch Call. Factrail. https://factrail.ai/facts/christchurch-call
https://factrail.ai/facts/christchurch-call
Accessed 20 November 2026.
By the Factrail desk · Method: how we source and score · Last reviewed
Dispute this factNamed here, or represent someone who is? Request a right of reply.